MIDDLESBROUGH V EVERTON
London Daily News - Monday 01 February 1904
Middlesbrough on their own ground before 15,000 spectators beat Everton by three goals to none. During an even first half neither side scored. Midway through the second half Brown opened the scoring for the home side with a fine shot. Further points were added by Gettins and Cassidy.

MIDDLESBROUGH MASTER EVERTON.
Athletic News - Monday 01 February 1904
By Boro
The National Cup-ties are drawing near, and thus for the meeting between Everton and Middlesbrough, on the Ayresome Park enclosure, both teams had the advantage of a special seaside training, the visitors coming across country on Friday night from their Blackpool quarters to Redcar, where they spent the evening and Saturday morning, whilst the home eleven had been sprinting to the tune of the bracing winds of Saltburn. With Hogg resuming at full back for Middleborough, after a rest from the previous week's engagement, both teams were at full strength, though it was still noticed that Settle was operating at centre forward in the Everton ranks. There were 15.000 around the ropes to witness the Tees-siders’ ninth attempt to secure the full number of points, they not having booked a win since their victory over Bury on December 12. However, there were able to stay the course better than the Mersey men and to book a very clever and welcome win, constituting, indeed, the heaviest defeat Everton have submitted to this season.
KEEN WAR WAGED.
The home team started to a cross breeze, which rather favoured the visitors, but quickly forced a couple of corners, which, however, were not skillfully placed by Goodison, and then Booth worked in a charming low shot which was just as charmingly saved. The amateur, Hardman, however, should have opened the scoring, being presented with an almost perfect chance by Sharp, who got one of his most skillful crosses right into the goal mouth. Hardman, however, mussed glaringly. Both sides were playing keen and top-class football, the passing of the forwards and the tackling of the defenders being alike of the best. Thus both goalkeepers were found employment. Atherton getting in a tremendous effort from long range. Then Cassidy was going through when Crelley appeared to foul him in the penalty area, but the breech was unnoticed, and the spectators grumbled. The play was exhilarating to a degree, each side claiming the advantage in quick turns; but to halt-time the real advantage lay with the respective defenders, and it was difficult to say which had been the better, for no matter what the shot either Balmer, Crelley, or Kitchen on the one side, or Hogg. Blackett, or Williamson on the other, was equal to it. Thus at the interval the scoring had not opened.
QUICK SCORING
The second portion started with a fine save by Williamson from Taylor, and soon after Kitchen did  equally well when Gettins headed a centre from Goodson very dangerously near. The latter, with Cassidy, was continually prominent with daring and skillful play, he having hard lines with a glorious long shot which skimmed the bar after he had beaten Balmer. Alter twenty minutes Brown, receiving from Goodson through; Davidson, found his opportunity, and with a low left-foot shot got the ball safely past Kitchen. Gettins only allowed a further five minutes to elapse before he took a long pass from Goodson in  midfield, and beating the entire opposition scored the second goal for his side after a brilliant run. The next minute or two ought to have brought No. 3, but the Last scorer unaccountably lilted the ball clean over the bar when only a yard out. Nevertheless, the home men were almost all over the Liverpool men in the closing stages, the latter conceding corners to escape the greater evil. From one of them, though, Cassidy chalked up the thud, which went through off Balmer, but it was Cassidy's goal all the same. There were a dozen corners in last 20 minutes, and all at the Everton end, but the home team's trio of goals was sufficient to constitute a handsome victory.
EVERTON’S BREAKDOWN
Quite the outstanding feature of the game was the utter collapse of the Lancashire eleven during the last half-hour, though in the first 60 minutes they had shown skill in attack and defence equal to the home team, and that was no mean standard, but neither the first goal their confidence went, taking their ability with it, and to the finish they were able only to “chase’’ the Middlesbrough players about. Their staying powers were most evidently lost in the long journey, or perhaps the manner in which Williamson and his helpers so easily dealt with and overcame their best attempts may provide the cause of so unexpected a caving in. The forwards can hardly be held wholly responsible, as in the latter portion they seldom got the ball to any advantage. Earlier, they had done some brilliant manoceuving at times, though Settle was the one man who never seemed at home, but much of his ineffectiveness must be credited to Jones, who was leech-like in his attentions. Taylor worked very well, but Sharp found very hard work in beating his opposing men. The defence had done so brilliantly to begin with that their failing came as a great surprise.  Booth was the one man on the side to do his great reputation justice throughout, and he cut a fine figure with his tenacious tackling, and speed, and his always true returns to his forwards. Kitchen saved most superbly, and was of great strength whilst Balmer and Crelley were two very great backs, kicking and defending admirably for 60 minutes only.
MIDDLESBROUGH’S RETURN TO FORM
The play of the home team was throughout very good and very pleasing, and it seemed the October form had returned. From beginning to ending they exhibited the energy, skill, and dash which eventually secured them the points. Much praise is due to the forwards for continuing to peg away even when the Everton defence seemed impregnable.  Their exhibition during the whole course of the game was just one which only wanted a weak spot in the opposition for goals to come. That they found a weak spot the result shows. One cannot bestow too liberal praise upon the defenders, who were found equal to neutralize the most polished efforts of Everton; indeed, the Tees-side defenders have seldom shown to such advantage. The play of the men from goal line to the centre was such that to individualize would be unfair. There was no weak spot, but Hogg and Blackett must be commended for a return to best form, and the team be congratulated upon a remarkably clever performance.  Middlesbrough;- Williamson; Hogg, and Blackett; Aitken, Jones, and Davidson; Gettins, Atherton, Brown, Cassidy, and Goodson.  Everton; Kitchen; Balmer, and Crelley; Wolstenholme, Booth, and Abbott; Sharp, Taylor, Settle, McDermott, and Hardman.  Referee; Mr. H. Ward, Nottingham.

ROBERT BALMER
Athletic News - Monday 01 February 1904
A Full Back of Promise
By Junius
During recent years Everton appear to have developed a desire for producing local full backs for their League team, and at present two Liverpool men fill this important division of their premier eleven.  In the subjects of our sketch they possess a reserve player for an vacancy in this department, who, though young, has more than average ability, and in his last appearance with the League eleven, Robert Balmer gave the Sheffield United right wing a rare taste of his quality.  The comparatively inexperienced youth- for he is only 20 years of age- created a most favourable impression by the manner in which he repeatedly broke up the combined efforts of such notabilities as Common and Bennett.  He commenced his football career at West Derby, and with this junior suburban eleven gave promise of developing into a capable full back.  In his school days he figured in the Liverpool Colleague team and secured a medal for assisting to capture the School Challenge Shield.  In connection with the West Derby League he was twice selected to represent the North against the South and had the honour of being chosen captain of the former side, which in both years proved victorious, and thereby qualified for the medals offered.  He joined Everton in 1901, as a left full back, which position he has invariably occupied-though on one occasion.  I believe, he played centre forward in a six-aside contest at West Derby, when his side proved the winners.  During his connection with Everton he has generally assisted the Reserve eleven, but on the occasions when he has been called upon to play for the League team he has invariably given a capital exhibition.  Though only standing 5ft 8ins, and scaling 10st 10lbs, he is one of the pluckiest and most whole-hearted players imaginable.  Fear is foreign to him, and his style of play is in every particular precisely similar to that of his more experienced brother.  The Everton directors are very judicious in selecting him at intervals only, for their recognize he is a coming League player, and do not desire to overtax his strength while young.  But that he may eventually become a permanent player in the team is only a matter of time and opportunity and the latter contingency is bound to arrive.  When it does come Balmer will be found ready to maintain the excellent traditions of his family, so worthily upheld at present by his brother. 

OVERWHELMING VICTORY FOR EVERTON RESERVES
Athletic News - Monday 01 February 1904
By Junius
For the second Saturday in succession Heywood were visitors to the city, but their latest performance was not very cheering to their supporters. Everton scored twice through Dilly and Clayton in the first half, but in the second portion O’Hagan (twice), Sheridan, Rankin, Russell, and Dilly added points, and Everton won by eight clear goals.  The game was too one-sided to merit criticism, and Everton were vastly superior to their opponents.  O’Hagan, Rankin, and Dilly were the pick of the forwards, whilst Clayton at half-back, and Murray at full back, rendered capital service.  For the losers, who were practically penned in their half throughout the game, Thorpe at half-back gave a very plucky exhibition, but despite the fact that he had eight points registered against him Whittaker kept a splendid goal, and could not in any way be blamed for the defeat.  Blomley at centre forward was in good trim, but he was badly supported by his wing men, and the score about represented the superior of the leaders of the Lancashire Combination. 

MIDDLESBROUGH 3 EVERTON 0
February 1, 1904. The Liverpool Courier
In order to fulfil their return engagement with Middlesbrough. Everton left their training quarters at Blackpool on Friday, and made the journey to Redcar, a pretty watering place with close reach of the Iron capital. Redcar was left on Saturday morning the players dressing in the saloon en route. The conditions were most favourable for a good exposition of the game. There would be about 13,000 spectators present when the teams lined up as follows: - Middlesbrough: - Williamdson goal, Hogg and Blackett, backs, Aitkens, Jones and Davidson, half-backs, Gettins Atherton, Brown Cassidy, and Goodson, forwards. Everton: - Kitchen goal, W.Balmer, and Crelly backs Wolstenholme, Booth (captain) and Abbott half-backs Sharp Taylor, Settle McDermott, and Hardman forwards. Referee H.Ward. By winning the toss Everton had a district advantage with the breeze, but immediately the home right got into a good position, and were not checked until they got with close range where Crelly brought off a fine tackle. The home side again made off, Cassidy and Goodson being prominent, and but for smart tackling, first by Booth and then by Wolstenholme, the visitors goal must have been captured. They followed a couple of corner kicks against Everton, but these carried so anxiety, and the visiting left then got away. They met with stubborn defence, but Booth supplemented their efforts and steadying himself, put a fine shot into Williamson hands. Their efforts was not long sustained, for Balmer and Crelly were kept bust for some minutes. Keen tackling prevented shooting and eventually Taylor put in a very tricky bit of play, in which he drew round him the home backs and deftly put the ball out to Sharp. The latter raced along in splendid fashion, and put in an accurate cross shot to the foot of Hardman, who was unmarked only three yards from the goaulmouth, but he shot wide. Balmer was loudly applauded for some splendid tackling and during the next few minutes the Everton forwards was soon busy near the home goal. First Sharp and then Hardman put in lovely centres, but there was no getting the better of Blackett and Hogg, and eventually Settle in attempting to head the ball from Abbott. placed it behind. Another movement on the home left ended in Cassidy badly missing an easy opening. A strong pressure followed, in which the Everton defenders were seen in capital trim as before Balmer clinched matters with a fine strong drive but at this stage his forwards could not keep possession and the home lot were again busy in attack. A magnificent shot from Atherton just missed the net, and a good shot from Goodson was kept out by Kitchen. Some fine passing between Sharp, Taylor, and Settle, and Hardman was the next item, but unfortunately the outside man lay offside and headway was lost by a series of thrown-ins. The Middlesbrough forwards worked their way to the Everton quarters again, but were beaten by Balmer and Crelly. Then Settle was unlucky in having a shot charged down by Hogg when only a few yards from goal, and a further return brought only an abortive corner. Another fine shot by Goodson was splendid headed out by Crelly. The Everton forwards, who led, now made a really brilliant effort by Settle made their way to within a few yards of the home goal. The ball was eventually put to Taylor, who, with a splendid shot, looked like opening the scoring, when Williamson in miraculous fashion managed to tip the ball over the bar. The corner kick brought an exciting tussle in the goalmouth, and Hardman should have scored. The pace, which all along had been fast, now increased and there were many exciting passages in front of both goals. The home left was particularly busy, and Kitchen was twice called upon, and cleared admirably. Half-time Middlesbrough nil, Everton nil. When play was resumed Everton made tracks for the home goal. McDermott made a capital effort to open the scoring, but his shot was cleared, and the home side retaliated strongly. The right wing got away in fine style, and Brown-taking advantage of a grand centre from Davidson opened the scoring with a splendid shot. Middlesbrough playing with the wind in their favour, had the best of matters for some time. Everton, however, defended stubbornly, while the forwards often troubled the Middlesbrough defenders Aitkens shot into the hands of Kitchen, and directly after Gettins finished a smart bit of work by scoring Middlesbrough's second goal. Towards the close there was a fierce scrimmage in the mouth of the Everton goal. From a corner Gettins struck the post, and from the rebound Cassidy shot in, the ball going off Crelly into the net. Result Middlesbrough 3, Everton nil.

EVERTON RESERVES 8 HEYWOOD 0
February 1, 1904. The Liverpool Mercury
Lancashire Combination “A” Division (Game 18)
At Goodison Park. A goal came from Dilly in the first minute. Clayton scored a second point. Half time Everton 2 Heywood nil. O'Hagan scored two, and Sheridan, Rankin, Russell, and Dilly all scored one. Everton winning a one sided game by eight goals to nil. Everton: - Dent, goal, Gordon, and Murray, backs Clayton, Russell, and Makepeace, half-backs, Rankin, Sheridan Young, O'Hagan, and Corrin forwards.

EVERTON REVIEW
February 1, 1904. The Liverpool Mercury
Following upon recent success accomplished by the Everton team, the result of Saturday's engagement with Middlesbrough must have come as a big surprise to the majority of their supporters. The disappointing was accentuated in as much as the North east Yorkshire team had been performing mostly in difficulty of late, for since the second half of the season had been enforced upon their record was one continuous loss of games. The first meeting this season ended, after a fairly good exposition of the game, in favour of the Goodison Park side by two goals to nil, so that the home eleven had every incentive to get upon level terms with their opponents. In this they not only succeeded, but they eclipsed the efforts of the “Blues” in as much as when time was called they had administered the most crushing defeat that Everton has sustained this season. The weather was fine, but the ground at Ayrsome Park was considerably on the soft side, and probably this had much to do with the inability of the Evertonians to keep the balance of play in their favour. At the outset the visitors had a district advantage in winning the toss, for they were backed up by a fresh breeze that blow from end to end, and it was generally conceded that the home side would have an anxious 45 minutes. Contrary to expectation, the Middlesbrough eleven were the more dangerous during the initial stages of the game, for they sped along the heavy turf with an accuracy that stood out markedly to the movements of their opponents, who experienced the utmost difficulty in keeping a foothold. Both sides had been in training quarters during the week, and so far as the Yorkshiremen were concerned, considerable benefit had been derived therefrom. They stayed the pace from start to finish, and it is a somewhat usual item to Chronicle a failure in this direction on the part of the Everton team. During the last stages of the game the home forwards played with a fruitless more closely identified with the opening of a match, and it was left to this period to establish their distinct superiority, for they secured their three goals within the last 25 minutes of the game. Everton's weakness lay in that failure of the forwards to keep possession of the ball. There was not that concerned action with the half back line that has been so prominent a feature in recent games, and more often than not the passing of the quintet was faulty and badly timed. The defect opened out splendid opportunities for the home half backs, who placed with accuracy to their forwards, and backed them up with such support that the van always gave one the impression that they would eventually assert themselves in unmistakable fashion. Now, and then there were flashes of exceptional merit on the part of the visitors, notably some clever manceurving on the part of Sharp, who on one occasion gave Hardman the easiest of chances to score. Had this been accepted there might have been quite a different complexion put upon the game, for everyone who follows the short in ready to admit is ready to admit that the first goal in hand is a great incentive to success. Other opportunities though not of so simple a nature were allowed to go a begging, and thus at the end of the first half, after having enjoyed the assistance of the prevailing conditions, Everton could claim no advantage; indeed on the general run of the pay the home side had a little in hand. When the game was resumed, there was a glimpse of the old time cleverness shown by the Everton forwards, who peppered away at the Middlesbrough defenders, and for a lengthy period kept them extended to their best efforts. Eventually the home forwards asserted themselves and after 20 minutes play Brown scored a clever goal, which was followed by one from Gettins, who, challenged by Kitchen tipped the balls into the net, while towards the close Cassidy met a return from the upright and added a third. There could be no question that the Middlesbrough team was the better side, and evidently North Sea breezes have done much in bringing the players back into form. As suggested, the Everton forwards were not at their best; indeed, it was only at odd intervals that they indulged that they indulged in those delightful touches which have formed so prominent a feature in recent games. The right wing was the most effective, but their centres were invariably met by Jones and Aitkens, the opposing half-backs who, were ever on the alert to prevent their rearguard from being unduly harassed. The Everton half backs had a vast amount of works to get through and under the circumstances they did well, while at full back Balmer gave a masterly display of timing, tackling, and clever kicking. Crelly was not so reliable, for Atherton and Gettins often had the better of him, while in goal Kitchen gave nothing away. On the home side Brown was a capable pivot in the attack, for he kept his wings going and gave Goodson, Atherton, and Gettins every opportunity to display their skill. The defence was capital, and in goal, Williamson showed much judgement in dealing with the few dangerous shots that came his way.

SATURDAY’S FOOTBALL
Liverpool Daily Post - Monday 01 February 1904
The question of sending teams into training has long been open to argument, and locally the results have been all against such a proceeding. Everton spent all last week at Blackpool, and before their encounter with Middlesbrough they had a twelve hours’ breather of East Coast air at Redcar. In spite of this, they performed in, to say the least of it, a very mediocre manner against their opponents and the most hardened partisan must admit they were fairly and squarely beaten.
Winning the toss the Goodison Park lot had a fairly strong helpmate in the breeze, but they never enjoyed anything like the same amount of pressure as the home forwards retaliated with; nor was their shooting when in front of goal as good as that of the Teesiders. Still there was comparatively little in it up to the interval, and the clean sheet indicted in a very fair degree the trend of play. Crossing over Middlesbrough at once showed that they were determined to break their record of eight successive matches without chronicling a win. They pressed persistently, and twenty minutes from the restart Brown netted the ball. After this there was no holding them, and a second goal was added within a couple of minutes. At this point Everton were fairly out-played, and when a third goal was registered just on time their rout was complete. Sharp put in some magnificent wing work, and Taylor displayed his usual bustling tactics in front of goal, but neither was successful in beating Williamson. Once or twice the left wing was dangerous, Hardman on one occasion being distinctly unlucky, and Settle all things considered, performed creditably in the centre position. The half-back line did not prove quite so efficient as usual, though Booth put in several brilliant bits of individual play. The display of Balmer and Crelly was marred by the fact that they were both caught napping when their opponents scored, but Kitchen could hardly be blamed for the three shots which passed him. There is no doubt that the Middlesbrough team, on Saturday’s form are a power to be reckoned with, and having now broken their sequence of losses, they will gave future visitors to their fine new enclosure at Ayrsome Park a heavy task if they require to add points. 

MIDDLESBROUGH v. EVERTON.
The Sportsman - Monday 01 February 1904
Delightful weather favoured this match at Ayresome Park, Middlesbrough, on Saturday, and a most inspiriting display was given by both teams. The visitors were the smartest side in the opening half, and it was chiefly owing to magnificent custodianship by William that Everton failed to find the net. A change come over the scene in the second half. Middlesbrough more than holding their own, and, giving another such brilliant display against Manchester City and Sheffield United, rattled their opponents off their feet. Brown opened the scoring in twenty minutes, and three minutes later Gettins put on a second, white five minutes from the close, Cassidy scored, the ball striking the legs ang glancing off into net, Kitchen having no chance of clearing. Previous to Saturday, Middlesbrough had gone through eight engagements since they beat Bury at home on December 12, and they have made themselves safe from being one of the bottom two.

MIDDLESBROUGH v.  EVERTON
North Star (Darlington) - Monday 01 February 1904
“Hope springs eternal in the human breast” sings the poet, but “hope deferred maketh the heart grow sick,” and sick in truth had grown the hearts of Ironopolitans interested in the fate of their League representatives. And with good reason. Since the day they defeated Bury by a goal to love- that was on December 12th- the Borough had managed to scrape up half-a-dozen points out of eight matches, three of them at home, and twice had they been leading 2-0 at the interval. For all practical purposes an average realisation of one point per match was required during the remainder of the season to make the club’s position secure. It was with sundry misgivings, therefore that the 16,000 supporters gathered at Ayresome Park on Saturday to see Everton tackle the Teessiders. A month or six weeks ago there would have been unbounded confidence in the Northerners’ ability to vanquish their visitors, but at that time the past record was bright and not blackened by a six weeks’ “frost.” But the bracing air of Saltburn had done its work, and on Saturday the 16,000 were cheered by a handsome victory, and Tees-side looks forward with considerably brightened hope to next week’s visit to Millwall. Saturday’s game was curious in some respects, but in none more so than in the fact that staying power won the game for the Borough. The first half was blank, and was notable more for failures than successes. Goodson, who was destined to play brilliantly later on, was a rank failure then, and throughout the home ranks there seemed to prevail a spirit of laisser faire which boded no good and much evil. Nor did the Goodison Park men shape at all brilliantly, and to many it appeared that they were holding themselves in hand, a fact which was vastly emphasized by the opening of the second stage. The first half was further marked by a referential error of omission which brought down upon the head of Mr. H. Ward, of Nottingham, the full force of a fierce demonstration of indignation. Cassidy when an almost certain scorer, was fouled inside the area by Balmer, but for some indefinable reason a penalty was not awarded. It is perhaps not saying too much to allege that a brillaint clearance by Williamson of a shot from McDermott-a shot which might very easily have scored- in the first five minutes of the second period saved the game for the homesters, having regard to the way in which an adverse score demoralises the Tees siders. This smart bit of work by the custodian-which was but one of many -coupled with the scoring of a goal by Brown after a quarter of an hour’s play settled by Brown after a quarter of an hour’s play settled the affair, and from that time onward there was but one team in it, and, thanks to other goals from Gettins and Cassidy, Everton retired with the heaviest defeat they have sustained this season, the score reading;- Middlesbrough 3; Everton 0.

MIDDLESBRO v  EVERTON
Newcastle Daily Chronicle - Monday 01 February 1904
GOOD VICTORY FOR TEES-SIDERS
The Middlesbrough players entertained Everton at Ayresome Park, Middlesbrough, when it was hoped that they might be able to secure their first victory since Dec 12. Since that date Middlesbrough have fared very badly, and though their position could not be said to be unsafe, it was not a good one. When Saturday’s rivalry met on Oct 3, at Goodison Park, the “Toffees” won by 2 to nil, and remembering that they just lost a fortnight ago at Newcastle the Teesiders recognised that their task was a difficult one. The weather was dull but fine. The attendance was somewhat disappointing only some 12,000 people being present. The Everton team had been staying at Redcar overnight, whist Middlesbrough had been staying during the whole of the week at Saltburn. Everton won the toss, and shortly before three o’clock the homesters started the leather towards the west end. Everton at once ran in and the leather was centred, when Crelly relieved. Play was in favour of the Teesiders, and they landed a throw-in at close quarters on the left, but they were driven back over the half line. A free kick for Middlesbrough was taken by Blackett, who put well forward. Brown shot nicely, but the ball touched an opponent, and went behind. From a corner conceded another corner followed, and Davidson taking possession put over the bar. The Tees-siders continued to have the upper hand, and they gave Balmer and Crelly a good deal to do. A free kick at midfield for Everton transferred play to the vicinity of the home goal, and Booth put in a capital shot, which Williamson saved in good style. The homesters were soon once more the aggressors, and Cassidy gave smartly to Goodison; but the latter returned the pass badly, and the visiting forwards took up the running. Ultimately the ball was put behind. At the other end Kitchen had to handle and he easily did what was required of him. Sharp got the ball, and, eluding several opponents, he sent in beautifully right across the goal-mouth. Here Hardman had a grand opening; but the amateur made wretched use of his opportunity, and put behind. The homesters had to defend t=for a while. Blackett relieved. The home forwards rushed cleverly away. The visitors’ custodian cleared two very fine shots. A visit was again paid to the Middlesbrough goal, and what proved to be a useless corner fell to Everton. The leather was brought away after a brief but rather warm scrimmage in a dangerous quarter. Even and interesting play followed. Cassidy put in a grand dribble, but he kept the ball too long, and he was ultimately dispossessed by Balmer. The ball travelled rapidly and frequently from one end of the field to the other. Abbott headed behind. A moment or two later the leather was put smartly out to Goodison, who, however, failed to reach it. Wolstenholme sent once more into the home quarters. Middlesbrough’s forwards were not long in again attacking, and Cassidy sent wide. From a throw-in near midfield Everton looked threatening, but they were pulled up, and Middlesbrough got over the half line. They were awarded a free kick, but only a bye resulted. Hogg gave the home forwards possession, but they failed to penetrate the Everton defence. Atherton then dribbled finely and put in a perfect stinger at rather long range, the ball just going outside the upright. Maintaining the pressure, the Tees-siders troubled Everton’s back division.
Balmer relieved well. The visitors next broke away, and several of them kept right in front of goal. Matters looked very serious, but Hogg managed to get the leather, and relieved anxiety by kicking well forward. Balmer passed Cassidy, who was in possession on the penalty line, but the referee disregarded all cries of “Penalty.” The same fate was shared by the home team immediately afterwards, as an Everton man landed close in. A corner for Middlesbrough was taken by Goodson, who placed accurately, but the visitors defence proved sound, and the leather was quickly taken to the other end of the field. Taylor looked all over a scorer, btu Williamson ran out, and taking the ball from his toe, just as he was about to shoot, kicked away strongly. The visitors got away on the left, but Hogg checked their career, and the homesters once more attacked with vigour. Goodson got through several players, and centred cleverly. Cassidy received and shot, but the leather was returned, and Jones getting up banged in, but Kitchen saved. Cassidy and Goodson were again responsible for smart work, and the latter shot, but the ball struck Wolstenholme, and bounded out of play. Then the Evertonians got the better of matters. Hardman and McDermott raced away in good style, but they failed to beat Hogg. The leather was taken again into the visitors half, but it was not there long, the right wing of Everton getting away and forcing a corner, but nothing came of it. With only a few minutes to go for the interval, Middlesbrough played with great determination and were very threatening when Davidson handled, and a free kick enabled the visitors to relieve the pressure. After a brief visit to the other end the Tees-siders returned to the attack, and Gettins banged well in, but the ball went wide. The homesters continued to press, but they were driven back, and the Everton forwards lining up well got into a good position. Taylor shot hard, Williamson saved cleverly at the cost of a corner, which availed the visitors nothing. Everton kept up the attack, and Aitken was responsible for good defensive work. A free kick allowed Middlesbrough to get away, and Goodson shot beautifully, but Kitchen was all there, and saved in clever style.
Half-time;- Middlesbrough Nil, Everton Nil.
On resuming after the interval Everton at once took up the running. Sharp centred, and Taylor got in a grand shot, which Williamson dealt with successfully. A free kick for the Tees-siders was taken by Blackett, who sent well into the visitors’ goal, and a couple of corners to Middlesbrough followed. Nothing came of them. Sharp and Taylor took the ball away to the other end; but their efforts only terminated in a bye. Hogg, with a free kick, gave to Gettins, and that player and Atherton headed to each other nicely; but they failed to make headway. After the home defence had been taxed, and had come through the ordeal, the Middlesbrough front division put in some smart work. Atherton headed for goal, but Kitchen cleared and almost directly afterwards Gettins sent just outside the upright. Urged on by the cheers of their supporters, the homesters kept up the attack, and Brown got in a beauty, but again Kitchen saved. Hardman was then given the leather; and he raced away in capital style, but when he was about to shoot he was dispossessed by Jones. At the other end, Goodson put just over the bar. The home goal was once more endangered, and then the leather was put right out to Goodson, who gave to Davidson, and the latter put Brown in possession with fine judgement, when the home centre with a lightning shot scored, amid wild cheering. A moment or two later, Middlesbrough’s second point was added. The Teesiders after this had matters pretty much their own way, for some time. Cassidy put right across and Gettins missed an open goal. After this Everton had a run down, and landed a corner, of which nothing came. The homesters again attacked and Kitchen saved a hot shot from Goodson. Gettins took a corner by which Goodson struck the upright, and Cassidy securing the ball on its rebounding found the net and registered the homesters third goal. From now up till the close Middlesbrough more than held their own.
Final;- Middlesbrough 3 goals, Everton Nil.
Middlesbrough- Goal, Williamson; backs, Hogg and Blackett; half-backs, Aitken, Jones, and Davidson; forwards; Getting’s Atherton, Brown, Cassidy, and Goodson.
Everton.- Goal, Kitchen; backs, Crelly and Balmer; half-backs, Abbott, Booth (captain), and Wolstenholme; forwards, Hardman, McDermott, Settle, Taylor and Sharp.

SPURS' VISIT TO GOODISON, PARK.
Football Chat and Athletic World - Tuesday 02 February 1904
SOME POINTS ABOUT THE E'VERTON TEAM.
The forthcoming English Cup-tie between Everton and Tottenham Hotspur, which is to be decided at Goodison Park, Liverpool, the famous ground of a famous club, is creating widespread interest in the Liverpool district. It is regarded as one of the tit-bits of the round, and notwithstanding the fact that the Spurs have this season fallen upon somewhat evil times—for them—the match is looked upon as by no means a certainty for the home club. There are many reasons why the game should be an interesting one apart from the stake at issue. In the first place the Spurs created a sensation in northern football circles by their triumphal progress through the cup-ties, culminating in their splendid victory in the Final tie, and there is no club which will be more heartily welcomed than the Spurs. Southern clubs always provide an attraction to northern spectators, and the visit to Goodison last season of the Portsmouth team attracted one of the largest "gates" ever brought to Goodison Park. Another reason why the Spurs' visit is creating so much interest is the fact that three old Everton players are connected with the side—Jack Kirwan and Ted Hughes (both Liverpool lads), and Jimmy Watson the full-back. Then again, the popular Secretary, Jack Cameron, played with Everton, both as amateur and professional, and was one of the cleverest and most popular members of the team. The Spurs are such fine cup fighters that the supporters of the Everton club are by no means confident of victory, and especially so in view of uneven form their team has shown at home. It is a fact that Everton this season have shown better form on their opponents' territory, as their fine performances against Manchester City (3 to 1). Stoke (3 to 2), West Bromwich Albion (nil to nil), Wolverhampton Wanderers (2 to 2), Blackburn, Rovers (2 to nil), and Notts County (3 to nil), shows. Contrast these results with their defeats at by Sunderland, Notts Forest, and Derby County; and this shows the difference in their form at home and away. At all events, it may be taken for granted that the Spurs will not suffer such a defeat as fell to the lot of Portsmouth at Goodison last season. Some notes on the players who will represent the Everton club may be of interest to Southern readers. In the first place, Kitchen the goalkeeper, is a man of first-class ability. He stands about 6ft, and scales over 13st. Then two local men in Balmer and Crelly are the backs. The former has been with Everton for about six seasons, and is a fine, fearless player. Crelly has played with Millwall, and is pretty well known in the South. He improved wonderfully of late. Both backs are about 5ft 9in in height, and while Balmer weighs about 12st, Crelly turns the scale at close upon 12st 10lb. At half -back Everton possess the finest intermediate line in the League—Wolstenholme, Booth, and Abbott—and they form the strongest part of the eleven. Booth and Abbott are  Internationals, and Wolstenholme is an inter-League player. Their heights and weights are as follows: Wolstenholme, 6ft and 12st Booth, 6ft and 12st 4lb; Abbott, 5ft 9 ½ in and 12st 8lb. Thus they will form a strong barrier to pass. Forward Everton are well off, though not so well as their supporters would wish. Sharp the outside-right, is this season showing grand form. He is the Lancashire County cricketer. 5ft 7in, and 11st. He played against Ireland in the early part of the season, and has been international before. With him is Jack Taylor. the old Dumbarton man, and the oldest player in point of service in the Everton team. He stands 5ft 9in and scales over 11st, and for pluck and hard work is always conspicuous. The other forwards include Jimmy Settle, the old international, as tricky and clever as ever; McDermott, from the Celtic (inside -right or left), a clever little, though Player; Corrin, who has played with Portsmouth, and is a Liverpool lad; Young, the centre, a fine dashing player, weighing 11st, and standing 5ft 8 ½ in; and  Hardman, the amateur from Blackpool, who, although small and light, is very fast, fearless, and clever at outside-left. Everton are adopts at the short passing game a fact which the Spurs should do well to note. The half-backs have a perfect understanding with the forward line, and act at times as extra front-rank men. They also are very fine shots, and are responsible for one-third of the goals obtained so far, so that the Spurs' custodian will have to keep his eye on the half-back line. The Spurs will want to play the long passing game, with those swinging passes out to the wings which bother so many defences. This is the class of football which always bothers the Everton eleven, as has been seen on more than one occasion this season. The teams which have beaten Everton at home have invariably adopted the dashing style of football as opposed to the more scientific, methods of the Goodison side, and this fact does not need any further explanation. It may be added, as showing that the Everton directors do not mean to leave anything to chance, that immediately after the game against Sheffield United, the Everton team went into special train for the Cup-ties.

TOTTENHAM QUIETLY CONFIDENT OF HOLDING THEIR OWN.
Football Chat and Athletic World - Tuesday 02 February 1904
“By Hotspur.”
There can be no two opinions but that everybody one runs up against in the Tottenham part of the globe is ready to discuss the possible chances of the Hotspur representatives against Everton. The Association Cup-tie is to be played next Saturday, and fortunate indeed is it that, from a playing point of view, the match cannot be decided previous to its inception by a battle of words. To endeavour by a series of theoretical reasonings on the eye of a momentous struggle to claim superior over an unknown quantity is no new thing, but, alas! the best laid schemes are often shattered after the "brawl," and 'tis then we realise again and again the futility of endeavouring to gauge the ultimate destination of fortune's wheel. Still, I am particularly requested by our worthy Editor to diagnose with the pen the prospects of the Spurs of Tottenham against the men of Everton, and, undoubtedly, mine is no easy task, for to me our opponents are practically an unknown quantity. One can only judge them on their league form, and that, while very flattering, causes one to pause and give serious thought ere he gives the fatal plunge of endeavouring to predict. I shall therefore only point out that I am despatching the Tottenham Cup-tie goods labelled "Dangerous." To take the Spurs' Cup form, and also their away matches, we have a peg on which to hang a few startling observations and ocular proof that, battling against any organisation on foreign territory, always stimulates our representatives to doughty deeds. Take their performances at Preston and at Villa Park, also the Crystal Palace and Bolton in the year when the Cup came Tottenhamwards; then, again, that decisive defeat of the famous Throstles on their own Hawthorns last season, when the Birmingham world wondered at the smashing defeat of a team who had been making hacks of all the other clubs in the League. Can we not say we have hopes—and strong hope,— of our men living up to their Cup reputation at Everton next Saturday?
Personally, I shall not be the least surprised at a drawn game, but 'tis quite possible that the choice of ground means a victory for Everton, who have certainly been holding high revel at the expense of all opposition at Anfield Road. To be brief, I have every confidence in the Tottenham men giving a good account of themselves. They expect a tough fight, and the Evertonians will need to show their best form and bustle about very considerably if they hope to enter the next round. The Tottenham players are at present getting fit at Southport, and from there they will travel to Liverpool just in time for the kick-off. The team will not be decided upon until the last moment, but we can expect them to line up before a thumping big attendance as follows: Williams, goal; Tait, Erents, and Watson, backs; Morris, Hughes, and J. L. Jones, halves; Warner, Jones, M. J. Woodward, Copeland, and Kirwan, forwards. And knowing the good sporting spirit of the Liverpool people, we know our men will have a big reception. Kirwan, Hughes, Watson, Tait, J. L. Jones, and Charlie Williams are no strangers on the Everton ground. All the players are well up in the geography of these surroundings. I only hope that over-elaborations will not be indulged in, and that our front line will make direct tracks for the Everton kitchen. The Spurs cannot command success. We trust they will do better, and deserve it. A drawn game will satisfy expectations; a victory would set Tottenham ablaze with jubilation.

TIT-BITS OF "THE" LFAGUE.
Football Chat and Athletic World- Tuesday 02 February 1904
Everton's 3 to nil reverse, sustained at Middlesbrough, was a sad disappointment for the Toffees' supporters. But then, Everton are ever flattering but to deceive, seems to me. Their first week of special training at Blackpool has apparently not led to good results thus far, but perhaps the Spurs will catch them on the rebound! One never knows where Everton are concerned. Saturday's was the heaviest reverse sustained by the Merseyman since the season's dawn and their forwards crumpled up badly, indeed, before Middlesbrough's defence, On the other hand the Teeside attack was great, and Millwall must needs have a care on Saturday. Brown, Atherton, and Gettins, in particular, were fine. The Middlesbrough win was badly wanted, for they had not come out on top for almost two months.

EVERTON RESERVE v.  HEYWOOD
Heywood Advertiser - Friday 05 February 1904
This return Lancashire Combination match was played at Goodison Park on Saturday, before a fair attendance. The initial game resulted in favour of Everton by six goals to one. Heywood had again absentees in the forwards, Bamford partnering Plumpton. Everton were without Whitley, Young, and Makepeace, R. Balmer playing left half. Teams;-
Everton; Debt, goal; Gordon and Murray, backs; Clayton, Russell, and Balmer, half-backs; Rankin, Sheridan, Dilly, O’Hagan, and Corrin, forwards.
Heywood; Whittaker, goal; Smith and Hodgkiss, backs; Walkden, Oldham and Thorpe, half-backs; Moores, Knowles, Blomley, Plumpton and Bamford, forwards.
Heywood kicked off with only ten men, and Everton at once pressed, Dilly scoring a couple of minutes from the start with a capital shot. The visitors retaliated well, and Murray missed his kick close in. one of the Heywood forwards had a splendid chance, but stumbled, and Murray managed to kick away. Everton resumed the attack following a good clearance by Balmer, and Rankin centred right across goal, the backs clearing. Next Corrin centred beautifully. Sheridan heading a few inches over the bar. During further pressure on the visitors’ goal Corrin again sent across, and the inside right shot just wide. Whitaker saved from Dilly. O’Hagan, who was showing good form, next sent over from a difficult angle, and on the visitors getting away Balmer put in fine defensive work. Whitaker cleared well from a corner, but was beaten by a long low shot from Clayton. Following this second goal to Everton play ruled in midfield for some time, but the home side easily held the upper hand. Heywood now had their full complement, but failed to call upon Dent. Dilly looked like running through on his own, but Whitaker ran out and kicked away. Rankin made a splendid run and shot, Whittaker saving under the bar, and Dilly’s shot from the clearance struck one of the defenders, who was winded. It was a lucky escape for Heywood. Everton continued to press, and the visitors’ goal had some narrow escapes. Whitaker cleared from O’Hagan at the expense of a corner, and he was again called upon by Russell. The custodian was fouled while clearing, but the free kick brought only temporary relief. Corrin was making a dash for goal when he was bowled over inside the penalty area, an appeal for a free kick being negatived. The same player a little later hit the bar with a capital shot, the ball going behind. O’Hagan lost a grand opportunity after Whitaker had stopped a hot shot from Rankin and Dilly, Russell, and Balmer all tried shots without avail. The Heywood custodian saved a grand long shot from Rankin, and a corner to Everton was fruitless. The home side and much the best of matters to the interval, but failed to add to their score. Dent only had to save on two occasions throughout this half.
Interval; Everton 2, Heywood nil.
After the interval Everton’s left got down, O’Hagan scoring the third goal. Whitaker saved well from the same player soon afterwards. A scrimmage in goal resulted in a fourth. Sheridan scored a fifth from long range. Whitaker handled the ball, but it went over the line. Rankin scored a sixth from short range, Russell obtaining the seventh. Dent saved well from Plumpton. Thorpe and Whitaker were conspicuous for the visitors, but Dilly scored the eight. Final- Everton Reserves 8 goals, Heywood Nil. 

TEAM ARRANGEMENTS FOR THIS DAY
Liverpool Daily Post - Saturday 06 February 1904
Everton v Tottenham Hotspur
English Cup-tie at Goodison Park; Kick-off at 3.
Everton.- Kitchen, goal; Balmer and Crelly, backs; Wolstenholme, Booth and Abbott, half-backs; Sharp, Taylor, Settle, McDermott, and Hardman, forwards.
Referee Mr. H. Ward (Nottingham).

OUTDOOR SPORTS
Liverpool Mercury - Saturday 06 February 1904
Everton will be visited by Tottenham Hotspur who, though not so prominent in the football world as they were  couple of years ago, may be depended upon to extend the local eleven to the utmost this afternoon. During the past fortnight the Everton players have bene training at Blackpool in preparation for to-day’s contest, and all the men are reported thorough sound and fit for the work they will be called upon to perform. They have derived considerable benefit from their stay on the Lancashire seaboard, and that they will be successful against the Southerners appears an almost foregone conclusion. With the team that has represented them throughout the majority of their League fixtures all-ready for the fray, Everton can view the tie with confidence, and if the form displayed against most League visitors to Goodison Park be reproduced there can only be one ending to the game, and that an unfavourable one for the Londoners. The latter have been recuperating at Southport, and will use every endeavour to vanquish the more fancied Evertonians. Preparations have been made to accommodate a huge assembly, and, as there is practically no other attraction in the city, Everton should likewise reap a substantial pecuniary advantage in addition to winning.
Everton v Tottenham Hotspur.- Referee H. Ward (Nottingham);linesmen C.H. Grey (Sheffield) and H. Shelton (Nottingham).
Everton.- Kitchen, goal; Balmer and Crelly, backs; Wolstenholme, Booth and Abbott, half-backs; Sharp, Taylor, Settle, McDermott, and H.P. Hardman, forwards.
Kick-off three p.m.
Tottenham Hotspur.- Williams, goal; Watson and Tait, backs; Morris, Hughes, and J.L. Jones, half-backs; Warner, J. Jones, V.J. Woodward, Copeland, and Kirwan, forwards.

EVERTON v.  TOTTENHAM HOTSPUR
The Liverpool Football Echo- Saturday, February 6 1904
ENGLISH CUP TIE AT GOODISON PARK
Referee H. Ward (Nottingham), Linesmen; C. Green (Sheffield), & H. Shelton (Notts).
RAIN DESCENDS STEADILY
A SEA OF UMBRELLAS
FOULS GALORE
A TREACHEROUS GROUND
WILD PASSING ALL ROUND
SHARP JUST MISSES
WOODWARD SCORES FOR TOTTENHAM
SEQUENCE OF CORNERS
JONES SCORES A SECOND GOAL FOR TOTTENHAM
By Pigeon Post and Telephone
That the chances of the draw should have given Evertonians an opportunity of witnessing the prowess of the doughy “Spurs” was fully appreciated by the fine crowd of spectators who, despite the none too pleasant weather, lined the arena at Goodison Park. The adherents of the Blues never for a moment contemplated the likelihood of defeat, although Tottenham have in the past annexed the much-coveted bauble by extinguishing Sheffield United, at Bolton, after a draw at the Crystal Palace. The Spurs are never to be despised, though this season’s career has not been at all glorious. They have disposed of ten out engagements, of which they have only lost four, these being Queen’s Park Rangers, Bristol, Luton, and Southampton. They have drawn four, and defeated Millwall and Plymouth. Their last success was at home, on Saturday, when they ran round Reading to the extent of 7 goals to 4. As for the Blues, they have been as erratic as they are brilliant, and their best form would make them quite equal to wiping the Spurs out. Everton’s supporters were particularly sanguine that the side would rise to the importance of the occasion and celebrate it by a sterling victory. Shortly before the game commenced word was received that the Knowsley party would not be able to put in an appearance. However, the Lord Major and Lady Mayoress and others were there. The teams lined up as follow;-
Everton.- Kitchen, goal; Balmer and Crelly, backs; Wolstenholme, Booth (captain) and Abbott, half-backs; Sharp, Taylor, Settle, McDermott, and Corrin, forwards.
Tottenham Hotspur.- Williams, goal; Watson and Tait, backs; Morris, McNaught, and J.L. Jones, half-backs; Warner, J. Jones, Woodward, Copeland, and Kirwan, forwards.
Referee Mr. H. Ward. Linesmen, Messrs Grey and Shelton.
A couple of hours rain just before the match bid fair to make the ground very treacherous. The goal areas, however, had been carefully protected. On the home side Corrin displaced Hardman on the left wing, and Hughes occupied centre half-back position for Tottenham. Twenty thousand spectators were present when Everton turned out. Captain Booth lost the toss, but there was little in it. The Spurs had only started when a couple of fouls were given against them, and on the last occasion Booth almost succeeded in finding Williams. Then came a foul against Wolstenholme, from which the Tots put on stern pressure, but failed in their shooting powers. Several rushes were tried by the Spurs, but Balmer and Crelly presented such a stern front that no headway was made. Tricky play by Morris and Hughes was followed by a dash up the right by Warner, and from the latter’s centre Copeland missed a reasonable chance. A rush by Sharp was well checked by Tait, and a burst on the part of Corrin and McDermot was broken up by Watson. Then Warner got to work again, and notwithstanding strenuous efforts by Abbott and Crelly, the Tottenham man got up in company with J. Jones, who finally put in a rather weak shot, which passed the goal about two yards wide. The state of the ground did not suit Everton at all, and the forwards could not manage much effective combination, though they made up for it in vigour and determination. Several chances were missed in front of goal owing to the treacherous footing, but at last Everton forced the first corner. Kitchen ran a long way out of his goal to withstand a rush by Kirwan and Copeland. This was followed by a wide shot from Warner. Next Settle took advantage of a long pass from the centre but his career was cut short by Wilson. Matters settled down in midfield, and for some time neither could make effective headway until Corrin put in a smart centre, which Sharp dashing up just missed. Scrambling play all round kept the game pretty well in the centre for some time, and the only excitement came from a couple of wild drives by McDermott. Then a foul was given against Booth, from which J.L. Jones drove the ball over the Everton goal. For some minutes what pressing was done came from the Spurs, but these movements were not accurate and ended in the ball being run out of play on each side of the goal. A brace of corners now fell to Everton, one of which was forced from Williams by Settle, and after the Tottenham men had been penalised a third barren corner fell to the home players.
WOODWARD MISSES A CERTAINTY
EVERTON’S DEFENCE “GROGGY”
McDERMOTT SCORES A DISALLOWED GOAL
TAYLOR SCORES FOR EVERTON
EVERTON BEATEN ON THE POST
Tair took a free kick, which nearly brought disaster, as the Spurs left took up the attack with vigour, and, after beating Balmer, Copeland tested Kitchen with a terrific shot, which the home custodian steadily repelled. The leather was not, however, removed to safer territory, and Woodward joined in the attack the trio beating down heavily on the Everton warden, who emerged from his den only to be eluded cleverly by Woodward, who netted coolly. This reverse came to the  Blues after twenty-five minutes’ play, and it was not unexpected, as the defence was very unsteady at times, and Kitchen frequently in jeopardy. A spicey bit of play by J. Jones and Warner ended in the former shooting into Kitchen’s hands, after which McDermott came out in the centre, and gave a long pass to Corrin, who raced forward, and just got in his centre from Watson. Settle failed to get in his shot, and Taylor missed altogether. Gradually the visitors worked their way to the other end, and here fell disaster waited on the Everton players J. Jones put in a long shot, which Balmer only partially played, and the ball glanced off the Everton men and passed into the net, this second point coming about five minutes after the Spurs’ first success, and being greeted with great enthusiasm by the Tottenham supporters. Then it did look as if the Blues were to taste blood, as from a corner the ball was headed and headed until right in the goalmouth, where Settle and McDermott were all over Williams, and though they stretched the Tottenham warder out success was denied them, as the scurvy leather rolled just outside the post. It was indeed an aggravating disappointment. Everton maintained the attack with determination, but when adjacent to the goal their efforts were very disjointed and wanting in method. Settle ultimately nearly did the trick with a ground shot which tested Williams. As half-time came nigh the rain beat down pitilessly, and completely drenched the players, and the condition of the great majority of the spectators may be more easily imagined than described. Before the interval came Taylor managed to get in a grand shot, which proved a trifle too high, and then came the referee’s signal, with Everton still attacking. During the first half there was not a great amount of different in the opposing teams, but the Sours accommodated themselves much more effectually to the slimy surface of occasion, and moving more slowly than the Blues and with greater deliberation they operated all through with greater judgement. When Everton reappeared after the interval they were greeted with a hugh cheer of encouragement. Corrin went off immediately with a fine long run, but Watson checked him in the action of shooting. Then Sharp dashed into the midst of a melee, but when the ball came to Corrin he ran it out. Abbott checked on the Spurs’ right twice over but a foul again Settle spoiled an advantage. Taylor and Sharp did well together but the visitors were now playing the kicking out game, until they got an opportunity of attack. Everton tried advances on either wing but the visitors were evidently bent on keeping their opponents out at any price for they this only resorted to kicking out tactics. Kirwan got away on his own, but made no attempt at a final effort and shortly afterwards Woodward got through, Kitchen running out and securing the ball. A centre from Kirwan went whizzling and then Woodward took a pass and went clean through his opponents, being left at the finish with an open goal. This splendid opportunity proved to much for the Tottenham, for he ended with a wretched attempt. Everton then pressed hard, and gained three corners in quick succession, but they were unable to find the net. Final Result- Tottenham Hotspurs 2 goals, Everton 1 goal.

EVERTON v.  TOTTENHAM HOTSPUR
Lancashire Evening Post - Saturday 06 February 1904
At Goodison Park, in miserable weather, rain falling persistently, before a crowd of 15,000 spectators at the start. Corrin instead of Hardman, and Hughes vice McNaught for Tottenham, were the only alterations in the team. Prompt to time Woodward kicked off. Two fouls in quick succession against Tottenham ended in Booth’s skimming the bar. Warner made a dashing run and centre, but Kirwan raised a rare opportunity to score. Play was fast from end to end, the defence on either side prevailing. Kirwan and Copeland made a dashing run, the former slipping when about to shoot. Taylor was grassed when about to shoot with an open goal. Play was fast Everton with long passing generally having the best of matters, Kitchen saved a rasping shot from Copeland. From a corner Woodward drew first blood for Tottenham. From the centre Everton went off with great dash, their final efforts being futile. After a grand run, Jones scored a second goal for the ‘Spurs after 30 minutes’ play. Tottenham played up with great dash. Williams was floored in saving from a corner, the ball luckily rolling behind. Play slackened down, both teams feeling the effects of the heavy ground.
Half-time-Tottenham 2, Everton 0
Everton played a greatly improved game in the second portion, Williams defending brilliantly. Corrin made repeated rushes on the Everton left, and McDermott shot into the net, but was given offside. From a centre by Corrin the ball put through Tottenham’s goal by Watson the right back. Result- Tottenham Hotspur 2, Everton 1.

SURRPISE AT EVERTON
Empire News & The Umpire - Sunday 07 February 1904
KEENLY-CONTESTED GAME:
VICTORY FOR TOTTENHAM.
BY A. J. E
An examination of Everton's connection with the English Cup-ties during the past four seasons reveals some rather curious facts. In 1900 Everton were drawn against at Southampton, in the first round, and were beaten 3-0. In 1901 they were again drawn against Southampton, the latter having choice of ground, but Everton won 3-1. The latter were beaten in the second round by Sheffield United, who were defeated in the replayed final by Tottenham Hotspur. In 1902 Everton were beaten in the first round by Liverpool, after replaying, the latter being “knocked out” in the next round by Southampton. In 1903 Portsmouth were met and defeated in the first round at Goodison Park, Millwall knocking Everton out in the third round. It will be seen, therefore, that Southern clubs have played a big part in Everton’s Cup-tie history in latter years, either directly or indirectly, and the encounter this season lost nothing in attractiveness from the fact that Everton’s opponents were another Southern club, who although they have not done so well in their Southern League matches, can always be relied on in Cup-ties to put up a good fight. Yesterday's match was played under most depressing conditions, the ground being heavy and treacherous at the start, and getting worse as time went on, the rain falling heavily and incessantly.  It was not a good game, but this was only what could be expected, players having great difficulty in keeping their feet, Everton especially so. Fouls were frequently the home team being the chief offenders in this respect. During the first half the Spurs did the greater amount of attacking, although one or two good individual efforts by the Everton forwards deserve mention. Corrin (substituted for Hardman at outside left on account of the heavy state of the ground) was always a worker, and led attacks on more than one occasion. He put across two grand captures early on, only to see Sharp too late for one, and Taylor kicking over from a second, finishing a third effort by shooting inches behind the post into the side net. On the part of the Everton team it was nearly all individual effort, the front line being consequently ineffective, and being made more so by the slowness of McDermott. Everton forced the first two corners of the game, but these were cleared without difficulty, the Spurs packing their goal. The Everton halves had not the opportunity of rendering much assistance in attack, being too much occupied in defensive tactics. The forwards and halves on the visiting side were very effective, owing to perfect understanding and wonderfully precise passing, considering the ground. Though the first goal to the Spurs was somewhat lucky, the movements that preceded it were good. Kirwan sent in a grand centre, Copeland shooting hard at Kitchen, who caught the ball and kicked away. The ball was returned, however, Kitchen being bothered to clear, and the ball eventually went behind for a corner. It was well placed, Woodward heading through. This was after about half an hour’s play. Everton took up the attack, but Tottenham got down, and Jones (J) shot at goal. This Balmer appeared in no way bothered to clear, but placing his foot to receive the ball at the bounce he missed it, and the Spurs were a second goal up. Kitchen would not doubt have saved this had he been prepared for it coming past Balmer. But unfortunate he was not. Following this, Settle put in a grand shot which deserved to score.
The second half was mainly in Everton’s favour though at the other end Woodward missed an open goal on two occasions, once from six yards line. Everton had somewhat hard lines in not scoring earlier than they did, as Wolstenholme hit the bottom of the post and Taylor the bar, with the goalkeeper quite beaten. Taking the game right through, the better team won. The Spurs forwards quite overplayed the Everton halves, and the defence of the visitors was safe.  Tait was, perhaps, the better back, the only palpable mistake he made being the shot that scored for Everton.  The Tottenham halves were all good, feeding and assisting the forwards judiciously, and stopping the Everton front line fairly efficiently. Of the forwards the left wing were the better, though the right played well. From Woodward we had one or two delightful touches, but his shooting was sadly out. On the Everton side, Balmer for once was at sea, and in addition to making some bad clearances, missed the ball altogether on occasions. Crelly was much safer. Of the halves Booth was much the best, sticking to Woodward most effectually. Forward Corrin, Taylor, and Sharp played well, and Settle shone on occasions. McDermott did some good things, but spoiled many otherwise good efforts by slowness. As a whole the forwards were ineffective owing to a lack of understanding and combination, and spoiled good movements by offside, and playing too much on the backs and giving them too much clearing room.

EVERTON v. TOTTENHAM HOTSPUR.
London Daily News - Monday 08 February 1904
Tottenham Hotspur gained a brilliant victory over Everton at Goodison Park by two goals to one. This was regarded as one of the most important of the Cup ties. and in spite of a heavy downpour of rain, about 18,000 people watched the play. Both teams were strongly represented. Corrin appearing for Everton instead of Hardman. The game opened at a great pace although the ground was in deplorable condition, quite against fast play. For half an hour the exchanges ruled even, and then Woodward headed through for Tottenham from corner. J. Jones soon followed with a second goal for the London club, who were playing in determined fashion. Everton then pressed hard, but failed to score, half-time being reached with the Hotspur leading by two goals to none. In the second half Everton were seen to greater advantage. At times Tottenham pressed, and Woodward once badly mulled a fine centre from Kirwan, but for the most part Everton attacked strongly. They were, however, met with sound defence. Williams and the Hotspur backs playing admirably. Watson failed at time from a centre from Corrin, and put the ball through his own goal, thus scoring for Everton, but Tottenham always led, and in the end they won with a goal spare.

HOW EVERTON FELL
Athletic News - Monday 08 February 1904
A Tale of a Tottenham Triumph
By Nondescript
Everton beaten at home! The one greet surprise of the round, I should say.  Yet merit would not be denied, and I imagine it will be conceded by almost all who saw the match that the “Spurs” deserved their success.  You know the old couplet;  Thrice armed is he who hath his quarrel just.  But four times he who gets his blow in “fust.”   Tottenham got first blow in, and ere the enemy could fairly recover himself another weak spot was found and down he went again.  Late in the bout he recovered his wind- but all too late.  And so another muffled note on the funeral bell.  “Toll for the brave, the brave that are no more.”  For Everton were brave enough.  Though misfortune marked them for its own, and held them forever so long under its sinister spell, they fought a good if a losing battle.  Goodness knows they might have fought better, but the team in general, though it better, but the team in general though revealing individual and collective shortcomings, gave the lie on this occasion to popular opinion- which has I must say, been shared by myself-that their valour evaporates when they are called upon to face a deficit.  In the second half of Saturday’s proceedings they were niggers in more than one sense.  They were several times baulked by mere trifles of bad luck- and had management-which means such a lot when a team is in desperate straits.  Do not let be inferred, however, that ill-luck befell only one side.  The Tottenham forwards had a bad habit of declining open goals and miracle dictum!  Woodward himself was in dire disgrace at least once.  One was thankful in a sense that it happened so, for his egregious blunder early on in the second half, when the “Spurs” stood two goals up, paved the way to some spirited proceedings at the other end in all of which keep interest was maintained until the end.  For it was a rousing good game, and considering how heavy was the going, with rain churning it the more every minute, then men stood the ordeal right well.  The misfortunes of Everton were manifold.  Kitchen gave away one goal; Balmer turned another ball through his own posts; Sharp missed an open space; McDermott could only have been inches off-side if that, when he found the net; Booth clean beat Williams, but shivered the post; Taylor did ditto in scraping the bar.  Yet they were a sorely tried team. Let us give the visitors their desert, however. They exchanged one fluky goal. Watson fairly setting the netting on a quiver with a ball which was intended for up the field.  Woodward’s defections have just been alluded to.  A small slice of luck at the one end would have returned the verdict 2-2.  The merest
Trifles, however, stood in the way of a 4-1 victory for Tottenham, who accommodated themselves better to the conditions, and are not to be begrudged what they extracted, but rather to be congratulated upon a clever achievement.  And we have a fine and a healthy admiration for the “Spurs” in Lancashire.  We have been previously witness to their doughty deeds, and we remember the time when beaten at Preston on their first visit to the County, the little knot of followers on the stand rose in their places at the conclusion of the game, and gave three heart cheers for North End.  It was something so weird and strange that we rude Barbarians of Northern climes were almost inclined to disbelieve eyes and ears.  But we like Tottenham none the less, though they keep beating us, and should be glad to see them again shortly –say at Manchester.
A Watery Grave
In continuation of our nautical lay concerning the downfall of Everton one might well add. "All lost beneath the wave.” One reason which I heard advanced for their defeat was the deplorable state of the turf. It is rather curious, then, that the worse the ground became the lustier was their attack. No, I don't think that argument will hold water, although there is not the least doubt that on a dry surface the feats which they attempted would have been more happily consummated. Their long passing, commenced very early by the forwards, did nothing more than present Tait and partner with free kicks galore, and they soon tired themselves with sticking to the ball too long, so that at the start they were not successful with either plan of attack. Sharp close in just missed a cross from Corrin, and then Settle, who was poaching behind the backs, could not gather a ball as it spun towards the goal-line off one of the defenders. Later on, when Settle wove towards the left, drawing Watson with him, no one on the home side was intelligent enough to slip into his place as the ball came back to the centre again. That was a reasonable chance neglected. On another occasion, Williams, by weight of numbers, friend and foe, was forced through the goal, the ball escaping by the post. Then Settle and Taylor both came by the ball close in and both seemed undecided which should take it, Taylor eventually firing over. And now for a chapter about Tottenham and all that they did. They did many clever things. Generally Wolstenholme and Abbott were altogether unable to hold the wings, and although Booth kept a watchful eye on Woodward, Copeland required his attention likewise, and Tom at times ’‘between the devil and the deep sea." The visiting forwards, disposing their attack in fairly equal parts, kept themselves fresh enough to deliver a succession of attacks which considerably harassed Kitchen’s department.  Kirwan and Copeland were especially demonstrative.  The first-named went sprawling in the slime when careering straight for the keeper. Next he got a beauty to the front, while later on he spun round Wolstenholme, crossed to Woodward, who tapped back to Copeland, who all but took the keeper by surprise. This shot was well fielded, but from a subsequent corner Kitchen quite lost the ball and Woodward had no difficulty in heading past him. This occurred almost on the verge of half an hour. Three minutes later, and after a spirited attack on the other goal. Jones at inside right, finding Balmer coming for him, tried a long shot, and it was Balmer’s misfortune to get only the sole of his boot on the ball and to see it squirm into the net. Kitchen’s view being quite obstructed. The early part of the second half found the half-backs a less formidable force, and the team was lucky to be charged nothing serious for their delinquencies. Everton now got more of the ball, but still kept poking it in the air too much, though after Woodward had quite spoiled the effect a tricky incursion on the part of Kirwan by the egregious effort which has been alluded to, the home attack settled down to rather better business. They were never quite so circumspect in their movements as the opposing line, but they got to the front pretty often. Booth, in addition to the raspier which hit the post, with Williams ’’beaten to the world,” gave his forwards one or two other excellent examples to copy, but obstacles would persist in cropping up. Sometimes a defender’s legs were in the way, at others the goal was not quite large enough. Sharp blundered away a possible chance of saving the game when he trod over the ball not couple of yards out. Taylor headed a beauty on the bar. McDermott was ruled off-side when did cap one of the prettiest movements of the day, and it was left for Watson to make a present of a goal in the manner stated. There was just a chance left as Abbott took a free kick tor tripping, but his shot was fit companion to much of his work, and that was distinctly below his average.
PERSONAL PIPS.
It was a fine point on the general run of the play which had most of the ball. Everton of the two are probably the better team, but their inconsistency, which has been so frequently advertised since they reached the seats of the mighty, was once more apparent. An unbalanced team in the first half hour—that was when they lost the game. Booth, Crelly, Corrin, and Settle were the few who did several reputations justice. The first-named behaved like a Trojan. He could not prevent Woodward breaking clear at times, but as a rule it was trick and tie between them, and the Everton half-back had a heap of work throat upon him by reason of the fact that Wolstenholme and Abbott were less happy than is their wont.  Crelley was the steadier back, Balmer for once in a way being shaky, kicking weakly for him, and generally being below himself. Corrin, whose election to the extreme left was decided upon in consequence of the heavy ground, stood worthily by his sponsors, and more good work would have been got out of him, but that McDermott was so awfully behind the times. In the second half certainly McDermott was more alive to his opportunities, and a few deft touches on his part helped Everton’s case on materially, but somehow he seemed not to be thoroughly awake until reaching an advanced stage of the proceedings. As between Woodward and Settle we were shown distinct types of centre-forward play, and the palm undoubtedly went to the amateur who would brush through and make openings for himself, while his passing when at full gallop was wonderfully certain considering the lay of the land. Altogether he appeared in bolder relief as a leader of men, and only as a deadlier shot did Settle claim any advantage. The last-named handled his wings with poor judgment, and only occasionally rose to a height of individual excellence. Taylor was “everything turns, and nothing great,’’ working hard in all three divisions of the team, but being a less powerful factor than I have seen him, while continual wordy warfare between him and Hughes did not improve his play. Laying well up Tait repeatedly intercepted passes intended for Sharp, nor was the latter allowed much free play by the other members of the Tottenham defence whenever he eluded “Sandy’s " vigilance. Tait himself played one of his best games, after starting shakily, and Watson, his one tremendous blunder excepted, buckled to heartily, several times asserting his resource in goalmouth. So much said of both, each managed to keep straight shots out more by accident than design. With all their shortcomings the Everton forwards gave Williams opportunities of asserting himself as a sound custodian, and save that his kicking from goal was weak, he has lost nothing from the character which was his when at Manchester. The old Tottenham half-back partnership is still a potent force, being seen to infinite advantage during the first half, when showing off stolidity and judgment in equal parts. Woodward, as the forward whose appearance excited the moat curiosity, caught the eye very favourably in field tactics, but he contributed no more to the success of the side than Kirwan, who was a constant thorn in the path of Wolstenholme and Balmer, and was exceedingly well partnered by Copeland. This pair engaged in some the prettiest movements of the day. Jones, on the other wing, too, pleased me immensely, and though Warner was the least conspicuous of the five, he had a sound idea of the geography of the posts. The value of sweeping crosses and long drives from the wings to the centre on such a day was demonstrated with force when Jones shot Tottenham’s second goal.  The ‘‘’Spurs’’ played this game for all it was worth. Yet they carried style in most that they did, and certainly out-pointed the others in keeping the ball nearer the ground- Everton.—Kitchen; Balmer and  Crelley; Wolstenholme, Booth, and Abbott; Sharp. Taylor. Settle, McDermott, and Corrin.  Tottenham Hotspur;- Williams; Watson and Tait; Morris, McNaught, and Jones (J.T.); Warner, Jones (J.), V.J. Woodward, Copeland, and Kirwan.  Referee; H. Ward, Nottingham. 

EVERTON 1 TOTTENHAM HOTSPUR 2 (Fac Game 45)
February 8, 1904. The Liverpool Courier.
F.A.Cup Round One.

In the first round proper of the always popular English Cup Competition. Everton were fortunate in being drawn at home. Moreover, they were lucky enough to be pitted against an attractive team in Tottenham Hotspur, who are rarely seen in the north. Both teams had been in training during the week, Everton at Blackpool, and the Spurs at Southport. Unfortunately, the day turned out miserably wet, rain falling without cessation from shortly after midday. This affected the attendance in some degree, though possibly the doubling of the prices for the goal end, stands had something to do with it. Shortly before the game started the attendance was estimated at 18,000. The Lord Mayor occupied a seat in the directors box. The ground was very heavy and slippery, and the conditions were all against a good exposition of the game. The teams were: - Everton: - Kitchen goal, W.Balmer, and Crelly, backs, Wolstenholme, Booth (captain), and Abbott, half-backs Sharp Taylor, Settle, McDermott, and Corrin, forwards. Tottenhan Hotspur: - Williams, goal, Watson, and Tait, backs, Morris, Hughes, and J.L.Jones, half-backs, Warmer, J.Jones, V.J.Woodward, Copeland, and Kirwan, forwards. Referee H.Ward. Tottenham kicked off, and in quick succession two fouls were given against them, the ball being eventually sent past. A free kick against the home team transferred play to Everton ground. The visiting backs kicked with great effect and the “Spurs” forwards were very energetic, with the result that Warmer got in a beautiful centre, which presented Kirwan with a lovely opening of which he failed to take advantage, greatly to the delight of the home supporters. The excursionists from London heartily cheered the “Spurs” vigorous efforts. Next Sharp made his presence felt on the right wing, but he was not allowed to get in a centre, and play for some time was in midfield. Everton experienced considerable difficulty in making headway and on two occasions Settle and Corrin both came under the ban of the referee for offside. At this period Everton was having slightly, the better of exchanges, though the visiting backs were hard to beat. Still keeping up the pressure, Everton gained the first corner of the match, conceded by Tait. This however, was of no avail, and immediately the Spurs via Kirwan, made tracks, for the other end. The outside man centred, and brought Kitchen out of his goal, but the custodian was not troubled, though there could be no denying the effective style of football given by the Spurs. Off-side against Warmer relieved the situation. A fine bit of passing between Copeland and Woodward was applauded, and happily for Everton, Kirwan was unable to reach the amateur. The home defence were experiencing an anxious time, for the visiting forwards manipulated the ball with marked success. Suddenly the game took a turn, and following an abortive corner forced by Taylor, another followed as the result of a free kick close in. nothing however, came of it, and a free kick to the Spurs relieved the pressure. After Booth had kick away from Kirwan's centre, Kitchen saved a capital shot from Copeland, and a little later the custodian kicked away a low shot from close quarters. A corner resulted, and from the Woodward opened the scoring, for the Spurs after half an hour's play. From the restart Sharp tricked a couple of opponents, and centred finely, Corrin's shot curling just round the post. The Spurs were soon pressing again, and Warmer dropped the ball well, into the Everton goalmouth, Kitchen having to save under difficulties. He was fouled, but the free kick brought no relief, for within a few minutes of the first goal Morris beat Kitchen for a second time with a long, Balmer being at fault. After this second reverse Everton made determined attempts to reduce the margin against them, but the Tottenham defence was very sound. Two corners were forced on each wing, but nothing resulted, the visitors packing their goal to good purpose. Suddenly Kirwan led an attack by the Southerns, but his shot went wide, and Everton were again exerting pressure only to find the visiting defence too strong for them. At last from Sharp's centre, Settle put in a really good shot, which deserved to score, and at the time much of the ineffectiveness of the home front line were due to the weakness of McDermott. Taylor tried to make amends, and had hard lines with a shot, which just skimmed the crossbar. Everton were attacking strongly when the whistle blew for the interval. Half-time Everton nil, Tottenham Hotsour 2. The weather was very gloomy when operations were resumed. Right from the kickoff Corrin who had been putting any amount of heart into his play, was conspicuous with a good run, and the ball remained in the Tottenham half, without, however, Williams being troubled. Everton opened the second period in a manner, which encouraged their supporters, but soon the Londoners took up the running, and afterwards, when Woodward was becoming dangerous. Kitchen had to come out of his goal when his backs were beaten. He kicked clear, but the ball was quickly returned, and after remarkably clever footwork by Kirwan, who easily discomfited Balmer and Wolstenholme. Woodward failed at an open goal. Tottenham were playing a winning game, and with an increase in the downpour there was a corresponding diminution in the hopes of the Evertonians. Still for a time, although the understanding between the halves, and forwards was greatly at fault, the home side kept at it so persistently that a goal seemed forthcoming. It looked odd on Sharp scoring but Williams saved at the expense of an abortive corner from Sharp, while a moment later the custodian and cleared a grand shot from Booth, the “Spurs” goal having marvellous escapes. Everton were now fairly penning their opponents, but Williams in goal performed prodigies of valour. Sharp missed when a few yards from goal, and Taylor banged in a lighting shot without avail, but strive as they would, the Tottenham defence appeared to bear a charmed existence. The “Spurs” rarely got over the half-way line, Everton having greatly improved in their tactics. Still the long looked for goals were not forthcoming. Both Sharp and Corrin sustained slight injuries, but despite these drawbacks, Everton continued to exert pressure. Afterwards the game opened out, and the Spurs long shooting was always dangerous. Everton had all the better of the game just before the finish. Watson, intercepting a centre from Corrin, put into his own goal. Everton tried hard, but failed to draw level. Result Everton 1, Tottenham Hotspur.

Jack Kirwan Ex Everton now Tottenham

EVERTON REVIEW
February 8, 1904. The Liverpool Mercury
To say that Everton's defeat at home by Tottenham Hotspur in the first round of the Association Cup-tie came as a tremendous surprise is putting the case very mildly. That they deserved to lose can scarcely be gainsaid, for they never seemed to realise what were the tactics necessary on such a suddened ground to gain the victory, and not until the second half was reached did they display any adaptability to the inclement conditions. Corrin was selected at the last moment to fill the extreme left position, this being presumably due to the heavy nature of the going, and although he was badly served by his partner, he proved one of the most useful of the forwards. The Spurs came down from Southport-having spent the week there-and judging from their display, they had derived considerable benefit from the change. For a fortnight Everton had been training in Blackpool, but whatever advantage they had gained by their sojourn on the Lancashire coast were by no means apparent in their movements against the Londoners. The game may be fairly divided into two portions, in which the Spurs and the home side respectively proved the most efficient, though it is worth bearing in mind that the visitors entered on the second part of the contest with a lead of two goals, and could thus be satisfied with devoting their attentions more on defence than in exerting their energies towards further onslaughts on the Everton goal. Tottenham won the match in the first half, and Everton, though they made a gallant effort afterwards, could never redeem their failings of the earlier portions of the game. Not one of the goals scored was a good point; the first was due to a blunder by Kitchen, who completely missed the ball in dealing with a corner kick, whilst the second was the result of a mistake by Balmer, who in the goalmouth diverted a long shot from J.Jones into the net. Even Everton's goal was presented for Watson turned a swift centre from Corrin past his own keeper, and accomplished what the Everton forwards had failed to do, namely defeat Williams. Still Tottenham were fully two goals better than their rivals at half-time, and even recognising the fact, that the better round themselves to valiant deeds in the concluding stages, it is difficult to understand why they could not have done this earlier, and not have waited for their opponents to incite than to such efforts by gaining the comfortable lead of two goals. It is also a matter of surprise that Everton should have attempted to play the close-passing game on such a day; when they did open out the play after the interval the beneficial effects were immediately apparent, and they practically courted defeat by their mistaken tactics prior to half-time. Seldom have the Everton half backs been so completely outmanurved as they were by the Tottenham forwards, and the latter found it an easy master to outwitted Wolstenholme and Abbott. They played splendid football through out the first 45 minutes, and gave the home defence a very anxious time. In marked contrast to the doings of the Southerners, the Everton forwards were utterly disjointed, and they persisted in finessing and dribbling in the mud until they were unable, through sheer lack of energy, to send in a decent shot. McDermott was the weakest player in the home ranks, and the conditions were always too much for him, for his passes invariably went astray, and he was easily dispossessed. Settle was of little use, his centre forwards and, with the exception of occasioned flashes by Sharp and Corrin, none of the members of the front line showed to advantage. The surprising feature of Everton's performance was the poor exhibition given by the half-backs, who failed to hold the Tottenham forwards, and were at times hopelessly bewildered by the sparkling combined onslaught of the Southern Leaguers. That understanding between them and their forwards, which has been such a conspicuous feature in their League matches, was altogether wanting, but as already stated, the criticism could not apply to their work in the closing stages of the struggle. Then both forwards and halves demonstrated what they really could do when moving in something like the customary fashion, and whilst giving them every credit for their splendid work during this period, their earlier failings were too pronounced to be excusable. The defence was likewise erratic, for though Blamer cleared well at times he was frequently beaten in his efforts to stop the Spurs left wing, and the old Everton player, Kirwan, had a rare time. Crelly was more reliable, but taken all round, there was not the same efficiency display in this portion of the team that is usually witnessed. Kitchen made one fatal blunder, which led to the visitors first goal, but he would most probably have stopped the second shot that scored had not Balmer interfered. It was, of course, difficult to maintain a foothold on the treacherous turf, but this handicapped both teams, and Tottenham made fewer blunders than Everton. Their excellent mancouvring in the first half gained for the visitors a deserving victory, and considering the state of the ground, they played, very fine football. Kirwan was the pick of the front line, but Woodward, put in some capital work, and on a pitch which appeared detrimental to one of his physique, gave a surprisingly judicious and dashing exhibition. The inside players combined grandly together, and, after establishing their lead, were content to vely upon occasional breakaways, in the second half. The halves were sound and reliable, placing nicely to the men in front of them, and Morris on the right wing was the most effective of the trio. Further behind, Watson and Tait kicked very cleanly, and seldom blundered, the notable exception being the miskick of the former about three minutes from the finish, which led to Everton's solitary point. Williams kept a clever goal, and some of his clearances were exceedingly smart. Once he was completely beaten by a terrific drive from Booth, which unfortunately struck the upright, but he certainly had much to do with his side success by his capable display when the home team were crowding on pressure. With Cup and League prospects now effectively dimmed, there is little of interest to anticipate with regard to the disappointing Everton team, and the remaining League matches of the season. Despite the adverse conditions, 20,000 people witnessed the contest, the receipts amounting to £850. The Lord Major, who occupied a seat in the director's box, and whose arrival was greeted with cheers, was an interested spectator.

SATURDAY’S FOOTBALL
Liverpool Daily Post - Monday 08 February 1904
Probably no team of its rank failed to rise to the occasion as did Everton on Saturday. When the draw was first published it looked a “dead snip” as the betting brotherhood say, for them to have Tottenham Hotspur down at Goodison Park- a walk over and a big gate. The best of the Southern League teams, however, always require a lot of beating when they go cup-hunting and no one knows this better than Liverpool followers of the game, as both our home clubs have had bitter experience in the matter. That Everton have no further interest in this year’s contest is party their own fault. If they had endeavoured to play up to weather conditions at the start, as did their opponents they would possibly have gone into the next round. Instead of “rising to the occasion” on the heavy going they preferred to go mud-grubbing in the heavy slush, and when it was all too late they bethought of pulling themselves together. Blunders and carelessness gave the visitors Blunders and carelessness gave the visitors a two-goal lead at the interval. The first point Kitchen conceded by leaving his goal absolutely at the mercy of his opponents, and the second was obtained through a disastrous blunder by Balmer.
Changing ends with the score two goals to nil in their favour, the Tottenham men could afford to be onlookers to the extent of acting purely on the defensive. It was not their game to further force matters by scattering their forces over the field; on the contrary, they acted wisely for their own interests by presenting a compact front, and let Everton do the attacking. When opportunity arose, without endangering their own citadel the ‘Spurs could make a sally and send the opposition belter-skelter to look after its own goal. That is what they did. It was a safe game to play, and by holding tight what they had secured, it gave the game the appearance that they were being hotly pressed. As a matter of fact, Everton did press hard at this juncture, but it was only on sufferance, for the reason stated. It was good generalship on the part of the Hotspurs’ captain. True, it might have cost them their ultimate victory; but-there is always a but- there was a perfect unison and understanding between the whole team, and full confidence in the strength of their defence. It was not like that of Everton’s groggy, vacillating and erratic. No team better deserved success than did that of Tottenham. They had come a long way to secure it, and, on the day’s play, they were the better lot. They played well together, showed fine judgement, and as was evidenced, there was perfect understanding between the respective lines. They had been well tutored up to victory. After the game was over, many of the spectators were of opinion that the Everton players deserved sympathy. Well, they would have done had they showed sounder work in the first position of play. That they experienced several “slices of hard luck” in the second half there is no denying; but all the same they threw away the game in its early stages, and anything they did after-victory excepted-could not atone for those blunders. It was about the worst exhibition the half backs could possibly have given-a line generally in which the team excels. The forwards were much too nice for the slop and rain; and the backs-well they gave the visitors their victory. We hope Tottenham as they deserve, will go much further in the contest and show other teams and spectators what sort of football players they are.

TOTTENHAM'S TRIUMPHANT TRIP TO TOFFEELAND.
Football Chat & Athletic World- Tuesday 09 February 1904
By " Montezuma.”
I know not whether the popular Spurs of Tottenham are mudlarks or otherwise; certain it is that they travelled to Goodison Park on Saturday and laid the confident Everton team in the dust—or was it mud? Was there a man so bold two months ago to even hint on Merseyside-or most other places—that Woodward and his fellows would overthrow the Blues on their favourite fighting pitch, he would have been considered but fit for putting inside a football-case and kicking. What, Tottenham to overcome such a finely balanced team as Everton? Sheer nonsense! Yes, so thoroughly oblivious is the football expert, the football man-in-the-crowd," to anything like precedent tradition—ay! and solid facts. For have not the Spurs ever shown themselves a Cup-fighting rather than a points-earning team? Have not the Spurs always come out on top following a sojourn at Southport? Methinks the Hottentots would fain carry this little seaside resort's ozone about with them to the end of the story, which would assuredly reach Chapter V.—the Crystal Palace, and a " happy-ever-afterwards " finis!
The clerk of the weather was absolutely seen at his worst in Liverpool on Saturday. Before noon the ground represented a huge sponge just after a dip in the muddy Mersey. Then for two hours prior to the start the rain came down, first steadily, afterwards in a terrific downpour, culminating in a fearful " waterspout " during the second half, which resulted in some of the contestants resorting to safety-pins to fasten up their weighty nether extremities with a view to increasing locomotion. Then the very cussedness of the thing! Just as the final tootle went the rain ceased and little bits of " blue " (not Everton) were seen overhead, smiling, as it were, on the Spurs' gallant victory. Everton left Hardman out of the team in favour of Corrin ' the latter being more likely to succeed under the untoward conditions prevailing.
Woodward started, and in the first minute a couple of free kicks fell to Everton—looked as though " Tots " were going to play the robust game. But here let me say that, taking the match in its entirety, Everton were distinctly the greater sinners in this respect. The visitors got into their stride so quickly, and what is more, maintained the advantage throughout the first half that the Blues, failing to secure the anticipated whip-hand, were frequently noticed resorting to illegal tactics. In the second stage, when Everton in turn exerted the pressure, the Spurs seldom resorted to anything unorthodox. Not that the game was rough in any sense of the word; " dirty " it was truly, but never rough. But I am digressing. Bringing the ball back, then, so to speak, Woodward and his confreres quickly fell into their stride. There was no needless finesse, but just sufficient cleverness introduced to get the better of an opponent and effect a rapid and accurate transference to a better-placed comrade. I tell you those Southerners required an immensity of holding. Their half-backs were rare workers, and many a time did Settle, Sharp, or Taylor's dribbles meet a hasty death. If Morris, Jones, or Hughes were passed then did we behold unflinching and effective tackling, by Watson and Tait, with the result that Williams kept in almost complete idleness; his turn came later. Everton's combination, in brief, was knocked into a cocked hat, their attacks evaporating long before firing range was reached. But not so the enemy. Kirwan was proving a big armful indeed, whilst Warner on the other extreme, got in many dangerous runs and centres. And how they were fed by the three insiders! Woodward appeared to revel in the going, and real class was writ in his pedipulations. J. Jones looked after Warner as a mother does her first-born, whilst Copeland in a quieter way was every bit as dangerous. Quite early on, Kirwan in his anxiety to meet a perfect cross from Warner, was just inches out of his reckoning when located almost under the bar; this was an earnest of what was to follow. The visiting quintette played such a lively and harmonious tune that in comparison it was pretty much a case of discord in the home defensive camp. Tottenham always looked the more likely side to open the account, yet thirty minutes elapsed before they did so. Kitchen had conceded a corner, which Warner placed with rare judgment; Kitchen rushed out a few yards to clear, but the flight of the ball deceived him, and Woodward was left in clear possession to find the desired haven. Five minutes afterwards Jones tried a long shot, which Kitchen would doubtless have cleared, but Balmer was anxious to do so, and stretching his leg out, had the mortification to find he had deflected the ball out of the keeper's reach. The Blues put on a few spurts after this, but never really looked like equalising, and breathing time arrived showing Tottenham with a well-deserved two goals lead.
Crowing over, the visiting forwards evidently thought they had done their share towards victory, and that it was now the turn of Williams and his helpmates in defence. Be that as it may, beyond some fine individual runs by Kirwan, little was seen of the Tottenham forwards in the second half. It was early apparent that the Toffees were bent upon retrieving their fortunes. But they reckoned without their host, so to speak, and he, chiefly Williams, the keeper, mentioned by “Yours truly" in last week's CHAT, was prone to playing the part of host most effectively when in other people's houses! But after a few minutes' play, Kirwan served up a delightful dodgy run, wherein, in most artistic fashion, he outwitted Wolstenholme and Balmer, and placed the ball slick in front of goal to Woodward's toes, for the latter to miss egregiously. This was practically the Spurs' last scoring chance. After that Williams seemed to have raised a hornet's nest around his head, or I should say the Toffie team buzzed around like so many busy bees. Right to the call of time did Everton practically pen the visitors to their goal. Williams, in particular, performed prodigies of valour, whilst Tait, Watson, and others tackled, kicked, kicked, tackled, and charged down all manner of shots unflinchingly. Eight minutes from the finish and still the Spurs stuck doggedly to their task—and their two goals lead. Then McDermott found the net. But stay, the referee disallows the point offside; 'yet it must have been a very near thing. Seven, six, five, four minutes remained for play when Taylor secures a bona-fide goal. The crowd went frantic—a 25,000 crowd, I should say—and a passing stranger might have thought it was a winning goal to Everton that had been proclaimed. In the last three minutes Everton worked strenuously for that small mercy—an equalising point, but it never came, and time proclaimed Tottenham winners of one of the warmest fights they have ever experienced throughout an honourable career.
To me Everton appeared to attempt their usual methodical dry-day tactics in the first half, whereas the winners suited themselves more in accordance with the prevailing conditions. But there was no mistaking which side exerted the pressure afterwards, and doubtless it was to some extent due to over anxiety that the Blues failed to turn their scoring openings to account more frequently. The losers certainly had little luck, and once a lightning ball from Booth struck the upright when Williams was yards away. The latter had a tremendous hand in his side's success, clearing time and again in marvellous fashion. Tait and Watson proved the stoutest of stout-hearted backs, and Sharp seldom got the better of the old North Ender, who wears wonderfully. Tottcnham Taffies versus Everton Toffies applies most appropriately to the Spurs' middle division —Morris, Hughes, and Jones—whilst the forwards, although they did not stay the gruelling course too well, excelled themselves in the initial moiety, and thereby quite upset the calculations of Everton's middle division, so that the latter were unable to assist their own forwards in the slightest. Kirwan played well to the finish, and was a most dangerous customer, whilst Woodward outshone his vis-a-vis Settle. Indeed, Settle was the weakest link in Everton's attacking chain. Copeland and J. Jones were rare grafters, whilst Warner played a telling Kirwan type of game. Needless to state, the Toffies were very cut up at having to bid such a hasty adieu to their pet hobby—their search after that "hidden treasure" yclept " the English Cup." Everton lost their grip of victory in the first half, and their only solatium is the knowledge that they eventually died fighting and full of fight. Their backs were not seen at their best, but the middle line played grandly after the interval, when the forwards, too, came out in a strong light ; they banged the ball about, which was the only right thing to do, for previously their dainty passes never came to hand, sticking in mid-stream to be picked up by those smart look-outs—Morris, Hughes, or Jones. Methought Collin, the man introduced at the last moment, was Everton's most successful forward. Tottenham, you have my best wishes, only don't do it again—especially at Everton!

SPURS SPLENDID SUCCESS.
Football Chat and Athletic World- Tuesday 09 February 1904
Tottenham Ablaze with Jubilation
By “Hotspur.”
My pen fails to describe the excitement and tokens of real honest enthusiasm displayed by every mother' son and daughter around this district at the brilliant victory gained by the Spurs of Tottenham at Everton on Saturday last in the Cup-tie. Certainly I have given every indication of the great confidence I felt that our men would prove capable of fully extending what was admittedly a very dangerous side, made doubly so knowing they had choice of venue on a ground where they have been showing such a great fighting demeanour. By a show of real grit and indomitable pluck the Tottenham men have once more startled the football world by a brilliant performance—a performance that will add lustre to their already great Cup fighting reputation.
The result—Tottenham 2, Everton I—is, I opine, looked upon as a bolt from the blue out Liverpool way, and although this sorry defeat of the Everton pets has proved the death blow to Liverpool hopes, I can assure all and sundry who reside near the banks of the Mersey that everything in the Tottenham garden at the present moment bears a very bright appearance. A victory gained at the expense of these much-lauded First Leaguers has indeed provided us with pleasant thought and most digestible matter for debate. Mine is not the task to describe the exciting incidents during the momentous struggle. Taking the point of view held by one who is entrusted with a watching brief to convey the impressions of the ordinary observer, I express the universal opinion of every follower of the club when offering hearty congratulations to the players who did such grand work midst trying circumstances on the Everton ground. While admiring the brilliant individual work of Charlie Williams, Tait, and Watson, also Vivian Woodward and J. Jones (for their two sparkling goals), it is as a combination, not individually, that we doff our caps for the honour to our district. They certainly performed what was universally considered a herculean task, and by their success proved themselves capable of upholding an established Cup fighting reputation—a reputation, which has reached a high standard, and which has made them so popular. The Tottenham goods were despatched to Everton via Southport labelled " Dangerous! " and the recipients, failing to handle the goods with judicious after due caution, have but themselves to blame for the explosion which shattered their hopes and expectations. There are many letters and wires arriving from all parts of the South congratulating the Spurs of Tottenham on this performance.

EVERTON v. TOTTENHAM HOTSPUR.—
Football Chat and Athletic World- Tuesday 09 February 1904
The official in charge of this game, Mr. Harry Ward, is a native of Sheffield, but has resided in Nottingham since early childhood. In the lace city he was a playing member of the Nottingham St. Peter's, Nottingham St. Mary's and Robin Hood Rifles football clubs. A member of the Notts Football Association eleven years, and thirteen years Notts Church Football Association. Is present hon. secretary of local referees' committee, and chairman of the Nottinghamshire Amateur Football League. Commenced refereeing Sin the Notts League, 1890, Midland League, 1895, Southern League, 1901, Football League, 1902. Was a linesman in latter from 1888 to 1901.
EVERTON v  TOTTENHAM at Goodison Park, Everton
Everton; Kitchen (goal), Balmer and Crelly (backs), Wolstenholme, Booth, and Abbott (half-backs); Sharp, Taylor, Settle, McDermott, and Corrin (forwards).
Tottenham Hotspur; Williams (goal), Watson and Tait (backs0, Morris, McNaught, and J.L. Jones (half-backs), Warner, J. Jones, V.J. Woodward, Copeland, and Kirwan (forwards).

THE GREAT CUP TIE AT EVERTON
Tottenham and Edmonton Weekly Herald - Wednesday 10 February 1904
BRILLIANT VICTORY OF THE ‘SPURS
CONSTERNATION AT GOODISON PARK.
Herald Special Report
The great battle which in consequence of the Spurs recent successes had aroused such tremendous interest both in London and Liverpool, has at length been decided, and once more the Tottenham men have upset all calculations, this time achieving a success more brilliant than any other in the round of matches played last Saturday. Surprising as this defeat of Everton on their own ground will doubtless appear to the vast majority, there were a few who with a closer knowledge of the Spurs' capabilities and of their fitness for last Saturday's encounter, were not unprepared for the result. But in Liverpool, on the morning of the eventful day, the expected defeat of the Southerners appeared to be almost the sole topic. Every newspaper, after readily admitting the greatness of some of the past deeds of the Tottenham men, foreshadowed an easy victory for Everton on this occasion. In fact, both papers and public regarded the matter as one which left no room for speculation, except as regards the number of goals to be piled up against, the unfortunate Londoners. Tottenham Hotspur were, indeed, looked upon as a sort of extinct volcano—a kind of spent force which, having seen better days, was entitled to the sympathy of all good sportsmen in the hour of " honourable defeat." In view of this universal and overweening optimism, it will be readily understood with what feelings of dismay the great crowd which had assembled to participate in a sort of walk-over, saw their team fairly and squarely beaten by the superior play of the despised Hotspur. Such extraordinary confidence could not have long survived the opening of hostilities, for the Northern crowds, besides being good sportsmen, are also excellent critics, and ten minutes' play must have convinced both the Everton team and its follower' that the business in hand was "no pinch." But we will leave the Everton people to their bewilderment and proceed to explain to our readers
HOW IT ALL HAPPENED.
At noon—three hours before the time of starting—the weather conditions underwent a change for the worse. There had been the promise of a fine day, but at the hour named an uncomfortable drizzle set in, which continued until after the game commenced. This, no doubt, had an unfavourable effect on the "gate," which scarcely came up to expectations. At the last moment it was found Lord Stanley and his party of distinguished guests had to forego their intention of being present; but the proceedings were honoured by the presence of the Lord Mayor and Lady Mayoress of Liverpool. Without rain the ground would have been on the soft side, but the steady downpour made the going very heavy. Those who knew the Spurs, and their methods will not need telling that this state of things in no way militated against their chances of victory.
Booth beat Jones in the spin of the coin, and sharp to time. Woodward kicked off against the disadvantages of wind and rain. Two fouls against the visitor , at once led up to an anxious moment, for from the second free kick Booth skimmed the Tottenham cross-bar, with a very fine shot. The Spurs now settled down to their usual game, and both wing, put in some excellent work. Balmer on one occasion being only just in time against an effort of Warner's. It must have been an eye-opener to the locals to see the Spurs cutting the pace and doing most of the pressing. For some time play was limited to the home half until at length .J. Jones kicked behind. Then from a foul against the same player, Abbott also shot wide of the mark. Responding to the anxious appeals of their supporters, who were evidently dissatisfied with the prospect. Everton made desperate efforts, but over-anxiety caused both Settle and Corrin to get off-side. A sharp burst on the right was very neatly frustrated by Tait, and the visitors then benefited by a foul against Corrin. By this time the battle was fast and furious, each side striving to the utmost to gain an advantage over the other. An exceedingly clever run by Kirwan and Copeland looked very dangerous to Everton;  but, fortunately for them, the Irishman slipped and fell just as he was preparing to test Kitchin. A determined tussle between Sharp and Tait, in which Sandy prevailed, caused great excitement, which was increased a moment later when Taylor, in a good position, miskicked. The efforts of the home forwards appeared to lack combination, but individual attempts at times caused trouble. At length Sharp forced a corner from which Kirwan raced away, and tried Kitchin with a long shot, which was easily cleared. A stoppage was now signalled to enable Morris to recover from an injury, which happily was not serious, for the Lincolnshire man was playing a splendid game. On resuming Corrin executed a capital run on the left, and swung across a grand centre, which both Tait and Sharp just missed. McDermott soon after found a grand opening, but his shot went yards wide of the mark. A foul against Abbott now led to a beautiful run by Woodward, whore final pass went out to the left, but Kirwan just failed to reach it. Some illegal attention to Woodward followed, and from the free kick Morris and Warner very nearly brought off a coup. Tait deftly beat Sharp by putting out, but the throw in prepared the way for a spirited attack, and Williams, in dealing with a fast grounder was fain to concede a corner. Booth then forced another, which was more easily cleared. Balmer and Wolstenholme were next in difficulties with the Tottenham left. Copeland, from 25 yards, put in a terrific shot, which Kitchen with difficulty cleared. So far this was a long way the best effort of either side in the direction of scoring. A foul throw against Everton soon set the Spurs going again, and from a scrimmage in front of goal, Kitchin ticked away very luckily. Up to this point the Spurs had proved themselves at least equal to the First Leaguer's in defence, and somewhat more methodical in attack. Try as they might, Everton could not repel the sager onslaught of the Londoner, and when at last success  rewarded the visitors, there was infinitely more room for disappointment than for surprise. The movement which led to Kitchin's defeat originated with Morris, from whose pass Jones and Warner cleverly beat Abbott and Crelly. Woodward opportunely joined in the fun, and Kitchin gave a corner. The flag kick was entrusted to Warner, who on recent showing, can have few equals in the art of corner kicking. Taking his time and Judging wind and distance with perfect accuracy, the Nottingham man landed the ball plump on to Woodward's head. The amateur simply nodded his approval, and the ball was in the net. This interesting event happened after 25 minutes' play. The feat was of course bitterly disappointing to the crowd, but to their credit it should be said they generously applauded the performance. This reverse roused the Everton men to more vigorous methods; but force proved no match for science. In fact, a bad foul against Settle proved a very expensive luxury, for J. Jones, getting possession some 20 yards out, let fly with one of his well-known expresses, which Balmer attempted to clear, but the ball glanced off his knee and flew into the net, leaving Kitchin no sort of a chance to save. And thus in half an hour
TOTTENHAM LED BY TWO GOALS.
From now until the interval the home team made the most desperate efforts, but they were confronted by an equally resolute defence. Exciting incidents followed in startling rapidity, the spectators meanwhile exhibiting signs of the utmost impatience. Here are a few samples the transaction of which occupied less time than it takes to tell:
Foul against Watson,
Sharp forces a corner,
Settle fouls Williams.
Hands against Morris,
Corner off Morris
Balmer puts behind.
In their attempts to beat Williams the home team took to shooting from anywhere and everywhere, whilst fouls and off-side were of frequent occurrence, but although close on half-time Settle shot just over, the interval arrived with the scores:
Tottenham Hotspur, 2; Everton 0
Although Everton had not experienced much luck in the play, they must be considered particularly fortunate in winning the toss, for, after a temporary lull, the wind suddenly freshened and by changing its direction, gave an advantage to the home team, who thus benefited by the climatic conditions in both halves of the game. This piece of good fortune was of exceptional value in the closing stages of a hard-fought contest.
There was no appreciable falling off in the pace when the teams resumed. Everton were first away, but Hughes made short work of Corrin, and a goal kick resulted. A similar fate betel a long shot from Settle, whom Hughes seldom allowed to practise at short range.  The Everton centre next fouled Woodward, who retaliated by running well forward and threatening danger until he was somewhat unfairly interfered with, his shot in consequence going wide. Kirwan on the left, made a promising movement, but in the end he was given off-side. A foul throw against J. L. Jones sent Wolstenholme and Settle to the front, the centre forward testing Willams with a very dangerous grounder which was cleared in masterly fashion. Immediately afterwards, Settle obtained possession from a corner kick, and Williams again distinguished himself by brilliantly saving, although the ball could not be effectively cleared. The succeeding shot looked like taking effect; but Hughes headed away in brilliant style. The home team were now pressing heavily, and it began to appear as though the two goals' lead would be none too much. A hot scrimmage in front of Williams might easily have resulted in a score for Everton, but Sharpe unaccountably kicked clean over the ball, which Williams gladly picked up and threw away, the crowd meanwhile expressing their disgust in unmistakable terms. Relief at length came when Balmer fouled Hughes, Woodward, from the free kick, making a lot of ground and passing to Jones. But "Bristol" was charged off before he could trouble Kitchin. Everton were soon back again, and the Spurs' defence was sorely tried; but Watson, Tait, and Williams, with the frequent assistance of the halves in one way or another, managed to keep the invaders at bay. It was only occasionally the Spurs could break away, but as frequently happens, these sudden breaks were full of danger. On two occasions, Woodward, by the most brilliant individual work, came to close quarters with Kitchin. Once he was somewhat unfairly interfered with and his shot went wide, but a succeeding effort completely beat the custodian, and grazed the wrong side of the post. Further pressure by the blues saw Taylor head just over the bar, and then McDermott and Settle were both guilty of fouls. Sharp next improved the home teams chances by forcing a corner, which led up to an attack that worked up the crowd to a perfect fever of excitement. The besieging forces- halves as well as forwards—for some time swarmed round Williams. Shot after shot was repelled until the climax was reached when Booth crashed the ball against the upright, from which it flew across to Corrin, who shot just wide of the other post. Williams immediately after was called upon to clear a difficult shot, and then by wat of diversion, Kirwan and Copeland raced away to the other end, only to put behind. In a trice the ball was kick, but fortune again favoured the Spurs, for McDermott, who beat Williams, was given off-side -a decision which although obviously correct, sent the crowd frantic with disappointment. There now seemed little else for the visitors to do beyond maintaining a stubborn defence. Further scoring on their part seemed out of the question. In fact, it became apparent that the Spurs had resigned themselves to the policy of WHAT WE HAVE WE’LL HOLD.
Their goal was consequently packed and little opportunity was afforded the invaders for deliberate shooting. Still, Williams was now and again called upon to show his ability. So successful were the Hotspurs tactics that it appeared exceedingly probable there would be no more scoring, but when only three minutes remained for play, Watson in a desperate attempt to clear a fast cross shot from Corrin, had the mortification of kicking through his own goal. Frantic cries were now raised for the equaliser, but the Londoners were not to be caught napping again. It is very rarely we see the Spurs adopting kicking out tactics, but now, for the first time that remained this policy for once commended itself and was successfully adopted. J. Jones finishing matters with a lunge which caused some alarm to the occupants of the grand stand. Thus, after a keen a battle as one need wish to see and an especially exciting second half, the Spurs, as we hoped, still further added to their reputation as cup fighters, and so qualified for the next round.
It will, we think, be admitted on all sides, that the visitors were the better team, and that they fully deserved a victory, which must rank as one of the greatest feats ever accomplished by Tottenham Hotspur.
For the winners, Williams gave a magnificent exhibition and frequently earned the applause of the crowd. The goalkeeper was grandly covered by Watson and Tait, the latter of whom was easily the best back on the field, while Watson apart from his one mistake, was a good second. We had heard so much of Wolstenholme, Booth and Abbott, who are said to form England’s best half back line, that we were anxious to see how Morris, Hughes, and Jones would compare with these stars.
Let it be said at once then that, good as the Everton middle line undoubtedly is, it showed no superiority over that of the Spurs. Morris was responsible for a lot of clever and effective work, and was at least as good as any of Everton’s halves. Hughes played his characteristic forcible and untiring game, and had much to do with Everton’s lack of combination. J.L. Jones, as is his wont, adopted quieter and more methodical tactics in which skill and resource were instantly noticeable. We consider the Hotspur defence was to some extent better than Everton’s and that the Tottenham halves were on a pair with these opposed to them. But, as regards the forwards, especially when judged as a line, we are convinced the Spurs held a big advantage. Woodward proved himself a better general than Settle, who is the amateur rival for International honours. The Everton man wandered too much, and consequently his wings had fewer opportunities than those of Tottenham, which were kept much better together by their centre-forward. The work of the amateur was characterised by rare dash and determination and no doubt this was Woodward best show of the present season. Kirwan and Copeland on many occasions astonished the natives by the ease with which they tricked the opposing defence. Both as individuals and as a wing. These two completely outshone Corrin and McDermott. Warner and Jones were always ready to make the most of good feeding, but the inside man had more opportunities, and was consequently more frequently prominent. His shot which scored Tottenham’s second goal will not soon be forgotten by frequenters of Goodison Park.
Possibly this further victory in the County Palatine will serve to convince Lancashire folk that Tottenham Hotspur in an English Cup tie is a dangerous team to run up against. Victories against Preston, Bury, Newton Heath, and Everton-three of them on Lancashire soil- figure among Tottenham’s cup records, whilst to the contrary stands the one goal defeat at Preston.
Teams;-
Everton- Kitchen; Balmer, Crelly; Wolstenholme, Booth, Abbott; Sharp, Taylor, Settle, McDermott, and Corrin.
Spurs;.- Williams; Watson, Tait; Morris, Hughes, Jones (J.L); Warner, Jones (J), V.J. Woodward, Copeland, and Kirwan.
Referee.- Mr. H. Ward, Nottingham. Linesmen. Messrs Grey and Shelton.
THE HOME COMING
The Spurs received a very cordial, not to say boisterous, welcome on their arrival in London on Saturday night. Several hundreds of people had assembled at Euston, and the players were cheered and chaired, and made as much of as it was possible for them to be, the great enthusiasm prevailing. There was no need of light porters.
SPURS’ NOTES
These will appear as usual in Friday’s paper. We shall also publish the opinions of Liverpool and other critics on last Saturday’s performance at Goodison Park.

BURY v  EVERTON
Liverpool Daily Post - Friday 12 February 1904
There is only one change in the Everton side for to-morrow at Bury, Hardman taking the place of Corrin. The match should provide excellent sport.

EVERTON'S INGLORIOUS UNCERTAINTY.
Lancashire Evening Post - Saturday 13 February 1904
Once again Everton have proved themselves conspicuously uncertain side. After a really fine run they went down completely at Middlesbrough a fortnight since. There was a disposition to regard this as a fluke, but when it was followed by defeat Goodison Park in the Cup there was feeling akin to disgust in the camp. It had seemed as if the club had a rare chance of earning distinction in the ties. With no possibility of falling low in the League table, and with no outstanding chance of the championship, the time was in every sense opportune for a great effort to secure the national trophy. However, the occasion found the players unequal to the demands upon them. Tom Booth tried in splendid fashion to rally his men to their best form, but even Wolstenholme and Abbott, his immediate colleagues, were found wanting; and the defeat was deserved. And now, I suppose, the Evertonians will affect to console themselves with the fact that they will be able to give undividual attention to their efforts after the League championship. Likely enough they will startle us now and again with brilliant victorties, for, in form, they a fine side; but they are so erratic that i have not the elast faith in them developing a sufficiently consistent vein to get to the top and keep there.

EVERTON RESERVES 3 BURY RESERVES 2
February 13, 1904. The Liverpool Football Echo
Lancashire Combination “A” Division
Bury were the visitors at Goodison Park this afternoon when there was a good attendance despite the atmospheric conditions. The following were the teams: - Everton: - Dent goal, Gordon, and R Balmer, backs, Clayton, Russell, and Makepeace, half-backs, Rankin, Sheridan, Meredith, O'Hagan, and Simpson forwards. Bury: - Monteith goal Hedson, and Gregory, backs, Mills, Brown, and Butterworthy, half-backs, White, Lamberton, Green, Houghton, and Bull, forwards. Green opened the game on behalf of the visitors, and even play characterised the initial stages. Everton assumed the aggressive and Monteith was called upon to save a good shot from Sheridan. In the next few minutes the visitors goal had a narrow escape. One of the Bury defenders almost putting the leather though his own goal. A couple of unproductive corners fell to Everton. The slippery state of the ground hampered the players more so Bury, and Everton being able to keep more on the best progress. Gordon tested Montieth with a good shot, after which Meredith opened the home score. A smart run up the field by the Bury men was without result, and Everton again swarmed round the visitor's defence, Meredith putting on a second goal. Again they got down but were never dangerous, and the Blues were soon attacking again. Simpson and O'Hagan were conspicuous on the left wing. After Sheridan had caused the visitors custodian to clear a swift shot. Everton were awarded a penalty kick. This was entrusted to Makepeace, who made no mistake, and put the leather into the net, thus notching Everton third point. Everton at the interval leading by three goals to nil. Final Result Everton 3 Bury 2

TEAMS ARRNAGEMENTS FOR THIS DAY
Liverpool Daily Post - Saturday 13 February 1904
Everton v Bury
League match at Bury; Exchange Sation 1.10; Kick-off 3.15 p.m.
Everton.- Kitchen, goal; Balmer and Crelly, backs; Wolstenholme, Booth and Abbott, half-backs; Sharp, Taylor, Settle, McDermott, and H.P. Hardman, forwards.
Reserves; Dilly and Rankin.
Everton Combination v Bury Reserve
At Goodison Park; kick-off 3.30
Everton.- Whitley, goal; Gordon and R. Balmer, backs; Clayton, Russell, and Makepeace, half-backs; Rankin, Sheridan, McAdam, O’Hagan, and Simpson, forwards.

OUTDOORS SPORTS
Liverpool Mercury - Saturday 13 February 1904
Everton, whose doings can now only raise a flicker of interest, are due at Bury, and, as it matters little whether they win or lose, the probability is that they will be seen at their best. They will play- with one exception-the same eleven that was beaten by Tottenham, this being the substitution of Hardman for Corrin. The Cupholders seem to be approaching their best form, now that the Cup ties have commenced, and they are sure to fully extend their visitors. Everton won the first match this season by two clear goals; but they have seldom shown to advantage at Gigg-lane. Considering the fact that everything points to their defeat, it is more than likely that the visitors will secure at least one point, for Bury, who are now safe, as far as retaining their place in the premier League is concerned, may be content to confine their energies towards the retention of the Association trophy, which they so cleverly won twelve months ago.
Bury v Everton Referee J. Adams, E. Whitehead and G.H. Hallows.
Bury.- Montgomery, goal, Lindsay, McEwan, backs; Johnston, Thorpe, and Ross, half-backs; Richards, Wood, Swann, Sagar, and Plant, forwards.
Everton.- Kitchen, goal; Balmer and Crelly, backs; Wolstenholme, Booth and Abbott, half-backs; Sharp, Taylor, Settle, McDermott, and H.P. Hardman, forwards.
Reserves; Dilly and Rankin.
Train leaves Exchange Station 1.10 p.m. Kick-off 3.15 p.m.
Everton Reserve v Bury Reserve, Goodison Park
Everton.- Whitley, goal; Gordon and R. Balmer, backs; Clayton, Russell, and Makepeace, half-backs; Rankin, Sheridan, McAdam, O’Hagan, and Simpson, forwards.
Kick-off 3.30.

EVERTON v  BURY
Liverpool Football Echo - Saturday 13 February 1904
LEAGUE DIVISION ONE
NEITEHR SIDE FIND THE NET BEFORE HALF-TIME
After the excitement of the Cup ties, last week, League engagements claimed attention to-day. Everton were due at Bury, and the team left Exchange Station at noon for the busy cotton town. The weather turned out wretchedly bad, a fair morning being succeeded by a cheerless afternoon. The wind was boisterous, and the rain fell heavy, but, in spite of these depressing surrounding, a capital crowd put in an appearance at the Gigg-lane enclosure. The Evertonians made one alteration from last week, Hardman coming in for Corrin. In persistent downpour the teams lined out as follows;-
Everton.- Kitchen, goal; Balmer and Crelly, backs; Wolstenholme, Booth (captain) and Abbott, half-backs; Sharp, Taylor, Settle, McDermott, and Hardman, forwards.
Bury.- Montgomery, goal; Lindsay and McEwan, backs; Johnston, Thorpe, and G. Ross, half-backs; Richards, Woods, Swann, Sagar, and Plant, forwards.
Referee- J. Adams of Birmingham
Everton won the toss, and they took advantage of the wind and rain, with the result that the opening stages of the game were all in favour of the visitors, who, from the outset, attacked with great performance. The high wind made the proper management of the ball somewhat difficult, but the Evertonians on several occasions got dangerously near Montgomery’s charge. On one occasion Hardman ran down in fine fashion, and he centred well, but Settle just failed to meet the pass and a fine opening was lost.
Following upon this the home team made progress in face of the gale, and Swann, beating Balmer, sent in a stinging shot, which Kitchen saved very cleverly. The visitors took up the attack again in the most determined fashion, and all the front line tried their luck with shots but there was a lack of accuracy and after a time the home team once more took up the argument. Sagar and Plant moved down in promising style, and Balmer was again caught napping with the result that a corner was forced. This, fortunately for Everton came to nothing, and the next stages of the game were in favour of Everton, who moved off in businesslike fashion. Montgomery was subjected to several warm shots, but he behaved admirably, and he saved a terrific shot from Booth at the expense of a fruitless corner, Everton kept up the pressure for a considerable time and they were distinctly unfortunate in not scoring. The backs several times clearing their lines more by good luck then good management. At length McEwan put his forwards in possession, and the home left ran down brilliantly, with the result that two warm shots were put in to Kitchen who saved the situation in the most masterly way. So far the Evertonians had enjoyed by far the best of the game, but they were no doubt greatly aided by the wind. The Bury defence was thoroughly sound, and several attacks on the home citadel were dealt with very cleverly. Following upon this Richards and Wood took up the attack, and Crelly was well beaten when the outside man shot wide of the mark. The visitors returned with renewed vigour to the attack, and the forward line moved along in fine combination when Settle spoiled the whole thing by shooting rather wide from long range. Everton continued. A free kick was well utilized by the Bury forwards, but, though they tried hard, they were unable to make such impression on the Everton defence, which was very good. On one occasion, however, Plant worked for himself a good position, and he looked like scoring, but unfortunately for his side his shot from long range went the wrong side of the upright. So far Everton, with the wind behind them, had the better of the exchanges, but smart as was the attack there was a lack of unison in the work of the forwards. A spell of midfield work showed that the visitors were smarter on the ball than their opponents, and again they put the home goal in jeopardy. There was still, however, the same weakness in shooting, and several palpable chances were lost by McDermott, Settle, and Taylor. The Bury forwards again asserted themselves, and Plant looked almost certain of scoring when Balmer cleared the danger at the expense of a corner. This was safely negotiated, and for a time the battle was waged in midfield. The going was terribly heavy, and this, coupled with the almost Arctic weather, began to tell upon both teams. Nevertheless, the pace was kept up in a most exhilarating fashion, and a break-away on the part of the Everton left ended in Hardman forcing a corner. This was capitally placed, and from the ball Taylor shot over the bar. Bury then took up the running, and, in the teeth of the rain storm, they gave the Everton backs considerable trouble, Swann eventually shooting strongly right into Kitchen’s hands. As half-time approached the Evertonians, recognising that they ought to secure an advantage, if possible, while the wind was in their favour, put on a double spirit but Lindsay and McEwan were both keenly alert, and several times the invaders were beaten back. The Bury men then made ground on the right, and Richards sent in a low, swift shot, which Kitchen cleared very cleverly. Everton took the initiative once again, and a combined movement was only spoilt through Hardman missing the final pass. The amateur, however, did his best to make amends for a moment later he raced down the length of the field, and from a difficult position he gave Montgomery a very warm handful. The home custodian threw clear, and a moment later half-time arrived, neither side having scored. Final Result Bury Nil, Everton Nil.

A GOALLESS DRAW AT BURY.
Athletic News - Monday 15 February 1904
By The Shaker
Although on the general average since Bury became participants in First Division football, they have had rather the better of Everton in the matter of points, the teams stand exactly level on the question of goal scoring, viz., thirty each, the Evertonians have annexed three League points this season at the expense of the East Lancashire representatives. In lieu of the expected 10,000 to 12,000 onlookers, the treasury drew from only about 3,000, and officialdom may account themselves lucky to get that. The fact is that the management of the club require to take in hand at the earliest opportunity the question of covering the open stands. The sooner this matter is boldly faced the better for the finances of the club.
THE RUN OF THE GAME.
Everton were fortunate to have the wind at their backs at the start, and for the first ten minutes they were all over the Bury defence. It was at this stage that Montgomery came out of his shell with some classic work between the posts; it could not have been excelled, albeit at least two of his saves struck one as a trifle lucky. After this, although Everton had decidedly the balance of the exchanges to the interval. Bury were by no means idle, and some rousing attacks were engineered and almost pushed home. On resuming, Bury had just as much of the play as had fallen to Everton in the first half, but the “Shakers” had perhaps harder luck. Time and again the Everton goal appeared on the point of falling, and once when three Bury attackers and Kitchen met in close strife a few yards from the goal centre, it looked as if nothing could avert a downfall. The ball came out of the ruck, apparently from the foot of Swann, with terrific force, and the spectators cheered wildly, believing that penetration had been accomplished. But the disappointment was keen as the ball came back again, having evidently struck the crossbar and rebounded into play. An incident quite as exciting took place in the second half at the Bury end. Montgomery had cleared from Hardman and fisted away, when back the ball came plumb into the centre of the goal. Montgomery secured, and running out with the ball his hands was about to kick away when Settle kicked the ball from his grasp, and Booth pouncing thereon, lifted into the goal. The spectators scarcely breathed as the ball dropped into an apparently defenseless goal. At the critical moment, however, McEwan sprang into the breach, looked about to fist out, but evidently finding the ball reachable with his head, applied his cranium to the leather, which bounded out of harm’s way, materially assisted thereto a timely application of the Bury captain’s toe. It was thrilling moment, and the crowd cheered as if a goal had been scored.
GOALKEEPING PAR EXCELLENCE
There could be no two opinions about the fact that the principal feature of the game was the magnificent goalkeeping. Montgomery has never done himself more credit, and thoroughly deserved the ovation accorded him when he left for the breathing space. Nor was Kitchen any behind his vis-a-vis. He had one advantage that stood him in good stead, and but for which there would probably have been a couple of goals scored—his long reach.  He was lucky, too, in many of the most crashing shots from the Bury forwards going straight at him; so that taken altogether he had to display less resource than his contemporary. But he stopped some great shots, and he, too, is entitled to the honours his side.
FINE INDIVIDUAL EFFORTS.
James Settle still holds a warm corner in the affections of the Bury football followers. This fact was evidenced by the cheers which greeted his brilliant opening play, when in the first ten minutes he dodged and twisted and dribbled and shot and passed like genius, and well done, Settle! rang round the ground. But Settle afterwards marred the impression thus made and the conjuring up of old associations by his doubtful tactics, which were frequently penalized. Swann, although not greatly in evidence in the second half, when Booth had his measure fairly well estimated, nevertheless got in two pretty runs in the first stage. The initial one was finished with a terrific shot which Kitchen did well stick to; in the second case Swann was tripped by Balmer as he was finally passing him, but recovering he again had a clear, course for goal, and was showing a clean pair of heels, and had covered perhaps 20 yards when Referee Adams pulled him up by giving a free kick for the foul. This was a most unlucky penalizing of an unoffending side. Sagar did many excellent things, one of the best of which was when he turned on his heel and slashed at the goal in a twinkling, and but for Kitchen’s smartness must have scored.
POINTS ABOUT THE PLAYERS
As I have already stated, the goalkeepers were the heroes of the game. Lindsay was in his element fighting against the unusually bad conditions and a dashing wing, while McEwan is to be congratulated on the coolness he displayed, particularly when he cleared during Montgomery’s absence. Many defenders would have lost their heads under the circumstances and have fisted out, chancing the results of a penalty kick. Thorps and Johnston ran a neck-and-neck race for premier honours in the half-back line, but George Ross was the best marksman of the trio, and thrice had hard luck in not getting through. Forward, Sagar and Richards were the best of a hard-working and strongly-aggressive trio, not one of whom displayed any signs of weakness. Settle opened best among the Evertonians, but afterwards fell away. Hardman was very smart on the wing, his speedy dashes and admirable centres being always dangerous. Sharp was a marked man, and was not nearly so much in evidence expected. Booth is a grand centre-half, playing the game like a gentleman, and playing it effectively, too. At back Balmer and Crelley were safe as rocks, though the latter developed an extraordinary fondness for kicking into touch when he had the wind at his back. Taken altogether, Bury may be said to have had the worst of the luck; on the play they just deserved to get home. Bury: - Montgomery; Lindsay, and McEwan; Johnston, Thorpe, and G. Ross; Richards, Wood, Swann, Sagar, and Plant.  Everton; Kitchen; Balmer, and Crelley; Wolstenholme, Booth, and Abbott; Sharp, Taylor, Settle, McDermott, and Hardman.  Referee; Mr. J. Adams, Birmingham. 

BURY V. EVERTON
London Daily News - Monday 15 February 1904
At Bury, resulting in a goalless draw. Wretched weather prevailed, and the attendance suffered. In the first half Kitchen saved brilliantly from Swann, Sagar, and Richards, while for Bury Montogmery effected several smart clearances. Everton did most of the pressing, and towards the interval secured a corner, which was got away with difficulty. After the change of ends Bury, with the wind in their favour, atatcked, Sagar and Richards hitting the crossbar, and Plant the upright, but they were unable to get through.

BURY 0 EVERTON 0
February 15, 1904. The Liverpool Courier
After their disappointing display against Tottenham Hotspur, Everton resumed their League programme on Saturday with a match against Bury on the latter's ground. The weather was stormy, and heavy rain fell. Everton made only one change, Hardman taking the place of Corrin. The teams were Everton: - Kitchen, goal, W.Balmer and Crelly, backs, Wolstenholme, Booth (captain), and Abbott, half-backs, Sharp, Taylor, Settle, McDermott, and Hardman, forwards. Bury: - Montgomery, goal, Lindsay, and McEwan, backs Johnston Thorp, and G.Ross (captain) half-backs, Richards Wood, Swann, Sagar, and Plant forwards. Referee J.Adams. Everton won the toss, and had the assistance of a strong breeze with the rain behind it. They were the first to attack, and for some few minutes monopolised the bulk of the play. The home defenders were, however, in stubborn mood, and met the attack of the visitors with confidence. The Bury left got away, and a fine centre by Plant was ably dealt with by Kitchen. The attack of the home side was but of a temporary character and the play was quickly at the other end, where Hardman put in a very clever cross shot, which Sharp only just failed to convert. Despite the depressing conditions the play was thoroughly interesting, and just now was fairly well divided. One movement, in which the home forwards were prominent, ended in Swann shooting straight at Kitchen, and within a minute Montgomery just managed to get away a smart shot from Hardman. Booth with a couple of fine touches, again played his men in fine position, and after a smart run down Taylor was fortunately ruled offside after fine work by McDermott. The bulk of the play ruled in favour of the visitors, but they could not get in an effective shot owing to the close attentions of the home rearguard. At length the Bury forwards got away in one of their characteristic movements, and after some capital play in which the whole line took part. Kitchen put in a magnificent effort, only to find Montgomery in readiness. Scarcely had the shot been repelled than Plant tried the Everton keeper with a shot of the first water. Kitchen was at his best, and cleared in confident fashion, and within a couple of minutes Montgomery was in difficulties, Sharp was particularly prominent in the Everton attacks, but, as on the previous occasions McEwan allowed but little latitude. Most of the play was monopolised by the visitors, but they were opposed to a steady defence, and scoring was indeed a difficult matter. One centre, however, from Hardman sent a begging and a little later on Settle had hard lines in not getting through. The home centre then got going, and looked like getting through, and then Booth pulled him up unfairly, but the infringement resulted in Everton's favour. So far it had not been too much to expect that the visitors would have secured a tangible lead, with the powerful wind behind them and that the Bury defenders held out so ably gave distinct encouragement to their supporters. Long and wild passing was now the order, and the swinging passes to the wings gave repeated trouble to the respective defenders. At length Richards got the ball and sent in a low swift shot to Kitchen, who cleared well. Within a minute Hardman missed a clever chance of opening the scoring, but on the interval Hardman ran down in splendid fashion, and put in a clever shot from a difficult angle. Indeed this effort was by far the best that had been forthcoming during the first half of the game. Half-time Bury nil; Everton nil. Shortly after the resumption Ross was winded, play being stopped for a couple of minutes. The next moment Richards was charged in the back by Abbott, and from the Free kick Bury went down with a rush, and Ross gave Kitchen a hot ground shot to deal with. Sharp and Taylor went away, the former centreing well, and Lindsay in clearing conceded a corner. Sagar ran round Balmer, and dropped a shot just on to the net. Bury were now showing very little judgement. This gave Everton an advantage, which they were not slow to turn in good account, Settle broke away nicely, and swinging out to Hardman, that player lifted over the crossbar. Although Everton had the wing against them, they had almost as much of the game as the home side. Play was well contested, considering the conditions. Towards the end Bury pressed, and Richards struck the crossbar. Try as they would neither side could score, Result; Bury nil, Everton nil.

EVERTON REVIEW
February 15, 1904. The Liverpool Mercury
The Everton team accomplished a creditable performance in visiting Bury and dividing the honours of the game. Though they were a trifle lucky, no one could really begrudge them the point, which they gained. The game was contested under the most unfavourable climatic conditions, for a gale blowing and rain descending in pitiless severily, and the spectators spent in uncomfortable hour, and a half, while the players had to contend with difficulties which rendered accurate football quite out of the question. In fact, such were the conditions that a little luck either way might have made all the difference between victory, and defeat. Everton had the good fortune to win the toss, and this meant not a little advantage to them, for they had the fierce wind behind them, and the driving rain was full in the face of the Bury side. As was not unnatural, the visiting team practically monopolised the attack during the first half. Time after time it looked as if the Bury goal would be captured, but the Everton forwards had to contend with not only a strong half back line, but a couple of determined backs, in Lindsay, and McEwan, and above all, a keeper in Montgomery, who displayed all his old judgement and ability. Bury must certainly be complimented upon their success in shaving off disaster, and although so severely handicapped by the weather, on more than one occasion their forwards troubled the Everton defence. In one instance a sudden breakaway might easily have led to the capture of the Everton goal, but Swann, after getting the better of Balmer, shot straight at Kitchen who had no difficulty in clearing the ball. Having to contend against such a strong wind naturally took a great deal, out of the Bury players, and it was rather unfortunate for them that during the second moiety the breeze abated somewhat, and the rain ceased. Still they gave a plucky exhibition, and only very fine defence on the part of Balmer, and Crelly, supplemented in splendid style, by Kitchen prevented them opening the score. Twice the Everton goal had particularly narrow escapes, both Sagar and Richards banging the ball at terrific speed against the crossbar under circumstances which, had the the aim been slightly more accurate, Kitchen would have had little chance of saving. Considering the state, of the ground the game throughout produced many highly creditable bits of play. The ball was rendered very heavy, and, with the going most slippery, it was not surprising the mistake on the part, particularly of the forwards were frequent. Both sides are to be commended for admirable defensive tactics, and it would not be easy to single out any particular member seeing that a perfect understanding prevailed amongst the respective defenders. In the forward line Bury were probably slightly better as regards effective combination. Hardman was conspicuous at times for trickiness in getting possession of the ball, but somehow or another more than one of his clever centres went astray. At the other end of the line Sharp was by no means as successful as usual, and it was rather astonishing to find him so frequently beaten even in the matter of speed by McEwan. Settle threw his heart and soul into the game against his old club, and did many smart things, but his marksmanship was not by any means of a high standard. Undoutledly Kitchen was chiefly responsible for Everton's partial success. He was always alert, and on one occasion, when a couple of shots were driven in from short range, he used with the utmost effect first his right hand and then his left. Throughout he kept a splendid goal, quite up to his best reputation.

SATURDAY’S FOOTBALL
Liverpool Daily Post - Monday 15 February 1904
Everton are to be congratulated upon securing a point at Bury on Saturday, this making three out of a possible four in the two fixtures. The weather was wretched in the extreme, persistent rain and a high wind rendering the surrounding exceedingly uncomfortable. The ground was heavy with mud, and this had the effect of retarding the pace somewhat. Nevertheless the game was an exciting one from start to finish. Both teams were evenly matched, and, though the visitors had rather the best of the luck, they were fully entitled to the division of honours. The main feature of the contest was the excellent defensive work of both teams. Montgomery kept out several stringing shots, and towards the close of the game Kitchen behaved with wonderful cleverness in the Everton goal. Indeed, had it not been for his agility, the Bury men would certainly have snatched a victory at the last moment. The Everton forward line, all things considered behaved capitally. Settle keeping his wings together with more than customary tact. The outside men, however, were as already indicated hampered by the state of the turf, and several fine openings were missed in consequence. The half backs had quite recovered their best form, and Booth put in some valuable work. Both Balmer and Crelly were reliable and confident, and Kitchen’s performance was highly creditable to that popular custodian. Altogether the team appeared to full advantage, and it would seem as though they had quite recovered from the temporary lapse, which led to their dismissal from the English Cup last week.
The Bury team also showed improved form. Their forwards possessed both speed and cleverness. The half back line is well balanced, while the full abcks gave a thoroughly meritorious display.

BURY v. EVERTON.
The Sportsman - Monday 15 February 1904
Played at Bury on Saturday, in stormy weather, before 5,000 people. Bury faced the elements at the outset, and Everton at once attacked, Montgomery saving several times, but a fine drive by McDermott almost found the net, the custodian throwing himself down to save. Bury broke away, and, getting past the defence, Swann raced on, but his shot was straight at Kitchen. Everton had the greater share of the play, but Bury were often dangerous. Settle and Hardman were conspicuous, but the final efforts often faulty, and half-time arrived without either side having scored.
Resuming, play was more even, but Bury took up the running and Kitchen twice saved from Swann and Richards, whilst at the other end Sharp gave a fine centre which was lost. The home team were now attacking strongly, but Kitchen saved from every side, whilst Swann hit the bar. From the breakaway the home goal escaped miraculously, McEwan heading away from under the bar. Bury pressed to the close, but time was called and the game ended in a pointless draw. Sides;-
Bury; Montgomery (goal), Lindsay and McEwan (backs), Johnston, Thorp, and G. Ross (half-backs), Richards, Wood, Swann, Sagar, and Plant (forwards).
Everton; Kitchen (goal), Balmer and Crelly (backs), Wolstenholme, Booth (captain) and Abbott (half-backs), Sharp, Taylor, Settle, McDermott, and Hardman (forwards).
Referee; Mr. J. Adams (Birmingham).

EVERTON RESERVE JUST WIN.
Athletic News - Monday 15 February 1904
Whilst their seniors were sharing the points at Gigg-lane, the Everton second string were accounting for the reserve team of the Cup-holders. In the first half, the crowd—which for such a day of unusual proportions-were treated to a fine display by the home players, and after Meredith had scored twice, Makepeace put on a third  put third from a penalty. In the second portion, the Everton players appeared inclined to take matters easy, and Houghton and Lamberton reduced the lead with capital shots. Everton then retaliated finely, but the grand goalkeeping of Monteilh averted further disaster, and the result was a victory for the leaders by 3 goals to 2. The new centre forward—Meredith-shaped very well, for a first appearance, and had the ferocity of scoring a couple of smart goals. O'Hagan ana Rankin also rendered good service, and in the closing stages the home forwards gave Monteith a rare time, after being somewhat somewhat somnolent  from the interval. For Bury, Monteilh, Ball, and Houghton were seen to advantage, but the full backs were only moderate, and were easily beaten. Everton have yet to meet with defeat in this competition, and their fixture with Accrington Stanley next week should produce a grand struggle.

NEWCASTLE UNITED V. EVERTON.
Sunderland Daily Echo and Shipping Gazette - Saturday 20 February 1904
This afternoon these teams played a friendly fixture at Newcastle. The United had not their best team out, several of the regular players being given a rest. They also gave trial to new centre forward named Mackey. In the League tournament the " Toffees " have invariably occupied a respectable position. They won the Cup in 1890-1, were runners-up Preston North End in 1889-90. and Sunderland the seasons 1891-5 and 1901-2, besides twice finishing the third rung of the ladder. Of the twelve League games played between Newcastle and Everton, the Tynesiders have won 6, drawn 3, and lost 3. This season the clubs occupy fifth and seventh positions the League table respectively. The kick-off was fixed for three o'clock, and the teams were as follow.— Newcastle United: Goal, Watts; backs. and half-backs. Gardner, McWilliam, and Carr; forwards, Rutherford, Howie, Mackey, Orr. and Roberts. Everton: Goal. Kitchen; backs, and Crelly; half-backs, Wolstenholme, Booth, and Abbot; forwards. Sharp, McDermott, Young. Settle, and Hardman. Referee, Mr R. Paxton, Sunderland.

ACCRINGTON STANLEY RESERVE V EVERTON RESERVE
Lancashire Evening Post - Saturday 20 February 1904
Six Thousand Spectators See Everton Reserve go Down
The ground was in a fearful state when Everton Reserve, the only unbeaten eleven in the Combination met last season's champions for the first time. An effort had been made to scrape away the puddle in midfield but without much success. There was a splendid attedance, quite 6,000 being round the ropes at the kick-off. Both teams came the same as chosen and they turned out in the following order;- Accrington Stanley;- McGregor, goal; Finney and Hampson, backs; Chorlton, Bradshaw, and Harrison, half-backs; Hesham, Hargreaves, Brunton, Becton, ad Garside, forwards. Everton Reserve; Whitley, goal; Gordon and Balmer, backs; Clayton, Russell and Makepeace, half-backs; Rankin, Sheridan, Dilly, O'Hagan and Simpson, forwards. Referee; Mr. Kenny, Preston. Everton won the toss, and had the advanatge of the slop. The visitors at once became aggressive, and after Finney had only partially saved, Chorlton forced Simpson to kick outside. A sprint up the left followed by Garside, but the Toffee men were soon down again. Their stay, however was somewhat brief, but they soon showed their sp[eed. After Balmer had taken the ball right from Brunton's toes, Bradshaw caught the spehere on the return, and scored a lovely goal 10 minutes from the start amid a chorus of cheers. Simpson then had extreme hard lines, with a beauty which sailed over the bar. Everton bore down into the Stanley half, and Sheridan forced McGregor to concede a corner. The game was very fast considering the state of the ground. A magnificent effort was next made by the Stanley forward. Hesham and Brunton worked the ball up and exchanged places. Whitley being only just in time to save a header from Hesham. The outside right again shot across the goalmouth, while Brunton made a plucky attempt to screw in. A very prounounced appeal for a corner was disregarded by Mr. Kenny, and the game continued more to the liking of the homesters. A neat centre by Hesham was headed over by Brunton. Dilly then broke away but Finney securing passed to the custodan, who cleared. Rain was now coming down in a heavy mist, which reduced the pace of the game, Everton came top close quarters and the Stanley goal had a narrow escape from a dtermined atatck by Simpson and O'Hagan. A couple of free kicks against Everton helped Stanley again get well up the field, a goal kick by Harrison being splendidly fisted out by Whitley. The ball was then screwed across to Hesha, who centredd from almost on the line. Both Brunton and Becton were quite ready but the former failed to hit it, so Becton banged in into the net. Stanley were now simply waltzing round their opponents. From a breakaway the ball struck in the mud just in front of the goal. Hesham missed the kick, but Brunton promptly shot past whitley and added the third goal to the intense pleasure of the homesters. A couple of minutes later a fourth goal was earned by Stanley though Everton appealed against it on the ground that Becton who placed into the corner of the net, was offside. The game continued in favour of Stanley.
Half-time Accrington Stanley 4, Everton Reserve 0.
The ground was now a terrible quagmire, and for some time both sides were busy mud-pugging in midfield. Everton tried the one-back game, and play for a time was fairly even. A corner was kicked out by Hampton, but the leather remained some minutes in the Stanley half. A heavy downpour spoiled the game. Garside was making tracks for the goal when he was charged and the ball went out of play. Stanley now kept their opponents well down the field, but two free kicks were given against Bradshaw for fouls. At one end Bradshaw shot right into Whitley's arms, and at the other McGregor caught a fine shot from Simpson and kciked away. Everton pressed for several minutes, Balmer testing McGregor with a long volley. The homesters had to fist away, and after another save by McGregor Garside gained possession and sprinted down the left. Clayton spoiled his efforts, but during the pressure Bradshaw again shot right at Whitley. Splendid passing was next shown by Hesham and Hargreaves and the latter gave Whitley another straight shot which was easily disposed of. Hesham followed up a pretty run with a neat centrte, but Whitley again saved. Ten minutes before time Simpson scored for Everton, and a few minutes later ba penalty for hands against one of the Everton backs was converted by Becton. Hesham scored just on time from a pass by Garside. Result; Stanley 6, Everton Res 1

ACCRINGTON STANLEY RESERVES 6 EVERTON RESERVES 1
February 20, 1904. The Liverpool Football Echo.
Lancashire Combination “A” Division (Game 20)
Great interest was taken in this contest at Accrington, between the Combination Champions and the undefeated Everton Reserves. There was 5,000 spectators. Despite the drizzling rain. The ground was in a fearful state. Both teams were at full strength, Simpson was soon given a chance, but he dallied too long, and Chorlton shouldered him off. Stanley went away, but Garside shot wide. The Everton forwards were again quickly on the aggressive, but Rankin shot wide. Bradshaw beat Whitley with a long shot, half-time Accrington 4, Everton nil, Full tine Accrington 6, Everton 1. Everton: - Whitley, goal, Gordon, and R.Balmer, backs, Clayton, Russell, and Makepeace, half-backs, Rankin, Sheridan, Dilly, O'Hagan, and Simpson, forwards.

LANCASHIRE AMATEUR LEAGUE
Lancashire Evening Post - Saturday 20 February 1904
LIVERPOOL LEEK v. BURNLEY BELVEDERE.
By kind permission of the Everton directors, this match was played at Goodison Park, in wet weather. Leek scored in the first minute through Lloyd Edwards, but Sandy equalised. Lock, however, hold the upper hand, and Lloyd and Griffiths scored in quick succession. Drew kept goal well for BurnIey and Lloyd also made fine save. Whittle fouled close in, but no penalty was allowed.
Half-time— Liverpool Leek 3. Burnley Belvedere 1.
After the interval Leek pressed, and McLean scored. Once the ball struck in the mud in front of Burnley goal, but the Leek forward could not send it into the net, and Drew cleared. Leek had much the best of matters, but the heavy ground shooting was often at fault. Towards the close Burnley pressed, but had hard lines. Jones scored for Leek. Result—LEEK 5. BURNLEY BELVEDERE 1.

TEAM ARRNAGEMENTS FOR THIS DAY
Liverpool Daily Post - Saturday 20 February 1904
Everton v Newcastle United
Friendly match at Newcastle; kick-off 3 p.m.
Everton.- Kitchen, goal; Henderson and Crelly, backs; Wolstenholme, Chadwick and Abbott, half-backs; Sharp, Taylor, McDermott, and H.P. Hardman forwards.
Reserve, Corrin.
Everton Combination v Accrington Stanley
Lancashire Combiantion match, at Accrington; Exchange Station 12.35; kick-off 3 p.m.
Everton Combination.- Whitley, goal; Gordon and R. Balmer, backs; Clayton, Russell, and Makepeace, half-backs; Rankin, Sheridan, Dilly, O’Hagan, and Simpson, forwards.

NEWCASTLE UNITED V. EVERTON.
Sunderland Daily Echo and Shipping Gazette - Saturday 20 February 1904
This afternoon these teams played a friendly fixture at Newcastle. The United had not their best team out, several of the regular players being given a rest. They also gave trial to new centre forward named Mackey. In the League tournament the " Toffees " have invariably occupied a respectable position. They won the Cup in 1890-1, were runners-up Preston North End in 1889-90. and Sunderland the seasons 1894-5 and 1901-2, besides twice finishing the third rung of the ladder. Of the twelve League games played between Newcastle and Everton, the Tynesiders have won 6, drawn 3, and lost 3. This season the clubs occupy fifth and seventh positions the League table respectively. The kick-off was fixed for three o'clock, and the teams were as follow.—
Newcastle United: Goal, Watts; backs, McCombie and Agnew; half-backs. Gardner, McWilliam, and Carr; forwards, Rutherford, Howie, Mackey, Orr, and Roberts.
Everton: Goa'. Kitchen; backs, Balmer, and Crelly; half-backs, Wolstenholme, Booth, and Abbot; forwards. Sharp, McDermott, Young, Settle, and Hardman.
Referee, Mr R. Paxton, Sunderland.

Y.M.C.A  v  WIGAN AMATEURS
Formby Times - Saturday 20 February 1904
On Saturday the Y.M.C.A journeyed to Whitley Park, Wigan through torrent of rain. The team was without Dent, being engaged for Everton Reserves.

O’HAGAN
Northern Daily Telegraph - Saturday 20 February 1904
O’Hagan a member of the Everton team, has been given permission to represent Ireland in the coming international matches. I mention this because O’Hagan was last year a member of the Old Xavierians team, in which he did some good service.

MEREDITH
Birkenhead News - Saturday 20 February 1904
Meredith, who made his first appearance from Everton Res last Saturday, at centre forward, a position Everton have been very weak at this season, gave a very fair display and scored two very fine goals.
He is a brother to Meredith, the Manchester City outside right, and last played for Chirk, so Everton have made a very fair capture.

OUTDOORS SPORTS
Liverpool Mercury - Saturday 20 February 1904
This afternoon the second round of the Association Cup-ties will be decided, but to Liverpool people little interest will be engendered, for both Everton and Liverpool have been thrown out of the competition. As a consequence, the Anfield ground will be deserted but the Goodison Park enclosure will be occupied by two Lancashire Amateur League teams, Leek and Burnley Belvedere, which should prove an interesting fixture.
Everton journeying to Accrington to engage the Stanley club,. The Everton League team should play a friendly fixture with Newcastle United, at Tyneside.
Friendly match at Newcastle; kick-off 3 p.m.
Accrington Stanley v Everton reserve, at Accrington.
Everton Combination.- Whitley, goal; Gordon and R. Balmer, backs; Clayton, Russell, and Makepeace, half-backs; Rankin, Sheridan, Dilly, O’Hagan, and Simpson, forwards.
Train leaves Exchange Station at 12.35 p.m. Kick off three p.m.
Newcastle United v Everton, Newcastle, kick-off three p.m.  
Everton.- Kitchen, goal; Henderson and Crelly, backs; Wolstenholme, Chadwick and Abbott, half-backs; Sharp, Taylor, McDermott, and H.P. Hardman forwards.
Reserve, Corrin.

NEWCASTLE UNITED 2 EVERTON 0
February 22, 1904. The Liverpool Courier
Kitchen saves Carr Penalty kick
At Newcastle. Play was not eagerly contested, but of the game Everton had the better of matters. Twice Sharp failed to score, whilst Taylor was always dangerous. Eventually the home side shaped better, and as a result of their persistent attacking. Mackey nearly scored. Still pressing Howie was fouled inside the penalty area, but Carr bungled his penalty kick , and no scored accrued. The shooting on both sides were very moderate, and it was palpable that neither set of players was very keen. Newcastle forwards were poorer in this respect and also in the matter of combination. Orr once missed an open goal badly. Everntually Everton forced their way down, and Young, Sharp and Taylor combined finely Sharp but the hardest of luck with his shot, for a very little would have turned it into the net. Half-time Newcastle nil, Everton nil. In the second half Newcastle shot better than the visitors and scored twice, goals from Rutherford, and Williams. Everton: - Kitchen, goal, W.Balmer, and Crelly, backs, Wolstenholme, Booth (captain), and Abbott, Sharp, Taylor, Young, McDermott, and Hardman, forwards. , Newcastle United: - Watts, goal, Binnie Roberts, and McCombie, half-backs, Carr, Mackery, McWilliams, Howie, McLarence, Orr, and Rurtherford forwards.

GREAT VICTORY FOR LEEK
Athletic News - Monday 22 February 1904
By Junius
With both the reserve and League teams away from Goodison Park, the Everton enclosure would have been otherwise desolate, but Leek obtained permission to play their Amateur League match with Burnley Relvedere on this ground, and despite the wretched weather there was a goodly crowd present to witness the match.  Leek started with ten men, but the vacancy was filled by a second team player, Jones.  They scored early, from, Griffiths centre, but Belvedere quickly equalized though before the interval; Leek added two more through Lloyd Edwards.  Afterwards, from another centre by Griffiths Mclean scored and the home players increased the lead by the same player, and won eventually by five goals to one.  All the Leek players gave a capital exposition and their victory was well deserved.  Lloyd, in goal defended excellently, whilst Griffiths and Lloyd Edwards were irresistible.  Lloyd on the extreme wing, was very effective and although rather neglected put in much good work.  For the visitors Drew kept goal nicely, whilst in defence Scott and Connor were very prominent.  The visitors had the misfortune to meet Leek at the top of their form. 

ACCRINGTON RESPLENDENT
Athletic News - Monday 22 February 1904
The Accrington Stanley team scored a brilliant victory over Everton-the only unbeaten team in the Combination –at Moorhead Park.  A steady downfall of “drizzle “did not prevent 6,000 spectators from gathering round the ropes to encourage last year’s champions.  After nine minutes play Balmer lifted the ball from Brunton perilously near to the visitors, to be caught by Bradshaw, who lashed the leather through the net, to the accompaniment of a roar of enthusiasm, and the uninvited stains of a solitary cornet.  This quickened the game although the ground was a quagmire, and the middle a miniature lake.  Becton took the honours of the second goal, and from this time to the half-time whistle the home side simply monopolized the play.  Brunton wedged a third past Whitley in grand style.  The fourth was appealed against on the ground that Becton, who placed it in the corner of the net, was off-side, but the goal was allowed, and the game started on its second half with four goals against the Everton men.  By this time the ground was in a fearful state, and both sides showed signs of fag.  Shortly after the start the visitors more by good luck than good management sent the ball creeping through the Stanley posts in a scramble.  Simpson taking that honour.  A penalty against one of the Everton men was converted by Becton, and two minutes from time Hesham completed the half-dozen goals for his team.  Both teams showed speed, and considering the state of the ground the game was full of interest and keenly followed.  The final result was –Stanley 6; Everton 1.

EVERTON v  NEWCASTLE UNITED
Liverpool Daily Post - Monday 22 February 1904
Played at Newcastle, before 5,000 spectators. The visitors played with the wind in the first half, and pressed at the outset, Taylor putting in a long shot, which Watts cleared by sending into touch. The Tynesiders played ten men, and McCombie was absent. Everton had the better of the exchanges, and Taylor and Sharp put in clinking shots, while Hardman both sprinted and centred in grand style. A capital clearance by Rennie, who made up Newcastle’s eleventh man, saw Roberts put in a good run and clever shot, which Kitchen cleared brilliantly. The play was of an uninteresting character, the men not exerting themselves to any extent. Crelly fouled Mackey, and Kitchen saved Carr’s shot, while at the other end Binnie stopped McDermott. Up to the interval there was no scoring, but on crossing over Rutherford and McWilliam each scored for the United.
Result; Newcastle 2 goals, Everton nil.

EVERTON’S NEW PLAYER
Liverpool Echo - Wednesday 24 February 1904
CHIRK CENTRE WITH A REPUTATION FOR SCORING
Everton Football Club have indeed been fortunate in securing the transfer of Ellias Roberts, of Chirk. Manchester City were “after” him, and, as he is a nephew of Meredith the City player, it seemed likely that he would join the City team. He is twenty-one years old, plays at centre forward, is of good build, and is a reliable shot. Already this season he has scored 30 goals for Combination team, and at practice this week he has shown that he can put sting behind his efforts. His first appearance with the team will be on Saturday at Goodison Park, Nelson are the visitors.
For Saturday’s match against Nottingham Forest, Young will figure at centre for Settle. Forest, Young will figure at centre for Settle, who has hurt his knee.
Sheffield Wednesday being engaged in the Cup tie (third round) on Saturday week, Everton are left without a home fixture on that date. A “friendly” will probably be fixed up.

EVERTON FIXING UP
Lancashire Evening Post - Saturday 27 February 1904
Elias Roberts from Chirk
The Everton Football Club have signed on Elias Roberts, who has been playing with the Combination team Chirk. He is a centre forward, whose reputation is exceedingly good. Strongly built, he is a good shot, as proved by the fact that already this season he has scored 30 goals for Chirk. he makes his first appearance this afternoon at Goodison Park against the Nelson team. Everton, by the way, should have played Sheffield Wednesday on Saturday next, but the Wednesday are engaged in the third round of the Football Association Cup against Tottenham Hotspur. As Aston Villa have said good bye to the Cup, and have no League fixture on that day, they have decided to accept Everton's terms for an ordinary match at Goodison Park next Saturday.

TEAM ARRNAGEMENTS FOR THIS DAY
Liverpool Daily Post - Saturday 27 February 1904
Everton v Notts Forest
League match at Nottingham.
Everton.- Kitchen, goal; Balmer and Crelly, backs; Wolstenholme, Booth and Abbott,. Half-backs; Sharp, Taylor, Young, McDermott, and H.P. Hardman, forwards.
Everton Combiantion v Nelson
Lancashire Combination match at Goodison Park. Kick-off at 3.30
Everton; Whitley, goal; Wildman and R. Balmer, backs; Clayton, Chadwick, and Makepeace, half-backs; Rankin, Sheridan, Roberts, O’Hagan, and Simpson, forwards.

FOREST'S FORM.
Football News (Nottingham) - Saturday 27 February 1904
TOO BAD TO BE TRUE.
EVERTON'S VICTORY  
A GOOD DEAL OF A FLUKE
Foresters played the best team available in to-days match, and they were badly beaten by Everton. But the visitors did not give such a display of good football as the reads suggests, and when Jones, the fine little full back, broke down and could not turn out in the second half, the Everton men had their path to the goal made very much easier. No doubt the fact that the “Reds” at the last moment found themselves rearranged, after having settled themselves as players will do, what this one and that one should do against certain of the Everton players, greatly upset the team to start with. Changes at the last minute are always demoralising. Any old player of football or cricket knows how much they affect even minor teams. How much more, then, the sudden removal of an important man from a tip-top organisation, with a consequent shifting about of half a dozen others. Morris was badly missed from the forwards to-day, but the half-back line was equally weak. Norris had much more than he could manage, and the Evertonians gave him no rest. The early stages of game foreshadowed that Forest would have a difficult task to escape defeat, and they began to falter under the pressure before twenty minutes had gone. Then gradually Everton forged ahead, and once there was a tremendous sally on the Foresters' goal. The attack was repulsed; but it was only the forerunner of many, and the "Reds" though they escaped this time.  
Never Got Really Steady again. There was as cheering over the fact that Forest had saved their goal as if the ball had been put into the Everton net. For quite a while after this the Everton men had the better of the game so far as keeping up the attack was concerned, which, after all, leads to goals. The " Reds" did not on more than two occasions in the next seven or eight minutes get anywhere near the Everton goal; the half-back play of Everton being excellent. Both Jones and Craig worked their hardest against the ever-increasing energy of the Evertonians; but Taylor and Sharp were a difficult pair for Jones and Innes to deal with, well assisted as they were by Young in the centre. We felt that at the rate they were going on Everton were pretty well bound to make a hole is our defence before long, and so it came about. Some elegant play by Booth and Abbott placed the ball well amongst the attacking party at the 'Blues," and a neat pass by Young to the feet of Taylor did the mischief. Taylor got a passage between the Forest backs, and from about fourteen yards took a steady quiet shot. The ball went over Linacre's right shoulder as he jumped for it., for Taylor was looking into his eyes at the time, and it was a case of planting the blow where it was most difficult to parry. This reverse happened just after the half-hour had gone. Play was brisker on the part of the – “Reds" when the ball was restarted, and particularly on their left, but the Everton defence of Crelly and Abbott was very strong. Than a great misfortune happened to Forest, for, in a collision with the sturdy Taylor, Jones went down with his left leg in a bent position, and he had to be lifted up.  He pluckily tried to play after a brief rest, but had to retire, and Shearman took the position of left back until the of ends. It was learned during the interval that Jones had wrenched his thigh- an accident of the same nature having happened  to him when playing in an international match at Wrexham. It was not a joyful procession of Foresters that into the pavilion, for a goal behind, with a doughty team and Jones hors de combat, was not reassuring for the second half. When they resumed, Warren took the right back position, and Craig crossed to the left. It is a valuable player who can be placed to stop either wing as the case may require. The Foresters started with two half-backs; but Timmins quickly fell back to centre-half position. Kitchen had a slippery shot to stop ere the second half was very old, notwithstanding.  Their weakened attack the  Foresters were doing very well for the first ten minutes. Spouncer showed quite a brilliant facility in dribbling when he had possession of the ball on one occasion. In succession he beat Wolstenholme and Balmer and looked like getting through, but Balmer came again, and hanging on, Spouncer had to part, when he had backed to his goal; and an Everton forward took the ball. Crelly, a fine picture of black-haired masculinity, met Shearmen in a shoulder to shoulder essay but Shearman  had the better position and the weighty Crelly recoiled. But our fellows could no permanent impression on the visitors, whose front rank governed the ball admirably. Linacre made a grand “full length on the ground" save, giving a corner. From this the ball was adroitly dropped in front of goal by the outside left of Everton, Hardman.  The ball, indeed, glided off the cross-bar on to the heed of one of the “men in blue" and so into  the net, and Everton were, like Russian fleet (a la despatches), is an impregnable position. There was an ominous quietness over the ground after  after the scoring of this goal. “You’re not beaten yet, Forest, a boy’s voice sang out encouragingly, but Taylor and Sharp put the matter almost beyond doubt when Abbott lifted the ball out on to the right. Taylor passed to Sharp, and Sharp passed the ball into the net. Sharp was the man, and Sharp was the action. Of course the Foresters were playing only nine men in the field it must be remembered. But they had full strength -in point of numbers at any rate-in the half-back and back division. Norris, however, had not the pace of the men opposed to him, and when Sharp got the ball it was necessary for the others to fall back on goal, for there was pretty certain to be a good centre put in. a fourth goal was managed off the Everton right before the end of the game was reached, and Linacre and Craig will, I have no doubt remember the little firm of Taylor and Sharp for quits a long time. So will Norris. Such a match as that of to-day is bitterly disappointing, without a doubt, to Forest supporters. For whilst Everton are by no means the strongest of even the upper middle division of League they played a game on the drying ground that was certainly much superior to that of Forest even from the start. There was something wrong with the Forest front rank, and two week spots were certainly those which Wright and Sugden did their best to fill. The half-backs of the other side have so much to do these matters that one need not be too severe on the forwards who fail. Against men of moderate calibre both Nugden and Wright are capable of playing a very fair game indeed. What is wanted, however, is that the men should be able to show the form required of them against all comers—a difficult though not impossible task for the right men. The point is to get the men who can do it. The committee did properly. I think, to give Innes a chance; but the fact that he has been out of First League football for so long discounted his reappearance considerably. It would probably takes Innes another two matches to settle down again and be able to “put all in,” so we may count him out this season. Height and reach are wanted in half-backs, but personally I am most favourably inclined to Crawshaw.  The Foresters are undoubtedly in a difficulty, and there is no use adding to the hardship of the position by haphazard suggestions. But it is the duty of their friends to help them in the present dilemma, and some well-considered and well-weighed advice by trusted friends and good judges might be of services. Do not let to-day’s result be over-disturbing. It would not happen many times that Forest would be let down so badly. There are men who can do better, and must. H.G.

EVERTON v  NOTTS FOREST
Liverpool Football Echo - Saturday 27 February 1904
LEAGUE DIVISION ONE
EVERTON LEAD AT THE INTERVAL
The Everton team left Liverpool for Nottingham yesterday afternoon, and spent the evening quietly in the lace capital, travelling thither this morning. The country was found to be under snow, but singularly enough Nottingham had escaped the wintry visitation. At Nottingham, however, a slight drizzle of sleet set in, and when play began there was just a suggestion of rain. Everton made two changes in their team-Rankin coming in for McDermott, while Young took the centre position in place of Settle. The Foresters are without Iremonger and Morris. The weather affected the attendance considerably, and there was only a comparatively small crowd present when the players faced each other as follows;-
Everton.- Kitchen, goal; Balmer and Crelly, backs; Wolstenholme, Booth (captain), and Abbott, half-backs; Sharp, Taylor, Young, Rankin, and Hardman, forwards.
Notts Forest;- Linacre, goal; Craig and Jones, backs; Innes, Warson, and Norris, half-backs; Wright, Sherman, Sugden, Timmins, and Spouncer, forwards.
Everton lost the toss, but at the outset they commenced to press, and for some five minutes fairly taxed the Forest defenders to the utmost. The home backs were safe, but eventually Young found an opening and sent in a capital shot, which Linacre, by a great effort, managed to save. The Forest forwards now put on pressure, but they found Balmer and Crelly a difficult pair to beat, though on one occasion the home centre had a chance at which he made a poor attempt. The next item was provided by Sharp, who raced half the field, and was only pulled up within the fifteen yards line, and another attack ended in Craig heading over his own goal, but the corner kick came to nothing. Then Sharp made headway, and Taylor shot splendidly, to find Linacre in readiness to bring off a gran save. After this there was a bout of end-to-end play, and excitement ran high, but both sets of forwards showed faulty shooting, neither custodian being really seriously troubled. The home forwards at length ran down in business like fashion, and Balmer was beaten, but he recovered himself very cleverly, and the Evertonians in turn advanced, but a neat check was administered by Warren, midfield play ensuing. Young displayed considerable cleverness, and presented a nice opening to Hardman, who however, utilised it badly. Next the Forest right were prominent, and Shearman had an excellent chance of scoring, but, to the disappointment of the spectators, he shot high over the bar. At this period the pace was much slower, and there were frequent cries of “Play up!” from the spectators, and in answer to this the visitors put on a decided spurt. Hardman ran down smartly and Sharp dashing in was about to give the finishing touch when Linacre fisted out right from under the cross bar. The Evertonians were now exerting considerable pressure, and a nice movement ended in Young working his way through and putting in a low swift shot. This was well tackled by Linacre, who fell in clearing, and Young had a second attempt but again the custodian recovered himself with agility, and the situation was saved. Following upon this there was a further spell of midfield work and nothing of particular interest happened for some time. The visitors worked down by easy stages, but the home half back line was exceedingly clever, and time after time the Evertonians were beaten back. They persisted, however, and looked distinctly dangerous when Rankin sent the leather high over the bar. The visitors, however, were not to be denied, and taking up the attack again they moved down in fine order. When close in Young passed to Taylor, and the veteran, tricking the back, ran in and scored a beautiful goal, the ball going right out of Linacre’s reach. As a consequence Linacre was not again troubled seriously. The Evertonians was still pressing when half-time came, the score standing;-
Everton 1 goal, Notts nil.
When the game restarted Jones was still absent having sprained his leg. After a short attack by the Forest, Everton worked to the other end, and Linacre cleared a shot from a forty yards’ range from Balmer. Wolstenholme also tried, the Forest custodian making a brilliant save also from Hardman. Everton were much the better side hereabouts, and the second goal was put on fifteen minutes after the restart. Handicapped as they were, the Forest had little of the play, and Sharp put his side further ahead. At the other end Spouncer had the hard luck to see his shot sent in with tremendous force, strike the post and rebounded into play, and then Kitchen cleared nicely from Shearman. The attack was only short-lived, and Everton resumed pressure, with the result that Sharp beat Linacre for a fourth time. Everton kept up the attack to the finish, and won easily by 4 goals to nil.  Final Result Everton 4 goals, Notts Forest Nil
Last season’s encounter at Nottingham ended in a draw of 2 goals each.

NOTTS FOREST 0 EVERTON 4
February 29, 1904. The Liverpool Courier
The return engagement was decided at Nottingham, Everton having travelled to the lace capital on the previous afternoon. The visitors were without McDermott, whose place was taken by Rankin, and Young was in the centre instead of Settle, while Iremonger and Morris were absent from the home side. Show was falling when the teams turned out as follows: - Everton: - Kitchen, goal, W.Balmer, and Crelly backs, Wolstenholme, Booth (captain), and Abbott half-backs, Sharp, Taylor, Young, Rankin, and Hardman, forwards. Notts Forest: - Linacre, goal, Craig, and Jones, backs, Innes Warren, and Norris, half-backs, Wright, Shearmen, Sudgen, Timmons, and Spouncer, forwards. Referee T.Kirkham. The Forest won the toss, and on Everton opening the game, the play at once settled down in the home half. The Everton forwards attacked in splendid fashion, and after a clever movement in which all took part, Young sent in a magnificent shot, which Linacre as cleverly saved. The Forest forwards got away on the left and gave Balmer much trouble. A moment later an opening was made for Sudgen, but the shot failed badly. Rankin then raced down, and putting to Young, the latter parted to Sharp, who contributed a very fine run down the right, and was only successfully challenged by Jones when just a few yards from the goal. After Spouncer had made some running, the visiting left wing pair got away, and Craig all but headed into his own goal. Nothing came of the corner kick, but returning again, Taylor put in a magnificent shot, which Linacre reached, and gave an abortive corner. Just now the play was particularly keen and in favour of the visitors, but the final shots was faulty, and Linacre was not troubled. A brisk movement by the Forest forwards resulted in placing Balmer in difficulties, but recovering himself, the play settled in midfield, where several Sharp passing movements ensued between the respective half-backs. A smart touch by Young resulted in a change of venue, and Hardman was given a chance of getting away, but misjudged the pass, and Craig put forward to Sugden. By gradual stages play was directed in the Everton end, where Shearman had a district opening, but shot ridiculously high over the bar. Meanwhile Booth, Abbott, and Wolstenholme had been putting in much good work. Eventually Hardman put across to Sharp, who again tested Linacre, though to no purpose. Then followed a brilliant attack on the Forest goal. Linacre saving twice from Young, while Abbott with a terrific shot only missed by the merest shave. The downfall of snow was now more dense, but apparently it had little effect upon the players, who contested every inch of the ground with the utmost keenest. Generally the play was now favouring the visitors, and on more than one occasion the Forest backs were distinctly fortunate in charging down well-directed shots. The Forest halves were in capital form, and eventually their successful work led to a stern attack on the Everton goal. Some fine kicking by Balmer was not a notable feature of Everton's defence, and again followed a Sharp attack upon Linacre's charge. Abbott was conspicuous, and for a couple of minutes they quite held up their opponents. Their consistency was ultimately rewarded, as following upon some splendidly combined work, Taylor threated his way through, and from short range, beat Linacre with a capital shot. A slight stoppage was caused owing to Sharp coming to collision with Jones, but on getting to work again Balmer was called upon to clear a dangerous shot from Sheridan. The Foresters then took advantage of some loose play on the part of Wolstenholme, and made play on his wing, and at the period Jones, who had evidently been suffering from the effects of the charge, left the field. Another fine clearance by Balmer was the next item, and then the whole of the Everton forwards moved away in fine style, only once again to find the Forest defenders in rare trim. As the interval approached the home players made a determined effort to equalise, but failed. Half-time Notts Forest nil, Everton 1. The Forest took the held in the second half with only ten men. Warren went back, and they played four forwards. The home team were completely outplayed by the smart Everton forwards throughout the close of the half. It was not long before Sharp scored a beautiful goal, and although Kitchen was once or twice called upon, the great bulk of the play was always in the Forest half. From a corner well taken by Hardman, the ball was headed into the Forest net, Sharp sented in fourth goal for Everton, and the spectators began to leave the field before the game was finished. Result Notts Forest 0, Everton 4.

EVERTON RESERVE DEFEAT NELSON
Athletic News - Monday 29 February 1904
A capture game was witnessed at Goodison Park between the above teams, and Everton eventually won by four goals to two.  Sheridan opened the scoring from a beautiful centre by Simpson but Hopgkinson equalized from long range, and O’Hagan gained the lead before the interval.  Afterwards Watkins made matters equal a second time; but Sheridan put on a third from a free kick, and after Whitley had smartly saved a penalty.  O’Hagan made the issue safe by scoring a fourth.  On the Everton side O’Hagan and Sheridan, the inside players gave a fine exhibition but the new centre from Chirk was not very prominent.  Makepeace was the best of half-backs, and young Balmer defended capably further behind.  Whitley was in rare form in goal, and his clearance from the penalty kick was one of the best bits of play seen during the match.  Nelson gave a good account of themselves, Walker in goal and Derbyshire at left back being the most conspicuous defenders.  At centre half Ainsworth rendered good service, whilst Watkins, Hodgkinson and Crana were the prominent figures in the forward line. 

THE FOREST STILL RETROGRESSING
Athletic News - Monday 29 February 1904
By Trentsiders
Football continues at a low ebb in Nottingham, and on Saturday the Forest sustained their seventh home defeat. Everton accounting for them by four goals to none. Without Morris and Iremonger, who were on the sick list, the Reds were, of course, at a great disadvantage, but their overwhelming reverse was mainly due to the fact that for more than half the game they had to play with only ten men. Jones spraining the guider of the leg, which gave way in the Welsh International Trial Match so badly that he was totally incapacitated. But even when at full strength it cannot be said that the Forest created an impression that they would win. Everton were always the better side. Their forwards, whilst not quite so dashing as they might have been, were a well-balanced and clever lot, and their de fence was thoroughly sound. On the other hand the Forrest front rank was very uneven. There were occasions when the players were able work into a favourable position, but their efforts were of a very scrappy order, and the Everton goal was seldom placed in any serious danger.  Whilst the defence remained intact, it proved fairly safe, but the half-backs were not altogether strong, and generally there was a lack of understanding. This was only to be expected, seeing what rearrangements had to be made in the constitution of the eleven, but for all that the display was exceedingly disappointing. There were some very quiet periods of play, and the supporters of home club had never much cause for enthusiasm. In the very first minute Booth got in a fine long shot, which Linacre was very smart to clear, and the Forest keeper distinguished himself by many brilliant saves. For some time there was not much to choose between the teams, each being responsible for attacks into which little spirit was thrown, but matters improved and some excellent individual attempts were made. Shearman put one sharp burst, only to be spoiled by Crelley, and similarly when Sharp appeared to be running through he was pulled up by Craig. The last-named made a very poor effort to drive home a free kick, and the next minute headed over his own goal. The Reds had very hard work repel the attack following the corner kick, but after a little over half an hour Taylor got through. The breakdown of Jones and for the remainder of the half the Forest took the extraordinary course of playing Shearman at back.
HOPELESSLY BEATEN.
A far more sensible arrangement was tried after the interval. Warren joining Craig and Timmins taking the centre half position. With their forces thus disposed, however, the Reds had still to act on the defensive. Linacre had several easy shots to deal with before Abbott, shooting through a crowd of players, once more proved his quality. It was Unfortunate that his clearance was of little avail, seeing that a goal resulted from the succeeding corner kick, which was taken by Hardman. The point was strongly objected to by the Reds, the ball apparently going through just under the bar without touching a second player, but the referee seemed to have no doubt upon the matter.   The third goal was the outcome of a fine run and a shot by Sharp, and the same player added the fourth after Linacre had kept out well from Hardman. The Forest made some of their best efforts in the closing stages. Spouncer sending hard against one of the posts, while Shearman had some hard luck.
CONCERNING THE PLAYERS
Linacre kept a splendid goal, and Craig, if a trifle rash, played a grand game. Jones also being in good form. Warren was clever at centre half, and he played very creditably when partnering Craig. During the first half lnnes was smart, and the Liverpool left wing could do very little against him and Craig. Innes, however, tired somewhat, and was not so effective afterwards. Norris, who captained the side, played moderately, and Sugden and Wright were weak spots amongst the forwards. Timmins was not a great success, but worked hard, and the bulk of the leading work devolved upon Shearman and Spouncer Kitchen had not much difficult work, the backs leaving little for him to do. The Everton middle trio played a capital game. Booth in particular, and the forwards combined in pretty style. Nottingham Forest;- Linacre; Craig, and Jones; Innes, Warren, and Norris; Wright, Shearman, Sugden, Timmins, and Spouncer.  Everton; Kitchen; Balmer and Crelley; Wolstenholmes, Booth, and Abbott; Sharp, Taylor, Young, Rankin, and H.P. Hardman.  Referee; T. Kirkham, Burslem. 

EVERTON RESERVES 4 NELSON 2
February 29,1904. The Liverpool Mercury
Lancashire Combination “A” Division (Game 21)
At Goodison Park. Nelson kicked off before a capital gate. Everton opened the score through Sheridan, and Hodgkinson equalised. The home team augmented before the interval though O'Hagan. Resuming, Watkins equalising, and from a free kick Sheridan gave Everton the lead. Whitley brought off a magnificent save from a penalty, and O'Hagan scored for Everton. Everton: - Whitley, goal, Wildman, and R.Balmer, backs, Clayton, Chadwick. And Makepeace, half-backs, Rankin, Sheridan, Roberts, O'Hagan and Simpson, forwards.

EVERTON REVIEW
February 29, 1904. The Liverpool Mercury
By their substantial victory at Nottingham on Saturday. Everton had amply revenge for the unexpected defeat which the Forest inflicted upon them at Goodison Park in October. Success such a margin as four goals to nil, would on the face of it, amply that Everton had come back to their most brilliant form, but this could hardly be applied to the game under notice. At a matter of fact it was not so much owing to Everton's superior tactics as to the weakness of their opponents that the success the issue went to decidedly in favour of the visiting team. The Foresters were handicapped by the absence of such important players to them as Iremonger, Morris and Calvey. With reserves by no means capable of filling the vacant places satisfactorily, not many, even of the home club's supporters imagined that they would be able to account for Everton. Apart, however, from this drawback serious as it was, they were still further handicapped by an injury to their left back. Jones who, as the result of a collision with Sharp, left the field shortly before the interval, and was unable to put in an appearance during the remainder of the game. Small although the match took place under adverse climatic conditions the ground was in excellent trim. Nottingham apparently having escaped the recent visitation of snow, which has played havoc with many football enclosures in this part of the county. During the whole of the proceedings there was a slight fall of snow, but it was not sufficient to hamper the player the players, or even to seriously interfere with the comfort of the spectators. Everton opened with conspicuous determination, and in the first few minutes it was only the alertness of Linacre, which prevented the downfall of the Forest goal. It was seen evident that the visiting side held the upperhand, for despite spasmodic rushes by the Forest vanguard, their attacks rarely suggested danger. The footwork of the Everton quintet, and especially the half-backline, was immeasurably better than that of the Forest, and it was really more by good luck than good management that 35 minutes elapsed before Taylor, with at beautiful efforts, had the satisfaction of defeating the trusty Forest custodian. It was just after this success that Jones was compelled to retire, and from this point the Forest apparently gave up hope of being able to avert disaster. In the second portion of the game Everton were even more prominent than they had hitherto been. The four Forest forest could make little impression upon, the resourceful Everton trio of halves, although it must be conceded that on two of three occasions, Kitchen was called upon to repel unexpected and dangerous shot. The Everton goalkeeper however, was not to be beaten, and for the most part the Foresters were obliged to act entirely upon the defensive. Three goals, two of which were obtained by Sharp, the other from a corner being diverted into the net by a Forest defender, were added to Everton's score which might have been still further increased had it not been for the skill, with which Linacre kept out all kinds of troublesome shots. Twice particularly he managed to get the ball away, when on the ground and surrounded by opponents, in most astonishing fashion. Young signalised his reappearance as centre forward by many neat touches, and although now, and again his passing was faulty, he still distributed the play, and kept his wings engaged in a manner which, had not a little to do with the success of the side. Rankin is filling McDermott's place at inside left, was hampered, though being out of his customary's position, but he was always a hard worker, and with Hardman constituted an effective wing, though it did not shine as conspicuously as did Sharp and Taylor, at the other end of the line. Booth and Abbott were the most successful of the halves, and while Balmer and Crelly were always safe, and reliable. Kitchen as has been indicated kept a splendid goal, whenever he was called upon, which was only at rare intervals.

NOTTS FOREST V EVERTON
London Daily News - Monday 29 February 1904
At Nottingham the Forest tewam suffered a severe reverse, Everton beating them by four goals to none. The winners were at full strength, while the home side without Morris and Calvey. It was not until after an hour's play that the visitors obtained their first goal. Taylor then getting through. Before the interval The Forest lost Jones, and for the rest of the game they had to play a man short. Everton scored their second goal after change of ends from a corner in somewhat lucky fashion. Sharp added the remaining points.

SATURDAY’S FOOTBALL
Liverpool Daily Post - Monday 29 February 1904
Although Everton secured a 4 to nil victory against the Forest at Nottingham on Saturday, the game cannot be any stretch of imagination be called a good one. The pace was slow throughout, and at times play was positively dull. It is only fair, however, to say that Everton were always superior to their opponents, who were handicapped by losing the services of Jones, the left back, before the interval. But, apart from this, the “Reds” never really seemed to get into their stride, and in the second portion of the game they were fairly and squarely outplayed. The wretched weather no doubt had something to do with the lack of enthusiasm, but the general opinion of those present was that the exhibition was not calculated to inspire it. The two outside men, Sharp and Hardman, were probably the best of the Everton forwards. The two goals which the Lancashire cricketer scored were the result of splendid individual efforts, and throughout the game the right winger showed capital form. Young did some useful work in the centre position, but he missed several opportunities of netting the ball, and it would seem as though shooting was not his forte. Taylor was as determined and energetic as ever, and he added to his record by crediting himself with one of the goals scored. Rankin was by no means a success, though once or twice he partnered Hardman to some advantage.
The half-back line was as alert and as tricky as usual. Abbott putting in some particularly useful work. Booth also played well, and time after time he broke up the forward movements of the Nottingham front line. Balmer and Crelly were bother on their best behaviour and Kitchen fulfilled an easy task with confidence and coolness.
On Saturday’s form the Forest were undoubtedly a poor lot, the absence of Morris, and Iremonger being appreciated felt, and without there is a distinct improvement they will lose more points on their ground.

NOTTINGHAM FOREST v  EVERTON
Liverpool Mercury - Monday 29 February 1904
At Nottingham, before 5,000 spectators. Forest were minus Morris (injured) and Everton had Rankin vice McDermott. The visitors had the better of the game during the first half, their clever combination frequently placing the Forest goal in great danger. Taylor scored for Everton after 35 minutes. Jones retired hurt, and did not resume before the interval.
Half-time -Everton 1; Nottingham Forest, nil.
Jones was unable to resume, and in view of Monday’s international, he may unfortunately miss his Welsh cap. Hardman placed a corner so well the ball hit the bar, and, dropping on to Rankin’s body, entered the net, scoring Everton’s second goal. Sharp ran through and added a third, the same player also scoring a fourth. Spouncer had bad luck with a terrific shot which hit the post.
Result- Everton 4 Nottingham Forest 0
Everton.- Kitchen, goal; Balmer and Crelly, backs; Wolstenholme, Booth, and Abbott, half-backs; Sharp, Taylor, Young, Rankin, and Hardman, forwards.
Notts Forest;- Linacre, goal; Craig and Jones, backs; Innes, Warson, and Norris, half-backs; Wright, Sherman, Sugden, Timmins, and Spouncer, forwards.

EVERTON v  NELSON
Liverpool Mercury - Monday 29 February 1904
COMBINATION
At Goodison Park. Nelson kicked off before a capital gate. Everton opened the score through Sheridan, and Hodgkinson equalised. The home team augmented before the interval through O’Hagan. Resuming, Watkins equalising and from a free kick Sheridan gave Everton the lead. Whitley brought off a magnificent save from a penalty, and O’Hagan scored for Everton. Result- Everton, 4 goals; Nelson 2.