Everton Independent Research Data

 

BEE’S NOTES
The Liverpool Echo-Friday, February 2, 1923
Everton are away at Stockport to whom they introduce McBain, Troup and Co. Meanwhile there is a big little game at Goodison Park, where the Villa send their Central League team, and the Liverpool Cup-tie “postage” will occur every quarter of an hour. So Everton are expecting the biggest gate their Central League register shows outside the minor Derby game.

LANCASHIRE CRICKET CAPTAIN. MR. JACK SHARP INVITED TO LEAD THE TEAM
Yorkshire Post and Leeds Intelligencer - Saturday 03 February 1923
At special meeting of the general committee of the Lancashire County Cricket Club, yesterday, Mr. Jack Sharp, the All-Englacd cricketer and international footballer, was unanimously invited to captain the county eleven during the next season. Mr. Sharp, who acted as captain on several occasionS last season, was born in February, 1878. He early developed great skill as a cricketer, and when only fourteen scored 208 not out for Herefordshire Club and Ground. He first went to Lancashire as professional footballer for Everton, for whom he did splendid service, and from which club got his international cap, playing against Ireland 1903 and against Scotland 1905. First introduced into the Lancashire team bowler, he developed unusual powers with the bat. He was accorded a benefit 1910, which realised £1.679. His best year was 1909, when he scored four centuries and thrice played for England against Australia. In that year headed the English batting averages, and scored the only century for England in the five Tests. Afterwards he was reinstated an amateur the Football Association, and later became amateur member of the Lancashire cricket team.

A PAIGNANT LETTER
The Liverpool Football Echo- Saturday, February 3, 1923
Bee’s Notes
“Sandy” has a poignant question;- Can you or anyone explain the lines on which Everton’s team construction is conducted? It has been patent to anyone for years that the weakness of the team has been with the inside forwards and yet here the management go and spend thousands of pounds on a man for the one position for which the club is well equipped, i.e., out side left. Another point is; Have they considered what the effect is likely to be on those men they already haver for the position? Then look at the construction of the team last Saturday. To bring in Grenyer they move Hart and Fleetwood, and so disorganise the whole line, whilst if they had brought Peacock to the half back line and put Irvine (or someone else) forward very little disturbance would have been necessary? There seems to be a mania for attempting to fit round pegs in square holes, a further example of which is the engagement of a star left half (or centre)- a position already well filled by Hart-and leave the right half position to be filled probably by Fleetwood, a place most judges consider he is quite unsuited for, good as he is in the centre.

STUB MARKS
Liverpool Football Echo-Saturday, February 3, 1923
By Louis T. Kelly

COUNTY COMBINATION
The Liverpool Football Echo- Saturday, February 3, 1923
Last week result
Grayson’s beat Everton A 2-0. Everton had the wind and most of the game in the first half but failed to find the net. The visitors’ defence played a strong game. With the elements in their favour Grayson’s opened the score owing to a slip by Kemp, and just before the close McCrae put through his own goal.

EVERTON AT STOCKPORT
The Liverpool Football Echo-Saturday, February 3, 1923
FRIENDLY FIXTURE WITH THE COUNTY SIDE
Everton having nothing on today in the Cup or the League, visited Stockport to play a friendly game with Stockport County. Everton won the toss, and started a dangerous movement out on the left, in which Peacock beat the home backs, but failed with his shot, the ball going outside. From a corner on the right Irvine headed in, Richardson clearing. Everton again pressed, Troup putting in a smart centre, but Thompson kicked away. Troup and Cock were often prominent and Chedgzoy several times tested Hardy, but the goal keeper brought off some fine saves.
Half-time; Stockport County 0, Everton 0
Wilson scored for Stockport.
Final; Stockport County 1, Everton 0

EVERTON RES v  ASTON VILLA RES
The Liverpool Football Echo-Saturday, February 3, 1923
CENTRAL LEAGUE
Owing to the senior teams both playing away this Central League fixture attracted a great crowd, Everton showed only one change from the selected side. Weller taking Brown’s place at right half. On the other hand, the Villa made no less than seven alterations. When play commenced the weather was fine, with a strong breeze blowing from goal to goal. Villa won the toss and soon showed vim on the left. Stephenson and Howgate carried play to close quarters, the former sending in a centre which Livingstone cleared. At the other end Everton attacked through Harrison, who was neatly robbed by Corbett. Again the Villa advanced and Stephenson, getting the better of Caddick, gained a corner, which he placed well into goal, Fern having to punch away a sharp drive from T. Jones. Still the ball hovered around the home citadel for a time until relief came through Campbell shooting over. Everton then made play in the centre, Forbes, after beating Ball, finishing with a poor pass to Parry, and the good opportunity was lost. Play so far had been fairly even, neither side could claim any advantage. A foul against Reid in the home quarters came to nought. Another spirited attack by the Villa almost brought the downfall of the home goal. Stephenson after tricking Caddick, placed the ball right in front of goal, and Reid was lucky to intercept a drive from Furtees. After this escape Everton forced the pace and Rooney had distinctly hard lines in not getting home a good drive. For several minutes Everton kept up the pressure, and had their finishing touches been a little more accurate their efforts would surely have borne fruit. A shot from Harrison was well fielded by the Villa custodian, as also was a low drive from Weller. Parry, on the home right, was very energetic and continually have trouble to Brett and Campbell. On one occasion he had very hard lines, for after beating the former, when a goal looked certain, he overran the ball when only a few yards from goal, and consequently Jones cleared easily. Play was taking a decided turn in Everton’s favour. Still, each time the visitors got to close quarters they were exceedingly dangerous. Fortunately, Fern was in his best form and extricated the home side several times when a goal looked imminent.
CHADWICK SCORES FINE GOAL
After thirty minutes play Everton opened the score. Harrison, making his way down the wing, centred the ball, and Chadwick hooking it over his head, finished by heading it into the net, much to the surprise of the keeper. Truly a marvellous goal. For a long time Everton had the bulk of the play, but the Villa at last gave a glimpse of their true form- they worked the ball towards the home end with perfect combination, and Fern had to admit defeat from a shot by Howgate five minutes from the interval, thus equalising the scores. No further scoring took place prior to the interval. Half-time; Everton Res 1, Aston Villa Res 1

STOCKPORT COUNTY 1 EVERTON 0
February 5 1923. The Liverpool Courier.
EVERTON LOSE AT STOCKPORT.
BUT NEW MEN SHINE.
For this match at Edgeley Park, Everton played their full League team, except that Spicer took the place of Downs. Although beaten they were much the better team, and at times fairly outwitted the home club. The County tried Kemp, a local junior, at outside right, and he justified the confidence placed in him.
A CURIOUS GOAL.
The game was well contested, and some pretty football was shown by both teams Wilson scored the only goal of the match and did so in rather a peculiar fashion. Kemp had worked down the wing, and after tricking Spicer he dropped the ball in the goalmouth. Harland fisted the ball out, but slipped and fell, and before he could regain his feet Wilson netted. McBain acquitted himself well in his new team, distributing the ball well. Along with Jeffs he was the pick of the half-backs. Raitt was the better of the backs, and Cock and Troup, the other new members of the team, were often to the forewith good work, the latter being a veritable box of tricks. Chedgzoy also put across some capital centres. The County defence were often hard pressed in keeping their lines clear, and Hardy was never at fault in dealing with the attack, which at times was very persistent . Everton: - Harland, goal, Raitt and Spicer, backs, Jeffs, McBain, and Hart (captain) half-backs, Chedgzoy, Irvine, Cock, Peacock, and Troup, forwards.

EVERTON RESERVES 2 ASTON VILLA RESERVES 1
February 5, 1923. The Liverpool Courier.
CENTRAL LEAGUE
A big crowd assembled at Goodison Park to witness a fine match in which Everton beat Aston Villa by the odd goal in three. It was soon evident that the Blues were the cleverer side and they shot for goal at every opportunity, although many efforts were lacking in direction. Even so the Villa were often dangerous and Fern was called upon to save some capital efforts. After 30 minutes' Chadwick scored a beautiful goal. Harrison ran down and centred, Chadwick hooking the ball into the net. Not many minutes had elapsed when the visitors equalised. Fern made a fine save, but Howgate, who was following up, tapped the ball into the net. The second half saw Everton making many desperate attacks, and they were at length successful in regaining the lead. Forbes putting in a shot which Jones could not hold. The Everton left wing was in grand form, Chadwick and Harrison blending well together. Forbes at centre also did well while Parry exhibited speed and resource. The halves were very good, with Weller perhaps the most prominent. The defence in which Livingstone was the dominant figure was also safe. The outstanding player on the visitors side was Stephenson, who played a sterling game at outside left. P. Jones, the keeper and Ball at centre half. Everton: - Fern, goal, Caddick, and Livingstone, backs, Brown, Reid, and Weller half-backs, Parry Miller, Forbes, Chadwick, and Harrison, forwards.

EN PASSANT
Athletic News- Monday, February 5, 1923
THE PRESODEMT OF THE F.A.
In all the Association Cup-ties on Saturday the players wore black bands on their left am, to mark their mourning and testify their profound respect for the late Lord Kinnaird, the distinguished President of the Football Association. His lordship passed away last Tuesday, at the ago of 75 years, andwas laid to rest at Ressie Priory, the family seat in Scotland, Friday. A famous footballer and a great player of manly pastimes, the late Lord Kinnaird during his long life bound the past to the present. Since 1891 he hold the exalted office of President of parent body of all football. He rendered inestimable service in popularising the game in its infancy, in lending dignity to the F.A and in setting a splendid example of the highest standard of sportsmanship whether on the field or in the council chamber. Never can he be replaced. The career of Lord Kinnaird is discussed at some length in another column.

STRAY LEAVES
Athletic News- Monday, February 5, 1923
THE PASSING OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE F.A.
THE LESSON OF HIS LIFE
By Tityrus
Now is done the long day’s work;
Fold the palms across thy breast,
Fold thine arms, turn to thy rest
Gone to his long rest is Arthur Fitzgerald, eleventh Baron Kinnaird, the President of the Football Association and a sportsman who was devoted to all that was true and good. In the real sense of th word he was a pious man. He came of an illustrious stock, and for the rare combination of his qualities he will live in the hearts of men. Reverence will crown his memory. It not for those without tie of blood to trespass over the threshold, but it is impossible to forget the grief which overtook him within a few days of the end of his pilgrimage. Gradually strength forsook him. The ebb-tide set in, and, as R. L. Stevenson said of Lord Durrisdeer,“without any mortal violence his spirit fled.” Thus shall we think of the departure of the leader of the people game the man who, more than any other  was the recreation of the few and the era when it became the pastime of the nation.
The life of Kinnaird might well serve as a test for a homily on several subjects of deep interest, but the one phase which should be emphasised by Football folks is that a devout man and a peer of the realm never lost the enthusiasm of his youth, and to the last considered it a pleasure and a duty to help in the good government of that game which he adorned in the full vigour pf manhood, and which changed so much during his career. A distinguished figure when true amateurism was the dominating tone he saw football, or the Association form of it develop professionalism, and become tinged with a spirit commercialism entirely foreign to his active experience and possibly to the ideals which inspired him to join the frolics of the field game at Eton in the conflicts of the collegians at Cambridge, and in the battles of the Old Boys' teams against the democratic forces which entered the arena between 1875 and 1885. The game was transformed, but the laird of Rossie Priory on the braes of the Carse of Gowrie never wavered in his loyalty to that which he considered good for the majority of boys and young men, good for the amusement of masses who could not play and could never hope to do so for manifold and convincing reasons.
THE MUBOULAR CHRISTIAN
It is this attitude of Lord Kinnaird that should be insisted upon now and for ever. In manner and speech there wasnothing of the haughty aristocrat about him. Quiet in talk and demeanour, there was a slight breeziness in his conversation, but the note of earnestness was never absent. A Christian athletic he possessed the virtue of helping others. Those who have read that interesting book devoted to the life of Quintin Hogg, the founder of The Polytechnic in London, have discovered many side-lights Lord Kinnaird’s life. Hogg was born in London on February 14, 1845, and the Hon. Arthur Kinnaird on February 16, 1847, in the same great city. Both were of Scottish descent, both met at Eton, and their friendship which began in the classroom was founded on religious fervour and football. They were the prime movers in what was sarcasticallydescribedat Eton as “The Synagogue,” for it was a Bible class. they were ready to pray or “take on " anybody at football. When they left Eton the pair hired a room for which they paid £12 a year, and started a school in London. They had all night prayer meetings and they worked among the Covent Garden porters and flower girls. Think of that and then remember that these two young men were mainly responsible for organising football matches in London under the title of England and Scotland. These were the germs which produced the greatest of all International struggles. The Hon. Arthur Kinnaird played in the informal and the officially recognised matches. As a young man he was frequently playingfootball-two or three matches a week—and he did not hesitate to assist the boys of the London Polytechnic when 45 years of age. Moreover, he had the honour of scoring in that match.
AMID CHANCE UNCHANGING.
The Mint that should be insisted upon is that he joined the commutes of the Football Association in 1868, a year after his first match with the Wanderers, an Old Boys’ club that five times won the Association Cup. Thus from 1863 to 1923 he was a governor of the game. In all its transformations and vicissitudes he remained staunch. There was no aloofness about Lord Kinnaird. He determined to assist in the legislation for the control professionalism, which he saw could not be prevented or stopped. His devotion to modern football has always appealed to thoughtful men. If all those who are pious, well bred, and well-educated are to withdraw their presence, patronage, and participation in sport directly the professional appears and finds a place, then heaven help the sports and pastimes any country. The late Lord Kinnaird was convinced that sport could not be divorced from the social, the moral, and the religious sides of life. He stood up manfully for the young man and his games. The players of games had a champion in him just as much as the ploughmen of Perthshire. This side of his noble character should appeal to his equals in pedigree, in rank, and opportunity for service to the community. The homily finished.
SECOND TO NONE.
On December 25, 1916, this column was devoted to a sketch of Lord Kinnaird as a player. A Summary of it may be reproduced, as during the war some of our readers may not have had the opportunity to see it. After being at Cheam School he proceeded to Eton, and began his football in the Michaelmas term of 861. He played in every position, and going on to Trinity College, Cambridge, was the captain of the team, but he was not among the football Blues, for the inter-university Association match was not instituted until March 30, 1874, but in 1868 and 1869 he played “the king of games and the game of kings,” royal tennis, for Cambridge University with R. D. Balfour, and was never beaten in the singles. In Soccer he played for all kinds of teams, and assisted London to beat Sheffieldat Battersea Park on March 31, 1866, the first representative game ever played. As a member of the Wanderers he helped them to win the Association Cup in 1873 against Oxford University, in 1877 against the Oxonians, and in 1878 against the Royal Engineers. For the Old Etonians he was among the victors against the Rovers in 1879, and yet again 1882 he helped them to conquer Blackburn Rovers'. Between 1873 and 1883 he took part in nine final ties, three for the Wanderers and six for the Etonians, and was five times on the winning side. In many respects this record is unique. The founder of the Old Etonian club was invariably either on the ball or in pursuit of it. The finest forward of his era, he would play in goal or at half back if the necessity arose. “The Football Annual” of 1871 summed him up thus; “Second to none at any part of the game. A good forward, never away from the ball, keen player, very fast, knows how and when to use his speed, possesses consummate judgement; is a good and safe back.” It was meet that fine a man and so great a player should become the president of the Association in1891. Meet and proper became in this same old Annual it is said of the Association: “Its policy is liberal.” Surely liberality, in every sense of the word, was the characteristic of chieftain we mourn.

EVERTON F.C. CAPTAIN GETS SEVEN DAYS
The Liverpool Echo-Tuesday, February 6, 1923
FOTOBALL SUSPENSION
Hunter Hart, the Everton F.C captain has received seven days’ suspension as a result of his affair in the cup-tie at Bradford.

HUNTER HART SUSPENDED
February 7, 1923. The Liverpool Daily Post and Mercury.
Hunter Hart, the Everton captain has been suspended for seven days as the result of the incident in the cup-tie at Bradford, where he was order off the field, he will not be available for the match against Chelsea on Saturday

BEE’S NOTES
The Liverpool Echo-Wednesday, February 7, 1923
The match at Goodison Park on Saturday is a very important one, as it shows Goodison people their first view of Cock against his old club members, and Troup and McBain making their bow. Hart is not eligible for this game, so the team reads;- Harland; Raitt, Downs; Peacock, McBain, Grenyer; Chedgzoy, Irvine, Cock, Williams, Troup
Everton reserves at Villa Park;- Fern; Caddick, Livingstone; Jeffs, Fleetwood, Reid; Parry, Miller, Forbes, Chadwick, and Harrison.
I learn that Birmingham have taken a fancy to a young Everton forward who came from Ireland.

THE FIRST APPEARANCE OF McBAIN AND TROUP AT EVERTON’S GROUND
The Liverpool Echo- Friday, February 9, 1923
THE VISIT OF CHELSEA
Bee’s Notes
We shall be glad to see Everton to-morrow, for it is a case of Cock v Chelsea, with McBain intervening! Chelsea have come on lumps in recent times, and their attack, through Armstrong’s appearance at centre, has been all changed. We do not readily forget how well he and others of his side played against Liverpool at Anfield and in town. Now tomorrow the Chelsea match becomes extra-ordinarily engrossing because we find Cock pitted against his old side, and the local folk will be able to see Neil, McBain and Troup for the first time. Troup I have seen in internationals, and I know him to be a dandy player-an artist on the touch line, and a man with a shot. McBain, too, we know by his “fruits” and by his international records-he is one of the toughest players I know. So when the Scottish regiment lines up tomorrow one will be sorry that Hunter Hart is not present. However, his time is short, and we shall be glad to see him back again. Meanwhile all Everton is agog with ideas of what the team is going to do. Some look pessimistic, forgetting that there are so many other sides so much worse than Everton that really to all intents and purposes Everton are safe for the season. However, it is such a long time since the Goodison Park side was in evidence that we look to them to-morrow to bring out their best and revive the fallen hopes. Certainly the Goodison Park people will always attended in force to see new players, and in McBain and Troup they strike absolutely at the Goodison Park. Therefore there is sure to be a big gathering of the clans when the following sides will turn put; Everton; Harland; Raitt, Downs; Peacock, McBain, Grenyer; Chedgzoy, Irvine, Cock, Williams, Troup. Chelsea; Hampton; Smith (G), Harrow; Wilding, Cameron, Meechan; Linfoot, Ford, Armstrong, Priestly, McNeil.

JOE PEACOCK
February 10, 1923. The Liverpool Daily Post and Mercury.
Joe Peacock right half has sustained a sad bereavement in the death of his mother and Fleetwood will fill his place.

ALL EVERTON’S NEW MEN OUT AGAINST CHELSEA
The Liverpool Echo- February 10, 1923
Stork Notes
Everton have had a rest, for although they have played a friendly game, hey have taken things easily, and will turn out this afternoon as fresh as paint. It will be interesting to see how John E. Cock performs against his former clubmates Chelsea. It is usual, in nine cases out of ten, for players to do well against their old club, and Cock will be keenness itself to show what a good man he is. McBain makes his first appearance before the Everton spectators as also does Troup. Let me tell you that McBain is a great centre half-back. I have seen several of his displays at the Manchester United ground, and I was impressed with his intelligent passes and clever tackling. McBain should fit into the Everton half-back line without any trouble whatever. I am told that Troup greatly impressed the critics at Stoke and Stockport. Today we shall judge the new men for ourselves. The Londoner’s attack, although showing signs of improvement, are not by any means a great quintet. They have scored just as many goals as their defence have allowed to go into their own net. In the matter of goals they have a better record than Everton, for the latter have a debit of 41 goals, while their forwards have only scored 34. Wilding, formerly a centre half back, has been drafted into the centre forward berth. He is built on big lines, and will keep McBain busy. The defence of the Southerners is a particularly good one, and Everton will find it hard to break down. One thing is Everton’s favour is that their opponents have had a strenuous mid-week game and may be suffering a little from leg weariness. Everton, in their last game here, showed the way to get goals, only to disappoint a week later. If Everton will only shoot often, and as hard as they can, I fancy they will win. To have shot and missed is better than to shots at all. Teams;- Everton; Harland; Raitt, Downs; Fleetwood, McBain, Grenyer; Chedgzoy, Irvine, Cock, Williams, and Troup. Chelsea; Hampton; Smith, Harrow; Priestly, Cameron, Meehan; Bell, Ford, Wilding, Sharp and McNeil.

BEE’S NOTES
The Liverpool Football Echo- Saturday, February 10, 1923
“Shareholders” protests against the Everton directors’ manner of selecting teams and treating of players, and also; “What is their explanation of changing Hart and Fleetwood from their right positions, where their respective displays were excellent, to other positions where neither excelled to the same extent.” Also, taking Peacock away from the forward ranks when he was developing into a very useful man as an inside right, was surely a bad move,

TROUP AND McBAIN HELP IN VICTORY
The Liverpool Football Echo- Saturday, February 10, 1923
“BEE” SAYS WILDING IS NO CENTRE AND THAT EVERTON’S NEW BROOMS SWEPT CLEAN AND PLAYED WELL
A WELCOME 3-1 WIN FOR THE “BLUES”
Everton; Harland; Raitt, Downs; Fleetwood, McBain, Grenyer; Chedgzoy (Captain), Irvine, Cock, Williams, Troup. Chelsea; Hampton; Smith (G), Harrow; Priestly, Cameron, Meehan; Bell, Ford, Wilding, Sharpe, McNeil. McBain, Troup, Cock-these were the main men of the Everton side at Walton to-day, when Chelsea paid their respects and put the big man Wilding at centre forward. It was McBain and Troup’s first appearance at home, and there would have been a massive crowd to see them but for the bad conditions of the morning. There would be about 23,000 spectators present, and much interest was centred in the new faces and the men concerned must have been pleased with their reception. Will they “make” Everton? That was the question. Fleetwood came into the side through Peacock suffering a severe bereavement. When Chedgzoy lost the toss the air was muggy. Howard Baker was amongst the spectators. The first point of play was an attempted clearance by Downs, the ball hitting Wilding, and Harland had to clear. Chelsea came a second time, and Downs made a long dive on to the ball and missed it, only to find that offside had been sounded. Chelsea passed back quite a number of times to their goalkeeper, and for a while there was nothing between the sides.
THE NEW MEN TO THE FORE
When McBain made a lovely dribble the crowd gave him a warm reception, and the movement led to the other new member,Troup, also coming into the “limelight." Thanks to Chedgzoy crossing the ball, Cock failing to back-ankle it, and to Troup making a first time drive towards goal. Hampton smothered the ball at the corner of the goal. Chelsea were not going to stand on this, and then Bell made a drive it required the best that Harland could do to prevent the ball entering the net. Moreover, Harland kept presession, in spite of a charge. Chelsea came a further time and Sharpe headed over the bar. It was nice, clean, and good football, and nothing was better than the work of Troup, who was dead on the mark and had some typically Scottish methods.
A TOUCH OF THE PICTURESQUE
Troup not only drove in after dainty dribbles—he was on the touchline when he raised his ankle and by swinging his foot round, brought off a spectacular effort, the like of which is not seen nowadays in 20 years in English football. Hampton was quite safe with cross shots, and also with a long effort by Raitt, and the match yielded more shooting in the first 20 minutes than has been seen for many a moon on any ground. Ford made three lovely drives, the first, the best of the lot, being caught by Harland, who jumped up. After these efforts, a header by Sharpe, a shot by Wilding that hit the corner flag, a good run by Meehan, and Williams and Hampton on the ground together two yards out of goal, the goalkeeper finding relief by throwing behind the line for a corner, and you will get some idea of the evenness of the game and the practicability of both sides.
PRIESTLY CAUTIONED
McBain set Troup in his charming manner, and when the ball was centred to goal Cock seemed sure to open the score with a header, but Hampton 's hand prevented this. Chelsea's forwards played a nice open game, and only sure defence by Raitt and Downs kept their dangerous looking moves from succeeding. Even Smith, the full back, tried a shot at goal. His partner, Harrow, who took all the throws in near his half had a hot time looking after Chedgzoy and Co., and Priestley brought down Troup in such a way that he was cautioned by Referee Pinkston. The free kick that resulted led to Cock hitting against the crossbar and Priestley clearing the rebound. Chelsea were short for some time of Ford, whose right ankle bothered him so much that he had to leave.
GOAL BY SHARPE
Chedgzoy was responsible for one of the funniest incidents of the game. He took a half chance with a centre on the touchline and lashed the ball straight up about 30 feet. As the ball came down Chedgzoy made a first-time half-volley centre, but the ball had, in its first aerial passed out of play. McBain made a nice straight drive that wassaved, and Ford returning to the field, made a header that caught. Then came a blow to the home side. On the right wing Bell slipped across a long  centre, and Sharpe, running pell -mell, headed the ball through Harland’s defence, and so great was the force of the run that Sharpe ran out of the field of play and pitched his face against the stump that supports the goal-nets.
COCK EQUALISES.
Fortunately, he recovered and in 6 minutes (that is 41) Cock equalised against his old club. Cock got his chance through bad defence on the part of the Chelsea backs, and immediately after Hampton had punched away from Williams. Cock very lucky indeed to get such a comfortable chance, but it was a sweet goal to him.  In this half Irvine and Downshad been indefinite. Frank Mitchell, the Liverpool goalkeeper, has to-day seen a specialist, who says that the arm is progressing splendidly.
Half-time; Everton 1, Chelsea 1
ALEC WALL’S HOPE
Alec Wall, who broke his leg some time ago tells me that the injury is going on nicely, and he hopes to and believes he can play next season. The air was much clearer in the second half, and the sun shone. Although Grenyer was limping, he was able once again to show the value of his head when corners were being taken.
WILLIAMS CHEERS UP THE CROWD
Raitt passed back as if in a dream. The referee spoke to Cameron, who was inclined to argue, so McNeil intervened. Then Williams made the score 2-1 at the fifty-third minute, to the joy of nearly 40,000 spectators. Chelsea were unwise to stop play and cry offside, as when the ball was last played Williams was on side. Williams did not lose control of the ball or wisdom when he was faced by a goalkeeper and a back. He hit a fierce ball high up to the back netting. This was a good goal. Ford, with a drive to equalise matters, and when Bell recovered from a knee injury he made a twisting, turning run and thoroughly out-paced Downs. However, when he cried “Bellows to mend,” he very foolishly shot instead of giving an unmarked partner a golden chance. Cock was near scoring through fanciful defence on the part of Chelsea, and when Hampson was injured. The stalwart figure that attended him was none other than Jack Whitley, who used to keep goal for Everton. The crowd just loved Troup, and called for him to be served. He was a very willing worker, and in appearance was like Jimmy Settle in his thinner days.
CHELSEA TIRING
Wilding was useless as a centre, and all the sparkle had gone out of Chelsea when Williams fired over the bar and Chedgzoy put a ball to land. The real truth was that Chelsea were tiring through mid-week Cup-tie game. Fleetwood, who looked to be seriously damaged came up as fresh as paint when he had the cold douche. Sharp, badly angled, made a difficult ball for Harland, and Downs was picturesque in his famous diving scene. One wondered indeed why he did not use his boot, and save his hair. Hampton made yet another fine save from Irvine.
A GIFT GOAL FOR CHEDGZOY
The Everton victory was complete when the daddy of the side Troup made a pass full of sense to Cock, who sense to Cock, who unselfishly passed to Chedgzoy, after rounding a full back, and gave the acting captain a gift goal at the 80th minute. Before the finish Hampton was hurt in the chest, yet was able to make a save from McBain. Final; Everton 3, Chelsea 1.

ASTON VILLA RES v  EVERTON RES
The Liverpool Football Echo-Saturday, January 10, 1923
At Villa Park. Everton had the better of the first half, and Forbes gave them the lead after a good dribble, in which he beat four opponents. Everton held the upper hand till the interval. Half-time; Aston Villa Res 0, Everton Res 1.
At seven minutes from time, Brown made the score equal from a centre from Crapper.
Final; Aston Villa Res 1, Everton Res 2

THE REAL TROUP.
Dundee Courier - Monday 12 February 1923
An English critic, writing on the Everton- Chelsea game, says: —Troup, the little outside left from Dundee, who made fame on the soddened pitch at Hillsborough the memorable international match of 1920, pranced along the touch-line in style that promises much good sport for the patrons of Goodison Park. All his work was polished and precise, and Priestley and Smith (G.) could never hold him. He varied his method of attack, centred accurately, shot strongly, and rarely placed the ball behind. In the opening minutes he sent in two great shots, each of which sent Hampton, the Chelsea goalkeeper, full length in the mud.

TROUP'S SUCCESSFUL DEBUT FOR EVERTON.
Dundee Evening Telegraph - Monday 12 February 1923
Outstanding Forward Against Chelsea.;
Alick Troup, the ex-Dundee forward, made his debut before the Everton crowd on Saturday, when Chelsea were the visitors. He splendid account of himself, and, in addition to being the best forward the field, had share in two of the three goals scored by his side. The Sporting Chronicle says:— Troup "was a sheer delight, and the 40,000 people became positively vexed when was kept out of work for a few minutes. Troup 'did most things bright and effervescing way, but in all things he was practical. For instance, he made three drives at goal as in many minutes, which is uncommon for extreme winger, but Troup was justified all he did. He back-heeled the ball, used his ankle to move it, diddled, dallied for a while, and dribbled to effect.  He was an excellent exhibition of football, full of personality and skill and wisdom in the winning side, Troup was the star."

EVERTON 3 CHELSEA 1
February 12, 1923. The Liverpool Courier.
EVERTON ON THE UP GRADE
NEW RECRUITS SHINE.
By F. M. N.
Even allowing for the fact that Chelsea appeared somewhat cup tired in the second half, Everton's victory at Goodison park gave their supporters sufficient indication of their improvement compared with the form of the side in their previous League game at Stoke, and I fully expect that when the new men thoroughly settle down to the style of their colleagues the Everton club will make headway. Certainly the performance on Saturday was mightily encouraging, and better times are, I believe, in store. There could be no two opinions with regard to the ability of Troup, who at once stalled himself a warm favourite by reason of his virile shooting, accurate passing, and dainty dribbles. Troup is undoubtedly an acquisition to the team, and with more support he is bound to make a big impression.
TROUP'S SUCCESS.
The little Scot did not receive the attention from his partner he merited, but at the same time he thrilled the onlookers with his dainty work, and they clamoured for the ball to be out to the left. With the proverbial power and accuracy behind his shots, one foresees that Troup will soon figure among the club's goal scorers. McBain, too, created a goal impression on his first appearance at Goodison Park. The ex-Manchester United man has played better, but one must allow for the fact that he was in strange company. That he, is fully acquitted with the requirement of the position was made plain, his constructive game being strong, and he showed defensive power which promises to develop on further acquaintance with his colleagues. In viewing McBain display, it should be remembered that he has been absent from competition football for several weeks, and was naturally somewhat out of touch. But McBain will prove his worth in the future. Cock had the great satisfaction of scoring a goal and paving the way for another against his old club, and on the whole the centre forward had a good share of the victory. He kept his partners well supplied with passes, and he swung the ball out to the wings with precision, but one would like to see more of his shooting power.
HARLAND'S FINE SAVE.
So much for a new en. But the team as a whole played well. Harland was at his best in goal, the Irishman saving several fine shots when Chelsea were at their best in the first half, and his safe catching and prompt clearances inspired confidence. Downs and Raitt gave a rather mixed display, flashes of brilliance being followed by faulty work, and when it came to a race, the ex-Barnsley man's lack of pace was apparent. Grenyer and Fleetwood ploughed through the heavy going very effectively, and Williams, Irvine, and Chedgzoy played their parts in a welcome victory.

PACE THAT KILLED.
Chelsea contested every inch of the way in the first half, but they tried perceptibly in the second portion, and had quite enough of it at the finish. Prominent players on the side were Ford, Bell, Meehan, McNeil, and Hampson, the latter making some smart saves. It need only be added that Sharp and Cock scored in the first half, and Williams and Chedgzoy in the second portion. Sharp, in opening the score for Chelsea, tripped over the net peg, and fell headlong, but fortunately was not seriously injured. Teams: - Everton: - Harland, goal, Raitt, and Downs, backs, Fleetwood (captain), McBain, and Grenyer, half-backs, Chedgzoy, Irvine, Cock, Williams, and Troup, forwards. Chelsea: - Hampson, goal, G. Smith, and Harrow, backs, Priestley, Cameron, and Meehan half-backs, Bell, Ford, Wilding, Sharp, and McNeil, forwards.

ASTON VILLA RESERVES 1 EVERTON RESERVES 2
February 12, 1923. The Liverpool Daily Post and Mercury
CENTRAL LEAGUE (Game 28)
Everton's success at Villa Park was mainly due to the visitors adapting themselves better to the heavy conditions and displaying superior combination in their forward work. In the opening half they were far ahead of their opponents, Forbes's goal resulting from a capital dribble. The Everton forwards often got the Villa defence in a tangle, it being remarkable how the home goal survived. The second half opened with a revival on the part of the villa, but after Stephenson had equalised from a penalty, the result of a foul by Livingstone, the Everton defence got the measure of the home forwards, and had no difficulty in beating off the attacks. Everton's winning goal was a gift affair, Jackson, the villa goalkeeper failing to accomplished an easy save. Nevertheless the Villa goal frame was struck on several occasions in the latter half. Forbes, Parry, and Virr were dangerous, Everton raiders, while Fern and Livingstone were the outstanding players in the defence. The visitors excelled in all departments, while the Villa who were best represented by the half-backs, were never allowed to become assertive.

EVERTON REVIVE
Athletic News- Monday, February 12, 1923
TROUP LEADS THE WAY TO CHELSEA’S DOWNFALL
By Junius
With N. McBain in the League team for the first time. Everton have conquered Chelsea at Goodison Park.  Possibly they had an advantage in so far as Chelsea had participated in a strenuous Cup-tie in midweek, and during the second half the home forwards cut out the pace and, with the exception of a few spasmodic bursts by the visitors, practically took full control of the game. There was a marked contrast in the play during the first and second portions. In the opening stage Chelsea quite held their own, and by opening out the play obtained the first goal. This came after the game had been in progress thirty-six minutes, Bell driving high past Raitt for Sharp to head the ball into the far corner of the net. Five minutes later Cock, who had moved into the inside position, cleverly gathered the ball from Troup, when but a few yards out, and placed his side on level terms. After the resumption Everton gradually got a grip on the game which they never relaxed, and after ten minutes they forged ahead. This success came about through Smith appealing for offside, while Williams went on to score with a fierce drive that sailed under the bar. Chelsea were this time a thoroughly beaten team, and their discomfiture was complete, when Troup, who had dropped back among the defenders, drove a long ball up to Cock, who was unmarked. The erstwhile Chelsea centre after a capital sprint took no risk at the finish, and passed to Chedgzoy, who, from six yards range and unchallenged, completed the scoring.
Troup's Captivating Exhibition.
From this brief recital of the salient features it will be gathered that Everton were good value for their success. Priestley was no match for Troup, who quite captivated the spectators by his clever, yet easy command of the ball. In the early stages he was the outstanding Everton forward, and, in addition, knew where the goal lay. He kept the ball low and centred at anice height, while his display generally made for the strengthening of the Everton attack, His work was at all times practical. The other newcomer, McBain, was a very capable centre half-back, playing quietly but watchfully, and placing the ball to advantage. He had an eye also to finishing touches, and Hampton did well to arrest two strong surprise drives. Chedgzoy was methodical, combining with Irvine to outwit Meehan, who started well enough, but, like his middle line comrades, did not maintain good his good form.
Chelsea’s Danger Spots.
Bell, fast and able to cover much ground, was always a source of danger, for he swung over centres of splendid length which frequently asked for conversion. Ford was the strongest in direct shooting, and his efforts frequently called for Harland’s best work. Cook dribbled well and closely, with a good understand with Williams and Irvine, and Wilding compared unfavourably with him. Wild lunges goal wards were his contributions to the visitors’ attack, which on the whole was limp. Downs was not at his best, many of his returns going Into touch, while he frequently found Bell more than he could manage. Raitt was the more dependable back, but even he found the right wing troublesome, and once, when he passed strongly back to Harland, he came near to recording a goal against his side. Chelsea’s defence, harassed again and again, palpably tired, and it was left for Hampton to stand between the Everton forwards and a crop goals. Everton; Harland; Raitt, Downs; Fleetwood, McBain, Grenyer; Chedgzoy (Captain), Irvine, Cock, Williams, and Troup. Chelsea; Hampton; Smith, Harrow; Priestly, Cameron, Meechan; Bell, Ford, Wilding, Sharp and McNeill. Referee E. Pinckston, Birmingham.

TROUP’S DELIGHTFUL GAME AND McBAIN’S IDEAS
The Liverpool Echo, Monday, February 12, 1923
TROUP -A CAMEO
Bee’s Notes
There is a touch of Jimmy Settle about Troup that I cannot get out of my mind. Perhaps it is because he entices the opponent to come at him, because he hugs the ball, because he does things in an unusual way, because he has an old-fashioned style, and in the personal touch he is the livest thing we have had on the left wing since Harold Hardman used to wing it in a  ferocious way and pick up trifles that the average pro, would not even go for. Troup is a footballer. I had advices from a friend of his and mine in Dundee weeks before he came here that he wanted to come away, and that he would do Everton a power of good. In my own view I wanted to see why there was need for anyone other than Reid or Harrison, for the former has played consistently well all through the season when he has appeared with the first team. However, no one can deny that Troup’s very enlivening display on Saturday must have an effect upon the whole side, and that we have yearned for a similar style of practical football for a long time. Troup has come to stay, and one hopes he will continue to travel on the same lines. Everton will never lack big crowds if that sort of football is served.
McBAIN -A CAMEO
Here’s another cameo. And another brither Scot, I refer McBain who played so well on Saturday without showing anyone any advertising tricks or even suggesting that he was using up his energy. He played a grand game. I doubt not that some of the 40,000 spectators will disagree, but I was most careful to note all he did- concentrating on his effort-and I found that only twice did he fail to deliver the pass he intended. That should be the key-note of all centre half-backs when they have got the ball, but, unfortunately, it is not so. McBain may not be a rousing, bustling tackler, but there can be no two minds about his shooting ability and his knowledge of the game and the need of a pass upward or to the wings. He is not big, as height goes, but he is the stocky sort that is fashioned after Downs and such. Cock, another practical newcomer, was all out for dribbles and draught like movements. He makes a move, points to where he wants to have the ball put for him, and is a trifle slow to get to most of the passes. However, his unselfishness is undoubted, and his passes are kept turf-high, for which many thanks. One would like him to hit out, to open his shoulders as it were, and box the ball to the goal boundary. A mixed metaphor-but you know what I mean. Which reminds me that on Saturday an operator cut into my wire to the office, asked the score, and then said, “Oh, I say. Glad to tell you I have kept out a fine draught through stopping it up with your notebook.” I replied, “Well, thank goodness some good has come out of the notes at last!” I have specially gone into Everton’s new players, because they are new and costly. It must not be thought that I overlook Harland’s fine goalkeeping, Raitt’ sure touch, Chedgzoy’s spurts, Irvine’s endeavour, or Grenyer’s forward play, Fleetwood’s doggedness, and hearty display with Troup of one Williams.

ALEX WALL
Hull Daily Mail - Tuesday 13 February 1923
Wall, the Everton half-back who sustained a broken leg recently, is making excellent progress towards recovery, and hopes to be able to play again next season. 

EVERTON NEWS
The Liverpool Echo-Tuesday, February 13, 1923
Bee’s Notes
Everton’s team for Chelsea to-morrow is the same as on Saturday with the exception that Peacock resumes in place of Fleetwood and Hart in place of Grenyer. After the match the players will stop the night in London and proceed the following day to Redcar, on the East Coast, for a bracer prior to meeting Middlesbrough on Saturday. The Chelsea team will be; Hampton; Smith, Harrow; Priestley, Cameron, Meehan, Bell, Ford, Wilding, Sharp, McNeil.

EVERTON'S TONIC.
February 14, 1923. The Liverpool Courier.
SEASIDE AIR.
After the Chelsea match today, the Everton players will travel direct from London to Redcar, where they will stay until Saturday, when Middlesbrough will be next. No decision has yet been made, in regard to the return match at Goodison Park, which clashes with the Anfield cup-tie. Birmingham have lost ever game they have play this year, Everton if one is to be judge by their scouting operations across the border, have not exhausted their banks balance on new players (writes out Scottish correspondent). McDougall, the Airdrionian centre-half, is now in their eye, but Burnley have also joined in the quest for this capable player.

EVERTON’S NEW YOUNGSTER
The Liverpool Echo-Wednesday, February 14, 1923
EVERTON’S NEW “NATIONAL”
Bee’s Notes
Everton have signed yet another international in the person of Robert Fairfoull, the son of the old Liverpool half back. Fairfoull is a schoolboy international, gaining his “cap” in the season 1920. He also captained the Liverpool schoolboys’ eleven during their very successful season. Robert is a big youth for his years- he is but 16-standing 5ft 10in., and can turn the scale beyond the 10 stone mark. He occupied the same position as his father, that of left half back, and is no stronger to the Goodison ground, on which he has played on many occasions.
EVERTON IN TOWN
Today we go to Chelsea’s ground to see Everton attempt a double. Peacock and Hart return to the side, so that the Walton team will include two Irishman, five Englishmen, and four Scots. I fancy Everton somewhat, because they are now confident and still, as it were, “playing for their places.” London people are keen to know how Jack Cock is playing.

CHELSEA V EVERTON
The Liverpool Echo- Wednesday, February 14, 1923
“BEE” TAKEN FOR REFEREE IN RETURN MATCH
STAMFORD BRIDGE, Wednesday. Afternoon.
London was damp, cold, wet, and foggy, and half an hour before the game started the club was looking out for a referee. In fact, I was accused of being that official, and pleaded “Not guilty,” with thanks. There were about 8—spectators present; the teams were;- Everton; Harland; Raitt, Downs; Peacock, McBain, and Hart (Captain); Chedgzoy, Irvine, Cock, Williams, and Troup. Chelsea; Hampton; Smith, Harrow; Priestley, Frew, and Meeham; Linfoot, Ford, Armstrong, Sharp, and McNeill. Inside the ground were a few ambulance cases, two pressmen, some other “dead-heads,” and the grand band of the Irish Guards. The light was bad, and some parts of the ground were ankle-deep in mud. Still, the course was playable. Frew, for Cameron, was the only Chelsea change. “Good old Jack!” shouted the Londoners, and they even took photographs of the former Chelsea idol as though he was a stranger in the land.
“BRISK STARS.”
In one minute Ford had scored. Everton had started on the right with a promising movement that looked full of danger until the ball cannoned against Cock. This opened out the way for Meeham, and when he passed to McNeill, who seemed very like offside, a centre was crossed by the left-winger, and Ford was unmarked. He headed to the worst possible place viz., to Harland’s left hand. But Harland was apparently stuck in a mud patch, and when he spread-eagled his legs the ball passed over them. It was a sensational opening, and Chelsea was deeply encouraged by the access. Cock very cleverly plied Williams a pass, only to find another player given offside. It was surprising how well Everton played, which they did more up-field, Williams, Cock, and Chedgzoy combining finely, and McBain, pretending to pass to the extreme left, hooked the ball to the extreme right. However, Irvine was dispossessed because he did not shoot first time. Everton made their most dangerous raid thus far in a curious way. Hart puzzled with the ball on the touch line, and the linesman very wrongly half flagged and then told the players to play on. Hart did so, and when he gave Troup a pass the little man hit a ferocious ball to goal, and Hampton did well to smother it. While the goalkeeper was on the ground he was harried and carried, but did not release his grip. Everton certainly played pretty and effective football, and when Chedgzoy centred hard and strong towards goal, Hampton went too far forward, and was very thankful that when he jumped his fingertips just edged the ball out of the way.
EVERTON GET NEAR
It was as near a thing as I have seen. |Keeping up the good work Everton went away again through Chedgzoy, and when he gave Troup a run for half the length of the field the “Scottie” offered Cock such a chance as Cock offered to Chedgzoy last Saturday when Chedgzoy got the first goal. Cock started to dribble instead of shooting, and half lost the ball. Irvine tried to make amends by hitting a low drive, the strength of which nearly forced Hampton over his goal line. Williams was also unlucky when he followed up, the ball skidding into touch. So pressed were the Chelsea men that Ford had to help the defence, and kick out of play. Everton were playing right on top of the Londoners now, and one was sorry that Chedgzoy at this point did not go straight ahead instead of dodging. Ford was again the dangerous man in front of goal, and when he sent Linfoot up the field Downs stabbed the ball back and earned the applause of those who could see the incident.
WILLIAMS EQUALISES
It was no surprise that Williams scored in twenty-three minutes. Everton were every bit worth the divider. They got a free kick for something we in the Press-stand could not see, and when Smith faltered Williams made sure, although it must be registered that he dribbled the ball back before the shot. However, there was never a doubt about the result, because Williams had time to consider everything and he had only the goalkeeper to beat. Half-time Chelsea 1, Everton 1.

CHELSEA 3 EVERTON 1
February 15, 1923, The Liverpool Courier.
EVERTON'S BAD LUCK AT CHELSEA.
BEATEN AFTER LOSING TWO MEN.
DOWNS IN GOAL AND CONCEDS TWO GOALS.IN LAST TWENTY MINUTES
By F.M.N.
It was a distinctly unlucky day for Everton at Stamford Bridage yesterday when the Goodison Club were beaten by 3 goals to 1 after giving a skilful display on a muddy ground. Misfortune dogged their footsteps from the start, and in the end they finished with nine men. Harland, being assisted off the field in the second half with a dislocated thumb and Williams retiring with damaged ribs. But for these mishaps, Everton would not have finished on the wrong side. Williams sustained his injuries a few minutes after the interval and was of little use afterwards, though he tried his best at outside left with Troup on the inside. However, ten minutes from the end, he retired altogether. It was some time before this that Harland in going down full length to a ball with three Chelsea forwards close at hand, sustained his hurt, which proved to be rather serious. The goalkeeper was in great pain as he was led from the field, and when I saw him in the dressing room after the match, it was plain to see that he had a severe shaking. Downs kept goal during the last 20 minutes, when the Pensioners forced the victory.
MIST AND MUD.
London, and the country generally, was enveloped in mist, and though it cleared somewhat half an hour before the game, there was some doubt about a start being made as the ground was very heavy indeed. The ruling official, when he arrived, at once went on to the playing pitch and decided that the match should go on. At one time in the second half the fog became much more dense, and it seemed possible that the game would not be finished, even though the players did not leave the field as the interval, but the referee was able to follow the ball if many of the spectators could not, and a full 90 minutes was played. Everton sustained a shock in the first minute as McNeil and his colleagues combined finely, and from the outside left's centre Ford headed into the net. Harland failing to get to the ball with his left hand. This set back might have been calculated to upset many teams, but Everton played fine football afterwards, the halves and forwards working together very smoothly indeed. It was no more then they deserved when Williams taking the ball from a free kick, and cleverly beating Harrow, drove the leather into the net to score a capital equalising goal.
DOWNS IN GOAL.
Turning round immediately at the interval, Everton, as I have said, were badly handicapped by Williams being hurt. Still the Blues had the better of the argument, but enjoyed little luck near goal. Then, when the accident to the custodian further weakened the side, Downs beaten by Armstrong from a corner, and just before the finish Sharp scored a third goal. It was certainly not Everton's day, and Chelsea must consider themselves extremely fortunate to gain the points. Teams:- Chelsea: - Hampton goal, Smith, and Harrow, backs,. Priestley, Rew, and Meehan, half-backs, Meehan, Ford, Armstrong, Sharp, and McNeil, forwards. Everton: - Harland, goal, Raitt and Downs, backs, Peacock, McBain, and Hart (captain), half-backs, Chedgzoy, Irvine, Cock, Williams, and Troup, forwards.

GROSS LUCK FOR EVERTON PLAYERS
The Liverpool Echo- Thursday, February 15, 1923
Bee’s Notes
There is something tragically unlucky about Everton this season, and yesterday the limit point was reached. First there was a sign of no match through bad conditions, and when an official came out of the ground and suggested that I should go and inspect the pitch as I might not permit play, I had to say to him; “If I referee the game will be over in ten minutes and there’ll only be one winner- I daren’t  go back to Liverpool without a victory.” Little did I think then that Everton would be so well on top of their rivals and still fail 3-1, the score they won by at Goodison Park. The circumstances were very much different, but there was one thing in common. You remember how Hampton was hurt on the chest, and you perhaps remember that I had something to say on Monday about those cases where by no means could the goalkeeper be dispossessed yet was kicked at by forwards-well, a second case occurred yesterday at Stamford Bridge, and Harland was so badly hurt -his thumb was knocked right up-that he was unconscious for some time and had to be taken to St. George’s Hospital. More than that Williams was so hurt in the first moments of the second half that he and Troup had to swop places, and the outcome was that with nine men (Downs in goal) Chelsea went on to win a game that seemed well out of their reach.
THE TURNING POINT
It was just after the half-way that the turning-point came. Williams was brought down outside the penalty area, and got a bump for his trouble. There were other bumps. Meehan taking a fancy to Chedgzoy’s ankle and Peacock going a roaming right over to inside life found his march ended by a hefty bump that he will feel to-day when he and the boys make the journey to Redcar. That was a minor blow compared with what happened when Harland left the field with the score 1-1 and the game played by Everton such that one expected Hampton and Harrow to compound any moment. There could be no two opinions as to how the game was going. Everton had Chelsea in difficulties and on a ground that did not lend itself to good play they were playing ideal football, although there were times, of course, when the ball was not kicked sufficiently hard and stuck in the mud.
CHELSEA’S EARLY GOAL
At the outset Chelsea scored a goal through Ford heading a centre by McNeil, both Armstrong and McNeill being objected to without avail on the score of offside. So early a goal- it came in one minute -on such a turf would ordinarily have been sufficient to win a game, but Everton for the remainder of the half formed good attacks, and if Cock had been hitting the ball first-time the equaliser would have come earlier than 23 minutes. Williams then took advantage of a free kick to equalise. Chelsea brought in Frew at centre half back. No one knew anything about him, and could not tell why Cameron had been deposed. Wilding after the trial match was rested, and Frew played a very useful game, although he had not a great deal to do, because Cock did not act too well on the heavy turf, as is often the case with big-built men, who are not able to twist and turn in a second. Perhaps Cock felt the presence of his former admirers. When a new player appears against his old club he does one of two things- plays well, and shows his old side what they have missed, or is self-conscious and does not do himself justice. I think that Cock was in the latter category yesterday.
GOOD FORM
However, there is no doubt that the whole Everton side played quite well until fate placed them at a disadvantage. The attack had a nice way with it; there was much good passing and much swinging of the ball about to unexpected quarters, notably when McBain, aiming apparently at the left wing, turned his toe and sent the ball to Chedgzoy. Moreover, Irvine played better than on Saturday, and was very dogged all through. On the left wing, Williams had played a good-class game, and had fared better than at any period since the first month of the season. Therefore it was unfortunate that he and Troup had to change places through the former’s injury. Troup could not produce his lovely runs as on the previous meeting, but he managed to find a way to shoot, and keeping the ball low, he tested Hampton with fine shots more than once. Chedgzoy, too, did many good things, and if he had a fault it was his desire to dribble on awkward patches. In the half back line, Hart was not suited to the heavy going, and McBain did not stand out boldly, as did Peacock. However, all the line in turn helped the ball to their forwards, and in that matter they deserved praise. At full back Downs started by making an error of judgement in attempting a dribble. However, he did such valiant work afterwards, notably when Everton were undergoing a lot of pressure through corner kicks, that one had to forgive him this excess of confidence. Raitt found McNeil a hard customer, but he and Peacock did very well against the Scotchman and his partner. Chelsea’s best were Harrow, Hampton and Meehan. Armstrong was strangely ineffective in view of his recent form, notably in the games against Liverpool.
AMONG THE DIRECTORS
Fern will join the party at Redcar for the Middlesbrough game, and one wonders what next stroke of ill-luck will befall a side that is playing good football. Even the officials seem to be struck-did not one director “Wade” into his single ticket, believing it was a return ticket, and tear it? Some said he was trying to make a single into a double. Fie!
HARLAND NOW CONSCIOUS AND IMPROVING
Harland, the Everton goalkeeper in a London hospital, had the following bulletin this afternoon; “Harland’s general condition shows no change, but he is now conscious.”

ROBERT FAIRCLOUGH
February 16, 1923. The Liverpool Daily Post and Mercury.
Everton have signed on as an amateur Robert Fairfoul, a son of the former Liverpool half-back, who gained a schoolboy international ''cap'' two season ago. Fairfoul who captained the Liverpool schoolboys team during one of their must successful seasons. Is only 16 years of age, but he stands 5ft 10ins and weights over 10 stone

MATCH POSTPONE
Middlesbrough have seceded to Everton request to postpone their league engagement at Goodison Park from Saturday the 24, to the following, Wednesday, on account of the counter attraction at Anfield on the former date in the cup-tie between Liverpool against Sheffield united the arrangement is subject to the sanction of the league management committee.

IRISH INTERNATIONAL INJURED
Northern Whig - Friday 16 February 1923
Alfie Harland, the Irish internationalist and ex-Linfield goalkeeper, was seriously injured while playing for Everton against Chelsea on Wednesday at London.  He dived at the ball and collied with a couple of opponents, sustaining concussion of the brian ad a disclosed thumb.  He was rendered unconscious and was conveyed to hospital, where he is detained.  Chelsea scored two goals after the Everton goalkeeper was carried off, and thus won by 3 goals to 1. 

TOM FERN KEEPS GOAL AT MIDDLESBROUGH
The Liverpool Echo-Friday, February 16, 1923
AGAINST THE ‘BROUGH SIDE
Bee’s Notes
Everton had high hopes that their tours this week would bring them some points that would gladden the hearts of their spectators. However, to date the sole total has been loss of two men through injury, and loss of two points at the moment that two seemed to be coming the way of the Everton club. To-morrow Tom fern keeps goal in place of Harland, who is progressing nicely, and doubtless someone will have to be found to take the place of Williams. To meet Middlesbrough at any moment, at the ‘Brough ground, is an awkward matter, but it must not be forgotten that the ‘Brough are not very confident these days -they have Jock Marshall, Carr (J), Andie Wilson, and others who are not pulling up any trees just now, so that it is quite on the cards that the “Football Echo” report will have a nice surprise result tomorrow. Letsopeso! Matters in the ‘Brough camp are not going at all nicely, and there may be some startling news shortly, although the club is not in the habit of throwing itself at the feet of players who are anxious to move hither and thither, as witness their method of standing out some time ago when Andy Wilson did not want to come back. In truth the Middlesbrough club has been one of the severest. Everton; Fern; Raitt, Downs; Peacock, McBain, Hart; Chedgzoy, Irvine, Cock, Williams, Troup. Middlesbrough; Williams; Holmes, Ellerington; Slade, Webster, Pender; I Carr, Birrell, Donaghy, G. Carr, Murray.

SERIOUS INJURY TO EVERTON'S KEEPER
Dundee Courier - Saturday 17 February 1923
Harland, the Everton goalkeeper, who was removed to St George's Hospital after the game at Stamford Bridge on Wednesday, was so seriously hurt that he was unconscious for a day. He is now rapidly improving.

BLUES TASK AT ARYSOME.
February 17, 1923. The Liverpool Courier
Everton have a severe task on hand in luck that just as a winning team as there are to tackle Middlesbrough, and it is the cruelest-got-together that Harland should be placed hors de combat through injuries. The Irish keeper will be of duty for some time, and are fortunate to have such a reserve for the position as Tom fern, Williams who was also knocked about in the mid-week match at Chelsea, is expected to be able to turn out. With the forward formation intacted, the Blues may snatch a point, for the Arysome Park, organisation will have George Carr absent, and others are doubtful starters.

A FEW WORD’S CONCERNING EVERTON’S NEW MEN
The Liverpool Echo- Saturday, February 17, 1923
By Stork
I have spoken to many who have followed the history of Everton ever since the day that Fred Geary, Chadwick and Milward were on the team-sheet, and they avow that Troup is the best outside left ever seen on the Goodison ground. This is a broad statement to make, and I am, unfortunately, not in a position to challenge the statement, for I was in long clothes in the days of those one-time brilliants, but Troup is certainly the dandiest left-winger I have had the pleasure of seeing at the Everton headquarters for many a long day. A noted player of my acquaintance tells me that Troup only played an ordinary game against Chelsea, and avers that the little fellow is capable of much better, and he should know for he has played with and against him. Saturday’s display was good enough for me, for it proved that Troup has a knowledge, and a good knowledge of the game he adorns. If he is capable of better things, let him trot them out, and the Everton stock will rise mighty high. McBain, their other Scottish international, is also another player who knows his game, and plays it when he can. There is no bustle about McBain. He simply gets there without being seen, and when once there he knows what to do afterwards. I have seen the ex-Mancunian several times previously and felt sure he would do the Blues a power of good, and once he gets settled down I am certain he will justify all I have said about him.
MIDDLESBROUGH’S FALLING AWAY
Everton, after their visit to London, where they dropped a couple of very useful points, went right up to the East Coast for a refresher. The airs of Redcar and Saltburn have a beneficial effect evidently, for the neighbourhood is becoming quite a rendezvous for football teams. Middlesbrough, Everton’s next opponents, are having a rocky time at the moment. Not since December 30 have the ‘Borough won a League match. There is something wrong with their attack. Is it because of Elliott’s absence and Wilson’s falling off? December 16 saw the Teesider’s on the third rung of the League ladder. To-day they occupy ninth place. Even Jack Carr, the cleverest of the footballing brothers of that name, has taken the complaint, and is only showing very ordinary form to that which gained him his trial at the Burnley ground early in the season. Marshall, their crack defender, was brought out for the first tie with Sheffield United, and suffers thereby. He was not thoroughly mended from his injury, and his all too quick return has placed him hors de combat. Jock would be keenness itself to turn out, believing himself fully recovered. It is a bad policy to try and bluff nature, which will run its own course, and will not be speedied up even by the most expert of trainers. Everton are forced to make changes, Fern returns to keep goal through the unfortunate injury to Harland, who I hope makes a speedy recovery. Cook and Williams were also injured, and it is not yet certain as the whether they will be fit to play. There are still a few weak spots in Everton’s armour, but they are gradually being erased. Downs, good back though he is, is not getting any younger, and consequently is losing in pace and wind, as witness his trailing of Bell a week ago. Dick has not been with the Everton club many years, but he has been worth his weight in gold to the Goodison club. The Everton attack is blending nicely, and it only needs better finishing work by the inside forwards to make it one to be greatly feared. Ayresome Park is not a kindly spot to visitors, who usually receive short shrift up there, and I will be satisfied if the Blues can force a draw.

STUD MARKS
The Liverpool Football Echo- Saturday, February 17, 1923
By Louis T. Kelly

SPECIAL REPORT OF THE HARLAND CASE
The Liverpool Football Echo- Saturday, February 17, 1923
HOSPITAL SAY IMPROVEMENT IS VERY SLOW
Bee’s Notes
Harland, the Irish and Everton goalkeeper, is still in hospital. Our London correspondent visited St. George’s Hospital, having arranged with the authorities to have a little chat with the player. When he arrived at the institution our correspondent was told by Harland’s medical man that his condition, contrary to expectations, had not improved sufficiently to permit of even a brief talk. In addition to a severe knock-up of the thumb, Harland sustained a rather serious concussion. So far he has been enable to gave any account of the accident, but ti appears that during the melee in front of the Everton goal he diverted the ball from the foot of one of his opponents. Then, to guard his face from the foot of one of the Chelsea men who was coming up he put his had against his head, however, to receive the impact on his thumb and head. Harland is now conscious, and every hope is expressed that he will make a sure recovery, but at present rest and quietude are essential.

SANCTION FOR EVERTON
The Liverpool Football Echo-Saturday, February 17, 1923
Bee
The clashing of the return League match between Everton and Middlesbrough next week with the Cup-tie at Anfield was mentioned at the meeting of the League this morning. Mr. John McKenna afterwards stated to an “Echo” representative that it had been definitely decided to give sanctions for the League game at Goodison to be played on Wednesday, February 28, instead of Saturday next. Harland is a little better today. He passed a fair night. Everton F.C have sent one of their representatives to London to “stand by” Harland.

EVERTON WITH FERN
The Liverpool Football Echo-Saturday, February17, 1923
TESTING GAME AT THE MIDDLESBRO’ GROUND
HARLAND AND A DISCLAIMER
F.E.H. TELLS HOW EVERTON GAINED GREAT VICTORY
EVERTON WIN 4-2
Everton; Fern; Raitt, Downs; Peacock, McBain, Hart (Captain); Chedgzoy, Irvine, Cock, Chadwick, Troup. Middlesbrough; Williamson; Ellerington, Fox; Slade, Webster, Pender; Botterill, Birrell, Donaghy, G. Carr, Murray. Referee; Mr. H.V. Scott, of Tamworth. Tom Fern was keeping goal at Middlesbrough today through Harland being in the London hospital suffering from concussion and other things. Harland this afternoon was stated to be showing some signs of improvement. We hope these signs continue, for the poor fellow has had a very bad time since the Chelsea game. Many people have said that the game must have bene a rough one, but we can deny that because Harland’s injury was quite accidental, and the game could not by any stretch of imagination be called rough. Everton have had a peck of bad fortune this season, and they hoped today at Middlesbrough to stop the rot. The men had been staying at Redcar, and owing to injuries to members reserve men had to be called up. The Evertonians delayed their stay at Redcar to the last possible moment this morning and only reached Ironopolis an  hour before the kick-off. They too taxis straight to the ground which, though in good condition, was obviously on the soft side.
HARLAND PROGRESSING
The weather was dismal to a degree, a leaden sky hanging gloweringly, and it was cold enough for snow, when the game began in a very bad light. There were changes in both elevens, so that the inquiries received on either side were counter-balanced. I learned from Messrs, Wade and Banks, the directors, who were the shepherds of the flock, that Harland is progressing favourably though still in hospital in London. Williams’s rib injuries are not very serious, but he is “plastered up” and, of course, unable to turn out. Chadwick took his place, while Fern appeared between the sticks. The home ranks were also reshuffled, Fox and Botterill coming in after last week’s action. Everton started and the home forwards at once made play on the right, but the ball was put over the line. Everton replied with a lively sprint by Chedgzoy and Irvine, but they were also upset when it came to finishing. There was some merry work in midfield, the Borough making ground cleverly. Birrell had the goal at his mercy when he bungled the chance.
DONAGHY’S BRILLIANT GOAL
The visitors gradually got into their stride, and Chedgzoy flying down the wing, put the ball to Irvine, who tested Williamson with a warm shot, but the veteran cleared with agility. The home vanguard then got going in determined fashion, and following a throw-in they succeeded in netting. Donaghy propelled a wonderful cross-shot into the net just out of Fern’s reach. It was a beautiful goal, and was cheered to the echo. After this success, which came in rather less than ten minutes from the start, the pace became livelier than ever. Everton made ground by easy stages, and Cock looked a certain scorer when his shot was rathe luckily intercepted. The visitors, however, continued to press hotly, and Webster distinctly handled the ball in the penalty area. The referee, however, apparently did not see the incident, for he disallowed the appeal. The Middlesbrough forwards then tried to force matters again, and Birrell getting the better of Hart and Downs was well placed when he missed his shot.
CONTRASTING METHODS
The Everton attack responded gallantly, and Troup, cutting in, finished with an exceedingly clever shot, which sent the ball just over the bar. Clever concerted work on the part of Peacock, Chedgzoy, and Irvine gave the home defenders considerable anxiety, but Fox eventually cleared. So far the game had been full of incidents, and there was not much to choose between the contesting sides. Middlesbrough were more bustling in attack, but their plan of campaign was not as meat and clever as that of the visitors. Troup was obviously anxious to make his mark, and he was well served by both Hart and McBain, but both the home backs were steady and cool.
CARR SCORING SECOND GOAL
The game had been in progress just half an hour when we experienced two tremendous thrills. Botterill was given an open chance by Downs, who was apparently relying on the offside rule. The Middlesbrough man, however, went on, and, giving the ball to George Carr, the latter scored a neat goal at close range.
CHADWICK AND IRVINE EQUALISE
Everton’s rely was most spirited. They simply swooped down on the home goal, and Chadwick taking a pass from Cock, scored a goal within a minute of that secured by Carr. This seemed to act as an appetiser to the Evertonians, for Chedgzoy got off the mark like a Waterloo Cup candidate and placing the leather with judgement to Irvine, the latter equalised with a very meritorious effort. All these happenings had taken place in less than five minutes, and the crowd was too excited to see that Downs had to be attended to. A more serious injury, however, occurred to Carr, who was badly damaged in collision with Raitt, with the result that he had to be assisted from the field. After a few minutes’ absence he returned, but he was limping badly and quite unable to take advantage of a pass when it was offered to him by Donaghy. Everton were busy on the left and Troup, in trying to keep the ball in play, broke the corner flag amid much merriment. Just before half-time the Evertonians showed their real power of attack, and a fast, rising shot from Irvine gave Williamson a moment’s anxiety. Troup then had another left-foot shot at goal. It was admirably contrived, but Ellerington managed to block it. Middlesbrough raced away on the left, but Carr was pulled up in time, and when Birrell attempted to mend matters he was checked by Hart. Chadwick got through but was thwarted at the last moment, and Troup had a shot blocked just as the whistle sounded for the interval. Half-time Middlesbrough 2, Everton 2
The first half provided some fine fast football, and, as I have already said, there was little between the contestants. Everton were neater in their footwork, but the division of honours at the interval was a just reflex.
CHEDGZOY’S EFFORT
It was duller than ever when the second period was entered upon, and Middlesbrough at once made play on the left, and Murray centred well, but Donaghy failed to trap the ball. At the other end, Chedgzoy made a characteristic effort, beating both Pender and Fox, and concluded by putting wide. The reply of the home side was a strong combined forward movement, but the players were rather disconcerted by the intervention of a sporting dog, who insisted taking part in the game. The dog, a black little mongrel, with an obvious intention of football still kept on the field in spite of the enticements of all the players, and he deliberately refused to listen to the overtures of Fern. Meanwhile Everton were exerting pressure, and Cock was well placed when he mulled the chance. A brisk movement on the part of the three inside forwards looked favourable for Middlesbrough, but Donaghy twice failed to rise to the occasion, and a long dropping shot fell just wide of the mark. Peacock and Chedgzoy gave the crowd a taste of their quality with a tricky little movement. It was exceedingly clever, but the pair had reckoned without Fox, who proved quite as cunning as his prototype.
CHADWICK SCORES AGAIN
In the later stages of the game Everton showed further development in their method of attack, and if Cock had seized upon the opportunities offered they should surely have taken the lead before it was actually accomplished. He made ample amends, however, with a brilliant run through and taking up the ball to Chadwick who deliberately netted with a well-considered shot.
CHADWICK IN BRILLIANT FORM
Hart than broke clean through, and was brought down by Fox in the penalty area. The spot kick was taken by Chadwick, who scored with a strong,. Straight shot. This was his third goal out of four. Final; Middlesbrough 2, Everton 4

CENTRAL LEAGUE
The Liverpool Football Echo- Saturday, February 17, 1923
EVERTON RES v  PRESTON RES
At Goodison park. Everton made one change, Forbes going centre forward instead of Chadwick, who was away with the first team at Middlesbrough, and Virr occupied the inside left berth. The opening exchanges were on even lines, the first advance came through Everton, but Harrison was given offside when an opening lacked prominent. Preston then gained an unproductive corner, and at the other end Elliott saved a smart drive from Harrison. Another fine opportunity was lost to Preston, when Marquis with a clear shot, put the ball right into salt’s hand. The visiting centre was again prominent, but this time Chadwick was rather fortunate in being able to intercept his progress. Elliott at the other end, brought off a fine save from a strong shot from Reid, and another good effort to more came through Forbes. Despite the numerous raids by Everton on the N.E citadel the visitors’ defence were able to keep a clean sheet when the whistle blew for the cessation of hostilities. Half-time; Everton Res 0, Preston Res 0
After about 25 minutes’ play in the second half Everton’s efforts were at last awarded with a goal scored by Parry, who stood along the wing and sent in a shot which completely deceived Elliott. Five minutes later Everton were awarded a penalty for hands against Wade. Harrison took the kick but his shot was well saved by Elliott. After thirty-five minutes in the second half, Parry with a splendid individual effort, scored a second for Everton Reserves. Final; Everton Res 2, Preston Res 0.

MIDDLESBROUGH 2 EVERTON 4
February 19, 1923. The Liverpool Courier.
EVERTON'S SMART AWAY VICTORY
CHADWICK SCORERS THREE GOALS.
By F.M.N.
A welcome victory at Ayresome Park rewarded the strenuous efforts of Everton, and when it is remembered that the Goodison Club at one time had to make up a deficiency of two goals, it will be readily conceded that the success was one of district merit. True, the Middlesbrough side were not at full strength with such players as Marshall, Wilson, and jack Carr absent, but with the exception of the latter, the team was the same as that which satisfied the directors the previous week at Sunderland.
THE UPWARD GLIDE.
At any rate the two points accruing to Everton were highly encouraging, and even it is not an occasion for hysteria or extravagant expectations. Everton accomplished sufficient to prove that the team continues to glide upwards. So well did the blues play, that it was a distinct surprise to find Middlesbrough 2 up in half an hour. Donaghy scoring a remarkable fine goal in the opening minutes, and George Carr piloting a centre from Botterill past Fern at close quarters.
BLUES RALLY.
Everton certainly did not deserved to be two down, and when Cock dribbled down the centre, and gave to Chadwick, that player scored a remarkably good goal. Within a couple of minutes Everton equalised as the result of a smart bit of play by Chedgzoy and a rapid shot from Irvine. Three goals were scored in five minutes, and the teams turned round on level terms. Everton took command in the second half, and two goals from Chadwick settled the issue. The first of these was the result of smart play be Cock, who made the opening for the inside left, and Hart, following a sinuous dribble, being brought down in the penalty area, ( Penalty kick ) Chadwick completed the scoring thus obtaining three of the four goals. Fore and aft the Goodison brigade were on top. In pace, tact, and skill the standard of efficiency was higher than in previous displays, the men in conceiving and executing their plans imparting the utmost enthusiasm to their task, and I have the greatest confidence that, with ordinary luck, the club will finish the campaign well. Fern deputised for the injured Harland with infinite resource, and the backs though uncertain at first played soundly.
BRILLIANT HALF-BACKS.
But the dominating feature was the high quality of the wing halves, and in a lessor degree the schemes engineered by McBain, Peacock, was in brilliant form, his constructive plans being supported by excellent anticipation, keen placing and sound tackling.
CHADWICK'S FINE SHOOTING.
The forwards as a line worked smoothly, there being plenty of sparkle about their movements. They imparied that finish which has not been a very noticeable part of the Blues attack. Chadwick was a revelation at inside left, and his three goals proved that he is still Everton's most effective sharpshooter. Further he showed improvement in ball control. Cock played much better than at Chelsea and two of the goals were due largely to his openings. Irvine also showed vast improvement and Chedgzoy was like a two year old. Troup's boundless energy amazed the onlookers. The Dundee man was not content to play outside left. He was down amongst the halves and backs when the situation merited his presence and he saved his side more than once. He is not only a player he is an enthusiast. Webster was the outstanding figure on the Middlesbrough side and Murray, George Carr and Donaghy were able forwards. Teams: - Middlesbrough: - Williamson, goal, Fox, and Ellertington, backs, Slade, Webster, and Pender, half-backs, Botterill, Birrell, Donaghy, G. Carr, and Murray, forwards. Everton: - Fern, goal, Raitt, and Downs, backs, Peacock, McBain, and Hart (captain), half-backs, Chedgzoy, Irvine, Cock, Chadwick, and Troup, forwards. Referee Mr. HV. Scott

EVERTON RESERVES 2 PRESTON NORTH END RESERVES 0
February 19, 1923. The Liverpool Daily Post and Mercury
CENTRE LEAGUE
The first meeting between these teams this season produced good football, although Everton were victorious by two clear goals, the Prestonians had quite as much of the play. Several times they penetrated the home defence, but usually finished with wild shooting. Marquiss in the centre, on three occasions got through with only Salt to beat, but his shots lacked sting and direction, on the other hand, each time Everton got to close quarters their forwards chiefly Parry and Harrison shot accurately and had Elliott not been in great form the score would have been heavier. During the first half there was no score. The players turned around without the usual interval, and for a time Preston held the advantage. The first goal, however, came to Everton through Parry, who finished good wing work by sending in a shot, which Elliott misjudged. Five minutes later Everton were awarded a penalty, and Elliott made a grand save from Harrison. Preston tried hard to get on level turns and Salt made a fine one handed save from Jefferis. Close on time Parry got the second with a good individual effort.

“TOFFEE” FOR EVERTON
The North Star, Monday, February 19, 1923
BOROUGH GIVE WAY AT AYRESOME PARK
FULL BACK HESITATION
GOODISON MEN GOOD VALUE FOR VICTORY
By Tees-Sider
The game between the Borough and Everton at Ayresome Park on Saturday was marked by a dramatic turn of fortunes. The first twenty minutes provided a district surprise for the home supporters, for at the end of that period the Borough held a lead of two goals, and on the run of the play they were well worthy of it, but subsequently they fell completely to pieces and Everton, taking an absolute grip of the game, ran out comfortable winners by four goals to two. A good deal of interest was evinced in the game because of the inclusion of five reserve players in the Borough team, and hopes were entertained that they would infuse new life into the play of the side. They certainly did in the first half, but they failed to stay the pace of a hard and gruelling game, and once Everton got a grip the Tees-siders were rarely in the picture. They flattered to deceive. After some exhilarating and sprightly play in the early stages, the Borough forwards and half backs lost all cohesion and initiative. This was solely due to a fatal weakness which developed in the defence of Ellerington and Holmes, both of whom became very unreliable under pressure, and played with little or no understanding. They were only able to cope indifferently with the attacks of the visiting forwards, with the result that the Borough half-backs had to fall back to assist in defence, and allow their own forwards to battle through unaided. Everton gained their victory in masterly fashion, and enjoyed a big advantage throughout the game by their tricky footwork and combination. Forwards, halves and backs moved together with commendable dash and resource. They were faster and far more decisive in their action than the home team, and the longer the game lasted the more pronounced did their superiority become. The outstanding feature of the game was the success of Chadwick, who came into the visiting forward line at inside left in the place of Williams. He crowned a great exhibition by accomplishing the hat-trick, though his success was chiefly due to the unselfish work of Cock, who proved an ideal leader. Although well watched by Webster, the Borough centre-half, Cock was generally capable of providing his inside man with some neat passes, and unselfishness marked his play throughout the game. This was particularly evident in the second half when he gave Chadwick a pass that led to Everton obtaining the lead. In the first half the play was of a sprightly description, and provided an amount of thrilling incidents. The work of both sets of forwards in the early stages was fast and lively, and the respective defences had quite a gruelling time. Within ten minutes the Borough took the lead. From a throw-in on the left wing, Donaghy trapped the ball and scored with a fine oblique shot from fully thirty yards’ range. It was one of the best scoring shots seen at Ayresome Park this season and flashed into the net like a cannon ball, the custodian having no chance whatever of saving. This early success seemed to imbue the Borough side with any amount of confidence and when George Carr placed them further ahead after 27 minutes’ play their prospects looked rosy. The second goal was the outcome of a fine piece of opportunism. Botterill initiated the forward movement and sent in a delightful centre which dropped a couple of yards in front of the Everton goal. Carr made a dash, beat the backs and placed the ball into the net. Then came a dramatic change in the situation. Everton made a surprising rally, and indulging in some brilliant play took command of the game. Within a few minutes, Chadwick notched a grand goal with a low shot which had Williamson well beaten, and two minutes later Irvine equalised, following some capital work on the right wing by Chedgzoy, while just before the interval Troup, who played a remarkably fine game on the left wing, all but gave them the lead. He certainly had a great opportunity of doing so. After beating Slade and Ellerington in turn, he went forward to within three yards of the goal, but dallying when he appeared to have the goal at his mercy he allowed Webster time to rush in and charge down his shot. At the same time it was a lucky escape for the Borough. The second half proved a disastrous time for the Tees-siders. In striking contrast to the first half their play lacked dash and understanding, and with the exception of Donaghy, who was always enterprising, the forwards were easily held at bay by the Everton defenders. Indeed, the amusing antics of a little terrier dog, who chased the ball about and evaded many efforts to capture him, proved more interesting than the play of the home team. Everton had the game completely within their grasp when Chadwick added a third, through credit for the success went to Cock. Finding that he was about to be closed upon by the two Borough backs, Cock deftly passed the ball over to Chadwick, who had a clear opening and made no mistake with a splendid shot. The fourth goal followed a few minutes later when Chadwick scored from a penalty given against Fox for a foul on Hart, who was going through on his own. There was only one team in the picture in the last twenty minutes, and the Borough retired well beaten by an all-round superior side.

BRILLIANT TROUP
Athletic News- Monday, February 19, 1923
AYRESOME BACKS COLLAPSE BEFORE EVERTON ATTACK
MIDDLESBROUGH 2, EVERTON 4
By Vulcan
After establishing an early lead of two clear goals Middlesbrough were beaten at home by Everton-not merely beaten, but reduced to such a state of complete impotence as to astonish the onlookers. There may or may not be foundation for the stories circulating of trouble behind the scenes in the Middlesbrough camp, but certain it is that this once brilliant team has fallen sadly away of late. Never before this season has the team plumped the depths which it did on Saturday. In extenuation it should be said that they had only five of the regular team on duty, and Botterill and Murray, in particular, were poor substitutes for the usual extreme wing pair, Jack Carr and Urwin. They wasted golden opportunities when accurate centres might have spelt goals.
A COMPLETE COLLAPSE
Downs is not the force he was, and Pratt, though the best back on the field, was inclined to stay too far away from his citadel. But the real cause of Middlesbrough’s downfall was the complete failure of the home backs- Ellerington and Fox. The absence of one man, even of Marshall’s calibre, should not have made all that difference, but the steadying influence of the Scot was badly missed. Fox is never the same defender without his regular partner, but he has never done so badly as he did against Chedgzoy. And the attempt to convert Ellerington into a full back was decidedly a failure. No more need to be said on that point, but with both full backs unable to rise to the occasion, the cause of Middlesbrough’s defeat is not far to seek. For a time the super-abundant energies of Webster covered their deficiencies, but when the valiant centre half began to fag Middlesbrough’s tale of troubles commenced. To Everton’s forward’s forwards must be accorded the honours of the day. Their defence was no more than useful, and I thought that if the home forwards had played upon Downs they would not have found him the obstacle he used to be. But what grand football we saw from the Everton vanguard. Troup is the best outside-left seen at Ayresome Park this season. The little Scot has all the attributes of a first-class man. He is fast, has admirable ball control, and he can shoot and centre with speed and accuracy. He made but one mistake when, with an open goal he passed to Cock instead of shooting, for he could scarcely have failed to score had he taken his courage in his hands. Chedgzoy was graceful and sinuous as ever, and Chadwick and Irvine a grand pair of inside forwards, ever thrusting for goal. I thought Cock the weakest link, and yet two of Chadwick’s goals were the result of Cock’s unselfishness, and that in a leader is at times a virtue.
IN DETAIL
The story of the game in detail is soon told, PETER DONAGHY’S  first shot at goal, from a throw-in, took effect, and it was a really brilliant effort. Then, after 27 minutes, good work by Donaghy ended in Botterill centring for GEO. CARR to put Middlesbrough two up. With a tenacious defence that should have sufficed, but within a minute CHADWICK  took a short pass of Cock’s, and reduced the lead. Brilliant work by Chedgzoy enabled IRVINE to equalise before the interval. The honours to this point had been fairly divided. Middlesbrough resumed with a rare burst of speed, but it proved illusory, and in the last half-hour they were helpless, CHADWICK giving Everton the lead after a great solo run of Cock’s, and then complete Middlesbrough’s discomfiture by converting a penalty kick against Fox, who had, in fact, been lucky to survive a similar appeal in the first half. Middlesbrough; Williamson; Errington, Fox; Slade, Webster, Pender; Botterill, Birrell, Donaghy, Carr (G), and Murray. Everton; Fern; Raitt, Downs; Peacock, McBain, Hart (Captain); Chedgzoy, Irvine, Cock, Chadwick, and Troup. Referee; H.V. Stott, Tamworth.

HAT-TRICK FOR CHANDWICK
The Liverpool Echo-Monday, February 19, 1923
CHADWICK ON THE MARK
By Bee
I am glad to deny the rumour that Harland is dead. The rumour reached Everton’s headquarters. It is not generally known that Chadwick the big centre-forward, was in readiness to play against Chelsea a week ago but eventualities did not permit. People say he is slow, but if only he could get that smashing drive in a little earlier he would not be kept out of any first-class side. Spectators are too hasty with a big-built fellow, and therefore I was sorry to see he had not bee persevered with, and, moreover, that the crowd was inclined to disfavour him. He got among the goals at Middlesbrough, and helped in a mighty victory, which astounded all those save the folk who have studied Everton through and through and knew by their Stamford Bridge display that they were playing nice football; and effective football to boot. Perhaps this display of Chadwick’s will once and for all give him an elongated trial in the senior side. Experience will count much for him.

ALL ABOUT THE WIN
The Liverpool Echo-Monday, February 19, 1923
By F.E.H
After Everton’s exhilarating exhibition at Ayresome Park on Saturday I feel inclined like Silas Wegg, to “drop into poetry” as thus;-
      “Sing a song o six goals,
       With four for Everton,
        Isn’t this a dainty dish
        For us to feed upon?”
The game, in spite of the wretched weather, was singularly refreshing. It was quite like old times to see the Blues showing their real grit and cleverness. Once they had wiped off the two goals arrears -no mean performance, by the way-the Mersey-siders took charge of the game, and in the end they won “hands down.” What struck me moist was the speedy way in which the new comers have fallen into their respective positions and their general understanding. It was an object lesson in intelligent combination and if continued will certainly carry the Evertonians far up the League ladder. Of course one ought not to lose sight of the fact that the home side were fielding no fewer than half a dozen reserves, but these were all triers, and collectively could be scarcely blamed for the defeat. The backs, it must be admitted, were at times very shaky, but quite a lot of good work was done by the halves. The uncertainty of the game was emphasised by the fact that Middlesbrough clapped on a couple of goals before giving their opponents a real chances of coming to grips. Donaghy opened the scoring with a magnificent effort which left us all staring with open eyes, and when Carr added a second, we began to rub them. There was ample reason for this, for before one could say “knife” Chadwick and Irvine with clever shots put their side on level terms. And so we crossed over. In the second period Everton’s superiority caused consternation in the Middlesbrough camp, and they seemed to fall to pieces when Chadwick gave his side the lead and put the “top hat” on the home club with a sure and direct penalty shot. I was especially glad to witness the success of the newcomers to the Everton fold. McBain should prove a valuable asset to the half back line, and Troup is already making his presence felt in the forward line. The half-backs were not quite convincing in some of their clearances, but, on the whole, there was nothing to grumble at.

TROUP'S IMPRESSIONS ENGLISH FOOTBALL.
Dundee Courier - Wednesday 21 February 1923
HOLIDAYING IN FORFAR.
Alex Troup, the ex-Dundee left winger, now with Everton holidaying at Forfar this week as his club has no match on Saturday. Our representative had a talk with Troup yesterday, and found him delighted with his short experience of English football. " We have a grand team," said Troup, " and you can look out for few more victories before the season closes. All our new men are doing well, and Davie Raitt is playing even better than he did at Dundee. Of course, the game is much faster than it is in Scotland. They believe in , the quickest road to the goal, and it is useless to try pattern-weaving. There are no soft marks in the English First Division," continued Troup. '' It is case of fighting hard every week. It was different with Dundee, when it was frequently a case of going to Dens Park knowing that you were almost certain of victory. Even at ' home ' Everton have to play hard, because the opposition is always first-class." Troup returns to Liverpool to-morrow.

HARLAND UNMARKED AND OUT OF DANGER
The Liverpool Echo- Wednesday, February 21, 1923
Bee’s Notes
Everton “A” are playing St. Helens Junction at Goodison Park, on Saturday afternoon at 3.15
AN ASTOUNDING CASE
Word comes from London this morning that Harland, the Everton goalkeeper, is a shade better, and that since the week-end he has taken the right turn. It will be about three weeks before he leaves the hospital. The club sent Mr. John Fare up to London to “stand by,” so serious was the case, and now that all is well and Harland can talk, the case is still more mysterious. The doctors cannot find a scratch or trace of a blow on the head, and therefore it is startling that Harland should have been unconscious for days together. His thumb was knocked up, but when he walked off the ground I thought he looked quite normal, although he was plainly in pain. Harland himself remembers nothing of the affair. If there was no blow on the head, how came it that Harland was unconscious from Wednesday evening till Friday morning, and again on Saturday? There is one thing certain; Harland is getting better, and the story, spread by someone else, that he might not play again is, happily, quite wrong.
Everton team at Preston reads; Salt; McDonald, Livingstone; Jeffs, Reid, Grenyer; Parry, Miller, Forbes, Virr and Harrison.
£.S.D!
“Disgusted” writes;- I have been for over 20 years a staunch supporter of the Blues, but never bothered with letter writing; however, I must write now and protest against the action of the Everton directors in having the next Saturday’s match transferred to Wednesday, February 28. Surely the Blues’ supporters would have gone to Everton just the same, and how many of us must now miss the match, or the alternative, lose a day’s wages, and perhaps get the sack. Is football now really only £ s.d.

McBAIN SELECTED FOR SCOTLAND
The Liverpool Echo- Thursday, February 22 1923
Bee’s Notes
At Glasgow, yesterday, the Scottish F.A Selection Committee chose the following team to play Ireland, at Belfast, on March 3rd- Harper (Hibernian); Marshall (3rd), Harper (Hibernian); Marshall (Middlesbrough), Blair (Cardiff City); Steel (Huddersfield), Morris (Raith Rovers); McBain (Everton); Archibald (Glasgow Rangers), White (Heart of Midlothian), Wilson (Middlesbrough), Cassidy (Celtic), and Morton (Glasgow Rangers). Harper, Steel and Morris are new “caps”
PLEA FOR WEDNESDAY
“Fairplay” writes;- In view of controversy that is going on re Everton’s action in postponing the Middlesbrough match, I should like to ask “Sporty” and others- Do they never consider the thousands of shop assistants, who, only for holiday matches, would not see a match in the season? We have to be content with a hasty glance at 5.30 at your notes, and then wait till 9.30 to study form. If “Sporty” and others were sports they would take a standing chance on the Cop with the real enthusiast and not want to be coddled on the stands, or deprive the other enthusiasts of a game on Wednesday, which otherwise they would not see. Why are no reserve matches played mid-week as was the case last season? A Little advertising, and they would attract more spectators than they do on Saturdays.
  “Grocer’s Assistants” write in a similar strain;- Do none of the “sports” who are at present working themselves up into indignation over the action of postponing the Middlesbro’ match ever give a thought to the thousands of people whose weekly half-holiday falls on a Wednesday? Many of these latter are just as keen supporters of our local teams as those who are lucky enough to have their Saturday afternoons free, but how often during a season do they get a chance of seeing their favourites? No, I think the E.F.C is to be congratulated for recognising the fact that to thousands of their supporters a Wednesday match is a godsend and the only direct means many have of keeping in touch with first-class football.

CHADWICK MAKING GOOD
The Liverpool Football Echo-Saturday, February 24, 1923
Bee’s Notes
Bury have had some rare, good centre-forwards on their books, but there was one whose talents they did not appreciate, who now looks like making a name, viz., Wilfred Chadwick, who last Saturday scored three goals on Everton’s behalf at Middlesbrough. Chadwick graduated with a junior club in Bury, and played several games for the “Shakers” during war-time without unduly impressing the authorities at Gigg-lane, and finally he threw in his lot with Rossendale United. Here he proved a prolific scorer in the Lancashire Combination and, after Bolton Wanderers had been given the offer of his transfer, Everton came along and booked him. He has scored ten League goals this season.

EVERTON “A” v,  ST. HELENS JUNCTION
The Liverpool Football Echo- Saturday, February 24, 1923
The opening play was mostly in favour of Everton, who several times got to close quarters but the heavy and greasy ball was the cause of their indifferent shooting. Rimmer, on the left, was prominent as was Howard for St. Helens, who several times got the better of the home defence. The first goal came to Everton after Alford had hit the crossbar with a good shot. Young met the return and netted. Just before the interval Everton were leading 1-0.

PRESTON NORTH END RESERVES 0 EVERTON RESERVES 1
February 26, 1923. The Liverpool Daily Post and Mercury.
CENTRE LEAGUE (
Everton visit to Deepdale on Saturday was productive of two points, the visitors being much the better side. The only goal of the match was obtained by Virr in the first half, and only bad shooting after the interval prevented Everton adding to their score.

EVERTON "A" 1 S. HELENS JUNCTION 0
February 26, 1923. The Liverpool Daily Post and Mercury.
LIVERPOOL COUNTY COMBINATION.
At Goodison Park, before 2,000 spectators. The early stages went mostly in favour of Everton, but owing to the heavy state of the ground and the greasy ball their shooting was indifferent. Rimmer and Alford were prominent on the left, and the shots, which went true, were ably dealt with by the St. Helens goalkeeper. Young was the best forward on the field, and after 35 minutes play he opened the score with a shot from a rebound, when Alford struck the crossbar. The second half play for some time was fairly even, and St. Helens looked like getting the equaliser once being fortunate to save their charge.

PENALTY KICKS LAWS
February 27, 1923. The Liverpool Daily Post and Mercury.
The council of the football association yesterday considered the practice of players lining up on the penalty line to impede a player when taking a penalty kick, and it was decided that such a practice was not in accordance with the intention of the penalty law, and it must be discontinued. This decision will be forward to the international board for its consideration at the next annual meeting of the board in June.

AT GOODISON PARK TOMORROW
The Liverpool Echo-Tuesday, February 27, 1923
Bee’s Notes
The holiday-makers will revel in the Middlesbrough game at Walton tomorrow at 3.15. we shall have the opportunity of seeing the cracks of the Borough side, and also a further view of McBain, Troup, Cock and Company. Therefore the game should be a rousing one. Everton are a new side these days, and their ill-fortunate has, one hopes, been left far behind.

GOALS AT GOODISON
The Liverpool Echo- Wednesday, February 28, 1923
MIDDLESBROUGH REDUCE BIG EVERTON’S LEAD
By Bee
Everton; Fern; Raitt, Livingstone; Peacock, McBain, Hart (Captain); Chedgzoy, Irvine, Cock, Chadwick, Troup. Middlesbrough; Williamson; Holmes, Fox; Davidson, Webster, Pender; J. Carr, Birrell, Wilson, Donaghy, Urwin. “Bee” phones from Goodison Park and says; The day was brilliantly fine for the re-arranged League fixture between Everton and Middlesbrough, which had been due on a Saturday but had been taken from its clashing “arms,” much to some people’s troubles. Everton were strongly represented, and Middlesbrough, as customary lately, were not a full strength. There was quite a good sized crowd at the start, the turf, after yesterday’s downpour of rain, being extremely heavy going. The Press-box at Goodison was never so full as this afternoon, not even on an international day. I don’t quite know what papers the “Pressers” represented, but perhaps some of them came from the “Tutan shamen News”! the referee was Mr. H.V. Stott, Everton won the toss, had the wind and sun behind them, and the hopes of anything up to 20,000 people. In the opening moments Livingstone slewed a ball square owing to the sticky nature of the turf, and McBain seemed to catch Andy Wilson on the leg.
COCK SHINES
The best incident of a dullest opening was an effort by Cock, who, from Irvine, had a capital chance, but was blotted out when he was trying to make sure of his shot. Cock and the defence lost sight of the ball for a moment, and when Cock found it he placed it to the extreme left-hand side. Williamson was not there, but the goalpost was, and so an early goal was strangled. Irvine tested Williamson at the right-hand side, and Peacock and Irvine paired off brilliantly, as if they were playing a foursome. Middlesbrough should have got going on the left, and did not, because Donaghy was inclined to over-dribble. There was a stoppage through a Middlesbrough defender hurting his left thigh, and while the injured man was being walked about outside the field of play Irvine crossed a ball that no one could reach, not even the goalkeeper, and the latter was therefore delighted to see the ball pull clear of the goalpost. The most tactical effort of the day thus far was a little bit of jugglery by Troup, who has a habit of encouraging the defence to “come on,” and then centring. He did this now, with such effect that Chadwick hit the ball first time, and it was a very useful shot, the ball narrowly missing the left upright. Still, it was practical football, and there was wisdom in every movement of it.
A RUDE AWAKENING
Middlesbrough lacked fire, and Jack Carr was not much in evidence. In fact, it was plain that he has had a bit too much football, thanks to representative games, Cup-ties, &c. Livingstone, after checking Wilson, who seemed to be right through for a goal, went to the trouble of fouling J. Carr, and when the free kick was taken it was poetic justice, perhaps, that the ball should hit Livingstone and partially stun him. A goal came in nineteen minutes, and it had a simple beginning. Raitt was attempting to clear and he took the opportunity of feinting, and thus when he turned round sharp to his left-hand side he had Donaghy guessing. The full back pushed the ball up the field, and Cock took full toll of an error on the part of a defender, and hit a nice shot to the right hand side of the post. The next three minutes were crammed with live incidents. First of all Fern saved from Urwin in thorough manner, and at an awkward angle. Second, Fern missed the flight of the ball, and was out of his goal when hart made a certainty. The cause of Middlesbrough’s “fright-fulness” in front of goal was made evident when Chadwick went straight away to score No.2, again to the right hand side of the goal, and this time Williamson was slow to get down to a slow-moving and low ball.
GOALS ON GOALS
Exactly one minute elapsed and Cock scored No 3, thanks to a ball which had been shot by Troup cannoning off Williamson’s chest on to Cock’s head. Troup had helped to make it a goal by pretending to call on his comrades for his centre, whereas from the start it was plain to those who knew his ways that he was going to shoot. Three goals, three minutes, three misses, and a host of other things made the game an enlivening one. How much Everton are better than they were is proved by the fact that they have scored seven goals against Middlesbrough. There was a special significance about Everton scoring three goals, as in some accumulations they thus equalled Sheffield United. Birrell scored from a breakaway after 27 minutes, the ball striking the upright when Fern had made a very useful effort to stay the flight of the ball. The accumulator scheme went to nought when Cock going down the middle of the field just nicely on side, and never losing control of the ball or of the defence, made the score 4-1 in 37 minutes. Andy Wilson was hardly seen throughout the whole half and Everton were right on top of their form, and altogether too good for the Middlesbrough defence. Half-time; Everton 4, Middlesbrough 1.
In the second half matters became interesting when Andy Wilson scored with a first-time shot from easy-range, thanks to Raitt letting in Urwin. A second time Raitt slipped up, but this time use was not made of the golden chance. The game took a starting turn when Birrell scored cleverly, to make the total 4-2. Middlesbrough went hard for the equaliser and Cock, unmarked and in front of goal, shot against the goalkeeper’s legs.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

February 1923