WHAT EVERTON ARE PAYING FOR HOWARTH
Lancashire Evening Post - Tuesday 01 December 1891
The value Everton set on the services of R.H. Howarth is set forth in the annexed cutting from Field Sports, Liverpool;- “One of the best captures ever made by Everton is that of Bob Howarth, who, in consideration of a payment of £200 down and a remuneration of £2 a week, has arranged to play with them as a professional til April 1894. By that time he will have completed his exams, and become a duly qualified solicitor. Judging from the accounts which have reached me, North End have not treated Howarth too well, but Everton have no reason to complain of the action which has driven such a grand exponent of the defensive game into their camp. The last time I saw Howarth play was in the International match with Scotland, and if he shows a time tithe of the form he displayed on that occasion he will indeed be an acquisition to Everton. When Kelso and Geary also return our League team will require some beating. We may be too late for the League Championship, but what about the Cup? Howarth has generally been known as a right full back, but he is just as effective on the left, and he will play in that position when he makes his first debut against the Rovers next Saturday.”

EVERTON LEAGUE v  SOUTHPORT CENTRAL
Liverpool Mercury - Tuesday 01 December 1891
This match will be played on the Everton ground, Anfield, to-day, the kick off being at 2.30 p.m. The following team has been selected to play for Everton;- Williams, goal; Fairbrother and Howarth (Late Preston North End), backs; Kirkwood, Holt, and Robertson, half-backs; Gordon, Wyllie, Maxwell, Chadwick, and Milward, forwards. Reserves, Mclean and Murray.

FOOTBALL NOTES
Montgomeryshire Express - Tuesday 01 December 1891
By “Centre.”
It is generally the outcry of all football committee at the commencement of the winter season that they intend, during the months allotted for the game, to in every way improve on previous form- more especially with the “pros” -and one of the chief clubs who indulged in this bombast was Everton. Why a month or two ago one would have thought (at least by their secretary, who is undoubtedly a most energetic one) that they would pass through all manner of obstacles, and easily take the name of “champions” in both the League and Cup competitions. But their present form, what is it? What have they done? Why simply broken faith with admirers of the game. Darwen proved themselves superior to the Evertonians, and on Saturday week they again met with such a defeat -5-1- as will long be remembered. Considering the number of imported men they have secured from time to time from various parts of the kingdom (including the Scotch amateurs?) one could hardly have expected such wretched form. I hope that they will improve and yet show themselves to better advantage.
Poor Wrexham! And yet another defeat. Everton Reserve (who tried conclusions with Wrexham in the Combiantion) are taking their victories like milk. The first team had better look to their laurels, or the Reserve will get in front. Truly, the Liverpudlians played a grand game against the Welshmen, for whom a small allowance must be made, as the Reserve played on their own ground. Everton kept on the aggressive, and won by 9-1.

EVERTON 3 SOUTHPORT CENTRAL 2
December 2 1891
The Liverpool mercury
Everton league v. southport central. A match between these teams was played at Anfield road yesterday. The weather being dull and threatening the attendance was not great, numbering about 2,000. The teams were Southport Gee (J) goal, Sugg and Fairhurst, backs, Gee (C), McLean, and Dodd, half-backs, McPherson Platt, Lee (T), Lee (H), and Halsall, forwards. Everton; Williams (R), McLean (D), andHowarth (R), backs, Kirkwood (D), Holt (J), (captain), and Robertson (H), half-backs, Gordon (P), Wyllie (T), Maxwell (A) C hadwick (E), and Milward (A), forwards.
Howarth, had a welcoming cheer on making his acout in the Everton jersey. The home team got well down from the kick-off, but the visitors removed operations smartly on the right. Howarth administered a check still Southport showed much activity, and attacked strongly when McLean cleared with a well judged kick to Maxwell who headed a raid Chadwick and Milward worked nicely but Sugg got his head in the way of a shot, and delayed disaster. The pressure contined. However and Milward scored whilst Maxwell paid attention to the goalkeeper. McPherson and Platt contributed another good movement on the right in arresting which Howarth slipped down but no danger arose. Everton then settled down to a persistent assault and were near scoring several times but the muddt state of the ground in front of goal detracted from accurate shooting. The central made play more even for a time, and were enabled to locate operations in the Everton quarters. They were not able to get in a shot though and Howarth passing up undiciously a very neat bit of passing between Milward, Chadwick, Maxwell, and Wyllie was finished off by the last named shooting, with a low shot, just wide of the post. Everton continued to have the best of it, but the visitors showed much vitality and good defensive tactics and shielded J Gee from being often called upon. McPherson and Platt again made a strong effort to get down, but though Howarth once more fell Platt could not get far, McLean coming to the rescue. More close shots followed from the Everton forwards interspersed with bad ones, but the ball fairly refused to travel though the mire. Howarth on the Central getting down on the left and centreing cleared grandly, and play resumed its familiar aspect of Everton attacking solidy and shooting gamely, always to find the visitors adepts in defence, and so the game contined until the interval. Everton leading by a goal to nil. Immediately on resuming, Chadwick shot in, and Gee though seeming to have stepped under the bar stopped the ball. Another fine shot went from the left, but the effective effort came from Gordon,, who centred truly, and Maxwell easily popped a goal. A fast spurt down the field by Platt gave T Lee an opportunity of shooting hard and straight to Williams, who saved finely. Another burst was of no avail to Southport, and Everton took up the attack, also to no purpose. The visitors now showed to more advantage than they had hitherto done and returned to goal in one of two clever movements, McPherson from a good pass by H Lee, essaying a splendid shot which was very neat penetrating goal. Howarth next cleared from a tussle in front, and soon Maxwell sent against the post. Fairhurst put the ballsmartly uo on robbing. Everton's right wing, and Platt made a running shot at goal at long range, which scored the ball passing through near the bar post, low down. H Lee and Halsall broke away a few minutes later from near their own goal, and, running strongly, grew really dangerous. Their progess was arrested in front of goal, where, amidst considerable excitement, Howarth extricated the ball. Everton helped materially by the good wotk pf Holt, clustered round goal, but could not find an opening whilst from a free kick in front the ball was placed over the bar. The Central improved as the game advanced. They ran and shot quickly and from a corner taking by Halsall on the left McPerson equalised with a keen low shot. They were once again threatening, but Everton managed to clear this time and tried hard to forge ahead. This they were very near doing on various occasion, but the Southport backs were clever enough to parry all the accurate thrusts until Gordonput a cross, and Milward shot in obliquely in a matter which gave Gee no chance. A futile corner followed to the visitors just before the finish, who were beaten after a fairly interting game by 3 goals to 2.

EVERTON v  ASTON VILLA
Preston Herald - Wednesday 02 December 1891
Played at Liverpool before 7,000 spectators. Teams;-
Everton.- Williams, goal; Collins and Earp, backs; Robertson, Holt, and McLean, half-backs; Latta, Wyllie, Maxwell, Chadwick, and Milward, forwards.
Aston Villa.- Hinckley, goal; Evans and Baird, backs; J. Brown, Cowan, and Campbell, half-backs; Athersmith, Dickson, J. Devey, Hodgetts, and L. Campbell, forwards.
The visitors opened the attack, but Everton smartly repelling had for a time much the upper hand. The Villa, from a clever break away by Hodgetts, scored. Everton now attacked vigorously, but luck seemed dead against them, Hinchley having some marvellous escapes. A corner now fell to the visitors without result. Nearing the interval Everton had two corners. Half-time-
Villa one goal, Everton, nil.
Devey restarted, and Campbell was away till Mclean robbed him. Hodgetts, however, got possession and raced away, but only to be driven back by Earp. The Villa’s backs were playing a grand defensive game, time after time sending Latta and Wyllie away, till at last Maxwell dribble past Brown and passed to Chadwick, whose shot went past Hinchley, and scored the first goal for Everton, which put both teams equal. Up to that point Everton had certainly the best of the encounter, and through some good combination on Latta’s and Maxwell’s part Chadwick was successful in putting the leather past Hinchley the second time. The pressure on the visitors was maintained with much success three more goals being recorded. Final score;-
Everton 5 goals, Aston Villa 1 goal.

OTHER CLUBS AND THEIR PLAYERS
Burnley Express - Wednesday 02 December 1891
Everton have secured Howarth, the North End full back, the terms being £200 down and £2 per week until 1894.

EVERTON BUY HOWARTH AND TRANSFER THOMSON
December 4, 1891. The Liverpool Mercury
R.H. Howarth was transferred from Preston North End to Everton and S. Thomson from Everton to Accrington

REFEREE
Ulster Football and Cycling News - Friday 04 December 1891
A referee in the Everton v Aston Villa match rounded on the spectators, and told them pretty straight that his position as referee was hard enough to perform without the addition of their howling. A tip for the locals.

REFEREE
Northern Guardian (Hartlepool) - Friday 04 December 1891
The unenviable lot of the referee gets no better, as Mr. C.J. Hughes, the well-known Association umpire was called a cheat, with a strong prefixing adjective at Everton. This sport of thing went on to an intolerable degree for some time, till at last Mr. Hughes calmly blew his whistle and stopped the game. Then with a Number Nine bluff in his eye he strode to the ropes and faced the knot of cads whence the bullying proceeded. He quietly told them that if they wished to see the match continued and played to and end they would have to shut up. So they did.

TODAYS GAMES
December 5, 1891. The Liverpool Mercury
The League will be in full cry this afternoon, and perhaps no match will arouse so much interest as that between Everton and Blackburn Rovers, at Ewood-Park. As will be seen from the name given below, Everton have selected a very powerful team, one which ought to about secure victory eve away from home. Howarth, who played for Everton against Scotland last year, is familiar with the Blackburn ground and players, and this fact should help to make the Everton defence stronger than it has been since last season. If Kelso, too, is fit and well, and the forwards up to last Saturday's standard, an exposition worthy of the journey to Blackburn should ensure. The Rovers apparently will be without McKeown, who has met with a rather serious accident. Everton have no combination match, but play at Anfield the Barrow Club.
Everton v. Blackburn Rovers, Blackburn, Kick-off at 2.30 p.m.. The following will play for Everton; Williams, goal; Earp and Howarth, backs; Kelso, Holt, and Robertson, half-backs; Latta, Wyllie, Maxwell, Chadwick and Milward, forwards. Everton v. Barrow, Anfield, Kick-off at 2.30 p.m. The following will play for Everton; Jardine, goal; Fairbrother and Kent, backs; Kirkwood, Jones, and A. Chadwick, half-backs; Gordon, Murray, Pinnell, McMillian and Elliott, forwards.

EVERTON NEWS
Lancashire Evening Post - Saturday 05 December 1891
That the darkening clouds which have been gathering over Everton suddenly parted on Saturday, and sunshine- momentary sunshine, it may be-broke forth refulgent, and gave buoyancy of spirit and confidence where depression and doubt had appeared to have permanently established themselves.
That the occasion was the meeting of Everton and Aston Villa; that the latter had been going “great guns,” having in their five preceding matches beaten in turn Stoke (away), Darwen (away), Notts (home), West Bromwich Albion (away), and Stoke (home); whilst Everton had cur a sorry figure at Preston, Darwen, and Wolverhampton, and had defeated West Bromwich Albion only on this post at home; that the chances thus favoured Aston Villa, and when the game started at Anfield-road hope, rather than assurance characterised the feelings of the Evertonians. That Everton had a few changes from the team that fell heavily at Wolverhampton, Robertson returning to left half-back, and Mclean superseding Kirkwood on Holt’s right, whilst Collins re-appeared and partnered Earp; that Aston Villa were without Cox, Baird taking his place and G. Campbell going half-back; that these changes were certainly an improvement as far as Everton were concerned, but hardly to the advantage of Aston Villa. That the game was expected to be a grueller, for Everton were determined to exercise all the pluck and skill they could command to shake off the ill-success which ahd stuck to them like an octopus so tantalisingly; that Aston Villa, on the other hand, had many an old account to settle with Everton, as they had never paid a visit in the League competition to Liverpool without suffering a substantial reverse; that the game opened full of promise of being fast and even, despite the miry state of the ground, but that Everton soon got into the proper if latterly unfamiliar line, and always seemed to hold the whip hand, winning, after pressing fully three parts of the time, by five goals to one. That maxwell gave an important display, as did Wyllie in tackling, and Chadwick and Milward in shooting, and that Latta thus found himself by way of a chance, in good company, the forward play being always compact and impressive; that the half-backs could hardly have bene improved even if Kelso had been in his place, and of the backs and goalkeeper they were seldom called upon. That Aston Villa were rarely in combination, and on Saturday’s form made one wonder how they could have won nine games out of a dozen, and have scored an aggregate of 39 goals; that Evans and Hinchley were the two most conspicuous men in the forlorn cause of the Brums.
That Everton visit Balckburn to-day with a much more sanguine feeling than they would have done only a short week ago, especially as Kelso was expected to renew play, and with the left defence deputed to the custody of such an old salt as Bob Howarth, who made his first appearance in the Everton jersey last Tuesday, when Southport central rather surprised an almost full Everton League team by running them closely; that at one time the score was two each, but Milward secured a goal towards the finish, and gave Everton a victory of three goals to two; that the Central were at times very smart in long passes and long shooting; that Frank Sugg, with his heading especially, joined in good defence; that Howarth was well received, but made a few skips and was evidently out of practice.

BARROW AT EVERTON
Barrow Herald and Furness Advertiser - Saturday 05 December 1891
Today will see the first appearance of the Barrow team on the Everton football ground. It is indeed a great honour to meet such a powerful team as the Everton Combination-which is considered in Liverpool circles to be even better than the League team. Now, Barrow, remember your Fleetwood match, and if you play a fine a game as you did then, I rather fancy the Evertonians will have a hard nut to crack. I don’t think for one moment that Barrow will win, but that they will give the “toffee men” a good game. It makes one sigh a little to see that Barrow have such men to meet as Jardine, Gordon, Murray, McMillan, Chadwick, Kent, and Pennels, their champion centre forward. However, here's luck to the wearers of the “chocolate and blue,” and with a strong pull may they create a surprise at Everton. Now, you Barrow forwards, remember good passing sometimes dazzles the best of teams, and this may be so to-day. I believe Jardine, of the League team, keeps goal. I hope to give a full report of the match on Tuesday.

BLACKBURN ROVERS v  EVERTON
Lancashire Evening Post - Saturday 05 December 1891
These teams met at Ewood Park, Blackburn, this afternoon, before 5,000 spectators. The weather was threatening, and the wind was strong and gusty. McKeown was an absentee from the Rovers’ ranks, in consequence of this accident. McLean played in the place of Kelso, and Howarth made his first appearance in a league match with his new club. Teams;-
Rovers.- Arthur, goal; Douglas and Forbes, backs; Smith, Holland, and Forest, half-backs; Hall and Campbell, right wing; Southworth, centre; Watson and Townley, left wing.
Everton.- Williams, goal; Howarth and Earp, backs; McLean, Holt, and Robertson, half-backs; Latta and Wyllie, right wing; Maxwell, centre; Chadwick and Milward, left wing.
Referee; Mr. Lockett, of Stoke.
The Rovers lost the toss and kicked off against the wind. Immediately Everton worked the ball down, and Milward shot against the cross-bar, the ball going through. He, however, was off-side, and the whistle went before he shot. Then Latta should have met the ball from the left, but he slipped and missed a beautiful opening. The first bit of sensation came when Douglas took a kick at the ball from Chadwick’s foot, with the result that it glided off his foot, and went between his own goal-posts, thus scoring the first goal for the visitors five minutes from the start. Robertson had to kick out to stop the home right. Ten minutes from the start Forbes miskicked, and the ball went out. Milward threw in, and Chadwick cleverly dodged Smith and Almond, and centred. Latta rushing up, added the final touch, this notching the second point for the visitors. A moment afterwards Latta sent across, and Milward was heavily dropped when he almost had got the ball through. Arthur fisted out at the expense of a corner, which came to nothing. Play was now transferred to the other end, through McLean handling and from the same trick by Earp the Rovers got a corner. Smith took the kick, and centred well, Campbell meeting the ball with his head and lightly tapping it over Williams’s head, three goals having been scored in the first 16 minutes. For some time the ball remained in the Everton quarters. Holt sent out to save, but on the throw-in he met the ball and kicked it to the other end. It was returned, and some beautiful passing enabled Townley and Southworth to get up, but from a misunderstanding Howarth was able to rub them and avert danger, but not for long, as Townley just failed to get his head in the way of a good one from the halves. Forbes and Douglas stopped an ugly rush from the other end, and almost took up the leather and pass it to the left wing, Walton ending some pretty passing by shooting over. At the other end Chadwick shot wide of the goal, and Arthur gave a corner. Latta took the kick, and put the ball behind the touch-line. A throw-in followed, and meeting the ball Maxwell shot a few inches wide. A piece of foolery on the part of Townley ended in a free kick for hands, and let in Latta, who shot to Maxwell, but the latter failed to shoot straight, and did not score. Robertson stopped Townley at a dangerous moment with a heavy charge. Smith cleverly robbed the Everton left, and passed to Walton, who sent the ball to Townley. The latter passed it to Southworth, who made a wretched shot. Maxwell sent the ball to Milward. Forbes after a smart tussle, beat him, and Chadwick ended up by shooting wide. Townley was next conspicuous for a clever bit of dodging. Play was quickly transferred to the other end, where Arthur had to save twice in quick succession. Up to half-time, Everton had the best of matters both in scoring and in play, the score at the interval standing- Everton 2, Rovers 1.
At the beginning of the second half the Rovers pressed. Townley cleverly beat Earp and shot, but Howarth was all there. Then Williams had to handle, and Latta put in a good shot, but Arthur came out and returned the leather. Then Townley forced a corner. Forest took the kick, but Smith shot over. Williams dropped another corner, and then Campbell caused him to kick out. Howarth stopped Southworth at a critical moment, and then Latta fouled Forest. Forbes took the free kick, and Walton after a bit of scrimmaging in goal equalised. On the re-start Chadwick sent in a beauty, but Arthur saved with Latta on the top of him. At the other end Southworth got the leather from the right pair, and tried a low shot, but did not make sufficient allowance for the wind. Wyllie handed in front of the Rovers’ goal, and then a fine combined attack on the Everton goal followed, but to no avail. The visitors’ goal was in danger a moment later from a free kick for a foul, but Holt relieved, a feat he repeated shortly afterwards. The Rovers were doing nearly all the pressing. Some pretty passing gave Townley an opening and he sent in a terrifically fast low shot. Williams, fortunately for Everton, had his body in the way. The visitors then got to the other end, where Chadwick and Milward were robbed and the Rovers resumed the attack, Almond tried a fast shot, which, in the fading light, appeared to go dangerously near. Then Latta ended in a brilliant, dashing, dodging run, with a shot which went a few inches wide. At the other end Hall and Walton both forced Williams to handle. The attack was very determined, and it was surprising how Williams managed to keep the ball out. During the next minute shot after shot was aimed at him. McLean beat Townley, and some more hot shots followed the free kick, but nothing came of them. After about half an hour’s play Townley put in a capital centre, and the ball was rushed through, but the point was disallowed, apparently on the ground that the ball had been fouled. The light was now getting very bad, the game having started a few minutes late. Everton did a little pressing at this point, but eventually Wyllie headed out the goal, and immediately afterwards Chadwick shot wide. At the other end Townley forced Williams to give another corner, which came to nothing. The Rovers in the whole of the second half did nearly all the pressing, and they had exceedingly hard luck in failing to win.
Result-Rovers 2, Everton 2.

EVERTON RESERVE v  BARROW
Lancashire Evening Post - Saturday 05 December 1891
At Liverpool before 3,000 spectators. The strangers made their first appearance before an Everton crowd, and were well received. Barrow had hard lines in the first half, but found the Combination leaders hard to beat, and turned over with three goals against them. The second half was fought out more evenly, and Everton again were an unbeaten team. Result-Everton 4, Barrow 0

EVERTON RES v  BUXTON
Wrexham Advertiser - Saturday 05 December 1891
At Buxton, on Saturday. The visitors ten minutes after the start, scored, and despite good defence by Buxton, two other points were noticed before half-time. Resuming, F. Kitchen scored, and then Pennell and McMillan made it seven for Everton. Result- Everton seven goals, Buxton, one.

BLACKBURN ROVERS v  EVERTON
Lloyd's Weekly Newspaper - Sunday 06 December 1891
The return match between these powerful teams was decided at Ewood-park, Blackburn, before about 7,000 spectators, who evinced the greatest enthusiasm during the progress of the struggle. Commencing with the wind behind them the Evertonians were speedily seen to advantage, and before fifteen minutes had elapsed they had registered a couple of goals. For some time subsequent the visitors had the better of the play, and the Rovers had to do all they knew to prevent them from augmenting the score. At length the home side rallied, and Campbell scored a capital goal for them, and half-time shortly afterwards was announced with the score two goals to one in favour of Everton. On resuming, the Rovers, with the strong gale in their favour, pressed, but could not get the ball through, Howarth showing splendid defence at back. Ultimately, after some exciting play, Walton from a bully, equalised matters. Afterwards Everton made several determined attempts to increase their score, but were driven back. Neither could the Rovers lower the Everton colours again, though the ball was put through once, but upon appeal the point was disallowed and the game resulted in a draw of two goals each.

EVERTON REVIEW
December 7, 1891. The Liverpool Mercury
Everton did not maintain at Ewood Park on Saturday the strong line assumed at Everton when opposed to Aston Villa; but they did fairly will to make a draw with Blackburn Rovers, who, like all other clubs, are seen at their best when at home. Indeed, they have only been beaten once at Ewood this season, and that was on the occasion of the visit of Preston North End, whilst those who have fallen at Blackburn are Sunderland, Notts County, Bolton Wanderers and Wolverhampton Wanderers. Everton have only once enjoyed the distinction of defeating the Rovers on the latter's own ground, which happened two season's ago, whilst last year, though then obtaining the championship, they were defeated by 2 goals to 1. The Rovers on Saturday undoubtedly missed McKeown , as Douglas was only of moderate assistance; but Everton were without Kelso, and he would not doubt, as he did on September 19, at Anfield, have despoiled Townley's dashing running propensity. The conditions under which the sides took the field were thus about even, and the result was, despite a high wind which blew from goal to goal, that the spectators had the pleasure of witnessing a carefully fought game, brimful of good points. Everton had the wind at the commencement, and went away in such well-knit combination that the two goals early scored were quite merited, for, allowing that Douglas made Everton a present of the point, it should be remembered that Milward, direct from the kick-off, scored with a fine shot, but was adjudged by the referee to be off-side though many thought otherwise. The Rovers improved after threw two goals had been scored against them, and had the best of the later play, whilst the Everton forwards became more ragged in their tactics. The second half was marked by the best periods of the game, but visitors seeming to control the ball better against the breeze than with it. Still the Rovers' forwards, especially the wings, were the more dangerous, and but for the splendid defensive tactics of Everton must have scored. Williams kept goal marvellously, and at one time knocked out five hard shots within the space of about a minute. Howarth was a bit faulty in his kicking at times, but was safe at close quarters, and Earp had plenty to do, and did his work fearlessly and effectively. Holt was at his best and never allowed Southworth to shine, and the forwards worked hard and evenly. Forbes, was too wily for Latta and Wyllie, and the Rovers halves were always smart.

BLACKBURN ROVERS 2 EVERTON 2
December 7 1981
The Liverpool mercury
The return League match between these teams was played on Saturday at Blackburn before about 6,000 spectators, almost whom were several hundred execurtions from Liverpool. The waether was fine, but the players were bothered with a strong wind. Which sweph from goal to goal. The teams were Blackburn Rovers: Arthur, goal, Bougas and Forbes, backs, Smith, Almond, and Forest half-backs; Hall, Campbell, Southworth, Watson, and Townley, forwards. Everton; Williams (R), goal, Earp (E), and Howarth (R), backs, McLean (D), Holt (J), (captain), and Robertson (H), half-backs; Latta (A), Wyllie (T), Maxwell (A), Chadwick (E) and Milward (A) forwards . The rovers kicked off against the wind but Chadwick sent to Milward whot shot the ball through, Douglas vainly edeavouring to stop it. But the point was promptly vetoed on a claim of off-side. The home left wing passed up beautifully though unable to beat Earp, and Robertson returning the ball shortly following to Milward, it was sent across to Latta, but he failed to reach it and a fine movement passed without effect. Everton were determined at this period and closed in soldily, but Forbes cleared in his masterly style, and enabled his left wing to bring on some pressure. They never beame dangerous, however, and the Everton left wing shifted the scene of interst. Maxwell took up the play, and Douglas, when hard pressed, was chagrined to see the ball shoot off the foot and penetrate his own goal, Everton thus assuming the lead luckily after ten minutes' play. Howarth was sson called upon to pay attention to Hall and Campbell and came out well, enabling Maxwell to shoot into Arthur's hands. Earp cleverly dispossessed Walton and Townley, and Maxwell again went away with a good turn of speed and shot. Arthur played the ball, but did not clear and so Latta stepped in and scored with a return. Amidst much enthusiasm from the Evertonians, Maxwell next hit the bar, and Milward nearly beat Arthur from Latta's pass. Everton continued to harras the Rovers defence, and seemed likely to assume a much stronger lead, but they failed to find a loophole, and play took a more open turn, as the home team at length got into speedy action, and made spendid progess, even against the wind. Townley and Walton were the most aggreasive and from a cross-pass Howarth gave a corner which proved fatal as from Smith's place kick Campbell headed under the bar. This gave the Rovers encouragement to renewed efforts, and the visitors' defence were well tried and found sound. Earp especially checking effectivaly. Howarth also robbed the right wing grandly, and Holt was always conspicuous at midfield. The play was spirited and pretty even between now and the interval which arrived with Everton leading by 2 goals to 1.on resuming, Robinson and McLean each beaten by the wings but Earp came to the rescue, and made a couple of clearances. The attack continued on the left, and Townley after one or two attempts, got round Earp, and shot hard and well, but Howarth rushed in and diverted the course of the shot. Back came the Rovers and again Howarth returned the ball to open ground. Forrest had a good chance a few minutes later, but shot too high, and Everton at length reached shooting distance without calling out Arthur. After withstanding a hot siege, Everton contributed a breakaway on the right, where Forbes robbed splendidly, and placed his men on the attack. Smith lifted over, and Williams saved twice, but Latta was penalised with disastrous results, as from the free kick the Rovers scrimmaged a goal. Walton putting on the final touch. The score was now even, and Everton pressed more hotly then they had done since changing ends, Chadwick testing Arthur, and Latta just missing from Maxwell. Everton were busy on the right shortly following but they could not beat Forbes, and the Rovers stormed goal fiercely,, Williams saving from Walton with his shins. Everton rallied once more, without threatening much, and then came a brilliant performance by Williams, he knocking out the ball five times in almost as many seconds. The Rovers continued to have the best of play, during which Townley screwed through magnificently, but Wiloliams had beem obstructe and the point was accordingly disallowed. A high-class game shortly afterwards terminated in a draw of 2 goals each.

EVERTON RESERVES 4 BARROW 0
December 7 1891
The Liverpool mercury
Having no combination fixture to fulfil on Saturday, Everton introduced the Barrow team to Liverpool public, this being their first engagement in this district. Thought beaten by 4 goals to nil they made a very crediable appearance their play at times being heartly applauded by over 2,000 spectators assembled. In the first half Gordon opened the scoring for the homesters and after Jardine was called upon to clear shots by Tadlington and Poole. Pinnell very trickily got though the opposing defence and scored the second point. Before the interval elliott was able to add a third goal, the teams crossing over with the score:- Everton 3 go9als; Barrow nil. In the second hlaf the visitors held their own and put in some clever play. Everton defenders however proved a great stumbling block, to their attack. Nearing the finish Kirkwood further added. The game throughout was pleasing and intersting Pinnell being most conspicous by the clever centre play. Result Everton 4 Barrow nil.

EVERTON AT EWOOD PARK
Athletic News - Monday 07 December 1891
By the Tramp
The return visit of last season’s League champions did not catch on with the Blackburn public as I expected. I hope to see a crowd 10,000 strong at Ewood Park on Saturday afternoon, but there were not many more than half that number present. The afternoon was very pleasant, and why people did not flock to the ground is bad to understand. Jimmy Douglas took the place of the absent McKeown and McLean figured in the Everton half-back division vice Kelso. Bob Howarth made his bow as a professional in a League fixture, and the full teams were;-
Blackburn Rovers- Arthur, goal; Douglas and Forbes, backs; Smith, Almond, and Forest, half-backs; Hall, Campbell, Southworth, Walton, and Townley, forwards.
Everton.- Williams, goal; Earp and Howarth, backs; McLean, Holt, and Roberts, half-backs; Latta, Wyllie, Maxwell, Chadwick, and Milward, forwards.
Referee; Mr. H. Lockett.
Losing the toss, the Rovers were set to face a stiffish wind which blew in the direction of the town. The ball travelled down the field with little effort, and it was a manifest advantage to have the breeze during the first half, whilst the players were fresh. There was a sensation in the first minute or so, Milward kicking the ball against Douglas, whence it flew into the net. “Off-side,” however, was the verdict of Mr. Referee Lockett, and his decision was taken without murmuring. Dismay was writ large on the faces of the Rovers very soon afterwards, Douglas being guilty of a serious error. He got up his foot to a shot from Chadwick, twenty yards from the posts, but instead of stopping the ball he diverted it over his head and through the goal. Arthur was so taken back by the untoward incident, that he made his effort to repair mischief too late. After some useless finessing at the other end the ball was back again, and Arthur had no sooner thumped away a shot by Maxwell than he was promptly beaten by Latta. Things began to look sultry for the Cup holders, but their prospects brightened hugely on Campbell heading a goal from a lovely centre by Albert Smith. It was now that the home team approached something like their true form, Townley’s fast runs and Hall’s sturdy play on the opposite wing being often helpful in breaking through the opposition. Crossing over with only a goal in hand, and a strong wind to battle with, was not very comforting for the visitors. Their friends declared they would be satisfied with a draw, evidently conscious of the inability of the team to improve their position. Whilst Everton monopolised the attack in the opening half, the bulk of their work now fell on the defence. Arthur made one or two smart saves, but it was not often that his powers were called into requisition. Latta was found guilty of fouling Forrest, and such good use was made of the free kick by Forbes that Walton equalised with a header. It was at this stage that the Blackburn section began to breathe freely. Their favourites were almost continually bombarding, and it was mainly the smart tactics of the goalkeeper that prevented the Cup holders from taking the lead. Try as they would they could not circumvent him again, and Townley having a goal disallowed for some infringement or other, the final verdict was a draw of two goals each. Everton had thus the satisfaction of booking three League points out of two matches with their Blackburn rivals. It was a capital game from start to finish, and from a Rovers’ point of view Douglas’s blunder was extremely unfortunate. It was one of the most curious incidents I ever saw, and about the biggest slice of luck imaginable for the visitors. Jimmy is, of course, not now class enough for a League team, but he lacks nothing for the sake of trying. Forbes soon detected the weak spot, and it was a treat to see him dash across and tackle the left wing when he saw the old warhorse likely to be beaten. Johnny is a rare tactician, and loves to be in the thick of the fight. It was pleasing to see Arthur in such good form. One of his saves when he dribbled the ball clean away from Milward was a gem, and he did another equally as clever a bit of generalship with Latta in close attendance in the second half. He is fairly earning a bumping benefit a week to-day. Smith was again the crack of the half-backs, Almond also shaping pretty well in the centre. The forwards were very uneven. Southworth passed unselfishly, but his shooting was poor. Hall and Campbell were a good wing, and now and again Townley put in a dashing sprint all alone, but Walton did not give him so much assistance as usual. None of the quintette shot for goal to my liking. Turning to the Everton forwards, let me first speak of Maxwell. When I saw him at Preston, where he made his debit for Everton, I declared he was not of the right metal. He funked terribly and placed in very mediocre fashion. Not so at Ewood Park, however. He might have been another player altogether. He kept his place and rarely missed anything that came in his way. His shooting with the wind at his back was of the proper stamp, and he gave Herbie more real anxiety than any two forwards in the team. All the front rank were well up to their work, Latta shinning on the right, as did Chadwick and Milward on the left. The latter screwed in finely several times, his efforts in this line deserving better success. Holt was the “dab” of the half-back division. He’s a wonderfully tricky player, and invariably popped in to the relief of his side when the pressure was heaviest. Sometimes Robertson came off creditably, but McLean had more than his match in Townley. He’s not quick enough for such a flyer as the light-footed pedagogue. Earp and Howarth may be termed a safe pair of backs without being flashy. “Bob” took matters as philosophically as usual, and constantly refused to be hurried or flurried. Some of his saves were extremely smart for all that. I like Williams as a goalkeeper. He does not seem to be troubled with nerves, and with ordinary luck his place in the team ought to be a certainty.
Other notes from Athletic News
FRED GEARY
Fred Geary will not be asked to play for Everton until the first round of the National Cup tie next January. On Saturday, Everton and Blackburn Rovers played their first drawn game in the League competition since its institution.
Everton will be able to say that they had the best of the League with the Blackburn Rovers. They won the first game and drew the return, so that they did well to squeeze three points out of their Blackburn rivals. By the way the Everton men set to work at Ewood they looked like romping in, but they did not maintain their form, and had it not been for Douglas’s curious performance the Rovers would just have won. It was a capital game, and one could not help speculating on what a splendid team could be constructed out of the twenty-two players.

LIVERPOOL AND DISTRICT
Athletic News - Monday 07 December 1891
By The Loiterer
By all accounts we appear to have done very well at Blackburn to come off with a draw. I have spoken to several, who say that the Rovers scored a third goal, and they cannot understand why it was not allowed. On all hands the performance of Williams is highly spoken of. It is strange, but this young man’s abilities were sounded in my ear before he joined Everton, and by no other than a Blackburn man. I cannot say that he is a member of the Rovers’ club, but he is a strong supporter, and business brings him to Liverpool very often. He saw Williams perform over the water several times, and was much impressed with his abilities as a goalkeeper.
The Everton Committee invited the players to a dinner at the Sandon last Tuesday, but only a few of the Committee attended. Why?

BARROW v  EVERTON
Barrow Herald and Furness Advertiser - Tuesday 08 December 1891
The Barrovians journeyed to Everton on Saturday last to play the renowned Combination team, without Whitehead and Fred Poole, whose places were filled by Blackburn (a Preston man) and Skinner. A Poole went centre forward, and Spiers was removed to half-back. There were over 5,000 spectators present, and the ground was in good condition with the exception of in front of the goals, where the rain had made it rather “sludgy” and bad  for both sets of backs. Everton won the toss, and Barrow had to face a strong wind. Elliott and Macmillan were the first to show up with a splendid passing run from a pass by Pennells, and soon after this player missed a splendid chance with being “too tricky” in front of Artis. Elliott eventually shooting hard past the post. The visiting forwards were cheered for a piece of brilliant passing, and Poole dodging past Jones, gave Saddington a chance, and Jardine was forced to handle and kick away a fast shot from the Barrow left. Marshall dodged past the home left, and then gave to Shaw, a quick race between the latter and Kent resulting in Shaw shooting wide of the mark. Gordon and Murray, by grand quick passing, got right down to the Barrow goal, and Artis was cheered for a miraculous save from a swift one of Gordon’s. The long-legged Pennell’s next caused roars of laughter by the simple way in which he “mesmerised” the visitors, but Nettan outwitted him, and gave to Poole who made a splendid dribble to Kent, and then passed to Shaw, who centred, but Fairbrother returned with a ponderous kick. Elliott and McMillan dribbled nicely down the field, and Fenton missing the ball, Pennells looked likely to score, but Marshall clean robbed him of the ball and cleared with a good kick. Everton now pressed barrow severely, and their forwards were conspicuous with a piece of magnificent passing. Fenton having to concede a corner to save. Elliott took the kick, but Blackburn headed away nicely. A moment later Gordon had a shy, Artis fisted out, and Mettam gave a corner. Murray next put in a splendid “grass-leveller” which Artis managed to turn round the corner of the goal to save. The corner to the home team came to nothing. Blackburn headed away a shot by Pennells, but the latter a moment later received the ball from Gordon, and put in a high swift shot which Artis cleared from under the bar amidst cheers. Poole and Marshall reached the Everton goal by some fine short passing, and Poole to gave to Sherliker, who tried a shot, and Jardine cleared. “Hands” against the homesters, and Marshall headed just past the post. A piece of really grand passing between Pennells, McMillan, and Elliott was stopped short by Spiers who took the ball from Elliott and kicked to Mattam. Good play by Sherliker, Saddington  and Skinner resulted in Saddington shooting and Kent conceding a corner to save. Spiers took the kick which landed the ball right in front of the posts, Mettam eventually shooting high over the bar. Some brilliant passing by the Barrow forwards was spoiled by Shaw shooting wide. Artis stopped four successive shots amidst cheers, but at length Gordon (who was behind the Barrow backs) sent in a swift one which Artis failed to reach. Pennells next scored a beauty from neat half-way, which should have been headed away by a Barrow back, but went through the goal. Artis was cheered for a magnificent save in the corner of the goal, from a swift one by McMillan. Sherliker was hurt, and had to retire, but came on again soon after. Gordon centred well after a hard tussle with Sherliker and Mettam, and Elliott scored. Half-time, Everton 3 Barrow 0.
Artis was loudly applauded on changing ends. With the aid of the wind it was thought Barrow would do better, but soon after the restart Mettam and Fenton were prominent with some good saves. Poole now got off with a splendid run, dodging past first one and then another, and passing to Shaw, whose centre shot was taken by Fairbrother, the latter clearing with a huge kick. Marshall got away and gave to Poole, who re-passed to Dick, and the latter made a well-merit try at the Everton goal, Kent giving a corner. Blackburn stopped Pennells just in the nick of time. Again the visiting forwards, by neat passing, reached the home goal, but Poole stuck to the ball too long, and Jones cleared with a long kick. Shaw got away, but Kent charged him off the ball and cleared. Good play by the Barrow left pair, Marshall, and Shaw, after a fine save by Penton forced Jardine to concede a corner, which proved of no avail to the visitors Mettam tried a long shot which went just past the post. Artis was again cheered for two splendid saves-and this is all the more pleasing seeing that he was playing without bars in his boots, in the sludge as well. A brilliant race between McMillan and Spiers resulted in the former passing nicely to Elliott who had a shot at goal, Blackburn clearing. Saddington, at the other end gave Jardine a hard one to stop. Everton now pressed, and Pennells gave to Gordon who shot at goal but found Artis waiting, and the latter easily threw the ball out. McMillan had a shy at goal, and Blackburn accidentally handling the leather, a free kick was awarded the homesters, Kirkwood took the kick and the ball struck the bar and went inside the net, but the appeal of Barrow for no goal was disallowed. Artis next stopped a hard shot by Kirkwood from a free kick; Pennells just falling to score a moment later. The Barrow forwards next got off, but Kent cleared. Chadwick took a shy at goal, Fenton heading away nicely. The Barrow forwards got away, and after some grand passing Poole shot, and Jardine cleared. The whole of the Barrow forwards failed to send the ball through the goal with only Jardine to face. Artis again saved a swift low shot by Pennells on the ground. A tussle lasting five minutes ensued, Artis eventually clearing with all his opponents forwards on him, amidst ringing cheers- a really magnificent piece of play. Time was now called, and the result of the best game yet played against the Combination team was Everton, 4; Barrow, 0.
Teams;-
Everton; Goal, Jardine; backs, Fairbrother, and Kent; halves, Kirkwood, Jones, and A. Chadwick, forwards, Gordon, Murray, Pennells, McMillan, and Elliott.
Barrow; Goal; Artis; backs, Fenton and Blackburn; halves, Spiers, Mettam, and Sherliker; forwards, Shaw, Marshall, A. Poole, Skinner, and Saddington.- Referee, Mr. J.M. Sloane.

EVERTON LEAGUE v  SUNDERLAND
Liverpool Echo - Friday 11 December 1891
TO THE EDITOR OF THE LIVERPOOL ECHO
Sir,- With reference to the above match, I beg to suggest that the match should commence not later than 11 a.m., so as to enable all comes to attend the “match of the season.” 1. that by starting at that time (11 a.m.) it would suit everyone who wishes to attend. As the match would be over about 12.40 it would give spectators nice time to get to their homes or to their friends’ houses in all parts of the surrounding suburbs, as well as in the city in time for Christmas dinner. 2. That by starting then it would not interfere with Sunderland’s team, as they will moist certainly arrive the previous night. By granting the above been the League champions’ committee, I feel sure will get the heartfelt thanks of the vast crowd who will patronise the match. Thanking the committee in anticipation and yourself for insertion.- Yours. &c., J.B.

TODAYS GAMES
December 12, 1891. The Liverpool Mercury
Everton at home is the attraction for local associationists this afternoon, when they will fight out the return battle with the Wolverhampton Wanderers. Three weeks ago Everton found themselves face to face with the cleverer set of opponents at Wolverhampton, and were beaten soundly by 5 goals to 1. This was at Molyneux ground. What will happen at Anfield-road today? Everton if the players whose names are given below turn out fit and well, should certainty give the proverbial “Roland for the Oliver,” and even emerge with a better goal return out of their two engagements with the “Wolves.” Later events have presented Everton in stronger colouring than hitherto, their defeat of Aston Villa and draw with Blackburn Rovers being two of their smartest achievements this season. On the other hand, Wolverhampton Wanderers were beaten pointless at Bolton a week ago; and as Topham will doubtless be again an absentee, patrons to the Everton ground will not feel anxious about the issue, though, should the Wanderers play the same brilliant game they did three weeks back, Everton’s resources will be tested to the last move.
Everton v. Wolverhampton Wanderers, Anfield, Kick-off at 2,30 p.m. The following will play for Everton; Williams, goal; Harp and Howarth, backs; Kelso, Holt, and Robertson, half-backs; Lattas, Wyllie, Maxwell, Chadwick and Milward, forwards.
Everton v. Northwich Victoria, Northwich Kick-off at 2.15 p.m. The following will play for Everton; Jardine, goal; A. Chadwick and Collins, backs; Kirkwood, Jones and Lochhead, half-backs; Gordon, Murray, Pinnell, McMilliam, and Elliott, forwards.

EVERTON v  WOLVERHAPTON WANDERERS
Liverpool Football Echo - Saturday 12 December 1891
The wretchedly wet weather of the week left the football grounds in a very muddy condition, and the “going” to-day was o the heaviest description all round. Notwithstanding the uncomfortable surrounding, however, there was a good crowd present on the Anfield enclosure this afternoon when Everton and Wolverhampton Wanderers commenced hostilities in their return League engagement. When the teams first contested at Wolverhampton on November 21, the “Wolves” fairly took it out of the League champions and gained a meritorious victory by 5 goals to 1. Since then the Wolverhampton contingent have knocked Blackburn Rovers to the tune of 6 goals to 1, but the merit of this achievement was greatly marred by their defeat last Saturday, when Bolton Wanderers had the best of them by 3 to nil. On the other hand, Everton’s supporters were somewhat comforted by the apparently returning form of their pets, a 5 to 1 victory over Aston Villa and a drawn game with Blackburn Rovers being voted a good performance. The teams started to-day with as even number of points (13) recorded in the League table, but as the Wanderers had played a couple of matches more than the toffy boys the supporters of the Anfield combination expressed themselves very sanguine of seeing the Liverpool cracks ascend the League ladder another step.
The heavy and incessant rains of the past week had rendered the ground in a sodden and sloppy condition, and in soe parts it was extremely treacherous. To add to the discomfiture of both players and onlookers, rain, sleet and snow began to descend shortly before noon, and continued increasingly throughout the afternoon, which had a pronounced effect upon the attendance, which fell considerably below the usual dimensions. The teams were as under;-
Everton League.- Williams, goal; Earp and Howarth, backs; Kelso, Holt, and Robertson, half-backs; Latta, Wyllie, Maxwell, Chadwick, and Milward, forwards.
Wanderers.- Rose, goal; Baugh and Mason, backs; Davis, Malpas, and Kinskey, half-backs; Wykes, Baker, Wood, Devey, and Booth, forwards.
There would not be more than 2,000 spectators only the most ardent enthusiasts braving the elements. Wood started hostilities punctually at 2.30 and play was first made up the visiting right. Robertson then defeated Wykes for possession, sending to Milward, who removed play in front of Rose. Holt gave to Chadwick, who shot in as fast as the ground would allow, just missing by about a foot, Howarth was applauded for a fine movement, and then Latta sent in, but Mason sent the ball back. After a very few minutes’ play the ground immediately in front of goal was literally a series of pools of water, and it was a matter of considerable difficulty for the players to keep their feet. Latta shot grandly into Rose’s hands, and Mason assisted the custodian to give relief. Keeping up an attack, however, Everton at last succeeded in drawing blood, Chadwick defeating Rose with a fine swift shot ten minutes from the start, Latta almost repeating the trick a moment later. The game was very evenly contested for some time and each goal in turn was assailed though, of course reliable passing was out of the question, and some of the incidents in the sloppy turf were highly amusing. Latta, Wylie, Maxwell, and Chadwick indulged in some neat passing, the latter’s shot missing by about a yard. Wykes and Baker dribbled up the field, but when Howarth was reached he gave them the order to retreat, pulling them up in the coolest possible manner, Booth went away, and passed to Devey, who had no opposition save Williams, but his shot went wide. Play was now again at the Wanderers end and Milward only just missed scoring. Malpas gave to Wood, and this player, with Devey made off at top speed, the latter scoring for Wolverhampton. The play continued of a give-and-take character, each side putting in their utmost. Robertson was applauded for smart play, after which the home left indulged in a pretty movement, and the ball was sent right across to Latta, who registered goal No.2 for Everton. This success spurred on the homesters to further efforts, and play continued in the visitors’ half of the field. The Wanderers’ backs and halves, however, put in all they knew, and kept the Wanderers at bay. Wood and Devey got to the other end, and Booth had a shie, but Earp repulsed and Holt further improved his side’s position. The ball during the last few minutes of the first half travelled between the respective goals, and both teams tried their utmost to score. Earp was slightly injured, which caused hostilities to be momentarily suspended play. The interval was shortly afterwards called with the score;- Everton 2 goals, Wolverhampton Wanderers 1 goal.
Maxwell restarted, and for the first five minutes Everton attacked persistently, but failed to break through the able defence shown by the Wanderers’ backs. Maxwell shot into Rose’s hands, and the visiting custodian effected a magnificent clearance whilst lying upon the ground. Whilst in this position Rose came into contact with an opponent, and for a few seconds play was stopped. Everton certainly were lasting better than their opponents, and for some time troubled the defence. Eventually the Wanderers’ forwards got in front of Williams and for a time the spectators looked on with bated breath, expecting every moment a score, but Williams kept out every shot sent in to him. Everton forced two corners in succession, but in each instance Mason gave relief. Wyllie was very near bringing about the downfall of the Wanderers’ citadel, but found Rose a stumbling block. Devey and Booth then got off on the left, being pulled up by Kelso, and Earp sent to midfield, where Latta and Wyllie took up the running and passed up to the right prettily the former shot only falling to go through by a few inches. A goal kick now gave relief, and then the Wanderers obtained a brief spell pressure, but play was not destined to remain here long, as Holt and Kelso removed play behold the half-line, where hostilities were for some time carried on, Milward and Chadwick indulged in a movement on the Everton left, and sent across to Latta, who failed to reach the ball. Holt, however, rushed in, and then Chadwick tried to get off but found it too much for him. Still Everton attacked, and Latta centred to Wyllie, who failed to take advantage of the opportunity.
Final Result; Everton 2 goals, Wolverhampton Wanderers 1 goal..

NORTHWICH VICTORIA v  EVERTON
Liverpool Football Echo - Saturday 12 December 1891
COMBINATION MATCH
Played at Northwich before 2,000 spectators. Snow rendered the ground in a wretched state. The game in the first half was very fast, Northwich having, if anything, slightly the best of it, the wind being against Everton. After thirteen minutes play Pickering shot from the left but Jardine was not troubled, it merely skimmed past five minutes later. The shot by Everton on the right was stopped by Harper, the ball being returned to the Everton end, where Leatherbarrow made a fair attempt, which went wide. Pools of water stopped the ball and rendered play difficult. Pickering the reserve International player for England, next shot from the left, and it was narrow shave. Burroughs next sent in a beautiful shot, and Jardine had to pull down the bar to let it go over, a proceeding which caused some protest. Murray also shot into Harper’s hands. At half-time there had been no scoring. Ten minutes after resuming, Everton, playing smartly with the wind, scored 3 goals, Northwich Nil.
Final Result.- Everton 3 goals, Northwich nil. Pinnell scored all the goals for Everton.

EVERTON REVIEW
December 14, 1891. The Liverpool Mercury
The well-wishers of E. Chadwick and J. Holt are reminded that the next Saturday’s match at Anfield, which is between Everton League and Notts Forest, is set apart for the benefit of these two familiar, popular, and clever members of the Everton team. It is not easy to say how far the prestige of the Everton Club is due to their pluck and skill, but certain it is that Holt’s consummate resources at centre half-back and Chadwick’s equally effective tactics as inside left wing forward have always been a main factor in its attainment. They have been the most regular members of the team, and have enjoyed singular immunity to their excellent tact. They deserve, and will receive, practical and very substantial recognition of the value of their services by Evertonians and others.
Everton and Wolverhampton Wanderers, though the weather conditions were no more favourable at Anfield than elsewhere, played off their return League match without besmearing the character of either team. Indeed, each side has rather gained prestige than otherwise from their displays on Saturday, for the game was an admirable demonstration of good football on a very slippery ground. It was an even contest, fast and interesting all through, and that Everton won by 2 goals to 1 was about a true reflex of the tendency of play. The rout of three weeks back at Wolverhampton has thus been avenged, if not thoroughly atoned, for a win in which the balance is only one of a single goal is not a fair set off of a defeat of 5 goals to 1. But it is something meritorious to be capable of turning a reverse into a win, and by their success Everton step up to fifth position in the League. The visitors had not the same representation as met Everton before, but Mapas, at centre half-back and Wood, centre forward, were quite as good men as Allen and Topham, and altogether the Wolves represented a very evenly balanced team, which was strong at all points in well-judged, long kicking, and stern without undue roughness in their tackling –Mason, Rose, and Kinsey especially defending well. The forwards were speedy and fearless, and the right wing the more difficult to cope with. Everton were ever demonstrating a feeling of confidence. They never flagged, however, and it was not for want of trying that the measure of their success was not greater. Maxwell had difficulty in keeping well up to the wings. Chadwick and Milward have got back to their old state of efficiency, and were stronger if anything than the right wing. Latta played with his customary dash, but did not get quite so much assistance as he should have done from Wyllie. Kelso returned, and though rarely at fault, seemed tame beside Holt and Robertson, both of whom were seen at their best. Earp increased his popularity by his brilliant play, his kicking being a treat to witness, and though accidently kicked just before the interval, causing him to limp, he played out to the finish with rare pluck. Howarth was safe, without being flashy, and Williams sustained his high character. Everton are visited by Witton tomorrow.

EVERTON 2 WOLVERHAMPTON WANDERERS 1
December 14 1891
The Liverpool mercury
Played at Anfield on Saturday in presence of 3,000 enthusiasts who braved the elements. The ground was in wrected condition and accurate play was rendered anything but an easy task. The teams were as follow:- Everton; Williams (R), goal; Earp (E) and Howarth (R) backs; Kelso (R) Holt (J) (captain), and Robertson (H), half-backs, Latta (A), Wyllie (T), Maxwell (A), Chadwick (E), and Milward (A), forwards, Wolverhampton Wanderers, Rose, goal; Baugh, and Mason, backs, Davis, Maspas, and Kinsley, half-backs, Wykes, Baker, Wood, Decey, and Booth, forwards . Everton soon got into their stride, and straightway set about finding some work for Rose. The forwards put plenty of dash into their work and after Wyllie lost a good chance by failing in the mud, Chadwick took a smart pass from the right, and drew first bllod. Almost directly thet were back again, but Latta shot pas. This served to waken up the Wanderers, and adopting clever long passing tactics, which admirably suited the ground, Woods and Devey took a prominent part in some eciting work in the vicinity of Willaims. A foul drove them back but they came again, and this time made no mistake, Devey doing the trick. Both teams now went at it hammer-and-tongs fashion. Maxwell narrowly missed scoring from a short return by Rose. Earp stopped a good attempt of the ‘'Wolves'' to get away, and after Robertson had put in some clever tackling. Rose was agin called upon, and ultimately Latta caught up a pretty centre from Milward, and put Everon ahead with a shot which gave the ‘'wolves'' custodian no chance. The play was give-and-take up till half-time, and no more scoring was done. Everton resumed with ten men, Earp having been injured, but he speedily returned, and then Everton began to pepper Rose in lively style. This custodian however, proved equal to all contingencies through badly injured on one occasion. Hostilities were soon resumed, and then Mason helped his forwards to raise thesiege at the other end. Here Wykes and Wood got down in front of williams, and it seemed all over with Everton until their custodian pulled off a magnificent save at the cost of a corner. Nothing resulted, and Latta raced away to other end, where Maxwell and Wyllie were too slow to take advantage of excellent openings. They still kept up the pressure, and hard lines were expected. After Rose had clearned a shot which beat both the backs the ‘'wolves'' were agaon dangerously near Williams. Howarth and Earp soon drove them back, and Milward all but got through. The last few minutes proved very exciting but nothing more was scored and Everton ran out winners by 2 goals to 1.

EVERTON v. WOLVERHAMPTON WANDERERS
Athletic News - Monday 14 December 1891
A HARD GAME AT EVERTON
By The Loiterer
It is only three weeks ago that the “Wolves” beat Everton by five goals to one. Jardine was blamed for it, and has not played for the League team since. The weather in Liverpool has been of an average kind, the wind rather above the common on Thursday evening, but as footballers out of work it was all right until Saturday morning, when the elements got a bit complicated, and it may be safely said that we had a thorough mixture during the forenoon, with the result that the Everton ground was in a bad condition-not so bad, perhaps, as some football enclosures, but quite bad enough, especially at the Oakfield-road goal. The teams were as follow;-
Everton.- Williams, goal; Earp and Howarth, backs; Kelso, Holt, and Hope-Robinson, half-backs; Latta, Wyllie, Maxwell, Chadwick, and Milward, forwards.
Wolverhampton Wanderers.- Rose, goal; Baugh and Mason, backs; Davis, Malpass, and Kinsey, half-backs; Wykes, Baker, Wood, Devey, and Booth, forwards.
The play was very fast at the start, with no advantage to either side, and Chadwick was the first to score from a pass by Kelso, but Devey soon equalised. Throughout the first half there was very little in the teams, but the plays always had a tendency in favour of Everton. The home team, however, did not play the correct game for the day. I cannot see why such a wealthy club as Everton cannot have a rough-weather team, as well as one that gives a drawing-room entertainment. There was a wide difference in the style of the two teams, and I must confess that I liked that adopted by the visitors. Short passing is all very well in its way, and looks pretty, but when the ball sticks in the mud a few yards short of its intended destination, and an opponent comes quietly forward and kicks it away, the effect is somewhat tarnished. This is what we were treated to, exception being made to Milward, who sent in a fine shot, which Rose very cleverly saved. Latta now and again essayed a long one, but they were rather too strong. The visiting forwards kept the Everton halves fully occupied, even if they did not test the abilities of Earp and Howarth so often. The left wing were the most prominent all through the game, and things looked badly for Everton when Earp let in Booth, but Howarth and Williams between them were equal to the occasion, and the Evertonians breathed freely once more. Soon after a second goal fell to Everton, the left wing working the ball up, and Latta put the finishing touch on. The visitors claimed that the ball had been out previously, but “Bobby” Stockton did not see it-not likely-and Mr. Johnson allowed the point, 2-1 being the state of the spoil at half-time. The play, on resuming was as fast as ever, and it speaks well for the stamina of both teams that the speed was kept up right to the finish. There was a lot of midfield work, in which the “Wolves” showed to the best advantage. The first real attack though came from Everton, and Rose had all his work cut out in stopping Maxwell’s shot. He injured his wind arrangements in the effort, and this just reminds me that there were several players limping about. The play was not at all rough, and the injuries were due more to the state of the ground than anything else. The visitors kept pegging away, and presently Kinsey gave Devey and Booth a chance. Like several attempts of the Wanderers, in which, by the way, these three were always to the fore, a score was very nearly effected. For a while the players could not extricate the ball from the mud, and first one and then another had a try, but at last Baker shot in, and Williams very cleverly saved. The home team now took up a more vigorous attack, in which Latta alone shone. All the lot came off in bad shooting. The only decent one sent in was by Milward, followed by a long one by Earp and Rose saved well on each occasion. In the meantime, the Wanderers left made gallant attempts to get down to the other end, but the ball was worked out. Each goal had narrow escapes, but nothing more was done, and Everton won by two goals to one. When you consider the state of the ground, the play was surprisingly fast throughout. Rose had considerably more to do than Williams, and kept goal very well. Baugh was the better man at back; mason got his leg injured early on, and, with Latta and Wyllie going so strongly, he was fortunate several times to clear. He had a splendid chap in front of him, however, and this youth fully earned his money. Kinsey’s display outshone the other halves, and he was the best man on the field. There was a great contrast in the style of the opposing forwards, and the way the visitors plodded through the mire was far more satisfactory than the attempted short passing by the homesters. Hope-Robinson was again prominent in the half-back division, but he had not so clever a pair to face as Kelso. The backs had not a great deal to do and very few mistakes were made.

LIVERPOOL AND DISTRICT
Athletic News - Monday 14 December 1891
By The Loiterer
The English Cup ties in Liverpool should produce good games. Everton should just about pull through against Burnley. The club is more fortunate this year in playing at home, and a canter with Burnley on January 2 should give us some clue as to which will probably win on the 16th. Bootle have a hard nut to crack in Darwen.
There is bound to be a great “fite” on Christmas Day, when Sunderland will be at Everton. I don’t like such an important fixture as a League match being decided on this merry day-it is not in keeping with the surroundings. I hope everything will pass of all right, and may the better team win. The “gate” is sure to be of huge dimensions, and Mr. Jackson anticipates a record. On Boxing Day the Echo and Express match takes place, and this should be another great draw. I hope so, if only for the sake of that deserving institution, the Stanley Hospital. Mr. Jackson is working hard for it, and as a life-governor he wants the money to come in well.

EVERTON v  WOLERHAMPTON WANDERERS
Birmingham Daily Post - Monday 14 December 1891
Played at Everton. Everton had their full team, but the Wanderers were short of Topham. Snow was falling when the kick-off was taken, and there were only about 2,000 spectators present. Everton played the best game on a very soft and treacherous turf, and Chadwick scored after seven minutes’ play. The visitors played up, and Devey equalised. The game after this was of a more even character, Baker having hard lines at one end and Latta at the other. Devey and Wood passed the whole field and the former had no one in front but the goalkeeper, when he made a poor attempt. Latta ran in, and tried Rose with a long shot, and again Devey had a grand chance, which he spoiled by being slow. There was further even play, and then Latta from a pass by Milward, scored the second goal. Earp was lamed, but nothing further occurred up to half-time, when the score read- Everton 2 Wanderers 1. On restarting Latta tried a fine shot, but found that he was off-side. Everton were having much the best of the game, and Maxwell nearly scored with a fine shot, Rose in saving, falling on the floor and pluckily throwing the ball away, but was temporarily injured in the effort. The visitors made an impression by fine play, and Baker had a good opening at short range. Williams, however, saved grandly. Everton after this had a good deal of the game, and Latta had hard lines with a shot, whilst Wyllie was knocked off the ball when he got well in front. Towards the end of the second half Rose made some grand saves, this saving his side from heavy defeat.
Result- Everton 2 Wanderers 1.

EVERTON v  SUNDERLAND FOOTBALL MATCH
Liverpool Echo - Tuesday 15 December 1891
TO THE EDITOR OF THE LIVERPOOL ECHO
Sir- It is in my opinion an excellent suggestion to have the Everton v Sunderland match on Christmas morning instead of the afternoon. Most of mu acquaintances prefer to spend Christmas afternoon in the bosom of their families, but are quite ready to go to see a good match in the morning. As the Sunderland team are to arrive in Liverpool on the Thursday evening it cannot make much difference to them which way it is. Hoping the suggestion will be adopted, yours, &c., SPECTATOR.
TO THE EDITOR OF THE LIVERPOOL ECHO
Sir.- In conjunction with many Evertonians, I notice with pleasure the suggestion that our team should play Sunderland on the morning of Christmas Day instead of the afternoon, as at present arranged. It is impossible for spectators living outside of Liverpool to patronise the match without in the majority of cases missing their Christmas dinner. But if the kick-off be fixed for 10.30 or 11 a.m. everybody would be able to enjoy the match and arrive home in time to enjoy also their Christmas dinner. Thanking you in anticipation yours, &c., QUINZE.
TO THE EDITOR OF THE LIVERPOOL ECHO
Sir.- I trust that the Everton Committee will, as “J.B” in his excellent letter suggests, not delay the kick off in the above match later than 11 or 11.30 a.m. by so doing I am sure they would receive the warmest thanks of hundreds besides myself who reside at a distance from the ground, and who would not be able to see the game should the kick-off not take place until the afternoon. I should immensely like to see the game started at 11 0’clock which would enable me, amongst many others, to get home comfortably in time for the Christmas festivities.- Yours, &c., Seaforth.  HOPEFUL.

EVERTON v  WITTON
Liverpool Echo - Tuesday 15 December 1891
Played at Everton this afternoon, before a limited number of spectators. Maxwell kicked off, and an immediate race was made to the front of the Witton goal. After one attempt had been made to capture the visitors stronghold, Milward sent in a capital shot, which all but scored. For a long time the home team kept up a strong attack, the Witton goal being subjected to a continual bombardment. At length by way of a change the
(Unfortunately paper faded to read 18 lines of the addition of the paper)
Free kick, they were enabled to make another attack, but without the desired result. Then the homesters rushed down and forced a corner, Wyllie afterwards sending in a capital shot, the Witton goalkeeper effecting a grand save. Shortly afterwards Maxwell dodged several of his opponents, and sent in a clinking shot which struck the crossbar, the ball rebounding on to the goalkeeper’s foot, and then going between the posts. In another minute McMillan added a second goal for Everton, and with the exception of one break away by the visitors, the home team kept very busy in the neighbourhood of the Witton goal.
Half-time score;- Everton 2 goals, Witton Nil.
Directly after the restart the Evertonians went away, and troubled their opponents’ defence, and fully ten minutes elapsed before the visitors succeeded in crossing the half-line. Here they did not long remain, for Gordon obtained possession, and dashed down the right, and then passed to the front of goal to McMillan, who when he shot through was manifestly offside. Milward then shot wide, after which Kent checked the visitors’ left, and gave his comrades another opportunity. This came to nought, the Witton players rushing down to the Everton goal, Sharples scoring their first point. In a very short space of time afterwards Wyllie scored the third goal with a clinking shot and then Milward added the fourth before the visitors could fairly recover themselves. After a scrimmage in front of the Witton goal, Gordon and Wyllie passed up again to within shooting distance, and then a partial clearance was made. Kelso met the ball, and sent in a fast low shot, which passed between the goalkeeper’s legs. Play still continued in the visitors’ half, and after a barren corner had fallen top Everton, the visitors made a rush down to home quarters, but Gordon and Wyllie passed prettily back again, and after Kelso had the benefit of a good throw in, McMillan scored the sixth and last goal for Everton. Final Result;- Everton 6 goals, Witton 1 goals.

EVERTON 6 WITTON 1
December 16 1891
The Liverpool mercury
A match between Everton and Witton was played at Anfield-road yesterday. The weather being very dull, foggy and wet, the attentance was only small. Whilst the ground of course, was in a most rendly condition. Everton had a mixed represntation the names being as follow:- Williams (R), goal, Kent (J), and Fairbrother; backs, Kelso (R), Robertson (H), and Collins (J), half-backs, Gordon (P), Wyllie (T), Maxwell (A), McMillan (J), and Milward (A), forwards. The home team at once pitched play in front of the Witton goal and got in one or two shots. The ball bung in the mud a good deal, and this fact, together with good smart defence work, served the visitors in good stead until they could not at length get the ball over the half line. Here Kent intercene and the Witton men were immediately hard pressed. The custodian parrving a fine shot from the right. Other narrow escape were survived. And than the Witton forwards varied the monotony by a couple of quick but ineffectual movements to the home goal. Everton were certainly trying for goals but, though they passed and shot satisfactory they could not beat the defence. Witton next got far enough down to shoot near the post on the left, and to this Wyllie repied by shooting grandly. The custodian however, made good use of the fist. Everton continued tolay siege, and at last met with success. Maxwell scored. The ball glacing of the goalkeeper's foot. Striking the post and then bouncing through. McMilan, quiclely following sent in from the left and made the record to goals. In favour of Everton which was the score at the interval. Goingaway from the restart the Witton centre-forward wound up a fine run by shooting near the post with a low aim, which rather severely tested Williams in clearing with his foot. Everton took up the attack repeatedly,, but were a long time before a piercing goal and even then it was done in an irregular manner, as McMillan finished off clever, passing between Wylli, Maxwell and himself by shooting through, when off-side. The Witton left wing and centre joined in a pretty piece of forward play and were getting dangerous but Kent checked them. A few minutes later, however Witton came out again in the left and sharpies screwed in and though the ball sticking in the mud hjust under the bar. The home team brighted up their shooting in response to this Witton success. And out of several shots got a couple home Wyllie and Milward each scoring a capiatl goal. Keeping up the pressure Everton forged further ahead as Kelso shot from a long range with such force that the custodian was compelled to allow the ball to pass between his hands and legs. Towards the finish from a throw in by Kelso, McMillan added another goal, and Everton won by 6 goals to 1.

EVERTON AGAINST SUNDERLAND KICK-OFF TIME CHANCED
December 16 1891
The Liverpool mercury
Meanwhile we are informed that at a meeting on Monday evening the Everton committee had under consideration suggestions that had been made to fix the kick-off in the great League match on Christmas Day between Everton and Sunderland at an earlier hour than usual. In deference to the wishes of many mebers who considered it undersirable that football should clash with religious observances, and from other well considered reasons the committee decided that half-past two was the most appropriate time for kick off.

EVERTON v. WITTON.
Manchester Courier - Wednesday 16 December 1891
Played at Everton, yesterday afternoon, before limited number of spectators. Maxwell kicked off, and an immediate race was made to the front of the Witton goal. After one attempt had been made to capture the visitors' stronghold, Milward sent in capital shot, which all but scored. For a long time the homo team kept up strong attack, the Witton goal being subjected to a continual bombardment. At length, by way of a change, the visitors went over the half line, and for moment looked dangerous, but Fairbrother then accounted for his opponents' rush, and gave the ball to Milward, who galloped through the slush, but could not score. Shortly afterwards Maxwell dodged several of his opponents, and sent in clinking shot which struck the crossbar, the ball rebounding to the goalkeeper's foot, and then going between the posts. In another minute McMillan added second goal for Everton, and with the exception of one break away by the visitors, the home team were kept very busy in the neighbourhood of the Witton goal. Half time score Everton, two goals; Witton, nil. Directly after the re-start the Evertonians went away, and troubled their opponents' defence, and fully 10 minutes elapsed before the visitors succeeded in crossing the half line, the Witton players rushing down to the Everton goal, Sharpies scoring their first point. In very short space of time afterwards Wyllie scored the third goal with a clinking shot, and then Mil ward added the fourth before the visitors could fairly recover themselves. After a scrummage in front of the Witton goal, Gordon and Wyllie passed again to within shooting distance, and then partial clearance was made. Kelso met the ball, and sent in a fast low shot, which passed between the goalkeeper's legs. Play still continued in the visitors' half, and after barren corner had fallen to Everton, the visitors made a rush down to home quarters, but Gordon and Wyllie passed prettily back again, and after Kelso had had the benefit of a good throw in, McMillan scored the sixth and last goal for Everton. Final Score:  Everton 6 Witton 1.

NORTHWICH VICTORIA 0 EVERTON RESERVES 3
COMBINATION MATCH
December 17 1891
The Liverpool mercury
These teams met for the first time in a combination match at northwich. Though the weather was wet and gusty there was a capital attendance. During the first half the home team had the help of the wind, and did most of the pressing but no goals were scored. Everton were soon to better adavntage at the second stage and scoring three goals (all from pinnell's shots). To nil, added another subtantial win to the unbeaten record. Everton team: Jardine (J) goal, Chadwick (a), and Collins (J), backs, Kirkwood (D), Jones (R), and Lochhead (A), half-backs, Gordon (P), Murray (P), Pinnell (A), McMillan (J), and Elliott (J), forwards
Played 12, won 11, lost 0, draw 1, for 57, against 6 points 23

NORTHWICH VICTORIA v. EVERTON.
Nantwich, Sandbach & Crewe Star - Friday 18 December 1891
These teams met for the first time in connection with the football combination, at Northwich, on Saturday afternoon. Up to the commencement of the match, snow had fallen heavily for about two hours, but it quickly melted after reaching the ground. The result was that the field was in bad condition; in fact, after the game had proceeded a few minutes, it became a sort of quagmire, rain descending during the whole of the afternoon. The teams were :—Northwich Victoria :—Harper, goal; Postles and Scanlan, backs; Dalton, Brown, and Stanley, half-backs ; Pickering, Hayes, Finnegan, Leatherbarrow, and Burrows, forwards. Everton ; Jardine, goal; Chadwick and Collins, backs; Kirkwood, Jones, and Lockheed, half-backs; Gradon, Murray, Pinnall, McMillan, and Elliott, forwards. Referee, Mr. Gough, Liverpool. The home team winning the toss, they elected to play with the wind in their favour. Very soon after the commencement of hostilities the home right wing got well down, and Hayes sent in a very nice shot, which, however, Jardine fisted out. A foul was soon afterwards given to the Vics, within a few yards of the visitors' goal. This was taken in hand by Finnergan, but quickly got away. Play was then transferred to the other end, but no advantage resulted. Pickering put in a good run, and made an excellent effort to score, but the sphere passed just outside the upright. Everton from the free kick worked the leather in front of Harper, who cleverly saved a somewhat difficult shot. After several minutes' play in midfield, Finnergan got possession, and sent in a beauty; which skimmed the crossbar as it passed outside. Burrows also kicked with good judgment, but, the ball went over the bar, the height of which Jardine reduced by several inches by one of his tricks. The Liverpool lads then became dangerous, but Postles and Stanley speedily returned. Northwich were again on the defensive, and a shot by Elliott went wide of the mark. The ball was taken down by Pickering, who passed to Leatherbarrow, whose fine effort was without effect. A piece 0f nice passing by Pickering and Hayes resulted in a corner, which was taken by Stanley, but a clearance was easily made. Hayes gave Jardine a very difficult shot to negotiate, and this he did with success. Half-time arrived without the registering of any goals. The match had scarcely been resumed when Everton galloped down the field and forced a corner, which was placed behind. Thence for a short time the visitor's put in great pressure, but Burrows securing possession got away, and one of his opponents in trying to rob him handled the ball just beyond midfield. The free kick was beautifully put in, but Chadwick and Collins, who were defending well, sent the globe towards the other end. After a bit of tricky work by Pickering and Hayes, the ball was centred to Finnerhan, who put it a few inches on the wrong side of fly upright.  Play was reversed, and McMillan sent in a scorcher, which Harper saved whilst full length on the ground. A fruitless free kick by Stanley having been taken, Pinnell secured the sphere. and succeeded in registering the first goal. The same player within the next two minutes, by means of a long shot, scored a second time; and three or four minutes later he again put the ball through the posts, 'thus obtaining three goals within some seven minutes. The home players did their utmost to score, but all their efforts were unavailing. The match ended— Everton; 3 goals; Northwich Victoria, none.

TODAYS GAMES
December 19, 1891. The Liverpool Mercury
The followers of the Association game in Liverpool have a high function to engage their attention this afternoon, as last season's League and Alliance champions –Everton and Notts Forest –meet at Anfield for the purpose of playing a match for the benefit of J. Holt and E. Chadwick. The Foresters have been to the Everton ground once before this season, and were then beaten by 2 goals to nil –a reverse only once repeated we believe, by any other club –and they will naturally try hard to place themselves on an equality with Everton at this renewed opportunity. This ambitious design will, of course, be sternly combated by Everton and the game, if the weather conditions are suitable, should rank as one of the best of the series at the Anfield enclosure. But apart from the equality of the play that may be in store, the object of the entertainment should prove a sufficiently powerful magnet to secure a full assembly, for Holt and Chadwick have done their duty well, for Holt and Chadwick have done their duty well, and played an incalculably important part in popularising the Association code in Liverpool thus helping thee advance the status of the Everton Club to that high pitch which has commanded a succession of fixtures with the strongest teams in the kingdom.
Everton League v. Notts Forest, at Anfield (Holt and Chadwick's Benefit), Kick-off at 2.30 p.m.. The following will play for Everton; Williams, goal; Mclean and Howarth, backs; Kelso, Holt and Robertson, half-backs; Latta, Wyllie, Maxwell, Chadwick and Milward, forwards.
Everton v. Chirk, Chirk. Kick-off at 2.15 p.m. The following will play for Everton; Jardine, goal; A. Chadwick and Collins, backs; Kirkwood, Jones, and Lochhead, half-backs; Gordon, Murray, Pinnell, McMillan, and Elliott, forwards. Reserves Kent and Fairbrother.
Friday (Christmas Day)
League; Everton v. Sunderland, Anfield.

NORTHWICH VICTORIA v  EVERTON
Chester Chronicle - Saturday 19 December 1891
Played at Northwich on Saturday in wet weather. Very soon after the commencement the home right wing got down, and Hayes sent in a very nice shot, which Jardine fisted out. The Evertonians became dangerous, but Postles and Stanley speedily returned. Northwich were again on the defensive, and a shot by Elliott went wide of the mark. The ball was taken down by Pickering, who passed to Leatherbarrow, whose fine effort was without effect. A piece of nice passing by Pickering and Hayes resulted in a corner, which was taken by Stanley, but a clearance was easily made. Hayes gave Jardine a very difficult shot to negotiate, and this he did with success. Half-time arrived without the registering of any goals. Upon resuming Pinnell secured the sphere, and succeeded in registering the first goal. The same player within the next two minutes scored a second time, and three or four minutes later he again put the ball through the posts, thus obtaining three goals within seven minutes. The game ended -Everton 3 goals; Northwich Victoria, none.

AT EVERTON.
Illustrated Sporting and Dramatic News - Saturday 19 December 1891 
THERE is an element of heroism in the spectator of modern football matches which ought not to escape notice. He throws down his glove-- or perhaps I ought to say his umbrella-- at Dame Nature's feet, and defies her utterly. If she grants him a serene sky, a windless day, and a nice dry ground for the game, she is a brick and he feels a vast deal of gratitude towards her. But on the other hand she may be in one of her worst humours-- and we have had plenty of reason to know how bad these can be! Still, it is all one to the enthusiast. Let there be a driving snow with a blighting wind, and inches of half congested ooze on the ground; let the wind howl its most furious menace of congestions, pleurisies, inflammations, coughs, colds, and consumptions, and the snow descend at the neck- nape till it be a drift an inch in vertical height it is all one to the man who has made up his mind he will see the match. He is content to take his chance. He may (it is perhaps even betting he will) by next Saturday be lying in his coffin as the result of his temerity. No matter -he will gather his pleasures while he may -at all costs. Of such human stuff it seems to me much may be expected in the hour of need. Where else in the world, save among Anglo- Saxons, is there such sublime self-devotion? Our dear friends on the continent must really someday invade our tight little island with half a million fighting men just that we may show how the same qualities which set us watching a football match in a snowstorm and shivering quietly all the while, will serve us well enough to pack the relics of their half million fighting men in double-quick time back across the Channel. This is rather a stately exordium for Everton; and I hope the Anfield Road team and its committee will appreciate the compliment of it. But truly it is provoked rather by the vile weather of the other day than by any feeling of inordinate regard for the little suburb of Liverpool which is already known all over the world for its toffee. It does not do to carry one's prejudices into the football field. I neither love nor hate any football team; they all inspire respect or contempt merely according to the qualities of their play. I leave to others the fits of infantine feeling and bellowing if that team of their predilection does not satisfy them, or if its antagonist gets the upper hand of them. There is a deal too much of this idiotic petulance abroad. I suppose "money "is at the bottom of much of it. Certainly no one can aver that the Everton League team has not been well supported by shekels. If money makes a team win matches, Everton ought again to be at the head of the League, and to stay there. In blinding snow and a high wind I journeyed on the top of an omnibus to the Anfield Road football field. The vehicle, like many of its fellows, went thither and nowhere else this morning. Its patrons were therefore of the kind one knows so well on the football field.: the public-house potman side by side with the impressive bank clerk in chessboard overcoat. No one individual among them was effeminate enough to carry an umbrella: for the most part indeed they faced the elements without even a waterproof. They talked of the coming struggle with an ardour that warmed them and their neighbours alike. Now and then from our perch we looked upon the top of a house the slates of which had been battered in the other night by a fallen chimney pot. There were many such. Liverpool, including Everton, seems to want no repetition of its experience of December 10, 1891. As for the fragments of tiles and terra-cotta in the streets and gutters, by their abundance they reminded me of a visit I paid some years ago to the site of a prehistoric city in an Hellenic island where the hillside was littered with broken earthenware pots and pans even to its temple steps. And even as we looked we beheld one chimney-pot, already overthrown and recumbent on the slates, glide with the added impetus of a gust and the slippery snow, plunge over the precipice of the gutter- spout and crash into a thousand atoms on the pavement. It seemed well that no human head had been at hand to give us an unrehearsed tragedy on our way to the football field. At the entrance a leaflet is thrust between the yielding fingers of the visitor. It is a sign of the times with a vengeance. "The Everton Committee earnestly request the assistance of the supporters of the organisation in protecting the referees officiating on the ground from insult and abuse." The leaflet proceeds to remark upon the arduousness of the position of the referee, and the excellent character hitherto borne by the Everton spectators; this latter it hopes will never be lost. Here's a pretty picture of actualities if not in Everton, elsewhere; but there is no need to dilate on it. There are times when the ordinary witness of a football match feels ashamed of his race. I do not claim to be immoderately endowed with gentle instincts but I have several times writhed with disgust at the brutal and dishonourable clamouring of my fellow bipeds against players and referee. No doubt the latter wears a cuirass upon his breast and wool in his ears. He is supposed to be concerned with his eyesight only, but there are times when he is off his guard and then he suffers in the same degree as the rest of us. The referee who two or three weeks ago stopped the game to protest against the blackguardly speech of two or three gentlemanly personages did well. It is a pity he was not empowered to do more than this. Anon we may expect the law of libel to be involved in aid of order on the football field, and enforced too with profitable severity. Of the Everton field itself more in praise might be said in dry weather than in wet weather, and herein of course it is not singular. Its arrangements are upon the whole admirable for the populace. They have the two ends to themselves and a nice hard, airy wooden tier to sit upon of course, however, there is no better for them and as umbrellas are not to be endured because of their obstructiveness, a man must be tolerably robust to join the mob here in bad weather. For those with an extra shilling or sixpence in their pockets there are covered stands the whole length of the field on both sides. This at once argues the Everton clientele a rich one; and we all know that Liverpool is not a poor place. It is also a somewhat varied one; never was I more astonished than to find myself neighbour hero to a woman with three small children. The audacity of the ordinary football spectator is considerable but this woman surpassed it. I think she must have been a baby farmer though, to do her bare justice (in spite of the inclement weather), her charges looked healthy enough. But neither they nor she took the least interest in the game. We must certainly have legislation to keep football to our own sex, or at least to keep aloof mothers and their tender off spring. The influences attendant upon the league football matches are not exactly of the educative or idyllic kind. Everton must be congratulated on having so good a field so near (speaking comparatively) to the centre of Liverpool. It is about a quarter of an hour's ride from. the shipping offices, and, like the course of the boy in Excelsior ever upward. The streets of residences on the way are not fair to see, save for the man who is enamoured of dull uniformity. But they debouch at length upon a tolerably spacious bit of common land (as we will call it), which on match days is soon trodden into a bog. The enclosure adjoins, and undesirable suburban rows press it on all sides; so closely too that from the stand during the interval in the game I could see a family eating buttered toast by the fire, and two canaries in one cage, billing and cooing with an ardour that told how little they felt the marrow- piercing rawness of the outer air. The spectacle of the unlovely boards of the football field stages so contiguous to their own back yards, and so obdurately opposed to any further prospect, must be galling to the tenants of these houses -nor have they compensation in the frenzied shouts which intermittently break into their domestic privacy, spite of shut windows and conversation ever so engrossing. There's no need here to tell of the trials the Everton Club have had about their field. Suffice to say they pay a rent for it that none but a rich club could Pay.  It is the same with their team. You soon learn -either through observation or the prattle of your neighbours -that the Everton player's are chefs d'oeuvre of their species. They are not paid quite enough to enable them to keep yachts and country houses and dogcarts with tigers in crimson lively (a washed-out crimson being the Everton colour), but it seems not improbable that a time will come. It is much that they receive gold pieces a week each, even though they may be still in their teens, and quite silly from an intellectual standpoint. I believe I am right when I say that Everton throws its cash at the feet of Scotchmen and even able Englishmen with a lavishness far in excess of any other football club in the known universe. But if Everton is thus the Mecca of the football player, How is it, one asks, that the team does not again, as last year, head the league list? The answer is not difficult it is due to the very opulence of the club; they are like the millionaire in search of happiness. This compassionable gentleman wastes his time in indecision whether this course or that will bring him most felicity, or else he takes pleasure after pleasure in full doses until he becomes sick of the sweet feast. The former parallel better fits the case of Everton. The club has such a plethora of talented players that it does not know how best to combine them; an embarrass de pieds. They cannot all be adequately exercised at once, and they must not be allowed to stiffen in inactivity and fall into the snares that beset the idle athlete. Fate too has been a little unkind in injuring these rare-logged young men one after the other. Geary, their centre forward, has long been on the sick list. Adjectives have been exhausted in praise of this prodigy, who a year or two ago was "in the market” at a cheap rate. His reappearance on the field will result in such a tumult of joy as no one except a leading statesman, a prima donna, and a centre forward nowadays inspires., These various circumstances have concurred in disappointing Everton; they have yet to learn, however, that, spite of proverbs and general belief, money is not all, even in football. As for the play of the Everton League team at Everton, it is characterised by the same all compelling vigour which other league teams must for their credit (nay, their existence) sake display in their home meadow. It is only “away” that the league team can afford to take matters easily, and be beaten. I am mortally afraid that we shall soon find all league matches "foregone conclusions;" then the rage for the carnivals o! Saturday afternoon's--" Our Grand Winter pastime." The phrase runs -will suddenly burst like a defective ballon.

EVERTON v.  NOTTS FOREST
Football News (Nottingham) - Saturday 19 December 1891
PLATERS BENEFIT MATCH
The Foresters met the famous Liverpool team this afternoon for the second time. In the early days of the present season they played against Everton on the ground of the latter and sustained their first and only defeat so far at the hands of a League club, Everton just winning by a narrow majority. The Liverpudlians were so delighted with the “reds” that they invited them to play a benefit match at Everton later in the season, J. Holt and Edgar Chadwick to be the recipients of the gate money. The admiration in which the two players mentioned are held, and the fame of the Foresters combined to being together a crowd of some eight thousand spectators. The weather was all in favour of a good “gate,” but the ground weas somewhat sticky for the players. Forest had not their best team. In the first place “Tich” Smith and Fred Thompson were away playing for England against the Trans-Atlantic footballers; Russell was not considered quite well enough to play, and it was deemed advisable to run no risk in view of approaching encounters; and Higgins, although nearly recovered from the injury he sustained at Sheffield, was not thought fit to be off the sick list. Mills, a soldier from Chatham, and a player who was a shinning light in the Swift’s team against the Wednesday Reserve, filled Tich Smith’s place; Mr. Lindley kindly took Higgins’s post; while Walters, also a swift, played vice Thompson, as left half back. Everton, who have been playing a strong game of late, were well represented, but Nottingham spectators were disappointed to find that Fred Geary was still absent from his place as centre forward, not having properly recovered from his serious injury sustained some time ago. The teams appeared on the field as follow;-
Everton.- Williams, goal; McLean and Howarth, backs; Kelso, Holt (Captain), and Robertson, half-backs; Latta and Wyllie, right wing; Maxwell, centre; Chadwick and Milward, left wing.
Notts Forest.- Brown, goal; Ritchie and Scott, backs; Hamilton, Macpherson, and Walters, half-backs; Mason and Mills, right wing; Lindley, centre; Pike and Shaw, left wing.
The Foresters won the toss, and Everton started the ball, going straight at the visitors’ goal. Scott and Ritchie worked the ball away, but for the next few minutes the defensive powers of the “reds” were sorely taxed, the famous left wingers, Chadwick and Millward being particularly aggressive. Maxwell also showed that Everton has been lucky in securing such a man to fill the vacancy caused by Geary being disabled. After an exciting time in front of the Forest goal, the visitors got away, and retaliated in fine style; but after an ineffectual attempt they were beaten back, and again confined to their own half for a time. At length they broke away, and made a spirited attack on their opponents’ goal. Williams and his backs having a very anxious time of it. The former saved very cleverly a couple of fine shots, and then Latta tested Brown’s goalkeeping at the other end. The right-winger sent in a magnificent shot, and Brown only just managed to keep the ball out, slipping down in his effort. A minute later Kelso tried a long shot, which failed to hit the mark, and the backs clearing the Forest right went to work in earnest, and Mills and Mason playing with great dash. The Everton backs were worsted, but Mason’s shot went wide. The game was very fast, and each goal was attacked in turn. The “reds” forced a corner from McLean, but it was not improved upon, and Everton inaugurated another attack, Maxwell being prominent in a rush, which ended in a corner being secured. Defending very finely the Forest backs had little difficulty in making all clearance, and the centre forward with Mills and Mason carried the game into Everton’s territory again, but they were compelled to retire. The home team then made determined efforts to start the scoring, and shot after shot was sent in without success, Brown coolly picking up the ball and shieing it  clear over the heads of the opposing forwards. The ability of the Forest goalkeeper did not pass unheeded.
Half-time arrived without either side being able to score;
Forst 0 Everton 0
Lindley re-started the ball, but the forward division could not get through the defence, and the “reds” were compelled to retire into their own quarters, where they had a warm time of it for the next few minutes. Scott frequently distinguished himself, whilst the half back Walters tussled hard with the tricky forwards opposed to him. Robertson sent in a long shot, which, however, failed to hit the mark; but still the Evertonians pressed; and narrowly escaped scoring once or twice. The Forest defence was perfect, and won the admiration of the crowd, who more than once heartily recognised smart play on the part of Macpherson, Scott, and Ritchie. Every member of the visiting team played with vigour, but the forwards found their match in the opposing backs. The same may be said of the Everton forwards, and in fact it would be difficult to say which was the strongest team. At last the Forest front division got started, and astonished the onlookers with as pretty a bit of passing as was ever seen. Macpherson finished up with a stinging shot, which Williams jumped up to and just put over the cross-bar. Then each side attacked in turn, the Foresters having every bit as much of the game as their opponents. Unproductive corners were taken by each team in quick succession, and then Brown again greatly distinguished himself, saving fine shots from Robertson and Chadwick in the most brilliant fashion. Matters now began to look serious for the “reds,” Everton being most persistent. But the backs averted disaster, and cleared their lines somewhat. A parting shot nearly brought up the desired end, however, Brown almost failing to reach a regular “grass-cutter.” Finally, the visitors succeeded in driving out their opponents, but they were not long allowed to remain on Everton ground, fine play on the part of McLean, Holt, and Robertson ending in the Foresters being cleared out before they could do anything. Everton got in front of the Forest goal, but could get no opening, despite the fact that all the forwards worked exceedingly hard. The game continued to be hotly contested, the Foresters trying hard to break though the defence of their sturdy opponents. Lindley started his men off on several occasions, but they could do nothing, and Everton again got slightly the upper hand. Responding to the cries of their supporters they swept down on the Forest goal in a body, but the “reds” never missed a kick and worked with a will, and the whistle blew before any score could be made, a splendidly contested game ending in a draw.
Forest None Everton None

EVERTON v  NOTTS FOREST
Liverpool Football Echo - Saturday 19 December 1891
HOLT AND CHADWICK BENEFIT
Happily the weather to-day was entirely different to that experienced last Saturday. The snow, rain, and fog had given place to a clear atmosphere and cheering sunshine, and the many “pilgrims” made their weekly journey under very happy surroundings. Four of the League clubs stood down from the contest, but excellent games in this series were provided at Bolton, Derby, Nottingham, Stoke, and Wolverhampton. Locally there was more than ordinary satisfaction expressed in football circles at the change in the atmospheric surroundings, Everton League having the eladers of the Alliance as visitors at the Anfield enclosure, the proceeds of the game being for the benefit of Holt and Chadwick. Both men are well known to followers of the winter pastime, and their powers as exponents of the dribbling code are admitted on all hands. Both have done their full share in bringing the Everton team to the very forefront of Association football, and a mark of appreciation is all the more becoming seeing that they are not imported players, but English lads born and bred. It will be remembered that Notts Forest paid a visit to the Anfield ground on September 21, and that a well-contested game ended in favour of the Liverpool club by 2 goals to nil. Everything was in favour of a big attendance to-day, and there was a large crowd present when the kick-off took place shortly after the advertised time. Two of the old Everton “warhorses,” J. Holt and Edgar Chadwick-than whom in their respective positions, two superior players would be difficult to find-took a well deserved benefit at the Anfield-road enclosure this afternoon when the Everton league team encountered Notts Forest, the Alliance cracks. The attendance was a large one numbering some 8,000, and the money taken at the gates, in conjunction with the quantity of tickets sold privately ought to secure a bumper for the beneficiaries.  Maxwell started, and for a short time the Foresters were confined to their own half, and several attempts were made to pierce the Nottingham goal, but the sterling defence of the Robin Hoods defied all the attacks of the famous Leagues. At length the visitors’ right wing broke through, and an onslaught was made by the Notts Forest men, only to be quickly repulsed. The Notts men made another fruitless attack, after which Chadwick and Milward put in one of their characteristic pieces of work, and went down the field in fine style, but Milward was ruled off side, and this put an end to what promised to prove a bit of interesting work for them. The visitors then gradually worked their way up to the Everton goal, and a rattling shot was sent in to Williams, who saved coolly and cleverly. After this the Leaguers went to work with a will, and Latta missed, but the opposite wing quickly took up the attack, and some really clever work was done by Chadwick, Milward, and Maxwell, but after the ball had been cleared from the Forest goal mouth, Kelso sent in a long shot which the Notts goalkeeper had some difficulty in negotiation. Then McLean had a rare tussle with Shaw, but came off with flying colours, and very shortly Maxwell gave the ball to his right wing, Latta making a dashing run and sending in a capital shot into Brown, who came to earth in his attempt to save. The Foresters than went over the half line, but had scarcely a look in when they came to tackle the rare line of the Evertonians. Shortly after the visitors got to the front of the Everton goal, but were defeated. First corner shortly after fell to the visitors, and then Maxwell went down to the visitors’ territory, and Brown had for a short time as much work to do as he cared for. Another fine bit of work was done by the Everton left wing, who were at length robbed, but McLean shortly after cleared the Everton lines. A fruitless corner fell to the Notts men before half-time and Everton were going down the field when the whistle sounded.
Half-time score;- Everton nil, Forest nil.
Lindsay restarted for the visitors, who were quickly compelled to retire into their own half and not strictly on the defensive, Robertson putting in a fine long shot, but without the desired result. The Evertonians continued to press their opponents, who certainly played up with vigour, but were apparently unable to meet the tactics of the League team. At length the Foresters went down in style, and McPherson put in a staging shot, which Williams put over the bar. Then the Everton men attacked strongly, and for some time made matters particularly warm for the visitors, who were for some time in sore straits. A capital shot was sent flying into the Notts, goal, but Brown was all there when wanted, and saved brilliantly. Then alternate attacks were made by either team, and the visitors lost several opportunities, but in most cases the defence was stronger than the attack. Maxwell made a good run and shot for Brown, who again saved cleverly.
Final Result;- Everton Nil, Notts Forest Nil.
Everton league;- Williams, goal; McLean and Howarth, backs; Kelso, Holt, and Robertson, half-backs; Latta, Wyllie, Maxwell, Chadwick, and Milward, forwards.
Notts Forest.- Brown, goal; Ritchie and Scott, backs; Hamilton, Macpherson, and Walters, half-backs; Mason, Mills, Pike, Shaw, and Lindley, forwards.

CHIRK v  EVERTON
Liverpool Echo - Saturday 19 December 1891
COMBIANTION MATCH
Played at Chirk to-day, before a small number of spectators. Chirk kicked off. After Everton had nearly scored, Elliott centred well, and Murray headed in. Pavey saved, and a corner resulted, which was cleared. A free kick for Everton was not made much use of, and then Chirk got a corner. James scored first goal for Chirk. Gordon had a good chance, but failed badly. Jardine had to kick out a long shot. Then again Jardine saved a good shot from Egan. From a pass by Gordon, McMillan shot and Pavey saved at the expense of a corner. This was well played, but after exciting play the danger was removed. Jardine saved twice, but on the second occasion he was hurt, and the game stopped directly after. Restarting Gordon equalised the score. A shot by Elliott skimmed the bar.
Half-time score;- Everton 1 goal, Chirk 1
Final Result.- Everton 1 goal, Chirk 1 goal.

EVERTON REVIEW
December 21, 1891. The Liverpool Mercury
Everton were occupied in giving a benefit to Holt and Chadwick, who certainly have dore their share, and more in building up the prestige of the Everton Club. Notts Forest were their opponents, and the principals were thus the champions of last year's League and Alliance. Notts Forest have, moreover, played very strongly this season, and are equal to an average League team. The weather, too, was fine, and with all the promise of a clever and pleasant game the attendance of about 8000 was not so great as it should have been. The covered reserved stand was thinly occupied, and it was evident that the high charge had proved prohibitive. However, the event was far removed from failure, and both Holt and Chadwick will be recipients of a substantial sum. The game was a capital one, the feature of which was the sterling defence on either side, especially that of the Forest, who had a hard time of it in the second half. Everton did most pressing, but shot none too well, latta and Maxwell being the cleverest of the home forwards.
The programme for the Christmas season is of a more momentous character than usual, especially Christmas Day, when Everton at Anfield play off their return with Sunderland. In playing Sunderland, Everton encounter, perhaps, the most powerful team in the county, and many have doubted the wisdom of having arranged such a serious piece of business on a festive occasion; but however exacting the contest may prove to the players, the public will be well satisfied with the privilege of spending the afternoon in witnessing a game that may have the effect of deciding whether or not Sunderland will be eventually hailed this season's champions. On Boxing Day the Anfield enclosure will be occupied in the afternoon by Everton league and Glasgow Rangers, who will decide a return match. Everton having won when in Glasgow on October 1 by 4 goals to 1.

EVERTON 0 NOTTINGHAM FOREST 0
December 21 1894
The Liverpool mercury
These teams played for the benefit of Holt and Chadwick on Saturday at Anfield. The weather was all that could be dirsed, but the attendance scarely came up to expectally considering the prestige of the visitors. The teams follow; Everton; Williams (R), goal, McLean (D), and Howarth (R), backs, Kelso (R), Holt (J) (capatin), and Robertson (H),half-backs Latta (A), Wyllies (T), Maxwell (A), Chadwick (E), and Milward (A), forwards. Nottingham Forest; Brown, goal; ritchie, and scott, backs, Hamilton, Macpherson and Walters half-backs, Mason , Mills, Lingley, Pike, and Shaw, forwards. Immediately following Everton kick-off, Robertson, Chadwick, and Milward joined in telling play on the left cuiminiting in Chadwick shooting narrowly over. Robinson again dispossessed Mason and Mills and enabled Milward to go ahead, but his shot struck the outside of the net. Everton kept well up, however, and Maxwell scooped the ball just a little wide. The Forest now got tairly under weight, the left wing passing McLean but he overtook Pike and Shaw, and drove clear. Again the visitors took up the attack but were still prevented from becoming dangerous. A third time they broke away and now got in a shot, what Williams properly attended to. Chadwick made himself prominent in tricky play, but it was of no avail, and better efforts weremade by Pike and Lindley each of whom shot well. Williams having some difficulty in stopping the straight one of the latter. Howarth finally rushed in front of goal, and cleared. Latta caught on and made a strong running shot, but was a little wide in his aim. Some smart play on the home left supplemented Latta's fine contribution. Milward had a fair shot at goal, and a moment later sent across to Latta nicely but the latter could not quite get up to drive the ball goalwards. A hot attack was indulged in by Everton, who were conceded a couple of corners, while Brown saved cleverly from a spanking shot by Maxwell. Latta returned and kicked hard but scott got his foot against the ball in its fight,, and so stemmed what looked loke being na fatal shie. It now became Notts turn to try their skill at close quarters, when Lindley at an opportune moment went off-side. The visitors maintained some pressure, during which Kelso was penalised for hands. But the free kick was easily rendered abortive, and Latta who appeared to be in a most spirited mood scampered off again, and shot brilliantly. Brown made only a partial clearance but no one fortunately for him, was hardy to send in a quick return. Ritchie robbed the Everton left, but McLean headed back to Latta who went off in a dashing dodging run, to be baulked near the goal-line. Everton fairly stormed goal during the next few minutes. Milward screwed in once and Maxwell shot in the right direction but had not made sufficient allowance for stickly ground,, and the ball stopped short by a few inches. Mills next wound up a fast movement by shooting well from the right, but Williams was safe. Pretty play, by way of reply was seen between Maxwell, Chadwick, and Milward, who forced a corner, and from the advantageons position that ensued Robinson and Kelso tried a long shot. Maxwell also sent in hard, but Brown gave further evidents of much resource in goal, and it was evident it would require a very keen shot to beat him. Shaw a little later on caused some anxiety to Evertonians on getting in a good aim, which Williams was only just in time to turn behond the post. The foresters also gave some trouble on the right but after much tumbling about the lines were cleared momentarily. Notts at this period were several times near scoring but the interval arrived with the sides even and the score nil. On resuming Williams had to throw out, and with the let off Everton settled down to a protracted siege on goal. Maxwell would doubtiess have scored had he not been foul by Hamilton, and then Milward and Wyliie each sent in a fairly good shot. A better attempt was that by Kelso, who tried from a long range. The pressure on the visitors' goal was severr, but the defence proved strong, and held out until the Foresters could move down in open order, when McPherson tested Williams with a hard and straight shot. Latta from Robertson and Maxwell again grew threatening, but Scott pervented an accurate aim. Lindley next headed a raid. McLean arrested the movement, but yet Willaims was called upon to negotiate a shot by Pike. The game returned to its general phase, of Everton raining shots in every direction round the goal, but never to get one through. Maxwell's aims being particularly good. Lindley varied things by going off down the centre; but when drawing near goal he paused to look round, and Howarth promptly took the ball away, and another ineffectual onslaught was carried on by Everton, with Latta and Maxwell the most conspicuous men in working hard to reduce the apparently impregnable Notts Fortress. And so the game proceeded. Both sides were well matched, and the visitors came out so strongly in staying power that towards the close they had rather the best of play; but there was no beating the defences, and a keen game ended in a draw, no goals having been scored.

CHIRK 1 EVERTON RESERVES 1
COMBINATION MATCH
December 21 1891
The Liverpool mercury
This match was played at Chirk. Both teams were well represnted. Everton were the first to show up, but had hard lines whilst James shot the first goal for Chirk. Jardine saved wellm, but was hurt and the game was stopped for some time. Gordon equalised. In the second half Everton only played ten men, Kent who had been injured in the first half, not reappearing. Chirk had the best of the play during the half, but Jardine had not many shots to stop, as Chadwick and Collins kept the home forwards in check. Everton were dangerous a few times, and Lochhead nearly scored. Towards the finish Chirk pressed. The game resuled in a draw 1 goal each.
Played 13, won 11, lost 0 draw 2 for 58,, against 7, points 24

LIVERPOOL AND DISTRICT
Athletic News - Monday 21 December 1891
By The Loiterer
I fully expected a much better attendance at Anfield on Saturday, on the occasion of Hall and Chadwick’s benefit. The heading on the bills was attractive enough, but failed to draw 7,000 people. The “gate” reached £119, and then, in addition, there are a number of tickets sold. This is not bad, but, like me, I think the players were disappointed. They have done more for the club than any of the £100 and upwards “down” individuals from Scotland, but the Everton supporters don’t appear to acknowledge it in a practical way. But for the practice of paying these men so much “down” as it is called, I should be inclined, like an old member of the Everton club. To kick against these benefit matches. The men are paid plenty without either benefit matches or bonuses.
To get the game. Notts Forest came with a weak team, being without those two sterling forwards, “Tich” Smith and Higgins, whilst the half-back division was short of Russell. They had fairly good substitutes in place of the two forwards, but Walters was altogether unable to deal with Latta, and Pike went to his assistance in the concluding stages of the game. The first half was very evenly contested, but as far as determination goes, correct football thrown in, the Forest can claim the advantage. Chadwick’s pedipulation of the ball several times was a treat to witness, although there was nothing of a scoring nature about it. The only forward on the Everton side that showed anything like dash was Latta, and he did lead Walters a dance. Maxwell was good in passing, but the shots that he sent in would hardly have knocked a flea over, and Brown cleared them easily. Although Williams had not near so many, they had more “sting” in them, so, taking everything into consideration, no goals in the first half about represents the play. The second half was more interesting, and the play more earnest. Everton had certainly the best of it, but Brown was in champion form, and the game ended in a draw, no goals being scored.
The Forest are a sturdy lot of players, and a grand team. Even without the players above mentioned, they made a splendid show against the League champions. Brown kept goal splendidly all through, and it was rather too bad of Latta to go at him the way he did after the whistle had blown for off-side. So fair is Aleck, that I am convinced he must not have heard the “tootle.” But apart from that, the next subject our football legislators should take in hand is this charging of goalkeepers. There is scarcely a match but these individuals catch it. In my opinion, any amateur who keeps goal is devoid of common sense. In Ritchie and Scott the Forest have a splendid pair of backs. There is not much of them certainly, but this does not interfere with their play in the least, and the way they cleared at all times was a treat. Hamilton and McPherson are of the game stamp, and I fancy scoring against this defence will be a difficult matter. Lindley played a very nice game, but, like all sensible amateurs, he does not risk anything, and this will cause his play in any professional team to be of an uncertain quality. The wings know how to pass, and can travel as well, and they also gave us evidence that they know where the goal lies. The Everton men were good, bad, and indifferent by turns. Hall and Chadwick were as good as any. Howarth played a very cool and safe game. I believe it is the thing to characterise his exhibition thus. Taking the team all round their play was just passable, but all through it lacked finish. There was too much hesitating, and the shooting was open to improvement. This means a lot, and if his shots had more force behind them, I should say maxwell played a grand game.

CHIRK V. EVERTON COMBINATION
December 26, 1891. The Wrexham Advertiser
Played at Chirk on Saturday, before a rather a small number of spectators. Everton won the toss, and Butler kicked off for Chirk. Everton at once came away, and Elliott shot. Povey missed, but the leather, went across the mouth of goal, and rolled out. Everton appealed for a goal, but the appeal was not allowed. The visitors again passed well, and McMillan was nicely placed, but Postles cleared. W.P. Jones put in some good work. Elliott centred from touch, and Murray headed in, Povey just saved at the expense of a corner. This was well placed, but W.P. Jones cleared with a good kick. A free kick for hands near the home goal looked dangerous, but Kent kicked behind. Another free kick for Everton in midfield was not made much use of. Chirk then began to show up, and going to the other end gained a corner. This was well sent in, and after the game had been carried on for some time in front of the visitors' goal, E. James shot the first goal for Chirk amidst cheers. On kicking off from the centre, Everton were again dangerous, Povey hitting out a good shot from Murray. Gordon had a chance but shot wide. A free kick was granted Everton near the home goal, but the ball was sent through without touching anyone. Egan and G. Owen put in some nice passing. R. Jones sent the ball back, but Mates returned, and the play was soon around Jardine, who kicked out two long shots. A free kick for Everton, was well placed, but McMillan handled. This relief was not for long, however, as directly afterwards Pinnell shot a little wide. At the other end, Jardine hit away a good shot from Egan, and then James kicked behind. The ball quickly travelled to the Chirk goal. Gordon centred, and Povey just saved a shot from McMillan, a corner following. This was beautifully placed, and an exciting bully took place in the home goal, the ball being finally removed out of danger. Elliott centred, and Povey missed the ball, but Gordon screwed over the bar. Egan and G. Owen were getting dangerous, when Collins came across and saved. A corner for Chirk led to some fast play in front of the visitors' goal. W. Owen put in a shot, which Jardine saved in fine style. Chirk still kept up the pressure, and from a shot by Butler Egan headed into goal. Jardine again saved, but in doing so, hurt his knee badly, and the game was stopped for some time. On resuming, the visitors rushed away, and from a pass by Murray, Gordon equalised the score. James directly afterwards shot behind. A free kick for foul play by Chadwick was cleared, and McMillan and Elliott burst away. The latter shot, and the ball hit the top of the crossbar and went over. Gordon got past everybody except Povey but shot wildly over the bar. Chirk then played up, and bombarded the visitors' goal for some time. Egan tried two shots, but they both went wide and half-time arrived with the score sheet; Chirk one goal; Everton one.

On changing ends, Everton only had ten men, Kent, who had been injured in the first half, not re-appearing. Chirk were the first to show up, and Collins and Chadwick were kept busy. Once Collins slipped up, and James got clean away. Chadwick came across just in the nick of time, and James finally shot wide. R. Jones handled the ball, but the free kick was not taken full advantage of, as the leather was sent behind. Chirk pressed nearly continuously, but the good play of the backs kept the home forwards at a distance, and Jardine was rarely troubled. A low shot from G. Owen just passed outside the posts. Two free kicks were granted the visitors near the home goal, but the danger was cleared, and the ball was quickly at the opposite end, Jardine saving a good shot from Butler. Povey was next called upon to save a fine shot from Lockhead, and Jardine had to kick out a long shot from Mates. Egan got well up, but kicked behind, and a long shot from the same player was also wide of the mark. The visitors then livened up, and Povey saved well. A throw-in fell to Chirk near the corner flag. Egan secured and sent in a fine shot, which Jardine hit away. Chadwick put in some good work. A free kick was awarded to Everton in midfield, but this did not relieve the pressure for Long. Chadwick deprived Butler when he was well placed. After the home team had come very near scoring, Everton had a turn. The home forwards brought the ball back, and G. Owen just shot wide. Towards the close of the game Chirk kept up a nearly continual pressure. Both Egan and G. Owen shot wide, and then Jardine saved a shot from W. Owen. “Time” arrived with Chirk pressing, and the match was left drawn –Chirk, 1 goal; Everton 1. The teams were as follows; Chirk; Povey, goal; W.P. Jones and Postles, backs; R.E. Jones, Mates and M. Roberts, half-backs; James and Owen, right wing; Egan and G. Owen, left wing; Butler, centre. Everton; Jardine, goal; Collins and A. Chadwick, backs; Kent, R. Jones and Lockhead, half-backs; Gordon, and Murray; right wing; Elliott and McMillan, left wing; Pinnell, centre. Referee, Mr. J. Taylor, Welsh F.A.

EVERTON 0 SUNDERLAND 4
December 26 1891
The Liverpool mercury
Williams saves penalty kick , McLean breaks his arm.
The Christmas Day attraction-no other could have been greater at Anfield was the return League match between Everton and Sunderland, the previous game, in which Geary received the injury that has incapaciatated him since, having been played at Wearside on October 3, and won by Sunderland by 2 goals to 1. It is singular that in all the contests hitherto entered upon by these teams no more than a goal had been the extent of victory, and that the narrow success had rested in every instance with the club. Of five matches played between Everton and Sunderland, only one was at Liverpool,, and so the visitors yesterday had a record in their favour of four games to one. The teams are evidently well match and it was a good idea to select a genaral hoilday as the occasion of the home feature with the Wearsiders, the only matter of regret being that the ground and weather were not more suitable for a fair and complete test of the skill of such apparently equal combatants. There was an excellent attendance every foot of space seeming to be occupied and it must have numbered fully 13,000. The teams were as follows:- Everton; Williams (R), goal; McLean (D), and Howarth (R), backs, Kelso (R),Holt (J), (captain), and Robertson (H), half-backs, Latta (A), Wyllie (T), Maxwell (A), Chadwick (E), and Milward (A), forwards. Sunderland; Doig, goal, Porteous and Gow, backs Wilson, Auld, and Murray, half-backs, Hannah (J), Hannah (D), Campbell, Miller, and Scott forwards. Everton kicked off and some nice passing on the home right at once called upon Sunderland to defend. The vistors'left made ground and forced a corner. During the scrimmage a penalty kick was conceded, but Williams made a fine save by standing forward, the ball flying over the bar from the return shot from a penalty shot by Wilson. Latter after Williams had received an ovation for his smart work in a trying crisis, went away but found a barrier in the left back. Milward passed to Chadwick who shot a little wide. The amidst much excitement, went to the other end, where Kelso came to the rescue, and working up again Sunderland were dangerous on the right. The ball went out, but the visitors returned in good formation on the left to be beaten off. Everton now had a turn and got a free kick on the left. Gow administered a check, and after a throw in the home team the two Hannahs sprinted goalwards and centred. Howarth in cleaning goal, gave a corner. No relief came and from the throw in the ball was placed to Miller who hanged through and scored. With this early reverse Everton moved quickly towards their opponents goal and Milward was unlucky in not penetrating, a hard shot sending the ball against a player. Sunderland were very threatening immediately following this let off. But Holt intercepted and, sending forward Latta made a great effort to get within shooting range, but the ball was overan. Keeping well in Sunderland quarters, Everton were very near equalising as Maxwell shot closely. A fast movement by the visitors on the left was too much for McLean to cope with, and D Hannah piloted through. Everton were again in trouble but Williams made a double check first running out and then falling back to fist out a return. The game continued to be keenly contested. Everton made strenuous efforts to improve their position and Wyllie finished off good forward work by shooting well. The pressure was sustained on the visitors goal, and a corner was forced, from which Robertson headed well in. goods shots were essayed but Doig was safe. A raid was then made on the Sunderland left, and in the course of a running charge at Scott McLean broke his right arm. Which caused his retirement. Kkelso now went full back and Latta dropped into the half-back line. Thus handicapped. Everton were hard pressed, and Williams and his co-defenders had a lively time of it. Some good defence was shown for a while but on Auld lobbing in a lengthen shot Williams seemed confused and making no attempt to meet the ball a third goal was easily registered. At this stage Chadwick also left the field and during his absence the visitors were seldom out of the home quarters. On Chadwick's return he headed a run, but the Sunderland left back pulled him up. There was little combination in the game now, Kelso being most conspiouous for his defensive tactics and when half-time arrived with the score 3 goals to nil against Everton. Play was still in close proximity to Williams. On Campbell restarting. Everton were quickly in the visitors' half, but there being only four forwards the combination was, of course, not finished. Still energy was dominant, and Milward, running across, shot hard and well, but without the desired effect. Another attempt was made to get at goal but the Sunderland half-backs were too wily and play was transferred to the home end. Here Kelso was especially successful in beating off the powerful attacking party. Sunderland continued to have the upper hand, and by some clever concerted play again surrounding the home citadel J Hannah from a pass by Miller smartly notching the fourth point. Everton put in all they knew to mend matters but their attack was weak, and was easily accounted for by the powerful defence of Gow and Porteous. Play was now delayed some minutes by the intrusion of one or two senseless spectaators, who deliberately walked on to the field of play to dispute decisions. These were of course, promptly expelled and the game resumed. For a time Everton had the best of matters. Chadwick and Maxwell in turn having a shy at goal. But all to no purpose. A smart bit of work was witnessed on the visitors left, but was as cleverly broken up by Kelso, who lobbed well forward. Coming again the W earsiders had matters much to their own liking, and had not Howard put in a timely rescue another entrance might have been compossed. From an Everton point of view the game had long lost its interst as the home side were seldom in the running. Sunderland also taking matters easy, play ruled tame Milward tried long shot out of range and then Williams had throw away an accurate aim by D Hannah. Latta was next conspicuous in midfield but Porteous relieved by a fine lob. Milward was also prominent on the left and rushing through all defence parted to Chadwick who missed badly. When in a close position, and the game ended in a decisive win for Sunderland by 4 goals to nil.

TODAYS GAMES
December 26, 1891. The Liverpool Mercury
The enthusiasts in Association games should be happy at this merry season. Yesterday he had the pleasure of witnessing in Liverpool one of the most important of the whole series of League matches, and today he has a choice of two high-class contests, with the opportunity of being amused and at the same time in helping the Stanley Hospital to a greater position of usefulness. Everton have a visit paid them by the Glasgow Thistle, which club will fill the gap occasioned by the Glasgow Rangers, who should have been at Everton today, having to replay their undecided tie with Kilmarnock in the Scottish Cup competition.
Combination
Everton V. Denton, Denton. Kick-off at 2.30 p.m. The following will play for Everton; Jardine, goal; A. Chadwick and Collins, backs; Kirkwood, Jones and Lochhead, half-backs; Gordon, Murray, Pinnell, McMillian, and Elliott, forwards. Reserves, Fairbrother.
Everton League v. Glasgow Thistle
Monday
Everton League v. Aston Villa, Birmingham (League)
Everton v. Heanor Town, Anfield.
Friday (New Years' Day)
Everton League v Kilmarnock, Anfield
Everton v. Gordon Villa, Gorton, Gorton (Combination).

EVERTON v GLASGOW THISTLE
Liverpool Football Echo - Saturday 26 December 1891
At this festive season of the year there is always an abundance of good things supplied for the followers of football, and enthusiasts are always certain of seeing some good performances. At Anfield, yesterday, a tremendous crowd assembled to witness the League contest between Everton and the famed Sunderland team, and the toffyites were sadly disappointed at a defeat by 4 goals to nil. Although disheartening to Everton, the brilliant victory of the Northern team gives greater interest to the fight for the League championship, and the race between Sunderland, Preston North End, and Bolton Wanderers will be watched with keenest until the issue has been definitely settled. Today our chief local teams were all engaged. The “unbeaten Everton” team journeyed to Denton to try conclusions with the club of that ilk in the Combination series, and at Hawthorne-road an Alliance contest took place between Bootle and Burton Swifts. Originally Glasgow Rangers were down as the visitors at the Anfield enclosure, but the Rangers having to replay their Scottish Cup tie with Kilmarnock a vacancy occurred, and the presence of the Glasgow Thistle was requisitioned. The visitors belong to the Scottish Alliance, in which series they have played 12 matches this season-won 5, lost 4, drawn 3, scoring 37 goals against 40. There was a good crowd present when the kick-off took place shortly after half-past two.
This match, an ordinary club fixture, was played on the Everton ground this afternoon in the presence of about 5,000 spectators. Calderwood kicked off, and the visitors at once made a move into their opponents territory, but after a stiff bit of work close to the Everton goal the homesters slipped down the field, and then Milward shot a trifle wide. Play for some time was confined to the visitors goal, but on their attempting to get away Holt accounted for their effort, and a couple of barren corners were taken by Everton. Latta then put in a splendid bit of work on the home right, but the ball was eventually forced over the line, after which the Glasgow right made a great race into the Everton half, but at length a splendid clearance was effected, with the result that Milward made a couple of capital runs, but on the first occasion he shot wide, and at the second the attempt was splendidly robbed. Still keeping up the attack, the Everton players kept their opponents continually on the defensive, and several attempts were made to capture the visitors goal, but without success. Then the Glasgow right raced away, and at length a shot was sent in to Williams, who, after picking up the ball was collected by Calderwood, but the attempt to “rush” the Everton goalkeeper did not meet with success. Then a grand bit of passing by the Everton right wing carried the ball to the front of the Glasgow goal, and the Scotch defence was for some time in continual hot water. Scoulles, the goalkeeper, played splendidly, and a eventually Stark and Muir made tracks for the Everton goal, Stark shooting to the front. Here a free kick was given to the visitors a couple of yards away from goal, and Carson succeeded in placing a point to the credit of the Thistle. Shortly after this the Evertonians went down the field with great dash, and at attempts were made by Maxwell and Milward; but the defence was splendid, and the homesters could not score. Before half time the visitors added a second goal from a scrimmage, and then Latta scored for Everton.
Half-time; Glasgow 2, Everton 1.
After the restart the game went in favour of the Glasgow team, and in a short space of time Gillespie scored the third goal for the visitors. Then a good bit of work was done by the homesters and shortly Chadwick and Milward got to work, the latter player giving Everton another point. Shortly after the home team at tasked in persistent fashion, and another goal was added from a scrimmage. After a short while the Scotch lads got away, and for a time the Everton defence was taxed, but the homesters retaliated and quickly forced a corner, which came to nothing. The visitors then forced a corner, which was cleared away, final Result; Everton 4 goals, Glasgow Thistle 3 goals.

YESTERDAY’S FOOTBALL
The Liverpool Football Echo- Saturday December 26 1891
EVERTON v  SUNDERLAND
The “match of the season” was down for decision yesterday afternoon and was witnessed by a tremendous crowd of spectators, the capacious Anfield enclosure being nearly packed. At 2.15, the time appointed for the kick-off, each of the stands was well filled. Campbell kicked off for Sunderland, Maxwell and Wyllie at once getting to work, but being finely checked by Gow, who sent to the left wing, where Kelso came off with a bit of clever tackling, which drove the visitors back. Sunderland came again, however, and obtained a penalty kick, Wilson kicking right into Williams’s fists, when Kelso cleared. Latta and Wyllie had a turn on the home left, but the leather went out, and Sunderland were soon again attacking, Scott and Miller working cleverly down and the last-named sending in a fine shot, which was well met by Howarth. Sunderland at this point showed better combination than their opponents, with the result that Campbell scored with a header, Williams being blocked by players of his own and the opposing side. From the centre the Everton left wing came into notice, Chadwick making a good attempt, but failing to reach the mark. Against the visitors’ left wing pair Holt and Kelso put in some first-class work. Holt beating Scott at a critical point and giving to Latta, who had to best of a tussle with Murray, but Sunderland came again, Campbell sending well in, when D. Hannah rushed in and scored a second point for the Wearsiders. The ground, having been sanded, was in good condition, and after this second reverse for the home side the pace was accelerated, Chadwick and Milward putting any amount of go into their play, but having wretched luck with their shooting, Maxwell being similarly unlucky. From a throw-in Everton had a grand chance of scoring, but Porteous and Gow supported Doig in such a style that no opening could be found. Campbell and Scott raced away, and when the last-named was becoming dangerous Mclean ran in and upset the Sunderland left winger, the Evertonians having slightly the worst of the encounter, and having to leave the field. Against ten men on the home side Sunderland made things lively for the Evertonians, Kelso, who took McLean’s place, making some grand clearances, but Williams’s charge fell again to a lengthy shot from the Sunderland captain (Auld). Although the home side were having much the worst of the argument the spectators ungrudgingly applauded the perfect display of football by the visitors, who at every point showed themselves all round perhaps the best team over seen on the Everton enclosure. The visitors were about to take a corner kick when the referee sounded the whistle for the half-time interval, the score then reading 3 goals to nil in favour of the visitors. At the end of the first half it was learned that Mclean’s arm had been fractured in the collision with Scott. On Maxwell restarting Everton worked capitally down, giving the Sunderland defenders a taste of their attacking powers. A useless corner was all that came of this, however, Campbell breaking away, but Holt was too clever for the Sunderland centre, who was neatly robbed, Howarth and Kelso were called upon for all the defence they were worth, but Williams was not troubled, Kelso performing grandly against Millar and Scott. A cross from Millar, however, gave J. Hannah, the old Sunderland player, an opening, and again the leather was inside the net. Everton made frantic efforts to score a point, but against the cool and perfect play of the Sunderland men these efforts might as well not have been made. At this point, a few individuals with more beer to them sense, caused a stoppage of play by breaking on to the ground. Latta shifted the first intruder in most workmanlike style, but the services of a member of the force were required to remove several enthusiastic Evertonians who were of opinion that the home side were not having fair play. Maxwell, Wyllie and Latta each made grand efforts, but every shot was met and repelled, while the Sunderland forwards, who only now made spasmodic attacks, generally caused anxiety to the home backs, when they got over the centre line. Williams charge was frequently threatened, and only for the grand defence of Kelso and Howarth and some clever work by Holt against Campbell, the score would have been much heavier against Everton. In the last five minutes of play Doig handled for the first time in the second half, an easy shot from maxwell being easily got rid of. The game throughout was fast and interesting, and although Everton were defeated, the spectators were rewarded by the finest exhibition of combined play ever witnessed on the Everton ground.
Final result- Sunderland 4 goals, Everton nil.
Teams;
Everton.- Williams, goal; Howarth and McLean, backs; Kelso, Holt (Captain), and Robertson, half-backs; Latta, Wyllie, Maxwell, Chadwick, and Milward, forwards
Sunderland.- Doig, goal; Porteus and Gow, backs; Wilson, Auld (Captain) and Murray, half-backs; J. Hannah, D. Hannah, Campbell, Miller, and Scott, forwards.

SUNDERLAND v. EVERTON.
Sunderland Daily Echo and Shipping Gazette - Saturday 26 December 1891
SPLENDID WIN FOR SUNDERLAND.
The return League match between Sunderland and Everton took place Liverpool yesterday before 16,000 spectators, including a number from Sunderland. The following were the teams Everton: Goal, Williams; backs, McLean and Howarth ; half-backs, Kelso, Holt, and Robertson forwards, Latta, Maxwell, Chadwick, Milward. Sunderland : Goal, Doig : backs, Porteous and Gow; half-backs, Wilson. Auld, and Murray; forwards, J. Hannah, D. Hannah, Campbell, Miller, and Scott.
Everton kicked off, and the game was at once fast. Within three minutes Sunderland were awarded a penalty kick, but Wilson, who took the place, kicked right, into Williams's hands. Good work Chadwick and Milward transferred the sphere to the other end, but Sunderland were not to be denied, and by hard work made their opponents act on the defensive. The pressure could not be resisted, however, and Williams was beaten by Miller. After this reverse Everton raced away and had hard lines, and immediately afterwards Campbell made a splendid run down the centre, and finished with a handful for Williams, who, however, got rid of it. Holt put in smart work, and Everton worked the ball again, but Gow was all there, and transferred matters to the other end, where the home backs were at fault, and D. Hannah rushed in and scored after a somewhat weak clearance by Williams. Everton now had a turn, and their left wing were again prominent, but the final effort was wide. A corner well put in by Latta was with difficulty cleared, the Sunderland men, who evidently meant to neglect no safeguard, all packing the goal. McLean charged Scott heavily, and both fell, McLean retiring from the game with a broken arm. Sunderland were having considerably the best of the game, and Auld, with a long shot, beat Williams. Some roughness was now displayed, and Robertson and J. Hannah were Spoken to by the referee. Up to interval Sunderland were the better team, when the whistle blew the score stood Sunderland 3 Everton Nil.
Immediately on re-starting Everton raced away and gained a corner, from which hot work occurred. Sunderland cleared, and soon at the other end, where Howarth relieved. They were not to be denied, though, and J. Hannah scored what appeared a clear offside goal, but the referee ruled otherwise. Latta created a diversion by collaring a demonstrative spectator who had made his way on to the field, and running him off the ground. Hardly had done so when another party made himself obnoxious, and the was stopped whilst he was reasoned with. Everton were now doing somewhat better, but they were dangerous. Their efforts lacked the finish which characterised those Sunderland, who played their best game. Unless it was Auld, there was not a weak spot in the team, whilst Everton were disjointed, and were also labouring under the disadvantage of a man short. Piay slackened, but it was still in Sunderland’s favour, who were rarely out of Everton's quarters, where Howarth, and Kelso and Williams were kept busy. Towards the close Chadwick and Milward raced down, and when right in the former shot over the bar. Time was now called, and Everton were well beaten. Score: Sunderland 4 goals Everton Nil
RECEPTION THE NEWS.
The utmost interest, was evinced in the match and the result was anxiously waited for in Sunderland. The half-time and final results were given out at the music halls before crowded audiences, who cheered vociferously. A number of the bustiness men in the town also obtained the result by private wire, and the flimsies " were conspicuously pasted up in their places of business. Much satisfaction was expressed on all sides when it became known that Sunderland had beaten last season's champions.

DOYLE AND BRADY
Empire News & The Umpire - Sunday 27 December 1891
In the action in Glasgow Sherif Court, at the instance of the Everton club, against Doyle and Brady, of the Celtic club, for alleged breach of contract, it is understand that some pleas as to relevancy have to be disposed of before the Sheriff can go into the merits of the case, which will not, therefore, he heard until next month.

EVERTON REVIEW
December 28, 1891. The Liverpool Mercury
Christmas, from a football point of view, has not been a merry one in Liverpool, for on Friday Everton and Bootle suffered decisive defeats, and again on Boxing Day Everton only just managed to beat Glasgow Thistle. The Christmas Day attraction at Anfield was a captivating one, and the attendance, though not the largest seen on the ground, was capital, but generally the game proved a great disappointment. The state of the field of play –which, despite a coating of sand, was hard and slippery –was against a perfect exhibition of play, but none was prepared to see Everton cut up so badly as they did. They were inferior in every department to Sunderland, who were universally admired for their splendid tactics, uniform speed, and well-judged balanced and presented no weak spot, though some members, notably Wilson and Campbell, outshone their conferes. It is singular that Everton, as they did at Sunderland, should be unfortunately compelled to carry on some portion of the game with only ten men. At Wearside Geary met his injury near the close of the match, but McLean's accident on Friday happened early on, and was thus a much more serious affair, as the game had fully an hour to run at the time McLean, in charging Scott –both falling heavily –broke his arm and caused his retirement. Sunderland were two goals ahead, and Everton's chances of drawing level were gone. They certainly played up pluckily, but in their disorganised formation they were never dangerous, and only once had Doig to defend in the second half. Porteus and Gow also had few opportunities of showing their mettle; but from the very occasional raids attempted by their opponents they gave evidence that they were in fine form, and would have been equal to the attack even if Everton had been represented all through with a full complement of forwards. Wilson, Auld, and Murray each gave a magnificent exhibition of half-back play, and it was with mingled feelings of delight and mortification that the spectators he held the case with which they outmanoeuvred the Everton vanguard. Supported by such a clever trio, the Sunderland forwards had every assistance to make their mark, and it must be said, they took full advantage of their position. They were very fast, and Campbell in the centre, nonplussing Holt with great skill, kept his speedy wings splendidly together, with the result that the combination seemed about as perfect as it could be on a hard frost-bound ground. Their passes were always good either backwards or forward, and how fine the shooting was is told in the score of 4 goals to nil. It soon became apparent that Earp was sadly needed to partner Howarth, as Scott and Miller were yards too fast for McLean, who rarely seemed capable of clearing his lines, and had he continued all through he would have been fairly “run to earth” and the weight of Everton's defeat made heavier than it really was. Kelso, going full back in the emergency, played brilliantly, and the defence was thus stronger than at the outset. Holt worked hard, but he knew what it was to be beaten frequently, as did Robertson and Latta, and none of the forwards came out strongly or satisfactorily, nor did Williams sustain his character as a reliable custodian.
The game at Anfield on Saturday between Everton and Glasgow Thistle was throughout of a most pleasing character, as the performance of the Scotch club quite exceeded the expectations of the home supporters. From start to finish the contest was full of good points. The Scotchmen opened the scoring from a penalty kick and were not long in backing it by a second goal. It was then seen that Everton had found their match, as the home players had to put in all they knew before Chadwick was able, just on the interval, to beat Scouller, who during the course of the game kicked and handled well. In the second half the visitors were first to gain another point, and then Everton went at it in rare style, and tried hard to recover their position, and taking the leather from midfield never allowed their opponents to touch it. Milward, from Chadwick's pass beating Scouller with a real beauty. Still determined, the Anfielders –though having to contend with powerful defence from Herod and Brownlee –gained another goal, from a free kick close in. Splendid work by both sides followed, and the Thistle custodian was indeed unlucky to get the fourth point against him, as according to the referee's decision he checked a grand attempt from Maxwell, when standing over his goal line. This was undoubtedly hard lines for the visitors. No further scoring was done by either side. Throughout the play of both teams was the best order, and the spectators were not slow to appreciate their efforts.
Today Everton have a serve task, as they visit Aston Villa, who on Saturday gave a specimen of their power when at home by defeating Darwen at Perry Barr by 7 goals to nil. Both at Anfield and Hawthorns-road there are to be matches this afternoon. Everton are visited by Heanor Town, from Derby, who have an unbeaten record to show, having won ten out of eleven games played and drawn one, scoring 45 goals to 7.
Association Matches The Newspapers Football Match
Express v Echo
This match, which was played on Saturday morning, caused considerable stir in the Anfield enclosure. The committee of management are to be congratulated upon the success of their efforts, as they will be able to hand over a goodly sum to the Stanley Hospital, there being fully 5000 spectators on the ground to witness the game. Among these present were his worship the Major (Mr. J. De Bels Adams), Councillors J. Houlding and Walker and other gentlemen who are ever ready to assist in any good object. Express won match 1-0.

EVERTON 4 GLASGOW THISTLE 3
December 28 1891
The Liverpool mercury
Owning to the Glasgow Rangers having to replay their Scottish Cup tie with Kilnarnock the Everton executive arranged with the Glasgow Thistle to meet them on the Anfield enclosure on Saturday, in a fieldly contest. The thistle-a good all round team-belong to the Scottish Alliance, in which they have played 12 matches this season their record being won 5 lost 4, drawn 3 scoring 37 goals, against 40. There would be nearly 6,000 specatators present when the following teams stepped on the ground:- Everton – Williams (R) goal; Howarth (R), and Fairbrother, backs; Kelso (R), Holt (J) (captain), and Robertson (H), half-backs, Latta (A), Wyllie (W), Maxwell (A), Chadwick (E), and Milward (A), forwards. Glasgow Thistle; Schuller, goal, Herod, and Brownlee, backs; Lindsay, Carson, and Martin, half-backs, Stark, Muir, Calderwood, Wood, and Gillespie forwards. The visitors started and at once made tracks towards the home goal. Where Howarth was called upon to conceded a corner, which however, only resulted in Everton making headway on the right, and Latta becoming dangerous Brownlee rushed to the rescue and cleared magnificently. The Thistle were now exceedingly troublesome on the right wing, and Fiarbrother failing to break up the combination of Stark and Muir the former had a very near thing as he headed over the bar. The homesters now seemed to realise what their opponents were made of and put more vigour into their play, which was the means of taxing the abilities of the Scotch defence to its utmost. Herod proved equal to the occasion, and lobbing well forward, his ran aftern prettuy combination caysed Williams to pick up from the foot of Calderwood. Kelso gave Latta who in turn went down with great dash on the wing,, and parting over to his left the Glasgow goal was for a time hotly besieged, Maxwell testing Sculler with a lofty shot, which the Scotchman caught and threw safely out. Play was now intersting, both teams showing fine form, which was much admired by the onloolers. The Glasgow men again became troublesome to Williams who had to fist away from Muir. His clearance was only temporary, however as again he had to deal with another attempt from McInnes. The game continued warm and, surrounding the home goal. The Thistle caused. Howarth to handle within the 12 t=yards limit. The penalty kick was taken most judiciously by Carson, who by a slow low shot gave Williams no chance whatever. This performance was ungrudgingly cheered by the onlookers, as the point was well deserved. From the midfield kick Holt was conspicusous for his tricky play,, as was Brownlee for his fine defence. The latter supporting his custodian in grand style. Maxwell was spendidly supported by Chadwick and Milward as he headed a warm attack on the visitors end, and though shot afater shot was banged in to Scouller, the desired effort could not be attained, as he used both hands and feet in a marvellous manner. Encouraged by the fine defence of their backs, the Scotsmen worked hard and well, and Gillespie trickily eluding Howarth brought pay in front of Williams, and after a dertermined effort, a second point was placed to their credit. With the second reverse Everton did not realise the position and in their old style fairly walked round their opponents and Chadwick, by a grand lofty shot, beat Sculler for the first time. Nearing the interval both custodians were troubled, but when the whistle blew the score stood:- everton 1 gaol, thistle two goals. Resuming Holt was the first show up, as he cleverly dispossessed Calderwood, and the Evertonians moved to their opponents quarters. Herod was lucky to get in a timely kick as the ball was sailing through. Fairbrother returned and Wyliie tested the ability of Sculler, a feat was immediately repeated by Latta without result. The visitors next became aggressive and Fairbrother was beaten by Muir who crossed accurately over to his inside left, and the Scotchmen lost no time in adding another point for the side from close rang. Not relishing this third defeat the homesters, from the midfield kick, fairly ran round their opponents and before any of the visitors had touched the ball Milward hanged through-a performance which was loudly applauded both sides now worked hard and some sterling play was withness. A foul against the visitors in their goalmouth quickly drew matters level the ball being scrimmaged through. Everton tried hard to get ahead and caused the opposing defence great trouble. After many attempts their effects proved successful as from a close range Maxwell gave Scouller a wark handful which according to the decision of the referee. He caught when behind his line. Give and take play was now withness neither side having the advantage and a pleasant and fuinely contested game ended in a win for the League champions bt 4 goals to 3.

DENTON 0 EVERTON RESERVES 7
COMBINATION MATCH
December 28 1891
Played at Denton on Saturday. The home team commented with ten men and were almost continuously on the defence. Everton leading by 3 goals to nil. At half-time. Denton improved later on but failed at goal, while Everton, always on form for their good combination added four more points and won by 7 goals to nil.
Played 14, won 12, lost 0, draw 2, for 65 against 7 points 26

EVERTON STUFF
Athletic News - Monday 28 December 1891
Everton have now lost another full back for a few weeks, for the ruddy-haired McLean fractured his arm in the match against Sunderland on Christmas Day. Everton have had a fair stock of full backs this season, but hardly too many, judging from the many accidents they have sustained. After McLean retired on Friday Kelso took his place, and once more proved what a sterling man he is in that position.
Some people take a delight in pointing out Everton’s formidable list of professionals and their consequent heavy expense. This may be all right, but what about Everton’s list of cripples? They have been numerous enough this season to set up a hospital. Poor McLean is the latest addition and he is not likely to be of much use against before the League season will be over. A fractured arm takes some mending. Everybody who knows the sandy-haired Scottie wish him a speedy recovery, as there is no more genuine player in the Anfield team.
When one learned the result of the Sunderland v. Everton return it almost forced the remark. “Here we have the League champions of ’91-2.”  To beat Everton on the latter’s ground by four goals to nothing is a staggerer, and should make the Wearsiders strong favourites for the championship. Within a fortnight Sunderland have visited two League clubs in Lancashire and scored ten goals to none. That kind of form takes some beating.

LIVERPOOL AND DISTRICT
Athletic News - Monday 28 December 1891
By The Loiterer
Glasgow Rangers should have been at Everton, but at the beginning of the week sent word that they could not keep their engagement, as they had to replay their Cup tie with Kilmarnock, I don’t know how much money was spent in telegraphing, but at length Glasgow Thistle was engaged. There was nothing-like the usual Boxing Day crowd at Anfield, and the game, if not scientific, was very exciting, as the visitors kept a lead in the scoring line for a long time. A free kick close on enabled Everton to equalise, Maxwell scored the winning goal, and Everton won by four goals to three-not a very great victory.
There is nothing very startling in Liverpool in football matters, at any rate. There are several wrecks to be got up yet, but what interests your readers of this column most is the wreck up at Everton on Christmas Day. I should say that there will not be a public inquiry into the circumstances, for the cause must be patent to everyone who witnessed the disaster. The fact is, Sunderland will lick creation on the form they showed against our cracks. There is some satisfaction in that, and Evertonians did not begrudge them their victory.
Everything passed off well, but matters got rather warm at one time, and it looked as if the game would be stopped owing to the spectators wanting to have a say in the matter. A Christmas Day crowd is not to be trifled with, and I think the fixture on this festive day in future will be less important than a League match.
I cannot understand how it is Sunderland have such a bad name for being rough. I saw nothing wrong with the men on Friday, and they appear to play pure football. what little roughness was knocking about was on the other side, and the charge which McLean gave Scott was not very gentle.

SUNDERLAND AT EVERTON
Athletic News - Monday 28 December 1891
By The Loiterer
Many, myself amongst the number, questioned the judgement of the Everton executive in arranging such an important League match for Christmas Day. Hitherto the events to be decided on this festive day have been rightly been of a festive character, though a Lancashire Cup tie was, some three years ago, played on Christmas Day. And it was a match! I never saw a ground in such wretched state. Everton had two engagements that day, playing Ulster in the morning and Park Road in the afternoon. Now, there has been a lot of letter-writing to the local papers suggesting that this match should be played in the forenoon, and the answer was that there were religious scruples in the way. Well, three years back is not far to form a precedent, but, at the same time, I am glad the Everton Committee of to-day have some feeling in this direction. If the twelve thousand odd thousand odd spectators planked down their “tanners” to see football as it should be played, then they got full value for their money. At the same time, I should be a long way out of it if I conveyed the idea that the great majority of them enjoyed it. But I will say this, that however disappointing the result must have been to most of them, they gave the victors a splendid ovation at the finish. Apart from a splendid exhibition of football (by one team). We had one or two humorous incidents thrown in - just humorous enough. This element is very prevalent at Christmas, and it was the only thing I was afraid of in connection with the match. Happily it did not assert itself to any great extent, but there was some difficulty in dealing with one big fellow who wanted to smash the referee and the whole of the Sunderland team. Latta chucked one chap off the field in fine style, and then this aforesaid big chap came on the scene and others followed. The noble army of stewards, which from the stock-i-trade of the Everton F.C viewed the scene with complacency until Holt came for assistance. However, I must congratulate all concerned, bobbies included on the fact they showed in dealing with the offenders. “Chuck ’em out,” was the cry, but persuasion, the plan adopted, was the best method, and I am pleased to say it was effective. The teams that did duty for the respective clubs were the best available, although Everton were unluckily deprived, through injuries, of the services of Geary and Earp. The teams were:— Everton;- Williams, goal; McLean and Howarth, backs; Kelso, Holt, and Hope Robertson, half-backs; Latta, Wyllie, Maxwell, Chadwick, and Milward, forwards.
Sunderland.- Doig, goal; Porteous and Gow, backs; Wilson, Auld, and Murray, half-backs; J. Hannah, D. Hannah, Campbell, Miller, and Scott, forwards.
The game was exciting enough in all conscience, for it was only three minutes old when Sunderland were awarded penalty. Experience has proved that this penalty is nearly a dead snip, but Wilson kicked straight at Williams, and on this occasion a goal did not result. For a start this was very warm, and not at all in keeping with the truly Christmas aspect of things in general. But there was more to follow. It was quite apparent to anyone who understands football that it was not Everton’s day out. The play had always tendency towards the Everton goal, but Williams had very little to do. You often read that So-and-So had numerous shots stop, but the Sunderland fellows had more “off.” than to put in shots which Williams could get at. This was characteristic point in Sunderland’s play all through the piece. They had two objects in view; one was to get a sufficient number of goals, and the other prevent as few as possible being scored against them. As is well known by this time, they succeeded admirably in attaining both these points. About here, at any rate, the methods adopted by the team have been severely commented upon, but, as far as I could see, there was nothing that could be objected to, only that they played about 50 per cent better football than the home lot. When you reckon up what it costs to run the show, 50 per cent is a lot. and if I was arguing the point from the actual run of the game I should be wrong, but I am taking the play of the two teams. You have seen, and I have seen, games played when one team has had the best of the exchanges and pressed for the most of the time, and lost. But there was nothing of this character about Friday’s match. The game, although it had a slight leaning in favour of Sunderland, was, so far actual pressing went, of an open nature, but as regards the play the Wearsiders could claim a great advantage. Luck, such as sending in a long shot on the off chance of its going through, did not enter into their play at all, but all they got was worked for. I cannot compliment Williams on the way he kept goal for Everton, and I am certain Jardine would have saved two goals at least, for they were points in which experience more than ability would have succeeded.  Apart from this, the Sunderland team fully deserved the victory. Unless it be Auld there was not a weak spot in the team. Whether it be in defence or attack, the men played with system, and when they passed the ball, in whatever direction it suited them best, it was always to one of their own men. On the other hand, the home lot were not so correct. Whether it was the aptitude of the opposing side intercepting passes I don’t know, but the Sunderland men invariably stepped in. Of course, it must borne in mind McLead retired with a broken arm after about thirty minutes’ play, but beyond weakening the forwards I don’t think it affected the result in any way, for Kelso certainly played a better back game than McLean had done, and Latta was a good substitute for Kelso. Taking the teams all round, Everton were far behind their opponents at all points, and in saying so I cannot give the Sunderland team a better compliment, and the spectators cheered them on their splendid victory, although four goals nil is a heavy licking for such a team as Everton to receive, and on their own ground, too.

ASTON VILLA v  EVERTON
Birmingham Mail - Monday 28 December 1891
A GREAT GAME
Last year’s League champions paid their annual visit to Perry Barr this afternoon, and played Ihe Villa in the presence of a big holiday crowd; in fact, the attendance was one of the largest recorded at the Wellington Road ground during the present season. As the result the rapid thaw, followed by the heavy rainfall, the field was in a rather treacherous condition, and the players were considerably handicapped by reason of their inability to obtain a secure footing. Both elevens were representative, and it was evident that the game was destined to be a stubbornly contested one. Wyllie and Latta were the first to got away, but Baird tackled them smartly, and a determined run by Devey caused the venue of play to be changed. Howarth, however, tackled the Villa man brilliantly, and little later the burly North End back gave the Villa forwards another taste of his defensive qualities. Athersmith ran quickly up his wing and centred, but although Devey tried hard to improve upon the chance, Williams saved his shot beautifully, and second later when Hodgetts looked dangerous the Everton custodian disposed of the ball in very ready style. A splendid pass by Holt to Millward enabled that speedy forward to get a clear run, and putting the ball to Maxwell, the last-named shot for goal. Hinchley mulled the ball, and it apparently rolled between the posts, but recovering himself quickly, the Villa goalkeeper sent it spinning to the corner. The Liverpudlians promptly claimed a point, but the referee ruled that there was no evidence to prove that the ball had actually passed over the goal line. On several occasions the Everton forwards came away in brilliant style, and their combination was always clever, but the defence of Evans, Baird, and Hinchley was so steady that although the visitors had considerably the best of the play the Villo goal never fell. On the other side Campbell executed some brilliant dribbles, and was by far the cleverest individual forward on the field. After one or two good attempts on the part of the Everton vanguard Latta got in a fine centre, and Millward, coming down the field with a wet sail, shot the ball past Hinchley at a terrific pace. Scarcely two minutes had elapsed since the first point had been obtained before the Everton pack came swarming round the Villa goal again, and Wylie for the second time defeated Hinchley. The Villa paid a flying visit to the other end, but Howarth got in their way, and immediately after this, when had Hodgetts had an open goal before him he made an execrable shot, which went several yards wide of its mark. Hinchley showed a strange lack of judgment in feebly stopping a shot which must have passed harmlessly outside, and as he failed to get the ball more than three yards away from goal, Latta cleverly passed it over to Maxwell, who shot another smart goal. The Villa had the advantage from this point to the finish, but they failed to score, and half-time the Liverpudlians were Leading by 3 Goals to 0.
On crossing over the Villa had the advantage of both hill and wind, and spurred on by the repeated injunctions of the huge crowd, the forwards commenced to play with the energy of despair. Five minutes from the start Devey received a pass from one of the halves, and with well-directed shot brought about the downfall of the Everton goal. The cheers which greeted this feat were absolutely deafening, and, inflated with success, the home forwards came down the slope with an irresistible rush, and Hodgetts lowered the Liverpool colours for a second time. The excitement was now intense, and such a scene of uproarious enthusiasm has rarely been seen on the Villa ground. The spectators had great hopes that their favourites were destined to draw level, but they were doomed to disappointment, for after a magnificent bout of passing between the famous Everton left wing pair, Chadwick finished up with sensational dribble, ana did not loose the ball until he had passed the Villa backs and put it safely out of the reach of Hinchley. This practically decided the game, for from now to the end the Everton forwards more than held their own. Chadwick and Millward gave the finest display of left wing work seen locally for many seasons, and they simply baffled the whole of the defenders the Villa could bring against them. Time after time the ball flew at Hinchley, but many of the shots were scarcely well directed, and consequently the visitors’ score was not further increased. As the result of a superb individual run by Devey, the Villa centre got within range, and with a sharp oblique shot sent the ball out of the reach of the Everton custodian. Once more excitement reigned supreme, and in response to the cries of their supporters the Villa made several determined efforts to draw level. Hodgetts, Athersmith, Devey, and Campbell worked very hard for the success of their side, and it was in no way due to any lack of skill or determination on their part that their team lost the game. Dickson missed a palpably easy chance of scoring, and from a foul right under the Everton posts the Villa ought certainly to have drawn level. Howarth cleared his goal well, and the Everton forwards were just rushing up the field when the whistle blew, and magnificent game ended in win for the visitors by 4 Goals 3.
Aston Villa: Goal, Hinchley ; backs, Baird and Evans; half-backs, Campbell, Cowan, and Brown ; forwards, Athersmith and Dickson (right wing), Devey (centre), Hodgetts and Campbell (left wing). Everton Goal, Williams ; backs. Earp and Howarth half-backs, Kelso, Holt, and Robertson ; forwards, Latta and Wyllie (right wing), Maxwell (centre), Chadwick and Milward (left wing).
The game was undoubtedly the finest witnessed in the Midland district this season, being even more replete with thrilling incidents than was the Sunderland match at Perry Barr earlier in the year. The winners well deserved their victory, and it is strange, indeed, that such a team should have done so badly in previous games. Their forward play was brilliant in the extreme, and the international pair, Millward and Chadwick, gave an unsurpassed exhibition on the left wing. The combination of the pair was unique, and hearty cheers were awarded them by even the most biassed supporters of the Villa. Holt, too, played a masterly game at half, and in Earp and Howarth Everton have at last secured a pair of reliable backs. With the exception of that of Dickson, the Villa play was also exceptionally good, and in the second half the forward work was particularly smart. The game will live long in the memories of those who saw it. The crowd was the largest seen at Perry Barr this year, and the game was conducted in the best possible spirit; indeed, the cordial reception the Everton players secured was one of the most gratifying features of a really great match.

ASTON VILLA 3 EVERTON 4
DEMEMBER 29 1891
The Liverpool mercury
Everton journeyed to Perry Barr yesterday to fulfil their return League fixture with Aston Villa. The last occasion on which the means met was at Anfield-road. When Aston Villa were beaten by 5 goals to 1. There was a tremedous gathering of spectators present when the following teams stepped upon the enclosure;- Everton: Williams (R), goal; Earp (E), and Howarth (R), backs, Kelso (R), Holt (J) (captain), and Robertson (H), half-backs Latta (A), Wyllie (T), Maxwell (A), Chadwick (E), and Milward (A), forwards. Aston Villa: Hinchley, goals, Evans,, and Baird backs, Brown, Cowan,, and Campbell (G), half-backs, Athersmith, Dickson, Devey, Hodgetts, and Campbeel (L), forwards .The sun shone brightly, and the ground was in fair condition when the teams stepped upon the field, which presented a very animated appearance. Losing the toss Devey, started for the Villa, before 12,000 onlookers. Everton had the best of the opening exchanges, as Milward getting a lob from Howarth. Had a lofty shy over the bar. The homesters, from mthe goal kick, went down in full force and Williams had saved splendidly from Campbell, Devey had another shy, with the same result. Everton now combined grandly and working through all defence, Chadwick tested Hinchley with a warm handful. Two corners to Everton followed this attempt, but the leather ultimately went skimming over the bar. The Villa defence was taxed to its utmost but through Maxwell tried twice nothing resulted. Progess was made on the home right, and sailing finely through the visitors defence, Dickson failed badly when near Williams. Everton next experienced the hardest of hard lines as their front rank moved smartly down upon Hinchley and an accurate shot by Chadwick before the home custodian could get away went to all apperances behind the bar. The visitors claimed strnuously for a goal but mr stacy thought otherwise. The visitors again became prominent for sterling tactics and for a considerable time kept their rivals well in hand. Holt being most conspicuous,, and time after time he broke them up. A movement by the Villa ran was cleverly checked by Robertson, and Everton getting into line fairly sailed round their opponennts, and Maxwell crossing accurately over to Milward the left winger banged through the first point for the vistitors, 20 minutes from the start. Not content with this success, barley a minute elapsed before a second point was gained by a spendid effort from the foot of Wyllies. The League championships continued to hold the upper hand,, and their play was really a treat to witness, the combination shown being most correct they repeatedly making rings round the Villa defenders. After a lively tussle between Latta and Baird the leather was cleverly taken along on the line,, and the Everton right winger screwing across to Maxwell. No time was lost before another goal was scored by a swift low shot from the latter. The villa tried hard to mend matters, but owing to the Anfielders defence they failed to make headway. Nearing the interval the homesters had a fruitless attempt at williams, and on the call of the whistle the score stood Aston Villa nil. Everton 3 goals.

On resuming, the Villa were the first to attack, But Kelso and Robertson sent them to the rightabout and a temporary raid up on Hinchley was checked by Evans. The Villa now worked hard and ashowed better quality of play. Coming grandily away on the left Devey quickly availed himself of an opening by a swift low shot from close ranges. This performance fairly brought''down the house'' as the spectators cheered again and again. From the centre kick fine play by Cowan and Brown placed their forward's in the Everton quarters, and Hodgetts cleverly caused a second downfall for Willams from a short cross by L Campbell. This second reverse did not in any way disconcert the Evertonians as they went away in full swing, Chadwick and Milward being warmly applauded for their short accurate passing. Outwitting, the Brum defenders Chadwick fairly excelled himself, as after clearing his way he scored a real beauty by a long high shot, thus giving his side a further lead. The Villa team tried hard to amend matters, and were successful in their efforts owing to a misunderstanding by Kelso, Hodgetts doing the needful with a lob which gave Wil.liams no chance whatever. Play now ruled even and was of the best description being fast and full of interst. A hot scrimmage next took place in front of Williams Earp, however, rushed to the rescue and came out of the oredeal with flying colours. Nearing the finish the homesters tried hard to make matters level but so strong was the Everton defence that they kept at bay, and on the call of time Everton after what was uadoubtedly the finest exhibition of football withness at Perry Bar this seaon retired the visitors by 4 goals to 3.

EVERTON RESERVES 6 HEANOR TOWN 1
December 29 1891
The Liverpool mercury
There was only a fair attendance at Anfield yesterday afternoon to withness the match between these clubs. the home team had the beeter of the opening stages but Simons held the opposing wing at bay Elliott and McMillan raced down and following a rush on the visitors goal McMillan sent past Carlin within a few minutes from the start. On resuming Kirkwood did a lot of work on the home left, and for the next few minutes the visitors were occupied in staving off the rushes of the home forwards. Twice Carlin was called upon, but the ball was safely got away, and Wright and Carter by good combination got well within xshooting range, but the home defence was stubborn, and the venue was as quickly changed. A couple of friutless corners fell to the Evertonians, when Wright spec down the centre, and successfully claiming a free kick the home end was reached, but the shooting was feeable and Smalley easily cleared. Chadwick sent down, and Pinnell had the goal at his mercy, but shot wide. Though from the goal kick McMillan got within range and notched his second goal. The home halves continually broke up the visitors combination and for the next ten minutes the Evertonians were severly pressing their opponents. Gordon tried a long shot which struck the bar ann passed through and hardly a minute had elasped when Pinnel added the fourth from a miskick in goal by Colton. A flash by the vistors wqas spoiled by erraticshooting and after Lochhead has sent down, a heavy scrimmage took place in the visitors' goal but the ball was safety got waay though within a couple of minutes the home ran again got under weight and Elliott beat Carlin with a long low shot. It was only a rare intervals that the visitors made any show attack and then when they did get into anything like position their final effort were too feeble to be effective. At length the visitors were penalised and Pinnell meeting the return from Carlin registered the sixth goal. Half-time was now called, with the score-Everton 6 goals; heanor town nil. And a raid was at once made on the visitors' goal. Murray sent in a clinking shot but, to the amusement of the spectators, his centre headed the ball clear, and the Heanor right pairr got prettily down, but failed to pass backs. For a time the visitors display nice points and obtained a free-kick in a favourable position, but failed to make use of the opportunity and the other end was reached, where Tyrer and Carlin put in some capiatl defensive work. Carter raced prettily down and centre well, but was not backed up, and immediately following Elliott had the goal at his mercy, but shot high over the bar. Peace dispossessed Pinnell and sent in a long shot, which Smalley successfully manipulated, and the home van by nice combination reached the other end. But the final efforts were erractic. Heanor played up to greater advantage later on and Wright was given an easy chance in front of goal but the ball passed harmlessly over the bar. Carlin cleverly saved a couple of good shots from Murray and Pinnel. Even play ensued, and the visitors left forced a corner off Chadwick and the ball being nicely centred Carter rushed it past Smalley, and scored the first and only point for his side, Everton winning by 6 goals to 1. Teams:-
Everton; Smalley (R), goal; Chadwick (A), and Fairbrother back; Lochhead (A), Jones (R), and Kirkwood (D), half-backs, Elliott (J), McMillan (J), Pinnel (A)., Murray (J), and Gordon (P) forwards
Heanor townL:- Carlin, goal; Tyrer, and Colton backs Webb, Peace, and Simson half-backs, Carter, Atkins Wright, Stow, and Jardine forwards.
Goals Everton McMillan two, Pinnell two, Gordon one, Elliott one. Headon town, Carter.

ASTON VILLA v  EVERTON
Birmingham Daily Post - Tuesday 29 December 1891
One of the most exciting games ever witnessed at Perry Barr took place yesterday. The local team were pitted against Everton, and the prospect of a good match brought together about twelve thousand persons. The recent form displayed by the respective clubs pointed to the victory of the Villa, but at so well did the visitors play that they upset all predictions by defeating the home team by 4 goals to 3. This victory was never secure until the finish, and a, during the second half the crowd were kept in a constant state of excitement. In the first half the Everton took a decided lead, for they scored 3 goals, whilst the Villa did not obtain a single point. The Everton were not very much superior in the outfield to the Villa, but near goal their shooting was more deadly. However, their goal record should not have been so great by at least a point at half-time, for one of the scores was the result of a palpable mistake made by Hinchley. Being three goals in arrear, the Villa's chances were very small, but in the second half they played a great game. Going away strongly, they scored two goals in seven minutes, and had all the chances been taken they would have won. A mistake in the back division let Millward in, and he placed a fourth goal to Everton's credit. Still the match was not over. Instead of being disheartened, the Villa strove their very utmost. They succeeded in scoring a third goal, and kept up such a hot attack that the visitors' victory was never assured until the finish of the game. The hard game in the mud told terribly upon the players towards the end, and all the men must have been very glad when the game was over. The second half's football was a brilliant exposition by the Villa, and had they only played at the start in the same way they would have secured the victory. They have never played a finer game against odds than they did yesterday. The backs were very sound, the half-backs did finely, and the forwards, with the exception of Dickson, who was a trifle slow, did splendidly, Devey and Athersmith working most indefatigably. The Everton men played downhill in the first half, and the game was fairly even. Both goals had several narrow escapes, and Hinchley soon saved two 'splendid shots which had well-nigh been fatal. On the second occasion the ball rolled all along the goal-line before he could reach it to kick it out of danger. The Everton, who seemed more at home in the mud, kept the ball in the Villa's half, and again got  dangerously near the goal, but Baird came to the rescue, and the Villa front rank worked their way up the field. L. Campbell was entrusted with the centre, but he unfortunately placed the ball outside. Once again the Villa got up, and Hodgetts ran through the backs, and entrusted the ball to Devey, but he shot too high. From the goal-kick the Everton left wing men worked their way down, and a fine shot was made by Millward, but Hinchley saved, although he shaped very badly. A similar attack was made a moment later, and Millward, dashing up just in time, scored the first goal for the visitors. The latter continued to play splendidly, and in about five minutes got through again, a long shot from Wyllie completely taking Hinchley by surprise.  The game was only 'twenty-five minutes old, and there can be no denying that, so far, Everton had shown the better form, and thoroughly deserved to lead. Hinchley had played very indifferently during the last few minutes. At length the Villa forwards got away in line, and Devey passed prettily to Athersmith, who centred splendidly, and Hodgetts had an opening. It was a grand chance, such as rarely occurs in a game, but the Villa man's shot was a few inches wide. Passing in capital form, the Everton forwards got down the held, and a couple of long shots went wide, Then a long shot which would have passed out was a stopped feebly by Hinchley, and Latta rushing in managed to centre to Maxwell, who placed another goal to the credit of his side. The point was undoubtedly the result of bad judgment on the part of Hinchley, who ought to have allowed the ball to go out. The Villa forwards now played better than before, and L. Campbell, dodging Earp, gave his side a grand centre, but they could not avail themselves of the opportunity.  Devey next looked likely to get through, but was pulled up by Howarth just in time, and Everton were soon attacking again. Their forwards played exceptionally well, but were driven back, and the Villa now had a look in, but Hodgetts's final shot hit the post, and a moment later Devey shot over the bar. This was the last effort of either side, for immediately the ball went out the referee blew his whistle, and the teams took a well-deserved rest. In the interval the Villa changed their jerseys, and appeared clad in white. They rushed off at once from the centre kick, and Athersmith, although floored by  Howarth, managed to pass the ball to Dickson, who was, however, too slow to avail himself of the opportunity, which was accordingly lost. Everton then became dangerous, but Baird cleverly stopped their rush, and Dickson tried a sprint, but although he beat his men he was too tired to dash in, and Howarth kicked away. Not to be denied, the Villa came with a fine rush, Athersmith being conspicuous for the game way in which he played. Near goal Brown passed to Devey, and he scored for the Villa amidst tremendous cheering. Two minutes later, or seven minutes from half-time, the Villa again came, and, amidst the greatest enthusiasm, Hodgett scored a second for the home team. The Villa were now playing magnificently, and their forwards passed with wonderful precision. A grand shot by Louis Campbell only just went out, and there was an evident determination on the part of all the team to retrieve their losses in the first half. Again the Villa came down the field, and Williams had another fine shot to stop. Some fine passing by the visitors' left wing resulted in a goal being scored by Millward. Still the Villa did not despair, and were again becoming dangerous, when Howarth tripped Athersmith. Nothing resulted from the free kick. A moment later, however, the Villa were again pressing, and the Everton defence had a very anxious time of it ; but they successfully weathered the attack, and then Millward and Chadwick were applauded for some splendid passing, but they only managed to put the ball on the wrong side of the posts. Athersmith a was conspicuous for a fine run and shot, but the ball passed over the bar. The other goal was soon attacked, but Everton met with no success. Continuing to press, however,' they gained a corner-kick, but it was weakly taken, and the ball then travelled to the other end, where Devey and Dickson tried shots; only a corner-kick resulted, and the next moment the other side were found attacking, but they carried the ball out. Then the Villa came with another rush, but Dickson lost a really fine chance by shooting out. At the other end Everton did similarly. Latta shooting wide. The spectators were now aroused to a perfect fever heat of excitement, as Louis Campbel, who received the ball from his fellow-countryman, G. Campbell, raced straight away for goal, with only the backs before him. At the right moment he centred to Devey, and he managed -to dash through and score a third goal for the Villa. The latter club, cheered by the spectators, played most resolutely, and the game was one of the most exciting ever witnessed. At length Everton raised the siege, and Evans, kicking out, gave a corner-kick. The ball was got away, but Everton had two or three shots which went wide. From one of the goal kicks Athersmith made a fine ran, and centred, but Williams threw the ball away. It came to Dickson but he waited until the backs were on him. A minute afterwards another attack was made, but did not succeed, and a despairing effort from a corner- kick yielded no result. Before the ball could be kicked from goal the referee blew his whistle, and the Everton team thus retired victors by 4 goals to 3. Aston Villa: Hinchley, goal ; Baird and Evans, backs; J. Brown, Cowan, and G. Campbell, half-backs; Athersmith and Dickson (right), J. Devey (centre), L. Campbell' and Hodgetts (left win), forwards. Everton: Williams, goal; M. J. Earp and Howarth, backs; Kelso, Holt, and Robertson, half-backs; Latta and Wylie (right), a Maxwell (centre), Chadwick and Millward (left wing), forwards Referee, Mr Hughes, of Northwich.

EVERTON v  HEANOR TOWN
Manchester Courier - Tuesday 29 December 1891
Played at Everton before several thousand spectators. Heanor kicked off at half-past two, and in a few minutes McMillan scored for Everton. This roused up the visitors, and after the restart forced the Combination to retire momentarily, Kirkwood and Chadwick cleared, and then another volley was sent into Heanor goal, the latter’s defence being perfect. The visitors right wing passed nicely up to Smalley’s charge, but the ball was sent behind the nets. From the goal kick Everton raced away, and forced a corner kick, which was sent in harmlessly. Pinnell narrowly missed scoring, but Everton were again in front of Heanor goal. Murray’s shot sticking in the mud in front of Carlen, the visiting goalkeeper. Gordon next lost a very easy chance, and Everton took another worthless corner. Carter led his colleagues again up to Smalley, when the latter got rid of a rand shot in quite his old style, and was deservedly applauded. A minute later the ball was in front of Heanor goal again, and Gordon passed to McMillan, who scored his second goal. Kirkwood at once led the “restart” back in front of Carlin, and the latter, running out, missed his kick and Gordon put on No 3. The home forwards smartly passed the ball down again, Pinnell soon after making the score four goals for Everton. Everton made the game very fast, foreign the play in a marvellous manner on the heavy ground. Elliott scored the fifth after the homesters had a hard struggle to break the defence., Heanor made a big effort to score, but found it difficult to pass Kirkwood, Jones, and Chadwick. Gordon just missed heading another goal for Everton, the ball going on the top of the net, but a minute later Pinnell added the sixth. Heanor made desperate efforts to score, and from a corner kick Smalley’s charge was at last forced, the visitors well deserving their goal.
Final score Everton 6 Heanor Town 1
Everton; Smalley, goal; Chadwick and Fairbrother, backs; Kirkwood, Jones, and Lockhead,  half-backs; Gordon, Murray, Pinnell, McMillan, and Elliott, forwards.
Heanor Town; Carlin, goal; A. Tyrer and Colton, backs; Webb, Peace, and Simpson, half-backs; Carter, Atkins, Wright, Stone, and Jardine, forwards.

ASTON VILLA v  EVERTON
Manchester Courier - Tuesday 29 December 1891
This League match was played at Perry Barr yesterday. Beautiful weather favoured the fixture, and consequently there was a very large attendance, about 10,000 people lining the enclosure. The thaw having set in, the ground was very soft, although it had been scraped and rolled in order to make it as easy going as possible. The visitors won the toss, and decided to play down the hill, with the wind in their favour, Devey setting the ball in motion. Wyllie and Latta were the first to get away, but Baird repulsed them. For fully three quarters of the first half Everton had considerably the best of the play, and Milward and Latta made a series of very fine runs. On one occasion Milward dribbled into goal, and when in close quarters passed to Maxwell. The latter shot, and Hinchley mulled the ball badly, and it seemed to roll over the line. Everton promptly claimed a goal, but the referee could not say that the ball had actually passed between the posts. At length from a centre by Latta, Milward scored a brilliant goal, and scarcely two minutes had elapsed before Wyllie shot another clever goal. At the other end Hodgett missed a most simple chance when standing in front of the Everton goal. Through an injudicious action by Hinchley, Maxwell was enabled to put on a third for the Liverpool team. Half time score; Everton three goals; Aston Villa, nil. The exhibition given by the Everton forwards was one of the very finest seen at the Villa ground since the season opened, and the team were loudly applauded when they left the field at the interval. In the second half the Villa came on with white shirts, the contrast between the colours of the rivals teams not being sufficiently defined. The home forwards now commenced to play with the utmost dash, and the game had not been in progress more then ten minutes before Devey scored a nice goal for his side amidst deafening cheers, which were renewed when Hodgetts got another two minutes later. The excitement was now intense, and the crowd were perfectly tumultuous in their applause when the Villa did anything worthy of notice. The Everton goal had several narrow escapes, and the enthusiasm of the spectators increased each moment. After a clever dribble Milward nearly reduced the Villa citadel, and Maxwell had hard lines in a grand shot. The Everton goal was nearly suffering another downfall as whilst they were claiming for off-side Campbell shot and the ball grazed the upright. Williams and Howarth looking at it without attempting to do anything. Chadwick and Milward fairly romped round Evans, and after some very tricky dribbling, Chadwick propelled a magnificently judged shot, which left Hinchley powerless, and the score then read four to two for Everton. The Villa men pressed very hard, and put on another goal. Final; Everton 4 Aston Villa 3.
Everton: Williams, goal; Earp and Howarth, backs; Kelso, Holt, and Robertson, half-backs; Latta and Wylie, Maxwell, Chadwick and Millward (left wing), forwards
Aston Villa: Hinchley, goal ; Baird and Evans, backs; J. Brown, Cowan, and G. Campbell, half-backs; Athersmith and Dickson , J. Devey, L. Campbell' and Hodgetts, forwards.

EVERTON v  ASTON VILLA
Sporting Life - Tuesday 29 December 1891
This important match was played at Perry Barr, Birmingham, yesterday afternoon, before a large muster, both teams being fully represented. The ground was heavy and treacherous. The visitors attacked, and at length Milward crowned their efforts by a grandly shot goal, and within three minutes Wyllie scored a second point for Everton. Hodgetts subsequently missed a ridiculously easy chance, and then Hinckley muffed the ball in an attempt to clear, and Maxwell popped it through, making the third goal for Everton, who led at half-time by that number to none. Upon resuming Villa dashed away, and Devey and Hodgetts both obtained goals in fine style. Chadwick then ended a grand run by scoring a fourth point for the visitors, who were now playing all round the Villa men. Afterwards Devey got an opening, and made no mistake, the game ending in a win for Everton by four goals to three. Teams;-
Everton.- Williams (goal), Earp and Howarth (backs), Kelso, Holt and Robertson (half-backs), Latta, Wyllie, Maxwell, Chadwick, and Milward.
Aston Villa.- Hinchley (goal); Baird and Evans (backs), Campbell, Cowan, and Brown (half-backs), Athersmith, Dickson, Devey, Hodgetts, and Campbell.

EVERTON FOOTBALL CLUB
December 31, 1891. The Liverpool Mercury
To the Editor of the Liverpool Mercury
Gentleman, _I think, the Everton team are charging rather a high a price for admission to their ground. Any person going to see the matches every week will find it rather expensive paying 6d, each time. I think 3d, is plenty to pay to see a football match. I am now referring to the League team. I am sure it would suit everybody, and more people would patronise the matches. Hope the committee will take this into consideration. Liverpool, Dec 30, 1891. Hopeful.