EVERTON 0 HUDDERSFIELD TOWN 3
January 1,1923. The Liverpool Daily Posy and Mercury
EVERTON BEATEN AT HOME.
HUDDERSFIELD'S CLEVER DISPLAY.
Everton yielded both points to Huddersfield Town in the first meeting of the Clubs at Goodison Park on Saturday. It was a new experience for Everton, for they had not previously been beaten by the Yorkshire side. Still there could be no disputing the fact that Huddersfield were the better side, and they won because they adapted themselves to the conditions with great facility. Huddersfield were smarter in all their movements, and the forwards swung the ball out to the speedy extreme wing men with great accuracy under difficult conditions. Stamina, too, played a big part in deciding the issue, and Huddersfield proved themselves better supplied in both a physical and football sense. There was plenty of good, hard football, and Everton held their own fairly well in the first half, but afterwards the superior methods of Huddersfield gave them a big advantage. All the goals were scored in the second half –tangible evidence of Huddersfield's wearing down tactics.
HARLAND'S GOOD WORK.
Harland was given plenty of work, for the Huddersfield forwards were never afraid to shoot, although they failed with at least three chances that should easily have been converted. At the same time Harland made grilling saves, his only mistake being when he misjudged the shot, that gave Huddersfield their third goal. Taylor was not so well employed, but gave evidence of his ability when occasions arose. The Huddersfield backs, as a pair, were better than Everton's. Raitt played soundly, but McDonald was not so confident, and his desire to dribble often brought him unnecessary work. Wadsworth and Barkas were as steady as a rock, and the Huddersfield halves made a splendid line, with Wilson a tower of strength. By comparison the Everton halves were much inferiors. They worked hard enough, but they rarely gave their forwards much help in a constructive sense. The Huddersfield forwards played the game best suited to the conditions, and Wilson, the centre, was repeatedly supplied with the right hand of passes, so that he was always a source of danger. Mann was a great schemer, and the extreme wingmen speedy and clever. The Everton line did not work well, Irvine was prominent without being successful, and although he frequently made great efforts to open out the game his passes to Chadwick were badly timed. Reid was much below his usual form, and Williams was not so certain with his finishing work, but Parry in the outside-right position gave a useful display, and with a little more dash and experience should improve his game.
HOW EVERTON LOST.
Wilson gave early evidence of his worth as a leader, and Harland did well to save a stinging shot in the first few minutes. Than Taylor dashed out to prevent a centre by Irvine from being picked up. Play was keen and wonderfully accurate in spite of the treacherous turf. Raiit showed clever defensive work, and Everton came within an ace of scoring when Barkes failed to clear, but the mistake was covered by the Huddersfield pivot. Harland made two exceptionally fine saves near the interval. He caught a center by Byers and scooped the ball away and when Mann got through and sent in a stinging shot Harland responded very skillfully. There was more incident in the play after the interval, and Wilson again led off with thrilling work. He put in a splendid run, and although he failed to get his shot home it was a fine individual effort. The Huddersfield attack developed very strongly, and Everton were hard pressed to keep their opponents at bay. McDonald let in Richardson, and the Huddersfield man got across a fine centre. Wilson let the ball pass, and Islip went through with a fine chance, which he wasted with a wide shot. Then Harland tipped over a beautifully placed shot by Byers. So persistent was the Huddersfield attack that it was obviously only a matter of time when the Evertoin defence would yield. Mann scored the first goal at sixty-five minutes. Byers put in a long shot, which Harland partially saved by falling to the ground, and before he could recover Mann sent the ball into the net. Chadwick almost equalised from a free kick, the ball striking the underpart of the crossbar, and although Irvine got the rebound, he shot wide. Richardson with another glorious run again put Mann in possession, and he finished by shooting against the woodwork. At eighty-five minutes, however, Mann scored a second goal. Richardson centred the ball, and Harland appeared to fist it against Mann, who got the ball into the net with his face. Two minutes from the end Byers scored a third goal with one of the best shots of the day. He drove in a high ball almost from the touchline, and Harland advanced a step to meet it, but he only touched the ball as it went into the net over his hand. Teams : - Everton: - Harland, goal, Raitt, and McDonald, backs, Brown Fleetwood, and Hart (captain), half-backs, Parry, Irvine, Chadwick, Williams, and Reid, forwards. Huddersfield Town: - Taylor, goal, Barkas, and Wadsworth, backs, Steele, T. Wilson, and Watson, half-backs, Richardson, Mann, C. Wilson, Islip, and Byers, forwards.

HUDERSFIELD TOWN RESERVES 2 EVERTON RESERVES 3
January 1, 1923. The Liverpool Daily Post and Mercury
CENTRAL LEAGUE
Under the most unfavourable conditions there was a display of very good football at Leeds-road. Both attacks overcame the mud with their vigorous play, and there was much clever work. Everton held a slight advantage forward, but it was not until the near the interval they were able to turn it to account. McGivney was the scorer, and his goal was the result of a good solo effort. Earlier Goodall had scored for Hudderrsfield from a penalty, given against Livingstone, who tripped Broom. In the second half Everton were decide4ly livelier. Hamson and Virr on the left wing were particularly dangerous, the latter scoring. Huddersfield, however, replied once more, and Marlow equlised. Everton obtained the masterly towards the end, and Miller scored a goal, which gave them the victory. Everton deserved to win on account of greater accuracy in the forward work and finishing.

THE NEW POWER
Athletic News
HUDDERSFIELD TOWN ALL ALERT AND SKILFUL
MANN ON THE MARK
EVERTON 0 HUDDERSFIELD TOWN 3
By Junius
The conditions Goodison Park were altogether unfavourable. It was a day on which physique had a distinct bearing upon the ultimate issue and in this respect there could be no two opinions as to the superior fitness the Huddersfield Town players. The ground was sodden, the players slipped and glided about almost in every movement,and it was due to their ability to adapt themselves better to the prevailing conditions that the Cup holders were able finally to settle the issue decisively in their favour. Soon after the proceedings opened one conceived an undercurrent of superiority that was bound eventually to assert itself. The longer the game went the more pronounced this became, and it occasions little surprise when during the last twenty five minutes of play, Everton’s defence had thrice been penetrated. The Huddersfield rear-guard was exceptionally strong, and having during the earlier stages broken up all Everton’s efforts to get within range of Taylor, they plied their forwards with passes that enabled them to take complete control of the game. They were more incisive in their movements, and did not spare themselves even when chances of getting possession seemed remote.
UNSPARING OF EFFORTS
To a man the Huddersfield forwards were speedier, and more alert on the ball, and two of their successes came as a direct result thereof. Following up—a potent factor that was quite neglected by the Everton forwards, whom I have not seen, this season, so lacking in celerity of movement —greatly contributed to the Town’s triumph. Occasionally the Everton front line showed pretty combination, but rarely recovered when finally challenged, and looking back upon the first portion of the game I can only recall three instances when Taylor was in request to accomplish anything beyond the ordinary. Wilson was the busy man the Huddersfield van in this period, and kept Harland extended; as also did Mann and Byers, but it was in the second half, as I have indicated, that the Town forwards outmanoeuvred and outpaced the Everton defenders, to drive home their advantage. After twenty minutes Mann opened the scoring after Harland had splendidly saved . The inside-right had only to tap the ball into the net, and possibly would not have accomplished his object had the defence been in position to support the goalkeeper. The nearest Everton came to scoring was from a free kick taken by Chadwick eighteen yards out. The ball rebounded from the bar, and Irvine with a clear opening sent wide. Five minutes from the close, Richardson taking advantage of weakness on the part of McDonald, centred, for Mann to notch second point, and Byers completed the scoring two minutes from time with high drive that Harland, who had stepped forward, could only partially arrest.Two players in Hart and Watson, impress me most by reason of the systematic thoroughness their work. The obvious was rarelya part of their scheming, and each, in his own particular way, opened out possibilities that were full of subtlety. Wilson (T.) was a sterling centre-half back, and Steele completed middle line whose work was sound both in aim and intrinsic character. Fleetwood, though strenuous enough, was not so successful as usual, and Brown had a difficult task on hand in subduing Huddersfield’s nippy left wing forwards.
ABLE UNDERSTUDIES
Leg injuries to Stephenson, Smith and Walter brought in Islip, Byers, and Richardson, and ably did the trio acquit themselves. Byers, speedy and centring well, was always a source of trouble to Harland, and Richardson, having once gained the mastery over McDonald, swept the ball across the goalmouth at leisure. Wilson (C.) was a capable leader, but had no luck with his marksmanship which he utilised on every possible occasion. Mann was a roamer and an untiring worker, whose close following up was a vast help to his side. The Everton forwards rarely judged the holding nature of the ground. Their passes frequently fell short. Reid and Williams were the most successive wing, though Irvine and Parry at times put in good work. Chadwick was ill at ease with Wilson (T), and Barkas and Wadsworth as indicated were stalwarts in defence. McDonald was not in his best mood, and this threw additional work on Harland. The goalkeeper, in marked contrast to Taylor, had a busy time, and acquitted himself well. He injured his shoulder in effecting one clearance, and this may prevent him playing to-day. Everton; Harland; Raitt, McDonald; Brown, Fleetwood, Hart (Captain); Parry, Irvine, Chadwick, Williams, and Reid. Huddersfield Town; Taylor; Barkas, Wadsworth; Steele, Wilson (T), Watson; Richardson, Mann, Wilson (C.), Islip and Byers. Referee; H. Hopkinson, Rochdale.

EVERTON’S FAILINGS
The Liverpool Echo- Monday, January 1, 1923
By Bees
Saturday's results showed Sunderland in a merry light, and Huddersfield in little less manner enjoyed themselves at Everton's expense. There can be no doubt about the Yorkshire side being of good standard and well-knit. The side that is well-balanced will always have my vote, for each works for the other and all for each other. Therein lies of  the path of success. Everton are to be commiserated with on one score--they, as usual at homesave against Manchester City and Blackburn, played enlivening football, and fared quite well, and was touch and go all through the first half which team took the vital lead. Now Huddersfield stayed thecourse better than their rivals, because they did not make work for themselves. They swung the ball about and did not stand on ceremonious dribbles, whereas Everton were inclined to do things before they got rid of the ball, which was absurd when one remembers what a glue-pot theywere working on. Huddersfield were well on top in the second half till Mann scored, and then a free kick could easily have turned the game inside out. I refer to the occasion when Chadwick hit the crossbar, and a point then would have meant a pound—and possibly two - to the home side. This was rank bad luck, but clubs make their own luck, and when forwards shot outside or high over one had to imagine two things--either bad shooting or a kindly feeling towards any man who could hit a greasy ball.
THE OTHER SIDE
However, Huddersfield shot in determined manner and at every conceivable Eustace, and therein they showed that the ball could be “punched” aright. Harland had an unenviable time, as the ground was hard to get over, and he had top take the dive at the deep end many times. In truth, he was a very unlucky man in many respects, because in each of the three goals there was a handling incident on the part of the Irishman, and he would have saved all three had the going been good. As it was he first of all touched Byers centre but could not scramble the ball away, while later he punched away and hit Mann’s head and the ball at one and the same time. Finally he did not quite get in to the centre put in late on by Byers, who is a lucky man, I fancy to keep out W.H. Smith. Undoubtedly, however, Huddersfield are a reformed and rejuvenated side, and they are going to make a big noise in the League. They have not lost for the last ten successive games, and Wilson, at centre, will not always be so unlucky with his first-time shots as he was at Goodison Park. I remember his playing at the same ground last year for Spurs, and then he made a great impression, butnow he shinned even better probably because he is looked upon as a goal-getter for his side and must live up to his reputation. At any rate, it would be nice to think other forwards took his first-time principle. He had able lieutenants, none better than Mann, whose personality and pluck counts for much.
WHERE EVERTON FAILED
Everton failed because they were weak in attack, and had the same reliability in the full-backs division that obtained where Huddersfield were concerned. The Yorkshire backs made mistakes rarely; Everton’s pair made mistakes and scored from them in the first half, whereas in the second half they did not net by when failing to clear at any costs- they courted loss of the ball, and lost it. Richardson and Byers as a consequence were speeding along and following up, knowing that dallying in such circumstances might lead to a mistake on the part of the losing side. So it was that the Yorkshire side got the value for their following up. Everton’s half-backs were hard working and successful in the main, and Hunter Hart, save for the period when he was beaten in a tackle by Mann, from which the first goal arrived, was admirable in snapping up passes and making passes to his comrades. Therefore it was all the more surprising that the left-wing pair did not shine. Davie Reid delayed his centres a trifle too long, and Williams did not put the ball accurately. Chadwick at centre, had little chance against T. Wilson, and with such passes as were made, the right-wing pair did best, Irving being the best forward that is the most serviceable. Parry at outside right had little chance to shine, but he is a live forward, and if a shade light, is, nevertheless, one who should train on.

EVERTON BEAT SPURS
The Liverpool Echo, Monday, January 1, 1922
A CHANGE IN THE WALTON AFFAIRS AND TEAM
A DISPUTED PENALTY
“Bee” describes goals by Peacock, Lindsay, Harrison, and Grenyer.
There are further rumours and statements regarding Everton going to Scotland for a dozen and one players. I am not disposed to say anything about the matter until something definite is done. In truth, most of the published statements are void of fact.  There is another matter—the appointment of a manager to succeed Mr. Davie Ashworth. Raisbeck's name has already been hinted in a paper. One could mention a dozen names, but it would not be fair to the men concerned, because they are already with other clubs, and publication of their names would not help their position with their present clubs. Everton today broke the New Year by welcoming the variable Spurs side 'at Walton. The ground was only a trifle drier than that on which Huddersfield on Saturday had fared so well, and Everton hoped the London side would not be so capable in the thick stuff as were the Yorks side. The home side were much curbed through the holiday games, and many of Saturday's players cried off through injury. The team, therefore, was much cut up to begin with. Everton; Harland; Raitt, Livingstone; Brown, Hart (Captain), Grenyer; Chedgzoy, Peacock, Irvine, Williams, Harrison. Tottenham; H. Blake; Clay, Foster; Smith, Low, Grimsdell; Walden, Seed, Lindsay, Handley, Dimmock.
PEACOCK OPNS THE SCORE
It was a dull day, but the dulness, from Everton'spoint of view, evaporated as soon as Peacock scored atter three minutes for the home side. He got his chance from the right wing through Chedgzoy sad Grimsdell getting together and going to earth. -It seemed that Blake imagined Peacock, who was out on his own, must centre, and the real truth was that Peacock himself intended to centre, and kicked half round the ball, the result being that Blake was wrongly positioned for catching. Chedgzoy was injured within the first five minutes, and the Spurs looked for a penalty when Hart handled the ball, but there was no doubt about the case being a genuine accident.
LINDSAY EQUALISES
Chedgzoy returned with his Leftknee damaged, but in the meantime the Spurs had scored good goal through Lindsay taking all the chance that Seed offered. Lindsay was at a very acute angle, much more acute, indeed, than that at which Peacock operated. However, Lindsay put immense force behind his shot, and the Spurs were equal in seven minutes. The wander was that the London side was not one up in the eighth minute, because Handley made a lovely dribble, rounded the defence, and seemed all over a scorer when Livingstone fell from the clouds and hampered him and unbalanced him, and forced him to shoot over the bar. Spurs had recovered from a seemingly lost position, and when Lindsay from long range hit a strong and long ball a goal seemed quite sure. The ball had that trifle of loft, however, that the further it went the higher it travelled, yet it was only a foot or so over the bar when the vital moment was reached.
LIMPING, BUT GAME
It was excellent football, on a ground that was fast drying but was still muddy, and there was much pretty footwork to interest the holiday crowd. For instance, Dimmock beat Brown with his left foot and instantly shot with his right, the ball going quite close to goal. Everton seem as if they cannot go through a match without some damage, and when Chedgzoy limped their task became a difficult one, because the Spurs were very determined and capable. The “gammy” Chedgzoy now put out his best and his worst foot, and when he forced a corner he ably took the spot kick, and also added a shot at a later point of the movement. Low was strong at centre-half for the Spurs, whose attack was very tactical, although Walden did a lot of prancing around to try to get Grenyer mesmerised. However, Walden’s best chance came through faulty defence, Livingstone letting him in, and when the little fellow passed back to seed, the inside right hit the ball first with his left and then with his right. The former was blocked, luckily, and the second was brilliantly saved by Harland, who flung himself to his left hand side and pushed the ball away. This was good goalkeeping indeed.
HARRISON GIVES THE LEAD
Unfortunately, Harland found Raitt and Livingstone not altogether certain in their kicks, whereas the Spurs’ backs had not so far put a foot wrong. Apart from the time when Dimmock hit a cross drive very low and exceptionally close to goal, the Spurs were out of the picture for some minutes, and they were vital minutes, for at the half-hour, Harrison took the lead through a penalty kick for supposed hands against Grimsdell. It was a simple affair, which started with Irvine passing to Peacock, and the latter attempting a pulled shot which to my mind, could not have been handled deliberately by Grimsdell if he had wanted to. In short, it was an accidental handling case, and Grimsdell made a gentle appeal- remembering the law about protests-but failed to get the referee to reconsider the matter at all. Harrison hit a “plonk” ball, which went into the corner of the goal. In the meantime Chedgzoy made a fine dropping centre, which Williams kept in play by headwork, only to see Harrison return the ball too strong top the right wing.
THRILLING ACTION IN GOAL
There was a thrilling and pulsating incident when Foster conceded a free kick for a foul on Chedgzoy. The outside right took the kick, and when the ball came close in Grenyer headed it. The goalkeeper touched the ball but lost possession, and Peacock seemed certain to be able to reach the ball, but in the melee Blake regained possession, and at the same time got a kick on the head through Grenyer following up. Harland broke Seed’s heart by his excellent save of another drive, and then came the penalty perpetration, which, as I have said, was, to my mind, an injustice to the Spurs. As if to recompense his comrades for the penalty, Grimsdell made a drive from Dimmock’s corner, and Harland, in saving he put the ball on the top netting.
(Unfortunately the rest of the article in this column has been torn off-Return from next column)
- a startling change for the man who scored the Cup-Final goal two years ago! Grimsdell had been trying to force a goal by helping the forwards, and when he matched up Raitt committed a foul, and was very careful to show the referee that it was inches outside the penalty area. POPULAR GOAL BY GRENYER
Livingstone and Grenyer had a merry innings against Walden, who found the sticky footwork against his neat footwork. Clay was an excellent back, and he had Smith limping through a collision, by which Irvine was prevented making a goal. From the corner in this incident Everton got their third point. Harrison taking the corner kick and Grenyer hooking the ball around with his left foot pretty high in the air. It was a very popular
(Unfortunately rest of article is torn off and missing)
Central League
Bury res 2, Everton Res 0

EVERTON 3 TOTTENHAM HOTSPURS 1
January 2, 1923. The Liverpool Courier.
EVERTON'S WELCOME VICTORY.
RE-ORGANISED SIDE GAINS VALUABLE POINTS.
EVERTON HIT WOODWORK TWICE
By F. M. N.
Everton gained a welcome two points at the expense of the ‘Spurs at Goodison Park yesterday, after a game in which fortunes fluctuated considerably. The ground was not quite so heavy as on Saturday, and Everton were more suited by the conditions. They started off with a bang for they were a goal up in less than two minutes, Peacock scoring with a smart shot. The success, was welcomed but the play which followed did not inspire confidence in the Blues, and the Spurs for a considerable period had matters all their own way and Lindsay scored a very easy goal within ten minutes. For some time afterwards the visitors were the more polished side, but Harland made some glorious saves. Offside tactics adapted by the ‘Spurs did not help Everton, but later the Blues made a spurt, and a penalty kick awarded against Grimsdel for handling (tackling Peacock; Daily Post) gave Harrison the opportunity to put Everton ahead. Thus at the interval the home side led by two goals to one.
DIMMOCK AS A BACK.
The ‘Spurs were unfortunate in as much as they resumed with Foster in a crippled condition as the result of an injury sustained in the initial half. After a few minutes he went to the extreme left, Dimmock playing full back. Thus the ‘Spurs were greatly handicapped. Still they made a good fight of it. Everton, however, were the better side and when Grenyer cleverly hooked a third goal from a corner the ‘ Spurs were well beaten.
A FASCINATION GAME.
It was a fascination game to watch, and the 20,000 spectators thoroughly enjoyed it. Everton made half a dozen changes, and for the most part the alterations worked out well. Chedgzoy and Peacock made a very live wing, with Irvine a dashing centre. The Irishman, however, was not as effective as on Saturday. Harrison and Williams were not so prominent, though both exhibited skill on occasions. Grenyer was about the best half-back, and his goal was cleverly obtained. Hart was not at home at centre half, but Raitt and Livingstone were sound backs, and Harland was safe in goal.
SPASMODIC SPURS.
The Spurs were spasmodic in their efforts. At times brilliant they fell away considerably. The backs were very aggressive up to the time Foster was injured, and they worked the offside rule for all they were worth with much success. Grimsdell was always a power, and the forwards nippy and elusive. Lindsay and Handley were very quick, but Walden would have preferred firmer going. Dimmock made a good emergency back. Teams: - Everton: - Harland, goal, Raitt, and Livingstone, backs, Brown, Hart (captain), and Grenyer, half-backs, Chedgzoy, Peacock, Irvine, Williams, and Harrison, forwards. Spurs: - Blake, goal, Clay, and Foster, backs, Smith, Lowe, and Grimsdell, half-backs, Walden, Seed, Lindsay, Handley, and Dimmock, forwards.

BURY RESERVES 2 EVERTON RESERVES 0
January 2 1923. The Liverpool Daily Post and Mercury.
CENTRAL LEAGUE
It was a well fought contest at Gigg-lane, but neither side exhibited good finishing power. Everton were much the superior side before the interval but finished badly. Simington, Bury's new Scottish inside left, was going through when he was fouled, Perry scoring from the penalty. In the second stage, Bury had the bulk of the play, and in the last minute Hoyland scored after a fine run. Salt gave a fine exhibition of goalkeeping and Caddick and Downs defended stubbornly, McGrae was the best of a moderate half-back line. The forwards were clever, but erratic in shooting.

BEE’S NOTES
The Liverpool Echo-Tuesday, January 2, 1923
INTENT
Talking of penalty kicks, I think yesterday’s case locally took the biscuit. It undoubtedly affected the ‘Spurs, who at that moment were making their presence severely felt. If Grimsdell handled that ball shot by Peacock then he should go on the balls and gain fame as a juggler. It was impossible for him to handle with intent; in fact, I don’t remember any Everton member making claim that he had handled- everyone was looking for a corner kick. The new rule concerning protests to referees has made the players very calm when debating class is due to start. However, Grimsdell laid his complaint in due course without getting so much as a consideration for the linesman. One other point about the Spurs; Dimmock promises to develop into a good full back; Handley is very clever, and it will surprise you to know that Everton have been after his transfer more than once recently, while when Wilson now of Huddersfield, was with the Spurs Villa offered £5,000 for his transfer without avail-this was two years ago. Last season they could have had him quite cheap. Londoners say that Wilson is no use on a dry ground. Well, in this winter sport, I would like to have him on my side, judging by the way he has played at Everton.
SOME STRENGTH
One feature of yesterday’s game was the return to power and precision of Sam Chedgzoy, who made sparkling runs and centres; and when he shot he got a full bang at the right spot and tested Blake to the full. Considering Chedgzoy had a gashed shin in the first ten minutes, his display was especially worthy; and the help he got from Peacock was another joy, just in the same manner that Grenyer returned to power and simply gripped Walden as tightly as the mud gripped every player. Walden has never been too well held in his visits here. Seed, however, was another proposition, and, indeed, the Spurs’ attacking line as a whole played the sort of football one loves to see and rarely has the opportunity of witnessing. It was varied, wheeling, fast and ‘cute, I do not think that Irvine was an improvement on Chadwick, who, like Williams, may have tired through stress of work and stress of desire to do well. The Spurs, after the interval, had the misfortune to lose Foster, who appeared at outside left for a time, and finally left the field a quarter of an hour from the finish. In the early stages of the second half there was much fire in the Spurs’ attack, Walden excepted, and anything might have happed. It did when a corner led to Grenyer trying a bow at a venture. It is true that Everton had hit the woodwork twice in the game, and it is equally true that in the end Everton were on top of their rivals, but for sheer football ability and strength the Spurs held the palm, and in defence, too-or, to be more precise, at full back- the visitors were superior. Clay’s work throughout was of a sturdy and competent nature, whereas Raitt and Livingstone at times miskicked, and only the excellent goalkeeping of Harland kept the many drives from scoring. As a game, it was really good football on a muddy turf, and there were many exciting incidents. Everton were desperate, and the merest flick of fortune led them to believe in themselves till they felt sure of another home victory. Harrison reappeared through Reid’s injury, and he shaped more like his old self. Hart, at centre-half made some well-timed passes without suggesting that he is quite hearty enough for a pivot.

HART RESTING
The Liverpool Echo -Thursday, January 4 1923
Bee’s Notes
“G.V.L.” writes; Having witnessed Everton’s recent League game in company with several of my friends, and having in mind the 3-0 defeat against Huddersfield, I venture to suggest that the enclosed team would shape very creditably and if not actually bringing off a win, would go a long way towards “stopping” Huddersfield; Harland; Downs, Raitt; Weller, Fleetwood, Hart; Chedgzoy, Peacock, Irvine, Harrison, and Reid. As a fact, Everton have brought in Fleetwood at centre half, Hart who has been unwell, having a rest.

WHAT WILL HAPPEN AT HUDDERSFIELD
The Liverpool Echo- Friday, January 5, 1923
Bee’s Notes
Everton at Huddersfield can expect another hot opposition. All those who have seen, and all those who have played against Huddersfield, vote them a very severe side in muddy conditions. They are essentially a Cup side, too, in build and formation, and they are sure to make a bold shot if they have any luck in the draw. Fleetwood’s return to centre half means that C. Wilson will again face the veteran die-hard. Tommy will keep watch on the smart-moving centre, and I shall not be surprised if he does not “gather him” more successfully than last time they met. In the other ranks we have the continued reappearance of Grenyer, Irvine as centre, and Harrison at outside left. The directors had no other option in view of the victory of last Monday over the Spurs, although that victory might easily be a trappy business and create a confidence that does not tally with future results. Think it over. Huddersfield plan of field. Everton; Harland; Raitt, Livingstone; Brown, Fleetwood, Grenyer; Chedgzoy, Peacock, Irvine, Williams, Harrison. Huddersfield; Taylor; Barkas; Steele, Wilson (T), Watson; Richardson, Mann, Wilson (C.), Islip, Byers.
Everton Res game tomorrow is a Central League “Derby” because Huddersfield are well in the running for the top post, and Everton, in view of their recent displays are going stronger than ever, and are not out of the running. It should be a fine tussle at Goodison Park. Team; Salt; Caddick, Downs; Jeffs, Weller, Rooney; Parry, Miller, Chadwick, Virr and David Reid.

EVERTON’S STIFF TASK
The Liverpool Echo-Saturday, January 6, 1923
By Stork
The Everton club cannot look upon their visit to Huddersfield with much hope in their hearts, for they will not forget the great game the Yorkshire team played down here a week back. Their victory over Tottenham, however, may rub the memory of that defeat out of their minds. Huddersfield are a real good side. They have weight, speed and combination, and the backs are particularly powerful. If Saturday’s game was a general sample of their work I am nor surprised at their quick rise in the table. There is all-round merit in the side, and they are built on cup-fighting lines, and if I were asked to name the winners of the cup I should chance my arm with the “Town” even though it is a rare thing for any club to win the cup two seasons running. Heavy ground should have no terrors for them, as they adopt the right tactics to suit the occasion. How they kept the ball low on the mud at Goodison. It was pretty to watch, and Everton should have learned a lesson from it. Wilson, their centre forward, is one of the best I have seen this season, and although he failed to get a goal against Everton, he was always a dangerous man, with plenty of spare energy. What he can do on hard grounds I am unable to say, but he would certainly be in any side I had anything to do with. The wing men are very fast, and drop in centres which are not for the ‘keeper, but put just far enough back to allow their inside colleagues to get a hit at them. Time and time again Everton have demonstrated their inability to stay the full nicety minutes and this was more than pronounced in last week’s game. Unless they get a good lead in the first portion they are always likely to find oppositions stealing a march on them. They were equally as good as Huddersfield up to a quarter of an hour of the finish, when Huddersfield showed superior staying powers and brought about the defeat of Harland on three occasions. The Irish custodian had made many excellent saves, and the mud around the double-decker goal had a lot to account for. Much as I would like to see an Everton victory, I cannot see how it is going to come about. There are many strange results in football, but even so I cannot brace myself up to expect Everton to triumph over Huddersfield. Teams; Huddersfield; Taylor; Barkas, Wadsworth; Steele, Wilson (T), Watson; Richardson, Mann, Wilson (C), Islip and Byers. Everton.- Harland; Raitt, Livingstone; Brown, Fleetwood, Grenyer; Chedgzoy, Peacock, Irvine, Williams, and Harrison.

EVERTON IN YORKSHIRE
The Liverpool Football Echo- Saturday, January 6, 1923
“FRESHMEN” AFTER THEIR CLEVERLYS VISIT
WHY HART WAS ABSENT
F.E.H. REPORTS DEFEAT AT HUDDERSFIELD
Everton; Harland; Raitt, Livingstone; Brown, Fleetwood, Grenyer; Chedgzoy (Captain), Peacock, Irvine, Williams, Harrison. Huddersfield; Taylor; Barkas, Wadsworth; Mann, Wilson (T), Watson; Richardson, Islip, Wilson (C.), Stephenson, Smith. Referee Mr. H. Hopkinson (Rochdale).
HUDDERSFIELD WIN 1-0
Everton players, having golfed at Cleveleys. were " freshmen" to-day when they appeared at Huddersfield. Hart, their captain, "among those present," but was not playing, as he had been far from well lately, and needed a rest. Huddersfield had to make changes, too. home side had Mann as half back, Steele having been suspended, while Everton brought back Fleetwood, and kept to the forward line that beat Spurs. The players in both teams travelled by the same train from Blackpool, breaking their journey at Manchester for lunch. There was much happy fraternising, and every prospect therefore of a good, clean game. Both teams looked all the better for their stay at the seaside, and all of the them were reported fit.
A MUDDIED FIELD
Golf appears to have been their main relaxation. The weather on their arrival at Huddersfield was delightfully fine, the sun shinning from an almost cloudless sky. The ground, however, was in a dreadfully heavy, muddy state, particularly in the centre, and even a liberal sprinkling of sand scarcely improved it. Chedgzoy signalled his temporary captaincy by winning the toss, and the visitors having the wind in their favour at once pressed, first on the left and then on the right. Wadsworth was too smart for Chedgzoy and the Huddersfield forwards proceeded to attack in dangerous fashion and in combined order. Stephenson put in a good shot which was well gathered, and Everton replied with a breakaway on the left, where Harrison made a very creditable effort which passed fast behind. The home players seemed more at their ease on the treacherous surface than the Evertonians, and they proceeded to open the play out in well-judged fashion. The visitors’ defence, however, was quite good, and after a time Williams got through on his own account, and finished with a shot that was very luckily intercepted by Barkas. Then Peacock pushed his way in, and his effort was saved only at the cost of a corner. This was beautifully placed by the Everton captain, but Taylor got the ball away from the ruck in front of goal.
C. WILSON SCORES
Huddersfield then made great play on the left, and Smith, rounding Raitt, put the ball to C. Wilson, who scored at close range with a swift, low shot. It was a good goal, but I thought Harland might have come out and anticipated the home centre-forward. For a considerable period after, the Huddersfield attack was most determined, and Smith and Stephenson were a constant thorn in the sides of Brown and Raitt. Islip looked all over a winner but he put the ball over the bar, and the next exciting episode occurred when from a fine pass by Richardson C. Wilson headed into goal, but Harland just pulled the ball from under the crossbar. At this point Smith left the field, though there had been so evidence of any injury, and he returned after an absence of less than five minutes. Meanwhile Everton were conspicuous on the left, where Harrison and Williams tried hard to get the better of Barkas, but without any semblance of success. On the other wing Chedgzoy had a glorious opening when he shot feebly yards wide of the mark. Nevertheless, the visitors were now enjoying a fair share of the attack, but the necessary finish was wanting. Raitt was again troubled by Smith, who put in an oblique dropping shot that was smartly intercepted.
MANN SPOILS THE PICTURE
At the other end Everton were once more in the picture on the left, but this time Mann proved the stumbling block. A minute later Chedgzoy was again on his toes over the slippery surface, when he was rudely pulled down by Watson. The subsequent free kick was cleared, but the International forward returned immediately to the attack and cutting in with wonderful cleverness, he finished with a ground shot that Taylor nearly allowed to slip under him. He just recovered, however, and the subsequent movements were on the home right. The ball was swung right across the field to Smith, but this time Brown was able to clear the danger. Chedgzoy was next away like a hare, and there was a regular passage at arms between him and Wadworth, honours eventually resting with the Yorkshire defenders. Another sally on the part of the Everton outside right terminated in his again being grassed by Watson, and the next episode was a laudable effort on the part of Irvine which failed to fructify.
EVERTON PENNED IN
The Huddersfield forwards made stronger pressure as the interval approached, Smith twice trying to find the target almost from the corner flag, while on another occasion C. Wilson drove past the upright by a mere matter of inches. Everton tried hard to equalise in the few minutes that remained before the crossing over, but there was still the same weakness in their final method of attack. Irvine was once almost through, but he hesitated and was lost. Peacock then got away, but he was hustled off the ball, and Taylor had no difficulty in clearing.
Half-time; Huddersfield 1, Everton 0
Although Everton were behind at the interval and in spite of their erratic finishing, they had shown many bits of excellent work, but they were opposed to a more strenuous side. There were 16,000 people present when the game was resumed. Huddersfield at once raced down through Richardson who passed to Wilson, and the latter beat Harland. However, the shot did not count. The visitors could not get going, and the home attack developed with additional keenness.
HARLAND AT BAY
A corner was forced on the right, and from this T. Wilson sent the leather high over the bar. A few minutes later C. Wilson got between the Everton backs, and sent in a tremendous low drive, which Harland literally had to throw himself at in order to save his goal. After a time the visitors managed to make ground on the right, but Peacock lost possession when well placed. Huddersfield’s pressure was well relieved first by Fleetwood and then by Grenyer, but the Yorkshire vanguard were soon busy again in front of their opponents goal. After a time the visitors managed to make ground on the right, but Peacock lost possession when well placed. Huddersfield’s pressure was well; relieved first by Fleetwood and then by Grenyer, but the Yorkshire vanguard were soon busy again in front of their opponents goal. Fleetwood and Irvine attempted to remove the venue, but Barkas passed the ball back to the keeper, who had ample time to kick clear. Another breakaway by Everton proved abortive, for Chedgzoy put wide and his next centre was dealt with by Wadsworth. This led to further attacks by Wilson and his wings, but both Raitt and Livingstone were now showing greater confidence and many of their clearance were admirable. The work of the home forwards was not so incisive as in the first period, and Everton as a consequence were more frequently seen in the firing line. Harrison was almost through when he was blauked, and Barkas ion stopping a rush was temporarily knocked out. The closing stages of a vigorous contest were fought with great determination by both sides. Final; Huddersfield 1, Everton 0

CENTRAL LEAGUE
The Liverpool Football Echo- Saturday, January 6, 1923
EVERTON RES v.  HUDDERSFIELD RES AT GOODISON
Both teams are in close running for the leadership of the Central League, and there was a big attendance at Goodison Park. The opening stages were fairly even. Gradually Everton settled down, and for a time the Huddersfield defence was sorely tried. Parry was conspicuous on the home right when he centred perfectly and Chadwick drove in first time, but Massey saved smartly. Huddersfield replied with a raid in the centre, and when the situation looked serious Caddick headed clear. After eighteen minutes’ play Huddersfield scored. The goal came against the run of play, for the home team had dominated the game up to this stage. The goal came about in this way; The leather was carried along the visitors’ left by Falk, who sent in a terrific centre, and Johnson had no difficulty in heading beyond Salt’s outstretched arm. After the kick off Everton made play, and Parry, who had given a bright display, was wending his way towards the Town goal. When a foot inside the penalty area he was tackled by smith, who handled, and the referee did not hesitate in awarding Everton with a penalty kick. Chadwick was entrusted with the kick, and scored with a swift ground drive, Huddersfield advanced on the right, but Downs nipped in and dispossessed Johnson. A few minutes later Everton had taken the lead, Parry again being responsible for the goal. The Everton winger gained possession and raced goalwards. When almost on the goal line he drove the leather sharply into the ruck of players in the goalmouth the ball striking the outstretched foot of A.W. Smith and going into the net. With a goal lead, Everton continued to have the best of matters, and Weller had hard lines when he compelled Massey to dive to clear a swift drive. The homesters were certainly superior in every department in comparison with the visitors whose combination at times was inclined to be a bit ragged, whereas the Evertonians adopted the short accurate passing. As a result they were repeatedly on the attack and on the run of the play deserved the lead.
Half-time; Everton 2, Huddersfield 1
The second half was contested more evenly and at a fast pace, and although both defences came in for a good deal of work Salt, in comparison to Massey had little to do. Downs was in good form, repeatedly breaking any combined attacks on the part of the Town forwards. Virr scored a third for Everton Reserves.

COUNTY COMBINATION
The Liverpool Football Echo- Saturday, January 6, 1923
Last Saturday results
Monks Hall and Everton drew 1-1. The ground was very heavy, but both teams soon settled down and made the best of matters. Monks Hall had a penalty goal lead until the Everton left-half equalised from a long dropping shot, the home goalkeeper letting the ball slip through his hands.

STUD MARKS
The Liverpool Football Echo- Saturday, January 6, 1923
By Louis T. Kelly

• Why did the referee allow Harland to carry the ball seven or eight yards, and why did he mulct Grimsdell in that penalty on glue-like Goodison? That’s where you get stuck.
• McDonald opened the New year in bed, and Fleetwood the reverse of fit
• Grenyer’s success was one of the brightest features of the Spurs’ match
• Peacock gave one of his finest and brightest forward shows. His work like that of Grenyer, must have greatly pleased the management.
• Monday was Irvine’s first appearance this season at Goodison in the centre forward position for Everton League; hence some allowance must needs be made.
• His presence appeared to infuse greater dash into the home attack, however.
• It is team work that has counted in the main, and this was made abundantly evident at Everton.

HUDDERSFIELD TOWN 1 EVERTON 0
January 8, 1923. The Liverpool Courier.
BLUES DISALLOWED GOAL.
AN INCIDENT THAT COST A POINT.
By F.M.N.
The Everton players are emphatic in their belief that they scored a good goal in the second half at Huddersfield, but the official result is that the Town won by a goal to nil. It is impossible for a referee to see everything and apparently when Chedgzoy centred and Williams headed the ball up he was under the impression it hit the under part of the bar and bounced down. From my position in the centre of the stand it was impossible for me to see whether the ball hit the bar or the top of the net, but I was informed by the players after the game that the ball hit the netting and not the bar. Anyway the point did not count and Everton retired beaten. I give full credit to the home side for their victory, which on the general run of the play they deserved. They were the more trustful in their methods, and their attacks were always laden with danger. Harland had far more to do than Taylor, but the gods were not good to the winners in front of goal, several shots being luckily charged down, while a goal was disallowed for offside and Wilson hit the post when a drive with the other foot must have found the net.
WHY HUDDERSFIELD WON.
Everton were very near on other occasions but generally Huddersfield were the more convincing. Everton made the mistake of holding the ball too close and the backs dallied too much. Still it was a gruelling game and Everton fought hard every inch of the way. They came out with flashes of brilliance, but the home defence was not to be mastered. Harland made some good saves, and he had no chance with the close range shot with which Wilson scored. Raitt has played remarkably good football since he joined Everton, but he was off colour on the occasion, and failed to cope with the feet-footed Smith in the early stages, when the chief damage was done. Livingstone made some fine clearances, but his coolness at times, is his undoing. Still, he was by no means the least successful back.
GRENYER'S SUCCESS.
The Everton halves stuck to their task in workmanlike fashion. Grenyer was the most successful of the trio, though Fleetwood and Brown were little behind in point of effectiveness. The forwards as a line did not inspire confidence. Wadsworth and his colleagues usually had their measure, though there were times when the Blues flattered. Chedgzoy gave occasional glimpses of his teal worth, but Peacock played a lot better, as also has Irvine. Williams and Harrison did fairly well, but the winger held the ball too long, and against such players as Barkas and Mann this did not pay. Taylor made one mistake when he almost let a drive from Chedgzoy through after he had stopped the ball. Wadsworth is a great back. He kicks like a horse, has plenty of pace, and is infinitely resourceful under pressure. Mann was a clever half, and Wilson a dour defender. Wilson (C.) in the centre proved a dashing raider, and he was ably assisted by the men on either side. Teams: - Huddersfield Town: - Taylor, goal, Barkas, and Wadsworth, backs, Mann, T. Wilson, and Watson, half-backs, Richardson, Islip, C. Wilson, Stephenson, and Smith, forwards. Everton: - Harland, goal, Raitt, and Livingstone, backs, Brown, Fleetwood (captain), and Grenyer, half-backs, Chedgzoy, Peacock, Irvine, Williams, and Harrison, forwards. Referee Mr. H. Hopkinson.

EVERTON RESERVES 3 HUDDERSFILED TOWN RESERVES 1
January 8, 1923. The Liverpool Courier.
CENTRAL LEAGUE (Game 24)
Everton Reserves defeated Huddersfield Town Reserves, at Goodison Park on Saturday, by 3 goals to 1, and fully deserved their victory. The Blues were far the better side in the opening stages, the visitors being kept on the defensive for quite a time. It was largely due to fine efforts on the part of Massey, the Tykes' custodian, that Everton did not score, for on more than one occasion he diverted strong drives from Chadwick, who was unlucky in not opening the scoring. As it was, the visitors scored first, Johnson heading in a free kick taken by Talck. This goal was absolutely undeserved on the run of the play, but Everton drew level immediately afterwards through the medium of Chadwick, who converted a penalty kick for hands, while they took the lead soon afterwards, when Smith shot into his own goal in an attempt to intercept a centre from Parry. Virr placed the Blues further ahead in the second half, and though the town did quite their share of the attacking, there was no further score. Downs and Caddick were good backs for the home team, Weller the pick of the halves. Chadwick, despite his slowness in taking opportunities, was the best forward, being the only one really to extend Massey, Who kept a very good goal indeed. Reid was badly supported, while Huddersfield's best were Brown, Johnson, and Talck.

A DOUBLE DOSE
Athletic News- Monday, January 8, 1923
THE VERSATILITY OF FRANK MANN
HUDDERSFIELD TOWN 1, EVERTON 0
By Icarus
Though their victory at home was not so decisive that at Goodison Park, Huddersfield Town have avenged the two defeats sustained the corresponding games last season. This in itself is satisfying, but when it is accomplished with men of merit out of the team on the two occasions the feat is made doubly consoling. On Saturday, a rearrangement of the Huddersfield ranks was necessary. Smith and Stephenson were again together on the left wing, but, owing to the suspension of David Steele, the right half-back, Mann dropped back into the intermediate line and Islip was placed at inside right. Of course, Frank Mann was quite at his ease, for he has occupied the berth often enough, and he is of the type of player who can adapt himself with success to most positions on the field, whilst the condition of the playing piece never seems to perturb him. The ground at Leeds-road was heavy, and both sides found the surface treacherous. But Mann revelled in his work and the slime underfoot, and played a half-hack game of the highest class, choosing tactics best suited to the occasion. More who were at Goodison Park the week before would remember that it was largely Mann’s work, that brought success to Huddersfield. He scored a brace of goals, and in the return encounter he made the preliminary move which resulted in the only goal being scored.
How the Coal Came.
This came after only nine minutes’ play, and was the reward of thoughtful combination and rare opportunism . Mann lifted the ball out to Watson, who was quick to see an opening to pass down the wing. The ball seemed to be travelling too fast even for Smith, but the wingman outpaced his opponents, baffled Raitt, and, after bearing down upon Harland, glided the ball deftly across goal for Charles Wilson to end movement by defeating the Everton custodian. The home centre-forward came very near to repeating the performance just afterwards, but Harland parried and held a delightfully-headed ball just below the crossbar. But it was not a game in which the goalkeepers were called upon unduly. Harland had move to do than Taylor, though the latter was once sorely tried bya short-range shot from Chedgzoy.  In the second half Charles Wilson again scored, but was adjudged offside. The Huddersfield men were always musters. They were sounder in the rear divisions, and their forwards were quicker on theball than those of Everton. But there was a period in the second half when the men from the banks of the Mersey appeared likely to snap a goal, and when they played together better than at any time during the game. Taylor, however, was ably protected by Barkas and Wadsworth that the Everton forwards had few chances of testing him. Wadsworth stood out because of his polished work in kicking and tackling, but his partner, more ponderous in style, was quick to see danger and equally alert to frustrate the plans of his opponents. He played a sound, stolid game.
When Richardson Failed.
Thomas Wilson was a power in the half-back line, and Watson supported his wing. But Mann was outstanding, both for his tackling and his placing. Richardson, I thought, was slow to take advantage of Mann’s good services, for the outside right did not always get the ball across to perfection. Islip and Stephenson worked well for their wing partners, and also for Charles Wilson. The last-named, always on the look-out for an opening, was the most dangerous forward on view. He swept the ball to his wings, and made some fine individual bursts. Smith always made good use of the ball, and caused Brown and Raitt much anxiety. Although he was not too well covered, Harland showed that he is a first-class keeper. He was quick to anticipate danger, and lost no time in gathering and clearing the ball. The work of the Everton backs was not impressive and Raitt was a disappointment. He demonstrated neither confidence for the ability to kick with accuracy. He was prone to seek relief in touch, and to pass across the goalmouth to his partner. Livingstone made some neat tackles, but he did not always place the ball with judgment. The Everton half-backs never got a grip on their opponents. Fleetwood passed well, but was inclined to pry Chedgzoy too freely, while, though he commenced strongly, Grenyer tired, and Brown could not cope with an industrious wing. Forward, the visitors never showed the same combination as the home men. I thought that left wing pair might have been utilised more. Whenever he got the ball Harrison did something useful, and Williams was crafty in his moves. Chedgzoy was apt to hold the ball, and showed little resource in his efforts to outwit Wadsworth. Peacock and Irvine were rarely, dangerous, although they made some nice passes. Huddersfield Town; Taylor; Barkas, Wadsworth; Mann, Wilson (T), Watson; |Richardson, Islip, Wilson (C.), Stephenson, and Smith (W.H). Everton; Harland; Raitt, Livingstone; Brown, Fleetwood, Grenyer; Chedgzoy (Captain), Peacock, Irvine, Williams, and Harrison. Referee; H. Hopkinson, Rochdale.

EVERTON PUT UP GOOD GAME IN YORKS
The Liverpool Echo- Monday, January 8, 1923
By F.E.H
When one comes to think it over, Everton, on the whole, were rather unfortunate in failing to secure a point against their powerful Yorkshire opponents on Saturday. They did not enjoy anything like so much of the attack, but there was a period in the second half when their footwork-especially considering the wretched condition of the playing patch- was extremely clever, especially on the wings. There is no necessity for me to retell the story of the struggle, except to say that it was fast and full of incident. Huddersfield’s goal came after ten minutes’ play, and in my humble judgement Harland ought to have saved it. He seemed to hesitate and Charles Wilson almost “walked” the ball into the net with a short shot. Later on Williams struck the inside of the woodwork and the ball descended-as many of the players declare-over the goal line. But as there appeared to be no confident appeal for a goal the referee did not interfere. Had it been otherwise the whole complexion of the game might have been changed. Everton were seen at their best in the second period. They “stayed the course” even better than their opponents and gave us some glimpses of delightful football, which was pretty but ineffective. Irvine once headed inches on the wrong side; Peacock drove as closely as may be; and Chedgzoy showed the art of accurate centring. But all these efforts proved fruitless. The forward line weakness lay in proper lack of finishing. The half-back trio, on the other hand, were splendid in their efforts to hold the Huddersfield attack. Grenyer and Fleetwood-age will never wither him-worked with conspicuous skill and strength. The backs were disappointing on the whole. Harland, apart from the incident already mentioned, was agile and alert between the sticks.

BEE’S NOTES
The Liverpool Echo- Tuesday, January 9, 1923
Everton have decided to bring in Hart at left half back, and Chadwick as centre for the Cup-tie-otherwise the team is as usual; Harland; Raitt, Livingstone; Brown, Fleetwood, Hart; Chedgzoy, Peacock, Chadwick, Williams, and Harrison.

COMING TO EVERTON.
January 13, 1923. The Liverpool Courier.
Once a certain Lanarkshire Club is out of the Scottish ties, Everton are to have the services of one of their half-backs. A similar report is correct in regard to McDougall, the talented centre-forward of Airdrieonian, whose name is connected with Newcastle United. Everton also approached Scott, the centre-forward of Larkhill Thistle, a junior team.

EVERTON  v  BRADFORD
The Liverpool Echo- Saturday, January 13, 1923
By Stork
At the first glance the Everton-Bradford tie looked a fairly good thing for the Goodison brigade, but on delving into the Avenue’s recent records it makes one wonder if the Evertonians have such an easy thing on hand. Up to January 8 the Yorkshiremen have played fourteen games and have only twice suffered defeat, and even if the class of football; in the Third Division is not quite up to the standard associated with the First League you can bet your boots that it is a hard school, where a side must be able to stay the course in the hardest of games. Bradford’s recent displays away from home have been astonishingly good, and tack on to that the fact that they have always done well in the first round and what solution do we arrive at? A quiet confidence in the Avenue camp. They regard their chances at Everton as hopeful, although they realise the magnitude of their task. That they are leaders of their particular division should compel respect from even a First Division side. Their main strength is at half-back where Fell, Howie, and Hubbart are playing rare football. Great tacklers, they also have an eye for construction, giving the forwards many fine opportunities with takeable forward pushes which should bring big goal crops. Of the forwards the left wing is perhaps the better. Turnbull and Peel are playing a delightful game. Week after week they are proving themselves the backbone of the attack, and if only Bradley and McLean would improve on their work many more goals would come Bradford’s way. Bradford have trained at home and Trainer Lundie reports his boys all fit. Everton have brought back Chadwick, which adds weight to the attacking line, Irvine is all too light for the centre-piece, where a wee bit of weight is necessary. Chadwick is the biggest centre forward playing at the present moment, and he is a rare shot; and if he will only sharpen up his “get-off-the-mark,” he will soon have a big goal crop. A word to the Everton team. Don’t take your opponents lightly. If you are to have a bit of fun, have it when you have obtained a commanding lead. Remember Crystal Palace! Get away from the whistle well, and go ahead until you have a good lead. This has a demoralising effect upon opponents. You play good football, good enough to account for Bradford; but let’s have no finicking, and then an Everton victory is almost certain. Teams; Everton; Harland; Raitt, Livingstone; Brown, Fleetwood, Hart; Chedgzoy, Peacock, Chadwick, Williams, and Harrison. Bradford;- Scattergood; Brabdon, McCluggage; Fell, Howie, Hubbart; Thompson, McLean, Bradley, Turnbull, and Peel.

SURPRISE SIGNING NEWS
The Liverpool Football Echo- Saturday, January 13, 1923
MERSEYSIDE CLUB TAKES A BIG INTERTEST IN A FAMOUS SCOTTISH HALF BACK
Bee’s
For some time Everton and Scottish clubs have been “tallying” according to rumour and some reports but nothing has arisen, and the “Echo” has barred all reference to the statements. Now, however, I can state that there has been a definite move on the part of the club at Walton towards a neighbouring city, where there has been a rumpus and a famed Scottish centre half back has been put on the transfer list. The man, as you may guess, is McBain, of Manchester United,

WHEN BENNETT WAS STOPPED ON LANDING STAGE
The Liverpool Football Echo-Saturday, January 13, 1923
Bee’s
Tom Bennett, whose photograph I give below, died on Thursday night through consumption. He was a grand driving type of centre-forward in his healthy days, and here was much that was romantic about his football, for he joined Everton from America, but was turned down. Later he went to South Liverpool, and was about to sail for America when the Everton director, Mr. W.J. Sawyer, got in touch and took him from the boat. He played some war-seasons for Liverpool, and did grand work down the middle.
West Bromwich are playing at Green-lane (Trans ground) on February 24. This is an arrangement as a consequence of the signing of Hallows and Bennet, who were from the Broadgreen school team to the Midlands last back-end.

COUNTY COMBINATION
The Liverpool Football Echo-Saturday, January 13, 1923
Last week’s result
Everton lost at home to Monk’s Hall by 3-0. The home team took advantage of a slight wind, but right from the kick-off Monk Hall gave them a surprise. A lightning shot from the outside left had the goalkeeper well beaten. Monks Hall played well, and were soon rewarded with a second, and before the interval had scored number 3. In the second half Monks Hall continued their attack, but full-time arrived with no further score.

EVERTON DRAW AT HOME
The Liverpool Football Echo, Saturday, January 13, 1923
“STORK” REPORTS WALTON INCIDENTS
BRADFORD A DOGGED SIDE
HOW YOUNG McLEAN SHAPED IN THE FRONT LINE
Everton; Harland; Raitt, Livingstone; Brown, Fleetwood, Hart (Captain); Chedgzoy, Peacock, Chadwick, Williams, Harrison. Bradford; Scattergood; Brandon, McCluggage; Fell, Howie, Hubbert; Thompson, McLean, Bradley, Turnbull, Peel. Everton at home to Bradford at Goodison Park, enticed a good sized crowd. Bradford had some of the old school in their team, and the appearance of Turnbull and Davie McLean’s brother was something worth watching. Everton brought back Chadwick and Hart to their customary places. Owing to the counter attraction at Anfield, also the dull weather, the attendance at Goodison Park was on the small side, 18,000 being a liberal estimate when the game opened. There was nothing of note in the opening movements, although Everton were early on the attack, only to be easily repelled by Brandon and McCluggage. Harland was the first keeper to become active, when he caught and cleared an oblique shot by Peel. Everton’s stock rose a point when McCluggage miskicked, but he made a good recovery before Chedgzoy could reach the ball. A pleasing feature was the method adopted by the Evertonians. They forsook the close passing game for the more effective swinging passes, with the natural result that more ground was made, and in a shorter space of time. Raitt came in for an ovation by reason of a clever stab which prevented Turnbull getting through.
A WHIZ FROM TURNBULL
Many had expected a walk-over for Everton, but after ten minutes Bradford were just as dangerous as their opponents, and Tunstall once drove in a fierce rising shot that whizzled over the bar. Raitt, who had shown excellent judgement both in tackle and pass, enabled Chedgzoy to go on with a ball that Howie had failed to gather. Chedgzoy took the ball close into goal before centring. His pass was an ideal one, and Chadwick, who was standing in front of goal unattended, had only to place the ball to put his side ahead. Chadwick made a mistake, however, and drove the ball fiercely only to get underneath it for the ball to fly nearly into the double-decker stand. The Bradford goal then underwent further pressure, and when a free kick was given for a foul on Chadwick, Scattergood adopted his usual method of coming out of goal and leaving his backs between the posts.
BRADFORD TAKE THE ELAD
Chadwick took the free kick and struck the upright a terrific blow. This was, indeed, hard luck for the Darwen boy, for all the Bradford defence was beaten. A couple of corners to Everton did not help matters. A surprising turn in the course of events came at the eighteenth minute, when Bradford took the lead. Raitt made a mistake when he essayed a tackle on Peel, who was allowed to go through on his own, and from not more than ten yards out squeeze the ball between Harland and the near post. This goal acted like a tonic on the visitors, and they came near to adding another when Turnbull grazed the crossbar. Bradford’s head was all against the run of the play, but they taken their chances whereas Everton had let theirs slip by. Everton made strenuous efforts to rub off the arrears, but try how they would they could not divert the ball past Scattergood. The Everton left wing was left out in the cold all too long, and most of their progress was entrusted to the right wing. Bradford resorted to all defence. Turnbull became a full back, and saved several dangerous looking movements from Chedgzoy. Everton were superior in the matter of football, but Bradford were amazingly fast on the ball. The halves were particularly tireless in breaking up so much so that they forgot to help their forward colleagues.
CHADWICK’S UNFORTUNATE TRAIT
Hart showed good judgement when he stopped Mclean from breaking through, and then Hubbert was knocked out with a powerful drive by Brown, which had followed a corner clearance. Everton had another chance when Chadwick received the ball clear of any opponents, but again that famous trait of his, slowness in getting away, robbed him.  He touched the ball just on the penalty line, but hesitated just long enough to allow McCluggage and Brandon to step in and clear. The Yorkshiremen came near to giving Everton a goal. Chedgzoy, who was capable of beating his half-back and back at any moment, slipped around them, and lobbed in a centre that was headed almost into the Bradford net by one of their own defenders. It was an unpleasing sight to witness Raitt make a deliberate kick at Peel. The last five minutes of the first half had not given much room for thought, as most of the play was confined to midfield. Half-time.- Everton 0, Bradford 1
A STUBBORN DEFENCE
On resuming, Bradford’s one idea was to keep Everton out, and in the hope of carrying this into effect they called all their forces to their aid when Everton made an attack. Peacock took a pass from Chadwick, and raced clean through on his own, but in the race with Scattergood the honour went to keeper, who kicked the ball away from the outside right’s toe, just as he was about to shoot. At long last Harrison got an opportunity, which he made the best use of, with the result that the Bradford goal underwent a heavy bombardment, but try how they would Everton could not break down the Bradford defence. There was a strong appeal for a penalty by the Everton players, but the referee said “No.” At this point Everton were right on top of their opponents, who were kicking here, there, and everywhere to keep their goal intact. Everton’s luck was dead out, however, whilst Scattergood was in his very best form, and it was entirely due to his brilliance that the Avenue were still in the lead. He made a brilliant save from Chadwick, following good work by Harrison and Williams, and later he was well in position in the event of a storming drive by Chadwick curling in instead of curling out, which latter it did.
WORKING TOWARDS LEVEL TERMS
When Everton were awarded a corner the only man who did not take any active part in the defence of his goal was Bradley, the centre forward, who was lying well up in case of a chance coming his way. Peel, who had been the Bradford danger throughout got the better of a tussle with Raitt, and cutting right into goal he sent in a shot which Harland smothered. To my mind, a pass would have served a better purpose, for two of his colleagues were standing with nobody to interfere. Again Bradford nearly presented Everton with a goal when, by a mistake, a defender put his side in jeopardy, but the ball eventually came to Harrison, who drove wide.
CHEDGZOY’S SLASHING GOAL
With only eight minutes to go all seemed lost from an Everton point of view, but Hart centring from a  throw-in, gave Chedgzoy a capital chance, which the latter made no mistake with, slashing the ball past Scattergood, who was helpless to save. Final; Everton 1, Bradford 1.

EVERTON 1 BRADFORD PARK AVENUE 1
January 15, 1923. The Liverpool Courier.
FA CUP ROUND ONE.
THRILLING FINISH AT GOODISON.
EVERTON'S BELATED EQUALSER.
By F. M. N.
It is indeed strange how frequently the cup upsets all caluations with regard to form and class. The only explanation one can offer is that the excitement at the knock-out competition upset players and put their nerves on edge. Certainly Everton's forwards must have been affected by the importance of the occasion on Saturday, especially when it came to settling the issue near goal. Had Chadwick and his colleague taken their chances the Blues must have beaten Bradford at the first time of asking, but the team are to meet once more to decide which is enter the second round. Due credit must be given to Bradford for the fine fight they made against more skilful opponents, but as a combined force they were not to be compared with the home side who could do anything but score for the greater part of the game. EVERYTHING BUT SCORE.
Time after time Everton worked the ball up but something usually went wrong with the final effort. Granted that the Evertonians were unfortunate in several of their efforts, the ball frequently flashing inches wide, they should have scored more than one goal. The great error of the day occurred in the first half, when Chedgzoy gave the ball to Chadwick three yards from goal. Ninety nine times out of a hundred he, would score from such a position, but the centre forward on this occasion in some unaccountable way, lifted the ball over the bar. Probably no one was more surprised and disappointed than Chadwick himself, when he found that what he intended to be a mere touch into the net lifted the leather into the air. A THRILLING MOMENT.
When Peel slipped Raitt in rather easy fashion on the half way line and went on to score a goal single handed, it seemed that Everton's luck was dead out. For the major portion of the game after the visitors' goal Everton were the aggressors.
THE EQUALISER.
Most people had given the game up for lost when the equaliser came. It was a thrilling moment. There were only about eight minutes to go when hart flashed the ball across the field. As usual there was a bunch of players in the goal area, but Chedgzoy caught the ball as it bounced and with a left hook shot he cleverly steered it into the net. Immediately there was an indescribable scene. The spectators went wild with delight, hats being thrown into the air regardless of what happened to them, and the cheering continued for several minutes. Everton played extremely well at the outset and victory only seemed to be a question of time. The forwards, however, did not finish well, and Chadwick was right of his game. On one occasion, however, the centre-forward was decidedly unfortunate, when with a terrific drive from a free kick he hit the post. Chadwick, like his colleagues, only needed the encouragement of a goal and Everton would probably have won by an ample margin. Peacock and Chedgzoy work very hard, and they were decidedly the more effective wing, and near the finish Peacock took the centre berth to try and force a goal. The halves were sounded, all three playing with fine judgement, and for the most part quite held their opponents. Raitt was uncertain at times and Livingstone was the better back, Harland did not have a great deal to do.
A BUSTLING SIDE.
Bradford are a bustling side with a very sound defence. Scattergood retains much of his old skill, and Brandon and McCuggare are good defenders. Howie was the best of the half backs, and Peel and Thompson the extreme wingers, were the outstanding forwards. Teams : - Everton: - Harland, goal, Raitt, and Livingstone, backs, Brown, Fleetwood, and Hart (captain), half-backs, Chedgzoy, Peacock, Chadwick, Williams, and Harrison, forwards. Bradford Park Avenue: - Scattergood, goal, Brandon, and McCuggare, backs, Fell, Howie, and Hubbert, half-backs, Thompson, McLean, Bradley, Turnbull, and Peel, forwards.

McBAIN AND EVERTON
January 15, 1923. The Liverpool Courier.
BLUES' JIB AT TRANSFER FEE.
Since the announcement was made that McBain, the Manchester United half-back, had been placed on the transfer list Everton along with other clubs, have made inquires as to what fee the United require. The figure quoted was so sustainable that quickly frightened possible buyers away, and as the present fee, at any rate, there is no likelihood of the player joining the Everton camp. Few, if any clubs are inclined to pay fancy prices nowadays, and the United may find a necessary to reduce considerably the original figure, If this is done, the Everton Club no doubt will complete with other clubs, but to stake, as one paper has done, that McBain is definitely joining Everton is absolutely incorrect.

CHANCES EVERTON MISSED
January 15, 1923. The Evening Express
Blues Ready For Bradford Replay
By CRI
If a team fails to take chances the gods give they cannot hope to make progress in the Cup competition. But at times, no matter how well a team plays in the open nothing will go right near goal so that luck, good or had, plays a prominent part in the national competition. Everton were certainly the better side on Saturday (writes Liver), but Bradford deserve every praise for the fine fight they made. Subjected to prolonged spells of pressure, the visitors backs and half backs stuck to their task gallantly, and very nearly succeeded in keeping out the Blues altogether. Everton undoubtedly gave their supporters a terrible fright, and it was only a few minutes from the end that Chedgzoy gave the desired relief. Whether the Evertonians will make amends on Wednesday remains to be seen, but on Saturday’s form the Blues should finish on the right side if they play their proper game.
A Sound Defence
The main feature of the Yorkshire team is the defence, Scattergood is still a most skillful custodian, and he has two good backs to protect him Brandon and McCluggage. Howie is a most serviceable half-back, and he certainly did much to upset the Everton line. I am told that the Bradford forwards did not play their usual style of game, trying to emulate Everton instead of swinging the ball about. It was only on occasions they impressed, though Peel and Thompson were most enterprising wingers. Raitt found in Peel a most elusive opponent, and the full back must pay more attention o this player on Wednesday. Peel scored a goal single-handled and the same player nearly sealed Everton’s rate with a similar effort in the second half. He defeated Raitt as he had done before, but this time Harland saved his shot. Had Peel placed the ball in the centre where the other forwards were waiting, Everton would not have another chance.
Blues out of Luck
Everton, I must admit had absolutely no luck with their shots, and several times the ball was placed outside when it should have been propelled into the net. The Blues front line did not maintain the tactics with which they started the game, and the play was not sufficiently distributed. The most was not made of the left wing. Peacock and Chedgzoy were in capital trim, and Williams and Harrison did well at times, but were a trifle off the mark in their shooting. Chadwick tried hard and he received some nasty knocks but it seemed that the occasion was too much for him. Had he scored when the great chance came Everton would have won by half a dozen goals. The halves played their parts well, all three doing good work, and Livingstone was the better back, Raitt being rather uncertain in his tackling Harland was not seriously troubled but Peel’s shot beat him all right. All arrangements are complete for the replay on Wednesday. Everton intend to take the players for a walk in the West Kirby district tomorrow, and the men travel to Bradford by the 9.40 train on Wednesday morning.
A special excursion train will leave Exchange Station at 11 o’clock for Bradford, returning at 6.10. Return fare 8s 9d.

EVERTON v  BRADFORD
Yorkshire Post and Leeds Intelligencer-Monday 15 January 1923
BRADFORD TEAM DO WELL
Bradford accomplished one the best performances of the day in forcing a replay with Everton at Goodison Park, and Park Avenue on Wednesday the Yorkshire club will have the opportunity of adding considerably to receipts which suffered from the clash with the Liverpool-Arsenal tie at Anfield. it was, there was only the moderate attendance 18,000, and the receipts amounted to £1,113. The Everton attack has only its own shortcomings at close quarters to blame for its failure settle the issue at the first attempt, for especially in the first half were innumerable opportunities of scoring thrown away. At the same time, credit must be given the Bradford defence for its stout resistance of many a hot bombardment. Everton owed most of their pressure to the scheming of Peacock and the speed and cleverness of Chedgzoy, and it was from the left wing that a splendid opening was made for Chadwick early in the game. From only three yards range, however, the Everton centre forward lifted the ball high over the Bradford goal. That was the precursor of a number of similar failures, but the Park Avenue side won the fullest advantage from the only scoring chance which went their way in the first half. Raitt was dilatory in getting rid of the ball near the half-way line, and Peel, dispossessing him, dribbled forward without opposition into the Everton penalty area. Delivering an oblique shot from about ten yards range, the Bradford left winger crowned the best individual effort of the match beating Harland, after twenty minutes’ play, and that lead was still the visitors’ at hall-time. With Turnbull apt to fall back to the assistance of the defence in the second half, there was little sting about the Bradford attack after the interval, and the cleverness of Peel was for the most part the neglected. While theEverton defence was only troubled by the individual forays of Bradley, their attack continued to assault the Bradford goal force, but for all their pressure Scattergood was rarely in difficulties. Howie kept such a close watch on Chadwick during this period that the home centre forward was never able to look like the slightest semblance of an opening through which to retrieve his early blunder, but Hubbert and McCluggage were frequently battling with the combination of Peacockand Chedgzoy. Fell, on the other hand, kept such a close watch on Williams that Harrison was given few with changes, and with less responsibility on his own wing. Brandon was able toget across the assistance of his less experienced colleague. In that way, Scattergood was well covered, and the dangerous shots which got through to him were dealt with in masterly manner. Less than eight minutes remained for play when Everton saved themselves from defeat. An injury to Fell hold up the game on the Bradford right, and when it was re-started the ball was swung across the centre to Chedgzoy. Realising his chance in a twinkling, the Everton winger whipped round, and with a wonderful shot at a venture he drove the ball well out of the reach of Scattergood from nearly twenty yards range. Not until equality had thus been restored did the Bradford attack display its real effectiveness, but a surprisingly strong rally was resisted. Result: —Everton 1 goal, Bradford 1 goal.

EVERTON BUSTKED
The Athletic News- Monday, January 15, 1923
PUT OFF THEIR GAME BY LUSTY BRADORD
EVERTON 1 BRADFORD 1
By Junius
THE game at Goodison Park resolved itself into cleverness and skill on the part of Everton against dash, determination, and vigorous methods by their opponents. The early movements were so much in favour of Everton that it would not have been surprising had the foundation of success been laid in the first fifteen minutes. But several openings were allowed to pass. When, after twelve minutes, Chedgzoy raced along and presented Chadwick with the easiest of chances three yards out only for the centre forward to drive the ball over the bar, the moral effect was possibly incalculable. The failure to accept the opening was accentuated seven minutes later when Raitt, indulging in finesse, was beaten by Peel, who raced almost from the centre line to cut inward and beat Harland with a ball that came off the foot of the post. It was quite an unexpected turn and provided the Bradford players with tonic that carried them through to the last ten minutes. Then CHEDGZOY with a direct drive when the ball was lobbed in by Hart. Everton in the early stages displayed much of the best to be seen in foot craft without, however, getting in any shots; that were likely to extend Scattergood. Everton made the tactical error in the first half of using the right wing almost exclusively, to the neglect of Harrison and Williams. There was a change of method in the second half when Harrison displayed much cleverness in eluding his opponents, to finish with either a rasping shot or a clean drive across the centre.
A Masterly Save.
As a result of more even distribution of Everton’s forward play, the Bradford defence, after the change of ends, was subjected to severe pressure, and it became a question as to whether they would be able to hold out. Twenty minutes from the end they again took a hand at attack, and Harland’s save from Peel, who had threaded his way through the defence and shot at an actual angle, was a masterpiece. Then Williams placed wide with an open goal in front, and Chadwick and  Peacock, too, couldnot locate the net.
After Chedgzoy equalising point there was still the same strenuous endeavour without tangible result. Had the Everton forwards persisted in the plan of campaign they adopted at the outset, I feel convinced they would eventually have won through, despite the favourable opportunities that they failed to turn to account. They allowed their opponents to put them off their game, and their recourse to the open style did not bring them much success. Chedgzoy and Peacock, the latter especially, contributed much serviceable work, but opposed to them was very capable half-back in Hubbert. Chedgzoy persisted in attempting to round him, not always to his side's advantage. Chadwick almost redeemed his early error when he drove against the post from a free kick, but generally he was out of luck. Peel and Turnbull were frequently prominent, and the most effective of the Bradford forwards. Occasionally they showed a nice understanding of each other's requirements, and while each showed exceptional speed, Turnbull was the marksman of the line, and caused much anxiety to Brown. Everton's half-back play was not quite up to its usual standard. Fleetwood was not so happy in his assistance to his forwards as is his wont. Hart and Brown maintained a good standard all through, and Fell played a good defensive game even if his methods were at times rather robust and lacking polish. Howie was a great intervener, as Chadwick will probably admit. Of the Everton backs I was most impressed with the work of Livingstone. He was cool, calculating, and unperturbed, and his placing was invariably accurate. Raitt was inclined to underrate his opponent, and almost paid the penalty on a second occasion late in the game. Brandon and McCluggage were robust defenders who left nothing to chance, and trusted more to lusty kicking than calculated direction. Scattergood and Harland were capable custodians. The replay on Wednesday. Everton; Harland; Livingstone, Raitt; Brown, Fleetwood, and Hart (Captain); Chedgzoy, Peacock, Chadwick, Williams, and Harrison. Bradford; Scattergood; Brandon, McCluggage; Fell, Howie, Hubbert; Thompson, McLean, Bradley, Turnbull, and Pell. Referee; I. Baker, Crewe.

EVERTON DRAWN
The Liverpool Echo- Monday, January 15, 1923
By Stork
Everton go to Bradford on Wednesday with the remembrance of Scattergood’s display. It was a near thing at Goodison and the late-on goal only equalised matters, whereas when Everton win the cup they opened with a last-minute goal which meant victory against Bradford City.
There was no doubt that Everton were the superior side. They could do anything but score, but credit must be given to Bradford’s defenders, who were quick on the ball and powerful kickers. After getting their goal it was all defence with them, all hands being called upon to assist in stemming the tide. Chedgzoy and Peacock were Everton’s most prominent forwards, for Harrison and Williams, until well on in the second half, had an idle time. Hart and Fleetwood had such a grip upon the opposition forwards that Raitt and Livingstone were never in serious trouble, while Harland, with the exception of Peel’s goal and the same player’s angular shot in the last few minutes, had few shots to save. Bradford’s defence was their great power, and special mention should be made of Scattergood, Brandon and the pivot, Howie, while Peel and Turnbull were the only danger of the Bradford forwards.

EVERTON AT BRADFORD
The Liverpool Echo- Wednesday, January 17, 1923
EVERTON BEATEN
BRADFORD PULL THROUGH BY THE ORPHAN GOAL
HART ORDERED OFF THE FIELD
By stork
Everton; Harland; Raitt, Livingstone; Brown, Fleetwood, Hart (Captain); Chedgzoy, Peacock, Irvine, Williams, Reid. Bradford; Scattergood; Brandon, McCluggage; Taylor, Fell, Hubbert; Thompson, McLean, Bradley, Howie, Peel. Bradford, Wednesday.
Everton at Bradford believed they had a good chance of battling against Scattergood and Co, with better result than on Saturday. There was much excitement in Bradford over the revisitation of the Everton side to Park Avenue and the “Yorks roar” was heard when the teams made their appearance. Everyone who had been the Goodison game, with its numerous goal kicks, said that Everton had a nice chance to win through. While Lancashire was enshrouded in heavy banks of fog, there was little of this at Bradford, and the small ground at Park-avenue which would not require a great deal of filling, was helped by 700 Everton excursionists. Turnbull, the star of the Bradford line, was suffering from a broken toe sustained in last week’s game. Howie took his place in the forward line, and Fell was the centre-half, Taylor taking the latter’s position on the wing. Everton also had to make changes, Chadwick, who was so knocked about in the first game, stood on one side, and Reid was preferred to Harrison on the left wing.
EVERTON FIRST AWAY
A local estimate played the attendance at 13,000 when Everton won the toss, and Williams, with a clever pass, set Reid going, the movement only coming to an abrupt ending when Peacock fouled Hubbert. Scattergood was the first in action, in stemming a rush by Peacock, who was followed up a nice centre from Chedgzoy. Then Harland was called upon, but McCluggage’s shot was not one likely to beat him. From this clearance Peacock showed the right motion when he lobbed the ball over Fell’s head to Williams. Scattergood ran out to smother the Everton inside left, and the ‘keeper’s clearance cannoned off Williams and nearly into the net. From this point Bradford put great spirit into the attack, and the Everton defence was sorely troubled. Raitt, standing on the goal-line, headed out a shot from Howie, and when Fell tried to drive through a crowd of players, he found Harland ready. Bradford adopted the right tactics on the sticky turf, swinging the ball about with good effect. Everton were not by any means having matters all their own way, and a possible chance was allowed to slip by when Chedgzoy placed the ball right in the middle only to find his colleagues had lagged behind. Howie and Peel made a good left wing for the home team, and it was from this quarter that most of the Bradford danger initiated Bradford showed much better football than on Saturday, there being more method in their work, and when the forwards made a move it was made in good order.
HART ORDERED OFF
A sensational happening occurred after half-an-hour’s play. Mclean was tackling Hart, and that player, losing his temper, retaliated and the referee, Mr. I. Baker, instantly ordered the Everton player off the field. Bradford is an unlucky city for Hart, for if my memory serves me right, it was at Valley parade where he received his last marching orders. Everton reorganised their half back line by bringing back Williams. Everton were now mainly on the defensive and when Howie made a clever pass between Brown and Raitt it spelt danger for Harland. Peel’s centre landed at the foot of Bradley, who, although with his back to the goal, hooked in a shot which Harland saved smartly. So far this was the only shot likely to reach its billet that we had seen. Peacock, following a spell in the middle line, raised the hopes of his side with a solo effort, and was only knocked off at the critical moment. Chedgzoy’s also tried his best with a look effort that pressed narrowly wide.
Half-time; Bradford 0, Everton 0
The first half had undoubtedly gone all in favour of Bradford, whose attack was the more purposeful, whereas the Everton attack had shown no plan of campaign. It was a pity Hart had fallen foul of the referee, for up to the moment of his dismissal he had played exceptionally well.
NINE MEN!!!
Again the Everton ranks were reorganised Reid playing left half. After Brown had shot wide the Everton goal had its narrowest escape. Bradford were awarded a free kick which was dropped into the arms of Harland, who lost possession, and unable to recover his mistake, Howie shot over with Harland out of his goal, but fortunately for Everton Raitt dashed in to prevent the ball travelling over the line. It was obvious that Everton were disorganised, so much that Chedgzoy was to be seen taking a hand on the left wing. After Harland had made a clever punch away from Thompson, Everton’s troubles were increased. Brown having to leave the field for a time with a knee injury. Chedgzoy was doing two men’s work, and when he centred Reid hit a true ball, and only the presence of Brandon on the goal line saved a goal. Despite their troubles, Everton stuck to their guns and came near to taking the lead when Reid lobbed the ball into goal, where Scattergood miss-punched but recovered in the nick of time. The game was now a grim duel between the Bradford forwards and the Everton defence, where Raitt and Livingstone were playing the game of their lives. Bradford missed a chance when there was only ten minutes to play. Bradley failing to take an offer by Peel in front of goal Fleetwood was laid out by McLean, and Howie shot over the bar. When the same player essayed a first time drive Williams placed his body in the way to avert disaster. Just on time McLean scored for Bradford thus sealing Everton’s doom, after a gallant struggle against tremendous odds an dan unkind fate. Final; Bradford 1, Everton 0

BRADFORD PARK AVENUE 1 EVERTON 0
January 18, 1923. The Liverpool Daily Post and Mercury.
EVERTON EXIT
BEATEN BY LAST MINUTE GOAL AT BRADFORD
HUNTER HART SENT OFF
Everton have finished with the F.A. Cup, and it took Bradford eight-nine minutes to put “paid” to their account. The goal which sealed Everton's fate was a dramatic one, coming as it did when everyone had settled down for an extra half-hour's play. Everton were unfortunate as regards injuries, not through intent, but due to the robust way the Bradford players threw themselves into the fray. The ordering off of Hart was a regrettable incident, and it had the effect of disorganising the Everton side. Mclean, when tackling the Everton captain, seemed to pay him special attention. Hart resented this and he retaliated. The incident came under the eye of Mr. L. Baker, of Crewe, who, without a moment's hesitation, ordered Hart to the dressing room, despite the many protests of a number of the Everton players. So disorganised was the Everton side that it was hard to follow the players about. First Chedgzoy would be in the centre, then outside left, and later helping Peacock –who had a spell amongst the halves –on the right, Brown and then Fleetwood, were both injured.
THE DECIDING GOAL.
There were only two real shots in the whole match, and one scored, but they were left until late in the game. Peacock obtained an opening a moment prior to Bradford's goal, and drove hard for goal, only for Scattergood to make a capital save. From that point Bradford put on pressure in a last desperate effort to snatch a victory. McLean rounded Livingstone, and with a great drive beat Harland. The flight of the ball could be easily followed, and the ball was going away from the Everton goalkeeper the whole time to enter the far side of the net. Bradford played a much better game than at Goodison Park. There was more purpose in their play out the secret of the victory was the excellent half-back play. Fell was great in the centre where he was responsible for the breaking up of all Everton's efforts. Irvine was overshadowed by his towering form. Taylor and Hubbert were also on top of their form, and unlike Saturday, they were not all for defence. They pile wings with the right type of passes, and Peel Howie and Thompson until the latter was injured, provided Livingstone and Raitt with plenty of work. The full backs McCluggage and Brandon kicked with power and accuracy, and covered up Scattergood to such good effect that he was rarely troubled.
CHEDGZOY'S DISPLAY.
Everton put up a determined fight right to the finish, but the odds were too heavy against them with Hart's absence and Brown limping. Chedgzoy did the work of two men in the forward line, and was always a danger when in possession. He seemed the one man who might have won the match. Irvine was outweighed, while Williams was so well watched by Taylor and Brandon that he never got a chance. One thing he did well; Howie was working his way to goal, and it looked any odds on him scoring, but Williams placed his body in the line of fire, and Harland was not called upon. Peacock, who had slightly strained his back, wheeled here, there, and everywhere, but at last had to give way to numbers. Fleetwood, amongst the halves, excelled. He broke attack after attack, and tried all he knew to get his forwards moving. Raitt and Livingstone played a great game, and it was hard luck for them, after keeping the Bradford forwards at bay almost to the end, to be on the losing side. Harland had an easy time, but was responsible for one mistake, which might have settled the issue earlier. Howie had taken a free kick, which dropped into Harland's arms. The Irishman lost possession, and Howie directed the ball goalwards, when Raitt dashed across the goalmouth and edged it round the post. It was not Everton's day, but it would be unfair to take any of the credit from the Bradford eleven, who won by pluck and determination. Teams : - Bradford Park Avenue: - Scattergood, goal, Brandon, and McCluggan, backs, Taylor, Fell, and Hubbert, half-backs, Thompson, McLean, Bradley, Howie, and Pell, forwards. Everton: - Harland, goal, Raitt, and Livingstone, goal, Brown, Fleetwood, and Hart (captain), half-backs, Chedgzoy, Peacock, Irvine, Williams, and Reid, forwards.

EVERTON’S GOOD-BYE TO THE CUP-TIE
Liverpool Echo-Thursday, January 18, 1923
EVERTON LOSS H(e)ART
By Stork
All things taken into account Everton were unlucky to lose in their replayed tie with Bradford. They suffered through numerous injuries and the loss of Hunter hart, who had the misfortune to receive marching orders for retaliating. Hart may have had some justification for losing his temper, for McLean had certainly fouled him badly; but the rules distinctly say “No retaliation,” and there it must end. Referee Baker was right in touch with the incident, and there was no hesitation in his decision. The winning goal, which came at the 89th minute, was as nice a point as ever I wish to see. Harland was beaten from the moment it left Mclean’s foot. The Bradford player had beaten Livingstone, and his shot pulled away from Harland, who never had any chance of getting to it. It was a thrilling finish to a grim struggle for the mastery. From the moment Hart left the field Everton were disorganised. They had no set plan of campaign, with the result that they were at sixes and sevens, the half backs and forwards changing nearly every minute. Why they did not try the one-back game is beyond me. It would have made for better attack, whereas it was all defence. They fought with great determination, and that they held the Bradford attack to within a minute of the finish was mainly due to the sterling defence of Raitt and Livingstone, the former especially who never put a foot wrong. Bradford showed better method than on Saturday, but their victory rests with the half-backs, of whom there was none better than Fell. He simply smothered Irvine, while Taylor and Hubbert were capable helpers. The backs kicked with amazing power, and, with the exception of Peacock’s terrific drive, Scattergood was on the “easy” throughout. Chedgzoy tried all he knew, and was always a dangerous man when in possession, and seemed the one Everton player likely to win the game off his own bat. Peacock was always capable of beating his man, but was always outnumbered. Fleetwood worked like  a Trojan for Everton. He was a great spoiler, and at times tried to get his forwards off the mark with nice forward passes. As already mentioned, Raitt was the great men of the afternoon, and but for his timely intervention. Howie’s shot, which was made possible through Harland failing to hold a free kick, would have trickled over the line and sealed the issue much earlier.

EVERTON’S TUSSLE WITH THE POTTERS
The Liverpool Echo- Friday, January 19, 1923
Bee’s Notes
Tomorrow, after the hurly-burly of cup-ties and replayed ties, we get back to the normal race-for-the-season, the League which is not the complacent thing it used to be. Take the case of Everton, for example. They have yet to make sure their membership of the division, which has ever been their lot, and with Stoke coming to them on the morrow, the outlook cannot be described as other than awkward. Stoke at the beginning of the season, lost match after match, but put up some fine shows, and should have bene better placed by now. This same thing applies to Everton and now that they clash, each playing member of the sides given below will realise that a point or two means a double-edged effect, for it means the lift of a lowly one and a push down to the other lowly one. Therefore, there is every ingredient to make tomorrow’s match at Goodison Park a very stern one. Stoke have got Kasher and Co, back to their side after suspension through New year “leave,” and as Stoke will be the fresher, through having mastered Blyth Spartans at the first time of asking, whereas Everton had to go to Bradford to replay a cup-tie, the Potters must put up a good fight. I am still of opinion that Everton are lowly through that little touch of luck that makes the whole of the winners win! It may seem fully to suggest such a thing time and again about a side that isn’t winning through, but the theory is based upon that what I have seen and know of the players at the club’s command. Let us hope that “touch” comes and stays with Everton for a while and that tomorrow’s game will bring two points to Goodison’s brigade. Everton; Harland; Raitt, Livingstone; brown, Fleetwood, Hart; Chedgzoy, Peacock, Irvine, Williams, Harrison. Stoke; Brooks; McGrory, Milne; Clarke, Kasher, Brittleton; Broad (T), Watkins, Broad (J), Nichols, Tempest.

COCK FOR EVERTON
The Liverpool Echo-Friday, January 19, 1923
EVERTON F.C SIGN FAMOUS CHELSEA CENTRE-FORWARD
At ten minutes past three this afternoon Everton signed on J.G. Cock, the international centre forward of Chelsea and formerly of Huddersfield. Cock signed for Chelsea in November, 1919 and Huddersfield received close upon £3,000 for him. He stans 5ft 11in., and weighs 12 stone. He played in internationals versus Scotland and Ireland in 1920, and in a Victory international versus Wales in 1920. Before going to Huddersfield Cock played for Brentford, and had already drawn attention to his ability by a seeming power to score goals at will. He was really Huddersfield’s player at the time, and his form led the Leeds-road club to bring him within the fold. He was not altogether happy, however, and he did little good for the club. Hence when Huddersfield began to feel a financial pinch he was one of the first to be let go.
A “MADE” LEADER
In the Army he was a sergeant-major and a physical drill instructor, and verily Cock leads his attack as if on parade. He has smartness and polish, and untiring energy. He is clever and strong, and should bequeath to the Everton vanguard that “sting” which somehow or other they have lacked this season. He will play against Stoke on Saturday, and one can see a huge gate at Goodison Park to see the new centre. There was considerable doubt as to the exact formation of the Everton team which would oppose Stoke at Goodison to-morrow, but the team was announced this morning as follows; Harland; Raitt, Downs; Fleetwood, Hart, Grenyer; Chedgzoy, Peacock, Cock, Williams, Harrison.

JACK G. COCK SIGN BY EVERTON
January 20, 1923. The Liverpool Daily Post and Mercury.
GW JONES TO WIGAN BOROUGH
Everton yesterday secured the transfer of Jack G. Cock, Chelsea Intonation centre forward, who was formerly associated with Huddersfield Town and Brantford. Cock who stands 5ft 11ins and weights 12 stone, played for England against both Scotland and Ireland in season 1920-21 and also in the victory International against Wales in 1920. Chelsea secured Cock from Huddersfield in November 1919, at a transfer fee of nearly £3,000 and he has played many fine games for the pensioner. He will make his debut for Everton against Stoke at Goodison today…Everton also transfer George Jones, outside right to Wigan Borough.

EVERTON’S MEETING WITH LOWLY STOKE SIDE
The Liverpool Echo- Saturday January 20, 1923
THE GAME AT GOODISON
By Stork
Everton, with no further interest in the knock-out competition, but with a heavy casualty list, can now set about their League position in deadly earnest. Although they are at the moment one step higher in the table than was the case last season, they are far from being out of the wood, and it behoves them to make a mighty effort to prevent a repetition of the back-end anxiety which has faced them for the past two seasons. It is not that they are playing poor stuff, but just the fact that they are dead out of luck. They were unfortunate not to bring a point from Huddersfield. Several of the players are form in their stand that they had a genuine goal disallowed. The Goodison team have a rare chance of annexing two points this afternoon, for their visitors, Stoke, are having a bad time, finding the First division a much harder proposition than they expected; but even so they are dead game and are trying desperately hard to prevent a slide back to the Division they were so keen to leave. Stoke realise their lowly position and will make a determined show at Goodison, and it must be remembered they have put up several amazing scores against sides which appeared to virtually have a walk-over. Kasher, the former Sunderland half back, returns to the side after his suspension, but Brooks still retains Scott’s place in goal, Raitt and Downs will find the Stoke wingers very fast, and Hart will have his hands full in dealing with J. Broad, the Stoke top-scorer. Fleetwood is playing his best just now, and I can bet the Stoke left wing will not receive much change from Everton’s strong veteran. Stoke have a decided advantage over their opponents. They have had ample time to fully recuperate after their Cup tie, whereas Everton had to play a gruelling mid-week game at Bradford. The Everton side will show many changes, for quite a number of their first team players were sorely knocked about on Wednesday, but with such reserve talent to put in the field I fully expect them to claim all points from the Potteries team. Yesterday afternoon Everton startled us with the information that they had signed J.G. Cock, the Chelsea centre forward, who a few seasons ago was the talk of the land, by Virtue of his scoring feats. Cock originally played for Huddersfield, and in his first season with the Pensioners was their top scorer. He has not been in the Chelsea side for some weeks owing to his loss of form, but that he is a good man when in form there is no doubt. I only hope he will fill the breach with success, then the biggest part of Everton’s worries are over. Teams; Everton; Harland; Raitt, Downs; Fleetwood, Hart, Grenyer; Chedgzoy, Peacock, Cock, Williams, and Harrison. Stoke; Brooks; McGrory, Milne; Clarke, Kasher, Brittleton; Broad (T), Watkins, Broad (J), Nichols, and Tempest.

STUB MARKS
The Liverpool Football Echo-Saturday, January 20, 1923
By Louis T, Kelly

• Everton are not likely to forget their latest visit to Bradford in a hurry
• And what of Hunter Hart’s “unique” experiences-viz., two visits to Bradford since crossing the Border, and an “order off” in each instance?
• Ten months ago he got march-ing orders in the Bradford City match at Valley Parade for alleged kicking at Hargreaves.
• Although a man short for an hour on Wednesday Everton managed to play something like five left halves, three outside rights and a couple of outside lefts!
• In fact the “Echo” man present, like others, found that the elephants- we mean telephone’s truck could scarcely cope with the kaleidoscopic changes that were being rung
• Not only were the Blues left without a skipper, but they were very largely like a ship without a rudder
• Candidly the men as a whole were over anxious and lacking in some measure real confidence in their own ability top rise above the troubles confronting them
• At the same time it was hard luck to go to the 90th minute and then lose all
• That last minute proved a wonderful one, for during same Everton almost won, and entirely lost the match, Scattergood coming within an ace of being beaten to clear, and send his forwards away to get the winning goal!
• Hart ordered off. Peacock a strained back, Brown crocked, and Fleetwood badly cripped-such were Everton’s misfortunes as against a partial lameness to one Bradford man-Thompson to wit.
• Despite all this, Everton fell far below expectations for there was scarcely one Bradford performer who really excelled.
• The Blues showed a painful lack of the requirements of the day- for their men seemed unsettled, there was no real plan of campaign, men overlapped each other, and often dribbled needlessly and fatally.
• Personally we thought that Fleetwood worked heroically to stem the tide; that Raitt did well under difficulties; and that Chedgzoy also put forth great efforts, with periodical valuable assistance from Peacock, who had no luck, however
• Of course, there may be others who saw the match who will differ from the fore-going, but candidly, Everton keenly disappointing in more than one section of the team
• Liverpool’s junior enthusiastic showed bad sportsmanship in cheering the ill news that Everton were a goal down at the interval

COUNTY COMBINATION
The Liverpool Football Echo-Saturday, January 20, 1923
Last week’s result
Although the Everton A had the three Central League half backs playing, Burscough obtained the only goal, which proved to be a winning one. Burscough’s new management seems to have put fresh life into the team

“COCK O’ THE NORTH” GETS GOAL IN BIG WIN
The Liverpool Football Echo-Saturday, January 20, 1923
THE REVIVAL OF THE EVERTON SIDE IN THE STOKE MATCH AT GOODISON
“BEE’S” VERDICTS, VIEWS, & DETAILS
Everton; Harland; Raitt, Downs; Brown, Fleetwood, Hart (Captain); Chedgzoy, Peacock, Cock, Williams, Harrison. Stoke; Brooks; McGrory, Howe; Clarke, Kasher, Rouse; Broad (T), Watkins, Broad (J), Nichols, Tempest. There is some very special news on the other page in my diary. Have a look at it, as it concerns Everton, who to-day received Stoke, and for the special occasion brought out Jack Cock, the well-known international centre forward, who has been out of the Chelsea ranks for some time. Cock is not only an artist with the ball but he has a voice, and has used it on the music halls to some tune! We remember his specially great goals at Everton two seasons ago, and a huge crowd went to see him today and to gather whether he will lend the height, weight and experience to the centre berth which has troubled Everton so much in the past. He had an ovation when he arrived with the boys on the ground, for what was a very vita match to both sides, in view of their lowly positions. Everton won the toss and put Stoke to face the sun. stoke started merrily and until Fleetwood cleared there was no Everton attack. When the Blues did more forward their work was of a more penetrating character than usual.
COCK IN THER LIMELIGHT
It was noticeable that the new centre forward was part and parcel of the plan. Hence, when Cock made a sharp dribble and a shot, the crowd went into the delight stage. The new centre steadied his shot, and when McGrory tried to head away he simply put the ball hard to his own goalkeeper. The goalkeeper patted away, and Harrison with a shot gained a corner. A moment later Harrison put in a fierce shot that hit the side netting. Peacock added to the fun by bringing Brooks to his knees, Williams colliding with the goalkeeper and play being stopped. So far so good, from the Everton point of view. Then in the next ten minutes we saw the reverse action. Stoke adopted sensible tactics and much of their football was good, but the finishing touch was necessary, as in the case of J. Broad, who went right through without being able to get any punch into the ball. Nicholas was equally there when Tempest made a nice dribble. The ground was very soft in patches, and definite shooting was not easy. For instance, when Chedgzoy ran up and seemed nicely placed he turned the ball inwards and found Peacock slide away from it.
CIRCUMNAVIGATING THE BALL
Then there was the case of Williams with a back header by Cock, the shooter kicking all round the ball. A Peacock dribble which included the little-used back heel trick, relished by the unwisest of men, as well as the wisest, ended without luck. Downs and Raitt two of the sturdiest full-backs in the country, had shaped solidly, and when Downs did his star act of diving at the ball to head it away, the crowd recalled old times. However, when Downs and Raitt tried to sandwich J. Broad, they were lucky to “lose the ball” and find that Broad was six yards away from it. The best pass of the day came from Downs to Harrison, and when Williams netted, the crowd were vexed that Cock had been adjudged offside. Rouse was a good half-back, and Stoke so far were quite as good as their rivals, although Harland had not been busy, and Brooks had been on the go all the time. Brooks never had a closer shave then when Chedgzoy passed to Peacock and the latter with a low ball went a mere foot outside the post.
DEFINITE DOWNS
Harrison and Chedgzoy wasted a ball or two now, and for sheer definiteness none did better than Downs, who made use of the ball and passed it with a purpose. Grenyer also came into the business working with an upward run, which brought a corner and resulted in Allan being quite near getting in his header. Grenyer went to centre-forward again to try to head Chedgzoy’s centre, but Howe, who was limping, headed away. At last Harland had to bestir himself to a catch with a high ball from the right.
TWO GOALS IN ONE PAR
Then came two goals in two minutes and joy in the Everton side. Peacock scored at 38 minutes, and Harrison or Williams at 40. The first goal was without denial or debate. Cock in an individual run and effort had bumped out the way of two Stoke defenders. The ball went out to Williams, and when Peacock got a chance pretty well out from goal, he shot instantly and well and gained the glad hand from his comrades. Hart also made a long one to find Brooks on the spot, but while Kasher was limping Harrison saw a chance to make one of his army pom-poms, and it may be that Williams actually deflected the ball. At any rate there was no denying the fact that Everton were two up and that Harrison was the virtual scorer. Before half-time Harland made a glorious save by diving at a shot from J. Broad. Half-time; Everton 2, Stoke 0
COCK’S FIRST GOAL FOR EVERTON
The crowd only had to wait a minute before the third goal of the day arrived. Cock scored his first goal for his new club, Harrison centred, and when Williams missed the ball, it travelled on over a full-back’s foot, and Cock had a presentation plate. Really he could not help himself, but doubtless the Chelsea man was glad to break the ice thus early. Watkins, by gliding the ball outside, missed a similar gift, and Harland made a funny save after he had got down too quickly for a low shot. A much better save was made by the Irishman when Watkins hit a pretty football, while this save was equivalent to that made by Brooks from Chedgzoy. In the sticky mud J. Broad missed a sitter, and really Stoke were weakening when the practical side of goal-getting arose. Brooks saved from Cock and then Downs, remembering the name McKinlay, decided to have a shot himself. It was not a bad effort either. Tommy Broad, who used to be with Manchester City, made a shot near to the angle of the post and Watkins was even better with a similar sort of chance.
THE FOURTH GOAL
Much of the sting had gone out of the game, but the crowd became enthusiastic when the Liverpool result was signalled, when Downs made a punt, and when Williams scored No.4 -time 67 minutes- and the goal due to a corner and loose defence. The joy of the day was added to when Downs saved a drive from Howe by “going off at the deep end.” Not since meeting Notts Forest in October had Everton scored 4 goals. And it would not be wise to put too much trust in this big victory to-day. Final; Everton 4, Stoke 0

EVERTON SIGN JACK COCK, AND ARE LIKELY TO PROVIDE ANOTHER SENSATION VIA SCORTLAND THIS VERY NIGHT
The Liverpool Football Echo- Saturday, January 20, 1923
Bee’s
Everton are the startling club just at the moment. They are taking stock. They paid quite a reasonable price for Jack Cock, of Chelsea, although a year ago he had £5,000 on his head. There are big changes in prospect and a transfer is in the offing as well as a big signing from Scotland tonight.

TROUP FOR EVERTON
Sunday Post - Sunday 21 January 1923
Last night Alec Troup, Dundee’s International outside left, was transferred to Everton. Mr Tom MTntosh, the Everton manager, and Mr W. C. Cuff, a Director of the club, were at the match at Dens Park yesterday afternoon, and in the evening negotiations were completed with the Dundee Directors, and Troup becomes an Everton player.  Mr Willie MTntosh, of the Dundee Club, was the man who captured Troup in rather unique manner when the little fellow was with Forfar Athletic, and has taken a deep interest in him while he has been Dundee player, conducted the negations on behalf the Dens Park club. Troup has been a great player for Dundee. He has been at Dens Park for round about ten years, and, coming there as a mere youth, he is still in his football prime.

TROUP LEAVES DENS PARK FAMOUS WINGER SIGNED BY EVERTON
Dundee Courier - Monday 22 January 1923
Great Favourite With Dundee Crowd announcement made exclusively in the " Sunday Post yesterday that Alec Troup, Dundee's clever outside left, has been transferred to Everton created the keenest interest amongst football followers not only in Dundee but all over Forfarshire. It is not beside the mark to say that the announcement was received with feelings of regret by very many of the club's supporters, to whom " Troupie" has been something of an idol, but it has been fairly common knowledge for some time that he would not be averse to a change, and the Dundee officials had no desire to stand between Troup and a step which he regarded as in his own interest.
Keen to Get Him.—
Everton has furnished him with the opportunity to gratity his wish. Mr W. C. Cuff, director, and Mr Tom M'lntosh, manager of the Merseyside Club, were present at Dens Park on Saturday afternoon for the specific purpose of " looking at" Troup. The little Forfarian had no knowledge of their presence. It was a big surprise to him when at the close of the game was called upon to enter into the negotiations regarding his football destiny, but the Everton talentspotters were keen to get him after his brilliant display, and Troup, like Barkis, was " willin'," with the result that the transfer was quickly completed. The financial figure involved in the deal has not been disclosed, but Troup, it learned, will pocket a four-figure sum— about £1100.
A Gift.—
Alec Troup will take with him to England sincerest good wishes of a host friends. Forfar has produced many clever exponents of the national game, and Troup is outstanding amongst, them. Like all great footballers, never learned the game—it was gift. When a mere toddler he could dribble round the " big lads " at his doorstep in Forfar with a skill which could not fail to be noticed. was a very young " junior " when played for Forfar North End, and seniors go he was something of a curiosity so far age was concerned when he donned the colours of Forfar Athletic. He was fact juvenile, iunior, and senior all in one season. One of Troups greatest games for the Athletic was in Scottish Cup-tie against Celtic Station Park,  surprised everybody that occasion by his skill as an inside left, and thenceforth his reputation was so firmly established that clubs of greater resource than Forfar Athletic  a desire to come to terms with the little fair-haired "loon." His brother David played for the Athletic as an inside forward for several seasons. Signed by Dundee.—
Alec was a plasterer trade,  was bulily engaged at his daily occupation one fine day in 1915 when Mr William M'lntosh, of Dundee F.C., sauntered into the county town and succeeded inducing Troup to change his football headquarters.  He played his first game for Dundee against Rangers at Dens Park. His connection with Dundee was subsequently interrupted by military service with the Royal Engineers, but while stationed the coast of Scotland he played on several occasions for Ayr United. After demobilisation Troup took up the outside left position in the Dundee team, and recent years the Dundee club has not had more consistent player than he. He has had his off days like every other body, but, generally speaking, his service to Dundee has been invaluable, and he as always a " draw " Avhen Dundee were playing away from home. His Caps.—Troup has been capped against England, Wales, and Ireland, and has appeared in inter-League games for Scotland against these countries. He got his English caps in 1920 in consequence of Alan Morton's inability to owing to injury. Troup's briiliant exhibition at Sheffield Avas the feature of the match. Troup leaves Forfar for Liverpool on Thursday morning. He is immensely pleased at the fact that he will be joining another great favourite of the Dens Park crowd, Davie Raitt, who is playing brilliantly right back for Everton. With Troup and Cock in their front line Everton's attack will take some stopping.

TROUP'S TRANSFER TO EVERTON.
Dundee Evening Telegraph - Monday 22 January 1923
To the Editor of the Telegraph and Post. Sir, —Allow me, as a follower of Dundee F.C., to state my views, which, I am sure, are shared many others, on the transfer of Alec Troup. Only those who have noted Dundee's deals in the past can have received the news of Troup's transfer without amazement. We are told that Troup wanted to leave Dundee —the usual story, but it is difficult to believe that he could not have been persuaded to wait until the team had finished with the Cup ties. Perhaps the club could not afford to wait. That seems the only explanation. If so, why can't the Directorate show their hand ? Other clubs tell their supporters what's what, but the men who pay up their " bobs " at Dens Park are left wonder what is taking place behind the scenes. The clumsiness of Dundee's moves in connection with the Troup deal must now the laughing-stock of football Scotland. The winger was left out of the team in their last two away matches and included in it in the last three home games. Was he being " exhibited under the most favourable conditions? Money talks at Dens Park, but not the way supporters of the club have a right to expect. Every doggie has his day, however, and let us hope trio time ie not far distant when wo shall have first-class fare across tho way at Tannadice Park and a management that will make the construction of a tip-top team their ideal in preference to the transferring part of the business. am, &c.,

EVERTON 4 STOKE CITY 0
January 22, 1922. The Liverpool Daily Post and Mercury
EVERTON'S REVIVAL.
NEW CENTRE ASSISTS IN STOKES DEFEAT.
Everton gained their biggest win of the season against Stoke at Goodison Park, on Saturday. The game, however, was not a good one, and much of the play was of poor quality. Stoke offered weak resistance, and on Saturday's form their position near the foot of the League table is easily understandable. Everton's superiority was never seriously disputed. Much interest centred in the appearance of Cock, transferred by Chelsea on Friday, and he signalised his leadership of the line by scoring one of the four goals by which Everton won. Downs after a lengthily absence, returned to the Everton defence, and gave a capital display. He played with all his all-time dash and determination, and was, in fact, quite equal except in the matter of speed to Raitt, who was very sound. The half-backs held the Stoke forwards with a fair amount of ease, and all played well; Cock without doing anything brilliant was quite satisfactory. He frequently used his head effectively, and his experience in knowing where the place himself for a pass was of considerable help to the inside forwards. He made one splendid solo run in the second half, and instead of doing the obvious, shooting for goal, he placed the ball perfectly in the right wing. The opening, however, was lost through Chedgzoy not having kept his place. Once an understanding is established between Cock and his colleagues such movements should lead to goals. Chedgzoy was not consistent, as he wasted many chances, and Harrison, too, was variable, but Peacock and Williams were helpful. Harland kept a good goal, but Brookes, the Stoke goalkeeper, was uncertain. The Stoke backs were sound, and of the half-backs Rouse was easily the best. The forwards were very poor. T. Broad did some good things, but he got little support, for many chances were missed.
HOW THE GOALS CAME.
Everton set up a strong attack at the outset, and Cock's maneuvering almost brought an early goal. Right, centred at a nice pace, and the ball went to the goal off a Stoke defender, Brookes being very lucky to fist away. Peacock was strong on the target, and Brooks cleared a hard drive. Then followed severe attacks by the Stoke forwards, but there was little sting in the finishing movements. Downs, however, made a fine save when he got in front of the Stoke centre just as he was about to shoot. The Stoke goal a narrow escape when Peacock sent inches wide, and then the sane player opened the scoring with a long range shot at thirty-eight minutes. Two minutes later Williams added a second, but much of the credit for the goal belonged to Harrison, who sent the ball to goal with tremendous force. William's part consisted of shooting out his foot, and he was fortunate enough to meet the ball, and it cannoned into the net. In the first minute following the interval Cock scored a third goal, and again Harrison started the movement. The centre was missed by Williams, and the ball travelled on over the foot of one of the Stoke defenders to cock, whose task was easy. Watkins failed with an open goal when he glided the ball wide, and Brookes dropped a long drive by Chedgzoy. Harland's must difficult task was caused through falling to his knees too soon when Nicholas shot, but he managed to scoop the call away before any damage was done. At sixty-seven minutes Williams scored Everton's fourth goal from close in, and Downs headed out in his most spectacular style a hard drive by Rouse. Teams: - Everton: - Harland, goal, Downs, and Raitt, backs Fleetwood, Hart (captain), and Grenyer, half-backs, Chedgzoy Peacock, Cock, Williams, and Harrison, forwards. Stoke City: - Brookes goal, McGrory, and Howe, backs, Clarke, Kasher, and Rouse, half-backs, T. broad, Watkins, J. Broad, Nicholas, and Tempest, forwards.

STOKE CITY RESERVES 0 EVERTON RESERVES 1
January 22, 1923. The Liverpool Daily Post and Mercury
CENTRAL LEAGUE
Everton won more easily at the Victoria ground than the score of a goal to nothing would suggest. The visiting forwards in the first half practically monopolished the attack, and a very little more steadiness on the part of the inside trio might have resulted in more goals. The only goal of the game was scored by Irvine after thirty-one minutes' play, the inside right beating R.H.Dixon, Stoke's new goalkeeper from West Stanley, with a fast shot from short range. The game in the second half was rather more even but there was one period when Dixon showed Stoke that they have secured a useful goalkeeper by saving a fierce short-range shot from Chadwick, Virr, and Irvine. The Everton defence rarely faltered under the Stoke pressure, both Caddick and Livingstone being resourceful and kicking with good direction. The half-backs were a level line, and they gave adequate support to the forwards, who did not always finish their work well.

SCOTTISH INTERNATIONAL FOR EVERTON
January 22, 1923. The Liverpool Daily Post and Mercury.
After the match between Dundee United and the Hearts of Midlothian on Saturday Mr. Andrew Coffey, chairman of the Everton football club and Tom MacIntosh, secretary signed on Alexander Troup the Scottish International outside-left. Troup has been with Dundee for the last few seasons, and he has presented his country on more than one occasion. He is 26 year of age and it is expected that he will prove a great acquisition to the Everton.

NEW FACES AT GOODISON PARK
January 22, 1923. The Evening Express
Troup Joins Blues
By CRI
The Everton directors are evidently determined to make headway, and the enterprise shown in recent days will, I feel sure, result in the club taking a place in the League more in keeping with the traditions of the Goodison organization. Following the signing of Jack Cock, who, by the way made an excellent debut on Saturday comes the news that Everton have secured Alexander Troup, the noted Scottish outside left, who has run Alan Morton close for the “premiership” so far as the extreme wing position is concerned. Troup is as tricky as they make them, and plays consistently well week by week out, so that the Blues forward line is likely to be strengthened considerably. Troup is about 26 years of age and is small but stocily built, but is undoubtedly one of the cleverest wingers of the day. Standing 5 feet 5 inches he weighs 10st 4lb. This said that Troup has been itching for a change for some time. He has played for Dundee for several seasons, and figured in the Scotland v. England match in 1920 in the Scotland v. Wales encounter in 1921, in the Scotland v. Ireland game in the same year, and last year again against Ireland. Dundee is the club from which Everton secured Raitt. They are at present runners up to Glasgow Rangers, the leaders of the Scottish League and must be a particularly strong combination to be able to part with Troup at this juncture. Troup started playing when he was but a youth, and as a matter of fact was only 17 when conscription was enforced, to that there is no “camouflage” about his age.
Still They Come
That Everton were likely to secure further additions to the staff was indicated in the Football Express on Saturday, and I understand (writes Liver) that there are still further signings expected. News on another page may confirm this view later in the day. If victories such as that achieved on Saturday are to follow, then Everton will be on the high road to success. The match against Stoke proved a highly interesting one, if it was only for the fact that Everton line moved more smoothly than at any other period this season. The introduction of the ex-Chelsea forward provided the necessary balance to the line and all things considered it must be said that Cock made a highly promising debut. He kept the ball low, led the line with rare judgment and tact, and his passes to the men on either side were very fine indeed. Obviously Cock was not trained to the minute, and he has been out of touch with First League football for a time, so that some allowance must be made. When he settles down he will I feel sure, form a great acquisition. His experience should prove of immense worth to the club. Stoke of course, are somewhat lacking, and it would not be right to place too much reliance on the form, but at the same time the Pottery men contested the issue strongly, and only their fallings in front of goal prevented them running the Blues close. It was Everton’s most substantial victory of the season, and I hope it is a good omen for the future. The whole side played with skill, vigour and enterprise, forwards and halves combining most effectively. Incidentally the home half-backs line was given correctly in the Football Express.
Dicky Downs
Tom Fleetwood was inclined to get into his old position, but a man, who can be relied on to play anywhere is a valuable man to have on the staff. Hart and Grenyer played there respective roles with ability and judgment, and further in the rear Dicky Downs demonstrated that he is by no means a spent force. Down attempts –and succeeds –to do things which no other player tries to do, and his heading dive at the ball is one of his feats for which is famous. He created unbounded delight by bringing off one of these movements on Saturday. The amazed look on Downs when he turned to find out “where that one went to” created roars of laughter. The ex-Barnsley man is undoubtedly still good enough for First League football. George Harrison showed a glimpse of his old form, and Peacock, Williams and Chedgzoy were also in the picture.

EVERTON’S BEST
Athletic News- Monday, January 22, 1923
J.COCK HELPS IN HEAVY STOKE DEFEAT
EVERTON 4, STOKE 0
By Junius
The first appearance of J. Cock, who was transferred from Chelsea on Friday, synchronised with Everton’s most pronounced victory of the season, and in great measure the new leader had much to do with the success against Stoke at Goodison Park. He did not altogether fit in with the scheme of things, but the forward line moved with greater precision and incisiveness than In recent games, and he was not only among the scorers, but made two goals possible by drawing the Stoke defence, and thus providing the opportunities for his colleagues. There were enforced changes on both sides, and the early portion of play found Everton almost continuously attacking, Chedgzoy, in particular, putting in many fine runs and clever centres, which only the agility Brookes and some ill-luck prevented from bringing the desired results.
THE TALE OF THE GOALS
Peacock opened the scoring, after 36 minutes’ play, with drive from twenty-five yards out. From this time onward, Everton practically took charge of the game. Within a minute Harland saved throwing himself full length a ball from Broad (J.), but three minutes after the opening success Harrison cut in from a clearance McGrory and shot with great power. The ball would undoubtedly have gone outside, but Williams, dashing forward, deflected it into the net. The Stoke forwards were altogether subdued. They excelled in speed, and their long passing bouts were always fraught with danger. Harland got away several really good efforts, notably from Broad (J.) and Watkins, but as a rule the line received little support from the half-backs, who were too concerned in arresting the movements Everton’s nippy forwards. The second half opened in sensational fashion. In the first minute Harrison dropped the ball in front goal, and Cock taking advantage of hesitancy on the part of the Stoke defenders, drove past Brookes. Downs dived at a terrific drive from Kasher and headed away, and other efforts by the two Broads, Watkin, and Nicholas were unavailing, while from a corner well placed by Chedgzoy, Cock tapped the ball to Williams, who beat McGrory and completed the scoring.
Everton’s Improved Forwards.
The Everton forward line as a whole, and particularly Harrison, did well, especially after the initial stages when they discarded reckless kicking and began to place the ball with some degree of accuracy. The Stoke attack was spasmodic, and most the advances wore carried out by the extreme men and Broad (J), the inside wingmen often operating among the half-backs. This was the ease more especially in the first half, though later on they changed their policy and showed some good first-time shooting. With the exception of Kasher, the half-back play was weak in constructive work, and the line compared badly with that of Everton. Raitt, Downs, and Harland were great defenders and were more dependable than the Stoke rear-guard. Stoke were earnest enough but lacking in the finer phases the game. Everton.-Harland; Raitt, Downs;Fleetwood, Hart (Captain), Grenyer; Chedgzoy, Peacock, Cock, Williams, and Harrison. Stoke; Brooks; McGrory, Howe; Clarke, Kasher, Rouse; Broad (T), Watkins, Broad (J), Nicholas, and Tempest. Referee L. Josephs, Bolden.

SCOTTISH INTERNATIONAL FOR EVERTON
The Liverpool Echo, Monday, January 22, 1923
WHAT TROUP NAS DONE
Bee’s Notes
Everton are well in the forefront of signings, &c. They have this day got hold of a Scottish internationalnamed Troup, whom I remember well for his appearance in the international at Hillsborough when, England won 5-4. Troup started football life is that football nursery styled Forfar Athletic, and then west to Dundee, from which club he has now been signed. He is an experienced player, for he must have been with Dundee for some ten years. That he is not playing now with the first team is due, it is said to a very fine young winger who has come to light and cannot be displaced. One of the beauties of Troup’s best features is his shot. He can, and does, shoot, and, as he can play as inside left, it is plain he has never lost his goal-getting propensities. I wonder if another Dundee man, Nicholl, is also expected at Goodison Park? Nicholl and Troup are bosom friends, and Nicholl is a very funny pivot. Troup, of course, has be depend upon sheer ability and touch-line artistry to gain his name, for he is not a big man. I gave a warning note on Saturday of things to come, and at night Messrs Cuff (chairman) and Mr. Secretary McIntosh got their man and left for home.
COCK’S FIRST APEPARANCE
It has fallen to my lot o travel to London with a mixed crowd in my time. I mind the day when I went up accompanied by warders from Dartmoor-spare the joke about my deserving to be there, &c, &c., ad nauseum. I mind the time when I went up with football authorities who pumped for news and views and were surprised when they got them. I mind that last week, as ever was, I came from London, and at Rugby, the first stop, two people entered the carriage. One was stoutish, the other a mere boy. The next stop was Crewe. The stoutish fellow slept like a top, I read and re-read the same line over and over again to try to entice sleep. It was no use. Finally my sleeping friend woke- and I found I had travelled for hours with Mr. Cameron, the Bury manager. We had wasted some good time. I though out his mission in Rugby. He pointed to the boy opposite-that was his mission. He had signed on this 18 year old lad. I hoped he did well by his club. I was reminded of the cheap signing and the boy when the news came to the “Echo” that Jack Cock had been signed by Everton. There is the difference between Bury and Everton. The difference between the “Echo” and other papers on Saturday was that we did not spend out time telling that epoch-making fact that “we were the only journalists to travel with the team,” but we did have the only complete report of the great win obtained by Liverpool at Middlesbrough, a win that after the mid-week cup-tie one did not expect. It is well, too, that the news of the win was well received at Everton, and was rather contrasting to the exhibition of unwise enthusiasm that obtained when the boys cheered Everton’s downfall at half-time at Goodison Park. Come, boys!
CHELSEA’S MAN
Jack Cock is a big fellow. He is rather pale-faced, but has a strong body and a good head of hair, as well as good heading capacity. He believes in moving upward when he gets the ball, but where he shone most against the Stoke side was in his manner of drawing the defence before he parted company. I expect that clever Hart would put centre forward so that he could have a pass-up now and again, and certainly Everton’s forward line played more like a five line than for some time past. No centre could have played with Everton’s attack as they have operated in some games. Cock was naturally a bit slow, and we did not see much of his shot, although the mud-patch he was operating on was sufficient to prevent any fellow hitting a ball very truly, while Kasher was on him well-nigh all the time. Some thought he did not keep his place. I thought otherwise. Like J. Broad (a more than ordinary centre, this Stoke fellow), Cock recognised his place was up the field, and not leading a hand and losing his power of dash when a chance came his way. It was not a game to enthuse over, if we except the welcome win and the lift in the goals-for department. It would be better to stay judgement for a time and depend upon something more difficult than Stoke, who are a big disappointment. Certainly Cock brought the balance necessary to the centre position and showed his weight. One would like to see more of his shot, however, for the attack has had plenty of good footballers, but it is in the registering of shots that we have been wanting.
DOWNS BECOMES YOUNG AGAIN
How old is Dickie Downs? Who cares. We know he is losing his hair on top, and the side-shows are growing grey. But on Saturday’s evidence I beg leave to doubt if he can be left out. He shows command of the ball and power of heading that are foreign to some members of the football fraternity. Moreover, when Downs elects to make a pass it invariably goes to the man intended, and he is able to take the ball in his stride. Why, therefore, should there be failings in this direction with others? Why, too, should veterans of the game be unable to perform the simple duty of throwing-in without granting a free kick, rich with trouble? I give it up. Everton certainly possessed a steadiness in defence that was comforting. But Stoke would have made it a very hot shop if they had finished off their plans instead of laying the bricks and forgetting to complete their house of attack. Stoke had some nice ideas, and were wanting in centre and right half-back. Rouse did quite well for Brittleton, and on the winning side none was better than Grenyer, who was enthusiasm itself when the ball was being centred. Chedgzoy’s best was his shooting, which was nearer the mark than his centring, and his force of foot was felt by Brookes, who did not convince me. Peacock dribbled well, and Williams and Harrison had a bonny first half without doing severely well in the second half.

EVERTON'S TASK AT STOKE
January 23, 1923. The Evening Express
By CRI
In view of the fact that Everton's new formation is to have another trial at Stoke considerable interest is centred in the return game in the Potteries. Troup, the new man from Dundee, arrived in Liverpool last night, and he is fit and ready for the fray. Naturally Troup has had no time to look round yet, but he thinks he will like the change very much indeed. He was greatly impressed with the ground at Goodison Park, and as he is acquainted with several of the players, notably David Raitt and Hunter Hart, Troup already feels at home. Fully aware that there is a difference between the English and Scottish style of play, Troup feels that when he settles down to the style of his new colleagues he will give satisfaction. Only in International games has he had an opportunity of crossing boots wit am English side. In view of Stoke's extraordinary performance at Blackburn the match tomorrow is of a rather open character. Ralphs, the man who played so well at Ewood, displaces Broad, who filled the wing berth at Goodison this being the only change. The teams will therefore be; - Everton; Harland; Raitt, Downs; Fleetwood, Hart, Grenyer; Chedgzoy, Peacock, Cock, Williams, Troup. Stoke; Brookes; Howe, McGrery; Rouse, Kasher, Clarke; Templett, Nicholas, J. Broad, Watkin, Ralphs.

Everton “A”
Everton “A” meet Grayson's Gartson at Clubmoor tomorrow; kick-off at 2.45. This is an important match and some capital play is assured. The Everton team will be chosen from; Kemp; Spicer, Helsby, Smith, Connah, Boness, MCGrea, Smith (E.), Young, Green, Houghton, Rimmer, Gables, Virr.
Everton “A” require a match away for February 3 rd .

EVERTON PART WITH McGIVNEY
January 23, 1923. The Evening Express
A Chester Recruit
Following the excitement occasioned by recent big transfers there are two items of a more tranquil character to record in the Everton camp. The clever reserve forward McGivney, who has accomplished some good work for the “A” and Central League team has been transferred to Chester. The player through on the small side is very skilful and wholehearted and he is likely to do well at Chester.
Wright of Earle Joins Everton
On the other side of the ledger that smart Zingari team, Earle have parted with Wright, their centre half-back to Everton. A player of great promise, Wright is expected to make his mark with the club.

EVERTON’S ENTERPRISE
January 23, 1923. The Evening Express
McBain Joins The Goodison Camp
By CRI
It would appear that Everton decided on a team-building scheme some time ago, and now the directors’ plans have been brought into the limelight. It is obvious that these enterprises cannot be carried out on the cheap and in signing Cock, Troup, and McBain in rapid succession the coffers of the club no doubt have been depleted to the extent, even at a modest computation of over £10,000. But if the players named prove successful the money will have been well spent. Recent signings create a record in the club’s history. Readers of the Express were given the wire as to the possibility of McBain joining the Blues, and therefore the news did not come as a surprise this morning. But the negotiations were of a protracted nature and it was not until last night that all parties were satisfied. McBain will find at Goodison Park several Scots and I am sure he will feel quite at ease right away. As the new man is at home anywhere in the half-back line, and at a pinch can go forward he is likely to prove a great acquisition, but he will no-doubt prefer to stick to one position. The fact that he was moved about from pillar to post at Old Trafford was the cause of his leaving that club.
Everton Win Through
For some time, of course, the Scot has been in the public eye owing to the fact that he asked to be put on the transfer list as he was not at home with the United and that, so it was alleged, he had some differences with his colleagues. At any rate he was not happy. Hence the change. It is no secret that several clubs were in the running, but Everton was favoured by the player. Mr. Tom McIntosh is to be congratulated on the successful completion of his “angling” expeditions, for the new man is undoubtedly a fine player. It will be remembered that the Scot played against England at Villa Park, Birmingham last April and with his old club he showed consistently good football until recently, when he was not allowed to settle down, but was moved from one position to another with unsettling tendencies. A fine stamp of player, McBain came from Ary United to Old Trafford last season, and at once created a favourable impression. The new man is not very well just now, and he will not be available for his new club next Saturday. In the course of an interview with a Press representative, a Manchester United official said;- We asked for £5,000 for McBain, and although we did not get quite this amount our club has lost nothing on the transaction. We are sorry indeed to lose this brilliant Scottish footballer.” “In the player’s own interest, we should not have been acting fairly if we had not fallen in with his wishes. “ The United paid £4,500 for the Scot. By the way a Manchester correspondent
suggests the possibility of George Harrison joining the United.

NEIL McBAIN SIGNS IN.
January 23, 1923. The Liverpool Daily Post and Mercury.
In securing the transfer of three international players in four days. Everton must have established something like a record in this respect, yesterday the directors completed the transfer of Neil McBain the Scottish International half-back, whom Manchester United secured from Ayr united last year. At a cost of £4.500. McBain who played left-half for Scotland last season against England at Birmingham was placed on the transfer list at his own request, and more than a dozen clubs have been anxious to secure his services, when Barton joined the team from Aston Villa, McBain yielded to him the centre-half position and the captaincy and afterwards played with success both at half-back and forward Everton secured Cock the Chelsea centre on Friday, and Alexander Troup the Scottish International outside left, from Dundee on Saturday .

M'BAIN SIGNS FOR EVERTON.
Hull Daily Mail - Tuesday 23 January 1923
Directors of the Club Monday visited Old Trafford with view to the transfer to the Merseyside club Neil M'Bain, the famous Manchester United player, and, after protracted negotiations, the deal was effected. M'Bain's transfer from Ayr United last season cost the United £4,500, the biggest sum they had up to that time paid for player. Until the recent trouble arose he has rendered yeoman service as half-back and forward. M'Bain played for Scotland against England last season, and in all probability will do so again, for there are few better half-backs playing. When Barson came to Manchester United M Bain relinquished the captaincy to him, and for several matches played at left half. At the request of the directors, he agreed to play in the forwards for a time, but expressed a desire to return to the half-back line soon as possible. Last week was rumoured that M'Bain would go Manchester City, but this proved incorrect. Since then several leading -clubs had been in negotiation for the transfer M'Bain, M'Bain's transfer makes Everton's third big capture of the season, Cock, of Chelsea, and Troup, Dundee, being the other two.

WHAT TROUP THINKS OF HIS TRANSFER.
Dundee Courier - Tuesday 23 January 1923
By Our Correspondent. I am looking forward to playing for Everton on Saturday," said Alec Troup to me yesterday, " although I have not been told if I am to turn out at Goodison Park or not. But will know when I reach Liverpool on Thursday evening, and no doubt you'll hear about it before Saturday," added Alec with a smile. " I'm sorry in a way to leave Den*," continued the Internationalist. " I have made lot of friends, and then I'll be leaving my fellow-townsmen, Dave M'Lean and Dave Nicoll. I have been anxious for change, and Everton are treating me well. "It not as if I going: amongst strangers. Davie Raitt, Livingstone, and the other Scotsmen there are all known to me, and now that Jack Cock is leading the attack I think the English Leaguers should do well. Jack, of course, a bit of a music-hall artfct, and although I've never met him, I hear he is a great lad, and I'm looking forward to hear him sing." Alec said with a laugh, he is no mean tenor himself, although, like many others, he prefers to play the part of listener. Troup being inundated with good wishes from his many friends in Forfar, who are looking forward to seeing him again the close season.

ALL ABOUT McBAIN, THEIR NEW EVERTON PLAYER
The Liverpool Echo- Tuesday, January 23, 1923
HIS LIFE STORY AND HIS PLAY
Bee’s Notes
We shall not know our new Everton if the club go on as they have been doing these last five days. First they signed Cock, them Troup, and now McBain is on the list. We shall want a guide book and numbers to find out who’s who when the team turns out for the next home game. Everton has not been the real Everton for many a year. There has been an absence of half-back strength to equal the days of Makepeace, Taylor, and Abbott. The club has been lacking in many respects, and although I was chided for my remarks regarding the sides when August came upon us, it is indisputable that age has been a barrier to Everton for some time in that the slowness of a solitary link would be the slowness of the side. I am not all for pace, as compared with skill, but one must recognise the fact that youth will be partially served in football- as in other walks of life. It may be said, “Ah, but these new men are not young men.” I agree. But they are skilled artists, and Everton apparently came to the conclusion that they must help themselves or sink for the first time into the Second Division. In my estimation there are half a dozen worse clubs than Everton in the League chart, and I honestly believe that the club had not the absolute need to go out at this time of day to redeem their repute. In fact, I would sooner they had got hold of youngsters and brought them “out” in the best sense of the term. However, Everton have decided that they could not wait, and the result is that they have refused to be burked of their desire. Their enterprise means one thing-they are assured good gates for the rest of the season, for there is quite a personality about the side that commands the attention of onlookers. In addition, the class of the side is increased by the latest signings. Sunderland have found the benefit of such a sweeping set of signings, and Everton can do likewise, as times goes on. 
McBAIN’S HISTORY
In securing the services of Neil McBain, Everton have accomplished a very good stroke of business. McBain, whose best position is at centre half, has been shifted about a great deal since signing for Manchester United; and this has been one of the contributary causes of his leaving Old Trafford. McBain, who is round about 25 years of age, learned his football in the ranks of a junior club in Campbeltown, of which town he is a native. At that time he played in the inside left position, but while playing in army football he discovered that his true place was at centre-half. When the war finished he received an offer from Ayr United, and this he accepted. He was not long on the books of the !Auld Toon” club until he secured his place in the first eleven, and he can boast that the Ayr people reckon him one of the best centre half backs that have ever played in their ranks.
OUTSTANDING
It was at Celtic Park in season 1919-20 that he caught the eye of the critic as a player of outstanding ability. On that day he gave a splendid exhibition, and one that will not soon be forgotten by the redoubtable Patsy Gallacher, who after the game described him to the writer as a “great centre-half.” When John Chapman was appointed manager of Manchester United and received instructions to strengthen the team, the first player he went for was Neil McBain; and it was only after a great deal of work that he managed to secure him at a transfer fee which was, at the time, stated to be in the region of £3,500. His opening games for Manchester United pleased everyone at Old Trafford; and when the time came for Scotland to choose her eleven to meet England McBain was one of the men on who representatives from North and the Border kept an eye. He was chosen to play in the Anglo-Scots match at Glasgow last season, and a result of an impressive display secured his cap in the left half position against England. That game was played at Birmingham, and one of its successes was Neil McBain. He, with James Blair, of Cardiff City, behind him, surprised many of the critics by the manner in which he held up Willie Smith of Huddersfield. McBain, it had been said, was on the slow side, but his speed on that day was a revelation. After his grand game at Birmingham he is sure to come into the reckoning when this year’s “caps” are being distributed. He is sturdily, if not powerfully, built, reaching 5ft 8in, and weighing a trifle over 12 stone. He is a strong and sure tackler, but his strong point is distribution, while he is particularly clever at heading a ball.
THE COST THEREOF
Of course, all signings are costly nowadays, and Everton cannot look in at a ground without the local treasurer putting on the thousands-cap. There in Everton are handicapped unfairly. However, Harland, Raitt, Hart, Troup, Cock and McBain between them have taken toll of the Goodison exchequer to the extent of the best part of £20,000. It must be reiterated that Cock was obtained at a reasonable cost. The signing of McBain by Everton was fore-shadowed in my notes of Saturday week. On Monday there came a newspaper denial- as usual with every live wire that I get- and last night word from Manchester said that emissaries from our club had been at Manchester four hours for the signing that is now an accomplished fact. I believe that the end of the Everton moves is not yet to hand, although one deal may not be re-opened.

THE TRANSFER OF TROUP TO EVERTON.
Dundee Evening Telegraph - Wednesday 24 January 1923
To the Editor of the Telegraph and Post. Sir,—What a sensation! When I opened my " Sunday Post" yesterday and saw Transfer of Famous Scottish Forward," little did I think it referred to " Troupie," the idol of Dens Park. I could hardly believe my eyes. What can I make of it—at a time like this, too, with our team well in the running for the Cup? The Directors can't plead financial difficulties. The Directors must understand its not them, but the habitues of Dens Park, who are the upkeep of the team, and the sooner they (the Directors) do the better.—l am, &c., A. F. T. S.
Sir, —Like great many more followers of football, I was amazed when I read of Alec .'"roup's transfer to Everton F.C. 'The Dundee F.C. Directors ought to be ashamed for allowing their best players to go. They jet away Davie Raitt, one of tho best right backs that ever kicked a ball on Dens Park. Wow they are allowing Alec Troup, one best left wingers, follow in his footsteps. Why are they transferring players ot such calibre? If the club had not been getting big gates there might have;been some excuse, but here we have team that cap draw the biggest gates, second to none in Scotland, even in these times of depression, they realise on an average 15,000 in the home matches. If they would lay down money they get for these players and provide good substitutes we might have some sympathy for them. But do they? No, A deputation goes off to look for talent, and the announcement comes, " Great Capture by the Dundee F.C." The "captures"; have not turned out to be " stars." ;  What is wanted in Dundee is another First Division, League team. Dundee can easily support two First Division teams. It only requires some of our thorough sporting gentlemen take the matter up.—l am, &c Jan. 24, 1923. Play the Game.

WHAT EVERTON PAID FOR NEIL M'BAIN.
Dundee Evening Telegraph - Wednesday 24 January 1923
It is understood that the transfer fee paid Everton to Manchester United for M'Bain was £4200. Tottenham Hotspur and Chelsea were at the final negotiations, and are said to have offered £4000. When M'Bain was first placed on the transfer list the fee required waa the vicinity of £4600. It is surprising that Everton persist spending huge sums for players when many of their " big money captures have failed to justify the expenditure. Such players as Brewster, Downs, Fazackerly, Hart, Raitt, Forbes, Davies, and Crossley have cost Everton thousands of pounds, and they have had little return for their outlay. They have now seven international players, Cock, Harrison, Chedzoy, and Downs having played for England, Holland and Irvine for Ireland, and Troup for Scotland.

EVERTON TEAM SHEETS
The Liverpool Echo- Wednesday, January 24, 1923
Bee’s Notes
Everton (v. Stoke, at Stoke) will be the same as last week, with the exception of Troup for Harrison;- Harland; Raitt and Downs; Fleetwood, Hart, Grenyer; Chedgzoy, Peacock, Cock, Williams, and Troup.
The Reserves who have a chance of topping the Central League, play Stoke Res at Goodison. Forbes reappears for the first time since his injury in October; Fern; Caddick, Livingstone; Jeffs, Weller, Reid; Parry, Miller, Chadwick, Forbes, and Alford.
The information I published yesterday regarding the new Everton men came from a Scottish quarter. I learn that Troup is much younger that was suggested, and that in fact, he was not of military age when the war broke out- that is convincing enough. Meantime Manchester Supporters’ Club have risen in wrath at the transfer of McBain to Everton. They say United’s loss is distinctly Everton’s gain.

BEE’S NOTES
The Liverpool Echo – Thursday, January 25, 1923
Everton have today transferred McGivney the strong-trying little centre forward to Chester, and have signed on Wright, the Earle centre half-back.

EVERTON AT STOKE
The Liverpool Echo- Friday, January 26, 1923
Bee’s Notes
Troup’s first game for Everton is tomorrow at stoke. He and McBain will doubtless get a warm hand when they appear at Everton, but at the moment it is not possible for the Manchester man to appear. Thus to-morrow, at Stoke, Everton will field the same side as last week, with the solitary exception of the outside left. We shall be keen to see what has happened and the “Football Echo” will be in unusual demand. Stoke have since losing hand-somely to Everton been severely severe upon Blackburn Rovers, and it is plain that the one change they made from the side at Goodison had a material effect upon the Potters’ vessel. It also goes to show Everton that Stoke are not as bad as their League position suggests. Their play last week lacked the final touch which will sink any side, however clever it is. However, with the new spirit in the Everton side a new centre and outside left to boot, Evertonians won’t be happy unless they get full points to-morrow. It is a greedy request, but it is not beyond “bounds,” and personally I think a new spirit of confidence will arise through the signings of the crack players, and a victory away will increase that confidence and put Everton into a very safe position. It is noteworthy that the half back line has not bene touched, and in view of McBain’s signing and the grand work of Alan Grenyer in recent games one is forced to wonder what will happen when the pivot comes to give help at Everton. The teams to-morrow line up in this order- Everton; Harland; Raitt, Downs; Fleetwood, Hart, Grenyer; Chedgzoy, Peacock, Cock, Williams, Troup. Stoke; Brooks; McGrory, Howe; Clarke, Kasher, Rouse; Broad (T), Watkins, Broad (J), Nichols, Tempest.

COCK AND EVERTON
Derby Daily Telegraph - Saturday 27 January 1923
Jack Cock went to Everton because as he says himself, "he was unhappy at Stamford Bridge."  Jack ought not to have been unhappy, for he has always been an idol with the Stamford Brdge habitues, and even through his period of lean success he has always had a sympathetic cheer given him.  Cock still wishes to take to stage life, and is edeavouring to come to terms with Everton in this matter.  He wants permission for time off to "play the halls." 

JOHN GILBERT COCK THE NEW CENTRE FOR EVERTON
January 27, 1923. The Liverpool Football Echo
Everton have just startled the football world by going to Stamford Bridge and securing the transfer of one John Gilbert Cock, who, for three seasons, has been perhaps the most-talked of Chelsea player. Rightly has Cock secured this notoriety for in each of those three seasons he has been the club's top scorer with 17 goals (1919-20), 12 (1920-21), and 13 (1921-22) to his credit. The campaign Cock had soared but one goal in eleven League games for the “Pensioners” a rate of progress which caused him to be left out of the League side, a position of affairs which made such a men as Cock discontented. That briefly is how he came to be transferred to the rich Goodison Park club for which he scored a goal last Saturday and incidentally led the attack to gets its most decisive victory of the present campaign. Jack Cock is a native of Hayte Pensence and he is the eldest of three brothers who have made their mark in football. Jack is the most distinguished of the three. As a schoolboy football always had a fascination for him and I believe I am right in saying that when he left school, though put to other work and intended for a different career, Cock had set his heart on becoming a professional player. He got his chance much sooner than he expected, for a lynx-eyed Yorkshireman from Huddersfield saw him playing one day in a very junior football and straight away induced him to sign for Huddersfield Town. Cock my with almost instantaneous success, but the war cut short his meteoric rise to fame, for he joined the colours and found himself stationed at Aldershot. He was soon out in France, and almost as soon his name appeared in the casualty list amongst those who had given their lives for King and County. Jack Cock, however, had the satisfaction of reading his own death notice shortly afterwards returned to Aldershot once more to become a staff-sergeant-major. It was then that he assisted Brentford in the war-time London Combination games, and it was at this period that Cock was probably at his best. I may be negative in this assertion; none the less I have never seen Cock play better football than he did in those days unless it be the occasion of the never-to-be-forgotten international at Hillsborough against Scotland, when he led the English attack. That was a red-letter day for Cock just as it was for England. After the war he returned to Huddersfield club, but in the first season of the resumption of the League football he was transferred to Chelsea for something like £3,000. Cock has been twice capped by England and scored in each game. Cock is a striking figure on the field. He is all, well-built with the figure of an athletic. Moreover he takes a pride in his appearance and his black hair is always brushed well back from his prominent forehead. Today he does not play with the same snap and vitality as of old, and were I to tell the truth, this would probably be found due to the fact that he hasn't taken his football and this training too seriously of late. He had an idea of entering upon a stage career, and then thought better of it. A temperamental fellow, Jack can rise to dizzy heights of excellence and when at his best can hold his own with any centre forward for he is a stylist knows how to feed both wings, to dribble down the centre, and to shoot hard and straight. But he has his off days like every other player. Everton have certainly purchased a celebrated and notable figure in the football world, but whether he will ever be the John Gilbert Cock of his Brentford and early Chelsea days –a dashing go-ahead enterprising pivot with a raking shot in either foot and a real brain guiding his twinkling toes – remains to be seen. Tis said, “A change is as good as a rest.” W.L.U

EVERTON “TROUP2 AT STAKE
The Liverpool Echo- Saturday, January 27, 1923
By Stork
Everton made no mistake against the poor Stoke side, and too much must not be put on that victory. Everton have gone all out for new stuff, and they certainly obtained players of great skill. John Cock has added the necessary weight to the forward line, and he plays with his head as well as his feet. He scored his first goal for his new club, but really he could not help himself; but it will give him a confidence which has been lacking for some time. Troup, the ex-Dundee and Scottish international outside left, who was greatly angled after, will make his first appearance for his side. I have spoken to several well-known players who have played with and against him, and they are unanimous that Troup is the best outside left they have ever seen. Although he is not a big man, he has a big heart, and is very fast and centres well. Their new centre-half, McBain, is not included in the side this week, due, I believe, to his being laid up with a slight indisposition. McBain is a great player. I saw him in his early game with the United, and he pleased me immensely. He is a very capable defender, this strong point is construction. He feeds his forwards as if with a spoon, and if the said forward cannot grasp the chances in both hands and make use of them we must not blame McBain. Downs gave a sterling display at left full back, and so retains the post, while Grenyer is right at his best. Stoke are in dire straits, but will get some encouragement from their big win over Blackburn Rovers on Monday, when they took big recompense for being robbed of victory owing to bad light and a chapter of accidents in December. I will not go into detail about their personnel, for I dealt pretty freely with them last week. Stoke are decidedly home birds, and will make a determined effort to wipe off last week’s defeat, but they will, I feel sure, fall before the strengthened Everton side. Teams; Stoke; Brooks; McGrory, Howe; Clarke, Kasher, Rouse; Broad (T), Watkins, Broad (J), Nicholas, and Harrison. Everton; Harland; Raitt, Downs; Fleetwood, Hart, Grenyer; Chedgzoy, Peacock, Cock, Williams, and Troup.

STUD MARKS
The Liverpool Football Echo-Saturday, January 27, 1923
By Louis T, Kelly

• Cock did not accomplished mighty things, but his methods tended to help his fellow-forwards to settle down and play a smooth, telling game
• With Troup and McBain’s advent the good work should still go on
• That it may do so say all of us
• Re-enter Downs for a typical display
• Saturday’s was his first League run since September 2, when he was badly injured at Goodison in the Newcastle match, and finally carried off
• Not previously during his four seasons with Everton had Downs filled the left back berth, so that his show on Saturday was all the more commendable.
• Williams is now Everton’s leading goal-getter, with ten to his credit
• Troup will be the smallest winger Everton have had since the merry, sprightly days of Harold Hardman
• McBain, Everton’s latest capture has only once been seen on Merseyside, but it was a very good once, viz., at Anfield last season when he played a Charles Thomson dominating type of game without the ruggedness of the burly erstwhile Wearsider
• McBain will be the tenth Scotsman introduced to Everton’s League team this season

EVERTON AND TROUP
The Liverpool Football Echo-Saturday, January 27, 1923
FOUR FIGURES FOR HIS SHARE OF TRANSFER
A DANDY WINGER
F.E.H DESCRIBES THE GAME AT STOKE
STOKE WIN 4-1
Everton; Harland; Raitt, Downs; Fleetwood, Hart (Captain), Grenyer; Chedgzoy, Peacock, Cock, Williams, Troup. Stoke; Brooks; McGrory, Howe; Clarke, Kasher, Rouse; Ralphs, Watkins, Broad (J), Nicholas, Tempest. Referee; Mr. Johnson, East Bolden. Everton were at Stoke to-day, and the occasion was noteworthy because it was Alec Troup’s first game for his new side. Troup, according to a wire from Dundee this morning, got four figures as his share of the transfer fee paid to Dundee, who have never before had so big a fee. Troup is a dandy winger, and an artist on the extreme left. McBain could not help because he is suffering from quinzy. He is likely to play against Chelsea. Stoke were beaten at Goodison Park by Everton’s biggest clear margin, but in the meantime Stoke had won at Blackburn, so the issue was somewhat open. It was quite like old times to visit the Potteries once again. The war among other things, separated Merseyside from the Five Towns in the matter of First League football, but the association is now renewed. The Everton team travelled early, and Stoke was reached before twelve o’clock. The weather was beautifully fine and mild, and the Victoria ground looked its best in the spring sunshine.
SIR F. JOSEPH TO HIS FRIENDS
The first persons of note I met were Sir Frank C. Joseph and Lady Joseph, who had driven over to see the game. The former popular Liverpool Councillor and aspirant for Parliamentary honours looked the picture of health, and sent greetings to his host of Liverpool friends. Great interest centred in the first appearance of Troup. There were about 20,000 people present before the game had been in progress many minutes. Stoke started with a slight breeze behind them, and they immediately made play on the right, where Downs twice checked before Watkins put the ball over the line. Everton replied with a counter movement on the left, but Troup let the ball go into touch, and the first dangerous attack came from Chedgzoy, who hit the side of the net. The visitors now came along with confident judgement, and Troup electrified the crowd with his speed and cleverness, which culminated in a hot shot which was well saved.
STOKE’S EARLY GOAL
Stoke were not long idle. They came down in great style on the right, and Downs was forced to grant a corner, and this led to a tremendous bully in the goalmouth, and there was wild excitement when Watkins, at short range, drove the ball into the net. It should be mentioned that a few seconds before this Kasher when well placed had driven the ball high over the bar. Stoke’s success had such a stimulating effect that for a short period they kept Everton strictly on the defensive, and both Broad and Watkins sent in shots which were luckily intercepted. Everton eventually made progress through Troup and Williams. The first-named player’s centre was accurate, but Cock was just too late on turn the opportunity to advantage.
BRINGING HARLAND TO HIS KNEES
Tempest and Nicholas were next in the picture with a speedy breakaway and Fleetwood being caught napping, the ball was put to Watkins, who drove straight at Harland; the later saved it on his knees, but in any case the Stoke forward was offside. The pace quickened as play proceeded, and Peacock was through the home defence when he sent the ball skimming just over the bar at the other end. Downs was in difficulties when Raitt rushed across to his assistance, but this did not prevent Broad attempting to score with a shot which he lifted high over the woodwork. So far play had ruled distinctly in favour of the home team, who were very quick and nippy on the ball, though many of the visitors’ movements, though individually clever, were frequently disjointed, Williams once looked like equalising, but his effort failed, and then we had one more exciting moment in front of Harland. They kept up the pressure for quiet a considerable period, and Broad coming along at top speed, sent in a beauty, but Harland jus managed to divert it round the corner of the post. The place kick was cleared, and Everton again tried to get on terms with their opponents.
 A TELLING FLASH FROM PEACOCK
After some give and take work in midfield the home vanguard became dangerous, but Watkins was over-eager when he drove the ball well over. The visitors then put in a double spurt, and Chedgzoy twice carried the ball too far before parting with it. At the first time of asking, however, the brilliant winger made rings around Howe and put the ball to Peacock, who netted without giving the home keeper the slightest chance of saving. This happened after rather more than half an hour’s play, and for a time there was a lull in the activities of both sides. Good work by Hart put the Everton right in possession, and Peacock showed his paces when he left the Stoke defenders standing still, only to send a raking shot on the wrong side of the bar. The Potters were the first to waken up again and after Downs and Raitt between them had kept the Stoke left at bay, Broad headed the ball into the arms of Harland. The retort of the Evertonians was a fine run down on the part of Williams and Troup, and from the corner flag the Scottish international put in a thrilling shot, which was only saved at the second attempt. Just before half-time Raitt brought Broad down, and Stoke were still pressing when Downs saved the situation. It had been a bustling first half, and on to-day’s form one can scarcely explain why the Potters are in such a lowly position in the tournament.
Half-time; Stoke 1, Everton 1
There were fully 23,000 people present when hostilities were recommended Everton were at once busy on the right, but the movement failed through lack of co-ordination, and for a spell there was some loose kicking in midfield.
WATKINS SCORES
Then Stoke attacked with vigour on the right, and Rouse put in a centre which Broad, who was slippery at times headed into Harland’s hands. It was a lucky escape for the visitors. The due credit must be given to the Irishman for his agility in meeting a ticklish problem. Troup and Williams were manceurving for position when Cock was ruled offside, as the visitors were once again forced to act on the defensive. Rouse and Watkins broke through and a corner was forced. This led to a great bully, from which Watkins headed the ball into the net, in spite of the fact that Harland touched it.
STOKE’S THIRD GOAL
In rather less than a minute from this the home advance line made further history. Tempest got past both Fleetwood and Raitt, and gently passed the leather to Nichols, who scored with a fast low shot. Everton made a very spirited reply on both wings, but Cock was ruled offside when he attempted to convert a rising pass from Chedgzoy. The great crowd cheered both sides on with an ever growing volume of sound, for they were delighted at Stoke’s surprising and startling display. Broad scored the fourth for Stoke the ball going into the net two minutes from time from the back’s foot.
Final Stoke 4, Everton 1

CENTRAL LEAGUE
The Liverpool Football Echo- Saturday, January 27, 1923
EVERTON RES v  STOKE RES at GOODISON PARK
The return fixture took place to-day at Goodison Park. The previous meeting ended in a win for Everton by 1-0. For to-day’s encounter Everton introduced Forbes and Alford, who have been laid aside for several weeks through injury. Everton won the toss, and had the assistance of a good breeze. The first item of note came from the Stoke right wing. Royal sending in a centre which Caddick only just prevented Eyres getting at. Parry then took up the running for Everton and after some neat work between Jeffs and Weller the former sent in a centre which was ably dealt with. Stoke were very persistent in their endeavour to notch a goal, and at times the home defence were hard pressed. A solo effort on the part of Alford ended in that player sending in a perfect centre which went abegging, no one being up to accept it. For some time play was of an even nature, the best attempt being a shot from Parry which skimmed the crossbar. Another dangerous movement was initiated by Brittleton, who placed the ball forward to Royal, and in return that player gave Groves a nice opening, but hesitancy spoiled him a golden opportunity. In one of Stokes raids, Weller, when under pressure, ballooned the ball in close proximity to goal, which caused Fern great difficulty in getting rid of a shot from Wareham. Although both goals were frequently assailed, Everton held the advantage in attack, without becoming seriously dangerous. As the interval drew near both sides strove hard for the opening goal, and although Stoke many times pierced the Blues’ defence the shooting of the visitors’ quintette when near goal was erratic. Their most dangerous attempt was when Davies headed against the angle of the upright with Fern unplaced. Everton also indulged in may raids, but like the visitors their failing was shooting when close in, and although the game was evenly contested incidents to arouse the crowd’s enthusiasm were very few.
Half-time; Everton Res 0, Stoke Res 0
Five minutes after the resumption Jones scored for Stoke. Chadwick equalised for Everton reserves from a penalty. Miller scored a second for Everton res.
Final; Everton Res 2, Stoke Res 2

HOW TROUP PLAYED.
Sunday Post - Sunday 28 January 1923
An exclusive message to The Sunday Post about Troup's play for Everton v. Stoke yesterday runs - Troup was not given a fair share of the ball. He was starved often, and when most favourably placed. On the odd occasion when did get the ball he was the only Everton forward who gave serious trouble to the Stoke goalkeeper. Two of his drives were terrific. On the whole, Troup came through the game successfully, but must be better supported and get more of the ball. He said to our representative at the close of the game— I think I’ll be very happy with Everton. There is big difference between English and Scottish football. Here it is all dash and go straight for goal. I’ll tumble to it right enough.’

STOKE CITY 4 EVERTON 1
January 29, 1923. The Liverpool Daily Post and Mercury.
EVERTON OUTPLAYED AT STOKE
The Evertonians gave a very disappointing display at Stoke on Saturday, and people are beginning to wonder what is wrong with the team. It is true that they caught the Pottery side in exceptionally fine form, but this does not account for so crushing a defeat. The home eleven showed a combination and “nippiness” on the ball that was painfully lacking in their opponents, and though Stoke were only on level terms at the interval their general style indicated that much might happen in the second period of the game. Such proved to be the case, for they developed the campaign with quite masterly coordination, and they kept the visitors' defence busy for almost the whole of the second period. There were of course, occasional breaks away on the part of the Everton forwards. The rigth wing was especially busy, but it rather looked as though Troup Everton's new Scottish international acquisition was starved. This was rather a pity because in the few chances that the clever little winger did get he displayed extraordinary speed and a skilful command over the ball. It was the opinion of many present that had to received more attention the adverse balance against Everton might not have been so great. For once in a way the half back line scarcely did itself full justice. Mistakes, too, were made by both backs, while Harland in goal was scarcely so reliable as he generally is. It is only fair to point out that two of the goals gained against the Evertonians were open to a certain amount of doubt, though the referee was confident enough. But, in any case-Stoke fully deserved a victory, which commanded the admiration of the 25,000 spectators present.
RUN OF THE PLAY.
There was little to choose in the choice of ends when Stoke started with just a suggestion of a breeze behind them. They were the first to attack, and immediately showed their intention of reversing their defeat of a week ago. The first step in this direction came when Watkin netted after a tremendous struggle in the goalmouth. The visitors to their credit be it said, played up with considerable spirit, and Chedgzoy got in a number of characteristic centres, which were lost mainly owing to the fact that Cock invariably seemed to be just too late to turn them to account. Twice Troup was given the ball, and he hot away along the wing in fine style, only to lose it at the finish. Further pressure on the part of Stoke severely taxed the visitors, but their spirits revived considerably when Peacock, from a pass by his partner, scored an equalising goal. The second half was one series of successes for the home team. After rather less than ten minutes going Watkin headed the ball into the net with fine judgement, and a minute later Nicholas assisted by Tempest, put on a third. The Evertonians steadying themselves tried desperately hard to make up their deficit, but they were consistency well held by the home defence, and two minutes from the finish Stoke emphasised their victory with a fourth goal. This came from the foot of Broad, who shot strongly, and Raitt trying to assist the goalkeeper, allowed the ball to glance off his leg into the net.
THE PLAYERS.
Great interest naturally centred in the first appearance of Troup, and it may at once be said that he created a distinctly favourable impression. But, as already mentioned, he was not permitted the fullest opportunities of showing his capabilities. Both Williams and Peacock were very clever, with Chedgzoy a brilliant outside right. It appeared to many that Everton's main weakness lay in the half-back line, though there were times when hart and his colleagues did good work. Downs kicked cleanly and well, though both he and Raitt were occasionally caught napping and Harland was below concert pitch. Teams ; - Stoke City: - Brooks, goal, McGrory, and Howe, backs, Clarke, Kasher, and Rouse, half-backs, Ralphs, Watkins, J. Broad, Nicholas, and Tempest forwards. Everton: - Harland, goal, Raitt, and Downs, backs, Fleetwood, Hart (captain), and Grenyer, half-backs, Chedgzoy, Peacock, Cock, Williams, and Troup, forwards. Referee Mr. Johnson.

EVERTON RESERVES 2 STOKE CITY RESERVES 2
January 29, 1923. The Liverpool Daily Post and Mercury.
CENTRE LEAGUE
Stoke, at Goodison Park, had an equal share of a scrappy game. The Everton team included Forbes, and Alford, who have been absent through injury for several weeks, and the home side were fortunate to share the points. During the early stages Everton held the balance of play, and had plenty of chances to score, chiefly through good wing play by Parry and Alford, but the inside forwards finished badly, and at half-time neither side had scored. The game had only restarted a few minutes when Stoke took the lead through Groves, owing to a misunderstanding between Fern and Livingstone. Everton then put on pressure, but their shooting lacked direction. Chadwick, however, equalised from a penalty, which was followed with a second goal from Miller, who was allowed to proceed whilst the Stoke players were appealing for hands. Just on time Jeffs gave a penalty, and Staley made the scorers equal.

TROUP’S DEPARTURE
Athletic News- Monday, January 29, 1923
As we announced in our last issue, Troup, another Scottish international footballer, was transferred by Dundee to Everton. Both Troup and John Cock, the new centre, were included in the Everton eleven at Stoke on Saturday; but “the little Potters” played a fine game, and won handsomely-a success which should be a tonic to Stoke. The effect on Everton must be depressing. One of our Scottish correspondents writes;- “Alec Troup’s departure for Everton caused considerable disappointment among Dundee’s supporters. He was a first favourite at Den’s Park. But it might be as well to let the discontented know that it had been for some time Troup’s desire to cross the Border. “He had gone the length of asking his directors to place him on the open to transfer list, and while they refused, they made up their minds weeks ago that it would be better for the club and the player to part. Troup did not know this secret decision. His name had been before for a little while, and several communication had passed between the clubs. “Troup was in blissful ignorance when he appeared against Heart of Midlothian that his play was being watched by two gentlemen from Everton, and great was his surprise the close of the game when was invited to confer with the strangers with view to transfer. “Terms were not difficult to arrange. A sum of £3,000 or little more covers the transfer fee, of which Troup’s share is, roughly, £1,000, “Troup is the second stalwart Dundee have recently transferred the Everton club. The first was David Raitt, a right full-back. Whether there be further transfers—not necessarily to Everton—in contemplation remains to be seen. Some people contend that there are. The Dundee directors adopt a sphinx-like attitude. “If one were to guess as to who will be the next Dundee player of note to leave, we should say Bird, a clever inside forward, who hails from Leicester.”
McBAIN’S MOVE
But the ventures OF Everton did not end with THE signing of Cock and Troup. Although he did not play on Saturday, being away in Scotland, Neil McBain, of Manchester United, was secured by the Evertonians last Monday. As McBain is also a player of Scottish international rank it would seem as if Caledonians of this class were in great request. Thus is complete confirmation given to the information which exclusively appeared in En Passant January 8. Half-hearted denials were followed by the placing of McBain on the transfer list. Everton, who were well aware of the trend of events before the news was made public, were anxious to secure this half-back, and they realised their desire on Monday last. Manchester United gave £4,500, and have almost regained their outlay.  Neil McBain, good footballer, was secured from Ayr United, and made his debut with the Manchester club on November 26, 1921, at Old Trafford against Aston Villa. During the remainder of the season he took part in  21 League matches at centre and left half-back, and inside-right. In precisely the same number of matches during the current campaign he figured in each position of the half back line, and seeing the weakness of the attack he was played at inside-left on eight occasions. His last appearance was at Hull on December 30, this being the engagement which brought about a strained situation with the sequel that everybody knows. McBain is a first-class player, who could command his place in any team. His desire was return to his home, but the Scottish clubs are better salesmen than buyers.
A LAND OF CONTRASTS
Thus Everton, vowing that they would never again pay the extravagant transfer fees in fashion, have broken their resolution, and expended £10,000 at least in strengthening their team. But as the Goodison Park club have disposed of half-a-dozen players they will able to mystify the inquisitive who will scrutinise their balance-sheet in spring. It is evident that Everton, with a deep-seated fear of the future, are not going to allow mere money, legitimately expended on players, to stand in theway of retaining their membership of the senior section. Safety first is the motto of Everton—and a good motto.

TROUP’S DEBUT
Athletic News- Monday, January 29, 1923
FAILS TO BRING IMPROVEMENT TO EVERTON
WINSOME WATKINS
STOKE 4 EVERTON 1
By Icarus
After their explorations ayont the Border the Everton club were able to place yet another man of repute upon the field at the Victoria Grounds, Stoke. They were denied the assistance of Neil McBain, secured from Manchester United last Monday, but Alec Troup, their second acquisition from Dundee, was on view to the Potteries crowd. But it was an unhappy day for Everton. They found Stoke in their happiest mood, and with a thirst for goals which a quintette at Ewood Park had not assuaged. The home side took command of the game at the outset, harassed their opponents until they became unbalanced and yielding in defence, and won by a margin to which they were fully entitled. Everton never displayed the same dash as their conquerors, nor did they ever show promise of turning the tide. True, they were on equal terms when the interval arrived, but James Broad had scorned a chance to place hisside ahead, and, in addition, he had twice been foiled by that nimble, quick-witted young Irishman, Harland. A goal fell to each side in the first half, Stoke’s arriving after eight minutes had gone, but it was a point which might well have been averted. Tempest placed a corner kick with such precision that the ball dropped into the goalmouth close to the line. Harland leapt into the air, but misjudged the flight, and the ball fell between Downs and Watkin. The international full-back was standing with his face to the net, and as the ball cannoned off him, the Stoke inside right slipped it through.
Rapid Ralphs.
After this Everton were again forced to retreat, so fierce and sustained were the attacks of Broad and his men. Much danger came from Ralphs, whom Downs could never hold, and it was from oneof his centres that Broad tried a crafty hook-shot. He was nearer the mark just afterwards, however; but Harland, throwing himself full length, saved his side. Cock tried to set his wings in motion, but his passing was faulty, and it was Troup who gave most anxiety to Brookes and his backs. Everton's equalising goal came after thirty-two minutes' play, Chedgzoy making ground and a judicious centre enabling his partner, Peacock, to score with a fast, low shot which travelled away from Brookes. After eight minutes of the second period had gone Tempest paved the way for Stoke’s second goal. He placed another corner kick and again Harland failed to reach the ball. Watkin nodding it through, the Everton players appealing on the ground that the ball had passed out of play in Its flight from the corner-flag. The Everton defence was again pierced two minutes later, Nicholas baffling Harland with a shot similar to Peacock’s. Then James Broad, who had been foiled throughout the game, satisfied himself by scoring, but his shot, which Harland seemed to have covered, was deflected into the net by Raitt’s foot. This occurred in the closing minute of the game, and it was fitting that Stoke’s marksman should conclude the scoring.
STOKE’S LEADER
He played well throughout the game, swinging the ball on both wings, and varying this means of advance by individual runs in which he displayed ball control and a deceptive swerve. Nicholas and Watkin were able supporters, the latter showing the cleverer footwork. Watkin did not neglect his wing partner, and Ralphs always responded well with a timely centre. Tempest was fast and forceful, but might have centred with more promptitude. At half-back Stoke were very powerful, Kasher being a rare spoiler who also attended to the needs of the men in front. But the man who took my eye was Rouse whom Wolverhampton Wanderers allowed to go. Clever in defence, and cool and collected his methods of dealing with Chedgzoy and Peacock, he yet knew how to keep the ball low and pass with advantage. Further behind, McGrory and Howe defended soundly and showed an understanding that was lacking in the display of the Everton back. They played so well—Howe in particular—that Brookes was rarely in trouble. Stoke proved to be a sound, workmanlike side who should advance in the League chart. Everton, however, would seem to have an arduous task ahead of them. Their problems, judging by the display of the team, are not solved, though the position of outside-left could not have been more capably filled. There could be no doubting the class of Troup when he was on the move. He did not run along the wing and lift the ball into the centre heedless of his colleagues’ positions, but he placed the ball well, and also made use of a delicious inward pass as deceptive as it was neatly done. All this he did when given the ball, but for the most part he was left to fend for himself, and be wandered in so doing. Chedgzoy was inconsistent, but Peacock Shot well, and with Williams worked hard to help Cock, but the centre-forward was little seen, and the attack never moved in unison. The half-backs had too much to do in defence to give much assistance forward, but Hart played the part of the spoiler with credit, and occasionally swept the ball to the wings. Fleetwood and Grenyer, however, were worried by their fast opponents, as were Raitt and Downs. Raitt, however, has pace, and checked Tempest, but Downs was often puzzled by Ralphs. Moreover, the Everton backs did not cover each other, and were often close together on one wing. Harland made some thrilling saves, but, I have said, failed to cut out two corner kicks that led to goals. Low balls, however, he was quick to clear. Stoke.—Brookes; McCrory, Howe; Clarke, Kasher, Rouse; Ralphs, Watkin, Broad (J), Nicholas, and Tempest. Everton;- Harland; Raitt, Downs; Fleetwood, Hart (Captain), Grenyer; Chedgzoy, Peacock, Cock, Williams, and Troup. Referee; L. Josephs, Bolden.

SHOCK FOR EVERTON SUPPORTERS
The Liverpool Echo-Monday, January 29, 1923
EVERTON’S BIG LOSS
By F.E.H
Everyone looked for the turning of the Everton tide. With one of their new players engaged in the Stoke game supporters at Walton looked for a bright light. The light that failed ignominiously and it passes comprehension how a side that has been strengthened can lose 4-1 after winning the previous game at home by an equally large margin. What is one really to say about Everton’s performances so far this season? The problem is one that would cudgel the brains of the brightest student of our University -to say nothing of those who have attempted to follow football form for what we vulgarly call “donkey’s years.” The game at stoke was just about as disappointing as the most perverse pessimist could image. Nothing seemed to go right. Although the Blues held their own up to the interval, there was an uneasy feeling that something was going to happen in the second half. And it did. The home side took command of the game, and when they had added a couple of goals in the space of sixty minutes it was- to use another colloquialism-all over bar shouting. I ought to say that Everton certainly strove hard to hold their end up even when they were two down, and a certain amount of sympathy must be extended to them when, in the last minute, Raitt, with all the best intentions in the world, helped them unintentionally to their fourth goal. One need not go over in narrative form the history of a doleful story. It is sufficient to say that two of the Stoke goals were questioned by the Everton players, but the referee, Mr. Josephs, apparently, was never in doubt in the matter. Peacock’s goal was the result of brilliant work on the part of Chedgzoy, and the last named player certainly showed once again his speed and wonderful control of the ball. But what rather puzzled many people was the comparative “starvation” of Troup. Everyone was agog with interest to see how the little Scottish International would shape with his new club. Let me say at once, and quite definitely, that he made the most of all the chances offered. His trickiness and speed took the eye at once and he put in one shot that might well have told a tale. Personally, I think he is an acquisition to Goodison Park, and he certainly justifies Shakespeare’s fine phrase “the readiness is all.” Cock was not at his best, and though the inside men did well they were almost invariably held. The halves proved a weak link in a chain that was not too strong in the other two departments of defence. Judged by the display given by the Potters it is unaccountable to measure their position in the competition. On Saturday’s form they ought easily to hold one of the highest rungs in the League ladder.

ALEX TROUP
Dundee Courier - Tuesday 30 January 1923
Referring to Alex. Troup's play for Everton against Stoke, an English critic writes: —" There could be no doubting the of Troup when he was on the move. He did not run along the wing and lift the ball into the centre heedless of his colleagues' positions, but he placed the ball well, and also made use of a delicious inward pass as deceptive it was neatly done. It was Troup who gave most anxiety to Brookes and his backs,"

EVERTON EXPERIMENTS
January 31, 1923. The Evening Express
By CRI
It would seem that Everton are taking the opportunity in their friendly game with Stockport on Saturday of trying out players in new positions with a view to taking a line for more serious work. Peacock, for instance is being tried as inside left to Troup to enable Irvine to partner Chedgzoy. McBain is due to turn out for the first time in an Everton jersey and young Jeffs, of Bootle Albion, who has been playing capital football for the reserves is to have a trial at right half-back. Stockport will find in this Everton team quite an attractive combination. The full side is;- Harland; Raitt, Downs; Jeffs, McBain, Hart; Chedgzoy, Irivine, Cock, Peacock, Troup.

ALLEN GRENYER TO CAPTAIN CENTRE LEAGUE
January 31,1923. The Liverpool Daily Post and Mercury.
The management of the Centre League yesterday choose Grenyer to Captain the Centre League to play North Eastern League at St Jame's Park, Newcastle on Saturday next.

FED UP
The Liverpool Echo-Wednesday, January 31, 1923
Bee’s Notes
“Fed Up” writes
I should like to voice my feeling against such ridiculous fees paid for men no better than we have playing amongst us. We tasted something similar last season, when they spent about £20,000. But, alas, where are those men now? Everton cannot stay the 90 minutes. How is it? Why Troup? What was the matter with Harrison or Reid? They want two inside men (right and left); someone that can find the net. Let the directors pack one or two scouts off into Cumberland for a few Saturdays; they will find something up there.