WEST BROMWICH ALBION V. EVERTON
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 01 December 1888
This match was played at West Bromwich to-day. Everton were minus the services of Ross and Holt, who were playing at Edinburgh, Sugg and A. Chadwick taking their places. The Albion were without E. Horton, Perry, jun., playing. The Albion won the toss, Davie kicking off for Everton. Pretty pressing brought the ball into Everton quarters, a barren corner resulting. Dobson was injured in goal and play was temporarily suspended. Re-starting, Weir threw in and the ball travelled quickly up and down field. The Albion obtained a foul in the Everton goal, the visitors saving splendidly. Play grew very even, the ball travelling rapidly up and down the field, each side displaying neat dribbling. Costly ran the full length of the field, but passed badly to Walker, who kicked down field again, when Bassett by a long shot, lowered the Everton colours amid loud applause, directly afterwards notching another, Ross being sadly missed at back. After interval Hendry re-started, and Sugg received a severe kick, necessitating his leaving the field, greatly weakening an already weak team. The Albion took the pressure, but play neither side was fast. Bassett sent in a hot shot amid shouts of Goal,” but Smalley saved again. The Throstles rushed up, but Smalley spilling two of his opponents averted disaster in the nick time. Not to be denied, the Albion gained three successive corners, Dobson finally clearing the lines. Albion wakening up attacked hotly, bombarding for some few minutes and obtaining two corners, and a foul in the goal month, the visitors saving miraculously. At length fortune favoured Everton, as Chadwick, running down, scored with an oblique shot and fairly beat Roberts. Dusk came on rapidly, preventing a good sight of the game. Chadwick sent in another hot shot, Roberto fisting out. Costley retired badly hurt and Everton were new playing nine men, which was hard lines. Final Result. West Bromwich 4 Everton 1
SPECIAL
There was fine weather for the proceedings. The number of spectators was disappointing. Dobson got winded early, but recovering he repulsed an attack by Hendry. The ball was a wretched pudding, and on Bayliss appealing it was replaced. Bassett passed nicely back to Bayliss, who almost scored, but “very nears " don't count. A corner, however, enabled Perry to notch the first goal. Forty minutes’ play elapsed before anything of importance took place, and then Bassett put in a clinker, which completely beat Smalley. A minute later Bassett again did the trick. Sugg retired hurt immediately after restarting. Roberta got a teaser from Coyne. Everton now pressed, even with ten men, and Chadwick beat Roberts cleverly. Everton’s ill-luck still dogged them, Costley retired hurt, leaving them with nine men to contest the last ten minutes of the game, which they did most pluckily.
NUGGETS
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 01 December 1888
WEST BROMWICH ABION 4 EVERTON 1 (game 13)
December 3 1888. The Liverpool Courier
This League match was played at West Bromwich. West Bromwich kick off in the presence of about 7,000 spectators. Just after the kick Dobson gave a corner from which nothing resulted. After a throw-out, Sugg passed to Davies, who turned to Coyne and that player shot outside. The home men then pressed and Smalley had to save, and in the opening play Sugg, Costley and Dobson showed up well, Bayliss passed right across to W.Perry, who neatly headed through and immediately after Smalley threw out grandly, Costley and Chadwick were next prominent, when Sugg coming in sent in a slow shot stung which Roberts kicked away, and what was made to the opponent end. From some pretty play in front of goal Everton give a corner, the result of which was that after Smalley had saved, Perry headed through. The following play settled in midfield, but Davie had a shot, which Roberts handed off. From good play on Bayliss Davie received a pass and just kicked over the bar. The home forwards by capital passing got down the field, and Bassett with a long shot scored. Score at half-time:- West Bromwich 3; Everton nil. Immediately following the restart Sugg was hurt in the right foot and had to retire. Smalley in saving gave a corner, but Weir headed away and them Davies put in a spendid run down the right, Chadwick eventually sending a shot which went outside Sugg on making his appearance was cheered. A fine shot was them sent in, which Smalley kept out, Everton raced down, and Coyne sent one in which Roberts fisted grandly, Weir then kicking over. After Sugg had again retired the play became faster, and Chadwick sent in a beauty, Roberts just being able to repulse it. The home men sustained a hot siege on Everton's goal and two good chances were missed. At length the visitors got away, and Chadwick propelled a grand shot from the left corner, which Roberts never attempted to stop. Everton were playing a little better now, and Chadwick (e) made another grand attempt, Roberts fisting out timely and immediately Farmer had a try the ball just going outside. Costley was then disabled and had to go off the field. Davies then raced down finely but could not avail himself of a good chance. West Bromwich again pressed Dobson twice kicking away grandly. A corner was given however, from the scrimmage in front of goal another point was added to the home team's score. More exciting play followed in front of the upright, but the home men could not get through, Everton in semi-darkness playing fairly well with their 9 men. Final result-West Bromwich Albion 4 goals; Everton 1 goal; Teams; Everton:- Smalley, goal, Dobson and Chadwick (a) backs, Farmer, Weir and Sugg, half-backs, Costley, Chadwick (e), Davie, Coyne, and Davies (j) , forwards. West Bromwich:- Roberts, goal, Walker, and Horton (j) backs, Bayliss. Perry (c), and Timmins half-backs Pearson Hendry, perry (w), Wilson and Bassett, forwards.
EVERTON RESERVES 1 BURSLEM PORT VALE RESERVES 1
December 3 1888. The Liverpool Courier
The Everton first team having to play their league contest at Birmingham on Saturday, the Anfield enclosure was occupied by the reserve team, who had for their opponents a very promising eleven from the Midlands. The Lancashire County Association had the services of Ross and Holt in their engagement at Edinburgh, this necessitated the home executive drawing upon the reserve to complete their first team, and in consequence of this the team than appeared on the field was very much weakened by the absence of A.Chadwick and Watson. A new man from Wrexham made his debut on the outside right in place of Keys. Teams; Everton:- Joliffe, goal, Pollock (Captain), and Wharmby backs Jones (j), Fayer (t) and Parry (j), half-backs Briscoe, Cookson Brown, Keys, and Jones, forwards. Vale:- Broomhall, goal, Tadall, and Skimmer backs, Chadwick,, Surees, and Farrington half-backs Sproston, Wood, Hood Stokes and Kirkham forwards. The Visitors having won the two W.Brown started the ball a few minutes before three. Burslem started with nine men. For a time the play continued in the centre. Good passing by the Visitors carried the ball into close proximity to the Everton goal, but it was kicked over the line. Everton then retaliated, and rushed down the field and for a time the play was in the neighborhood of the visitors's goal. A rush by the Burslem visitors caused Joliffe to save. A foul was given against Everton close to the home goal, but the ball was cleared. A long shot again caused Joliffe to use his hands and the leather was quickly transferred to the opposite goal, but Fryer kicked over. From a throw in the visitors forwards became dangerous, but Joliffe was all there, making a spendid save. From a goal kick Everton rushed down but failed in front of goal. Burslem now pressed but hands in front of goal removed play into the centre Briscoe rushed down and passed to Brown, who was tripped and from the free kick Everton were near scoring. Parry passed to Jones, who made a good shot for goal, and immediately afterwards Briscoe was again prominent with a good run and spendid shot but Broomhall saved. A corner now fell to Everton but the ball was cleared and a long shot again caused Jolliffe to use his hands. Wharmby give a corner Briscoe again prominent for tricky play. From a free kick Everton near scoring, and in the scrimmage in front of goal, Fayer received a severe kick in the face and had to retire. Cookson was also down and also retired, Everton though playing with only nine men held their own. Keys proceeded in two brilliantly runs. The visitors pressed but the good defence of Everton prevailed disaster. After the ball had again been in Burslam territory, good passing carried the ball into home territory and the Visitors sccond. Immediately after this the whistle blew. Hood restarting the ball and for a time play continued in the centre. Good passing by the Everton centre forwards carried the ball into the neighborhood of the visitor's goal, but the backs cleared, Burslem carried the ball down the field, and looked dangerous, but kick over. A free kick was given in front of Everton goal, but nothing resulted. A foul was given against the visitors for tripping Brown when close to the goal, but the ball was cleared. From a goal kick the Burslam forwards rushed down and caused Joliffe to save. A corner now fell to the visitors, but the ball was headed over. From a miss kick by Wharmby another corner fell to Burslam,, and Joliffe saved grandly. From a throw in Kirkham rushed down the field, but Pollock checked and returned the ball. Good passing caused Joliffe to use his hands. Everton now played up strongly, but from a free kick Burslem again sent the ball down the field, Everton came again and obtained a corner, from which a goal was scored by Brown. After some even play in midfield hands against Everton aloud Burslam to get near the goal but the ball was kick over the line. A corner fell to Burslam and a hot tussle took place in front of the Everton goal, but the home defender stayed unbroken. A long shot again caused Joliffe to use his hands, saving at the expense of a corner, but the ball was kicked behind. From the kick out Everton rushed up the field, and obtained another corner but the dexterity of Joliffe kept the visitors from scoring. Although Everton falt the loss of the two men injured, yet they played up well, and after a well fought game the match remained a draw. Result Everton one goal Port Vale one goal.
WEST BROMWICH NOTES.
Athletic News - Tuesday 04 December 1888
The Albion hare eventually played a match at home, and not before it was time. Owing to a misprint on the official League list. Saturday's match was described as being played both at Everton and West Bromwich, and as most of the local papers fell into the same error, we had last week three different writers wishing, the Albion good luck at Everton. These remarks undoubtedly deceived a good many, who would otherwise have been present. Even this does not explain the smallness of the gate, which certainly did not exceed 1.500 all told. It seems to me the recent disastrous losses of the team have had a very prejudicial effect upon their supporters. I am afraid I have been travelling far away from what I intended to comment upon, and that is the match v. Everton. They made their first appearance at West Bromwich, and I was pleased to see the crowd give them such a good reception. Sugg especially coming in for a lion's share of it—l suppose for his cricketing abilities as much as football. The game was a most pleasant one from start to finish, there being not the slightest pretense of rough play on either side, and Everton certainly improved their reputation in the eyes of the Bromwich people. The first part of the game was characterized by good forward play on the Albion side, and defence on the part of Everton of the very highest order. I expected to see Everton weak at back through the absence of Ross, but both men played splendidly, and Sugg's head and height repeatedly prevented the downfall of his goal. Basset was undoubtedly the finest forward on the field. The goals he obtained were scorchers, and he made a similar shot a minute or two after which Smalley very cleverly saved. Roberts, in goal, did some smart things, but the shot which scored against him was certainly the weakest of all the lot. The remainder of the players did well, and it would be invidious to single any one out fur special praise. The score of four to one about represents the play, and Everton took their defeat very well
RESERVES
Whilst the Everton team were being routed at West Bromwich the Reserve occupied the Anfield road enclosure, and had for their opponents the Burslem Port vale Rovers, an interesting game resulting in a draw. The home team was weakened by having to supply substitutes for Ross and Holt who were assisting Lancashire at Edbinburgh, and in addition, they had two men injured before half-time, so I think they have no occasion to growl at the result. The visitors are a well-balanced lot, and will want a deal of beating by any of our reserve teams.
LIVERPUDLIANA
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 08 December 1888
By Richard Samuel
A CHAPTER OF ACCIDENTS
Last Saturday we had a trio of defeats by the three principal clubs of Liverpool, an occurrence which is very rare in these times. Everton were called upon to lend their best back and cleverest half-back for the service of the county, and there was no refusal to be tolerated, even though the club’s reputation might lose in the League fixture at West Bromwich. The had to change their front line, introduced Davie, a youngster from Chirk, and, as I intimated last week, this is likely to turn out a beneficial change. Sugg again got into harness and Albert Chadwick made his first appearance with Everton’s first eleven. Everton anticipated defeat; it was a mere question of keeping down the severity, and “taking one consideration with another,” four to one may not be regarded with consternation. It would seem that the men made a gallant fight, especially under the peculiarly adverse conditions which prevented towards the finish. Sugg was lamed, and Costley followed him from the field shortly after, and Everton finished the match with nine men. The wretched attendance was somewhat significant, and it would seem that the result of the miserable bickering amongst the Throstles is beginning to make itself felt. The Football league has not brought an accession of lustre to the Albion and they have not stood the test of the severe week-to-week matches like their rivals the Villa. Will they retain possession of the Cup? I think not.
WHERE THE PROFESSIONAL SHOE PRINCBES
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 08 December 1888
A new departure prosed
As will be gathered from the following letter and circular, the rules regulating professionalism are to be again ventilated with a view to removing the irksome restrictions against an imported player playing in ordinary club matches until he has resided within the stipulated six miles for a couple of years. There is a growing feeling that, whilst this hard and fast law may be needed as respects cup competitions, no such binding rule is necessary for club matches simply and solely. Mr. Barclay, as will be seen, is taking the bull by the horns, a meeting being summoned for Thursday next.
PROSPOSED FOOTBALL CONFERENCE
Sir-will you permit me to state in your columns that this meeting is not called to act in a spirit of antagonism to any Association as seems to have been hinted in some quarters. It is felt that we cannot reasonably expect the English Association to amend the professional rules unless we can make out a good case. It is understood that “someone” will bring the matter forward at the next general meeting in London, but unless we are agreed beforehand as the arguments to be used and the line of action to be adopted it is useless to hope that a satisfactory result will be arrived at. Hence the conference. Let the clubs meet and be prepared to recommend some way of solving the difficulty and then some good may be the issue. We are all agreed that something should be done. This being so, what better course can we adopt than meet together, decide upon the “something.” And lay our plan before the Council of the English Association? – Yours truly, W.E. Barclay.
COPY OF CIRCULAR
Dear sir= In a brief circular, issued on the 26th inst, to several of the leading Association Clubs in the North and Midlands, I informed you that I had been requested to call a meeting of club representatives, to consider the rules bearing on professionals and professionalism, and if possible to adopt measures to modify or abolish the system at present prevailing. There can be no doubt that much of the ill-feeling existing in Cup tie competitions is due to the suspicious which naturally exists, the clubs commanding good gates can also command good “amateur” players.
Rule 22 states; - “Any member of the club receiving remuneration or consideration of any sort above his necessary hotel and travelling expenses shall be considered to be a professional.”
Rule 23A is to the effect that players of a “different nationally” cannot play as professionals in ordinary club matches, unless they have resided for two years within six miles of the ground or headquarters of the club for which they play.
In reference to rule 22, is it reasonable to suppose –is there anyone foolish enough to believe- that a working man, engaged at his trade, is willing to forfeit a day’s pay for the sake of playing football? Or, assuming that a working man –a mechanic or laborer, or whatever he may be-thinks so little of his family and so much of football as to give up part of his work, and consequently part of his wages in order to assist his club, is it not monstrous that legally no allowance can be made in such a case for time lost from work?
In rule 23, the term “different nationally” cannot fairly apply to any person born in the United Kingdom. It is sheer nonsense to speak of a person born in Scotland, Ireland, or Wales, being of a different nationally to a person born in England. The contention of the promoters of the ensuing Conference is, that whilst Football Association have an undoubted right to regulate in every particular their own Cup Ties, they ought not to interfere with liberty of contract. In short, it is contended that any player born in the United Kingdom should be eligible to register as a professional for any club he may think proper, and be in a position to play for that club in all ordinary club matches during the season for which he is bound to the club. No professional to play for more than one club during the same season, unless the usual agreement be mutually cancelled.
This professional question is assuming more serious dimensions every day; and we have only to study the condition of things in Scotland where with hugh gates, there are absolutely no professionals (?) to see the unwisdom of continuing the present state of things in England. Let us have fair open transactions and liberty to make agreement with any player in an honest, straightforward manner, and thus put an end to the intolerable system under which every club and working amateur player are open to suspicious.
I am requested to point out that the Meeting will be held at the Grand Hotel, Lime-Street, Liverpool, On Thursday, the 13th December, 1888, at three o’clock in the Afternoon, when it is hoped every leading Association club may be represented, by at least two delegates, so that if possible some definite resolution may be arrived at, tending to a satisfactory solution of the difficulty. If you have not already brought the matter under the notice of your Committee, kindly do so, and let me know if your club will be represented. I am, dear sir, Faithfully yours W.E Barclay, Everton-Terrace, Liverpool, 30th Nov, 1888.
SWEETLY WHISTLE THE THROSTLES
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 08 December 1888
Consistent Everton
By Mickey Free
Now ye may talk as you like, but who’ll deny the fact that consistency is a fine thing in its way, especially when it means always getting drubbed when out of sight of the home enclosure? How is the peculiarity to be accounted for? Certainly not because Ross and Holt were playing for the County, as that is only one case. Is there any reason beyond the possible stuffiness induced by a long railway journey? I think there is, but for fear of having eleven men sitting on my chest I think I shall leave it for the Committee to try and solve. Well, sir, we were consistent again on Saturday at West Bromwich as the licking by four to one indicates. Granted that there were two mishaps, both in the second half, when Everton had the wind in their favour, that does not account for lost chances in the first portion of the game. The back division did their level best to keep the Throstles from nestling too close to the Everton sticks, but their best efforts were not seconded by the forwards to any appreciable extent, and so they had to bear the brunt of the battle. Davy in the centre, was a perfect frost. I had hoped that he would improve on the previous week’s form. Vain wish. He has not got it in him. Coyne was not so good as the previous week, and Costley was blowing like a porpoise before he had played fifteen minutes.
THE START AND FINISH
When the Midlanders won the toss and took advantage of wind and incline, I concluded that Everton would have a warm forty-five minutes, but never calculated on a three goal result. Bassett was not properly looked after, and heigho! He looked after the goals, and prettily he did it. His first was a beauty, the goal following was well worked up for, and so half-time came. It was heart-breaking to see Sugg go down all of a heap as the game was re-started. He had been playing a capital game up to this point, and his loss was great indeed. In spite of this, however, Everton pulled themselves together, and Roberts was several times troubled, but he was successful in all except that one shot from Chadwick, which was a kind of duplicate of that by Bassett. Then Costley got an ugly smack across the shin on which he had no guard, and off he was taken. With the visitors so much weakened, it was little wonder that the West Bromwich men came to the front and made it hot for Smalley and Co. Yet one goal only was added. The home team did not impress me as being anything like the team of last year. Mickey Free.
EVERTON V LONGEATON RANGERS
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 08 December 1888
Dull weather heralded the advent of the Rangers at Everton. Ross was an absentee. Teams; Everton; Smalley, goal; Sugg and Dobson, backs; Weir, Holt and Farmer, half-backs; Costley, Chadwick, Morris, Coyne, and Davie, forwards. Longeaton Rangers;- F. Start, goal; Wiseman and Winfield, backs; Newsome, Plackett, and Clifton, half-backs; Lock, Vessay, Orchard, Hardy, and Start, forwards. The Rangers stated play twenty minutes late before five thousand spectators. Seven minutes after the start, Morris receiving the ball from a free kick on the left, landed a beautiful goal. Fifteen minutes later good passing by Weir, Coyne and Davy let in Chadwick, who scored a second point. Vessy gave Smalley his first shot, which he threw clear, but Weir sent it to the right and Chadwick scored again amidst great cheering. Everton continued now to have rather the best of the play. Hardy raced up, Holt tackled him and Wisemen just cleared. Half-time; Everton 3, Rangers 0. Final Result; Everton 3, Longeaton Rangers 1
NUGGETS
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 08 December 1888
EVERTON 3 LONG EATON RANGERS 1
December 10 1888. The Liverpool Courier
The English cup tie prevented South Shone fulfilling their engagement with the Everton on Saturday, and therefore's match was made with the Staffordshire organization who have a very excellent reputation. The home executive have been trying to improve their team my introducting a new play,, Morris of Oswentry, going centre. Ross was unable to play his absence from the back division being keenly felt. Fully 7,000 spectators were present when the teams put in an appearance, J Holt the popular half-back receiving quite an ovation in recognition of his services for the county on Saturday last. Dobson having lost the toss, Orchard kick off Vesey and Locker raced up the left, their good intentions being foiled by Farmer and Dobson. From a throw in Chadwick and Costley dribbled down the left, and passing to Morris he put in a regular beauty which defeated Stuart five minutes from the commencement. A brilliant run by Hardy gave the defence some trouble, Dobson with a good punt removed the danger. Everton now pressed on the right, a shot from Weir just going outside. From the kick out, Holt passed to Coyne who again shot in, Start again proving equal to the condition. Everton renewing the attack brought the sphere well in front and after a great piece of passing again defeated the goalkeeper. (Chadwick). The Rangers began to play much better, their passing being much admired, after a good shot from Plackett Winfield upon Smalley to clear; Weir was now cheered for some grand tackling, his play at this point being superb. A grand run by Davie enabled Morris to get in and he in turn passed to Chadwick his final effort again proved successful. J.Start and Hardy with a beautiful ran brought the play well into the Everton quarters. Erratic shooting and solid defence kept the goal intact. Half-tome Everton 3 goals Long Eaton Rangers nil.
After the usual interval for rest Orchard put the ball in motion. The visiting van took up the attack and a scrimmage was formed in the Everton goal mouth, Dobson and Sugg removing the danger with some fine kicking. Play was now confined to midfield for some time until Coyne broke away and passing to Morris he missed a grand opportunity by shooting over. The Rangers right now put in a dangerous rush, Dobson having to concede a corner, the place kick going behind. A run by Davie placed Everton in position a shot from Coyne striking the upright. The Rangers obtained another corner, the ball being well placed by Clifton,but Smalley and the backs were bad to beat, and again Davie and Coyne were on the job, a shot from the latter going outside. From the centre of the field the Rangers raced down, and passing the home halfs, Vessy got possession, and with a terrific shot he placed the ball to Smalley's hands, who appeared to throw over the bar. A plea for goal was raised,, and to the astonishment of both players and spectators a goal was conceded. Chadwick removed the venue with a brilliant run, and passing to Morris he ought to have scored, but missed a grand opportunity by being too slow on the ball. Give and take play followed, each goal being visited in rapid succession until Holt passed to Davie, who forced a corner the ball going outside. Everton now pressed with great determination, but the fine back play of the visitors prevented any further scoring. A very pleasant game ended favour of Everton. Final result: Everton 3 goals; Rangers 1 goal. Teams Everton:- Smalley goal Sugg and Dobson (captain), backs, Weir,, Holt and Farmer, half-backs, Davies (j), CoyneMorris, Chadwick,, and Costley forwards. Rangers:- Start (f) goal, Winfield, and Wiseman Backs Clifton, Plackett, and Newton half-backs, Hart (js) Hardy, Orcard, vessy and Locker forwards.
SKELMERSDALE 1 EVERTON RESERVES 4
December 10 1888. The Liverpool Courier
Played, at Skelmersdale on Saturday, Everton took a fair team. Pollock won the toss and played against the wind. Everton at once pressed, and after some brilliant indivual play Briscoe scored, but, to the amazement of All the referee disallowed the point. directly afterwards Taylor put in a good shot, which the full-back headed through. Skersdale got a foul off Milward in front of the Everton goal, hust befoire half time, and they improved their chance and scored. Upon the re-start Everton played a good passing game and goals were scored by Milward (2),, and Bob Watson. Especial notice should be given to a brillant combined run by Watson Keys, Milward and Bricoe, which finished up with Milward scoring. Everton won by 4 goals to 1.
EVERTON v. LONG EATON RANGERS.
Athletic News - Tuesday 11 December 1888
A POOR GAME AT EVERTON.
By "The Free Critic”
Everton had a rest in the League competition on Saturday, and arranged with Blackpool south Shore, but the latter are at their old game in the English Cup competition, and therefore could not come. The Long Eaton Rangers were invited down, but somehow they did not fetch an Everton crowd, and it was a poor gate—for Everton- though most clubs in Lancashire would consider between 5,000 and 6,000 remarkable good goods. I should like to see the Everton ground packed when it is finished. Close upon £1,000 is being spent in erecting stands for the accommodation of the spectators. Land is rather precious about Anfield-road, and they have to make the most of what they have. Last year an extra stand—a "standing” stand—was put up behind the bottom goal, and now we have one at the top with sixty tiers. That will look nice when crowded. Along one touch-line about a dozen rows have been added, and on the other it is intended to put the whole lot under cover. When all this is done they expect to have sufficient room for 25,000.
The team put in the field by Everton was a rather peculiar one. Frank Sugg and Dobson played at back, and Farmer was at half along with Holt and Weir, whilst Davie and Coyne were on the right, and Chadwick had Costley for a partner at the opposite side, the centre being occupied by a grizzly Oswestrian. I was informed that the Rangers had brought their full team, but I could not say, for they were all new faces to me, and I fancy this is about the first time they have visited Lancashire. They were very well received by the spectators, and must have been gratified by their welcome. Little Holt was heartily cheered on his attaining county honours, but his Evertonian partner in the Edinburgh match did not play, and Everton had to manage without Ross. The game was not a good one. The ground was very greasy for one thing, and when Morris led off with a rather simple goal in the first five minutes it looked as if the Rangers would not enjoy themselves. For a considerable time Everton had all the game, but their forward play is not A 1, and the backs rather easily robbed them. Several corners were granted, but Everton don't care for corners, and only a single good one was put in during the whole afternoon. Chadwick got a second goal with a capital shot, and then the Rangers showed what they could do. Up to now I had been very much disappointed with their play, but they improved greatly, and the two wings proved themselves to be very quick. There was one very still' struggle within easy distance of Smalley, but Weir cleared, and Sugg's long legs often rendered good service, whilst Dobson was always in the thick of it, and little Holt astonished the Rangers above a bit. Again a change took place, and after pressing a bit Edgar Chadwick put one just inside the post, and at half-time Everton led by three goals to nil. From the form shown by the Rangers I was led to expect it good even game in the second half, and it was so, for the forwards at once dashed down the field, and it took Dobson all his time to stop them. Farmer was not much use in front of him, but Holt and Weir were playing well, and Frank Sugg was in capital form. The ball did not often get to Smalley, but occasionally it did, and Bob was always there. Davie—who cannot do evens—waited up the field, and one of the Rangers backs came down. This caused the referee to give off-side against Davie about half-a-dozen times in rapid succession, and the spectators, who must have something for their money—and they certainly had not good football-amused themselves by hooting the referee. However, they got tired before the official, though when the whistle inflator awarded a goal to the Rangers, when Smalley thought he had headed the ball over, they had another good Innings. The game continued very even and very poor right up to the finish, and Everton had two very near chances of again scoring, but did not, and won by three goals to one.
The Everton forward play is all rot, as the team was constituted on Saturday, and I am sure the Everton committee will not bless the luck which deprived them of the services of Davie Waugh and almost enough men to make another team. They have been most unfortunate in having their men injured, and it was with a sense of relief that no casualties were reported on Saturday. Davie is too slow and easy going, and has not much bant about him. Coyne is fair, but that is all—he is too anxious to dodge. Morris is stiff, and made some ridiculous passes, and the left wing was undoubtedly the best, Chadwick towering high above the rest by his clever play and fast shooting. Holt was the leading light at half-back, and it is really amusing to see the looks of astonishment on the faces of his opponents as the little man unexpectedly darts up, and has the ball away whilst the other man is considering how it has all happened. Weir also played a good game, and I was surprised to see Sugg such a success at back, whilst Dobson played as well as I have ever seen him, and he had something to do, for Farmer rendered him very little assistance. The Long Eaton Rangers are not so good as I thought they were, if Saturday's performance is their usual form, but I was told that it wasn't, and from the occasional flashes during the afternoon I dare say there is some truth in it. They want a centre-forward. Their wings are good, especially the left outside and right Inside, and the two others did very useful service. They went in for a lot of long passing, and did it very effectively, and they were quick on the ball. The halves were clever, Clifton and Plaskett being the best, though the latter does not use great judgment. Wiseman is also a good man, and likewise a sturdy man, and he played a capital game at full-back. His companion. Winfield (the captain), is also very good, and though the goalkeeper did nothing very striking for a start, he came up to time afterwards.
BURSLAM PORT VALE 2 EVERTON 2
December 11 1888. The Liverpool Courier
Played on the ground of the former in foggy weather, which prevents accurate play in the first half each side scored, but during the latter portion were decidedly unlucky, one of their players kicking through his own goal result a draw 2 goals each. Goals Ballam and Weir own goal for Port vale, Morris and Chadwick for Everton , attendance 2000 Teams Port Vale :- Maudslett, goal, Bateman, and Skinner backs, Chadwick Shields, and Elson half-backs Povison, Balham, Randle Ditchfield and Reynolds, forwards. Everton:- Joliffe goal, Chadwik (a) and Ross (captain) backs, Weir,, Sugg and Watson, half-backs. Farmer, Angus Mooris, Chadwick (e) and Costley, forwards .
PLAYERS, PROFESSIONALS, AND PAYMENT
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 15 December 1888
THE LIVERPOOL CONFERENCE .
Special Report
Mr. W. E. Barclay, , the genial and enterprising secretary of the Everton Football Club, has every reason to be gratified with the success of his labours in connection with Thursday’s conference. A more representative gathering could not have been hoped for than that which met at the Grand Hotel to discuss the amendant of the rules relating to the payment, registration, and birth qualification of professionals; and it is certain that the ‘powers that be cannot afford to ignore the conclusions arrived at. Of course the South was conspicuous by its absence, but there was sufficient compensation in the presence of representatives from nearly the whole of Lancashire, from Crewe, Nottingham, Burslem, Sheffield, Chester, Lincoln, Northwich, and the important centres, the total approaching close on a hundred. Amongst them we noticed the following; Messrs R.P. Gregson, and J.S. Roscow (Lancashire Association), R. Wilson, W. Jackson, J.J. Ramsey, A. Coates, and R.L. Stockton (Everton); J.J. Bentley (Bolton Wanderers), E. . Goulding and W. Blinkhorn (Halliwell), H. Bromlow (Bolton Charity Cup Association), G. Wild, and D.B. C. Jepson (Darwen), J.O.B. Grundy (Crewe Alexandra), J. Gregson (Heywood), A.S. Moore (Manchester District), E. Ramsbottom and J.S. Smith (Southport Central), A. Daniels (Davenham), H.J. Williams (Notts Jardines), G.A. Hughes (Northwich Victoria), J.W. Abrahams (Crewe Alexandra). J. Prescot (Bootle), J.C. Granville (Burslem Port Vale), J. Panter and T. Sadler (Newton Heath L.Y.R), J.G. Hall (Crewe Alexandra), Meroer (Rossendale), W. Wray and E. Grffith (Chester), C. Driver (West Manchester), J. McMillan (Sunderland), F.H. Lipsham (St. Oswald’s), L. Emery (Burslem Port Vale), A.J. Dickinson (Sheffield), William I. Irving (West Manchester), J.T. J. Lister (Burnley), George Armistead (Burnley), G.H. Hunt and W. Tunstall (Haydock), F. Dyson (Manchester District), Joseph Brierly and H. S. Hamer (Bury), H. Vesvers (Denton), J.E. Kershaw and Christle (Heywood). Aston Villa and West Bromwich Albion were amongst the clubs who refused to recognize the necessity for reform. The Villa regarded the meeting of the Conference as precipitate had declined to take part; whilst the Albion thought the Association rules were never satisfactory than new. Mr. N.L. Jackson’s letter, in which he thought it unnecessary to attend, considering the subject under discussion, was received with a little mild mirth. Major Marindin wrote expressing his inability to be present, and so the meeting unanimously elected Mr. JH. Houlding, City Councillor and President of the Everton Club, to the chair. The preliminary business as to the admission of the press was soon settled in the affirmative. Mr. Barclay opened the ball with a written statement, in which he sketched out the hands for discussion –payment of wages for time lost, the two years’ qualification, and the difficulty of transferring players. He boldly demand liberty of contracts, so that in ordinary club fixtures they might play and duly registered man. The present rule, he said, led to veiled professionalism and dishourable bargains. He advocated abolition of rules which simply defeated the object which they were passed.
Mr. R.P. Gregson, of the Lancashire F.A. and Football Association Council, regretted that he was not in a position of greater freedom and less responsibility. Personally he thought the time had long gone by when a revision of the rules became necessary, and the majority of the members of the Association were of that opinion. A man ought not to be regarded a professional who simply received wages for loss of time. There were 800 registered players in Lancashire, and he refused to believe they were all professionals. As to the nationally difficulty the Scotch Association had brought their troubles on themselves by shutting their eyes to the professionalism in their midst. Mr. Gregson concluded with the expression of the conviction that the rules as at present led to the manufacture of professionals.
The Chairman proposed to come direct to the point by moving that a day’s wages should be allowed to players, and this was seconded by Mr. Granville (Port Vale), Mr. Gregson, however, deprecated binding themselves to any direct line of conduct, but thought rather that a committee should be appointed to embody the opinions of the conference in a recommendation to the Football Association. This suggestion was promptly adopted and there was a pretty general consensus of opinion that rule 21 and 23a required revision. Mr. Brierley (Bury), and Mr. Dyson (Manchester District) both speaking to this effect. Mr. Green (Westhoughton) thought that the terms “amateur” and “professional “should be struck out entirely and the word “player” substituted in all cases, leaving clubs to make the best terms they could with the players. This, however, seemed to be too drastic for the conference. Mr. Dyson said he was authorized to say on behalf of Manchester that they thought it should be permissible with careful safeguards to pay players a day’s wages in additional to hotel and travelling expenses. Mr. Hughes, from Northwich, as representing a club who could not afford to pay professionals, and therefore a disinterested party, supported the contention that they ought to be able to pay men for loss of wages. Mr. Goulding thought the time had come when the enforcement of registration, when only small sums were paid, should be abolished. In Halliwell they had several players simply retained at 2s, and 2s 6d, a week in case of accident to the first team, and it was ridiculous that they should be compelled to register those. Mr. Bentley having added his opinion that the rule required alteration, the way was cleared for Mr. Gregson’s motion;-
That it is the opinion of this meeting that the following resolution be submitted to a committee to be subsequently appointed. –That Rule 22 read;- “Players and others, amateur or professional. Any member of a club receiving remuneration or consideration of any sort above his necessary hotel and travelling expenses and wages actually and of necessity lost, shall be considered to be a professional.” It will be seen that the alternation consists in the addition of the words “and wages actually and of necessity lost.” Mr. Bentley was the seconder, and it was carried unanimously but for one exception-Mr. Goulding- who thought it desirable to fix a limit as to payment. He told an extraordinary story about a member of the Corthian team receiving no less a sum than £70 as compensation for loss of professional emoluments on one particular match. Then again there was the case of W.W. Read, in another pastime, who received £1,000. This extreme view was met by Mr. Gregson, who said the provision of safeguards might be safely left to the Committee of Council. In the preliminary of the discussion on Rule 23a, it was resolved on the motion of Mr. Gregson, seconded by Mr. Barclay, that the cup qualification be left to the managing organizations, subject to the rules of the association. Mr. Panter (Newton Heath) moved as the substitute for Rule 23s;-
That a professional from any part of the United Kingdom having signed his registration form may play in ordinary club fixtures on any date he may be selected after he has been duly registered. Mr. Dyson briefly seconded this, and Mr. Brierley (Bury) expressed the extreme view that the cup competitions ought to be framed on the same lines. Mr. Gregson however, protested against the government of the Lancashire, or any other association, being dragged into the discussion. He was sure there were those in the room who were just as much opposed to importation as there were others who were strongly in favour of free trade in football. This brought up Mr. Abrahams (Crewe Alexandrs) in an original speech. He was strongly opposed to importation except as a measure of self-defense. He would do away with it entirely and form a limited radius within which players could be engaged for their respective districts. “Give our own lads a chance,” was his motto. The only question put to a man about to be imported was whether he was a good footballer. Nothing about whether he was a good worker or teetotaler. (A voice; “Good drinker,” and laugher). He thanked the gentleman for that reminder. Drinking seemed to be the only qualification for professionals now-a-days. He believed if they looked at home for their players they would have as good clubs and better morality. Who were first to bring the cup to Lancashire? Blackburn Olympic! Did they rely upon Scotchmen? Then there were the Rovers, the Albion and the Villa, who chiefly relied upon their own talent. He had a resolution on this subject of importation, but he refrained from moving it. Mr. Bentley was fain to admit that there were many suspicious characters in Lancashire and the Midlands, but still clubs did not seem to care to encourage local talent, and if they wanted imported men they ought not to be hampered by rules. They ought to be able to play whom they liked in ordinary matches. He strongly objected to those amateurs who were amateurs simply because they dare not become professionals. Mr. Green, the next speaker, made some reference to the Association Secretary, which brought up Mr. Barclay, who said he had never received an acknowledgment of the receipt of a registration form from the secretary. This thrust at Mr. Alcock having been thoroughly appreciated, Mr. Barclay went on to condemn the construction placed by the rules on the words “different nationally.” These words could not fairly apply to anyone born in the United Kingdom. Take his own case. His father was a Scotchman, his mother an Englishwoman and he was born in Ireland. Was he an importation? The meeting declined to grapple with this conundrum and proceeded to carry the resolution with three dissentients. Mr. Hughes (Northwich) thought an amendment of the 25th rule desirable to the effect that a professional should be allowed to play for any club he liked without obtaining special permission from the Associations. It was not good enough to have to wait six or seven weeks for a reply. (Hear, hear and laughter). Mr. Gregson, however, thought the rule a good one as it stood, and protected the weak against the strong. Mr. Brearley was of the same opinion, and that there should also be some check upon the peripatetic of amateurs. Mr. Gregson’s “pet theory” for this was a system whereby an amateur could, if he chose, bind himself, to play for a given club during a season. Mr. Bentley was opposed to wholesale transfer. If a club wrote to the Association respecting a transfer, they would have, or should have (ironical cheers), a reply by the next post. This bit of pleasantry over, Mr. Gregson submitted the following committee to formulate the opinions of the conference and report to the clubs, after which a further meeting will be held;- Messrs Barclay (Everton), secretary, Suddell (North End), Crump (Birmingham), Woolfall and Gregson (Lancashire), Hughes (Cheshire), and Mitchell (Birmingham). This was carried and votes of thanks to the Chairman and Mr. Barclay terminated a most harmonious meeting.
LIVERPUDLIANA; BY RICHARD SAMEUL
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 15 December 1888
AN OFF-DAY AT EVERTON
Everton got a break in their heavy task of wading through the League fixtures, but they are not afraid of hard work, and it was only very unwillingly that they were content to fall back upon a visit from Long Easton Rangers to provide the half-holiday fare for their faithful supporters. These, by the way, are beginning to exhibit signs of “education,” for the gate fell below its ordinary proportions to the level of a modest five thousand. With the visit of the Long Eaton men, Everton completed a list of engagements with Derbyshire clubs, which has included every one of note with the exception of Staveley. The County, the Midlands, the Junction have all passed before an Everton crowd, and as St. Luke’s also played Bootle, and Long Eaton Rangers made their bow on Saturday, we may be supposed to have had a sufficiently enlarged view of the capabilities of Derbyshire footballers. The impression left is not great but still creditable, for there has not been one team which did not show enthusiastic pursuit of the sport, as well as a familiarity with the game in its best forms. By far the best performance was that of Derby Junction at Everton, but the show of the latest visitors was very fair, and their defeat by three to one reflects no discredit on them. More changes in the Everton team. Exit Davie, enter Morris. Will he do? Not much better than Davie, whose shrift must be short or Everton’s record will suffer.
A MODERATE DISPLAY
The match was not of the most exciting description, but with their usual impetuosity Everton gave a fillip to the proceeding by scoring a speedy goal. Morris was the executant, and thus early installed himself a favorite with the crowd. For a long time Everton held a powerful grip of their opponents and amongst a lot of lesser lights Chadwick easily shone, and again distinguished himself by scoring a clever goal for his side. With two goals to the good the teams crossed over, and then it was seen that the visitors were going in for more determined opposition. They were either overcoming the stiffness consequent upon their long railway ride or else making a very determined attempt to get on terms with their opponents. They certainly made an infinitely better show than in the first half, and improved as timer wore on. Chadwick got another goal for Everton, but this was counteracted by one obtained by the visitors, but strongly objected to by Smalley and the crowd. The referee came in for unfavourable notice on account of this decision, and experienced some of the unpleasant aspects of a referee’s task. Towards the finish J. Start made many dashing spurts on the right wing, and so threatening did these attacks become that Everton actively bestirred themselves, and some retaliatory operations at the Rangers’ goal brought a somewhat quiet game to a termination.
CRITICISM OF THE PLAYERS.
The Everton forwards are still at sixes and sevens, the half-backs as strong as ever, and singularly enough, even in the absence of Ross and Dick, the rearguard showed no falling off in its proverbial safety. Sugg was a very business-like confrere to a brilliant comrade in Dobson, and Smalley was himself. The visitors’ goalkeeper at one period did some very excellent work, but the half-backs and backs may be cleared as good, and the forwards as unequal. Perhaps the best back on the field was Weir, who played in his usual effective style –but more so. The merits of the new men are now tolerably well decided, and it does seem most singular, that in all the recent trials no recruits have been forth-coming of anything more than very ordinary merit.
STOKE CITY V. EVERTON
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 15 December 1888
At Stoke, today, in dull weather and the ground very slippery. Only two thousand spectators attended. Both teams were fully represented with the exception that Sayer took the place of Ramsey for Stoke. The home team started the game shortly after the advertised time, and Everton early had a chance, but Angus shot wide. Millarvie made a smart run, the ball being place over the bar. Costley then had to retire hurt for a few minutes. Everton worked the ball up, but could not pass Clare. Again the visitors pressed, gaining a corner, which was placed behind. Walton effected a good run, the sphere going just outside. Costley had only just returned when he twisted his left knee, and was carried off the field. Everton still kept up the pressure, and Rowley was several times called upon to save. Stoke made matters lively, and the ball struck the bar, but no score was made. Morris missed an easy chance, and the game slowed down. At half-time neither team had been able to score.
Half-time Result;- Stoke 0 Everton 0.
Re-starting, Stoke visited the Everton half, and Slaone headed past the post. The light was now very bad, the play being followed with the greatest difficulty. Smalley had to fist out, a corner resulting, but nothing came of it. Stoke returned a free kick being awarded in front of goal. Sloane narrowly missed and Ross cleared grandly. Everton now retaliated, a long shot by Holt having to be fisted out by Rowley. Lawton and Edge were prominent for Stoke, Ross, played well and Rowley had to fist out again. The Stoke left made a swift run and McSkimming should have scored, but failed miserably. The leather travelled from end to end, and the light now became so bad as to render play impossible. A consultation took place with the result that the referee stopped the game 15 minutes from time and declared the game a draw, no goals having been scored. Final Result Stoke 0, Everton 0.
SPECIAL
S we neared Stoke the fog thickened, and on the field of play it was not inviting. The ground was soft, but not so bad as it might have been. The game on the whole was but a poor one, and owing to the darkness the whistle sounded 15 minutes before time. The Everton demon was again on the job as Costley was disabled in the first half after twenty minutes’ play. In spite of this and the decidedly bad play of the remaining forwards, a drawn game was a fair index of the game. Ross handled the ball once in front of his own goal in the first half, and many grumbled, but it wouldn’t have mattered in the least, as Bob was waiting behind, smiling in anticipation of a wet fistful. The free kick was beautifully accounted for by Ross. All’s well that ends well.
NUGGETS
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 15 December 1888
STOKE 0 EVERTON 0 (game 14)
DECEMBER 17 1888. THE Liverpool Courier
When the Everton team arrived in Stoke at noon on Saturday to play their fourteenth match in the League competition a dense fog overhung the town, but towards the time to kick off it lifted a little. As Stoke had defeated Blackburn Rovers, and were only beaten at Burnley by one point, in their last two matches, a grand even game was anticipated. There was only one alteration in the usual Stoke team, Ramsey being absent and Sayer taking half-back instead of forward. Everton had their full team. The following opposed one another:- Stoke : Rowley, goal, Clare, and Underwood, backs,, Sayer, Shutt, and Smith, half-backs Lawton, McSkimming Sloane Edge, and Milarvie,, forwards. Everton:- Smalley, goal, Dobson, and Ross (Captain), backs, Weir Holt, and Farmer half-backs, Davies (j), Watson, Morris, Chadwick, and Costley, forwards. Everton won the toss, and Sloan kicked off for Stoke. Smalley had at once to use his hands, and a foul took place right under the Everton posts. A goal kick gave temporary relief, and by means of long kicks the visitors forwards took the ball up, being well returned by Clare, Costley got off, but was well tackled by Clare, who kicked out, long kicking being the order of the day. Lawton fastened on and ran up, but Ross robbed him splendidly. Milarvie had a clear run, but spoilt by heading out. From the throw out Davies and Watson took it up and the Stoke goal was placed in jeopardy Morris trying a shot wide of the posts. From the kick off play was taken to the centre and Milarvie and Edge broke away, Dobson defending well. some nice passing between Morris and Costley took it up, Clare robbing them, and Edge and Sloane returning, the ball was kicked behind, Costley retired for a short time, being hurt, and Sloan's followed suit, but returned in a few minutes. Slaone broke away, and the Everton goal was in danger; a goal kick relieving when Davies got off and shot in effectual. Costley was here carried off the field, his knee giving away. Dobson next showed some rather tackling; Malarvie breaking away Rowley saved grandly at the expense of a corner. Davies and Watsontaking it up again the former shot, Clare returni8ng well. even play followed, Chadwick screwing in from the corner forced Rowley to again fist out. Shutt was next conspicuous by some good tackling. The home left getting off passed Dobson, Smalley having to kick out, a corner being conceded was well placed, and a shot attack the crossbar, and after Ross had headed out. Half-time arrived with a clean sheet. On resuming the Everton goal was visited with out success and Stoke continued to press for some time, when Chadwick got off, Clare returning and Smalley had to kick out a corner immediately after being conceded. It was well placed, but the Everton back play was too good. A free kick was taken dangerous near the visitors goal,, but relief was obtained, a grand piece of defensive play by Smalley and Dobson being deservedly cleared. Twice shortly after was Rowley called upon to save, which he did grandly. Edge raced up the left, Dobson eventually robbing him and returning well, Rowley again having to save. The home forwards them got off, but could not pass Ross. Chadwick and Holt raced up the left, Rowley having to kick out Chadwick's shot. Milarvie and Edge than had a turn, passed Dobson and a final kick went across the goal mouth. Some close play near the Everton goal followed Ross defending well. Darkness coupled with the fog now made it extremely difficulty to follow the ball. Final score Stoke nil Everton nil.
EVERTON RESERVES 3 STOKE SWIFT 0
December 17 1888. The Liverpool Courier.
The Anfield executive provided an excellent bill of fare for their supporters on Saturday, Bourne having won the toss, Milward kicked off and immediately assumed the aggressive. A grand pass by Angus enabled Keys to try a shot which Hassell cleared. A good run by Wainwright brought the play to the other end where Chadwick kicked clear. Hutchinson and Broadhurst raced up the Stoke right where Higgins cleared after a rather persistent attack. Good passing by Brown and Angus gave Milward an opening, who shot through, but being off-side the referee refused a goal. From the centre of the field the home forwards raced down Briscoe finished up a great movement by scoring a very fine goal. Encouraged by this point Milward doubled down the centre, and passing to Angus he shot in but Hassell removed the danger but only for a minute, Angus meeting the ball again with a terrific shot again defeat the goalkeeper. The Champions commenced to passing on the right, and passing the home left Higgins was forced to conceded, but nothing profitable resulted. Everton again came to the front and after a beautiful run Briscoe registered goal no 3. Half time arrived Everton winning by 3 goals to nil, after the usual interval A.Milward put the sphere in motion against the wind. Brown forced a corner, which Biourne headed clear for some time the play was confirmed to the Stoke quarters but the fine defence of Mountford and Hasell kept their goal intact. A spendid game ended in a 3-0 win for Everton. Teams; EvertonReserves Joliffe, goal Higgins and Chadwick (a) backs, Jones (wh) Pollock (h) (captain), and Fryer (t) half-backs, Brown (w), Angus, Briscoe (w), Keys (j), and Milward (a) forwards. Swifts:- Halsall, goal, Boune (captain), and Mountford, backs, Harbour, Farmer, and Ryder, half-backs, Hutchinson, Broadhurst, Wainwright, Lunnicliffe (w), and Milward, forwards.
NORTH STAFFORDSHIRE NOTES.
Athletic News - Tuesday 18 December 1888
By Our Own Correspondent
After their experience of the past week, I imagine that the Everton team will have a very poor opinion of the Potteries as a pleasant place to live. On Monday they visited Burslem to play Port Vale, and the game took place in weather which was really unfit for football. The fog was so dense that the players were barely distinguishable, and it was impossible to say with certainty who scored the goals. Port Vale managed to make a draw with the Liverpool team, and on Saturday I expected to see a great number of spectators present to witness the game at Stoke.
THIS MIST.
The weather was, however, worse even than on Monday, and a much smaller number of spectators than usual attended. Everton brought a very strong team, Stoke lacking the services of Ramsey, who was not sufficiently recovered from injuries received at Burnley on the previous Saturday. Sager took his place at right half-back. In the first portion of the game Everton had much the best of the play, but their shooting was rather faulty. Several splendid shots were put in, only to be repulsed by Rowley, who kept goal finely. Costley was injured early in the game, and had to be carried off the ground, Everton playing with ten men—real Everton luck. Stoke improved later on, but Ross and Smalley defended grandly, the former putting in some huge kicks. The second half was pretty even, Stoke having rather the best of matters. The fog grew thicker and thicker, and eventually the game had to be abandoned a quarter of an hour before the appointed time, the match resulting in a draw, no goals having been scored. It was a pity that the weather was so unfavonable, as the game was completely spoiled. The Everton team played in much better form than they exhibited against Port Vale, the forwards showing good combination. Ross was a tower of strength, and Smalley stopped everything that was put in. On the Stoke side, Milarvie showed greatly improved form, and executed several clever runs. Rowley, in goal, performed brilliantly, and was, ably supported by the backs.
Stoke swifts took nine players to Everton, and, as a consequence, suffered defeat by three goals to none after a hard and fast game.
LIVERPOOL DISTRICT
Athletic News - Tuesday 18 December 1888
CHAMPION RESERVE AT ANFIELD
A great amount of interest was centred in the return match with the Everton Reserve and Stoke Swifts, as they played a drawn game at Stoke some weeks ago. Halsall early on had to clear a shot from keys, but the Swifts then took up the running and attacked persistently. The home forwards eventually cantered to the other end, Briscoe scoring, whilst a little later Angus added another, Briscoe following this up with a third. After the interval the home forwards for some time kept in the Stoke half, but the defence was capital. From now to the close the home team had the best of the game, ultimately winning by three goals to none.
NOTES
M. McKinnon, late of Everton playing for Crosby.
LIVERPUDLIANA BY RICHARD SAMUEL
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 22 December 1888
Everton and draws
Everton not been noted for playing drawn games at any time, but they have lately had quite a tendency in this direction. Two were recorded last week, both singularly in matches with North Staffordshire clubs, Port Vale and Stoke. The latter team have improved considerably since the commencement of the season, when their position in the League was not so easy to justify either on form past or form present. Several notable successes have greatly enhanced their merits in the eyes of the football world, and Everton were gonerthy booked for defeat by the tipsters, the game being down to be played at Stoke. Thither wont one of the best teams Everton has put in the field this season, but still not quite as strong as it had been intended it should be. Angus did not turn out, and Watson was gain included in the right wing, as partner to Davies, the Chirk man. By the way, Davies is an Englishman, and now, I understand, a fully-fledged professional on the Everton roll. Morris was again tried in the centre with as little effect against Long Eaton Rangers, whilst the left wing was again held by Costley and Chadwick. The back division was, as usual, powerful, quite representative with the exception of Dobson for Dick. Stoke were not quite at their strongest, and a good game was anticipated. A fog which overhung the ground made play anything put an interesting matter for the spectators, whilst it greatly depleted their number, so that it would not be easy for the home side to cover expenses after paying Everton the required guarantee. Not very much of game appears to have been visible, but what was seen appeared to be mostly favourable to the visitors. The Stoke custodian has an excellent reputation, and it did not suffer by his last performance. In the first half Everton peppered hotly round Rowley, but no shot could find its mark, whilst Sugg and his confreres easily kept the home forwards at bay. The match came to a premature end owing to mist, and no goals having been scored the players were nothing loth to acquiesce in the referee's decision. Davies appears to have confirmed impressions of ability, but he has to unlearn a very bad habit of slugging the ball too closely. The usual casualty to an Everton player was afforded on this occasion by the disablement of Costley from severe wrench.
CHRISTMAS ARRGAMENENTS
All Liverpool is agog over the coming struggle at Anfield-road between Bootle and Everton. It is freely asserted that both teams will be strengthened for the occasion, and all manner of rumours are afloat. I can say for certain that Mills-Roberts will kept goal for Bootle, if his professional duties do not debar him. Beyond this all is rumour. Let us hope that in the season of good will and good fellowship we shall have a fair, honest game. Mr. Gregson is to be referee, and the players will have to be on their best behavior in the face of recent occurrences. It is satisfactory to show that nearly all the ardent animosities have been swept side, and there is nothing to fear from the players. It is from the spectators that most of the suggestions is to be dreaded, so let us censure heartily any approach to “dirty” play from whichever side it proceeds. Let this censure be unanimous and it will not be necessary to express it more than once. It was said that Holt had made it a condition of his signing for Everton that he should not be asked to play against Bootle. It is scarcely likely that he will stand out, however, and it is to be hoped that both he and his old comrades will for the sake of old friendships restrain any bitterness which may be provoked under the circumstances. Everton have two matches on Christmas Day with Ulster and Park Road, the latter a Lancashire Cup tie, whilst Everton will again be away from home on the 29th.
PRESTON NORTH END V. EVERTON
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 22 December 1888
The League contest between the above clubs-the first on the list and the fifth respectively-took place at Deepdale this afternoon before 8,000 spectators. The match had been anticipated with some interest, as the Prestonians wished to gauge the strength of the rising Liverpool club, and they were also glad of the opportunity to once more see N.J. Ross playing at “Fruitba.” The teams were;- Preston North End;- Trainer, goal; Howarth and Holmes, backs; Robertson, Russell, and Graham, senior half-backs; Gordon, Ross, Goodall, Dewhurst, and Drummond, forwards. Everton; Smalley, goal; Ross and Dobson, backs; Farmer, Holt and Weir, half-backs; Angus, Chadwick, Brown, Briscoe, and Watson, forwards. Referee; Mr. Brownlow. A loud burst of applause heralded the appearance of Everton prominent among whom was J, Ross, and there were cheers when Jack and Mr. Sudell had a short but friendly chat in midfield. Then Drummond had a good reception, Everton kicked off uphill at 2 40, Drummond at once making an attempt to get down the left, but the visitors returned, and Watson and Briscoe had to be stopped. Then N. J. Ross repelled the home right, but the ball was at once in possession of North End, Goodall shooting wide, but at the end of four minutes Drummond centred, and Goodall scored for North End. .A run followed by the Everton forwards, Chadwick making a long, swift shot, which, however, went wide. Both teams now warmed to their work, Watson and Weir gave a little trouble to the home backs, but they were kept in check, and three corners followed to the home team. From a throw-in the home quarters, the ball was passed across in' front of Trainer, Watson not being up. Then the visitors’ forwards came up again with some very creditable passing, but Angus shot wide amid cries of Off-side.” At once the home right centred, Goodall shooting over the bar— a rare chance missed. Watson and Briscoe made several fine but fruitless attempts to get past Robertson and Howarth, while Ross earned applause by neatly, dispossessing Gordon. Play now became very monotonous, until a well-meant attack by Everton ended in Chadwick kicking into the hands of Trainer. Several times were the home forwards repelled by the clever tackling the Everton backs and half-backs. Everton at last won a corner, and Trainer had to kick the ball away, and after the North End forwards had once more been thrown back the Evertonians again attacked, Brown heading into Trainer’s hands, and Chadwick attempting to charge the goalkeeper through. For this Everton were cheered. Watson and Briscoe had also shots for the home goal, and at the other end North End had a free kick for a foul by Holt. Russell on the other side was similarly penalized. The home right again failed to circumvent Ross and Farmer. Watson got past both Graham and Holmes, and had just been charged over by Graham when half-time arrived with the score North End 1, Everton 0. Give and take play marked the beginning of the second half. Considerable amusement was caused by N. J. and his brother trying to dodge each other. This time, however, the young ’un came off best. Farmer and Dobson did some clever tackling, the display of the home forwards being very weak. In seven minutes a free kick for hands fell to the home team near Smalley, from which Goodall headed the ball through. From the kick-off the visitors’ left got near Trainer, and there was seen a struggle between Ross and the home right, but Goodall put in an even shot, Smalley saving by falling on the ball, and getting it away. Everton left now played up with a vigour, a fierce attack ensuing in Trainer’s keep. The latter had at close quarters to save warm one from Briscoe, as Brown was upon him. Surrounding Smalley a free kick fell to North End. Goodall passing to Gorton, who struck the crossbar, and Dobson got it away. The ball continued in Everton quarters, Jack Ross defending grandly, and Smalley saving a good shot from Goodall. Drummond gave Smalley a hot shot. At the other end Angus won a corner, and Holt shot over the bar. Goodall was near scoring, and from free kick the ball was put through the North End goal without touching a player. The home forwards, however, continued to have the best of it, but both Smalley and Trainer had to save. At last Dewhurst shot in, and the ball passed through the Everton goal off Farmer. The Everton goal had more narrow escapes, but nothing further was done, and the North End won comfortably. Final Result. Preston North End 3, Everton 0.
SPECIAL
The game at Deepdale today, proved very disappointing to the Preston spectators, although their team won. That of course had been expected with confidence, but the play for a good deal of the game was of a very uninteresting description, the home forwards being easily robbed in front of goals. Smalley kept goal well. Ross had an exceedingly good reception and played a grand game. Dobson also played well, as did also Farmer and Weir at half-back. The forwards, however, were only considered a moderate lot. The home defence was quite good enough for all that was put against them, and it was considered that if the North End put forth their strength they might have won by twice the number of goals they did.
NUGGETS
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 22 December 1888
PRESTON NORTH END 3 EVERTON 0 (game 15)
December 23 1888. The Liverpool Courier
The first of the League fixture between the above organistions took place at Deepdale on Saturday. Eight hundred spectators accompanied the team, Everton were short of Davies, Sugg, and Dick. Teams:- Preston North End:- Trainor, goal, Howarth and Holmes, backs. Robertson Russell, and Graham, half-backs, Ross, Gordon Goodall, Dewhurst, and Drummond, forwards. Everton:- Smalley goal, Ross (captain), and Dobson, backs, Farmer Weir, and Holt half-backs, Angus, Chadwick, Brown, Briscoe, and Watson, forwards. Ross lost the toss, and Goodall kicked with the advantage of a strong wind, and immediately Preston took up the attack. A grand shot from Dewhurst was well repulsed by Dobson. Everton now showed up on the right, Briscoe kicking over the bar. A grand combined run enabled Goodall to score five minutes from the start. From the kick-off Preston again pressed, Ross robbed Gordon in the nick of time. Goodall went away with a fine dribble, Holt foiling effort effort by good tackling. Dewhurst and Drummond now raced down the left and passing tom Goodall to kick over. Everton now improved in the play. Angus and Chadwick put in some good passing, on the left. From the pass Brown shot in Trainer clearing Ross jun forced the play to the right, but could not break the fine defence of Ross and Dobson. Brown broke, and passing to Angus he forced Howard to conceded a corner, but nothing tangible resulted. Everton now passed on the right. Trainor having to save in succession. The ball was now confined to the home left. Drewhurst missed a grand opportunity by kicking out. Everton now had a free kick against Russell. The Ball was well placed, but an erractic shot spoiled the advantage. Screw at half-time:- Preston North End 1 goal, Everton nil. After the usual interval, Goodall put the ball in motion, and immediately North End rush away, Dobson intercepted a grand move, and Everton removed the venue to the otherend, where Brown experienced very hard lines, a foul against Everton near the goal mouth, where some good heading was shown by Dewhurst and Drummond, a second goal being scored amidst the hearty cheers of the Prestonians. From the centre, Brown put in a beautiful run, Trainer having a grand shot from Angus. Ross now stopped a dangerous run on the part of his brother and Chadwick was again bust at the other end, Smalley was saved for some spendid defence. Weir now passed to Chadwick, who raced down, and another corner fell to Everton the place being nicely taken. Angus just missing his mark with a spendid shot. Ross took a free kick well in front of the Preston posts, the ball passing between untouched. The visitors now caused some trouble Howarth and Holmes removing the danger with some fine kicking. Preston now infused more life into the game and after some fine passing Dewhurst scored a spendid goal owing to a misunderstanding on the part of the visiting backs. From now to the end of play was very even. Everton ought of scored but lack of combination in front of goal robbed them of a couple of goals. The Everton team played a spirited game. Result Preston 3 Everton nil.
EVERTON BEATEN AT DEEPDALE
Athletic News - Monday 24 December 1888
The League match with Everton was looked forward to with great interest at Preston, owing to the late North End captain. N. R. Ross, now sporting the Everton colours. There was a rumour abroad to the effect that Ross would not turn up to play against his old club mates generally, and his brother in particular, but these were found to be without much foundation, though I believe it is a fact that Ross did not want to play, but, owing to so many of the Everton team being disabled, Jack determined to assist them, and be must have been gratified with his reception on his old battlefield, for when he appeared and shook hands with Mr. Sudell the cheering was immense. There was a large attendance—about 7,000—but the game was not so interesting as was generally anticipated, but really the Everton club have been so unfortunate in getting their men injured that their team is but a shadow of its former self. Drummond reappeared in the North End team, which was the best they could put on the field, and when Goodall scored in the first five minutes it looked as if the Everton team were in for a good drubbing, but though North End had much the best of the play they only wen by three goals to none, one being scored in the first half and two in the second. The game fell very flat, and Ross and Dobson were quite good enough for the rather poor display of the North End forwards in front of goal. Ross played exceedingly well, and was repeatedly cheered, and Smalley, a Prestonian, was very successful in goal. The half-backs did fairly well, Farmer, perhaps, being the best, but the forwards are a very poor lot, though it must not be forgotten that they were very much mixed up. The North End forwards were not up to the usual standard, bat the backs and half-backs were too much for the Everton front rank. The result was never in doubt, and this seemed to have an influence on the home team.
EVERTON RESERVES
Athletic News - Monday 24 December 1888
The Anfield enclosure was again occupied with the reserve, and they had the North End juniors as opponents. The home team played against the wind in the first half, and North End attacked, but their shooting was faulty, and then Everton had a look in, and Millward scored. The play was exciting, and Joliffe saved well on several occasions, both Inglis and Irwin playing a good game for the visitors, and at half-time Everton led by a goal to nil. With the wind Everton pressed and played a winning game throughout, Milward especially being in good form, and when the whistle blew Everton had won by four goals to one. Joliffe kept goal well, and Milward was conspicuous amongst a nicely balanced lot of forwards. The North End forwards showed 'event nice snatches of passing; but they shot badly, and their defence was not so good as their opponents.
PRESTON NORTH END V. EVERTON
December 24, 1888. The Birmingham Daily Post
At Deepdale, before 8,000 spectators. Everton kicked off uphill. North End at once attacked, and in five minutes Goodall scored. Three corners fell to the home team, but Jack Ross and Dobson defended well, while the Everton forwards made several good runs, and Trainor had once to throw away. Play became very slow and uninteresting. A corner to Everton was useless, but Trainor had to save. Time after time were the home forwards repelled, and Watson had the ball near Trainor when the interval arrived, with the score –North End 1 goal, Everton 0. Seven minutes from the restart Goodall headed a second goal for North End from a free kick. Play improved after this, the Everton forwards attacking and Trainor saving. Gordon hit the Everton crossbar, but Ross and his companions continued to defend well, while Smalley smartly saved shots from Goodall and Drummond. The game was from this point all in favour of North End, but they were very weak in front of goal. Everton won a corner, and, after a run by Goodall, Angus and Briscoe each had shots at the home goal. Time after time were the home forwards dispossessed. Both goalkeepers saved, but Farmer put a shot from Dewhurst through his own goal, making the home score three goals. Everton had several more narrow escapes, the result being –Preston North End 3 goals, Everton 0.
EVERTON RESERVESS 4 PRESTON NORTH END RESERVES 1
December 24 1888. The Liverpool Mercury
The new stands on the Anfield-road enclosure have greatly improved the appearance of the ground, and though they were not so well filled as we expected there was a good number of spectators when the following teams faced:- Preston North End Reserves:- Culshaw, goal, Hays, and Whittle, backs, Worthington, Dempsey, and Joy, half-backs Irvin Gilleade, Inglis, Dobson, and Gillespie forwards. Everton Reserves:- Joliffe, goal, Higgins, and Chadwick (a) backs Parry (t), Pollock (h) (captain) and Fayer (t) half-backs, Falls Jones (wh) Milward (a) Keys (j), Morris, forwards.
Milward kicked off and Morris at once tried a long shot which went wide. North End made an attack, which was freshened by Higgins. Whittle returned, and Irvin passed to Gillespie who shot wide. Hands spoiled the home forwards when well within the enemy quarters.Irvin was cheered for good play on the right, Gillespie again shooting wide. Milward playing in good form troubled the visiting backs, and hands in a dangerous position was given again North End. Jones took his kick which went behind. Inglis robbed the home halfs and passed to Dobson, Higgins brought him up, but Gillespie shot wide. Everton had now to concede a corner. Inglis took the kick which went behind. Inglis imitated a bit of pretty passing. The defence being too good the visitors were unable to score. Thus was a good attack made by the Everton forwards, and a spendid attempt to score was made. Culshaw had to concede a corner and from the kick Irwin made a spendid dribble nearly the length of the field, and Joliffe was cheered for a grand save. Jones made a good run up the left and passed to Falls, who made a poor shot. The attack was kept up, and for pretty passing in front of goal Milward beat Culshaw and scored Everton's first goal. A tussle took place between Irvin and Morris, Morris getting the best of it. Jones and Falls raced up the left, but Jones shot very wide. Dobson and Irvin was cheered for a fine run, and Irvin cleverly kept the ball in and made a good but futile shot. Milward put in a good dribble in the centre, and passed both backs and Everton had a chance, which they lost by bad following up. Higgins made a grand save. Inglis returned to Joliffe, who fisted out. The North End forwards now made a pretty combined dribble and Higgins gave a corner. Inglis tried a high shot, which just missed its mark. Joliffe again was cheered for a grand save, keeping the globe out when it seemed impossible to do so. The game was very exciting, North End sending in shot after shot Joliffe still keeling his charge intact in champion form. Inglis ran down the right, after even play, and just shot wide. Everton took the ball up from the kick, and gained an abortive corner. Inglis again made a grand single-handed dribble and had hard lines. Half-time arrived with the score Everton Reserves 1 goal, Preston North End Reserves nil. In the second half, Inglis kicked off and Jones raced down the left, and Whittle caused laughter by neatly robbing Milward. The Wind, which was blowing from end to end was in Everton's favour, and a different complexion was put on the game. Culshaw being called upon to save by Milward. He just fisted out, and Milward, playing in grand form, took the leather into the goal mouth, and with a fast shot which struck the upright, defeated Culshaw, and made the score two to nil. Jones was now loudly cheered by the delighted crowd for a grand dribble down the left. Heys robbed him and North End attacked. Chadwick making a hugh kick Keys raced up the right and Culshaw had to fist out a good shot. Keys robbed Jones cleverly and kicked to Fryer, who returned, and the home forwards salted down in line, and an exciting bit of play ended in Falls scoring the third. Bad shooting spoiled North End and Everton again were swarming in front Milward doing the needful amidst loud cheering. Joliffe now made a mistake, which nearly gave a goal to North End, fisting the ball straight up, Dobson headed in and the leather just missed the goal. Everton gained a corner and kept up a installed on the North End goal without anything tangible being scored. North End with four goals against them were playing well, and tried heard to break the ice. Their Forwards dullied rather too long in front and lost the advantage gained. Everton playing a winning game gained a futile corner and ‘'hands'' in front of goal also helped them without result. Dobson and Gillespie raced up the left and Dobson amused the crowd by shooting nearly to the touch line. Irvin now went half-back and North End had the best of the argument for some time. Keys and Morris broke away, Milward spoiling their efforts by missing his kick. Not to be denied, Morris raced up the left, and sent in a grand shot which was well saved. North End now made a determined effort, which was successful. After passing nicely in front Gillespie got the leather, and sent in a good high shot, which Joliffe only partially stopped, and North End had secured their first goal. Final result:- Everton Reserves 4 goals, Preston North End Reserves 1.
EVERTON 3 ULSTER 0
December 26 1888. The Liverpool Courier
The series of matches arranged by the Anfield executive for the Christmas holidays took place yesterday morning in beautiful weather. The Ulster team are very popular with the Everton patrons, but their display was rather inferior, no doubt due to the fact that they arrived from the sister isle a few hours before they had to take the field. Fully 6,000 spectators were present when the teams put in an appearance at 10.45. Ross having lost the toss. Milward started hostilities against a very strong breeze. For a few minutes the play was confined to midfield until until Angus with a screw shot, tested Pinkleton, who kicked clear. Davie forced his way up the centre until met by Pollock,, who robbed at a dangerous moment, and again Everton were busy on the right, Watson missing a rather easy chance from a pass by Fall. Hands against the Irish captain gave Falls an opening, his shot being well cleared. Pinkleston was again called upon immediately after to stop a slinger from Weir. Miller and Martin looked dangerous on the right, but could not break through the fine defence of Ross and the veteran Mike,, who gave the ball to Milward and after some fine passing on the left Milward scored the first goal. From a throw in by Leslie, Coyne and Davie dribbled up the left, Ross removing the danger with a strong punt. Milward receiving the pass forced a corner. Which Stevenson kicked over. Tierney now raced up the centre, his final effort going very wide. Weir brought the ball down the right pinkertton saving shots from Watson and Keys, who strove hard to increase the lead. Two corners now fell to Everton, Leslie kicking clear a grand shot from Pollock, who experienced hard lines shortly after with a beautiful header. Watson accounted for a fine screw by Milward. After a short run by Coyne, Angus got the ball well in front from a corner kick, Phillips clearing in the goal mouth, and again Weir rushed in from half-backs and banged the ball through. From the kick off the Ulster van went away win a fine combined run, Coyne finishing with a wide shot. Angus now pressed on the left, and getting well down Milward again shot in, Pinkleton again clearing. Joliffe was now called upon to clear from Meyers. This brought half-time. Score Everton two goals Ulster nil. After the usual rest Meyers re-started, the play being confined to the home right Watson having hard lines with a grand shot, which struck the uprights. Ross made an alteration Falls going in gaol, and Joliffe going left wing forward, the play of Joliffe causing great amusement for the spectators. Coyne and Meyers broke away, Higgins again proving a stumbling block, and again Everton assumed an aggressive attitude, Pinkleton repelling a strong shot from Angus Martin with a rear turn of speed dribbled up the right, and passing Ross Fall kicking clear. The home van pressed forward to the other gaol, and from now to the close of the game the home team had pretty much their own way, the sphere rarely going over the centre line Just before the close Joliffe increased the score. From a pass by Falls. Final Result Everton three gaols Ulster nil. Teams Everton:- Joliffe goal, Ross (captain), and Higgins, back, Weir, Pollock and Stevenson half-backs, Angus, Falls, Milward Watson, and Keys, forwards. Ulster:- Pinkleston, goal, Watson, and Downes backs Phillips, Tierney, and Leslie half-backs Miller, Martin, Millar (j) Davie, Coyne forwards.
EVERTON RESERVES 3 BLACKBURN PARK ROAD 2
December 26 1888. The Liverpool Courier
Lancashire Cup Round Three
At the advertised time for commencing this important fixture, the weather was something wretched. A very heavy downpour and a regular gale of wind was the order of the day throughout the whole of the match. The ground was very slippery and the Players experienced great difficulty in keeping their feet. At 2-30 the players mad their presence on the field, the home team being rather weak owing to the numerous conditions that Council the Lancashire senior cup. Dobson lost the toss, in front of around 40000 spectators, and Brown put the ball in motion, and passing to Briscoe it was odds on Everton scoring. Frankland clearing with a hugh punt, from which Nackerath screwed across to Gargett, who with a long shot, beat Joliffe ten minutes from the start. Immediately after Dobson fouled the ball. The free kick was nicely placed by Eastham Holt clearing in the goal mouth. Bricoe and Jones worked beautifully down the right, a shot from the latter taking effect to the delight of the spectators. A.Chadwick was nest conspicuous with a grand bit of tackling and passing to Brown, he struck the Blackburn upright with a spendid shot. Whitaker and Mackereth pressed on the left, a grand pass from the latter being badly missed by Garner. Briscoe beat Jackson in a warm tussle, and Jones getting possession he gave Noble a rare fistful to clear. The Blackburn right again came down with a great dash the final effort of Mackereth going over. Dobson now took the kick out, and with a powerful lunge kicked the ball from his own goal within a few yards of the opposite end, the finest kick ever seen on the Everton enclosure. Two corners new fell to the home club, Noble stopping a rare header from Higgins. Farmer next stopped a rush by the blackburn men, and passing to Harbourhe missed a grand chance by kicking outside. Half time, one goal each. After a slight rest Lighhound put the ball in motion, and immediately the visitors broke away. Dobson in working the ball clear had the misfortune to hands the ball, and from the free kick Joliffe stopped a regular beauty from the foot of garner. The home right again raised the siege, and after some grand running Harbour obtained the lead by shooting through. Everton now had the best of the game, but the greasy state of the ball rendered accurate shooting impossible. After some exciting play in the Blackburn quarters Whataker got away, but Farmer robbed him, and dribbling nicely down the centre sent a spendid shot, which took effect. Even play followed until Garner got passed Chadwick and with a low shot defeated Joliffe a second time. Shortly after the official whistle sounded. leaving Everton winners by three goals to two. Teams Everton:- Joliffe goal, Dobson (captain), and Chadwick (a), backs Farmer, Holt, and Frier (t) half-backs, Harbour, Higgins Brown, Briscoe, and Jones forwards. Blackburn Park Road:- Noble goal, Frankland and Yates, backs, Jackson, Eastham and Hartley, half-backs, Mackeretth, Whitaker, Lightbrown Gargett, Garner, forwards.
EVERTON O BOOTLE O
December 27 1888. The Liverpool Courier
This important and much talked of fixture between these two local rivals took place at Anfield-road yesterday, the unhappy difference which have lately prevented their meeting being amicably arranged. The clubs have met often in local Cup ties and in friendly competition during the past ten years, and Everton may fairly claim to have established superiority over their Bootle friends being the victors in nearly every encounter. Notwithstanding this fact, the Bootle club has always come up smiling, and it may be said coincident of turning the scale''this time'' ‘'new men and new methods'' have been tried, and at the present juncture this is more noticeable than on any previous encounter, there being very few men now playing for either team who played in last year's cup tie. There is, however, to some extent a similarity of fortune in the position of the Evertonians club, who have always in these encounters been enable to place their full strength in the field. This year the hospital contingent is very strong and they are minus the services of Smalley, Dick, Waugh and Costley. From the Bootle team we miss the old Veteran Veitch their other changes being, however, an improvement upon last year's eleven. The weather was not too propitions, the ground being sloppy from the rains of the last few days, making accurate play impossible and causing evident amusement to the vast crowd, who througed the new comfortable enclosure as the players endeavored sometimes in vain to keep their foothold on the treacherous turf. The kick off was advertised for two o'clock, but long before that hour the throng of partisans were crowding the approaches to the ground and when the teams put in an appearance there would be fully 16,000 spectators present. Ross having won the toss Galbraith kicked off for Bootle amidst much excitement. The Bootle left rushed down and a foul was given against Dobson but nothing tangible resulted. Booth continued to press and Ross was compelled to kick out. Everton now rushed up, but Angus shot wide. From a foul Galbraith shot, but Joliffe fisted out. The game was very fast, and Everton rushed up Brown shooting well in compelling Jackson to concede a corner, which came to nothing. From a free kick off Davies got up, but the ball went out Everton having slightly the best of the game. Dobson relieved a rush by the Bootle left and the venue was quickly changed. Angus passed to the right, but Davies missed a good chance. MacFarlance playing grandly. The Everton let got up, and Chadwick shot but Jackson saved. The Everton forwards again got up but the ball was kicked out. Ross Dobson and Weir relieved a good rush by the Bootle forwards. From a foul against Holt Bootle got away, but the ball went out. Give-and-take play followed. The Everton left got well up, but Farmer dallied, and the ball was worked away. Even play followed, the game being very fast. Dobson tried a long shot, and Jackson fisted over. The corner, however, came to nothing. Dobson shooting wide immediately after Everton pressed, but the ball was forced out, Davies hugging the ball too much. The play continued in the Bootle half, and Jackson saved a low shot from Chadwick. The Bootle left got away, But Dobson relieved grandly. Davies was now prominent with a grand run, the ball, however, going out. A foul against Bootle was taken by Weir, and Chadwick just missed scoring Briscoe heading wide a little later. Everton still pressed, and Chadwick again narrowly missing scoring the same player immediately after striking the upright amidst great excitement, Davies shooting wide just after. A foul against Everton was kicked out by Campbell. Dobson compelled Jackson to handle. Bootle had z luck in, but Ross soon cleared. A foul was given against Campbell for tripping Weir, but nothing came of it. Half-time being called with a clean sheet. Brown kicked off after the usual interval. The Everton right worked down Briscoe and Brown clearing well. Bootle pressed and a corner resulted which was worked away. A foul against Bootle was taken by Weir, and Miller conceded a corner. The Bootle forwards got up, but Woods shot wide. Everton pressed, but MacFarlane relieved. After a good rush by the bootle forwards Jamieson out the ball through but the point was disallowed for offside. Bootle convinced to press, the excitement being intense Everton rushed off, and a foul was given against Bootle. The play ruled very fast and exciting, Everton having slightly the best of the play. The Bootle right got down, and a scrimmage ensued in which Ross was winded. Bootle pressed, and the ball went behind. Bootle now played grandly, the Everton defence bring severely tried. A foul was given against Campbell, and the Everton forwards got down, Miller relieving Everton having hard lines. Everton still pressed, but found the Bootle defence too good, Brown and Holt being Noticeable for good play. Chadwick screwed across but Briscoe missed, a corner resulting which proved fruitless. Davies shot wide soon after. Hands was given against jamieson, Chadwick shot in well but Jackson grandily, Davies shooting badly just after. Dobson saved a good rush. Davies shot behind after good play by the Everton forwards, Everton pressed, Angus shooting behind. Even play followed. Everton now pressed, and Hotshot wide. Ross took a free kick for a foul against Bootle, Campbell being noticeable for dirty play, but the Bootle left worked up, Dobson relieving, Davies shot wide. A foul was given against Everton and one against Bootle immediately after offside against Everton and from the free kick Bootle got up, but Dobson relieved. Time was called with the result a draw. Result; Everton 0, Bootle 0.
Teams; Bootle, Jackson goal, McFarlane, and Miller backs, Allsop (a), Hughes (w), and Campbell (w), half-backs, Woods (j), Galbraith (h), Jamieson Jones, and Galbraith (d) forwards; Everton:- Joliffe goal, Ross (captain), and Dobson backs, Farmer, Holt, and Weir, half-backs, Angus, Chadwick, Briscoe, Davies, and Brown (w), forwards.
LIVERPUDLIANA BY RICHARD SAMUEL
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 29 December 1888
CHRSITMAS AT EVERTON
Two matches ware played on the Everton ground, on Christmas Day, the game in the morning being with Ulster, whilst in the afternoon the Cup tie with Blackburn Park Road was brought off. The morning game in complete farce. The Ulster team was never a great one, it is now a very inferior one, and though Everton were represented by a very shaky eleven, a weak reserve team, they won easily by, three to mil. There was no presence or show of pesstance and Joliffe, who kept goal for Everton, got tired of his inaction and exchanged positions with Falls. The latter soon came down to take a corner0kick, a very peculiar circumstance, for the spectacle of a goalkeeper taking a corner-kick is decidedly a rare one. There was an attendance of four thousand, and in the afternoon, when the most miserable weather prevailed, this figure was at least equaled. The game was of a far different character, and it was only after a very stiff struggle that Everton came off victorious by three goals to two. The Everton Committee had obtained permission to play the tie before the prescribed date, Park Road acquiescing. All the eligible members of the Everton team except Smalley took part in the game, and the visitors made this put forth their most powerful efforts. Despite the wretched state of the ground, the game was very fast right through.
THE MEETING OF BOOTLE AND EVERTON
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 29 December 1888
By Richard Samuel
At length the great Liverpool rivals have met, and still the question of supremacy is in abeyance. For years the race to the front between these two clubs has been of a neck and neck character, and though Everton has got within the charmed circle of the Football League, Bottle’s reputation has kept pace with that of their rivals, and looking back on the performances of the clubs in the present season there is not much to choose between them. Bootle have met every club of note in Lancashire, and can claim victories over Accrington, Burnley, Blackburn Rovers, Halliwell (twice), Darwen, Blackburn Olympic and South Shore. Everton’s most notable victories have been against Aston Villa, Accrington, Bolton Wanderers, Burnley, Notts County Derby County (twice). The history of the various matches between the clubs themselves is meet exciting one. The games have always been the of keenest nature, but Everton have generally got the verdict by a goal or the match has been drawn. Frequently the bitterness and partisanship, and sometimes disgraceful scenes have characterized their meetings, and at times the relations between the executives have been entirely broken off. This has been the case during the two seasons preceding the present, but gradually a relief has been given to the strain, and now the relations are of a very cordial description. Three games have been arranged between the clubs, the first of which came off on Boxing Day, and the takings at this gate were divided between the clubs; whilst there are home and home fixtures yet to come off, the first of which is at Bootle on March 9th, the final being at Anfield on April 13th. Great preparations had been made, in anticipation of a record gate at the Everton ground on Wednesday, and the expectation was not beyond the mark. The enclosure now bears the resemblance of a hugh circus, with its two immense galleries, rising tier above tier, and its covered stands stretching the length of the ground on the one side and for the greater part of that distance on the other. Every inch of available space was utilized, and the spectacle was of a most imposing description. The charge for admission was sixpence, so that the takings from something like fifteen or sixteen thousand spectators will leave the rival clubs in a happy position for some time to come. There were few who grumbled at the increase in the price of admission, which is to be deprecated generally, but which, under the circumstances, was quite justifiable. The demand for places was so great as to justify the increase on ordinary business principles, whilst a further justification is to be found in the desire to prevent anything like an uncontrollable rush. At such a season, few supporters of the clubs will be disposed to grumble at giving a substantial lift to their favourites, whilst it is absolutely the duty of the Everton spectators to show their appreciation of the efforts of the committee to make the Everton enclosure one of the most remarkable in the kingdom, and to share in the pecuniary responsibilities attaching to such a great undertaking. Something approaching a thousand pounds must have been expended in the alterations, and a big hole will have been made in the deficit by the magnificent gate of Wednesday last. An enormous quantity of rain had fallen on Christmas Day and the morning of the match, and the Everton ground bore tome resemblance to its condition of the Cup tie between North End and Crewe Alexandra last season. The teams made their appearance in fragments, Farmer leading the way with Joliffe and receiving a hearty cheer. It seems Bob Smalley was hurt at Preston and could not play, but the utmost confidence was felt Joliffe’s ability. The remnant of the home team made their appearance with the exception of Holt, and it was feared amongst uneasy Evertonians that Johnny would adhere to his expressed determination not to play against his old comrades, so when he came out a great cheer arose. The volume the cheering was far greater when the Bootle team came out, and it was noticed that there was a stranger amongst them. No one seemed to know who he was, but at last it went, round that Millar, Middlesborough, the Durham full hack who created a sensation in the far North and South match, had come to assist Bootle. But where was Hastings, the crack Bootle forward? Hurt against Crewe, he could not get himself fit for the great game, to his bitter disappointment, and the irreparable loss of his club. There was no help for it, Jones must partner Jamieson, and as Ferguson could not take his place in the centre, Spencer was sent to occupy an entirely new position. And now the referee. . Mr. Gregson had failed, Mr. Duxbury had been requisitioned, Mr. Hull was anxiously sought for, and whilst debating as to whether an old Everton umpire should go to the responsible post, Mr. Duxbury leapt on to the field and was loudly cheered. And now the game is off amidst roar of excitement. Ten seconds and Bootle are down on the home goal, where Dobson twice fouls, and with bated breath the free kick is watched and a wild cheer goes up the danger is averted with a big kick from “Dobbie," as he is affectionately called. Let is now Everton’s turn, and rushing upon Jackson’s charge they threaten to carry it, impetuously to the accompaniment of that same hoarse roar of excitement. Millar is evidently no chicken heart, and drives Davies back time after time. Then Dobson tries some long lunges, and Jackson's resource is tested whilst he comes off with flying colours from the trial. Everton are evidently playing to score, Ross, Holt and Dobson letting fly repeatedly, and the Bootle backs have a most uncomfortable time. Every inch of ground is fiercely fought up to half time, and though Chadwick had made some splendid shots the Bootle goal was uncaptured, whilst Joliffe had not been severely tested at all. He was occasionally troubled, not often. Afterwards the game wore a different aspect. The Bootle forwards were evidently better at short passing than those of Everton, and some ugly attacks were directed at Joliffe. Ross tried to dribble and was despoiled Galbraith, who, with Wood, forced his way past the home backs, but the ball rolled too far. Jamieson and Jones were also making Dobson pant just now, and a corner kick on this side landed the ball right in the home goal, where it was hardly driven away, when up the right wing in pretty style came the Bootle forwards, and Allsopp lifted the ball well into goal. Ross headed for it, missed it; Dobson overran himself in struggling to reach it, and Jamieson pouncing the sphere banged it past Joliffe. Such a cry of exultation arose as is seldom heard on a field, but before Mr. McMurray, the Bootle umpire, could state his case, Mr. Duxbury had pointed to the Everton goal, indicating that, as the starting point, and Bootle supporters looked blank—offside. The situation had been very serious for Everton for a long time, but they now bestirred , themselves and were not again pressed, whilst a fierce , struggle was kept up round Jackson, where Macfarlane , covered himself with glory, quite excelling his efforts of the first half. And the end came with a blank sheet. The result was satisfactory to Bootle, a disappointment to Everton. On their own ground the Everton team is almost invincible, and they were prepared to lay odds on themselves for Wednesday’s game, whilst Bootle were depressed owing to the absence of Hastings, from whom so much is always looked, and never in vain. The game was contested in a splendid spirit, the number of fouls, even with such an aggressive referee as Mr. Duxbury, being below the average of an ordinary game. The play, too, was of a high class under the circumstances, and intensely exciting even in its dullest passages. Everton’s defence was superior, Bootle’s attack more coherent than their opponents. Of the defenders Ross and Dobson were in great form, and Holt easily surpassed Farmer and Weir, whilst Chadwick was the best forward on the field. Jackson kept goal gallantly for Bootle, Macfarlane was in fine form behind, and Hughes was simply unapproachable at half-back. The wings were clever, but Jamieson missed Hastings sadly, whilst Spencer did all that could have been expected from him as centre forward. The next meeting will be held under different circumstances, let us hope, and no doubt the teams will be somewhat less hampered by absenteeism. – Richard Samuel.
WITH THE PRESTON TALENT
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 29 December 1888
The game between North End and Everton at Deepdale was about the poorest there has been on that ground this season. The home team, from some causes were never cared to exert themselves; perhaps they were keeping in mind the many other matches they had to play during the holidays. The meeting of the teams excited some curiosity in Preston and there was a fairly large gathering of spectators –including many from Liverpool- who gave Jack Ross a cordial and hearty reception on his reappearance on the old battleground, though in the ranks of the enemy. Mr. Sudell also greeted N.J. like a gentleman, an event which evoked another round of applause from the stands. The home team was well represented, Drummond taking his usual place on the left after a pretty long rest. The home team scored a goal in the first few minutes of the game, and then fell off in their play, the proceedings becoming very monotonous. Play resolved itself into a series of attacks by the home forwards (who were almost immediately robbed of the ball by the Everton backs), with now and again a good run by the visitors’ forwards, the wing men working very hard. Considerable across at the tussles between Jack Ross and the North End right wing, the former in almost every case coming off with flying colours, but it must be admitted that none of the home forwards were seen at their best –in fact, they were about at their worst. The two goals secured in the second half were won- one from a free kick and the other passed through off Farmer. Nobody appeared sorry when the game ended, and it appeared to be the general opinion that the home team were really not trying. Trainer saved two or three times cleverly, and all the backs and half-backs were safe. Graham being especially prominent. It was evident Russell’s leg was bothering him, and he left the field for a short time in the first half. The forwards did nothing worthy of mention. This remark will also apply to the Everton front rank, who have little or no combination. The halves are a smart trio, and Ross and Dobson were reliable backs. Bob Smalley kept up his reputation as a custodian clearing time after time splendidly. He was however, injured by a charge in the second half, which prevented him playing against Bootle, and Fred Dewhurst sustained a serious kick on the left ear, which compelled him to have that organ in a “sling” on Christmas Day. The game was a very friendly one.
ACCRINGTON V EVERTON
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 29 December 1888
This was a return match and played at Accrington before 3,000 spectators. Teams;- Accrington; Horne, goal; Stevenson and McLennan, backs; Howarth, Tattersall, and Pemberton, half-backs; Lofthouse, Boner, Barbour, Kirkham, and Brand, forwards. Everton; Joliffe, goal; Dobson and Ross (captain), backs; Weir, Parkinson, and Sugg, half-backs; Watson, Briscoe, Brown, Chadwick and Angus, forwards. Referee; Mr. Fitzroy, Norris. Accrington started against the sun, and Brand immediately had a couple of flyers, both however, over the bar. Everton returned with a smart passing run, and after a second invasion Parkinson lifted well in, and Brown took an easy goal. Corners to either team followed and Accrington were very near once or twice through smart work on the left wing. Dobson followed close to goal, and Haworth enabled through an equalizer. Everton brushed up and Horne had to clear from a corner, but the Reds were at the other end where Brand shot over the bar off-side, spoiling another passible chance. Everton goal narrowly escaped later on, and Accrington kept forcing the play, beautiful tactics by the left wing keeping the strong defence pretty busy. Lofthouse got one well across and Brand tried a roller, which was rather wide, and Pemberton shot well over the top. Stevenson cleared at the other end. After a corner from Sugg, Kirkham dashed one against the bar, and Joliffe saved wonderfully well, Lofthouse following with another corner by aiming just wide. Everton were attacking when the interval came with one goal each. The second half opened with a brief attack at the Everton end, and, after which the visitors took a couple of fruitless corners. Then Kirkham dashed a sailing shot along the front of the goal and Lofthouse twisted about, but couldn’t reach it by a foot. Good work by Watson carried the war over the line, and Haworth fouling the ball close in Everton had a chance, but he leather was driven back. Then Barbour shot over with no one in front but Joliffe, but after the Everton goal had been endangered, Haworth got a flyer through at a corner, and from an ensuing scrimmage in the goal mouth. The ball was forced over the line, making a third goal for Accrington. Everton smartened up, but Accrington kept the lead up to the finish winning somewhat easy.
Final Result; Accrington 3, Everton 1
SPECIAL
A hard frost following up the Christmas deluge did not make the ground specially inviting for this afternoon’s fixture, whilst another item which interfered with correct ideas, from a player’s point of view, was the friskiness of the ball, which was rather apt to play pranks. Still it was a fairly good game nevertheless, Everton hardly came with really good intentions of substantiating their first League victory, for only 10 turned up; but Harry Parkinson, a Bell’s Temperance lad, who prevailed upon to make up the complement, rendered yeoman assistance at half-back and excelled an ordinary substitute game. Accrington may be briefly put down as having the best of the game all through. Faulty defence on the part of McLennan was responsible for Everton’s goal and, indeed, Jack did not show off his usually sound game at any time during the afternoon. However this was made up by very judicious tactics by Stevenson, whose careful play was mainly responded to by Ross at the other end. Accrington attacked very strongly uphill, and once or twice when the ball was nearing the goal the defenders’ hands flew up suspiciously; and on one occasion, after Dobson had knocked out the ball, the Accringtonians took the ball by the horns and rushed the free kick through.
NUGGETS
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 29 December 1888
THE MEETING OF BOOTLE AND EVERTON
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 29 December 1888
“Mickey Free’s” Impressions
As I know that my friend “Dicky Sam” will have a lot to say about the match on Wednesday, I shall entailment short. Well, sir, there has been nothing else talked about it for weeks amongst footballers but the chances of Bootle at length turning the tables on their old opponents. I well remember the last and only occasion upon which they did the trick, and it may not be considered out of place here to mention it. Everton as on Wednesday, had a couple of their prominent men disabled. The teams which faced each other that year (December, 1882) were as follows;- Bootle; W.S. Jones, goal; C.H. Allsopp, and W. Williams, backs; J. Rogers and F. Owen, half-backs; A.A. Allsop, J.E. Grayson, J.T. Brittains, R. Ashton, J. McInnes, and R.E. Lythgoe, forwards. Everton; F. Brettle, goal; R. Morris, and T. Marriott, backs; A.E Walsh, and W.H. Parry, half-backs; D.H. Williams, W. Williams, J. Richards, M. Higgins, G.D. Edwards, and J. Pickering, forwards. The old style of six forwards was played, and Bootle won by two goals to nil, Grayson and Ashton being the goal-getters. What a change in both teams since then! Well, Everton were minus Waugh and Smalley on this occasion, and Bootle were without Hastings, but they had a new man at full-back and another amongst the forwards –D. Galbraith-and it’s pleasing to note that he was the only one who could be accused of foul play. His putting up his elbow and catching Ross in the chest was a regrettable trick. Apart from this, the game was contested in the most friendly spirit, and nothing but the wretched shooting of Everton, coupled with the selfishness of Chadwick and Davies, prevented the Evertonians notching another win. Chadwick almost completely ignored his wing man, Angus who is consequence had little to do, and was the only clean man on the field. Davies does his kick and rush in a dashing way, but that system has been expleded years ago. It is very attractive to look at, but accounts to a great waste of energy, with no corresponding benefit. The back divisions were all there when wanted and Holt and Hughes divided the honours for half-back play, Joliffe still maintains his record against the first team of Bootle, as they have never scored against him. He only touched the ball once in the first half, and not very often in the second, whilst Jackson had a few saved by putting the ball over the bar. Taking the dreadful state of the ground into consideration the game was a good one, and Bootle carried away a substantial Christmas box, their share of the gate being, I understand, only a few shillings short of 160 pounds. The new stands were not completed a minute too soon. I have not heard what the gate was including stands, but it must have been close on 370 pounds or thereabouts.
ACCRINGTON 3 EVERTON 1 (game 16)
DECEMBER 31 1888. THE Liverpool Courier
The Everton team let Liverpool on Saturday to meet the champion drawests in their League match at Accrington. The latter played their full strength whereas Everton were minus Holt (ill) and Farmer. A modest number of spectators was present. Teams Accrington:- Hurne (jk) goal, Clellan, and Stevenson, backs, Pemberton, Tattersall, and Howaoth half-backs, Brand, Kirkham, Barbour, Bonar, and Lofthouse, forwards. Everton:- Joliffe, goal, Ross (captain), and Dobson, backs, Weir, Sugg, Parkinson, half-backs, Watson, Briscoe, Brown, Chadwick, and Angus forwards . Everton started with ten men only, one being a substitue. Everton won the toss, and Barbour kicked off with the sun in his eyes. At once the homesters pressed, Lofthouse sending one in over the bar. Chadwick then came on. Pemberton stopped Watson well. a free kick well played by Pemberton resulted in a goal kick. Chadwick took it up the centre, dodging splendidly passing to parkinson, the latter to Watson, who rushed the first goal. After the kick-off Ross was cheered for fine tackling, and returning well forced a corner, Chadwick heading over at once taking it down. The home team took it down, Lofthouse being conspicuous forcing Joliffe to concede a corner. A pretty pass by Brown to Angus was neutralised by off-side play. Hands against Ross right in the goal month resulted in Brand scoring, Howarth playing. On restarting Both Dodgson and Stevenson kicked well, Horne having to use his hands for a corner kick for the goal kick. Lofthouse raced down, a sever struggle taking place near the Everton goal, Brand kicking behind. Pretty passing by all the home forwards was neutralised by Brand's off side play. A grand shot by Chadwick waswell repulsed by Horne. The visitors were then pressed, the ball eventually bounding over the bar. Brand showed magnificent dribbling, Weir clearing more than once. Howarth bring Chadwick up. Ross kicked well, Brand racing down the left. A foul by Watson well placed was repulsed by Dobson. Chadwick got off passed to Brown the latter to Angus who was tackled by McLellan. From a grand centre by Lofthouse, Kirkham shot against the bar Joliffe throwing out, a grand ran up by Watson and Briscoe giving Howarth and Stevenson plenty to do. At half-time the score 1 all. On resuming Stevenson was called upon to defend Barbour eventually sending behind. Good kicking by Haworth, Parkinson and McLellan followed Stevenson conceding a corner. Watson was next conspicuous for some tricky play. Hands by Haworth in the month of the home goal, Pemberton relieving well, and Dobson kick over the posts. Harbour ran up, placing the visitors goal in jeopardy. A throw in gave little relief only to be returned by Stevenson. Dobson and Sugg showed good defensive play. Haworth shot in twice. Dobson kicking out. From a long shot, however, Haworth scored. After the kick off Howarth had another shot which hit the crossbar, the visitors goal being fairly believed. A goal kick gave temporary relief, Ross showing brilliant form. A couple of free kicks fell to the homesters near goal, and from a scrimmage it was sent through. Accrington had by far the best of the game for some time, Weir tackling well, and Ross kicking splendidly. Once when the ball had passed Joliffe Ross kicked across. Everton then pressed a little, Dobson by a long kicking sending in over. After Horne had fisted out, a good run down by Watson was not utilized owing to his not being supported. A corner to Everton was well repulsed. A grand game resulting-Accrington 3 Everton 1 goal.
IZATT
Scottish Referee - Monday 31 December 1888
Izatt a well-known Glasgow player, and late of the Everton in whose ranks he was the cleverest forward, was, on returning to Glasgow, suspended until the end of the present year. Today his suspension expires, and he is now at liberty to play. We believe he has thrown in his lot with the 3rd Lanark.
EVERTON RESERVES 1 BOOTLE RESERVES 1
December 31 1888. The Liverpool Courier
Everton first team being engaged in a league fixture at Accrington the rival Reserves had the one of the ground at Anfield-road on Saturday. As Everton have already been victorious over the Bootle second string twice this season the meeting was looked upon with internet and there were about 3,000 spectators present, when the teams put in an appearance. The Everton team was somewhat weak, the absence of Joliffe, Chadwick, Briscoe, and Brown being much felt . Teams:- Everton,, Lindsay goal, Ashcroth, and Higgins, backs, Fayer Pollock (h) (captain), and Farmer, half-backs, Keys,, Harbour, Milward Jones, and Kelly forwards, Bootle:- Griffiths, goal, Woods and Howarth backs, Hobley, Dodd and Moffatt, half-backs, Galbraith, Morris, McCowan, Barbour and Deane forwards. Pollock having won the toss, Milward kicked off down hill, and immediately Farmer had kicked out. From the throw in by Hobley McCowan dribbled up the centre and from a fine pass by Morris, Gralbrath shot in, Lindsay clearing. Everton now raced down and from a accurate pass by Milward Kelly put in a magnificent screw which griffiths fisted over the bar, nothing tangible resulting from the corner. A grand rush on the Everton right forced another corner, Pollock heading over the bar, Morris and Galbreaith removing the venue to the Everton uprights where Ashcroft cleared in the nick of time. Higgins now gave Milward a grand opening, and taking full advantage of the position he forced his way until tripped by Woods, for which he was penalised, Farmer shooting over the bar from the free kick. Barber put in a nice dribble up the Bootle left until he was prettily relieved by Fayer who turned over to keys, who gave to Milward. He again forced his way until tripped by Hoblay, for which a free kick was concede. Milward scoring with a low shot a quarter of an hour after the start. From the midfield Bootle pressed Everton having two men short for some time owing to injuries to keys and Milward. From a corner kick Deane missed a grand opportunity by shooting outside, Milward resume and from a pass by Kelly Milward put to a spendid run the ball going outside. Barbour now shot in, Lindsay clearing. Higgins gave a corner the ball going over. Half-time Everton 1 goal Bootle nil. After the usual rest, McCowan put the sphere in motion and again Milward was busy, his shot at goal going over. Bootle got nicely into action, and from a pass by Morris,, Gailbrath had a shy at Lindsay, who throw of Galbraith pressed. Ashcroft kicked clear Morris renewed the attack, and from a good return Hobley defeated Lindsay with a low shot Bootle still kept up the pressure a shot from Morris going over. The Everton vanguard hard to break away, and the absence of Keys as the right weakened their attack. Jones got in a good pass. Howarth heading clear a shot from Kelly, Morris and Galbraith, with very good passing caused the Everton backs some trouble, Fryer removing the danger with a long kick. Farmer worked the leather up the field, Milward just missed scoring. Everton obtained two corners, nothing resulted. Hands against Pollock gave Bootle an opening, Higgins heading clear in the goalmouth. Milward and Kelly brought relief in the home left Howarth kicking clear. Galbrath gave Morris an opening, he shot striking the upright. Milward was again prominent with a superb run Howarth robbing him, when meeting in position. Good passing brought both well into the Everton quarters, Lindsay saving a good shot from Barbour who was subsequently given offside. Fayer threw in to harbour who forced his way up the field, Woods kicking out to save. A very pleasant game ended in a draw. Everton Reserves 1 Bootle Reserves 1
ACCRINGTON
Athletic News - Monday 31 December 1888
Blest with even a fairish share of luck on Saturday the "Reds" would have literally chawed up the Everton toffee. As it was they just made things comfortably square with the damage the Liverpudlians did in the opening bout at Anfield-road. On that occasion the East Lancashire club sent a "scratchy" sort of team down, and Everton, with about the same amount of misfortune, unintentionally returned the compliment by turning up at Accrington on Saturday minus an eleventh man—Farmer. There was very little lost here, though, for Harry Parkinson, a shining light of the Bell's Temperance Club, who kindly took the place of the missing one, played a thorough serviceable game; indeed, he was as good a man as any of the lot. The play was pretty much Accrington's. Inimitable tactics on the left wing, which was always kept well supplied from Barbour and the half-hacks, were mainly responsible for the bulk of the game being confined to the Everton half, but what with erratic shooting and a load of bad luck on the top, only three goals were taken, as against Everton's one, which was got early on through had management on McLennan's part. A bad ground and frolicsome ball put a break on accuracy, but good efforts were noticeable nevertheless. Everton showed very little forward play after a few opening brushes, and Watson was about the only man who forced things on, and except just towards the finish they had only an occasional look in during the second half. Several times the visiting defenders showed up under the role of goalkeepers, and it is noticeable that two of Accrington's goals were from free-kicks, awarded for seemingly creditable attempts to keep the ball out by hook or by crook. Ross played a brilliant back game, and but for that the Liverpudlians might have been in a worse street. At the other end, too, McLennan's defence was none too reliable, and only Stevenson's watchfulness kept work off Horne. George Haworth weighed is wing up rather easily, and Tattersall, who improves every match, was also a smart half – back. Bonar was a weak spot, but he is only filling the place up until a more suitable partner is found for Lofthouse. Jimmy is getting a "good old has been," and asked to retire some time since.
LIVERPOOL AND DISTRICT COMMENTS.
Athletic News - Monday 31 December 1888
THE GREAT FIGHT AT ANFIELD
By The Loiterer
Yes, the great fight has taken place, and the result of an hour and a half's hard work has ended in smoke; in fact, we are as we were, or, in other words, the result was a draw, no goals being scored. Bootle and Everton (our local rivals) have not met (except in Cup ties) for some years, but a change of officials and, doubtless, a little diplomacy has resulted in the arranging of three matches this season, and the one under notice was the first of the series. The Anfield ground was very soft from the recent rains, and altogether against a good exhibition of football, but the whole 22 did their best, though I cannot say the display was of the first water. It was, however, a game in which the defence on both sides was decidedly superior to the attack. In the first half the attempts of the Bootle forwards were of a spasmodic character, and the opposing half-backs nipped in the bud all, or nearly all, their efforts to break away. On the other band, although hostilities were carried on in the Bootle half, I cannot say that Jackson had a shot but what the most mediocre of goalkeepers would have cleared. True, the defence of the backs was good, but there was no luck about it, and it cannot be denied that the home forwards did not play a correct game when near goal. The shots that were not wide of the posts, or over the bar, were easily manipulated, but, nevertheless, the game so far had been all in favour of Everton. With the change of ends, however, came a change of the game, as the Bootle forwards attacked vigorously, and it was not long before Jamieson put the ball through, but it was promptly disallowed. At the time I entirely agreed with the referee's decision, as he stood about opposite the Press box, and Dobson did not appear to touch the ball; but it now transpires that Dobson admits that he touched the ball, and thus placed Jamieson "onside." Compared with the first half, all I can say is, that the game was more open, but still slightly in favour of Everton, and Davies certainly ought to have scored from a pass, straight across the goal, by Chadwick. None of the forwards did much, but both sets of halves worked hard and well, Hughes and Holt especially playing a champion game, and there was nothing to choose between the full-backs. The work done by the Bootle pair compared favourably with their opponents, both in kicking and tackling. I don't see that either side has any occasion to grumble at the result, as Everton, on the day's play, ought to have won, but didn't ; and, as a matter of fact, Bootle won, but still the official result is a draw, and there you are. It certainly makes the next meeting of an interesting nature. I may add that the number of spectators was about 14,000.
THE RESERVES AT ANFIELD
For the third time this season the reserves of our two leading clubs tried conclusion. The two previous encounters have been won by Everton, but this fact did not take any of the interest out of the present match, as is testified by the presence of 3,000 people. Both sides were somewhat weak, through having to provide men for the senior teams, but a good game resulted in a draw of one goal each. The defence on both sides was good, Fayer or Everton, and Howarth for Bootle, perhaps being the best; but Milward shone out conspicuously amongst the forwards, some of his runs being well executed. Morris and Galbraith showed some nice passing, and they were principally instrumental in putting Bootle on a level footing.
NOTES
The gate without the stand, at Everton on Boxing Day realized £297, which means that close upon 12,000 persons paid for admittance. Add to the seat another 2,000 for members and the fair sex, and we have an attendance of nearly 14,000. At this was what we may call an extra match, Everton and Bootle each took a half but of course, Everton had the stand money, and the prospective gates at the remaining home-and-home fixtures should gladden the hearts of each club’s treasurer. I understand the total receipts amounted to £360.
Everton defeated Blackburn Park-road in the Lancashire Cup ties on Christmas Day, but I understand the Park-road have lodged a protest on account of the Everton team being late. I do not think it will carry.