EVERTON V ASTON VILLA
January 2, 1891. The Birmingham Daily Post
Both clubs played their first teams, Latta again taking his place for Everton. The home team had much the best of the opening movements, and Cox saved a shot from Geary. Graham and Hodgetts at length removed the ball, and Cowan sent in one which Jardine put behind, but nothing resulted from the ensuing corner. Everton again worked down, and Geary tried a shot, which Cox placed behind. Everton sustained the advantage, and a somewhat soft goal was scored by Chadwick, the view of Warner being obstructed by the backs. The Evertonians continued to hold the advantage, and several shots were put in, but were misdirected. Milward passed nicely over to the right wing and Latta shot through, but as he was offside the point was not allowed. From a corner Milward headed the second goal. After this the visitors showed better form, but Dickson missed a ridiculously easy chance. This was followed by a couple of attempts from the two Browns, both of which went high over the bar. Just before half-time Warner made a fine save from Milward. At half-time the score was –Everton 2 goals, Villa 0. On restarting the Villa made good advance, but were easily repulsed. Everton got up again, and Latta missed a good opportunity, whilst ineffective shots were propelled by Geary and Brady. Brown and Cowan were prominent with pretty play and Graham was offered a clear opening, but allowed Kirkwood to interfere. Result Everton 5, Aston Villa 0.
SOUTHPORT CENTRAL 2 EVERTON RESERVES 2
January 2 1891. The Liverpool Mercury
Played at Southport yesterday. The ground was very hard, rendering play difficult. The first half ended in favour of Everton, who were leading by a goal to nil, at the interval. In the second portion the visitors again scored, but the central equalised and the game ended in a draw-2 goals each.
BLUE REVIEW
January 3 rd 1891. The Liverpool Courier.
When jubilating over the defeat of Everton on the banks of the Wear, the “Wolves” little dreams of the cured fate which awaited them, and which was so new at hand, “never ballos before you are out of the wood” is a maxim which should be hope in mind, but which the Midlanders completely ignored, and now we learn for the thousandth time how perilous it is to gloss over the misfortunes of an dishonorable foe. But the avenge was on their track and singularly it fell to the lot of the hardy man of the North to compass their downfall as they had previously done as champions of the Liverpool district. This untoward check was disheartening to the “Wolves” but still more so was that unexpectedly –perhaps not generally no –administered by the erratic Bolton Wanderers during the holiday season. Whilst these ravage but the prestige of the “Wolves” were being made, the Evertonians had risen like the mythological client from the devouring times, more powerful and more determined than ever, for now after a period of reaction which brought Wyllie on the scene the “In comparable Latta” was with them, and only those who have witnessed his masterly displays can realise what a tower of strength he is to the team. Accrington, however, were beaten by a narrow majority without his aid, but the stalwart Burnleyites, with Aleck on the right, were beaten by seven to three, and than on the first day of the new year came the long expected and much desired return game with Aston Villa, who it will be remembered, had the good fortune to effect a draw on the home ground at Perry Bar. But hereabouts, and generally too, the solution of the first fixture between the clubs has been regarded as a fluke, and this it was contended subsequent events would abundantly prove. And so they have but perhaps more effectually than even the most sanguine predicated, for it could scarcely have been expected that the Villians would be beaten by 5 goals to nil. As a matter of fact they were beaten from the start, for although nearly thirty minutes elapsed before a way was found through goal, Everton by far the best of the game. Dennis Hodgetts, once one of the finest outside-left players in the kingdom, was completely nonplussed, and to add to the general feebleness of the Midland men, Albert Brown headed through his own goal just prior to half time, so that being a couple of goals in arrears the game at that period was virtually over. What an complete difference, the reappearance of Latta made on the Everton right was seen in the vastly improved play of Brady, his colleagues, who shortly after the change of ends shot a couple of goals in masterly style. There was the same cunning manceurvingf as of yore, in appreciation of which the hugh crowd of ten thousand or more applauded as only an Anfield crowd can. These three victories in which the scoring was 14 goals to 4, give Everton an almost impregnable positions, and should the team be successful against Notts County today, the championship will almost be within hand. Everton will still have one of the two remaining League fixtures on the home ground, namely, the return with North End, and as has already pointed out on the strength of tabulated results this is an advantage which it is to be hoped will bring the team still closer to the much desired goal. Everton (as district from the League team) added another victory to their already long season's list against Port Vale Rovers. The Rovers, who are ex-holders of the Staffordshire Juniors cup, play a good game, and were only defeated by one goal to nil, Everton having a point disallowed. The Evertonians “let in” the New year at Southport, where a capital game with the Central resulted in a draw of one goal each.
EVERTON v. NOTTS COUNTY.
Lancashire Evening Post - Saturday 03 January 1891
This match was played to-day at Anfield in the presence of about 11,000 spectators. Several changes were made in the Everton ranks, and the teams accordingly faced follows Everton. — Jardine, goal; Hannah and Doyle, backs; Parry, Holt, and Kirkwood, half-backs; Milward, Chadwick, Geary, Robertson, and Latta, forwards. Notts, - Toone, goal; and Hendry backs; Osborne, Caldehead, and Shelton, half-backs; McGregor, Mclnnes, Oswald, Locker, and Daft, forwards. The game started at a tremendously fast pace, and within a few minutes of the start Geary scored by means of a splendid shot from Robertson. The visitors continued to play most gamely, but the Everton forwards were in rare form. Toone had repeatedly to save the most difficult shots. Robertson especially was a success, and Geary also shaped finely in his new position. Eventually Chadwick, from a pass by Latta, beautifully scored the second goal for Everton. The play afterwards was of a more even character, and the Everton goal was occasionally assailed, but the visitors’ shooting was not up to the mark. Towards the end of the first half, play raged constantly round the visitors’ goal, Toone’s saves being simply magnificent, Everton scored two points which were disallowed on the ground of off-side. Half-time—Everton 2, Notts County 0.
Upon restarting Everton dashed away, and Latta scored in less than a minute with splendid shot. The ball continued hover round the Notts’ goal, but inaccurate shooting prevented a score Ultimately Shelton sent in a capital long shot, which appeared to have gone through, but the referee, after a brief consultation, disallowed it. Afterwards the visitors were fairly outplayed, and whenever they had a chance in front of goal their bad shooting spoilt it. The third goal for Everton was finely scored by Milward, who had just previously had a point disallowed. From a foul almost in the goal Notts scored their first point, but after a bit of unexciting play Geary with a long shot beat Toone. Two shots followed. Result— Everton 4, Notts 2.
EVERTON NOTES
Lancashire Evening Post - Saturday 03 January 1891
That the return of Latta to the Everton team has worked wonders ; that in the Christmas matches the Dumbarton man placed with all his old finish and effect; that his dribbling and dodging and shooting were something remarkable for a man who had not kicked a ball for two months : that Brady will not go now ; that his place looked insecure on his recent performances ; that he never played better than in the last few matches ; that Parry is an improvement Campbell ; that the Welshman was the best half- against Burnley ; that all through he has kept up a high standard of play ; that certainly plays to Chadwick and Milward with more effect than Campbell; that the old Bootle man will have to stand down for Parry for some time; that old Evertonians were very pleased to find all the old team, except the goalkeeper, doing duty. That Wyllie was something of a frost in his first appearance on the Everton ground ; that he is very shy of a charge ; that he does not apparently believe in bustling for the ball ; that he has a preference for shooting off-side goals ; that he is a dead shot, and that this seems to be his only qualification, so far as he has shown his form Everton : that he was to have played against Aston Villa ; that it was considered advisable to save Latta for the Notts County match; that for some reason Wyllie did not play expected ; that he was said to be suffering with a bad leg ; that people do not quite remember how this happened, for he was very careful of himself on boxing Day.
That the match with Aston Villa was a very poor affair ; that the Villa men played like a third-rate club ; that the two weakest men were Hodgetts and Albert Brown ; that there was scarcely good performer in the team ; that Evans, who played for Bootle last season, was the best of the backs, but he did not shine brilliantly ; that Warner was remarkably cool ; that he seemed so cool as to appear frozen ; that his performance in goal was a very poor one indeed ; that Everton won with ridiculous easy ; that Latta and Brady again shone brightly ; and that Geary was very much off in his shooting.
EVERTON V NOTTS COUNTY
The Referee - Sunday 04 January 1891
This fixture was decided on the ground of the former, before a large gate. Robertson kicked off for Everton and soon after the start Geary scored. . Exciting play followed, Chadwick, however, lowering Notts colours with a good shot; and when half-timer arrived the score was Everton, two; Notts nil. On change of ends, Notts kicked off, and play became very even. Each side scored twice, Everton having the misfortune of one of their backs putting the ball through his home goal. Final score Everton, four goals; Nott County, two.
EVERTON v. NOTTS COUNTY.
Sporting Life - Monday 05 January 1891
These teams meet on the Anfield road enclosure, Liverpool, on Saturday, before fully 11,000 spectators. There had been several changes in the Everton ranks, and anxiety was manifested as to how they would work. They came off, and everyone was pleased. The play was opened at a fearful pace, the home side being particularly active. After about four minutes play Geary notched the first point from a splendid pass by Robertson. The Notts men played up grandly, and the backs and custodian were severely pressed. Toone many times scored brilliantly, especially from Robertson. Eventually Chadwick received a pass from Latta, and with a neat low shot beat Toone for the second time. This roused Notts, who played much better together, and though Oswald, Locker, and Daft dribbled and passed well, the home backs were equal to them, and Jardine had not much to do. Towards the end of the first half play again reverted to the Notts end, and Toone's saving was marvelous. The forwards were greedy for goals, and they put the ball through twice, but had no goals allowed as the off-side rule had been infringed. When ends were changed the home side led by two to none. On resuming Everton went off with an electrifying dash again, and from some quick passing in goal mouth Latta put on the third legitimate point amid excitement. The play continued in the neighbourhood of Hendry, McLean, and Toone, but the home side fell off a bit in their shooting. Then Shelton sent in brilliant half volley, which appeared to go straight to the referee, who declined to agree to the claims of the Notts players. For short time Notts were now out-played and when they had a chance they spoiled it by bad shooting. Milward got the ball past Toone again, but no goal was allowed for it, and then from a foul the visitors scored their first goal. Everton, and Geary put on the fourth goal with a long high shot, and Notts replying with a second, the game ended —Everton. four; Notts, two. Everton; Jardine, goal; Hannah and Doyle (backs), Parry, Holt, and Kirkwood (half-backs); Milward, Chadwick, Geary, Robertson and Latta. Notts; - Toone, goal; Mclean and Hendry (backs); Osborne, Calderhead, and Shelton (half-backs), McGregor, McInnes, Oswald. Locker, and Daft.
EVERTON V ASTON VILLA
Athletic News - Monday 05 January 1891
Another holiday crowd of about 9,000 turned out to see this match on New Years Day. The first match at Birmingham resulted in a draw of two goals each, so additional interest was centred in this match. The members of the Everton team are popular anywhere round about the district, and although the reverses in November may have cooled the ardour of some, the splendid victories of Christmastide and New Year have caused these to be forgotten. A feeling of certainty prevails that the Liverpool club will, at any rate. Be at the top of the League. Three stiff fights remained, viz., Notts County, Preston North End, and Burnley. By the time these notes appear we shall know the result of the first, but the North End match, for obvious reasons, is a bit of an uncertainty. The North End players, I hear, we pretty confident of repeating the dose, whilst the Everton men are certain they won’t. So we shall have to wait. Meanwhile Everton are gaining fast, and I cannot see any of the others to beat them. The ground had a sprinkling of sand on, but was nevertheless, on the slippery side. The teams were;- Everton; Jardine, goal; Hannah and Doyle, backs; Kirkwood, Holt and Parry, half-backs; Latta, Brady, Geary, Chadwick, and Milward, forwards. Aston Villa;- Warner, goal; Evans, and Cox, backs; Brown, Devey, and Campbell, half-backs; Albert Brown, Cowan, Dickson, Graham, and Hodgetts, forwards. Until the players “found their feet” play was rather slow, but there was plenty of excitement, as Everton had undoubtedly the best of matters, the wings working well, and at length Latta beat Warner, but the point was disallowed. However, after more pressure, Chadwick scored a legitimate goal. The Villa could make no headway, but the play was not brilliant on either side, the home forwards shooting badly. After a lot of pressure the Villa left came away in good style and seemed certain to score, when Doyle came up and conceded a corner. The game was now much faster, and some hot work in the visitors’ goal resulted in Albert Brown heading through his own goal. Again Hodgetts and Graham showed the way, and the last named had a splendid chance of scoring, as he was right in front, with no one to face only Jardine. But he did an even more ludicrous feat than kicking over the bar for he missed the ball altogether, and Parry cleared. The Villa men played up better now, but whatever chances presented themselves, which by the way were few, were spoiled by wretched shooting. The home forwards were the quicker lot, and their dash was too much for Cox, who caused Warner to scoop out a mis-header just on half-time. With two goals in hand the Everton men were not content and kept pressing, Milward once dashing up in fine style and putting a pass from Brady through, but he was ruled off-side. After a visit to the home end, Milward was again prominent, and finished up a grand effort by centring finely, Latta putting high over the bar. The players seemed to relax their efforts and the game was slower, but Everton could yet claim the advantage. Albert Brown, who had not done anything worthy of his reputation, now beat Doyle. His centre, however, lacked force, and Parry cleared. The Villa supporters called upon their men to feed Hodgetts, but when Dennis got it Hannah deftly robbed him. Although Everton had the best of it, no further damage was done for half an hour, when Brady scored through some tricky play of Latta’s. A minute after the same player notched a fourth goal, Milward this time having a hand in it. The home left were going strongly, Chadwick passing effectively, and his partner putting in his well-known rushes, consequently Evans had a warm time of it. The Villa forwards showed improved form, and Dickson tried a long shot which Jardine saved well, and a little later he had a second puzzling one to stop. However, Everton replied with another, Geary shooting from long range, and several of the Villa men had a try at stopping it, but all failed. Just on “Time” the visitors came away in a threatening manner, but the close found them in a minority of five goals. It was not by any means a brilliant game, being too one-sided but the home team gave an excellent account of themselves. Jardine had not much to do, but what shots he had were difficult ones. Hannah and Doyle were simply impassible, the former having Hodgetts weighed up to a nicety. Holt caused a lot of amusement with his tactics against the burly Villa forwards, and Parry maintains his improved form of last week. Kirkwood, too, was “peedling” around and putting in those tasty passes of his. The wings were in their best humour, passing effectively, the outside men showing any amount of dash. In point of merit, I should say they were about equal. Geary is a little “off” yet. He seems to have lost the knack of passing and keeping his wings together, and his shooting is not so accurate as in the early part of the season. For Aston Villa, Warmer was not over brilliant in goal, but quite passable. Evens is known about here, and his play has improved. Cox was inferior to his partner, but Campbell played a good game against Latta. The other halves were out-classed. The forwards at times passed very well, but were not in it with their rivals. They had not the same method and the defence was altogether too good for them. It was a cold New year’s greeting they got at Anfield.
EVERTON V NOTTS COUNTY
Athletic News - Monday 05 January 1891
By the Loiterer
That defeat at Nottingham of three goals to one on November 1st had to be avenged, and the Everton team felt quite capable of accomplishing it. It was only a question of time, and the opportunity came in the early days of the New Year. I had on my right a Nottingham gentleman who bemoaned the condition of the ground. Well, it was not perfect, but it was as good as can be expected after three weeks’ frost, followed by a sudden thaw. To come to the point the turf was deceptive; sometimes the ball would stop where it alighted, at others it would travel freely. The state of the ground at present receives more attention than circumstances warrant. If a team can only play on a dry ground, so much the worse for them when they come to play on a soft or muddy turf. I don’t know what kind of stuff is prepared at Trent Bridge, but any team should be able to gauge the ball after a quarter of an hour’s play, no matter what the conditions are. Neither side was fully represented, but here are the teams;
Everton; Jardine, goal; Hannah and Doyle, backs; Kirkwood, Holt, and Parry, half-backs; Latta, Geary, Robertson, Chadwick, and Milward, forwards. Notts;- Toone, goal; Gunn and Hendry, backs; Osborne, Calderhead, and Shelton, half-backs; McGregor, McInnes, Oswald, Locker, and Daft, forwards. The home forwards were soon on the job, as a fine dart from Latta enabled Chadwick to send in to Toone, and rom the rebound Geary scored. Everton still continued to press, and eventually Chadwick obtained a second goal. The game was more open now, and McGregor and Oswald essayed shots which were wide. In the open the Notts forwards did very well, but at the pinch Hannah and Doyle were too good for them. At the other end Toone had some “teasers” to deal with, but managed to keep the shots out. Gunn frequently let in Milward, and the entire is due to Toone for keeping the scoring down. Shelton also played well, and at the interval Everton led by two goals to none. On resuming, the home team kept up the pressure for a time, and then the Notts left transferred play, and Calderhead seemed to shoot through, but the referee would not allow the point. Play was fast and even, but some grand passing by the home left enabled Milward to score a third goal. McInnes was always prominent, and now Oswald and Locker joined him, and the three bothered Jardine so much that he was penalized for “carrying” and from the free kick Notts scored. The muddy state of the ground seemed to have no effect on the Everton team, and the forwards were continually on the aggressive, Geary scoring the fourth goal. Locker immediately replied with a somewhat lucky one as Doyle evidently booked him as “off-side” but the goal counted. After this Notts played up gallantly, but it was too late to even draw level, and the final result was a win for Everton by four goals to two. No matter what state the ground was in, I think Everton would have won comfortably. They played a better game all round. Toone certainly had far more work than Jardine, and no fault could be found with his performance; but the backs were not in it. Hendry played a grand game, but Gunn was very much off. I believe he was handicapped with his understandings, but at their best I should say Gunn and Hendry are inferior to Hannah and Doyle. In Calderhead and Shelton, Notts have two good halves, but contrasting still further, they are no better then Parry and Holt. All played a grand game, but I should like Parry’s style to be more polished. Forward, Everton were superior. Geary seemed to be at sea for a while, but his play with Latta in the second half could not be excelled. Milward and Chadwick were as good as ever, and I cannot see how the former can miss international honours this season. Robertson in the centre, was very fair. On the Notts side, McInnes was the best, but all occasionally did good work, although lacking dash and resource at the finish. Who is to beat Everton for the League championship now? It is just possible, but not probable.
LIVERPOOL DISTRICT NOTES
Athletic News - Monday 05 January 1891
By the Loiterer
The “signing on” process is being quietly conducted at Everton and the only doubtful one for the next year is Hannah. The Everton players have been the recipients of a handsome New Year’s gift, which they fully deserve. Next Saturday’s match with North End is the last League game of the season. There will be a big gate with anything like weather. The Everton team were at Bolton last Monday in charge of Messrs, Barclay and Molyneux, and gave great praise to the Wanderers for their magnificent play against the “Wolves” The Bolton Wanderers have always been great favourites at Everton. In a fortnight Everton have played four League games, and put in eight points. Good business.
ENGAGED PLAYERS FOR NEXT SEASON
Registered to 1892
Everton- J.A. Angus and T. Wyllie.
MANCHESTER AND DISTRICT
Athletic News - Monday 05 January 1891
THE “TOFFY” MEN TRIUMPHANT
The Everton club, who have this season decided upon running two first-class teams, sent what they term the “Everton” down to Alexandra Park to antagonize the Manchester team. With such players as Angus, McLean, Gordon, McMillan, McGregor, and Elliott in their ranks in addition to the rest of the team, who are players of the first water, it would hardly be right to class the team as juniors. A large crowd welcomed the respective teams, and it was seen that the home team were short of Gould, Maddocks, and Powell, and as these players had not intimated their inability to play the mancunians started with nine men, Butterworth who was on reserve, filling one of the vacancies. From the start the play was of an even character, Manchester, notwithstanding their short number, playing very well until Cuthbertson and Maxwell, of the Amateurs’ team completed the eleven, when Gordon, for the visitors, scored, Earp slipping on account of the state of the ground, which was in a dreadful condition. Ultimately the mancunians pressed, but McLean played a grand game, and Angus shortly afterwards saved in a splendid fashion with several of the forwards hovering round him, half-time being called, Everton leading by one to none. During the second half the visitors attacked strongly, Earp saving several times in grand style, although the ice hampered him sadly, as he could hardly keep his feet. Elliott scored again, and when the whistle sounded Everton had won a good game by five goals to none.
MIDLAND NOTES
Athletic News - Monday 05 January 1891
It is impossible to disguise the fact that the Everton defeat has given rise to feelings approaching consternation in the ranks of the patient, long, suffering, and forgiving supporters of Aston Villa. Of course, no one in this district ever expected the Perry Barr players to defeat the Evertonians on their own field; but it may be asserted with quite as much truth that no one expected such a pronounced thrashing would be administered. When Everton met the locals at Perry Barr, no one could complain of the show given on either side, and there are lots of people, who still declare that the Villa really won. So persistently have the Birmingham players disappointed their friends by their feeble display in Lancashire, that it is worse than idle to attempt to excuse their wretched performances. Time after time have the Villa collapsed just when there was reason to expect them to retrieve their fallen fortunes; time after time have they gone utterly to pieces before the onslaught of the Lancashire clubs; and so unreliable and shifty are the various expedients resorted to that the hitherto faithful followers of the club must be excused if they break the tenth commandment and sign-with a deep sigh-for some of the talent possessed by rival clubs. In extenuation of the heavy defeat recently sustained, it is said that the Villa had as much of the play as their opponents. For my own part, I an unwilling to offer any excuse, and can only think the better team won, as they deserved to do. BRUM.
EVERTON V NOTTS COUNTY
January 5, 1891. The Birmingham Daily Post
The meeting of these clubs at Liverpool attracted a large amount of public interest, and those present witnessed a fine exhibition of football. Everton at once began to attack, and within a few minutes Geary was enabled to kick a goal, after a brilliant attempt by Robertson. Some even play followed, and then Chadwick scored a second point for Everton. Twice the home side got the ball through the posts, but on each occasion the goal was disallowed on the plea of “off-side,” When half-time was reached Everton led by 2 goals to 0. After the charge of ends the Notts team played up well, but they could never recover from their bad start. Two goals were scored on each side, so that victory rested with Everton by 4 to 2. The last point for Notts was gained by H.B. Daft with a beautiful low shot.
EVERTON 4 NOTTS COUNTY 2
January 5 1891. The Liverpool Mercury
This return match was played on Saturday at Anfield. Before another large concourse of spectators. Notts winning the toss, Hope Robertson kicked off towards the Anfield goal. McInnes fastened on the ball, and passed over to Daft, who was nicely robbed by Kirkwood. Coming again the homesters returned, not to be satisfied, and Latta rushing the ball up the wing and beating Hendry, offside was ruled against him. From the goal kick Chadwick got possession and shot in hard, Toone saving a beauty, but Geary dashing in, brought the downfall of the Notts goal, amidst loud cheers, after five minute's play. From the midfield Daft got off, and Hannah slipping, Oswald shot in, but Jardine saved splendidly, Latta now got away in a strong run, and amidst great excitement Notts cleared. The right wing of the visitors tried hard to relieve the present, but Doyle returned the ball well up the field, and the home team gave Toone some trouble to save, which he did in splendid style, until Chadwick got possession and defeated him, and so placed Everton two goals ahead. From the restart Doyle and Hannah, but intercepted the Notts left made off for the home goal. The Everton forwards now showed some pretty passing, but Toone was in champion form. Locker tried hard to get away, but was pulled up by Holt. Everton now had several shots, one from Chadwick forcing a corner, which was act turned to account. Daft got possession, and made off for the home goal, but was pulled up by Hannah. Some clever combination by Everton gave Notts anxiety but Chadwick got in the way of Geary and spoiled his shot. The remainder of the first half was all in favour of Everton, who led at the interval by 2 goals to nil. After a rest Oswald re-started. Notts raced off, but Latta getting possession passed to Geary, who had hard lines. The Notts left got off, and Daft sent in a good shot, which just passed outside the post. Milward and Chadwick were now conspicuous by a fine run, until pulled up by Gunn. The Everton right again got hold, and Geary passed well ever to the left, Milward forced a third goal for the homesters. The Anfielders now slowed down, and Notts getting off shot in, and Jardine was penalised for going over the regulation mark, from which, Notts adored. From the re-start Everton dashed off, and Toone had to save shots from Robertson, Latta and Chadwick. Notts tried hard to get away, put Parry returned to Latta, he passed to Geary and the latter scored a beauty with a low oblique kick. The game was now very even and after some midfield play, the right wing of the visitors got away, and McInnes passing over to the lift, Locker scored a second goal for his side. Everton continued to press, he found no further opening, and the game ended in a victory for Everton by 4 goals to 2. Teams Everton: - Jardine, goal Hannah (captain), and Doyle, backs, Kirkwood, Holt, and Parry, half-backs, Latta, Geary, Hope Robertson, Chadwick, and Milward, forwards. Notts County: - Toone, goal, Gunn, and Hendry, backs, Osborne, Calderhead, and Shelton half backs, McGregor, McInnes, Oswald, Locker, and Daft, forwards. More good work again have Everton added two wins, which must be gratifying to the full with their followers. The Aston Villa match was to one side to tell in much attention, and as the midland club was fully represented, it is strange to those who watched the New Year's match at Anfield, how Aston Villa could manage to make a draw with Everton at Perry Bar
It is true the Anfielders were a differently constituted eleven than that which did battle on October 11. Latta had just previously met with his accident rendering the attack somewhat disorganized. The case with which Everton had avented their partial failure when at the Aston Villa ground, gave confidence that Notts County on Saturday would be tackled successfully, and this forecast was simply realised. Everton play is not fully represented by the score. They were unlucky in their claims for goal, while their opponents secured the two goals by a slice of good fortune, rather than the reward of mark-one goal being scored accidentally by an Evertonian as the result of a free kick in the goalmouth, and the second point during some indecisive back play on account of an impression that the offside rule had been broke. The game was carried on at a terrific pace, especially during the first half. Captain Hannah and his men by downright good skill work, dictating the terms of warfare, and playing football as ought to be, and as they can play it to perfection. Everton led at the interval by 2 goals to nil. The second half, was more evenly contested the home team apparently in a condistory mood, and satisfied that the game was safe, took matters comfortably. Brady enjoyed a well-earned rest, and this necessitation. Geary partnering Latta, and Hope Robertson, taking the responsibly of centre forward his shoulders. The attack suffered little conseqenances of the changes, Geary did some excellent work on the right with Latta, and the runs contributed by this wing were really brilliant Robertson avail a very useful centre forward. His weight told officially against Calderhead. The left wing was again to the fore, and together the attack was of a most complete kind. The halfbacks never fagged and each, as his turn caused sustained his reputation. Jardine who could be held responsible for the two goals, was not often called upon, but managed to give a taste of his activity in goal. The Backs again were an important factor in the plan for victory, and compared with Notts were far ahead, and confirmed the opinion long formed that, Hannah and Doyle are defenders not daily matched. Toone in goal for Notts was a success, and fully justified his selection as goalkeeper for the North against the South. Gunn was in a new position as far as Liverpoolians had seen him, as do defenders with Hendry and shaped fairly well. Calderhead played a good halfback game, as did Shelton. Oswald kept his wings well together and shot often, but generally the Notts forwards had not much opportunity of showing their combination, the home halves being too clever for them.
MANCHESTER 0 EVERTON RESERVES 3
January 5 1890. The Liverpool Mercury
At Manchester Gordon scored the first point for Everton, this being the only point scored during the first half. Resuming Elliott scored for Everton. Final result in favour to Everton by 3 goals to nil.
NORTH V. SOUTH.
Morning Post - Saturday 10 January 1891
The Notts Forest Club ground at Nottingham will be the scene of this match next Monday. There have been some changes in the players originally chosen, but the sides will now, in all probability, be constituted thus:— South: L. R. Wilkinson (old Carthusians), goal ; W. C. Wells (Swifts) and I. M. Ingram (Old Wykehamists), backs; E. Shaw (Great Marlow), A. H. Hossack (Cambridge University), and W.Winckworth (Old Westminsters), half backs ; A. G. Henfrey (Cambridge), centre ; H. Offer (Royal Arsenal) and R. R. Sandilands (Old Westminsters), left wings ; G. Brann (Swifts) and G. H. Cotterill (Corinthians), right wings. North: Toone (Notts), goal; Underwood (Stoke-on-Trent) and Earp (Notts Forest), backs; Holt (Everton), Barton (Blackburn Rovers), and Shelton (Notts), half back: Brown (Aston Villa) and Smith (Notts Forest), right wings; Geary (Everton), centre; Chadwick (Everton) and Townley (Blackburn Rovers), left wings.
EVERTON REVIEW
January 10 th 1891. The Liverpool Courier.
Consequently upon the defeat of Notts County great joy prevailed in Toffeedom, for by this auspicious event Everton advanced a stage nearer the realisation of a long0deferred hope. Much was said earlier in the season as to the avil effects of over-work intensified as it was by loss of natural rest and the fatigue of travel; but not that the results of the holiday season are calmly surveyed it really seems marvellous how, under different conditions and impulses, so much should have been accomplished. The match against Notts County was the fourth on the home ground during the holiday season, and as was confidently predicated, the whole resulted in splendid victories for the Everton team. On Boxing-Day Accrington were beaten by 2 to 1, and on the following day Burnley succumbed by 7 goals to 3. Now the team tested until the first day of the new year, where Aston Villa, of whom better things were expected after the check received at Birmingham, were beaten at all points of the game, and suffered a crushing defeat by five goals to nil. In forcasting the result of last Saturday's match. Parry openly declared that Notts County would also be easily beaten, but as a matter of fact the “lacemen made a much better fight of it than did the Perry Bar team, although a victory of four to two leaves no room for doubt as to which was the better team. Thus we have four important League matches decided in the course of nine days, four victories gained, with a goal advantage in favour of Everton of 18 to six. But whilst these are most satisfactory results, it would be manifestly indecent to unduly exult or regard the struggle as virtually over. Everton have still two more matches to play before the League series of fixtures is concluded and it must be bear in mind that whilst the Rovers will make a bold bid for the coveted championship honours, Preston North End are due at Anfield today. Much, of course, depends upon the result of this important encounter, but as Everton will have a thoroughly effective team, with Latta again in his very best form, the utmost confidence prevails that the Deepdale reverse will be wiped out and with a final victory at Burnley, the crowning triumph of the club will have been realised Everton in 20 minutes played have gained 29 points, whilst Blackburn Rovers for 18 have 24 points to their credit, their most formidable opponents being Bolton Wanderers who have more than once and when least expected proved a match for their doughty neighbours and who thwarted the “Wolves” when their prospects looked brightest. There will be a great struggle for supremacy at Anfield today, and whilst hoping that the best team may win, the hope naturally rises uppermost that Everton –good old Everton –will be the victorious team.
FOOTBALL CHIP .
Liverpool Football Echo.
The contest for the championship of the League is going on fairly well, and Everton are nearly certain to be the champions. Notts County came and saw, but they did not conquer, they going down to the tune of 4 goals to 2. The game was one of the best seen on the Anfield ground, this season, and was full of sensations. George Toone gave a grand display of goal-keeping, and if he does not guard the English citadel against Scotland this year Toone will not get his just reward. A great interest was taken in Latta and Henday. These two are old opponents, and everyone will remember that when Hendry played last year for the Glasgow Rangers and Patrick Thistle at Anfield-road he played Latta to a nicety. In fact it has been said that Hendey has bottled Latta up oftener than any other man living. But last Saturday Alex was in fine fettle, and fairly walked round the big Uddingstone man to the latter's discomfiture. Charlie Parry again showed his true form, and played a champion game. At the beginning of the season Parry said he would make Campbell move from his place, and we think he is keeping his word. Harry daft was a bit of a frost, but then he was playing against Everton's skipper, who was in rare trim. Little McInnis of the Notts team was voted good goods. He several times got past Doyle, but Parry always went to the rescue of his comrades. Doyle always plays to win. But Danny, my boy, don't get so excited; leave Captain Hannah to do this shouting. Alex Brady was unfit for services. Geary partnered Latta and Hope Robertson went centre. This arrangement worked very well. Geary played one of his best games, and he and Latta made a strong wing. Alf Shelton had a lively time of it, with these two, but he played the game without losing his temper. During one portion of the game he happened to touch Geary with his foot and it was pleasing to bear the Notts man immediately ask Geary if he had hurt him. This little incident speaks volumes for Shelton, and shows that he can play the game in a proper style, always trying to a void roughness. Next week is the absorbing topic of the day. Can Everton beat Sunderland? The match will be worth going miles to see. Jardine will be unable to play, so Angus will be called in, and this will strengthen the Salmon and Blues. Everton have yet to win a match at Sunderland against Sunderland, and if they can manage to do it next Saturday, their old defeats will be forgotten. We understand that an order had been given by the Everton Committee to “strike” the League medals they propose to give to the players when the cup is welcomed to Liverpool. The design is of a very unique character.
EVERTON V PRESTON NORTH END
January 12, 1891. The Birmingham Daily Post
Fully 14,000 people assembled at the Everton ground to see the local organisation try conclusions with Preston North End with Preston North End. When the two clubs met at Preston in November North End won by 2 goals to one, but since that time Everton had been playing very brilliantly, whilst Preston had fallen off, and a victory for the Liverpool team was generally expected. Play was very fast and skilful at the start, the visitors showing to especial advantage. Each goal was frequently in danger, but nothing was scored for half an hour, when a fine attack by Preston resulted in a goal for the visitors. Preston had the better of the play afterwards, but just before half-time Everton pressed, the sides changing over with North End a goal ahead. Early in the second half Everton attacked vigorously, but the visitors' defence was admirable, and at length Preston got down to the home gold. Some rather desultory play ensued, but towards the close the excitement ran very high. A splendid shot by Geary only missed by a few inches, and in the end Preston North End were left victorious by 1 goal to none.
EVERTON 0 PRESTON NORTH END 1
January 12 1891. The Liverpool Mercury.
Everton played their last League match at Home on Saturday, and for a fitting finale, were opposed by the popular Preston North End team. This was practically the event of the season at Anfield as the issue was a vital one, and may prove the key to the League pussle. Various circumstances favoured the occasions. The weather took a turn of a genial kind hardly to be hoped for, and the Sun came and neutralised somewhat the effects of the frost. There were no clashing events. All Rugbeians were idea, and so helped to swell the usual Evertonians throng, and as Booth's match was scratched most of the players availed them as vet of the rare opportunity of witnessing a stern League contest. The enclosure was filled to overflowing, and so the number would be towards of 15,000. Great pains had been taken with the ground, and though it was still hard and slippery in places, it was rendered in fair playing condition by the aid of ashes, sand and sawdust, for which, Mr. Elliott and his staff deserves much credit. Mr. Betts the referee declined, properly to say whether the ground was fit for the purpose of a league match, leaving the clubs to move in the matter at the meeting tonight; but we have not been informed of any objection. The teams, which were as follows, had a flattering reception: - Preston North End: - Trainor, goal, Holmes, and Ross, (captain), backs, Drummond (g), Hendry, and Stewart (w), forwards. Gordon, Drummond (j), Campbell, Crossan, and Gallagher, forwards. Everton: - Jardine, goal, Hannah (captain), and Doyle, backs, Kirkwood, Holt, and Parry, half-backs, Latta, Brady, Geary, Chadwick, and Milward, forwards. It will be seen that North End were with Kelso and J.Ross while Crossen appeared for the first time in a League match. Hannah was lucky in the toss, and Campbell opened play. Parry spoil Gordon run, but North End returned on the left. They were stalled of without much trouble but a fine kick by Ross give his forwards another chance, when Gordon tested Jardine, to find the custody a solid one. North End were persistence, using their weight well, but the home defence behaved excellently, Hannah, Parry and Doyle, in turn staying raids. Everton improved momentarily on the right, but Ross kicked back, crossan shooting in, and Jardine running and chucking clear. More pressure was put on, and Doyle came finally to the reasons. Geary made a splendid run and pass, which was deemed so ominous by Ross that he brought down execrations on his head for fearlessly kicking into touch. Everton were not yet beaten off, and Geary tried a couple of long shot. Campbell escaped past Holt, and wound on a spanking run by shooting long and low, the ball going past off the post. The home team came near scoring a little later, but found the defence too sturdy. Campbell grew dangerous again, until Latta was put into possession, supported by Brady, a fine shot being grandly intercepted by Holmes. An examination of boots was now resorted to, with the result that Chadwick was requested to discard his new for old ones. This gave the players a little breaking time. On resuming Everton attacked hotly, Chadwick shot in hard and straight, and in stopping the ball, Ross seemed to have fisted it, but no notice was taken. Everton left wing continued to haress Holmes and G.Drummond without advantage. Play then went to the other end by means of strong kicking, and after Gordon had put wildly behind, Crossan beat Jardine out of a scrimmage. Everton were thus after a quarter of an hour's play in a minority, and they went forward with a will. Kirkwood lobbed accurately to Geary who shot, but found Trainor safe. Then a corner fell to Everton, and Ross ultimately located play in Everton's quarters. The defence held good, and Latta soon went away, and Geary beating Hendry, the ball was punched over the bar for a corner. Preston North End grew determined, and for a long time the home team were in turbulent water, during which, critical period Hannah was ever setting his men an example in coolness. Latta by way of relief, ran finely, and passed across, but unluckily no one was handy to take the ball. Hannah next kicked over to Milward, who shot high above the bar, and Doyle having sent back from Gallacher, the interval came with North End leading by a goal to nil. Considerable fractions were evinced at midfield on resuming and twice Mr. Betts threw up for interruption. Doyle put his right wing in an advantageous position a fine shot being grandly surmounted by Ross. Everton closed up again, but failed at the proper moment. Excitement ran high, and evidently pervaded the players, with the result that scientific play was not easily discernible. The Everton right and North End left indulged in see saw movements to no advantage to either side, and then Jardine saved from Campbell whilst Gordon put behind soon afterwards on Stewart kicking accurately. Hannah came up to the assistance of Latta, who ran on but offside spoilt the effort. Everton attacked in better style now than hitherto and Ross several times kicked out, the lengthy siege enabling North End to display their grand defensive resource. Until ten minutes of time the home team were pressing more or less. Then J.Drummond shot Herr, as did the left wing, but Jardine cleared coolly. As a last effort Milward, who was now playing centre, dashed down only to see the ball kicked out without ceremony, and Everton were forced to retire beaten by a goal to nil. There can be no doubt that on Saturday's play the best team won, and moreover, the actual score rather underrates the respective quality of skill displayed. The achievements of Everton were a disappointment; those of North End came as a revelation. The winners have a knack of rising to their highest standard when battling with Everton and if Mr. Sudell's men had played all though the season as strongly as on Saturday, they would never have lost the lead of the league. In the first few minutes even victory seemed assured to North End. They gave no quarter nor asked for any. Everton were thrown on the defence at the outset, and the superb half-backs upset the home forwards combination whist Ross Holmes and Trainor were always equal to any stray raids on goal. As the game went on the Everton attack certainly improved, but the three inner forwards kept play too much to themselves, Milward especially getting few opportunities. The shooting too, was generally bad, and it was galling to Liverpoolians to witness the repeated chances mind. In the second half more particularly, after the difficult work of getting within shooting bounds. The Everton halfbacks were below their normal state of efficiently, Parry being the most successful but none ever flagged or shirked work. Hannah was cool and safe, whilst Doyle prevented Gordon and J.Drummond shinning greatly. Especially in the matter of shooting. Jardine played one of his granded games. Several of his clearance were most brilliant, and the return shot that beat him would have baffled the majority of goalkeepers. He apparently did not see the ball at all. The strength of North End was in their back play. The exhibition of Stewart and G.Drummond at half-back and Ross and Holmes at back, could hardly be surprised. Trainor had very little chance of showing his worth. Perhaps the feature of play that gave North End the greater amount of effectiveness was their long accurate kicks and passes, and find heading their height being an advantage to them in the latter made of working the ball. It was not a pretty game. The pace was too great and feeling too keen, and there was much kicking out, and not a few altercations. The match was disastrous in another respect to Everton, as Hannah sprinted his ankle in which be awkward should it prevent him playing against Sunderland.
STOKE SWIFTS 1 EVERTON RESERVES 3
January 12 1891. The Lievrpool Mercury
The return match was played at Stoke and the visitors won by 3 goals to 1. Last time won by 5 to nil. Everton: - Angus, goal, McLean and Cresswell, backs, Martin (captain), R. Jones and Hammond, half-backs, Gordon, McGregor, Robertson, McMillan, and Elliott, forwards .
EVERTON PRESTON NORTH END.
Sporting Life - Monday 12 January 1891
THIS LEADERS TAKEN DOWN AT HOME.
The teams a met at Everton, Liverpool, on Saturday, are the keenest possible rivals, and it was not surprising that fully 16,000 spectators lined the enclosure. The ground was hard and frost bound, while the thaw of Friday had failed to clear all the snow off the surface. In consequence, the Everton executive had covered the field with sawdust, hay seeds, and fine cinders, so that a good foothold was obtainable. North End played Crossan (late of the Glasgow Celtic) inside left, and J. Drummond partnered Gordon on the right wing. The visitors started the game, against wind and sun, and at the outset it was plainly to be seen that a grand game was to be played. North End at once took to pressing their opponents and Gallacher and Gordon were each within an ace of scoring in the first minute. Before Everton could get above half way of the field Campbell had filled Jardine a hands, and shot only a few inches wide of the goal posts. Then Latta and Brady, with perfect passing, got round Ross, and enabled Geary to give Trainer his first bit of trouble. The North End, however, come down on Jardine again, and Holmes with a tremendous kick placed the ball in front of Jardine. Gallacher met with his head, and placed it to Crossan's feet. He steadied it, and with a splendid shot beat Jardine amid cheers. From the kick off Everton become dangerous, but Ross, Holmes, Hendry, Stewart, and G. Drummond were too much for them. Once Trainer saved again, but up to half-time the Prestonians had all the best of matters, and half way through led by one to none. On resuming Everton began to play desperate game, Holt, Geary, and Parry playing heavily on the Prestonians. Holt and Geary were each cautioned, and both sides settled down to work. Trainer s charge was the first to be jeopardized by Geary, but the hall curled outside the posts. Then it was apparent North End had got the measure of their opponents, and kept them well at bay. Their defence was, however, capital. Once J. Drummond all but beat Jardine in a long shot, and then Campbell, G. Drummond, and Stewart all had tries, but they could not affect a further downfall, and the Prestonians won by one goal to none, Mr. Betts (London), the referee, had to order Chadwick to change his boots on account or playing with indiarubber soles. Teams: North End.—Trainer (goal). N. J-Ross and Holmes (backs), G. Drummond, Hendry, and Stewart (half-backs). Gordon and J. Drummond (right wing), Campbell (centre). Crossan and Gallacher (left wing). Everton;-Jardine (goal), Hannah and Doyle (backs), Kirkwood. Holt, and Parry (half-backs), Latta and Brady (right wing). Geary (centre), Chadwick and Milward (left wing).
EVERTON NOTES
Lancashire Evening Post - Monday 12 January 1891
After the defeat of the team on Saturday, Liverpudlians who during the past week have done such a large amount of crowing, must feel very small. Before the game commenced there was any amount of confidence amongst them that the North End were about to be all but pulverized, but as soon almost as the game commenced it was quite evident that the boot was on the other leg. The North End started off with determination, and they kept it up. There can be no doubt about it that the best team won, and many enthusiastic Evertonians admitted it afterwards. The change from McKenna to J. Drummond on the right wing did not add to the strength of the side, and on all hands the opinion prevails that the soldier lad should be a permanent partner with Gordon so long as Jimmy Ross is absent. In consequence Gordon did not play up to form, or the result would in all probability have been more decisive than it was. In all other sections the North End played a champion game. Campbell and Crossan proved good men, the latter putting in some really fine bits of passing and dodging, and the manner in which he notched the only goal proved conclusively that he keeps cool and knows full well what he is about, Gallacher was again in form. To say which was the best half-back would be difficult, as all three played perfectly, but among the spectators Stewart was an especial favourite. Ross and Holmes also played sterling football, and Trainer, as usual, was always ready and capable of doing all that fell to him. Jardine, in the Everton goal, was flashy and lucky, but Hannah and Doyle both defended capitally. Parry was the best of the half-backs. Holt being to anxious to show his trickery. Latta and Brady were never more completely held in check in their lives, and after a time lost their tempers, and were then but of little use. Geary did nothing all the afternoon, thanks to Hendry, and G. Drummond had Chadwick and Milward weighed up. The latter, however, played the best game on his side.
WEARSIDE
Athletic News - Monday 12 January 1891
As you stated, sir, some time ago, the most interesting of the English Cup ties next Saturday is that between Everton and Sunderland. Everton are determined not to throw away a point, for I am informed that they have given notice protest against Doig, the home custodian, should he figure between the “sticks.’’ Although the notification of a protest here has caused some irritation among more susceptible Wearsiders, I have heard nothing but praise of the sportsmanlike conduct of the Liverpool club in giving their opponents such ample notice. The ground of the protest, understand, is that Doig played in Scotland during the close season. Surely, however, if, as Sunderland maintain, he did so before he signed for them, that is no disqualification whatever for a Cup tie. I thought the distinction had been made clear by the case of Bell, of Middlesbrough. I can scarcely think that Everton would found an objection on such a flimsy pretext. Either they have misconstrued the rule or they have something else up their sleeve. Be that as it may, Sunderland intend play Doig at all hazards. The team, without him, would be like the play of Hamlet without the Prince of Denmark. With Kirtley as substitute the confidence the players in themselves and the confidence of the public in their ability to win would be rudely shaken. For my part I prefer Potts of the “A” team, a player who wants only an inch or two added to his stature to make a first-class goaler. It is bound to be a terrific game. Probably there will be very little science exhibited on either side; the “man” will played instead of the “ball,” and Sunderland are big, heavy, Dutch built team, they are not likely to come off second best in that respect. The are being carefully trained for the event on diet of egg-flip and “porritch,” with an occasional "haggis" as a change, and should step on the field as hard as – well, some people’s heads.
LIVERPOOL AND DISTRICT NOTES.
Athletic News - Monday 12 January 1891
By the Loiterer
The great fight is over! The details of the match will be dealt with in the proper column, but I just want to have a say in the matter. The match was regarded as an important one all by all lovers of the game, and quite 18,000 persons witnessed the performance. The result, you all know, was a win for the Preston Club by one goal to none. The game was played at Everton, and it is needless to tell you the result was not a popular one. Well, that does not matter. The best team undoubtedly gained the verdict. It was a very exciting game, and soma good points were brought out, but they were of a defensive character. .Both sides showed grand defence, but the North End excelled. The game opened in favour of North End, and play for the first ten minutes was all in the Everton half. Then matters were fairly even, but Crossans was successful in piloting the ball past Jardine. I don’t wish to say the point was a fluke, but it was one of those shots which might as easily have gone outside as through the goal. The ball was well centred from the right, and was bobbing about the heads of the players few yards from goal, when Crossans got his foot to it, and before Jardine knew it the Prestonian had scored his first goal in a League match. Everton had all the play in the second half, but what a defence they met. No matter how they played, the Everton forwards could not overcome Ross and Co. The Preston halves played a good game. I formed a high opinion the Sunderland trio when they were down here, but they were not in it with the Preston lot. Stewart was everywhere—heading and kicking judiciously, and seldom making a mistake. Hendry was also in the thick of it, and did yeoman service, whilst Drummond was not much behind the ex-soldier, and played confident game all through. I knew “Nick” Ross would be on the job, and I have never seen the great back play a better game. He kicked out a lot, certainly, but some of it was judicious in the extreme. Holmes was less prominent, but no fault could be found with his play. Trainer had not much to do, once only seriously called upon. Altogether the defence of the Preston men was the feature of the match. No matter whether it was the individual action of the backs or coalition with the halves, the whole formed such a barrier that the Everton forwards, clever as they undoubtedly are, could not break through. I have not much to say for either set of forwards. I should say had the better lot. The home defence was strong, but it had not the confident style of their opponents. Parry alone of the halves came to the North End standard, and neither of the backs were equal to Ross and Holmes. If I had to write a column I could not say any more. It sounds queer, but the superb defence of the Preston men won the match.
Bootle Notes Only
Firstly they had the benefit match which the Everton Club generously gave them, and which realized £126 16s, 10d; and then later, they had a profit on Jardine’s transfer to the 'same club of £65. There goes £192 towards the £203 deficit.
Mems.—the Bootle team watched the match at Everton. Were they pleased with the result?- The Liverpool and District Association have at last obtained badges for the juniors. The seniors cannot arrange their ties yet. The gate at Anfield was £490. I should say the future gates will be all profit.—Some anxiety is felt here as to the result of the Cup tie Sunderland. Jardine, through playing at Carlisle for Bootle, cannot keep goal. It will be a great game, and it is a pity the railway companies cannot see their way to run a trip.—The general verdict was that the Everton forwards could not play for toffee against North End. But what about Nick Ross and Co. If they played as they did against Everton no forwards would shine. The Everton contingent left for Notts yesterday. Holt was badly hurt on Saturday, and may not be able to do himself justice. A. Hannah, the Everton captain, was injured on Saturday, and will hardly be able to play against Sunderland. If not his club mate, McLean, will take his place. The Everton team leave for Sunderland on Friday morning in charge of Mr. Molyneux.
BIG GAME AT EVERTON.
Athletic News - Monday 12 January 1891
THE CHAMPIONS BEAT THE COMING CHAMPION?
By Free Critic.
Preston North End may not be the same team they were a couple of years ago, but their name is still one to draw the crowd, and on Saturday, when they met Everton, there was the largest gate ever seen at Anfield, and the receipts amounted to £489 15s. This means that over 16,000 paid, and as the club has 1,500 members, and hundreds took the liberty of climbing the hoarding, it may safely be said that 18.000 witnessed the game last Saturday. Besides this, there were a few thousands outside who could not gain admission, chiefly because the turnstiles had been closed, and these gentlemen were very wrath, but the Everton executive knew how many their ground would hold, and stopped the demand accordingly. A great deal depended on the result of this match so far as the Everton team was concerned, for if they won the championship would be as good as and the committee might just as well have handed over the “fivers” at once, whereas if they lost the Rovers might beat them, and down went the ‘'fivers”. Everton had their best team up, and had North End, although J. Drummond was placed on the right wing with Gordon, but this, I suppose, was the best thing the Preston men thought they could do. However, the teams were follow; - North End.-Trainer, goal; Holmes Ross, backs G. Drummond. Hendry, and Stewart, half-backs: Gordon. J. Drummond, Campbell, Crossens, and Gallagher, forwards. Everton;- Jardine, goal; Hannah and Doyle, backs; Kirkwood, Holt, and Parry, half-backs: Latta, Brady, Geary, Chadwick, and Milward, forwards. Referee: Mr. M. P. Betts.
There was a great deal of skirmishing about the condition of the ground, but when Mr. Sudell arrived he at once said there should be no protest, and this was quite right, for although the ground was hard and bumpy, the Everton executive had done all they could to make it playable, and the foothold was very good indeed. It was soon apparent that it would be no child’s game, for both sides went at it with a considerable amount of vigour - perhaps a little more than was comfortable—but no bones were broken. North End went to the front very early on, and were on the aggressive for a great portion of the first half. The Everton forwards were very loose, and as they had to face some magnificent defensive play, they did not get along with their accustomed success. The three Preston halves were in tip-top form, and when they had been settled there were Ross and Holmes to deal with, and on Saturday’s form this couple requires beating. Then, again, there was a man named Trainer in goal, and all the Everton forwards could do was to make long shies at him, which the Welshman generally allowed to go out. The only goal of the match was scored by Crossans, the ex-Celtic player, but it was the result of a splendid kick into goal on the part of Holmes, who planted the ball very nicely, and after being headed about a bit, Crossans got his foot to it and tapped it through, the Everton backs and the North End forwards being in such a cluster as to prevent any possibility of Jardine getting at it. The excitement was most intense, and it seemed to affect the Everton players, for they showed but little combination, and were met by about the best defence I have seen this season. Occasionally they got dangerous, and once nearly scored through Ross not allowing Trainer to take the ball, but by far the most of the play was at the bottom end, although Jardine had not a great number of shots to stop. Up to the interval North End continued to have the best of it, but did not again score, and turned round with goal to the good. I ought to have mentioned that early in the game Chadwick was found to be playing in shoes with indiarubber soles, and was ordered off to change. The second half was a contrast to the first, for the Evertonians strove most desperately to get on an equal footing, and although Trainer had not a great deal to do,' this was due to the effective play of those immediately in front him. Once or twice Geary burst away, and Trainer was on the lookout for a long, sharp shot, but it seldom came, Ross and Holmes and the half-backs being on the track of the “flier," who eventually went outside left and gave Millward a chance. Once Geary got through and put in a stinger, but it went just outside, and if it hadn’t. Trainer had got to the right post. The North End men were a goal in hand, and they knew it, were quite content to keep their opponents out whilst being satisfied with an occasional run by their forwards just to give the defenders breathing time. There is no doubt the North End meant winning, for their defence was as prompt and safe as it was possible to be, and those quick crosses from the left wing to Latta, which latter generally takes and shoots into goal, were lost by the determination of Ross and Stewart, who bowled the Dumbarton man over most unceremoniously, and cleared or allowed the ball to go out. It must not be imagined that Everton had all the game during this half, for often enough the home goal was placed m danger, and I should imagine Jardine stopped more shots than did Trainer. Once he partially mulled a high one, and Crossans had an easy chances of running the ball through, but didn’t; whilst several times it seemed almost certain that Jardine would be beaten, but he came out with flying colours. For all that, most of the play was at the bottom end of the ground, but the defence could not be broken, and North End won—and deservedly won -a hard game by one goal to none.
I have seen a great many good backs while knocking about the country, but not one equal to N.J. Ross, on Saturday’s form. Yes; N. J. is the best back in England at the present time, at least that is my opinion. All through he kicked powerfully, tackled superbly—are sorry I cannot put in a few more of ’em—and one bit was so good that I could not help forsaking my usual reserve and cheering vociferously. Geary and Chadwick had apparently beaten him half way up the field, but the North Ender kept between them, and just at the right moment made a sudden stop, put his foot on the ball, turned round, and had it up the field in Iess time than it takes to record it. But, beyond all this, his display was simply grand, and he seldom allowed Latta to get in those dangerous cross shots of his. Trainer stopped several attempts very well, and Holmes was meet useful, but after Ross comes Stewart, and in the ex-soldier. North End have picked up a splendid half-back —one who plays the old North End game. Steward is a big, athletic-looking fellow, but he seldom uses his weight, and puts in his kicks splendidly with great judgment. Drummond came next, and there was no mistake about Georgie trying to win. He always had his eye on the ball, and his display was first-class. Hendry was continually on the job at centre half, and was certainly too much for Geary; in fact, the North End half-back line was more like the old days than any I have seen since Russell, Robertson, and Graham were their best. Notwithstanding the fine play of Ross at back. I am inclined to think that the real secret of the North End victory was the steadiness and the cleverness of their half-backs, and this is the most important part in all big teams. Let the halves be rotten and there will be some scoring. I cannot say I was much impressed with the North End forward play. Gallocher and Crossans were certainly the best wing, and despite sundry Scottish Press opinions. I rather fancy Crossans will not disgrace the North Enders. He is not a “star” by any means, but he appears to have a good knowledge of the passing game, and is very tricky. Gallocher was, perhaps, the best of the lot, and the only fault I could find with the pair was that they kept the ball too much on the wing. Campbell was not quite up to expectation as a centre, for although he as a well-built young fellow, he seldom went for one of his opponents. He had many opportunities had he cared to go at the Everton backs, but of course Doyle is no chicken, and this was evidently Gordon’s opinion, for the latter seldom went near “Dannie,” and it was certainly not owing to any excessive roughness on the part of the Evertonian. But Parry and Doyle weigh about 28 stones between them, and Gordon did not care to experiment. Besides that, he had a rank bad partner in J. Drummond, who was seldom in the right spot -didn’t try get there, in fact -and when he was rarely passed the ball with any degree of accuracy. Everton did not play up to form -that is to say, they did not show that dash and quick passing for which they are so noted. Their goalkeeper was all right –perfect- and both Doyle and Hannah played well, particularly the former, who came next only to Ross in the matter of back play. Hannah was steady as usual, but had the misfortune to severely injured his ankle about ten minutes from the close. It is to be hoped the Everton captain will all right again for next Saturday's Cup tie at Sunderland, but the outlook is not very bright. Of the half-backs I was most taken up with Parry, and there is no doubt he and Doyle had Gordon well in hand. The Chester man is a big one, and seldom makes the mistake of not using his weight, and is remarkably good with his head. J. Holt did very well, but should guard his temper, although on the one occasion he was spoken to by the referee, Campbell was as much to blame as he. Kirkwood trotted about as usual, but was not quite so effective as I have seen him, and comparing the three with the North End trio, I am bound to say the Everton people came out very badly. They could not smash the combination, and it was here that Everton were beaten, for, as I have said, the North End forward play was nothing to brag about. I cannot pick out one of the home front rank who did anything extraordinary. Ross was evidently quite conversant with their style, and the half-backs were continually on the ball. Occasionally there was a good run, but that was all, and there was not a really smart bit of combination during the afternoon. Milward waited on the outside but waited in vain, whilst the neat runs and centres by Latter were absent, for the Simple reason that Brady was very little use, and Ross and Stewart were far too clever for any individual efforts of Latta s. Geary only got off about once, and passed very wildly—a remark which applies to the whole string. It was very seldom indeed that they did anything to justify the scoring abilities which they undoubtedly possess, and were very little use against the North End defence, which, it is pretty evident, is the chief means of winning their matches. Briefly, the North End defence was in front of that Everton, and it turned the scales of victory. I may mention that North End is the only club that has twice beaten Everton this season, and is the only club against which Everton have not scored -a remarkable tribute to Trainer, Ross, and Co. The result was a great disappointment to the Everton people, but the committee accepted it in a true sportsmanlike spirit, and both Mr. Barclay and Mr. Molyneux said that they could always stand a defeat when they were beaten by superior play. Quite right, too.
EVERTON NOTES
Athletic News - Monday 12 January 1891
There was a record gate at Everton on Saturday, and at sixpence each £489 15s was taken at the gate, which were closed a quarter of an hour before the start, and kept out fully 5,000. The next gate to this is also down to the credit of North end, at Everton (last season’s League match), whilst the third was obtained on Boxing Day, when Accrington played at Anfield-road, and drew £408. Of course, the other League games brought in trifling sums varying from £250 to £350, but to call it a good “gate” the Everton treasurer and his assistant most have turned the fourth hundred. And people wonder at Everton getting so many men and paying for them.
For some reason or other, a certain section of the Everton spectators took a delight in hurling insults at Mr. Sudell, who was umpire for North End. I do not know why, for his decisions were 50 per cent, more fair than the modem twelfth man; and the same may also be said of Mr. Stockton, who officiated on the other side the field. It is not very generous to hoot and yell at gentleman who is on the field, especially when there is no cause for it.
The Everton people took their defeat on Saturday with very good grace, and said very little about it, only that North End were the best team on the day’s form, and deserved to win. It was undoubtedly a great disappointment, but Mr. Barclay and Mr. Molyneux took the proper view of it, and gave their opponents every credit. It speaks volumes for the North End defence to prevent a team like Everton scoring against them during three hours’ play.
DOIG AND FA CUP TIE
Sunderland Daily Echo and Shipping Gazette - Tuesday 13 January 1891
An impression has got, abroad in certain circles that Doig is not eligible to play in the Cup tie on Saturday, and that Everton-have written to the effect that they intend to enter a protest against him. I may say that the Sunderland Club have not received my communication from the, Liverpool club about eligibility to play, or, for the matter of that, regarding any other player in the club. When Doig signed for Sunderland he was under suspension by the Scottish Association, and therefore could not play, and, what is more, did not do so until he came to this town. I do not as a rule pay heed to rumours of an airy character, but as this one has assumed a definite shape it is well for it to disposed of at once. Whatever differences existed between the Sunderland Club and their captain have been amicably settled, and Johnny has signed the professional form to play for them next reason. This the first time that Auld has signed a professional form, and he remains an amateur no longer, although it is a very short step from Scottish amateurism to English professionalism.
NORTH V SOUTH
Liverpool Mercury - Tuesday 13 January 1891
BRODIE NETS ON TRAIL
This important contest, looked upon by all interested in Association football as an international trail match, took place yesterday on the Town-Ground, Nottingham, belonging to the Notts Forest Club, the executive of which had made capital arrangements. The ground, considering the hard weather, was in a very good condition, and not very slippery. The goal nets introduced by Mr. J.A Brodie, of Liverpool, were used, and were considered by the goalkeeper a very useful introduction. The only alternation in the teams announced was that Albert Smith, the amateur right half of the Notts Forest Club, who was in the reserve, played centre half in place of Holt, of Everton, who was injured in the match with Preston North End on Saturday. G. Howarth, of Accrington, the reserve centre half, an telegraphed for on Sunday night by Mr. S.W. Widdowson the honorary secretary of the selection committee, but he was unable to come. Under the circumstances, Smith being on the spot, was asked to play, and completely justified the honour done him. The game was not particularly exciting. The North team was cleverer than the South, and eventually won by 3 goals to nil, scored in the first half, which curiously, was contested on more even lines than the second half, during which no score was made. The galliant and clever defence of Wilkinson in goal, however, prevented the North forwards from getting through, although they were continually shooting with direct aim and good intention. Each player in the North team did his share, but Chadwick, Geary, Townsley, Earp, and Smith attracted most notice. Goodall was rather selfish and Albert Brown, in consequence, had not so much opportunity as he ought to have had. Toone had only one really troublesome shot to stop, which was from the foot of Offer at the commencement of the second half. Winckworth was the best of the Southern halves, and Ingram of the backs. Cotterill and Brann played pretty well in the first half, but did not get pass Shelton much in the second. Sandilands beat Barton occasionally, but the South forwards were on the whole completely held in check, and the North backs had an easy task. The teams faced each other, before 4,000 people at 2.35 as follows;- North; G. Toone (Notts), goal; J. Earp (Notts Forest), and T. Underwood (Stoke), backs; J. Barton (Blackburn Rovers), A. Smith (Notts Forest), and A. Shelton (Notts), half-backs; A. Brown (Aston Villa) and J. Goodall (Derby), right wing; F. Geary (Everton), centre; E. Chadwick (Everton) and J. Townley (Blackburn), left wing. South; L.R. Wilkinson (Old Caerthusians) goal; W.C. Wells (Swifts) and F.M. Ingram) (Old Wykehamists), backs; A.H. Hosack (Cambridge University), W.R. Winckworth (Old Westminsters) and E. Shaw (Marlow), half-backs; R. R. Sandilands (Old Westminsters), and H. Offer (Royal Arsenal), left wing; A.G Henfrey (Cambridge University), centre; G.H. Cottrill (Old Brightonians) and G. Brann (Swifts), right wing. Umpires; North, Mr.S W. Widdowson (Notts Forest); South, Mr. N.L. Jackson (Corinthians). Referee; Mr. J.C. Clegg (Sheffield). There was no wind to assist either side when Geary started the game. Passing between the North centre and left immediately took the ball in front of Wilkinson, where it was left for Goodall to shoot through as Wilkinson ran out and slipped. However, the Derby County player kicked wildly over the bar, through not six yards from it. Midfield play followed, but the North early showed superior resource. Their left wing passed Hossack, but Townsley, who shot and struck the bar, was given offside. Henfrey got away but was checked by Underwood. Brann secured the ball, but Henfrey breasted outside when it was centred. A rate to and fro each set of forwards was resultless, Earp stopping Sandilands and Offer, and after a few minutes in midfield, Geary, Goodall, and Brown rushed upon the Southern goal, which was desperately defeated by Ingram, Wells, and Wilkinson. The latter sent a weak shot back to Geary’s feet, and that player contrived to push the ball through thus scoring the first goal. This good fortune was almost succeeded by another in favour of the North Brown cleverly passing across the goal to Chadwick, who sent in a terrific shot, which hit the left post and bounded back into play. The Northernest had much the best of the play forward, pressing hard round the Southern goal. Brown again distinguished himself up the right, passing beautifully to Chadwick who was unable to get his shot in. The last-named player, however, a minute later received a pretty pass from Goodall, and screwed it beautifully through scoring the second point for the North. Three minutes had only elapsed before Wilkinson was forced to save his goal at the expense of a corner,. Townley took the place and sent in well in front of the goal, where Geary eventually shot past Wilkinson, scoring the third point. The remainder of the first half was in favour of the North, for although Sandilands, Henfrely and Brann occasionally raced away; Underwood and Earp did not allow Toone to be called on. Crossing over the North were leading by 3 goals to nothing, and Wilkinson had a warm time of it immediately on the game being resumed, Geary, Townsley, and Chadwick each shooting straight at the goalkeeper within the first two minutes. Wilkinson was safe and presently Sandilands, helped by Shaw and Offer, made for the other end, but though Offer looked like scoring with a fast low shot Toone threw himself full length at the ball and put it into touch. The corner kick was useless. Play of an open character succeeded the goal kick, but, gradually forcing the Southerners back, Geary and his wings besieged Wilkinson, who, with Ingram and Wells had a lively time shots were continually sent in, but nothing came amiss to the Old Corthusian goalkeeper. He had to give many corners the Northerns bringing up their total of flag kicks to ten before the whistle sounded for the finish. Towards the close of the game it was very noticeable that the ball did not go much on the North right wing, where Goodall had occasionally done some clever things, but he did not combine with his Aston Villa partner, Albert Brown as he ought to have done. Toone was only once called on in the last 20 minutes. Sandilnds being alone in an attempt to score which was well meant. It was remarkable that the Southerners saved themselves from a severe defeat, but Winckworth fell back between Wells and Ingram and Wilkinson dealt with the ball so well that nothing could be scored by the North in the second half, play being tame towards the finish. The result-North 3 goals, South nil- does not indicate the game, which was greatly in favour of the North all through.
FOOTBALL NOTES, GOSSIP, AND SPORTS AND PASTIMES.
Preston Herald - Wednesday 14 January 1891
It will be admitted on all hands that North End performed a capital feat—one worthy of their best days when they beat Everton at Liverpool on Saturday afternoon, and thus rendered it possible that Everton may not after all become possessors of the title now held by North End of League Champions for the season 1890-91, and thereby holders of the challenge cup which was to be presented to the Deepdale representatives on Monday evening. Since North End on their own ground defeated Everton in the earlier part of the season, have been told by ardent supporters of the “toffee’’ team that such defeat would amply atoned for at the Anfield-road enclosure when January 10th arrived. North End have perhaps not gone to the extent of asserting that they were certain of pulling off the double event, but we believe several of the team and the executive have had a quiet faith that it might be accomplished. And the 10th of January has come and gone, the double event has come off, and now the Evertonians are in doubts whether, after the all, the Cup will come to Liverpool but find a resting place in Blackburn instead. Considering the way in which Everton have been playing this season, and the uncertain form of North End, especially in League matches away from home, their success on Saturday was a very fine performance, and we heartily congratulate Mr. Sudell and the team upon it. Everyone agrees that they played to win, and victory crowned their efforts.
According to all accounts the best team won on Saturday, and the score obtained is said not to really represent the merits of the two elevens on the afternoon’s play. The form of Everton was a disappointment—and a very been disappointment, too, the thousands of Dicky Sams who were present—whilst that displayed by North End came as a surprise to their opponents and almost everybody else. The very fact that they were playing against the club who were confident, or nearly so, of wresting from them the League Cup seemed to inspire North End with increased energy and playing power. They commenced the fray as it bent on winning, and when their forwards had once penetrated the home defence the Deepdale backs set themselves to prevent the downfall of Trainer’s charge, and also to make frequent and vigorous dispatches of the leather into Everton quarters. As a contemporary says, Everton were thrown on the defence at the outset, and the superb visiting half-backs upset the home forwards’ combination, whilst Ross, Holmes, and Trainer were always equal to any raids on goal As the game went on the Everton attack improved, but the three inner forwards kept play too much to themselves, Milward especially getting few opportunities. The shooting, too, was generally bad, and it was galling to the home supporters to witness the repeated chances missed, in the second half more particularly. The Everton half-backs were not up to their usual efficiency. Parry being the most successful, but none ever flagged or shirked work. Hannah was cool and safe, whilst Doyle prevented Gordon and J. Drummond shining very greatly. Jardine played a grand game, and the shot that beat him would have baffled the majority of goalkeepers. The strength of North End was in their back play. The exhibition of Stewart and G. Drummond half-back, and Ross and Holmes at back, could hardly be surpassed. Trainer had very little chance showing his ability. Perhaps the feature of play that gave the North End the greater, amount of effectiveness was their long and accurate kicks and passes, and fine heading, their height being an advantage to them in the latter mode of working the ball. The pace was great throughout, and feeling very keen. The match was disastrous in another respect to Everton, as Hannah sprained his ankle, which will be awkward should it prevent him playing against Sunderland in next Saturday’s English Cup tie; The “gate” at Everton on Saturday was a record one, and at sixpence each £489 15s was taken at the gates, which were closed a quarter of an hour before the start, and kept out some 5,000 would-be spectators The next gate to this is also down the credit of North End, at Everton (last season’s League match), whilst the third was obtained on Boxing Day, when Accrington played at Anfield-road, and drew £408. The other games brought in sums varying from £250 to £350 but to call it a good “gate” the Everton treasurer and his assistant must have passed £400. Good business down Everton way for footballers!
A writer in contemporary of to-day (Monday) has the following observations in regard to the North End team for some reason other, a certain section of the Everton spectators took delight hurling insults at Mr. Sudell, who was umpire for North End. I do not know why, for his decisions were 50 per cent, more fair than the modern twelfth man; and the same may also be said of Mr. Stockton, who officiated on the other side the field. It is not very generous to hoot and yell at a gentleman who is on the field, especially when there is cause for it,”
The same writer says;—“understand that Campbell, of North End—the ex-Woolwich Arsenal man—has now signed professional form, and is engaged for five years.
PRESTON NORTH END v. EVERTON.
Preston Herald - Wednesday 14 January 1891
Everton played their last home League match on Saturday, and, as a fitting finale, were opposed by Preston North End. This was practically the match of the season at Anfield, as the issue was a vital one to the Everton Club. Various circumstances favoured the occasion. The weather took a turn of a genial kind hardly to be hoped for, and the sun came and neutralised somewhat the effects of the frost. The enclosure at Anfield was filled to overflowing, and the number present would be upwards of 15,000. Great pains had been taken with the ground, and, though it was still hard and slippery in places, it was rendered in fair playing condition by the aid of ashes, sand, and sawdust Mr. Betts, the referee, declined to say whether the ground was fit for the purposes of a League match, leaving the clubs to move in the matter at the meeting of the League. The teams were as follow: North End.— Trainer, goal; Holmes and Ross, backs: G. Drummond, Hendry, and Stewart, half-backs Gordon, J. Drummond, Campbell, Crossans, and Gallocher, forwards. Everton; Jardine, goal; Hannah and Doyle, backs; Kirkwood, Holt, and Parry, half-backs; Latta, Brady, Geary, Chadwick, and Milward, forwards. It will be seen that North End were still without Kelso and J. Ross, while Crossans appeared for the first time in a League match on their behalf. Hannah won the toss, and Campbell started the game. Parry spoilt Gordon’s run, but the visitors returned to the attack on the left. They were stalled off without much trouble, but a fine kick by Ross gave his forwards another chance, when Gordon, tested Jardine, who was equally to the occasion- North End were persistent, but the home defence behaved well, Hannah, Parry, and Doyle stopping raids. Everton improved on the right, but Ross kicked back. Crossans shooting in and Jardine running and throwing clear. More pressure was put on, and Doyle came finally to the rescue. Geary made a splendid run and pass, but Ross kicked out into touch. Everton were not beaten off, and Geary tried a couple of long shots. Campbell escaped Holt, and wound up a clinking run by shooting long and low, the ball going, just off the post. The home team came near scoring a little later, but found the defence too good. Campbell was dangerous again, until Latta was put into possession, supported by Brady, a fine shot being grandly spoilt by Holmes. An examination of boots was now resorted to, with the result that Chadwick was requested to change his new ones. On resuming, Everton attacked hotly. Chadwick shot in hard and straight, and, in stopping the ball, Ross seemed to have fisted it, but no notice was taken. Everton left wing continued to trouble Holmes and G. Drummond without advantage. Play then went to the other end by means off strong kicking, and after Gordon had put behind, Crossans beat Jardine out of a scrimmage, to the great delight of the North End supporters, at the end of a quarter of hour’s play. Everton quickly resumed vigour, and Kirkwood passed to Geary, who shot, but found Trainer about. Then corner fell to Everton, and Ross ultimately sent play into Everton’s quarters. The defence continued good, and Latta soon went away; and Geary, beating Hendry, the ball was punched over the bar for a corner. Preston North End grew determined, and for a long time the home team were in trouble, during which critical period Hannah was ever setting his men an example in coolness. Latta ran finely, and passed across, but unluckily no one was handy to take the ball. Hannah next kicked over to Milward, who shot high above the bar, and Doyle having sent back from Gallagher, the Interval came with North End leading by goal to nil. Considerable activity was evinced in midfield on resuming, and twice Mr. Betts threw up for interruptions. Doyle put his right wing in on advantageous position, a fine shot being grandly spoilt by Ross. Everton went up again, but failed at the critical moment. Excitement ran high, and scientific play was not so prominent as it might have been. The Everton right and North End left indulged in give-and-take play, and Jardine saved from Campbell, whilst Gordon put behind soon afterwards, after Stewart’s kick. Hannah came up to the assistance of Latta, who ran on, but offside spoilt the effort. Everton attacked in better style now, and Ross several times kicked out, the lengthy siege enabling North End to display their grand defensive resources. Until ten minutes of time the home team were pressing more or less. Then J. Drummond shot hard, as did the left wing, but Jardine cleared. As a last effort, Milward, who had gone centre, dashed down, only to see the ball kicked out, and Everton were forced to retire beaten. Score; - Score; Everton None, North End 1.
EVERTON V SUNDERLAND
Liverpool Mercury - Thursday 15 January 1891
The team to represent Everton in this English Cup tie, which will be played at Sunderland on Saturday next, has been chosen as follows -Angus, goal; Hannah and Doyle, backs; Kirkwood, Holt, and Parry, half-backs; Latta, Geary, Robertson, Chadwick, and Milward, forwards Reserves, McLean and a Campbell. Mr. W. L. Jope has been appointed referee.
SUNDERLAND V. EVERTON.
Sunderland Daily Echo and Shipping Gazette - Thursday 15 January 1891
Saturday will be a red-letter day in the history of football in the North of England, and with fine weather the Everton Cup tie will probably draw the largest which has ever been seen in these parts. Since the draw has been rife as to the likely result, and in football circles all over England the encounter is much talked about. The teams have met four times in all, and the Wearsiders have been declared victors thrice, all played at Sunderland; whilst have won once at Liverpool by one goal, so that there is very little between the teams. Many good judges consider that the winner of this tie will lift the Cup. The ground is in splendid condition, and has been well rolled. For the convenience of the public the North-Eastern Railway are running excursions from Middlesbrough, Stockton, Darlington, Hartlepool, Bishop Auckland, Newcastle, and Blyth and Tyne District. Many enthusiasts also express their intention from coming from the Midlands and Lancashire. Since the Blackburn match great improvements have been made to the stands, so that there is ample room for everyone to see the match. The kick-off is fixed_ for 2.30 prompt; Everton will arrive by the 1.35 train morrow, and will make the Roker Hotel their headquarters.
BLUE REVIEW
January 17 th 1891. The Liverpool Courier.
With the setting of the sun on the evening of Saturday last, the final scene, so far as League fixtures are concerned, was enacted at Anfield, and how great the interest was that centred in the all important contest between Everton and Preston North End was shown by the enormous crowd of 16,000 or more which struggle for admittance to the spacious enclosure. The supporters of the local club were hopeful, but by no means sanguine, that the Deepdale reverse would be effaced, and that the claim to championship honours would thereby be strengthened, but fate ordained otherwise, and it fell to the lot of the North-Enders to accomplish what no other team has done. The close of the day found them the proud winners of a dual and “bloodless” victory, for at Deepdale the verdict was in their favour by two to nothing, and in the final struggle, although the margin was reduced, it was one to nil. How the match was won and lost is now a matter of history, and as summaised by a free but unbiased critic, it may truthfully be reiterated that “Everton” did not play up to form, and putting sympathy in the background, it must candidly be admitted that the best team won –at all events the best team on the day. Although close upon thirty minutes elapsed before Crossans, during a determined attack close in goal, put the ball through and decided the issue, barely five minutes had elapsed before the eye solved the problem. The Everton backs defended well, and Jardine could not be blamed for not arresting a shot which owing to the crowd of players surging in front of him, it was impossible even to see, but elsewhere there was a continuous lack of combination, resulting in erratic passing such has perhaps never before been witnessed on the part of the Everton team. More frequently than otherwise the well-positioned North Enders had the ball placed at their very toes, and were thus enabled to monopolise the lion share of the game. Latta who singular to say, was very feebly supported by his old colleague, was unable to make headway against Ross, who never perhaps displayed such consummate act and skill as in this memorable match. Parry play was the redeeming feature of the half-back division who were outshone by that so ably let by G. Drummond and Howart, the latter of whom bid fair, prove a most valuable acquisition to the North End team. There was throngous a marked contrast in the play of the two teams, for whilst that of the winners was vigorous and full of confidence, the efforts of the homesters betrayed a conspicuous degrees of embarrassment and consequent uncertainty of action which culminated in defeat. But whilst the Prestonians deserved to win, they were nevertheless somewhat fortunate in doing so, for although Geary like his colleagues, was not seen at his best he sent in one shot which only missed by the nearest shave, and was a high man only by a superhuman effort could, but the ball passed outside and as it was the favouring chance, the fate of Everton was sealed. In the light of subsequent events, however, the championship is still an open, and with a win at Burnley all may still be well, Lets hope. More cherry news, however, came to hand on the return of the team that represented Everton against Stoke Swifts, although the result was less decisive than in the Anfield match, which the homesters won by five goals to nil. Still Everton had all the best of Saturday's encounter, and without being unduly stretched gained the line by three goals to nil.
FOOTBALL CHIPS.
Liverpool Football Echo.
Everton prospects as League Champions are not so rosy now as they were two weeks ago. Preston North End put a damper on their spirits, and no mistake. It is getting quite evident that Everton cannot win when a big issue is at stake. For instance, look at Stoke and Blackburn Rovers last year, and also last Saturday's defeat. The North End boys played a winning game from the start while the Salmon and Blue never seemed to get into their proper stride. Parry was the best of the home side, and we question whether Mr. Gordon has ever received such a showing up since he started playing. If by chance Gordon and Parry, Mr. Daniel Doyle and showed fine form, was always in attendance. Have you ever seen a set of forwards play worse, Geary and Brady especially, who both played like novices. Latta tried to do a lot, but Jack Ross had laid himself out to watch Dumbarton man, and that is the reason he did not shine. George Drummond, on the North End side, played a grand man. The old Un is a long way from being dour. Stewart and Ross were the heroes, both playing great games. The soldiers was a find indeed for Preston. The North End introduced a new forward in their ranks in the person of Crossan, late of the Celtic. He is also a good find, and should be a permanent in the North End ranks. It is no easy matter for a person to name the winner of the League Championship. Perhaps the present holders may have something to say on the question before it is decided. Their victory on Saturday last over the favorites at Anfield has caused some disappointment to Evertonians, although the homesters have not lost heart yet. The question of an umpire keeping off the field of play and near to the touch line has troubled not a few since Saturday last: but seeing there is no rule on this point, they must simply grin and abide it. It is reported that Doyle has signed a two year's' engagement for Everton, together with several other players. Good business this; and we wish both players and club success. Everton were successful against the Stoke Swifts for the second time this season, winning the return match last Saturday by 3 goals to 1. Everton are evidently very popular in the Potteries, judging by the attendance which around the match. A couple of lines on the posters which met the rane of the visitors were as fellows: - Another treat in store. “Meeting of the champions juniors –Everton v Stoke Swifts.” And the crowd was not inapporated, either. The Everton team have an excellent impression of Joe Lothouse of the Blackburn Rovers. The Rovers and Everton teams met at Crewe Station, the former returning from the futile victor over West Bromwich Albion, and the Toffeeites making for Liverpool. Of course, every footballer knows Joe Lofthouse, and he heartily shook hands with most of the Evertonian. Joe say he never gave a heartier shout than when he heard the result of the North End v Everton League match. “Not because of any animosity, you know,” said he, but because it has given us the opening for the League competition we have long been waiting for, and of which we intend to take full advantage. We shall sail right away to the top of the League now.
THE EVERTON MATCH.
Sunderland Daily Echo and Shipping Gazette - Saturday 17 January 1891
We are informed that the field in Newcastle-road has been cleared of snow this morning, and the match will take place. During the morning numbers of men were busily engaged with shovels and carts in removing the heavy fleecy covering from the ground and stands. The Everton team are staying at the Roker Hotel, an Echo reporter, who visited them this morning found the players in the highest spirits and confident. Their team, as finally selected last night, will be as follows:—Goal, J. Angus D. McLean and D. Doyle; half-backs, D. Kirkwood, Holt, and C. Parry; forwards, A. Latta, Geary, Hope-Robertson, A. Chadwick, and A. Millward. Our reporter was informed that Everton had not protested against Doig and did not intend to do so; that they could, if they liked, protest against Wilson, Auld, and Miller (whom they seemed to think would be played against them), but that they are sportsmen in Liverpool, and would accept the verdict even if Sunderland beat them by a dozen goals. Jardine is disqualified from keeping goal, having played for Bootle in an English tie at Carlisle, while A. Hannah and Brady are injured, and will therefore be merely spectators.
-WE HEAR AND SEE—
Lancashire Evening Post - Saturday 17 January 1891
That the North End’s win over Everton last Saturday has raised them considerably in the estimation of all followers of the game ; that the North End played one of their old-fashioned games, and if they will keep it up the English Cup ought find its 1890-91 resting place on the banks of the Ribble. That the team which played on Saturday can only improved in one section, the inside right position; that last Saturday J. Drummond was the poorest man the field; that he has fairly got slated, some of the remarks being bit too strong; that he was out of his place, and those who put him on the right wing were just as much to blame as he was: that in consequence of his presence, J. Gordon was not of much use. That the Scotch opinions of Crossan, which we gave in our last Saturday’s issue, were about on a par with others we have seen ; that since he joined the North End, Crossan has certainly shown sufficient speed to justify his inclusion in any first-class team ; that last Saturday he played really fine passing and dodging game until he was kicked on the knee; he and Gallacher reminded one of the old Drummond-Dewhurst left wing ; that Stewart last Saturday played a really brilliant game, and in him the North End have secured a gem ; that after the game a number of Evertonians were overheard to say, “Stewart is the best half-back that ever played on our ground ; we’ll have him next season that no doubt the Everton Executive would like to get him, but they won’t. That the Everton players were bent on seeing if Campbell had anything in him—whether he was soft or not; that they found he was game, and if anyone else doubts it let them ask Holt, Geary, Hannah, or Doyle; that the game had not been long in progress before Holt and Campbell had an altercation, after which they understood each other, the result being the complete discomfiture of the Evertonian. That the Everton players did not conduct themselves in the best of manners; that one of the team used some disrespectful threatening language to Mr. Sudell and he will no doubt hear further of it ; that the referee was told what had taken place, and reprimanded the player ; that it was quite within Mr. Betts’s power to have sent him off the field, but did not; that he acted wisely in not doing so, but if the matter is reported to the Association Mr. Sudell, the man will not be so lightly dealt with ; that two of the Everton players were continually doing all in their power to annoy Mr. Sudell; that they threw the ball at him, and went for him several times ; that if the Evertonians are desirous of gaining the respect and good fellowship of other clubs, they will well to dispense with a host of last Saturday’s petty meanness.
Our Liverpool correspondent writes -That Everton will not soon recover from shock of last Saturday’s defeat; that they never for a moment contemplated the result of the great match; that they could not conceive how Preston people could be so confident over what looked to them a foregone conclusion as a defeat; that for all that they do not depreciate the victory in the very slightest degree; that they are almost enthusiastic in praise for their old foes ; that Ross came in for especial praise; that he deserves all he can receive; that it was an article of Everton faith that Latta could always make circles round the great Jack ; that this is now felt to be not an article of faith, but a very heresy ; that Latta was always ready to get away when a chance offered, but never could find a passage; that when Stewart was done with, and that was very rarely, there was always the Ross obstacle; that only once did Latta beat the great Prestonian; that the performance of Stewart was quite a revelation ; that his coolness in such an exciting event singular to a degree; that it was this icy coolness of the North End all round which must have chilled their opponents.
That Geary only excited derision, and never got really dangerous all through; that Chadwick was dreadfully selfish, and egregiously blundering in his shots; that Milward's removal to Centre did not come off against Accrington : that Great Marlow, as he is dubbed, meant well no doubt, and that his dashing run would have been equally sensational with of his Accrington effort if had been to brush Jack Ross aside as easily as he floored McLellan ; that the boot was on the other leg this time ; that Ross unceremoniously tumbled the youngster in the sand and sawdust, and the last dying flicker of Everton hope was rudely extinguished ; that Brady has been shunted for to-day’s big game at Sunderland ; that it is not a wise move. The the North Enders made very marry after the match; that there was quite a demonstration at the Star when cheers were called for the champions; that Hannah may play at Sunderland, but it is doubtful; that he twisted his ankle in the closing minutes of the game; that McLean will take his place if necessary; that Sunderland could not desire a better opportunity of winning renown than they will have today. That the principal topic of conversation at Blackburn this week has been the manner in which the League has dealt with the protests against the state of the ground in several recent matches; that before the meeting it was generally believed in the town that none of them would have to be replayed, because if the conditions were good enough at Everton, when the Rovers were beaten, it was in their opinion, quite evident that they would be good enough in the later matches. That the indignation of Blackburn people was so deep for words when they found that the League had gone back on a former decision, and ordered the Rovers to replay two wins, while the other clubs in the running for the Championship had losses to replay; that unfair as this arrangement is, the Rovers would not grumble if they might be allowed to meet Everton again at Anfield-road; that the League is likely to hear something drop over this business before it is done with, especially if it should unfortunately happen that the Rovers lose one or both the replayed matches; that there were plenty of people ready to declare that the League had driven the first nail into its coffin by such a manifestly unfair decision.
That in the Lancashire Senior Cup competition Burnley Union Star have the dubious honour of having been drawn with Everton, the match to be played at Burnley; that owing to the consideration offered by Everton it is expected the match will be played at Everton.
SUNDERLAND v. EVERTON.
The Referee - Sunday 18 January 1891
This match took place at Sunderland, nearly 20,000 people being present in anticipation of a tough game. The home club lost the toss. The state of the ground being very fair, the visitors kicked off, and the home team immediately attacked, and several fruitless shot were sent in. A visit was then made to the home end, where Doig saved a shot from Chadwick. Even play followed, but eventually Campbell got possession, and shot a splendid goal for Sunderland. On kicking off from midfield, Sunderland were again to the fore, but nothing further occurred up to half-time, when the score stood—Sunderland, one; Everton, nil. The home club restarted, and immediately pressed, the Evertonians only just saving, Angus getting rid of two shots in splendid fashion. Sunderland continued to press, but the defence proved impregnable, and Sunderland won by one goal to nil.
SUNDERLAND V EVERTON
January 19, 1891. The Birmingham Daily Post
The tie between these clubs at Sunderland chatted an enormous amount of public interest, and the game was witnessed by fully 20,000 spectators. Sunderland were thought to possess a reasonable chance of success, as recently in a League match on their own ground they had defeated Everton. Considering the score weather the grounds was in fairly good condition. From the first the struggle was keen and exciting both sides striving their utmost. After the game had been progress about ten minutes Sunderland began to press, and, amid tremendous cheering, Campbell kicked a goal for the. The Everton forwards tried hard to equalise matters, and made several desperate attacks, but the Sunderland backs were always equal to the occasion. Towards the close of the first half the play was all in Everton's quarters, and the goalkeeper had several times to use his hands, when the referee's whistle blew for the change of ends Sunderland led by 1 goal to nil. In the second half the home team still appeared to have the best of it, but the play was scarcely so exciting as before. Neither side was able to score again, and so Sunderland were left with a highly creditable victory of one goal to nil. Football Notes.
For thoroughly consistent form it would be hard to find a better example than, the Sunderland club. In their two League matches with Everton they have lost and won by a goal, and on Saturday, the scoring was the same, Everton being once more ousted from the English Cup competition by one point to nothing. The winners had considerably the best of the game, and Everton, and may thank a remarkably fine defence for averting greater disaster, as three-fourths of the play was in the strangers' quarters. Murray, the leviathan Third Lanark man, completely obstructed the glory of the usually brilliant Everton right wing, and the Sunderland forwards excelled themselves in cleverness, though it must be admitted that their shooting was weak and erratic. Many people will consider Sunderland safe to win the English cup, but there are at least half a dozen powerful rivals who may overthrow them. Their prospects are, however, undeniably bright if fortune favours them in the draws.
SUNDERLAND 1 EVERTON 0
January 19 1891. The Liverpool Mercury
Everton were destined to meet Sunderland in the competition, and at the matter had to be decided on the banks of the Wear, where Everton had suffered a narrow defeat so recently as the 20 TH of the month this tie was one of the hardest, and excited the greatest interest of the whole 16. Everton, without Hannah who is still lame from the injury he received in the Preston North End match, and also minus Jardine, whose assistance rendered to Bootle against Carlisle made him ineligible left Liverpool at 8-30 on Friday morning and arrived in Sunderland just before two, where they had a mixed reception, though the cheers drowned the groans, by about 8,000 spectators. The utmost stir was created in Sunderland and neighborhood over the renewed struggle between the great rivals. Excursion trains were run from the surrounding towns, and by the time the start was effected the ground was packed with a crowd of about 18,000. The teams and officials were as follows: - Everton: - Angus, goals, McLean, and Doyle, backs, Kirkwood, Holt (captain), and Parry, half-backs, Latta, Geary Robertson, Chadwick, and Milward, forwards. Sunderland: - Doig, goal, Porteous, and Oliver, backs, Wilson, Auld, and Murray half-backs, Harvie, Smith, Campbell, Scott, and Hannah (d), forwards. Referee Mr. W.H.Jope; umpires, Messrs J.H.Strawson and J.Tillotson.
Everton won the toss, but there was little wind, and so advantage was not very great. Campbell kicked off, shortly before half past two. Auld stopped Chadwick and Milward. They, however, secured a couple of throws in, from the second of which the ball was sent to Harvie who shot to one side of the post. A visit was now paid to the home half in which Kirkwood was conspicuous. Campbell again, and Murray sent well to the front, causing McLean to kick into touch. The ball being well centred by Wilson, Campbell and Smith in turn had dangerous shots. From a goalkick Doyle changed the venue. Good passing was witnessed between Latta and Geary. Porteous intervened, and transferred to the home right wing, the consequence being a grand run by Smith and Harvie, both of whom did their best to score. The defence, however, was not to be broken just yet, and the ball was smartly run into the home half byLatta and Geary and centred. Once more Porteous proved the saviour of his side, averting danger at a critical moment, Scott and his partner ran down, and Hannah, took aim, but his shot was too high. By good combined play the visitors halves cleared, and Holt landed the ball in the home territory. He was stopped by Porteous. After Oliver had rendered himself conspicuous for a piece of nice defence, Geary was penalised for a foul. The free kick again gave Sunderland the upper hand, and the Everton half was invaded in vain. Chadwick and Milward removed the play. Doig, however, threw away. A good run by Smith and Harvie was well centred, and a throw in ensued for Everton, followed by two similar points for Sunderland. Murray obtained a throw in, from which grand play resulted, and Campbell at length scored the first goal 15 minutes from the commencement with a ‘'daisycutter'' The goal was a surperb one, and Angus could not be blamed. From the centre kick Everton made several desperate attempts to get on equal terms and both the home backs and Doig were kept busy. Holt was conspicuous for some splendid saving tactics, but fell in the snow, and the ball being worked forward by Harvie was put once more in the visitors goalmouth. Angus fell clinging to the ball, and amid cheers marvelously. A fast run to the other end, resulted in the first corner, for Everton. It was taken by Milward and well placed, but Geary with a clear chance, made a poor shot. A free kick for the visitors was the next item. Doyle took it, and again Everton might have scored, but lost the opportunity. A long drive by Latta went outside. Campbell and Scott next had chances, but Mclean and Doyle kept out the ball. Midfield play became the order of the day. Chadwick by tricky play caused the home halves to retreat. He gave to Geary and the latter shot. The ball seemed about to go through when Porteous kicked it over the bar. A corner of course followed. It was cleared, but a free kick for a foul was awarded to Everton. The ball was put through the home posts. The visitors were under the impression that they had scored, and claimed, but the referee through the ball passed through untouched. Scott and Hannah from the kick led a raid and McLean kicked out. Sunderland still held the advantage by a series of throws in, until Hannah handled, and thus afforded the visitors some relief. Campbell immediately after secured the leather, but the home team were penalised for ‘'hands'' in turn, and Doyle helped the ball well down the field. Latta then obtained possession, and shot wide of the mark. Parry, who sent across to Latta anticipated a long pass by Campbell intended for Harvie, and things looked ominous for the home team, when Murray cleared. Campbell then kicked across the Everton bar. A splendid piece of headwork was witnessed soon afterwards, and from now to the interval play was more or less located in promity to Everton goal. Changing ends with a goal in their favour Sunderland renewed the attack, and Campbell was just about to shoot when Doyle upset him. Campbell returned however, and sent in a fast low shot, which Angus wonderfully saved by giving a corner. Corners for Everton followed, and then then lively work took place in midfield, when Robertson charged Campbell, and had a foul given against him. Then Campbell fouled one of the visitors. After the free kick the home centre forward again got up, and from now the game for Everton was almost altogether a defensive one. They very rarely got over the centre line, and when they did the Sunderland backs proved too many for them, they playing with excellent tact and judgement. A foul was then given for Sunderland through Campbell. Doyle took the free kick, but the return was exceptional smart. Smith next passed to Campbell, but that player was dispossessed when he had a chance. Still the home team pressed, and Hannah made a shot which, Angus saved well. Everton then crossed over for a short time, and Latta made Doig save a warm shot. The latter part was in favour of Sunderland, who won by 1 goal to nil, and confirmed the result of the League match of a month ago. Of course, the defeat of Everton's a sore disappointment, but it is no way a surprise. The two league matches had shown that it was only the advantage of playing at home that formed the dividing lone of two equal teams, and the third game, of the rubber has made assurance doubly sure that Sunderland and Everton are two exceptional even organizations. Sunderland, it will be noticed head had the good fortune to command the services of the identical eleven that had won the League match, while Everton had two or three changes, and this has a factor that told somewhat in favour of the home club. On the whole, Sunderland played the better game on Saturday. Their various department were more accurately balanced than those of Everton; but it was in the first half the home team were superior, the second stage being as even as the failure of either side to score indicates. The game was a fast one, and carried =on amidst much tumult from the vast assembly, but though play was energetic roughness was rare and, fouls infrequent. The Everton forwards were shockingly weak, and never did anything great. Milward and Chadwick alone combining will. Robertson was a moderate centre, thanks chiefty to Auld; and the right wing were decidedly of f colour, Geary tried hard. He looked for work and had plenty to do, but he was seldom dangerous. Murray proving a veritable stumbling block, recently forceful of his injured leg, when intercepted by the determined Oliver. The Everton half-backs however, were seen to much advantage. Kirkwood played better then he had done during the past few weeks, and the middle line was strong all across. Doyle and McLean made sterling backs, the latter being almost as smart as he was in the Wolverhampton Wanderers match. Angus kept goal, splendidly and one save in particular, when he threw himself on the ball and clean the post, evoked a burst of applause. Doig had very few shots to attend to, so well was he shielded by Porteous, and Oliver, though neither of the home backs compared favorably with those of the visitors. The halfbacks play of Murray, Auld, and Wilson was again the chief seat of Sunderland's strength. Murray was the hero this time, and not Wilson, who was not so successful as previously against Chadwick and Milward. The forwards play of Sunderland was another than that of the visitors . Campbell doing clever things at centre but like Everton the vanguard shot badly. Everton took their beating with good grace, and, to the surprise of the Wearside, made the welkin ring with song and on their drive from the Roker Hotel to the station. The ‘'gate'' realised £416. Parry has been asked to play for Wales against Ireland . The team will be chosen this evening.
SUNDERLAND v. EVERTON.
Sunderland Daily Echo and Shipping Gazette - Monday 19 January 1891
VICTORY OF SUNDERLAND.
By general consent most important tie in the round was that between Sunderland and Everton, which was set down for decision on Saturday on the ground of the former Newcastle-road. Both clubs have made themselves widely known by their splendid performances, and so evenly did they appear to be matched that the issue remained a very open one. The teams were as follows: Sunderland: Goal, J. E. Doig; backs, T. Porteous and J. Oliver; half-backs, H. Wilson. J. R. Auld, and J. Murray forwards, J. Harvie and J. Smith (right), J. Campbell (centre), D. Hannah and J. Scott (left). Everton; - Goal, J. Angus; backs, D. McLean and D. Doyle; half-backs, D. Kirkwood, J. Holt, and C. Perry: forwards, A. Latta and F. Geary (right), H. Robertson (centre), A. Chadwick and A. Milward (left). Referee—Mr. W. H. Jope Umpires—Mr. Tillotson (Birmingham) and Mr. Strawson (Lincoln).
A heavy fall of snow during the night caused some fear lest the game should be postponed. However, the officials quickly had a gang of men at work with shovels and some 20 carts in which to carry away the snow, and in the course of a few hours it was announced that the stands were cleared and the ground in splendid condition. The various excursions from different parts of the North of England each brought their contingent of spectators, and as the fateful hour approached a record gate seemed certainly to have been established. The number of those present was estimated at about 20,000.
THE GAME.
Everton won the toss. At 2.26 p.m. Campbell set the ball in motion from the lower end of the field. Auld, by a good piece of play, stopped an attempt by the visitors' left to break away. They, however, secured a couple of throws in, from the second of which the ball was sent to the top end by Campbell, who gave to Harvie. He was some distance off, but he unhesitatingly drove the ball before him. It passed to one side of the post, and Angus did not even move to intercept it. A visit was now paid to the home halt, in which Kirkwood was conspicuous. A good run by Smith and Harvie was well centred, and a throw in ensued for Everton, followed by two similar points for Sunderland. Further play at home right wing was against the visitors. The ball was shot across to the other wing, and here Murray obtained a throw-in, from which grand play resulted in a centre. Campbell at length secured, and, amid a terrific crescendo of cheers, scored the
FIRST GOAL
to the credit of Sunderland exactly 15 minutes from the commencement. In spite of the cold and snow hats went in the air, sticks followed, and the enthusiasm became immense. The goal was a superb one, and Angus could not be blamed if he succumbed to such a ground-grazer. From the central kick Everton made several desperate attempts to get on equal terms, and both the home backs and Doig were kept busy. Holt was conspicuous for some splendid saving tactics, but he fell in the snow, and the ball being worked forward by Harvie, was jammed once more in the visitors' goal month. Angus secured, and was rolled over. He fell, clinging to the ball, amid deafening cheers and counter cheers, and for a few moments the fate of the Everton goal seemed to be sealed a second time. However, the danger was averted, and a fast run to the other end resulted in
THE FIRST CORNER
for Everton, which seemed to put more spirit into the partisans. It was taken by Milward and well placed, but Geary, with a clear chance, made an abominable shot, and sent behind once more, at which the spectators broke forth into ironical applause. A tree kick for the visitors was the next item. It was taken by Doyle and again Everton might have scored but lost the opportunity. A long drive by Latta went outside, Doig failing to reach it with the tips of his fingers. Showers of hail began to fall when the home right wing broke through and carried the ball into their opponents' half. Both Campbell and Scott had chances, but more by luck than skill the ball was kept out by McLean and Doyle. Midfield play had become the order of the day. Chadwick by tricky play caused the home halves to retreat. He gave to Geary, and the latter shot. The ball seemed about to go through, when Porteous kicked it
OVER HIS OWN BAR.
A corner of course followed. It was cleared, but a free-kick for foul was awarded to Everton. It was right in the home goal mouth. After two or three false starts the ball was put through the home posts. The visitors were under the impression that they had scored, and their impression was shared by a large number of spectators. As a matter of fact, however, the ball in its passage between the posts did not touch anyone, and thus a goal was not allowed to Everton. Auld again came to the rescue at a critical moment, and the resulting exchanges ended in the ball being banged behind the uprights. Angus soon after ran out and footed the ball away. Hannah headed back, and with his partner Scott maintained a merry game of hide and seek. Three of the home forwards again made at Angus, just as Murray sent a shot into the goal mouth. Angus, however, evaded them, and one of the home forwards falling, the ball rolled harmlessly out of play. At halftime the score was still— Sunderland 1 goal Everton Nil.
After the usual interval, Robertson, at 3.18., resumed the game. Sunderland were now playing from their favourite end, and there was every reason to believe that they would improve their lead. An immediate invasion of the home half began, but it was only momentary, and Auld quickly sent to the front, but a pass by Campbell was not utilised, and after some further play Latta and Geary changed the venue, being helped by bad miss on the part of a home player, which evoked cries of "Oh!" Each side had a throw-in, Geary on the last occasion being the offender. Campbell secured and gave a lightning-like shot, which caused Angus to drop his full length and fall on the ball it was all done in a moment, and was
A MAGNIFICENT EXHIBITION
of offensive and defensive tactics. The ball was cleared by the Everton custodian and returned, but cleared again, passing at length into the possession of Smith and Harvie, near mid-field. McLean seemed to be apprehensive, and without so much attempting to save, he yielded a corner, which, however, came to naught. A run up by the Everton left was checked by Porteous, but at the cost of a throw-in, which was repeated a moment later. Porteous headed away, and Wilson helped the ball still further down the field. Here Robertson yielded a free-kick for a foul, and the home right wing made considerable progress. The ball was transferred to Campbell, who ought to have scored, but being surrounded and hard pressed he put the ball over the bar. The same player soon after was shoved off the ball by an opponent. A foul was claimed, and the exchanges went on at the lower end of the field, the visitors apparently being utterly unable to make any progress. However, "the visitors were not done with yet, and Doig had to jump at one tall shot. He repulsed, but the ball hung ominously near the Wearside uprights, and there was a thankful exclamation of
“IT'S ALL RIGHT NOW ! "
when Murray kicked down the arena. Some indignation was caused by Perry, who chucked Smith clean over his back. A free kick, of course, followed for a foul and Angus was compelled to handle, throwing out just as Campbell charged him. Another free kick for a similar offence by one of the visitors fell to Sunderland, and
SOME HOT WORK
ensued, the ball been repeatedly raced to the lower end. Harvie fell on the snow, and lay as if stunned. It was thought that he had been seriously hurt, and a cheer went round when he got up and resumed play, although limping painfully. Urgent appeals to the home team to play up were raised, and they were well responded to, but the pace had evidently told on the athletes, and the rate fell off considerably. In the last ten minutes Everton made unceasing but unavailing efforts to get on even terms. The home team on their side secured a couple of corners, neither of which was converted. They, however, pounded away at helpless Everton until the sound of the referential whistle and a great stir announced that all was over, and the game ended in the victory of the home team, the final score being—as before Sunderland 1 goal Everton Nil.
THE BATTLE OF THE BROBDINGNAGIANS.
Athletic News - Monday 19 January 1891
EVERTON V. SUNDEBLAND.
By Lilliput
Seldom has the luck of the draw pulled together two bigger opponents at so early a stage in the prince of contests, and never when the interest in the meeting has been so widespread and universal, so that even out of what is generally accepted as evil much good can come, and although the two north country bigwigs may fancy their lines have not fallen to pleasant places, yet to be the cynosure of all eyes should carry some recompense, and the disagreeable features of the early meeting should be modified greatly by deep, deep gilding of gold. Put the brightest side possible forward, but yet it must be deemed unfortunate, not only for the clubs principally concerned, but also for the competition itself, that Everton-Sunderland should have been drawn out of the hat coupled in the first round, for not only had both clubs reason to think they would go further, but their meeting at a more advanced stage of the competition would have made the “pot” bubble over with boiling and seething excitement. That fickle jade, Fortune, however, is no respecter of persons, and had there needed proof that the drawing for the Cup competition is above suspicion, no bettor could be produced than the meeting of them two clubs. MATTERS METEOROLOGICAL
Various and sundry snow showers made the outlook anything but promising, but the Sunderland Executive were up and doing, cleared off the cold, damp element before it had time to congregate in unwholesome quantities, and Old Sol at last asserted his genial influence, and quickly brushed aside both clouds and snow, too game opening in brilliant sunshine.
THE GROUND
Many fears were expressed that the "bogey man” Cup contests, Mr. Protest, would put in an appearance; but when the ground was examined all fears of such a visit vanished, too turf being fairly soft and pliable, and no more snow present than made falling pleasant. Considering the hard frosts we have had, the Sunderland executive must have been at considerable trouble with their ground, or, unlike other poor mortals, they have had all the temperature, and we have had all the weather.
AN IMMENSE CROWD
How those messes did roll up, shoal upon shoal, and still they came, until the poor districted Sunderland secretary, in his agony, appealed to them to desist. Fully an hour and half before the advertised time for kick-off the eager spectators commenced to throng Newcastle-road, and by 2-15 all available space was occupied to such an extent that an extra baby could not have been squeezed in. And a right jolly, good-natured, and well-behaved body they proved, fully 20,000 strong, the “brogue” of the district and idiom pertaining to more distant and more emerald places being strongly in evidence.
POSITION OF PLAYERS
A mighty shoot proclaimed the advent of Everton into the playing space, which had scarcely died away when uproar signaled the appearance of the home lot. The colours of the two sets of players contrasted nicely, the Liverpudlians adopting a somewhat somber dark shirt with thin amber stripe, while the home lads danced out in a gay and festive red white stripe. Their names were:-Everton;- Angus, goal; Doyle, and McLean, backs; Parry, Holt and Kirkwood, half-backs; Milward, Robertson, Chadwick, Geary, and Latta, forwards. Sunderland; Doig, goal; Oliver, and Porteous, backs; Murray, Auld, and Wilson, half-backs; Scott, Hannah, Campbell, Smith, and Harvey, forwards. Umpries, J.C. Tillotson (Birmingham Association), and J. Henry Strawson (Lincoln City). Referee, W. H. Jope (Wednesbury).
It will be seen that the visitors were seriously handicapped by the absence of Brady and Hannah, while Sunderland put full strength into the field.
THE GAME.
Kicking with the wind, Sunderland at once took a strong lead, the whole of their team placing in the most determined fashion, and the defence were worked hard and continuously, but the game was by no means scientific, too much long kicking and attention to the man being observed. But this was little to be wondered at, considering the circumstances of the game, and the loud and excited crowd, who yelled almost enough to drown thinking. Gradually, however, the home lads put some method into their action, and Angus only just threw away in the nick time, while again and again the home team swooped down upon their opponents' goal, and fifteen minutes from the commencement, from a pass by Hannah, Campbell scored with a beauty, well out of the reach of Angus. Yes, the crowd whispered once again in a truly lusty north country style, but it was evident the success went down badly with the visitors, and for the first time during the game they showed their true style, and a large amount of the forward play that has made them famous in the football world. Geary, Latta, and Chadwick all had long pots at Doig, but they were too far off to prove dangerous, although on one occasion he was beaten and the Sunderland goal only saved by Oliver kicking over the bar and conceding a corner. This advantage was followed by two more of a like character, and the fine determined passing by the whole of the home front rank altered the venue of the fight, and Hannah and Campbell both missed easy chances of scoring, Angus hereabouts doing some clever work in goal, and twice saving splendidly. A good deal of forcible play was indulged in, and it was of a rough and tumble character until Everton, by superior speed, raced to the bottom goal, and were awarded foul close on the line. The kick was smartly taken, and passed through perfect sea of legs without touching anyone, and loud claims for goal were answered in the negative by all the three officals, who were certain and unanimous in their decision, and from what I saw they were distinctly right Sunderland pressed hard, and at half-time were having the best of it, the score reading— Sunderland 1 goal Everton none
With the wind and slight snowstorm brewing, Everton looked to have a good chance, but from the very start of the second half, so superior was the form shown by the home team, that, barring accidents, there looked only one in the hunt. For the first half-hour pressure strong, severe, and continuous was lavished on the Everton goal, and time after time Sunderland should have scored, but a certain wildness robbed them of well merited reward. After half-an-hour’s play. Everton again put some backbone into their efforts, and after Doig had stopped a hot ’un, Chadwick only missed scoring by a few inches; but the grand defence of Sunderland again broke up the effort, after this spurt they appeared altogether dispirited, and bar a few spasmodic dashes, which were easily overcome, the Everton course was run, and the wonder is how it was Sunderland could, not get more through, considering the many opportunities they had, the score at the finish still being; Sunderland 1 goal, Everton none.
Sunderland on the day’s play quite deserved the success, as they were out-and-out the better team, not only at back, but strange to say, in the front division as well. The whole of the eleven worked with a confidence, dash, and determination that was sure to prove successful, while, on the other hand, Everton after the first quarter of an hour were knocked all to pieces. Only one word will adequately describe the defence of the winners, and that is superb. Never once was a mistake made, and it was inspiriting to see the way they dashed into and broke up the combination of the League champions until this dreaded five of Liverpool almost appeared like children in their hands. Considering the great excitement of the occasion, Sunderland maintained their balance wonderfully well, and I should judge played a little above their ordinary form forward. Only one mistake was made, and that was the right wing was neglected too much. Had Harvey and Smith been fed more, the score would have been heavier. The great weakness of the team is lack of shooting power. Everton were distinctly and decidedly off colour. Undoubtedly the loss of Hannah and Brady made a lot of difference to them, but not one of them played well with, perhaps the exception of the centre-half. Combination was conspicuous by its absence, and when crude attempts were made at passing. Auld, Porteous and Co quickly broke it up. Latta was very unwell, and should never have played. Wyllie was at hand and anxious to take his place, but the Everton committee thought it unwise to change the team at such a late hour.
PLAYERS
For Sunderland, Porteous played grandly at back, all the three halves were superb, both outside-wing forwards, Scott and Harvey, played beautifully, and Campbell made a most capable centre. On the Everton side, McLean was the best back. Holt was the most prominent half although all played well, and Chadwick and Milward were the pick of the forwards.
NOTES FROM THE NOTE
Athletic News - Monday 19 January 1891
WEARSIDE.
“The Everton blackguards,’’ as I heard them foully slandered, arrived here on Friday afternoon, and were met by the “scalawag" population of the Wearside borough. They stayed at the Roker Hotel. The team received me somewhat frigidly, in keeping with the temperature out of doors, where the "beautiful snow” lay half a foot thick. A gentleman connected with the team introduced himself as “Mr. Wilson, assistant treasurer of the club.” Now l am aware that Everton shovel in the sponduliz in a way that no other club can do, but still I was not prepared for an “assistant treasurer.” I received an even greater shock when politely informed by the same urbane gentleman that Doyle was to play centre forward. To be sure, if “ Dannie” once secured the ball and got fairly under weigh, he would be a terror to all beholders, and as easily turned off the track as a house-end. Oliver is the only man who might do it. Which reminds me of the old philosophical puzzle, “If an irresistible force came in contact with an immovable body, what would be the result?” When I threw off my disguise and announced myself as the real and only “Gideon” (none other are genuine), it was wonderful what a change was wrought by the magic of that name. Mr. “Wilson” became quite affectionate, and kindly put me right about the players' names and their position, in the team. I suppose, now, that Mr. Molyneux will have his little joke, and if enjoyed it at my expense, I do not begrudge him his cheap form of amusement. The Evertonians are very jolly fellows. I was introduced to nearly all the team, and when we did part it was with mutual expressions of regret.
Despite the fact that Sunderland, on their own ground, have thrice previously beaten Everton, the visitors declined to regard them as any other than ’' a second-class combination.” If they are at all careful of their own reputation, they will, after the experience of Saturday, form a higher opinion of their four-fold conquerors. I shall not go over the ground already covered by your special representative. I would merely venture to add the expression of my belief that the best, or to be grammatically accurate—the Sunderland Committee are such purists the better, team won. Had Everton played Geary in the centre, taken off Robertson altogether, and partnered Latta with Wylie, they might have made a drawn game, although, under no circumstances, I think, would they have won. Latta and Geary did not combine well, and were outshone by the left-wing couple. There was, however, a woeful lack of heart about their whole proceedings. I was told beforehand that they were determined to win. If so the first goal obtained by Campbell knocked that determination out of them. Liverpool people may be inclined to pitch into Angus. Should a scapegoat be required, better, my friends, select someone else. Angus did all that mortal could do. For various reasons he is not exactly idolized at Newcastle-road. The memory of the old Albionite affrays still rankles in the breasts of Wearsiders. But Angus stirred their enthusiasm in spite of themselves. He certainly saved a second goal from the foot of Campbell, which, for lightning-like rapidity, I have never seen equaled, or, rather, imagined, because the ball was not visible except to the keenest eyes until Angus threw himself desperately at it right on the line. My old friend reproached me at Roker because I have before now had occasion to scarify him with the critic’s scalpel I trust he will admit that I have at length made the amende honorable. He richly merits the praise which I have awarded to him. The surprise of the home side was Oliver. Everton frankly told me before the game begun that they considered the Sunderland left back to be the weak spot in the Wearside defensive armour. But if Latta and Geary thought they had him trussed and roasted, they were hugely mistaken. Murray did not let them pass him often, but when they did Oliver was an insuperable barrier. Not only did he tackle clean, he also placed the ball with care and judgement-a thing which I have seldom if ever known him to do before. If he were at all consistent in his play I should be the last to demand that he be removed. Grant that it be not a flash in the pan, like Kirkley’s display at Blackburn last season, which caused Lancashire people to wonder why Sunderland did not prize his prowess more. Campbell, of course, carried off the honours among the forwards, and Murray among the halves. These two men were superb. The attendance of the public I estimated at eighteen thousand; an official computation placed it at about twenty thousand. I am prepared to throw in the extra 2,000, which does not include some hundreds who witnessed the game gratis from the roofs of neighbouring houses, or perched atop of the covered grand stand and the press-box. A force of 20 police was on the ground, but perfect order was kept without the assistance of the tip staffs, although I would not have answered for the consequences had the game gone the other way. Newcastle-road was an extemporized cab rank. I heard of a few accidents to pedestrians, but their injuries were not severe. A returning crowd is always, to me at any rate, an imposing sight. For half an hour I witnessed the defile past a given point. Still they came, and Wearmouth Bridge has seldom had such a portentous burden to bear. The proceeds—about 420—like the numbers, establishes a record for Sunderland, for England north of the Tees. Bigger receipts were taken at Everton last week, but here the maximum charge is Is. 6d., whereas there, I understand, it in 2s. 6d. The match was the sole topic of conversation on Saturday night. It was the same all over, at home, in the club, or in the open streets, and a good many temperance pledgee were broken. , Various jeus d’eaprit were vended by enterprising hawkers, them being a card which Everton stood by a coffin and wept over their ruined Cup hopes. A protest is still possible, but hardly likely. It is the boast of Everton that they are true sportsman in Liverpool. I do not question it. All I ask is that they will show that sportsmanlike spirit and keep the promise which they made beforehand, that, although they had a case against three of the home players yet if Sunderland beat them even by a dozen goals they would accept their defeat. My compliments to the “Loiterer” and “Mr. Wilson,” and my condolence with them on this unfortunate contretemps.
ASSOCIATION
Sunderland Daily Echo and Shipping Gazette - Tuesday 20 January 1891
The crowd that assembled to witness the Sunderland-Everton tie was a whopper. The receipts amounted to £420, and there were not less than 20,000 spectators present. In conversation that I had with several of the toffeemen before the match they expressed themselves confident of their victory, and did not seem to have any doubts as to any other issue. They had, however, mistaken their men, and before the allotted time of play had expired they were run completely off their feet. Sunderland played a splendid game, the defence being their shining point. The Everton forwards could not get far from the home halves, and in the matter of combination the Sunderland front rank was the better of the two. Some allowance must be made for the fact that Geary was not his old place, but the right wing. McLean was a good substitute for Hannah, the Everton back. The Sunderland team, there is no doubt, fully earned the triumph. Mr. Jope, the referee, was determined that the game should played in strict accordance with rules. Soon after the commencement he had occasion to speak to one of the visitors for roughness, and wound up by telling that a repetition of the offence would lead to his being ordered off the field. This prompt decision had its effect, and the play from that was a much more gentlemanly character than is often in cup ties. The referee, I am told, is of opinion that the best team won, and considers that Porteous and Oliver are worthy of International honours. He particularly admired Auld, Campbell, and Harvie, and regards Smith as a much better man than he is generally supposed to be. He thought that the only mistake made by Sunderland was in the three inside forwards lying too well up the field, this compelling them to frequently turn round to accept from the outside men. Mr. Jope is an authority on football; therefore I make no apology for giving his opinions to my readers. In the Sunderland and Everton tie it may be stated that 10,000 words were telegraphed to newspapers in all the big football centres. Press representatives were present from Manchester, Liverpool, and other large towns. In addition to the above an enormous number of private messages were sent, and a quantity of matter was dispatched by train.
BLUE REVIEW
January 24 th 1891. The Liverpool Courier.
Will history repeat itself? Such is the question now being seriously asked, and indeed there is good reason for the anxiety, which prevails. So far as Everton is concerned, the holding of the Association Cup –which is still regarded at the chief honour of the season –is by a curious coincidence reduced to a dead letter at the outset, as was the case a year ago when the Anfield road team succumbed to Stoke in the first round of ties. Neither is there any very encouraging prospect as regards as League Championship and the magnificent trophy, which accompanies that event. The issue may truly be said to being evenly in the balance, for only by Everton's success at Burnley, and a reverse on the part of the (Rovers who have yet five matches to play) and Preston North End (who have seven) can the hopes of the Liverpool champions be realised. It was certainly hard lines on Everton to be drawn in first instance against a team like Sunderland, and to be handicapped by a long and tedious journey. The undoubted disadvantage of playing on a strange ground has been clearly established by the results of the season, and especially so in the case of teams so evenly matched as Everton and Sunderland, whose three matches have been decided by a goal in each instance the total of the series being only three. But Everton in the absence of Hannah, their captain who was hurt in the match against north End, lost the services of an astute leader and able player, and although no fault whatever can be found with McLean, still the influence of the sturdy Scot was visibly wanting. But while Everton were beaten by a goal to nil, this untoward result was by a mishap to Doyle, which unabled Campbell to race up and shoot rapidly before Angus could change his position in goal. Still no one will grudge the Wearsiders the victory they so well deserved. They are a splendid team, whilst Doig they have one of the very best custodian the country can boast of, and the wonder therefore is that they do not figure higher in the records of the League. Doubtless they will improve their position and with North End out of the way, a bold bid for cup honours will be made.
FOOTBALL CHIPS.
The Liverpool Football Echo.
There seems to be no end to the generosity of the Everton club. It is rumored they are going to give a helping hand to Accrington, who will take proceeds of the gate. The date of the match however, has not yet been fixed. The Everton players were promised £1 each if they beat Sunderland in the Cup tie. It is said they didn't earn their “quids.” Mr. Jackson, the assistant treasurer for Everton, brought back from Sunderland more money than he took. The Everton exchequer was benefited by something like £200. Golden salve is good for wounded feelings. Fred Geary, we understand, has signed on for another two years. The committee, however, are not sure yet about Chadwick. Pa Jackson, junior, however, thinks he could net Edgar if he was given the power. By the way, Chaddy is contemplating matrimony. Be careful Edgar. All hopes of bringing the English Cup to Liverpool this season have vanished. Sunderland played a grand game and fully deserved to win, being smarter and quicker on the ball than Everton. Angus played a splendid game in goal, and frequently caused the Wearsiders to cheer him instily. Hope Robertson was a rack failure, and might as well have been at home in Liverpool for all the good he was at Sunderland. Latta was also a frost, and we don't think the Dumbarton man was ever seen to worse advantage. He seemed frightened, and it is claimed as a setoff that he was unwell. If so, why did he play? Wyllie was on the ground ready to do service. Geary played a very hard game, but being in between two bad ‘uns his good work went for nought. Chadwick and Milward were easily the best wing, but still the young Cockney might have tried a bit better. Kirkwood played an improved game, and worked hard all through. Mclean was a great success, and worthily filled Hannah' shoes, and was every bit as good as Doyle. The players took their defeat in very good part, and fairly surprised the natives on the journey from the Roker to the station. Holt and Angus stayed behind till Monday. What was the attraction? It is said that the centre half fell head and ears in love, so for fear anything happens shortly you had better make up your minds what kind of a present you are going to give him. On the journey back the Rovers' saloon was hooked on behind Everton's. Is this an indication of what is going to happen in the League? Everton did protest after all, but it was not sustained. There were good grounds for protesting, and undoubtedly of the Sunderland players had violated the rules, but it appears that the Association had condoned the offence and Everton had no official estimation. Mr. Molyneux stated Everton's case in grand style, while Mr. Tom Watson appeared for Sunderland. Watson looked surprised when Mr. Clegg asked him who he was. Fancy the great Tom Watson of Sunderland not being known. Everybody will be sorry to hear that Fred Geary is not playing at London today, on account of the death of his brother.
CORINTHIANS 1 EVERTON 3
January 26 1891. The Liverpool Mercury
Everton commenced their metropolitan campaign on Saturday when au the historic final cup tie ground-the Oval at Kennington-their tested the quality of the corinthians, a famous amateur combination that was represented on this particular occasion by seven or eight internationals. The weather, unfortunately, was wet in the extreme, the event being thus robbed of much of its attractiveness, and not more than 2,000 spectators were courageous enough to face the persistent downpour of rain. Geary through bereavement, was an absentee, and Hannah and Brady were again left out as not being thoroughly recovered. The teams and officials were Everon: - Jardine, goal, McLean, and Doyle, backs, Kirkwood, Holt (captain), and Parry, half-backs, Latta, Wylie, Robertson, Chadwick, and Milward, forwards. Umpire Mr. Clayton. Corinthians: Moon, goal, Wells, and Anderson, backs, Winkworth, Brown, and White, half-backs, Brand, Currie, Lindley, Lambie, and Sandilands, forwards, Umpire Mr. N.L.Jackson, referee Mr. Clegg of Sheffield . Holt was successful in securing the choice of ends, and turned his back to the wind. Lambie opened with a run, but Doyle, from whose pass the Everton left wing created a chance, which was ineffectively utilised, returned his kick with interest. Doyle thus rated another attempt by the Corinthians, and this gave the visitors right wing an advantage, but again the shot passed behind. The home right wing caused the danger to be greater than it had previously been a corner being conceded, but this was tided over, and Everton were not slow in turning their attentions towards Moon's charge, which Robertson captured the game having been in progess about a quarter of an hour. The Corinthians were off in a strong run on re-starting and pressure being brought to bear on the left, Sandilands equalised. Kirkwood and McLean both failing to cut short the aggressive inovement. Corner next fell to Everton, who attacked very determinedly, but found the defence of Anderson and Wells of sound quality. Wykes and Latta showed some excellent work but White was very successful in checking a too close acquaintance of the Everton right wing with Moon. White was once penalised for a foul, but Kirkwood unluckily sent behind, and from the kick off at goal, Latta drove hard and straight, a fine shot, which Moon brilliantly compassed. Everton continued to menace the home goal, an aim by Milward being particularly near taking effect. At half-time, however, the record was one all. On resuming the Cornthians were at once thrown hard on the defensive, and from a scrimmage Robertson again proved too resourceful for the watchful internations custodain. Having survived some hair breath escapes the home team had a turn at attacking. Sandiland assayed a shot without avail, but the Corinthians maintained their pressure, during which good shots rained in, the defence of Everton always proving equal to the incisive moments of their opponents. The play was carried on with energy, and Everton staying better soon asserted superiority and as the end of fast play approached, literally besiege goal, but were hampered with offside claims. The right wing of Everton at length returned to some purpose, however, as Milward shot successfully. This was the last point, and Everton thus achieved a meritorious victory of 3 to 1-which is the inverted result of the match played at Anfield in 1888 when the Corinthians beat Everton by 3 goals to 1.
EVERTON RESERVES 4 BANGOR 0
January 26 1891. The Liverpool Mercury
The Evverton league team being away touring in the south the Anfield enclosure was occupied on Saturday by their second string, who had Bangor as their opponents. Some even exchanges took place in the first half but before the interval Everton scored twice, to the visitors nil. Gaining two more in the second portion. Everton thus added another victory to their long list by 4 goals to nil.
CORINTHIANS V EVERTON
January 26, 1891. The Birmingham Daily Post
At Kennington Oval, in wet and stormy weather. Everton who were without Geary, scored first, but the Corinthians immediately equalised. Nothing more was scored in the first half, but directly after Everton got a second goal. After this the Corinthians had the better of the game, but failed to score, and Everton scored again, and won by three goals to one.
A VICTORY FOR EVERTON.
Sporting Life - Monday 26 January 1891
CORINTHIANS V EVERTON
After being deprived of an opportunity witnessing football of any kind since December 6, it would have been surprising if the habitués of the Oval had not taken advantage of the chance offered them on Saturday last by the management of the famous Corinthian Club. The consistently brilliant form shown by the Everton team, who are the premiers of the League this season, invested their meeting with the Corinthians with interest, and with ordinarily fine weather there would have been a very large attendance. As it was, in spite of steady and continuous rain during the forenoon and throughout the game, quite 3,000 spectators braved the weather to see what proved to be an exceedingly interesting game. Neither side had quite its strength, as while the brothers Walters, Veitch, Hossack, Cotterell, and Ingram were absent from the Corinthians, Geary, Brady, and Hannah were all unable to play for Everton. The thaw following on the lengthened frost, had naturally made the ground very soft, and the going was so heavy as to handicap the players materially. Still, the form was distinctly above the average, and as there was, on the whole, very little between the sides, the game evoked more than ordinary enthusiasm. The toss was won by the Everton, and as there was a fairly strong breeze blowing down the ground from the west, the Northern team, electing to kick to the Gasworks, gained an important advantage. The kick-off Lindley, for the Corinthians, was at once returned, and though Sandilands made a diversion into Everton’s half, Chadwick and Milward on the left made such a vigorous attack that a corner was registered against the Corinthians. Relieved of the danger, Currey changed the venue well into Everton’s half, but the better combination of Liverpool forwards enabled them for a time to maintain the advantage, and twice the Corinthian goal was seriously menaced. Some neat play by Sandilands and Lambie relieved the Corinthians, and in spite of the excellent defence of the Northern backs, ball was taken at ran express speed right up to the neighbourhood of their goal. The only result, however, was a corner kick, and as this was not well placed, nothing came of it. Once more the Everton forwards carried everything before them, and after a good run along the left by Chadwick, Robertson succeeded in eluding Moon, placing a first score to the credit of Everton just a quarter of an hour from the start. This reverse had a very stimulating effect on the Corinthian forwards, and Jardine was called on to save. A corner kick followed without result, but the ball was still kept in the visitors’ quarters, and after some good play by Lambie and the ball was sent through Everton's goal amidst general applause. On the resumption, Everton for a short time closely invested the Corinthian lines, and but for the efforts of the backs, for whom Holden-White and Winckworth were conspicuous, they must have scored. Two corner kicks were, however, unproductive, and then the Corinthians in their turn were the assailants, Currey, having apparently at least saved one good opening which he allowed to Moon, twice saved his side in splendid style, and when half-time arrived the ball was well in the Corinithian half. After the change of ends Everton at once asserted their superiority, and the game had hardly been renewed before Milward was able to accredit them with their second goal. A few minutes afterwards Robertson also got ball past Moon, but as he was clearly off-side the point was not allowed. Just at this time it looked as if Everton were going to outstay their opponents altogether, and the game then seemed to be entirely in their favour. Although they had to play for the first half against the wind, however, the Corinthians were not by any means done with, and they played, indeed, with such pluck that the last half hour was very interesting. Currey, Sandilands, Lindley, and Lambie kept the Everton backs hard at work. Sandilands once was well in range of the Everton goal, with no one except Jardine in front, but his final kick was very erratic, and he sent the ball just outside the goal. Attacking in their turn, Everton was twice dangerous, but their shooting throughout was rather faulty, and both chances were lost. For a few minutes again the Corinthians kept up a vigorous attack on the enemy’s line, and two corner kicks were tried without success. Everton, breaking away, changed scene for a time, but the forwards were in the habit of getting too far up, or they might have scored twice. As it was, before the finish Milward got another opening, and a third goal for Everton left the League leaders winners of an extremely hard fought match by three goals to one. Corinthians, considering that most of the team were quite out of condition, made a very creditable show, and had they been in better training the result would in all probability have been different. Messrs. J. E. Saunders (Corinthians) and W. R. Clayton (Everton) were umpires, and Mr. J. C. Clegg (vice-president Football Association) was referee. The players were : Everton;- D. Jardine (goal), D. Doyle and D. McLean (backs), J. Holt, C. Parry, and D. Kirkwood (half-backs), A. Milward, E. Chadwick, H. Robertson, T. Wyllie, and A. Latta. Corinthians.—W. R. Moon (goal), W. C. Wells and E. P. Anderson (backs). W. N. Winckworth. C. Wreford Brown, and C. Holden-White (half-backs). G. Brann, E. S. Currey, T. Findley, J. A. Lambie, and R. R. Sandilands.
EVERTON NOTES
Athletic News - Monday 26 January 1891
Everton have been very generous with Accrington. The latter have not had the best of luck this season, as everyone knows, and approached Everton with view to playing them a benefit match at Liverpool. The Everton people looked at the matter in an admirable spirit and promised the "Reds” a match. In these days of keen competition and high wages, this act of generosity redounds to credit Mr. Barclay and his committee.
THE FIRST BIG ASSOCIATION MATCH IN LONDON
Athletic News - Monday 26 January 1891
Everton just beat the Corinthians
By the Old Athletic
Until last Saturday, with the exception perhaps of the Corinthians v Cambridge University, we have not had a single Association match of any importance in the London district this season. Somehow or the other, our Associationists cannot manage to arrange such an interesting programme as their Rugby brethren. Why, I don’t know; perhaps because they are aware of their own weakness. It may be so. While we have read about all the big matches coming off in the country, thanks to the foresight of the authorities in protecting their grounds, one cannot but feel sad at the lack of enterprise shown by the metropolitans in failing to do the same, or making any preparation whatever to resist “King Frost” Up to last Thursday it seemed very improbable as to whether we should again have any football, but likely on Thursday such a decided change took place that in a couple of days the “bone” was clean out of the ground, and mud had to be coped with instead of snow ice. All our big Rugby matches were declared off, and as I wended my way to Kennington Oval in the pouring rain, I had some misgivings as to whether any match would be played. I met Apted, the ground man, after I had passed the turnstiles, and very sad he looked at the prospect of his turf being kicked up. Still though on the soft side, it played very much better than anyone could have imagined would be the case, and a fast, well-played contest resulted. Of course, that Corinthians suffered the most. Their heavy men forward were sadly handicapped in comparison with their lighter rivals, who, however, could have hardly be said to have their best team, as Geary, their celebrated centre-forward –owing, I was told, to a family bereavement-was unable to take part. This was, no doubt a great disappointment to the majority of the spectators, who, I mat state, turned up, in spite of the unpromising weather, to the tune of some 2,000 strong. They were not what I term a strictly impartial crowd, far from it, and lost no opportunity of caviling at the Evertonians’ play, and were utterly regardless of any little lapses committed by the Corinthians. There really however, was very little need for their demonstrations, as a fairer game, or one in which there were fewer appeals, I have seldom witnessed. It was rather hard luck for the Corinthians to lose the toss, and for the first half to have to play against a strong wind and a blinding rain, they managed to make a galliant fight, and had little the worst of the play. The game opened sharp to time with some scrambling play on the left in the Everton half, but a long pass from Latta across to Chadwick and Milward enabled the latter pair, by some fine passing, to transfer the ball to the home half. Wells made a mistake, but the ball rolled behind before the Everton forwards could get on to it, Lindley temporarily relieved, but Holt placing the ball on the left wing, Chadwick and Milward were once more attacking. Latta got a long pass from the last-named, but shot behind; and then Brann dashed down the field and spoiled a long single-handed run by kicking to Doyle. Lambie shot, but Mclean saved at the expense of a corner, from which the Everton right got off. The ball was crossed and Milward dropping it at Robertson’s feet the latter rolled it through the Corinthians goal; Moon, who seemed hampered by his backs apparently not seeing the danger until it was too late. Everton’s triumph was short lived, as from the kick-off Lindley and Lambie ran up to the Liverpool quarters, and when McLean tried to stop them, transferred to Sandilands, who equalized amidst tremendous cheering, which the fine bit of play fully merited. From this point up to half-time very little occurred that calls for special comment. Everton certainly had the best of it, but the excellent defence of the Corinthian backs neutralized every attack. Twice Doyle made tremendous kicks from midfield, which forced Moon to handle, while little Holt played a grand game, feeding his men splendidly, time after time talking the ball from the opposing forwards. Chadwick and Milward put in some excellent combined work on the left, but those immediately in front of them, Currie and Brann, seemed unable to make much headway on the holding turf. No sooner had ends been changed than Everton at once ran the ball to their opponents’ goal, and after a brief scrummage Robertson kicked through. For a few minutes the Corinthains looked like going all to pieces. Twice Everton narrowly missed scoring, and once the ball was sent through, but “off-side” was claimed and allowed. This seemed to wake the amateur up to the real state of affairs and in turn they attacked with vigiour. A regular bombardment of the Everton goal now commenced, and fully a down shots were sent in, any one, of which with a bit of luck might have scored. Jardine made two wonderful saves, and Doyle, by a clever kick, got away what looked like a certain point. For fully twenty minutes the ball was hardly ever out of the Everton half, but then, apparently disheartened by their many fruitless attempts the play of the Corinthians slackened, and just before the close, after some clever passing by the Everton right wing, Wyllie centred and Milward scored the third goal for his side, who thus won a capitally contested match by three goals to one, a result which is a very little luck might have reversed. At the same time the best team, on the day, certainly won; but, as I have said above, the weather was against the heavy Corinthians, who considering the little practice they have had of late, worked wonderfully well and hard right up to the finish. Their combination though at times brilliant, was not as consistent as that of the Liverpool men, who had Geary been present, would have scored more. Robertson at times was very wild, and lost many chances. The best man on the field was undoubtedly Holt, who I shall not be surprised to find get his International cap again. He was as wonderfully safe tackle for such a little fellow, but his great point was the manner in which he fed his forwards. Holden White was the best of the halves on the other side, but the Corinthian backs, though they at times played well, made one or two bad mistakes which might have been serious. It was however, a gallantly-fought match, and had the weather been dry would have been anybody’s game. Today Everton play the Royal Arsenal at Woolwich; tomorrow Chatham, at Chatham, and on Saturday’s form they ought to win both matches easily.
WEARS SIDE
Athletic News - Monday 26 January 1891
The Jamus-faced policy of the Everton Club has been severely animadverted upon here during the last week. Before and immediately after the Cup tie they asserted that it was not their intention protest. “We are sportsmen at Liverpool, and will accept the result, whatever it may be.” First thoughts are always the best, and if Everton had made good their promise, they would have been more popular in Sunderland than they are at the present time. A forty – eight hours’ think appears to have caused them to change their mind, and on Tuesday, I believe, they informed Sunderland of their intention to protest. The news did not become generally known until the following day. As may be imagined, it caused great surprise and intense indignation among the home partisans, and when, on Wednesday night the public learnt that the protest had been dismissed, they, of course, expressed profound satisfaction thereat. Sunderland had little time in which to prepare their defence, and, should say, owed their escape less to the skill of their advocate than to the inherent weakness of the Everton case. They had, of course, legal right to protest; but, after their voluntary pledge, I deny their moral right do so, and they have suffered in the estimation everybody in consequence.
ROYAL ARSENAL V EVERTON
January 27, 1891. The Birmingham Daily Post
The second match of the Everton southern tour took place at Plumstead, in splendid weather, before 8,000 people. Everton soon took the lead, scoring four goals by Latta, Milward, Wyllie and Chadwick in the first half. In the second portion the game was more even, but Robertson scored again for Everton, who had much the better of the play, their forwards being especially brilliant. Result Everton 5, Royal Arsenal 0.
ROYAL ARSENAL 0 EVERTON 5
January 27 1891. The Liverpool Mercury
Everton League team played the second match of their Southern tour at Plumstead yesterday afternoon in magnificent weather, and about 10,000 spectators. Everton at all points of the game proved immensely superior to their opponents, and won easily by 5 goals to nil. The points were obtained by Latta, Milward, Wylie, Chadwick,, and Robertson, Campbell and Shaw took the place of Parry and Kirkwood, who were injured on Saturday . Teams Arsenal :- Bee, goals, Connolly, and McBean, backs, Howath, Stewart,, and Julian half-backs, Christy, Meggs, Cloak, Offer,and Fry, forwards. Everton: - Jardine, goal, McLead, and Doyle, backs, Shaw, Holt (captain), and Campbell, half-backs Latta, Wylies. Robertson, Chadwick, and Milward, forwards.
CHATHAM 1 EVERTON 4
January 27 1891. The Liverpool Mercury
This the third and last of the Everton Southern tour, was played at Chatham yesterday. The weather was unfortunately unfavorable as rain fell during the game, with the wind, in the first half, Everton pressed very much, Milward scoring twice and Wylie and Elliott one each. On charging ends, play was more even, Colvin scored for Chatham, the only point of the second half. Final Result Chatham 1goals, Everton 4 goals. Teams Chatham: - Oakley, goal, Pellest and Gascoigne, backs Pratt Davidson, and Leitish half-backs, Davies, McLeod, Colvin, Ekins and Hohart forwards. Everton: - Angus, goals, McLeod, and Doyle, backs Shaw, Holt (captain), and Campbell, half-back, Wylie, Kirkwood, Milward, Chadwick, ands Elliott, forwards. Attendance 5,000.
CHATHAM DEFEATED BY FOUR GOALS TO ONE.
Sporting Life - Wednesday 28 January 1891
EVERTON V CHATHAM
In continual of their Southern tour, the Everton team went to Chatham yesterday afternoon, and encountered the local team on the Maidstone-road enclosure, fresh from their victories over the Corinthians on Saturday by three goals to one, and over Royal Arsenal on by five goals to none. The Chatham team have not achieved any very excellent performances during the present season, and only on the previous Saturday they were worsted by the 93rd Highlanders by three goals to none. For the past five or weeks they have played but little, owing to the unpropdious weather, and were consequently out of practice. Like the Royal Arsenal combination, there is not a single professional in the team. Yesterday, however, they were seen at their best, particularly in the second half of the game. Everton registered four goals in the first half, but after the change of ends they failed to increase their score, while their opponents succeeded in registering a point themselves. Great interest was centred in the match, but. Unfortunately, the weather was still on the wretched side, and rain fell an hour before the match commenced, and continued almost without intermission throughout afternoon. The approach to the ground from the town, a distance of upwards of a mile, was a veritable quagmire. Spite of the drawbacks there was a gathering of spectators numbering nearly five thousand on the ground. A moderately strong wind blew from end to end of the ground, and losing the toss, Chatham had to commence against this drawback. Chatham were without two of their best men, C. E. Hibbard, the well-known centre forward, and A. E. Jenner, half-back, and the services of Lieutenant J. M. Colvin, of the Royal Engineers, were enlisted to the forward ranks of Chatham. Changes were made in the Everton team, as will be seen from the names below. Colvin set the ball in motion for Chatham at a quarter-past three, and at once advanced on the right into Everton territory, but Doyle prevented them from becoming dangerous by clearing with a sturdy kick. Elliott and Chadwick got off on the Everton left, but the former was promptly brought up by Pellatt within shooting distance of the Chatham goal, the ball going outside off Elliott. Oakley's goal-kick removed the play to the centre of the ground, and for the next five minutes neither goal became jeopardized. Then Robert and Ekins made off on the Chatham’s left, but the former was deprived by McLean close to the goal-line. The Everton forwards then attacked very holly, but Pellatt and Gascoigne defended in fine style, and Oakley averted shots from Wyllie and Milward, while the latter on one occasion shot within a few inches of the post. It was not until quarter of an hour had elapsed that Milward found an opening, and registered the first goal for Everton with a smart high shot, which baffled the Chatham custodian. Undismayed by this reverse, Chatham strove hard, and Hobart forced a corner off McLean. This was admirably negotiated by Leitch, the ball descending immediately in front of the Everton goal, but Colvin just missed the ball, and Holt cleared in capital style. The Everton forwards bounded off into the Chatham lines again, and after some intricate and puzzling passing between them, Elliott scored the second goal for Everton with a high and hot shot. Going to the attack again, the Everton men again placed the Chatham goal in jeopardy, but Oakley averted a tall shot from Milward in magnificent style. Chatham then became aggressive, Davis and McLeod running well down the right together, and Davis sending in a well-directed shot, which Doyle checked. At this juncture Chatham played up vigorously, effective work being rendered by the half-backs, and Colvin and Hobart. At the end of half an hour looked threatening, and from a well-judged pass by Wyllie Milward obtained the third goal for Everton with another grand shot. In the remainder of the first half Everton kept the Chatham defenders very busy, and Wyllie eventually obtained an exceedingly lucky goal with long shot, the Chatham custodian running out to kick the ball and missing it. and the ball rolling gently between the uprights. Half-time arrived with Everton leading by four goals to none. Upon the change of ends Everton attacked in a line, but Milward handled the ball, and Chatham were thus enabled relieve the pressure. They consequently obtained a corner, but this proved unproductive, as also did another corner a little later, Campbell middling well, but Wyllie shooting wide. Little Hobart was enthusiastically cheered for a smart run, the result of which was a corner off McLean. This was taken by Leitch, but Colvin shot wide of the goal. Then the Chatham goal was again in danger, but a couple of shots from Kirkwood and Chadwick were splendidly averted by Oakley. Chatham were playing a capital game, and they continued to do so to the end. Hobart and Ekins brought off brilliant run, and from a capital centre by Hobart Colvin registered a goal for Chatham with a low shot amid tremendous cheering of the Chatham partisans. Nothing further occurred, and the match ended in a victory for Everton by four goals to one. The Chatham players and their supporters were quite jubilant over the result. Everton played a much superior game to their opponents, but Chatham lads worked hard all through. Referee. Mr. Walter King. Teams Everton;- R. Angus (goal), D. Doyle and D. McLean (backs), J. Holt, A. Campbell, and Shaw (half-backs), Wyllie and D. Kirkwood (right wing), E. Chadwick and J. Elliott (left wing), and A. Milward (centre). Chatham;- E. J.Oakley (goal). W. Gascoigne and Pellatt (backs), E. P. Prall (captain), J. W. Dawson, and W. Leitch (half, backs), W. McLeod and H. Davis (right wing), F, G. Ekins and H. Hobart (left wing), and J. M, Colvin (centre).
EVERTON V CHATHAM
January 28, 1891. The Birmingham Daily Post
Played at Chatham yesterday afternoon in rough weather before 5,000 spectators, Everton scored four goals, to none in the first half, Milward scoring twice and Elliott and Wyllie one each. Colvin scored for Chatham twenty minutes after the change from a centre by Hobart. Chatham play a good game in the second half. Result Everton 4 goal, Chatham.
A SPIRITED FOOTBALL TUSSLE.
Diss Express - Friday 30 January 1891
Football has advanced runs and rushes into the position of far and the most popular of British outdoor winter games; but this severely frosty season the sport has been sadly interfered with. Match after match has had to abandoned because of the impracticable state of the ground; and many a tussle that has actually taken place has been sadly spoiled by the difficulties the frost has placed in the way of players. But the welcome thaw of last week raised the hearts of all lovers of football, and on Saturday the game was in full swing all over the land. The opening match of the Southern tour undertaken the Everton club was largely spoilt by the heavy rain, the turf at Kennington Oval being very soft and slippery. The prospect of a good match, however, drew quite 2000 people to the Surrey ground, and, apart from the rain, the match was most enjoyable one. Everton, who lacked the services of Geary, their centre forward, won the toss, and the Corinthians kicked off in the face of strong wind and blinding rain. For little while the game presented no particular feature, but the Lancashire club gradually got the upper hand, and within 10 minutes of the start Robertson scored for Everton. The ball, however, had scarcely been set rolling again when Lindley and Lambie took the ball down, and Sandilands equalised. Everton played up hard after this, but the Corinthians defended well, and despite fine shots by Latta, Doyle, and Millward, half-time arrived with the score standing one goal each. Directly after the resumption the Everton forwards came away in splendid style, and out of some play in front of goal Millward forced the ball between the Corinthians posts. Another goal to Everton was disallowed for off-side, but then the Corinthians played up in fine form and for nearly quarter of an hour taxed the defence of Everton severely. Sandilands kicked just outside, and next came quite half a dozen shots into the mouth of goal. Any one of these might have taken effect, but after a while Everton cleared their lines, and though one or two good chances were missed, Millward, from pass across by Latta, obtained a third goal. The game thus ended in victory for Everton by three goals to one.
BLUE REVIEW
January 31 st 1891. The Liverpool Courier.
The Southern tour of Everton was attended with results, which conclusively show that amateur teams, however, good have little or no chance when pitted against a first-class professional team. It was urged in behalf of the Corthinians that they were not fully represented, and that with ordinary luck the verdict against them of three goals to one –which oddly, is turned a “narrow” margin –might have been reversed. This is the old style of minimizing a defeat, but of course it is comforting to fall back upon the back eyed excuse that the absence of this or the other good man naturally affected the issue. For the matter of that, Everton were not nearly fully represented, for although it was pointed out that Geary was missing from the centre of the forward rank, no mention was made of the absence of Brady, or of Hannah, the captain of the team; and taking all things into account, it will naturally be concluded that “Pa” Jackson's cracks were beaten on their merits, and that too, on their own battle-ground at Kennington Oval. Holt was as vivacious and clever as ever; but as was only to be expected Milward, who was not deemed good enough for the North team, was the recipient of general praise. This to some extent may be traced to a sympathetic feeling because of his southern extraction, although hereabout the merits of the Great Marlow youth have long been recognised. If the “Old Athletic” does not know a good man when he comes across his line of vision, who does? Milward certainly played a very fine game (say that excellent judge) and if this was his real form, there are more unlikely things than the ex-Marlow man getting into one of the international teams this year. A matter of fact, there is no more consistent player in England today than Milward. Without even being sick sorly, or maimed, he always players will and it was a lucky day for Everton when Mr. Stockton so earnestly urged the committee to give him a place in the senior team. Journeying on to Plumstead on the Monday, the Royal Arsenal team were encounted but of course, the tourists had an easy task on hand, and as their fame had preceded them there was a much larger gathering than was the case at the opening match of the campaign. Latta, Milward, Wyllies, and Chadwick scored in the first half and Robertson in the second and eventually the Evertonians won their second victory by five goals to nothing. The second period was more even, but apparently only on sufferance, as the shooting was chiefly confined to the wings. Throughout the play of the Everton forwards was extremely brilliant as much so that the “Royalists” were rarely in a position to trouble Jardine, who in both matches kept goal remarkably well. The concluding match of the tour was against Chatham, but as the Corinthians and Royal Arsenal had failed to lower the colours of the victorious Anfield “boys” it was hardly to be expected that Chatham would accomplish that feat. In the first half Everton forced the play, with the result that Milward scored twice, and Elliott and Wyllie once each, and being four goals ahead at the interval the play slowed down, evidently with a view of testing the calbre of the Chatham team. From now to the end Chatham played a much better game, and were at length rewarded with a goal, which in the end left them in a minority of 4 to 1. As Milward played centre-forward in this match with success, Southern critics were not loth to confess that his high home reputation in was fully borne out by the events of the tour. To win three matches in four days was smart work on the past of the Everton boys, and as they registered 12 goals to 2, they well deserved the cordial greetings, which awaited them on their arrival at home.
Everton had the Bangor team as their opportnents, both sides being well represented. The game was an interesting one, but all in favour of the Evertonians, who defeated their opponents by four goals to nil.
