NEWTON HEATH 1 EVERTON 1
May 2 1889. The Liverpool Mercury
The visit of our local team to Manchester last evening, attracted about 4,000 spectators, but they were greatly disappointed by the absence of Smalley, Ross Farmer, Weir and Briscoe. Powell beat Dobson in the spin of the coin, and Parry started against the wind. Immediately Chadwick and Holt gave Brown a chance of shooting but his shot went wide. Again the visiting forwards came down and compelled Hays to fist out. Owen spoiled Milward and gave D.Doughty, who shot into Joliffe hand. Dobson cleared and a foul off Doughty relieved danger for a while. Nidd sent to Chadwick and Milward, who executed a meritorious run and had hard lines in not scoring. Newton Heath then pressed for a spell, but Tait shot wide, and Joliffe cleared easily from Doughty. Even play now became the general order. And up to half-time neither side could claim an advantage. During the second half the Everton team had matters pretty well their own way, with the assistance of the wind, and from a good pass by Chadwick W.Wilson scored a beautiful goal. Continual pressing however did not add to the score, and it looked as if Everton would be returned victors but just on the call of time a bad miss by Dobson let in Tait, who rushed in and gave Joliffe no chance with a lighting shot, this being the only time they had passed the backs. Result a draw 1 goal each. Teams; Everton:- Joliffe, goals, Chadwick (a) and Dobson (captain), backs, Wilson (w) Holt, Nidd (f) half-backs, Brown Davies (j),Parry, Chadwick (e), and Milward, forwards. Newton Heath:- Hays, goal, Mitchell, and Powell (captain), backs, Burke, Davies, and Owen, half-backs, Tait, Gale, Doughty (d), Graig, and Doughty (r) forwards. Referee T.Hulme. (Bolton).
LIVERPUDLIANA’ BY RICHARD SAMUEL
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 04 May 1889
On Tuesday evening the official season closed, and this is the time of the statistician. An excellent record of the season’s work appeared in a local contemporary, but as it was compiled up to last Saturday, the list needs some modification. The complete list is as follows;-
Everton;-
Played all matches 61…Won 34…Lost 21…Drawn 6…Goals for 132…Goals against…99
At Home; Played 41, Won 31, Lost 8, Drawn 2, For 106, Goals against 43
Away;- Played 20, Won 3, Lost 13, Drawn 4, For 26, goals against 56
The most striking feature in the above figures is the poor average of Everton in their matches away from home, and indeed of the three matches won, that against Derby County is the only one against what should be considered a first-class club, Denton and Southport Central being just a step removed from the front rank. On the whole the figure throughout are very satisfactory, and at this juncture it will be just as well to glance at the entire results. Possibly some reflections on the occurrence of the season may not be out of place when football is in the back ground and affording scoope for reflection only. The next important business is the annual meeting of each of our leading clubs, and these promise to be sufficiently exciting both at Everton and Bootle.
BURNLEY AT EVERTON
The match between Burnley and Everton last Monday produced some excellent play, and resulted in an unexpected victory for Burnley. The winners played a capital game, the passing of the forwards being first class, and the team generally had a less obese and far less forbidding aspect than several elevens I have seen in Burnley colours. There was, moreover, and entire absence of roughness in their play, and though I do not wish to say that this is characteristic of Burnley football, yet their appearances in Liverpool have generally produced a crop of objectionable incidents and unseemly scene. Everton had a somewhat mixed lot to represent them. Holt was absent and his place was filled by C. Weir, who is not of today, nor of yesterday, whilst amongst the forwards might be found Mike Higgins-good old, perennial Mike. Somehow there was an appearance of superfluity of adipose in the appearance of the Everton men. Young Milward, Chadwick, Watson and Charles Weir especially looked as if they might with advantage to under the hands of the trainer. And this characteristic heaviness showed itself in the play. The Burnley men were altogether too quick for their opponents, and well deserved their success. At the same time, the best might well have been on the other leg, for Everton forced the pace at several points with the utmost determination and tried to rush the game. Cox, however, kept goal grandly for the visitors and made some remarkable saves. So did Smalley in the Everton goal, whilst Dobson and Ross were both very bad to beat. Altogether I was greatly struck with the new Burnley representatives. White was a champion at full-back, but perhaps the best of a fine defence was the very fine display of Dannie Friel at centre half. He was as fast as trickery, and as accurate as ever, and certainly showed to far greater advantage than on the occasion of other Burnley visits to Liverpool. The forwards, three of whom were reserve men, so it was stated had a perfect understanding and worked very hard throughout, Jack Yates being no white behind the best. The Everton forwards were very poor, Chadwick being as bad as any of them, whilst the tricks of old Mike are evidently played out. It is one thing for a veteran to kindly step into the breach, to rescue his club from a dilemma but with the great staff employed by the Everton committee it ought certainly to be unnecessary for such tried old players as Higgins to be compelled to demonstrate how “superfluous lags the veteran on the stage.”
THE NEW CRY AT EVERTON
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 04 May 1889
By “Mickey Free”
Sometimes one way, sometimes the other. On Saturday it was the right way, on Monday t’other, and the reason for the one to nil being reversed is not difficult of finding.
BUT ONE AT A TIOME
Saturday saw the Witton boys again at Everton, and on the occasion the ground was in better condition for a display of football, but the day was close, there being heavy thunder clouds hanging about, and the result of all this more than counterbalanced the bad state of the ground on the previous occasion, so that the going was slow, generally speaking, in fact at times even tame. Turner was an absentee, and a substitute was found in the Everton veteran, Higgins but the visitors made the same mistake in placing him which the Everton executive repeated on Monday, viz, playing him forward. “Mike” was never a success forward, as in his best days his efforts were marred by selfishness, but he made his mark as a half-back, and out of that position he should never have been played.
The game began by Milward kicking off. A visit by Witton to the Everton goal end was promptly repulsed. Angus screwed from the left, and had Keys been in his place it is possible that the little demon Sharples might have been nonplussed at an early stage. A second chance came very soon after, but “Fits,” the referee, happened to be in the line of fire, and the ball flew harmlessly off his back, and Everton lost chance number two. Pretty heading by Rushton, Smith, and Grimshaw forced Everton to concede a corner. The bias was on the wrong side, and the ball went there also. Twice in quick succession was the Witton fortress in danger, first from Milward and next from Keys, but on both occasions the ball was elevated too much. Then, Witton spurted ur, the halves were passed, Ross stopped one shot, but in dealing with a second he nearly upset the Everton applecart by heading against his own crossbar. Smalley hit clear, Isherwood returned, and this time Dobson’s head did the needful, and so the anxious faces of the Evertonians resumed their ordinary appearances. It was now Everton’s turn, and Briscoe looked like scoring. Out shot Sharples like a flash of lightning, Briscoe dropped his shoulder to meet the impetuous charge, and away went Sharples flying over Billy’s back amidst great laughter. Sharples picked himself up wonderfully quick, and was ready in a trice to do any amount of work. Rushton had a shy at Smalley, but it was no go, and half-time saw them no further towards a win than when they started. Crossing over, Witton started, and Weir almost did the trick. Briscoe followed with a neat try, and then Keys, in an attempt to get through was hurt. Ross promptly took the forward position, sending Keys back; but as this change did not work straight off, the Captain went centre, and I had scarcely finished a sentence predicting a score if Jack got the ball, when, lo! He got it, and, dashing through, beat Sharples and so put on the magic one.
Some amusement was caused by the serious manner in which the referee consulted his never-failing chronometer each time the ball was kicked over the stand before he permitted the use of a second ball, and as a bedroom window suffered in one of these flights we wondered how much extra time was allowed for the bending of a pane of glass. The end came leaving Everton winners, although Rushton and Horsefield made several brave attempts to make it otherwise.
Monday saw Burnley at Everton, and the one to nil was reversed. And no wonder. It was not a veteran’s match, and yet Higgins was played forward, as already stated. Why this was so is not at all clear, as Angus was on the stand, and although this player is not as quick as I should like, still he is streets ahead of Higgins as a forward.
Tuesday evening brought Bootle Reserve, and even here, although the decree was one to nil on the right side, the unfortunate spirit of change might have brought about another defeat from Bootle, as Joliffe was peremptorily ordered to stand down for another Everton veteran “Lindsay” but so far as I can gather this was the last straw and the players rebelled, with the result that Charley took up his accustomed position; and well it was that he did so, as he never kept goal better, and was loudly cheered. On one occasion, especially, when he was being charged by three of his opponents he turned his back and threw the ball over his head clear in a way that astonished not a few, and thus by the firmness of the players themselves. Everton were prevented making another fatal charge, and Bootle were deprived of a double crow. And, goodness knows, it has become nauseous to hear the continued howling about the first team triumph. One would think that they were now placed on a eminence so high that Everton couldn’t reach them with a fifty-foot pole. They forget that the majority was a bare goal got in the last couple of minutes, and that Everton had more of the game than they had.
BUT WHY THESE CHANGES?
The team which did duty against Renton and Witton won their matches. Was this not enough to justify the same lot being tried against Burnley? My idea is that it is time enough to change when there is a manifest failure and a game lost through it. It looks as if the financial success of the club had turned the heads of some of the executive. Well guided there is nothing to prevent Everton from becoming one of the best clubs, if not the best, in the country, and this is what I have wished for and hoped for. Still, although Everton has in a measure advanced with great strides, yet she is almost as far off what I hope to see as ever. If the same spirit of chopping and changing which we have lately seen in the disposition of the players prevails to any appreciable extent in the internal management, then we have not far to look for the cause.
NUGGETS
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 04 May 1889
LIVERPOOL AND DISTRICT NOTES
Athletic News - Monday 06 May 1889
NOTS RANGERS AT ANFIELD
By the Loiterer
Quite a respectable crowd assembled in the Anfield enclosure on Saturday, principally to see the match, I suppose, but a lot also came to see what sort of man the Everton committee have in view to till the centre-forward position next season. Geary, in the first half, did well, and the few spurts he and the right made were such as to arouse the enthusiasm of the crowd. He is, however, only light, and this is against him, but he has a fair turn of speed, and his head appears to be screwed on all right. In the second half he did little or nothing, but whether it was the result of a knock or being short of wind I cannot say. Now to the game. Play was carried on in the Rangers half for some time, and then Geary made off and beat Dobson nicely, but when just getting within range he was knocked off, and the ball went out. The home team again play to the Rangers' end, but the two smiths and Topham defended well, and Toone kept out several shots in good style. Geary and his right wing made one or two spurts, and they were always dangerous ones, but, as a rule, play was in the Rangers' quarters, and from a bouncing shot the home team nearly scored, the ball hitting the crossbar, and the goalkeeper being charged against one of the uptight, the rottenness of the structure was at once manifest. However, a friendly spectator volunteered to act as a splint, and play was resumed, but up to half time nothing was scored. On resuming, the Rangers visited Smalley, and then Toone was called upon to clear shots from Parry and Briscoe. The game was now very slow, and eventually degenerated into tameness itself. Parry scored, but the point was hotly disputed, and rightly so, and some little time elapsed ere the Rangers continued the game. From the kick off play for a time was carried on more briskly, the Rangers' left putting in some good runs, but nothing only corners resulted, and it continued uninteresting to the close, Everton winning by one goal to none.
The home team, on paper, looked a rather scratchy lot. Including, as it did, Briscoe, Wilson, and Albert Chadwick, but I suppose it is what is left of the eleven. Smalley kept goal well, and he had one or two difficult shots to clear. Dobson played a good game on the whole, though Geary was too clever for him occasionally. Albert Chadwick was rather weak in his kicks and slow, but showed excellent judgment throughout. The halves all played a good game, Weir putting in same judicious bits, and Farmer one or two clinking shots, which took Toone all his time to negotiate. Holt was as tricky and amusing as ever, but his play was marred by several shady practices. Milward partnered E. Chadwick on the left, but he did not shine; in fact, the left was weaker than usual. Parry took the centre, and if using his weight had anything to do with it he would do. Briscoe put in several good centres, and now and again passed well, but in Shelton he had a good man to deal with, and was consequently not so successful. The Rangers' backs were sturdy defenders, and the goalkeeper also saved well repeatedly, end several times under difficulties. Of the halves, the right pleased me most, and though on the small side he put in some good work. Shelton also did well, especially in the second half. Geary I have dealt with, but the best forward of the bunch was the outside left. He treated us to several quick runs, and showed a lot of restore in evading his opponents, and had the appearance of a finished player. The other forwards did not strike me as being over smart, though in the first half they did some nice bits of passing, but as the game progressed they went decidedly stale.
CHIPS
I hear that Gordon is endeavouring to shuffle out of his agreement with Everton, and it is probable the lawyers will have a little picking out of the affair.
The weather was very sultry on Saturday, and still three more weeks to run. Ugh! The Bolton Wanderers are at Anfield tonight-kick-off 6.15. The Wanderers are always welcome in Liverpool, and next to the North End command the largest gates.
The rumour that Fred Geary, the centre-forward of the Notts Rangers, is going to Everton is revived. It is said that everything is almost settled.
EVERTON 1 NOTTS RANGERS 0
May 6 1889. The Liverpool Mercury
The Anfield enclosure was patronized on Saturday afternoon by some 5,000 spectators, who witnessed what on the whole must be described as a tame and uninteresting game, the sultry weather depriving the players of much of their usual ‘'go'' Dobson won the toss, and Geary kicked off towards Oakfield-road, some exceedingly neat passing on the part of the Notts forwards showing that the Everton defence would be severely tested. Twice, early in the game, Cook and Shaw got to close quarters, Chadwick saving well on the first occasion, and Smalley by a grand effort on the second. Parry led an attack on the Rangers goal, but several opportunities of scoring were missed, Shelton and Sharpe gave Weir and A.Chadwick no end of trouble, some of their passing runs in combination with Geary being much admired, But Smalley was safe as usual. Farmer got the leather from the visitors right wing, and the home forwards made a determined attack, which ended somewhat awkwardly, Parry in charging Toone snapping one of the goal posts. Geary again raced through the Evertonians, passing to the left wing, and a good shot was directed at Smalley, who had just cleared when he was sent spinning by Cooke. Good tackling and returns by Holt, Farmer, and Weir gave the Everton forwards many opportunities, but the defence of Smith and Topham was too good, and half-time arrived without a point being scored. The visitors attack was now somewhat weakened by a re-arrangement, Shelton taking up the halfback position and Carlin going forward. Parry restarted play, and the Evertonians were soon swarming round their the opponents goal, a well judged kick by Weir giving Parry a rare opportunity for a header. Several good chances were mulled, and Shelton relieved Wilson of the leather, Sharpe taking play to the home end. Holt cleared at a critical moment, Briscoe made a good run and centre, Toone saving finely from Parry, Milward a minute later being unsuccessful with a fast low shot. Everton were now having much the best of the game, but hard luck attended every effort until a free kick in front of goal, when after a scrimmage Parry succeeded in getting the leather past Toone. The remainder of the game was even. Result Everton 1 goal; Notts Rangers nil. Teams ; Notts Rangers:_ Toone, goal, Smith (gh), and Topham backs, Smith (w), James, and Carlin, half-backs, Shaw, Cooke, Geary (f), Sharples, and Shelton forwards. Everton:- Smalley, goal, Dobson (captain) and Chadwick (a), backs, Farmer, Holt, Weir, half-backs, Briscoe, Wilson, Parry, Milward, and Chadwick (e), forwards.
EVERTON 1 BOLTON WANDERERS 0
May 6 1889. The Liverpool Mercury
The re-appearance of the Bolton Wanderers as Anfield last evening, proved as popular as all their previous visits had done quite 5,000 spectators witnessing the match. The Wanderers were strongly represented, the only regular man absent bring Brogan, and his place was filled by Galbraith of Bootle. Armitt assisted Everton, whilst Joliffe had charge of goal. The visitors, who invaded goal in a spirited manner, hands, opened the attack by Galbraith clearing danger at a most critical moment. Everyone backs away on the right and left and having moved up in good combination, off-side put Brisk out of court at an easy range, and renewing the pressure another fair bid for goal, was made Wilson centering and Armitt heading neatly. Weir made an indifferent aim on behalf of the Wanderers, and then Briscoe and Wilson passed smartly from Weir, but in an instant dangerous , had beaten Dobson though he only shot wide. The Wanderers right wing again menaced Joliffe saving well. play went in faviour of Bolton, who kept the ball in the Everton half for considerable time. Their combination, however, was not over brilliant neither was their shooting. Dobson eased the progess with a good kick, and dashing run by the home forwards raised from Holt pass.
Joliffe next looked like assembling to a scrimmage, by punching upwards but Dobson was at hand to clear. Going up on the left, Everton attacked well jus prior to half-time. Parry making a couple of good attempts to score. Ends were charged with nothing done in the shape of goals. On resuming, Davenport and Gailbraith on the one n hand, and Chadwick and Armitt on the other, visits to the advantage of Everton, Parry shooting strongly from a pass. Davenport and Barbour were then baulked when at close quarters and Weir and Barbour retaliated in a clever dribble, but the latter was once more foiled at the post. Turner was next disappointed in the final touch to a strong tussle in front, and Joliffe knocked out from hands. Shortly afterwards a free kick fell to Everton, Parry pushing the ball through with his hands on Dobson kicking against the bar. The ensuing play was carried on with energy and on about level terms the main features being the good combination of Chadwick Armitt,, and Parry, the heading and tackling of Holt, and the general good kicking of the Wanderers. Hands were given against Bolton a few minutes from the finish, and on Dobson placing well Armitt scored. Everton at once closed up to goal and were near increasing their lead from hands but were this time well checked, and as interesting game resulted in a victory of a goal to nil for Everton, who on the whole showed the best backs, Armitt strengthening the attack considerably. Teams Everton:- Joliffe, goal, Chadwick (a), and Dobson (g) (captain), backs, Farmer Holt, and Weir, half-backs, Armitt, Chadwick (e), Parry, Briscoe, and Wilson forwards Bolton Wanderers:- Harrison , goal, Jones and Doyle backs, Roberts Milne, and Bullough, half-backs, Turner Weir (d), Barbour, Gailbriath, and Davenport, forwards.
A DISPUTE BETWEEN FOOTBALL CLUBS.
May 7, 1889. Birmingham Daily Post
At Liverpool County Court, yesterday Everton sued Sunderland Albion for £35, the amount deposited by the latter club on consideration of Everton playing a match at Sunderland in March. Everton went to Sunderland, but the home team scratched the match in the last moment giving the reason that the ground was not fit to play upon in consequence of a fall of snow when the case was called on it was started that if had been settled, Sunderland Albion paying the claims and costs.
EVERTON AND LADYS
May 9, 1889 Otago Witness, Newlanders
The Everton, are about tired of admitting ladies free to the grounds, it is not the lady exactly that they object to, but the lady's extension. Two thousand of these occupy a considerable amount of space, and but for the present feminine fashion, the additional stand on the Everton ground would scarily have been required.
LIVERPUDLIANA; BY RICHARD SAMUEL
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 11 May 1889
Football under difficulties
The sweltering heat was not at all favourable to the best forms of football last Saturday, and the matches between Bootle and Earlestown and Everton and Notts Rangers were not of a very exciting character. Each had, however, a spice of interest attached to it. Evertonians looked forward to the meeting with Notts Rangers with interest from the fact of the probable appearance in that team of Geary, the centre forward of Everton for next season. The game was both favourable to the Liverpool teams and to a similar extent in each case- one to nil. The Everton victory was rather a doubtful one, and the Rangers did not all like the decision which gave Everton the goal and victory. Geary made many friends by his fast runs, tricky dribbling and accurate passing, but he did not shine in the last half, owing to the attentions of Holt.
A GOOD WIN A BAD LOSS
On Monday night Everton with a rather shaky eleven opposed a very strong side of Bolton Wanderers, the only absentee being Brogan, and his place was occupied by Galbriath of Bootle. In the first half of the game it appeared as if the Wanderers would win rather easily, but Everton’s characteristic dash at the finish landed them into a clever victory. This defeat might easily have been averted but for Davenport’s obstinate refusal to get the regulation distance while a free kick was taken by the home team.
RANGERS AND TROTTERS AT EVERTON
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 11 May 1889
By Mickey Free
Only one is still trumps at Everton, but as good luck would have it the one was on the right side in both cases. In the first match it was a rather doubtful score, but the referee appeared to have no hesitation about the matter, and so we must be thankful for small mercies. The Notts Rangers drew a very fair gate, and some eagerness was evinced to see what sort of a shape the visitors’ centre forward would make. Little Geary is a regular sprinter and a good shot, but he is about two stone too light. A centre for a first-class club which has to meet the best teams in the country, wants weight as well as speed, and I question whether Geary is much over nine stone. However, he created a very good impression, and one other impression also prevailed, which was that Holt played rather more heavily on him than was necessary, but I suppose Johnnie knew that if Geary got past him he would have a poor chance of overhauling him. The game throughout calls for no special comment, because as to science, or go, it was not in the same street with the match of Monday against the Wanderers. I just landed in time for this set-to, and was pleased indeed that I had, as the game was well worth watching. Besides, it enabled me to have a few words with both secretaries. One landed me with a ticket for Kenny’s benefit,” which I heartily hope proved as great a success as he deserves; the other landed me a few oratorical thumps straight from the shoulder. I’ve survived it, however (!), and my opinion, although modified, are not altered. For instance, the left wing which faced Bootle Reserves proved that there was no need to play Higgins against Burnley if proper steps had been taken to ensure the presence of certain players in case their services were required. Everton benefited by the breeze in the first half of the game, but the powerful kicking of the back division enabled the Wanderers to rush up time after time into the home end. The result from these onslaughts were very disappointing to the few Bolton men present, as the shooting was execrable. Once Joliffe looked like being bowled clean as instead of hitting out straight, he skied the ball, which dropped back almost to the place from where it had been hit. The Trotters dashed in, a moment’s suspense, and Charley’s fist came out again, and amid considerable cheering danger was averted. Half-time arrived with no score, and it now looked odds on Bolton, but somehow or other Everton seem to play harder against the Wanderers than any other club know of, and hence it was that the second half proved a surprise, as Everton had the best of the play and managed to win from a free kick. Previous to this the ball was put through, but it was shoved through by Parry, who jumped up with the idea of heading it and handled instead. The Wanderers’ left came up beautifully on one occasion and middle, but Galbriath missed a chance which would have been child’s-play to Brogan; in fact, “Kenny” seemed lost without his partner. The game was voted one of the best, so far as half-back play was concerned, that we have seen for many a day. Holt, Farmer and Weir never lagged, and Roberts, Milne and Bullough were just as indefatigable. The sprinter was a terrible stumbling-block to Briscoe, as was Doyle to Armitt. It was amusing to see these players shoot off at various angles when they attempted to remove the burly obstructionists. The end came, and the delight of the Evertonians was unbounded at a victory over so strong a team, e’en though it was but one to nil.
According to Rule X11 the time for the annual general meeting cannot now be far distant, as the rule referred to states that it should be held within fourteen days after the close of the season, therefore the members are all on the qui vive, and it has been suggested to me, that if not too late, I might call the attention of the Committee to the desirability of helding the meeting in some hall or room where the whole of the members may have a chance of gaining admission, and thus be enabled to exercise their rights of membership. I therefore take the opportunity of doing so, as I know there was hardly sufficient room last year and that there must be over a hundred more members this season.
LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 11 May 1889
MR. BARCLAY ON HIS DEFENCE
Sir- No one can accuse me of ever having shown a desire to rush into print, and knowing now valuable and limited your space is, I am entirely reluctant to trouble you now. I am, however, forced in justice to myself and my colleagues to ask you to permit me to refer to the remarks of our mutual friend “Mickey Free” in your last issue. “Mr. Free” appears to have come to the conclusion that the Everton Committee are responsible for the frequent changes in the personnel and positions of the teams. Had he taken the trouble to obtain his information from myself or Mr. Stockton, he could have learned the truth, and I should have shown him the same courtesy as I have always endeavoured to show to everyone with whom I come in contact during the eight years I have been connected with the club. He however, seems to prefer to rely upon gossip and the remarks irresponsible parties rather than to apply for information first hand. He asks: “Why these changes?” “Why Higgins was played forward ? “Why Angus was not played ?” and winds up with a paragraph about the club not being well guided, and the chopping and changing which he alleges has taken place. I regret that “Mickey” should consider the humble individual who now addresses you so utterly unworthy of credence that he prefers to base his conclusions on rather than my statements. I absolutely deny that there has been any “chopping or changing" whatever during the current season. Surely “Mickey" must be aware of the long and continued series of accidents with which we have had to contend. Costley, Dobson, Ross, Dick, Weir, Holt, Smalley, Parry, Davies, Waugh, and Keys have all been on the injured or sick list, and at the present time Milward, Waugh, Dick Angus and Davies —from various causes -are unfit to play. Higgins played forward against Burnley simply to oblige Mr. Stockton (who was looking after the team for me during my absence), no other man being available at the last moment, and the team waiting to go on the field. As to the phrase "well-guided, “ probably “Mickey” is of opinion that the club would have been “well-guided” if we had been suspended for a month, or if we consistently placed a lot of cripples in the field in order to gratify him, and to avoid “chopping and changing.” I again repeat that when changes have taken place they have been unavoidable, so far as the committee are concerned. Yours &c., W.E. Barclay, 33, Everton-terrace, Liverpool.
THE EVERTON CLUB
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 11 May 1889
SIR,- Although the “Nuggets” in last Saturday’s Football Field I noticed the following; “The members of the Everton Club say they will dismiss the cotton sample carriers and debating society men and elect practical men for the committee next season.” I think the party who caused the above to be inserted has outstepped the limits of common decency, and disclosed to the public that he is both shallow-minded and discourteous. In addition to this, I very much question its truthfulness. I believe anyone thinking such scurrilous remarks in a committee of gentlemen, or men of common sense, would be scouted and denounced and justly so. –Yours respectfully, -A Spectator.
EVERTON V. ULSTER
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 11 May 1889
This match took place at Belfast today, in fine weather, before about three thousand spectators. Everton kicked off, rushing the ball up the field, Barry and Miller had a good run from Ulster, but it was spoiled by Dickson, right in front of the Everton goal. The visitors forwards retaliated and Millan put in a grand shot, which Perry sent through, but the point was disallowed for offside. Some give and take play followed, the forwards of each pressing and passing splendidly but the defence was particularly good. Lemon and Small for the home team made a magnificent dribble and passed to Barry. A corner was obtained but nothing resulted. Ulster for a length of time had the best of the game, but their shooting was defective, while the play of Dobson and Chadwick was superb. Everton got away with a good rush, and a fierce tussle took place between Briscoe, Wilson and Elleman, in which the latter cleared. Half-time was called, neither side having scored. Half-time Result; Ulster 0, Everton 0. Final result; Ulter 0, Everton 2
EVERTON RESERVE V. DAVENHAM
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 11 May 1889
The day for the match between the above clubs, at Liverpool was miserably wet, the spectators under such circumstances not being very numerous. Davenham won the toss, and Everton kicked off with only nine men present, the full number being shortly made up. Everton pressed and looked like scoring, but Ashcroft cleared. Several unproductive corners followed, but the ground being like a swamp anything like correct play was out of the question. The Davenham left came up, and Fayer failing to check Stringer, Joliffe was beaten on the second attempt. Soon after brown shot in and Harbour equalized. A few minutes later Malan again drew ahead for the visitors. The game became a bit brisker, and Pollock, for Everton, again draw level by a capital shot, which bounced off the goalkeeper’s hand and through. Half-time Result; Davenham 2, Everton 2.
Five minutes after changing ends Keys landed a third goal for Everton, and a minute later Watson repeated the dose, but it was disallowed on an appeal for a foul. Everton now had the play pretty much as they liked, and pressed severely. Twice Watson shot in hard, but the Davenham goalkeeper hit out well. Later on, however, Watson was rewarded by scoring the fourth goal from a nice pass by Fenn. Final Result; Everton Reserves 5, Davenham 2.
NUGGETS
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 11 May 1889
ULSTER 0 EVERTON 2
May 13 1889. The Liverpool Mercury
FOOTBALL NOTES
Athletic News - Monday 13 May 1889
Everton paid their annual visit to Belfast on Saturday and met the Ulster Club, winning by two goals to none. The first half was pretty even, and no score was made by either side, but after the interval Everton improved a lot and obtained two goals. The Everton backs, Dobson and Chadwick, played a fine game, and it was chiefly owing to their efforts that Ulster did not score in the first half.
CHIPS
What a long list of injured men Everton have... No wonder they have lost matches, for they have not been able to play the same team two weeks together.
Mr. W.E. Barclay has no intention of resigning the secretaryship of the Everton Club, though it is quite possible he will ask for an assistant.
Tom Evans has given up the treasureship of the Liverpool Association. Tom was one of the promoters of football in Liverpool, and played for Everton about ten years ago.
EVERTON RESEVRES 5 DAVEHAM 2
May 13 1889. The Liverpool Mercury
The wet weather, the attendance being only small, and the ground too slippery spoiled this match, which was played at Anfield on Saturday for good play. Everton though starting short handed, at once took up the attack, Fenn being particularly active, but Davenport's defence proved to good, though the home team were very near scoring once or twice during a siege of 20 minutes. The visitors broke loose now and then, and going well on the left, the ball was shot against the bar, Stringer beating Joliffe from the rebound. Everton at once closed up to goal in good style. Keys took aim from fenn's pass, but was checked and then Brown put in, Harbour scoring. Watson followed with a spanking shot, which Postles neatly knocked aside. Davenham then improved their position by clustering round Joliffe, who running out to clear, was nonplussed by Malanm; but just on half-time, Pollock scored a good goal, ends being changed with the record 2 each. Everton soon drew in front on resuming, Keys heading through. Watson sent the ball out of the reach of Postles a moment later, but the point was lost on appeal for a foul. The home side maintained a steady pressure from now to the finish. Watson received the ball, form Fenn, and scored a fourth goal, striking the bar shortly afterwards; whilst Harbour was awarded a goal from off the post. This point was stoutly protested against by Davenham, but to no purpose and in a few minutes the game terminated, Everton winning by 5 goals to 2.
EVERTON 6 BLACKBURN OLYMPIC 1
May 14 1889. The Liverpool Mercury
This match took place last evening at Anfield, Hunter won the toss, and for several minutes the visitors had the best of matters, and it was not long before Parker shot through. Chadwick and his old club mates Fecitt then made tracks for the opponent's goal. Beverley returned to Costley and Yates, but Costley marred a good combined run by finishing with a very poor shot, which feat he immediately repeated. Chadwick met the kick-off and sent the ball up the field to Parry, who headed past Ward, and dribbling nicely, put in a clinking shot which completely beat Hunter. Everton now lived up, and for a spell had a good look in, but tall kicking by beverley, Ward, and Hunter kept their fortress intact. Matthews and Dewhurst then go away, and a foul by Dobson made matters look bad for Everton. A good pass, however, a little later on, enabled Fenn to score a fine goal with a low oblique shot, and he followed in a few minutes with another, which Hunter allowed to go through. Half-time arrived. At the restart the visitors certainly had the best of the opening maneuvers, and with Farmer being hurt, they had several good chances,, which were not properly utilized. The Everton forwards rallied and executed a pretty run, Chadwick finishing by shooting a splendid goal. From now to the finish the Evertonians had matters entirely their own way,. Chadwick Briscoe, and Fenn each added to the score, and when time was called Everton left off winners by 6 goals to 1. Teams Everton, Joliffe, goal, Owen, and Lloyd,, backs, Wilson, Dobson (captain), and Farmer, half-backs, Fenn Briscoe, Parry, Facitt, and Chadwick forwards. Blackburn Olympic:- Hunter (captain), goal Beverley, and Ward, backs, Astley, NcOwen and Almond, half-backs, Dewhurst, Matthews, Parker, Yates, and Costley, forwards.
LIVERPUDLIANA; BY RICHARD SAMEULS
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 18 May 1889
SHADOWS OF THE PAST
Just one other dose of football; there is nothing for it, as there is nothing to chronicle of legitimate seasonable sport in this district during the past week. Monday night there appeared a vision at Everton which ought to have been more widely advertised. Everton were down for an engagement with Blackburn Olympic, and everyone looked for a visit from the very amateur team which has of late done duty for the first provincial holders of the English Cup. And lo? There stood Beverely and ward, the two splendid backs that are the veterans short of wind and stiff of joint of its day. Astley alone stood in the place of yore in the full-back division, Jack Hunter and Hacking having exchanged places whilst Gibson was missing. And the forwards, the buzzing, biting, not-to-be—shook-off quintette, who proved to the big burly “boys” of Eton that Lancashire pluck and indomitable spirit could rise superior to physical disparity, they were there to a man – the shadows of the past. No need to criticize the play with severity, the veterans were beaten by 6 to 1, and Everton were afforded the opportunity of displaying the feebleness of two aspirants for admission to their frim from Newtown, a pair of backs Owen and Lloyd, names perhaps the most ineffective ever put on the team by the Anfield Road club. Some fine passing amongst the Everton forwards was the one interesting part of the play, and conspicuous in the attacking party are Fecitt of the Rovers, and young Fenn, a promising Bootle lad, with a proneness to roam. He was fatal to the best of them at Everton on the occasion of notice.
EVERTON LOOK UP
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 18 May 1889
By Mickey Free
The first team were at Belfast on Saturday and managed to win by 2 to nil. To beat Davenham by 5 to 2 was, under the circumstances a very good performance indeed for the Reserve. The ground was in a dreadful state; still the boys took to it kindly and at times showed good football.
Monday was the game par excellence, and a better display by the forwards against a strong team representing Blackburn Olympic we have not had for many a long day. In the first half Fecitt and Chadwick got along splendidly together, the former giving many evidence of his old cunning, with the result that we were treated to many little bits of brilliant play. In the second half the play was more in the centre and on the right which gave Fenn a chance of giving us a taste of his style, and if Monday’s form was correct it is decidedly above the average as he showed good judgement, speed and shooting ability. Parry seems to be much faster than when he made his first appearance. He passes well, can use both feet, and by a judicious use of his weight almost compensates for any deficiently in skill or speed. Two new full backs were on trial, but they were not up to the Everton requirements. Fortunately they had little to do, thanks to the good half-back play, and Everton won handsomely by six to one. I do not think this score would have been reached if Hunter had played in his proper place, and allowed McOwen to go Between the sticks.
MR. BARCLAY AND HIS “DEFENCE”
Throth, Mr. Olympian, it was with regret that I real that same epistle. I cannot plead ignorance of his intention to rush into print, because after the match against the Wanderers he told me he would so. I therefore expected something, but certainly not the weak argumentative epistle which appeared. To sum the whole thing up in as few words as possible it is this. I made a distinct charge which he has not attempted to refute. Everyone knows that the changes were continually being made, and if not made by the committee, then by whom? When Everton played their League match at Blackburn I expressed my views pretty forcibly before a couple of committee men who happened to be there, and proved my assertion by facts, not “gossip,” I asked was it not a fact that Briscoe was not considered good enough for the right wing- his usual place? The reply was, “Yes” “Then why was he played on the left at Nottingham?” In the same way Costley was not good enough for the left? “Yes” “Then how is it he is played in the centre, where he was absolutely useless?” In like manner Keys, who is a very fair outside right, was put centre against Aston Villa at Perry Barr, and in that position he was completely at sea. Is this, I ask, making the best use of the material ready at their hands? Nothing of the kind. It looked more like an excuse being sought for the purpose of justifying the executive in hunting up for other players to take their places at a cost to the club which must be a serious matter indeed, especially when we have not even the consolation of knowing that the money was well spent. Here are the names of some of the talent thus raked up;- Morris, Davey, Coyne, McKinnon, and Davis. The first was fairly laughed off the field in a reserve match. The second and third were recommended to Ulster, who gave them a trial and had reason to regret it. McKinnon could play occasionally, but it was only as the spirit moved him; but the last named player was the greatest “white elephant” of the lot. And all this time, sir, we had players like Briscoe and Keys, who with Milward in the earlier part of the season were making a splendid reputation for the Reserve. Once again I must hark back, and in this instance it is for the purpose of having my view corroborated in one instance at least by none other than N.J. Ross. On the advert of Ross at Everton he was taken into the counsel of the club and suggested the desirability of Briscoe being put into the first team. He was met with the reply that Briscoe was too slow. Jack’s answer was, “Let me have him for a month and I’ll take that out of him.” It was no use, the experience of a man like Ross was to good enough. Later on in the season Everton had no alternative but to play Briscoe, the occasion being a match at Deepdale against North End, and at half-time Ross remarked to me on the field “Didn’t little Briscoe bother Graham! I knew very well if the Committee would let me have him I could make a player of him.” Not much “gossip” about that. The match which gave rise to my remarks was that against Burnley. Mr. Barclay says Higgins played to oblige Mr. Stockton, as only 10 men turned up. There was no need for any such obligation, as there were seven of the reserve team in the dressing-room, the left wing men who played against Bootle Reserve being amongst the number. I ask, again, why was not one of these men put in the position? And now with respect to the long string of “lame ducks” A stranger reading the letter might reasonably conclude that Everton had a whole team on the sick list at one and the same time. They have been unfortunate at times, just like many other clubs that I could name. I shall mention a few cases to prove the fallacy of the reasoning. When Dobson was invalided Ross and Dick were to the fore, therefore, his loss was not felt. When Dick was ditto or suspended Ross and Dobson were in position, and again on the Saturday when North End were playing the final for the English Cup Ross was away lame, his place being taken by Albert Chadwick in the League match against Blackburn Rovers, which Everton won, and boasted that they had accomplished without the aid of Ross what they could not do with it. The last paragraph is twaddle. I do not wish to urge my claim to be called a friend of the Everton club, and yet I am forced to think that there are few who will dispute it. Therefore, granting this point, why should a friend wish to see the club suspended? Did I leave them in the lurch when that unfortunate event occurred? The reference is unintelliable. It has always been my wish to see players in the team, not cripples. Unfortunately it has been more frequently the other way about.
NUGGETS
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 18 May 1889
BURY V EVERTON
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 18 May 1889
Dear sir,- Many of your readers will, doubtless, remember that towards the close of the season 1887-8 the Everton clue were ordered by the Lancashire Association to send their first team to Bury in consequence of having failed to send their full strength in a first team fixture, and through their failing to do this the Association were again appealed to. But, although Everton successfully evaded their liability, they promised to send their team over to Bury for a night match sometime during the season just terminated, on payment of expenses. They have been written to several times during the past three months, asking when they were prepared to fulfil their promise. In the first instance they asked for half-gate terms; and when reminded of their promise and asked to fulfil it, no reply could be obtained, but they now shelter themselves behind the plea that it is too late. Such conduct in a club aspiring to be considered a first-class organization is contemptible and a more deliberate case of shuffling has rarely been known. We have no animosity against the Everton club, but simply wish that the public should be made acquainted with the mode their business is conducted. _Yours, &c, JNO H. Lightbown, Secretary Bury A.F.C. –The Editor “Football Field.”
EVERTON 2 DARWEN 0
May 20 1889. The Liverpool Mercury
Although football is supposed to have given way to cricket the supporters of Everton turned up to the strength of 7,000 at Anfield, on Saturday, to welcome Darwen on their first appearance. The ground was in first class order. The visitors had their full strength, while Facitt, Almond, and Bethel Robinson substituted the home ranks. Parry started the game for Everton, and tipping the ball to the left, it was soon carried by Faceitt who was awarded a fruitless corner. J.Marsden soon again had to-clear his lines with a hugh punt, and Haddon tested Smalley with two well-judged shots. After Hudden had worked a shot from Briscoe Almond enabled his side to keep on the aggressive and Fewitt screwed across the goalmouth, where Briscoe dashed up and scored for Everton. The visitors now put in a deal of good work, but found the home defence impenetrable and it was not long before Holden knocked the ball through his own posts from a nicest-placed corner from Chadwick which brought about half-time. Changing over both teams started strongly but it was soon perceptible that the players were laboring under the heat. Both goals were visited, but no further scoring took place, which was mainly due to the fine defensive work of J.Mardsen for Darwin, and Almond, Dobson, and Robinson for Everton, a pleasant game thus ending in another win for the Anfieldites by 2 goals to nil. For the losers, J.Mardsden at full back was a host in himself by his clean kicking and played sterling football; Owen and Thornber were fair halves; whilst there was not much to choose between the forwards. The winning team all round played a good game, and infused some life in the first half. Dobson and Robinson were safe at back; Almond at half-back was seen at his best, and was greatly liked by the spectators, while of the forwards rank Fecitt and Chadwick made good partners, Parry lacking too much after the goalkeeper to satisfy many of the patrons and Briscoe did his share of hard work. Teams; Everton:- Smalley, goals, Robinson, and Dobson (captain), backs, Nidd, Almond, and Farmer. Half-backs, Briscoe, Wilson, Parry, Chadwick, and Faceitt forwards. Darwen:- Holden, goal, Marsden (j), and Leach, backs, Thornber, Owen and Marsden (t), half-backs, Hayes, Marsden (w), Haddow, Smith, and Slater Forwards.
LIVERPOOL AND DISTRICT NOTES
Athletic News - Monday 20 May 1889
By the Loiterer
DAWREN AT ANFIELD
In fine, though a trifle too warm weather, Darwin appeared at Anfield to try conclusions with a strong team representing Everton, which included Fecitt and Almond from the Rovers, and Bethel Robinson. The home team soon won a corner, and then Smalley saved well on two occasions. Everton again pressed, but Holden and Joe Marsden defended well, and Smalley had to knock out twice. The home lot once more attacked, Fecitt being prominent, and from his centre Briscoe scored. Play now ruled more even, and Parry mulled a glorious chance from Chadwick. After this Darwen now kept play in the home half for a little while, and both Dobson and Robinson gave corners, which were, however, cleared. Everton replied, and put on a lot of pressure, and from a well-judged shot of Almond’s Holden conceded a corner, from which he but the ball through his own goal. The kick-off brought the visitors no relief, but beyond a corner for the home team nothing resulted, and again Smalley had a visit, but half-time found Everton leading by two goals to none. On resuming, play was all in the Darwen half, but nothing of note occurred until Briscoe missed a chance from Fecitt, and a little later Wilson followed suit. The visitors were seldom dangerous, but a free kick off Kidd menaced the home goal, Owen eventually shooting over. Play was now more even and rather slow, hat nothing more was scored, Everton ultimately winning by two goals to none. For the home team, Smalley was in good form, the few shots he had to negotiate being of the difficult order, and he cleared on one occasion marvelously. It was also Dobson’s day out, his kicking being more accurate, and some of his shots being dangerous ones. Bethel Robinson seemed to be out of practice and his kicking was very weak. Of the halves Almond was head and shoulders above Farmer and Kidd, the latter seldom petting in good work, and Farmer was off colour. Chadwick and Fecitt, is the first half, put in some pretty and effective bits, Fecitt being the best of the two. Parry again took the centre forward position, and put in some clumsy though effective work. The two right wing men, Briscoe and Wilson, were subjected to adverse criticism from the stand, but a lot of it was not called for, and in the second half they did their share of the work, and, taken altogether their play will compare favourably with some of their predecessors. Of the Darwen team Joe Marsden was the shining light, his play throughout being judicious, and when required he put in some strong kicks. He, however, aroused the passion of the crowd by several times putting Fecitt offside, and although perfectly legitimate, his action and the remarks of the spectators were alike to be deprecated. Holden did not keep goal well, several times clearing badly, and Leach was inferior to Marsden. Owen was the best of the halves, Thornber being outclassed by Fecitt and Chadwick. The forwards appear to have the style as in the days of Tom Marshall and Bury, and without being particularly clever they several times gave Smalley as much as he could do to clear the shots they put in. Taken altogether, the match was an enjoyable one, but towards the close the weather had the best of the argument, and play was consequently a trifle tame.
CHIPS
Talking of new officials and committee, I hear that several of the Everton executive are tired of working hard for nothing but abuse, and it is probable that great changes will be effected at the annual meeting.
I understand that it is simply a question of the value of Fecitt’s services as to whether he will be a member of next year’s team at Everton. But he is an amateur.
Tonight (Monday) we shall have the North End here, and the team scraped together for Everton should render a good account of themselves.
Geary has not landed yet, but I understand he will be before long. I hope so, for he is a capital centre forward.
BOOTLE WANDERERS 6 EVERTON RESERVES 2
May 20 1889. The Liverpool Mercury
Played at Snadfield-place the home team winning by 6 goals to 2.
EVERTON 1 PRESTON NORTH END 3
May 21 1889. The Liverpool Mercury
The visit of North End to Anfield last evening called together a great assembly of spectators numbering about 10,000. Dewhurst started the ball, but Almond took Drummond a pass and placed to Facitt, but Chadwick missed his kick and the ball rolled out. Again the home team forced the play and this time Chadwick put in a rafting shot which Turner had some difficulty in clearing. Roused by the enthusiastic cheers of the crowd, the Everton team kept Holmes and Haworth fairly busy, but their defence was admirable. Ross jun and Dewhust put in a pretty dribble down the centre and Almond in tackling gave a corner, which proved fruitless, but not before Ross sen had put in a spinkling shot. Geary Parry, and Wilson came away and the homesters had hard lines through Wilson's centre dropping on the crossbar while Parry paid attention to Trainor. Still having slightly the best of the argument though the good half-backs pair of Haworth Almond and Farmer, Geary obtained possession from Chadwick in midfield,, and executed a brillant run; but Trainor cleared his shot, and R.Haworth sending to Ross sen, be adroitly passed to Gordon and some exceedingly pretty play was witnessed between G Howarth Ross sen, Drummond, and Almond which eventually ended in Ross securing a corner. Dobson cleared this, but Gordon coming down in fine style prettily passed to Ross who bring in a good position was enabled to score first blood for North End. Everton worked the ball up very nicely good passing being shown by Parry Geary and Chadwick, and Parry compelled Trainor to run out to save. Half-time arrived with Everton one goal to the bad, but being in no way disheartened they continued to have equally as much of the game as the North End, but lacked the finish and judgement of that well-known team. Dewhurst when coming down the centre, saw an opening for Ross, sen who making the most of the opportunity, rushed up and scored number two for the visitors. The home team, whether through excitement or the hot face at which the game had gone on, now fell off sadly and it was not long before Ross jun, after a spendid spirited on the right scored again, for the North End with a magnificent oblique shot. Just on the call of time Everton gamely responded to the cries of the Spectators and by excellent passing brought the ball in close proximity to Trainor and Geary was enabled to send in a lighting shot, with completely beat Trainor, and made the game 3 to 1. Nothing further being added, a fast and exciting game ended as above. Teams: Everton:- Smalley goal, Robinson (b) and Dobson (captain), backs, Howarth Almond, and Farmer half-backs, Fecitt, Parry, Geary, Chadwick, and Wilson, forwards. Preston North End:- Trainor, goal, Howarth, and Holmes, backs Robinson, Kelso (r), and Graham. Half-backs Gordon Ross (jun), Dewhurst, Drummond and Ross (nj) (captain) forwards.
LIVERPUDLIANA; BY RICHARD SAMUEL
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 25 May 1889
Everton would beat Preston North End. Therefore it was that George Howarth, Almond, Bethall, Robinson, Fecitt, and Geary all recruited the “Crippleton” team, and that the last flicker of the expiring season, which has been so unconscionably long a-dying, flared up in quite a blaze at Anfield-road, on Monday night. Hither journeyed the proud Prestionains sans Goodall sans Russell, but with eleven good men and strong. Kelso for Russell, Jack Ross for Goodall, adequately stopped the gaps in the champion team, which nevertheless carried a passenger the whole journey. I would dilate upon the incidents of one of the most exciting games, certainly the finest display of football seen at Anfield road in the last twelve months; but those who trouble to scan this weekly budget are probably as surfeited of football as he who writes it, and therefore I forbear. Bear with me, I will not say much. Everton did not win. Nay, ‘twould even seem that added strength in an opponent but serves to call forth additional brilliance in this wonderful team. Certain it is that Everton were more conspicuously out of their latitude than ever they were with the bright particular star of the football firmament. For a space the great crowd gave tongue in wild and hoarse roars of excitement, as the pent up enthusiasm of the team in Everton colours came, and came again to the narrow pass “Where stood the Dountless Three” Howarth, Holmes, and Trainer never faltered, never paltered, and the spent waves of Everton opposition subsided, as the roar of the throng gave place to spasmodic yells and howls of derision. For the North End passenger afore-mentioned was playfully inclined, and when the attack of his fellows began to gather force, he floundered helplessly and dangerous amongst the Everton defenders; good-humoredly and promiscuously rolling them and himself on the flat. Everton were gradually cornered, and three goals, each a splendid effort, were scored; the final effort in each case coming from one of the brothers Ross, two from the late captain of Everton. The crowd commenced to leave the ground, the game was done. So evidently thought the players. But no. The ball got down to trainer, was only weakly met by Howarth, and as the Everton forwards crowded on the visitors’ backs, Geary rushed up and scored, a perfect torrent of applause denoting that Everton had at length “broken their duck” in matches with North End. And so the game ended. Everton would be a North End. Why not? But it is a long journey yet. The lesson on Monday is that a heterogeneous collection of brilliant individual players will not make a great team by more aggregations. The North End team is not of mushroom growth. Careful selection of undeveloped talent, assiduous practice, patience; these are some of the essentials of the growth of a great team, and these have been conspicuously lacking in the ambitious but overreaching management of Everton in the past 12 months.
FURTHER REMARKS
It will not be smiles here to comment on some of the players who appeared in Everton colours on Monday night. First, with respect to Geary. The young Notts man made a big bid for popular favour, especially in the early part of the game. He made one run which fairly electrified everybody, and generally his fast spurts and taking touches were much admired. He is but light, unfortunately, and unless Everton ground alters very much in the close season, it is quite safe to prophesy that he will not stand the wear and tear of the exacting League matches on such a dreadful turf. As for Fecitt- well, he was a complete failure so far as providing a colleague capable of making an effective left wing with Chadwick. By the way, it is beginning to dawn on some minds that the latter player is very hard to suit, and the young Blackburn man has certainly not fulfilled all that was expected of him. George Haworth and Almond were in fine form, but Bethall Robinson was not.
EXHIBITION MATCHES AT EVERTON
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 25 May 1889
By Mickey Free
Football dies hard up this way, not but that it ought in all reason to have ceased before now, as the weather is decidedly against such a necessarily vigorous game, and it is all in favour of growing grass, a commodity wanted badly. Darwen turned up on Saturday with a strong team, but aided as Everton were by outsiders, they managed to settle the Darreners rather easily, despite the good defence of Darwen, to say nothing of Joe Marsden’s little dodge of getting up the field so as to place the Everton forwards off-side. He played a good game nevertheless, and so did Holden in goal, even though he did some against himself by showing the ball through over his head from a corner kick. The game throughout was rather slow. The first goal was obtained by Briscoe from a pass by Fecitt. The Everton halves (conspicuous amongst whom was Almond) proved an almost impenetrable barrier to Darwen, so that they had not many chances to break their duck.
Monday again proved the great event, and there must have been quite 10,000n spectators present. The Evertonians were in the field at the appointed time, but the champions were 20 minutes late. They were well received, and on taking up their positions it was noticed that “N.J” partnered Drummond on the left. It was as strong a team as they could very well get together, and Everton had the assistance of Almond, George Howarth and Bethall Robinson. Of this lot “Jud” took the palm, although Almond played a fine game. Bethall was hardly up to his best form. In the front rank the new centre took his place, and, as expected, he proved an acquisition. His speed is just what is wanted, and he is a good shot; but, as I said before, he lacks weight, so that if he had what Parry could spare they would both be better men. The slowness of the right wing was made all the more glaring owing to Geary’s speed, whilst Wilson’s attempts to dodge the North Enders was, to say the least of it very injudicious and time after time he lost the ball, to the great disgust of the spectators. Chadwick and Fecitt did fairly well, but the latter “funked” the men in a most palpable manner. Well, perhaps he was wise. The game opened at a pace which was a caution considering the state of the weather and in less than a minute Geary gave Trainer a fistful. Parry robbed the “demon” as he was darting off, and Chadwick had a possible chance, but the shot was wide. Again Parry tried a long drop and Chadwick shot in splendidly, but Trainer saved grandly. The Evertonians were in ecstasies at this point owing to the form displayed by the men. Geary was again to the fore but shot wide, and then Bob Howarth let out and the North End travelled towards the Everton goal at which Gordon, Kelso and “N.J” in turn had shies, but the ball in each case was met by the backs. Smalley cleared a dangerous looking corner shot, and then Wilson by a screw struck the cross-bar, but there was no luck, and the ball went over instead of under. After a splendid tussle between “Jud” Howarth and Ross, sen, the ball came Everton way. Dobson missed his man. Ross, jun got the ball and sprinting along the wing, finished with a lightning screw shot which didn’t give Smalley the ghost of a chance. The account was thus opened after 30 minutes’ severe play, during which time Everton had rather the best of it, but the pace was beginning to tell on the home team, whilst the superior passing of North End saved so much labour that they were comparatively fresh. A fine pass by Gordon to the left five minutes later was received by Jack Ross, who shot a splendid goal, the ball going just past the tips of Smalley’s fingers. Ends were changed, and by a good passing movement, in which Fecitt, Geary and Chadwick took part, the North End goal was threatened and that is all, as Chadwick shot over. Smalley stopped a splendid shot by Ross, jun., but Jack beat him a third time, and Everton fell off very much until within a few minutes of time when they made a desperate effort, which was crowded with success, as Geary defeated Trainer with a rattling shot, the game ending in a win for the champions by 3 top 1. According to the card today sees the close of the season, when Accrington make their appearance.
LETTER TO THE EDITOR
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 25 May 1889
EVERTON FOOTBALL CLUB,
Sir, I do not intend to prolong the discussion with “Mr. Free.” I can only say that his assertions in the last issue are even more ridiculous and misleading than those I formerly complained of. Probably he is annoyed because we have not given him a trial as centre forward. A “friend” of Everton indeed? I pity the club if it had to depend on such “friends” as “Mr. Free” I advise your readers to take what “Mickey” says cum grame salis, and regret that he cannot find anything better to do than try to obtain the applause of the few at the expense of the respect and esteem of the many. But, then, he must write something, as that after all we must not consider him too seriously. Perhaps I made a mistake in trying to correct some of his assertions, as since my letter appeared he has not had the common courtesy to acknowledge my presence when we have met. In future I will lot this Mrs. Micawbar-like friend of Everton, who did not, and I presume never will, desert us, alone. But I promise him that if at any time he requires information I shall be glad to afford it him. Had he asked me I could have told him that there were not seven reserve players in the dressing-room when Mr. Stockton asked Mr. Higgin’s to play. But then he prefers to base his facts on gossip, and when brought to book accuses me of “twaddle,” and tries to pose as a friend of Everton! The less he appeals to Ross as an authority on the actions of the committee, the less harm he will do to his case. And now, Mr. Editor, I leave this remarkable authority on football, and this “called friend” of Everton to make what reply he likes. I am content to let him go on in the future without correction, but after the warming I have given it will be your readers’ own fault if they forget the grain of salt-Yours, &c, W.E. Barclay.
ACCRINGTON v. EVERTON.
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 25 May 1889
Fine summer weather favoured this event, and probably 6.000 spectators were present. Haworth was absent from the Reds. Everton lost the toss, and, half-an-hour after time, kicked off, facing the sun. Chippendale early skimmed one over the bar. Barbour next troubled Smalley with beauty, which he saved splendidly. A smart scrimmage followed, and again Smalley hit out, and a barren corner followed. Everton then assaulted, but hands off Fenn relieved. Geary and Fecitt put in a pretty run and pass to the right, McLellan relieved, and Geary again got down. A corner followed, and Geary headed in and McOwen saved smartly. Directly after Parry lost a couple of chances. Accrington then came with a rush, Barbour shot in strongly, but Smalley just reached it and punted clear, and the game was waged in midfield. At half-time there were no goals scored. Final Result; Everton 1, Accrington 0.
NUGGETS
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 25 May 1889
ACCRINGTON AT ANFIELD.
Athletic News - Monday 27 May 1889
Had the players in Saturday's match been animals instead of human beings, Messrs. Barclay and Hartley would run a great risk of doing "time “ for cruelty to animals, for after a rather threatening morning the weather was delightfully fine, and a large crowd turned out to see the "reds." So appreciative are they up Everton way, that I believe we should have seven or eight thousand people as keenly watching and criticizing the game on Midsummer Day as at Christmas. The Everton committee, therefore, are not to blame if they cater to the full extent for their numerous patrons. Considering the weather, Saturday's match was fast, and cash side put forth their best efforts. At the onset, Accrington had the best of the game, and the play was even, but from a corner the home team ought to have scored, and Everton kept up the pressure, Chadwick eventually relieving by kicking wide. From the kick-off the Accrington right took the ball to the other end, but it was soon back, and Party headed wide. Again Accrington came away, and Barhour showed grand tactic., and compelled Smalley to fist out. Parry was now prominent, but from his centre Chadwick shot over, and later Fenn kicked wide, and at the other end Barhour, just on half-time, was equally faulty in his final efforts. The interval was reached with the score sheet blank. On resuming, play continued fast and even, and then Geary headed wide and gave Gallocher a chance, but he shot over. Accrington were again aggressive, and Smalley had to kick out, and Robinson also saved well. The home team had now the best of it, and Fecitt's shot just skimmed over; and on another occasion McOwen cleared well. Dobson had the best of a couple of tussles with Boner, and the home team forced the pace, Chadwick eventually scoring. McOwen was again troubled, and twice saved grandly. The home team still pressed, but only a corner resulted, and this Wilson placed behind. Parry next put the ball through, but was ruled "off-side,” and McOwen saved a grand shot from Geary. “Time” was soon afterwards called, Everton winning by one goal to none.
Smalley had not much to do, but one time he saved splendidly, and both Robinson and Dobson were safe at back. At half Almond was not so successful as against Darwen, but played a good game for all that. Farmer was quite as good, and some acrobatic feats of his were amusing; but Wilson was not class enough for Lofthouse and Kirkham. Forward, Geary further impressed the onlookers by his speed and judicious passing. Parry and Chadwick came next, but neither Fecitt nor Fenn did much, though now and again they put in some tasty bits, and the latter worked hard. For Accrington, McOwen did some good work in goal, and the shot that took effect was not negotiable. Stevenson and McLennan also played well, Stevenson especially kicking strong. Our old friend, Chippendale, was as good as of yore, but of the lot Pemberton was the best, Tattershall being rather weak. Barbour, in the centre, did a lot of clever work, and Boner and Gallocher were a superior wing to the left.
CHIPS
With the new rules in operation, I hope this will be a thing of the past, and let us have done with quasi-amateurs. Almond finds that the Everton air agrees with him, and would like to stay down here, but the Rovers know they have a good man, and are not disposed to put in the waste paper basket his registration paper. Townley too, prefers this locality to Blackburn but he is in the same fix, and, moreover, his pater objects.
Jack Weir has not given satisfaction to the Everton executive of late, and they have what would be called, if he were a pro, given him the sack.
The meeting of the local Football Association on Wednesday was principally taken up with a discussion as to what Mr. T. Evans’s testimonial should consist of, and I understand it will be in every respect worthy of his acceptance and in keeping with his long service and the ability which he has shown in the successful handling of the finance department.
I understand Mr. Barclay and Mr. Lewis had some hot words in London about Almond, of the Rovers.
Almond appears to have told the Rovers a lot of fairy tales, doubtless with an object in view, but Mr. Barclay informs me that they have not offered Almond any inducement to break his agreement with the Rovers.
I am afraid Herbert Facitt is getting on the shelf, judging from his display here.
Everton mean to play football as long as they can, and want a match for next Friday. They will guarantee not to play after midnight.
EVERTON 1 ACCRINGTON 0
May 27 1889. The Liverpool Mercury
About 7,000 spectators assembled at the Anfield ground to witness the last Saturday match of the season when Accrington and Everton met for the third time, the two previous games having resulted in a win for each. The home team played with the sun in their eyes during the first half and the visitors at the outset attacked rather strongly, Chippendale lifting over the bar, and Smalley saving twice smartly. Chadwick and Fecitt relieved in a neat run but hands in front rendered the effort futile whilst a renewed attack by Wilson, Parry and Fenn was of no better advantage, as Chadwick shot badly. Everton continued to have the best of the game until Accrington went up in close order and forced a corner. Geary fastened on the ball quickly and ran prettily, Fecitt trying a fair shot, and after Robinson had cleared danger in the goal mouth Chadwick lobbed across accurately to Fenn who lost a fine chance through slowness. Accrington replied in good formation, but before growing dangerous Farmer pulled them up effectively, and Everton looked likely of making a capture, but Geary's shot was not quite straight enough nor did Parry utilizes a pass from Farmer and Almond properly. A moment later Smalley stopped brilliantly a sharp shot from Barbour, who replied by putting just outside the post. Between now and half-time Chadwick had an opportunity of scoring but screwed far too high, and ends were changed with a clean sheet. Accrington, despite the inconvenience of the sun severely troubled Robinson and Dobson on restarting, and when the former missed his kick at a critical moment the outlook of Everton was ominous, but Dobson dashed across just in time to prevent the left wing shooting. The visitors maintained a steady pressure, their forwards showing superior combination to those of the home club, but Everton's defence was always reliable. Towards the close, Parry and Geary changed position when a marked improvement was made in the home attack, and Parry dashing through enabled Chadwick to score. Geary followed by shooting through, but a foul was ruled, and soon afterwards a spirited game resulted in a victory for Everton of 1 goal to nil. Teams; Everton:- Smalley, goal Robinson, and Dobson (captain), backs, Farmer, Almond, and Wilson, half-backs, Parry, Fenn Geary, Chadwick, and Fecitt forwards. Accrington:- McOwen, goal, Stevenson and Mclennan backs, Tattersall, Chippendale, and Pemberton half-backs, Gallocher, Bonar, Barbour Kirkham, and Lofthouse forwards.