EVERTON v DARWEN
The Liverpool Daily Post- Wednesday, December 2, 1896
In view of their engagement with Everton next Saturday in the first round of the Lancashire Cup competition, the Darwen team have been sent into strict training. The men were somewhat roughly treated at Burton on Saturday last, but it is expected in the Peaceful Valley that the visitors will make a decent show against their powerful rivals. The committee of the Darwen club have offered the men a bonus if they should win or even make a draw, and the men are determined to qualify for receiving the extra pay. The players are indulging in long walks on Darwen Moor Common, and that they will turn out next Saturday in the pink of condition goes without saying. The following team ahs been selected to do duty for Darwen; Kingsley, goal; Nixon and Leach, backs; Sharpe, Morrison, and Cowan, half-backs; Hunt, Tyrer, McKee, Lees, and Kinsella, forwards.

ECHO AND EXPRESS v UNITED RAILWAYS
The Liverpool Daily Post -Thursday, December 3, 1896
The greatest interest is being centred on the coming battle between the above teams, and the result of the contest is being eagerly canvassed. Both teams made a good fight lasty year and already the Press team have (through the kindness of Kirkdale Football Club) had several practice games on their ground next to Goodison Park. The donations are coming in very well, and with the gifts by Messrs Henderson and Son, of Church-street, Mr. F. Sugg, of Lord-street and a promise by the Bovril company to supply both teams with refreshment at the interval, show a laudable desire to promote a deserving charity.

EVERTON 5 DARWEN 1
December 7 1896, The Liverpool Mercury
Lancashire Senior Cup-First Round.
There would be about 4,000 spectators at Goodison Park on Saturday to witness the tie between these clubs. both teams were at their best, and lined up as follows: - Everton:- Menham, goal, Storrier, and Arridge, backs, Boyle Holt and Stewart (captain), halfbacks, Taylor, Bell, Cameron, Chadwick, and Schofield, forwards. Darwen: - Kingsley goal, Nixon, and Leach backs, Sharp, Morrison, and Cowan, halfbacks, Hunt, Tyrer, McKae, Lees, and Kinsells, forwards Darwen had the better of the opening play, and within a couple of minutes, and opened the scoring by Kinsells after a race with Storrier for possession. Thus early encouraged the Darwen forwards went off at a great pace, and for some time had a lead in the operations of play, McKea, the centre took a smart pass from Kinsells, and his attempt to score only missed the net by the nearest shave. Almost directly afterwards the same player experienced ill luck in heading over the bar, when Menham had practically no chance to clear. The Everton forwards now roused themselves and put on pressure, but the Darwen defenders, who tackled and cleared, with good judgement, often thwarted them. Eventually Cameron equalised, after play had been in progess half an hour, and ashortly afterwards Bell gave his side the lead. The Visitor's played up strongly to the interval, but failed to score, and on changing ends the recored stood-Everton 2 goals, Darwen 1.
As in the initial half the visitors had the better of the opening play, and Tryer drove into the net, but offside was successfully claimed. The game then settled down in Darwen quarters, and a long pressure was maintained on Kingsley's charge, but the custodian brought off some magnificent saves from Chadwick, Cameron, and Taylor, and Leach eventually cleared in strong fashion. Menham was then tested from long range, and had no difficulty in keeping out shots, and following a further attack, Bell passed out to Taylor, who shot hard in, and the ball cannoned off Leach into the net. Getting to work again a further raid was levelled to the Darwen goal, and Taylor registered a fourth goal. Meanwhile the visitors had been playing pluckily, but were evidently fagged, and after forcing a couple of corners they were again thrown on defence. Chadwick finished up a movement by defeating Kingsley, and this was the last point scored and Everton winning by 5 goals to 1.

EVERTON REVIEW
December 7 1896. The Liverpool Mercury
Although the scoring in the Lancashire Cup competition at Goodison Park between Everton and Darwen greatly favoured the home side, the result was not altogether in keeping with the general run of the play. The visitors show pluckily from first to last and if their movements were not as finished as those of their opponents, they were nevertheless of a character that would pull them through many a stern encounter. They at off, with a dash that fairly look the Evertoninas by surprise, and they well earned the goal that gave then the lead for a considerable period during the first half of the game. The Everton players meanwhile were apparently reserving themselves for the latter stages and to an credinary observer it was patent that the visitors would not be able to stay the pace. Such turned out to be the case, for in the second half particular towards the close, the Evertonians asserted themselves and completely wore down their opponents, and it was during that time that the forwards substantially fastened their best. The Everton backs had plenty of work to do, and generally had ample room to get the ball away, so that they were under favorable conditions. The long kicking of the Darwen forwards at times gave them trouble, and caused endless running out on the part of Menham, who at one occasion overstepped the mark, and was lucky in being covered well by Arridge. The halfbacks played a steady game, and in the second half were more attentive to their forwards, who had innumerable chances to make headway. There was nothing exceptionally brilliant about the forward play during the greater portion of the game, but there were several magnificent individual efforts that kept up the enthusiasm of the crowd. Taylor was the most prominent in this respect, and since his inclusion at outside right this position has never been more successfully maintained. Cameron kept the wings well, and Schofield in the first half, and Chadwick and Bell in the second put in good and effective work. The Darwen team were a fairly well balanced lot, and in defence they were exceptionally clever. The custodian Kingsley dealt with shots that would have unhinged many a keeper of repute, for the saved repeatedly even from short range, and it rebounds greatly to his credit that he kept out every shot that was possible to save. The two bacls, Leach in particular played a fine defensive game, and at times came out of difficulties when failure seemed almost certain. The halfbacks were a hard working trio, and struck to the Everton forwards gamely throughout the whole of the play. While the three put in good work Sharp was the most finished, and was mainly instrumental in setting the van going. The forwards played a vigorous dashing game, but when nearing goal, they were somewhat unstrung and invariably passed the ball too far forward, and unabled an opponent to clear. However, when in possession, they made for goal in unmistaken fashion, and they were never out of their reckoning with final effort. Indeed in the first half with a little steadiness they might easily have given the Evertonians a more severe task to secure victory.
The replayed match between Bolton Wanderers and Everton is down for decision this afternoon at Burden Park. Despite the disparity between the clubs in their position in the League tables, there is sure to be a big struggle, and there are many who are confident of the ability of the Everton team to turn the tables upon their opportants, and if the form against Burnley is maintained there need be little fear as to the result. It is reported that Wright is fit and well, and will take up his usual position in the Bolton team, which will be at its full strength. For the convenience of local followers a special excursion train will leave Exchange station for Bolton at 1-10.

THE LIVERPOOL DISTRICT NOTES
The Athletic News- Monday, December 7, 1896
By the Loiterer
The emergency Committee of the Lancashire Association took a right view of Milward’s case when it came before them on Monday evening. The popular Evertonian had several testimonials of previous good character, but I daresay the candid way he detailed the circumstance went a long way in his favour, and a week’s suspension about meets the case. Similarly this punishment would have mattered little either to Milward or the club, but the re-played League match at Bolton this afternoon makes it a more serious matter for the club than it would appear. When it is borne in mind the full team failed to knock the Wanderers at Goodison Park only a week or two back the chances of Everton winning at Bolton with a weakened team are not rosy, Schofield, however, is a good player, and one who knows where the goal is situation, and he has a knack of putting the ball in very awkwardly for a goalkeeper. He was hardly as accurate as usual in his aim on Saturday, and he hesitated too much in his play, which is a great fault, when opposed to players who are keen on the ball. The team, on the whole, have improved, Cameron especially being much faster and more dangerous at goal.

DARWEN SHOT UP WELL AT EVERTON
The Athletic News- Monday, December 7, 1896
By the Loiterer
The Lancashire cup-ties in general were voted easy things for certain clubs, and the results in general have turned out in accordance with the popular verdict. For one thing, the weather clubs had to put up with the disadvantage of playing away from home, as regards the Liverpool matches, and, taking the game at Goodison Park first, the attendance proves that the majority of the weekly subscribes viewed the match as a walk over. In this they were mistaken, for many a League match has not been fought as keenly. All through the game the “Darreners” had a say in the proceedings. They started in good style, for they kept the play in midfield, and when Everton got going, and pressed them, their backs were reliable, and at any rate kept them out, though luck aided the visitors. Then the Darwen right got an opening, and made the best of it, for the ball was planted between Storrier and Arridge, and whilst they were making up their minds what to do Kinsella settled the question by getting at the ball and netting it. This point was something to be going on with, but the subsequent play did not detract from the performance, as the home goal had a narrow escape from McKie, and then Kinsella tried a header, which only just missed scoring. These items happened before the Everton men had got going, but afterwards they tumbled to the situation, and gradually took up a leading position. For a long time, the Darwen men kept them out, the backs playing a most stubborn game, and Kingsley had not much to do. But the pressure increased, and the Darwen keeper was all there with three shots that came to him, and then Cameron, who received the ball at close quarters, did not give him a chance, and the score was equalised. It was not long before Bell scored again, and the Evertonians looked more at ease. Darwen, however, gave them a shaking, as they attacked gallantly several times, and Menham was called upon to defend several times, and once his charge had a narrow escape, as the ball came to Hunt, and he made no mistake in his attempt. Only Arridge, blocked the way, or Darwen would have crossed over on an equal footing. The visitors were the first to show up on resuming, and Tyrer netted the ball early on, but off-side spoiled the effort. Then Everton took up a strong position. So stubborn was the Darwen defence that the home lot were sent away empty handed, and in turn Darwen had a spell of attacking, and it was through this opening out of play that Everton obtained a further lead, Taylor receiving the ball, and beating Kingsley a third time. The visitors played up pluckily, but were a bit outclassed. Their defence was severely tested, and came out well, but another good bit by Bell let in Taylor, who shot, and the ball cannoned off Leach into goal. This reverse did not affect the visitors in the least, as they afterwards had most of the play, and won several corners. Their efforts, however, lacked finish, for in other respect they played an exhilarating sort of game, and always kept the ball moving, and in the right direction. But for all that the Everton backs seemed to have an easy thing on in dealing with their attacks, and when the half-backs found an opening, and Chadwick scored the fifth goal, and all over as regards the result. The Darwen men, however, kept up well, although several of their men were pumped out, and in the end Everton won by five goals to one. The game was a good one, and where Darwen failed was for what of finish to their efforts. They never gave up, and the forwards, although outclassed, pegged away, and on the whole made a good show. Their tactics were just the opposite to these employed by the home lot, but they adapted themselves to their own method, and made a good show. The defence had a bust time of it, and got through a lot of work in a creditable manner. The half-backs disputed every inch of ground, and when they were beaten Leach or Nixon chipped in, and proved good defenders, whilst Kingsley gave a good account of himself, although five goals were scored against him. Not much fault can be found with the home side. Schofield was no great shakes as a substitute for Milward, and the persistent way the Darwen men defended seemed to upset the other forwards. The half backs, too, had their hands full, but the defence generally was sound, Menham, however, did not do anything out of the common, and it is not due to his ability that the scoring was not more even.

EVERTON v  DARWEN
The Liverpool Daily Post-Monday, December 7, 1896
LANCASHIRE CUP
So far as the Lancashire clubs were concerned the League competition took a back seat on Saturday afternoon, and gave place to the Senior Cup contest. Everton were not given a very stiff team to face in Darwen, but as the latter had been assiduously training throughout the week in view of the event, they anticipated giving the Evertonians a good game. Everton lost the toss, and Kinsella started the game before about four thousands spectators. The opening stages were very even, Darwen having quite as much of the attack as Everton. From midfield the visitors worked the ball nicely, Morrison and McKie sending along, and McKie, dashing up, got hold and put in a beautiful shot, registering the first goal for Darwen within a couple of minutes. This was a bit of an eye-opener for the home players and supporters and quite unexpected, but it counted all the same. However, the reverse spurred on the home men, and for several minutes Kingsley’s charge was the scene of hostilities, but the only shot deserving mention was by Chadwick, when he sent the ball just over the bar. The visitors, however, were by no means idle, and a free kick almost resulted in McKie again doing the trick, the ball just passing wide. A moment later Menham was compelled to run out to clear. This led up to a strong attack on the Darwen goal, Taylor putting in a good shot. The visitors, however, were having quite as much of the game as the home side, Kinsella putting in a shot which only went above the bar by a few inches. As excursion train from Darwen having now arrived, the “Darreners” were exceedingly jubilant on learning that their side were one in front, and called upon their champions to “Play up.” This part of the business, however, was now done by Everton, who seemed to awaken from their lethargy, and assailed the visiting goal to some purpose. Kingsley, Leach, and Nixon, however, were in fine trim, and frequently repulsed the efforts of the Everton men. On one occasion Schofield put in a lovely centre, and Cameron seemed certain to score, but Kingsley saved in marvellous manner. There was now no mistaking the determination of the Everton men. They treated their opponents seriously, and fairly kept up a persistent onslaught. The “Darreners,” however, had got in front, and intended, if possible, to keep there. Certainly, their defence was deserving of the highest praise, for their fine performance, Kingsley in particular, who kept out shots by Schofield, Cameron, and Taylor in quick succession, any one of which might easily have passed into the net without disgrace to the custodian. Still the attack was monopolised by Everton, and after repeated  failures a score at length came. Boyle put in a long shot, which Leach blocked, but before he could clear the ball Cameron, who was standing close in, banged the ball into the net quite out of Kingsley’s reach. Having opened their account, Everton played with more confidence. They again attacked strongly, but were met with a stubborn defence. A fine run by Taylor, however, resulted in a second point, Bell receiving his partner’s pass and beating Kingsley. After this Darwen had a look in, but without causing much anxiety, as the bone defenders were not pressed, and though Menham was once called upon be easily cleared. At the other end, Everton as the result of a long kick by Arridge and a judicious move on the part of Holt, strongly assailed their opponents’ charge, but again Kingsley proved a capable goalkeeper, and twice repulsed shots. Everton, however, still maintained their position, Chadwick being pulled up for offside when in a splendid position, the decision meeting with the disapproval of the crowd. Just before the interval Darwen broke away, Holt coming in for cheers for the smart way in which he pulled them up. Menham left his charge open, and Hunt had a clear goal, but Arridge beautifully cleared, Everton leading at the interval by 2 goals to 1. On resuming Darwen aroused themselves, and Kinsella and Lees getting along on the left, Storrier was severely pressed by the former, and was compelled to grant a corner. This was cleared, and Everton were soon again at the other end, where some exciting work was witnessed in close proximity to Kingsley’s charge. Shots were repeatedly sent in, but the goal was so well packed that an opening could not be found. Cameron had an abortive shie, and was soon afterwards given an easy chance by Taylor, but missed. The game was not too exciting now, but Darwen were almost acting exclusively on the defensive in which department they showed to great advantage, Kingsley still continuing to display excellent form between the sticks, whilst Leach on one occasion saved what appeared to be a certain goal. Prolonged pressure by Everton was at length brought to a close by Taylor shooting over. Midfield play ensued for a somewhat prolonged period, the halves on each side playing well. Taylor scored the third goal, soon after putting in some smart sprints, one of his efforts receiving well-merited applause. Schofield was the next to test Kingsley’s capabilities, which he again displayed to considerable advantage, saving finely. Taylor afterwards scored the fourth goal and Chadwick the fifth, just on the call of time, Everton being victorious by 5 goals to 1. Teams;- Everton;- Menham, goal; Storrier and Arridge, backs; Boyle, Holt, and Stewart, half-backs; Taylor, Bell, Cameron, Chadwick, and Schofield, forwards. Darwen.- Kingsley, goal; Dixon, and Leach, backs; Sharpe, Morrison, and Cowan, half-backs; Hunt, Tyrer, McKie, Lees, and Kinsella, forwards.

BOLTON WANDERERS 2 EVERTON 0
December 8 1896. The Liverpool Mercury
The replayed League game between these clubs took place yesterday afternoon at Bolton, and as was the case on the occasion of Everton's first visit this season in Burnden Park, the weather was altogether against there being a good exposition of the code. Rain fell heavily, and the ground was saturated in parts, so that one can well imagine the difficulties experienced by the players. Exactly exactly the same team that opposed Darwen on Saturday last represented Everton, and the Wanderers had their full strength out. The sides were as follow: - Everton: - Menham goal, Storrier, and Arridges, backs, Boyle, Holt, and Stewart (captain), halfbacks, Taylor, Bell, Cameron, Chadwick, and Schofield, forwards. Bolton Wanderers: - Sutcliffe, goals, Somerville, and Jones, backs, Paton, McGreachan, and Freebairn, halfbacks, Thomson, Gilligan, Nicol, Wright, and Jack, forwards .
Everton were fortunate in gaining the choice of ends, for they had the assistance of a fairly stiff breeze. However, the Wanderers were the first to become dangerous, and had the right taken advantage of a fine pass from Jack the scoring account must have been opened early. The ball was quickly at the other end, where Jones gave a corner, but Taylor made little use of the opening, and a spell of fairly even play followed. Eventually the Everton forwards got nicely under weigh and looked like obtaining something of a tangible nature when Paton checked their course. Holt was then busy in attending to the movements of Nicol, but ultimately Jack and Wright sped down the left only to be well met by Storrier, who cleared with the result that both Cameron and Bell made tracks towards Sutcliffe, and when in good position the Everton inside right was ruled offside. Following this the Everton goal was in danger, as Nicol forced a corner, but the ball was headed over, and immediately afterwards as the result of a fine movement on the Everton right, Taylor was in splendid position for shooting, when the referee pulled him up for offside-a ruling that was not at all favorably received in many quarters. Still the Evertonians maintained the lead as far as play was concerned, and Stewart from a free kick drove the ball into the net, but failed to get the necessary assistance to record a goal. This was followed by a severe bombardment of Sutcliffe's charge, Chadwick testing the custodian, with the shot that was fisted away with difficulty, and on returning Jones conceded a corner which brought about a melee in front of goal. McGreachan was prominent in defence at this juncture though disaster appeased certain, as Somerville raised his kick, but the wily custodian pounced upon the ball and was lucky to get it away. The Wanderers forwards with but few exceptions was at this period rarely dangerous, and the Everton backs were mainly occupied in keeping their was well forward. Chadwick and Schofield put in good work, but Paton was a stumbling block to meet of their incursions, though hopes were once again raised upon Schofield claiming a free kick, but unfortunately, Taylor headed over the bar. From the goal kick the Wanderers swooped down upon the visitors charge, and after Storrier had kept out a shot in clever fashion, Nicol had no one to beat but Menham and the latter brought off a grand save. The pressure on the Everton goal was however, short lived, and for some minutes afterwards the visiting forwards were busy attacking the Bolton defences, which was all that could be denied. Bell Schofield, and Cameron dash in, but all were treated alike and after a further visit in the other end, where McGreachan tested Menham the interval arrived nothing having been scored. It was generally admitted that the Wanderers had done exceptionally well under the existing conditions in keeping out their opponents during the first half and on resuming, conditions were certainly most favorable to them. However, the Everton forwards opened strongly and forced a corner. But shortly afterwards Thomson, who lay in a distinctly offside positions passed to Jack, who put the ball past Menham, and despite repeated protests, the referee Mr.Green, allowed the point. This had a disheartening effect upon the visitors, and they were again forced to defend. Wright shot in, and Menham cleverly saved, And almost directly afterwards the custodian kept out a clinking shot from McGreachan in most clever fashion, running out of goal, however, proved his downfall later on, as he failed to secure the ball, and Gilligan added a second point. This latter reverse appeared to disorganise the visitors, but after some little time they recovered their equilibrium, and Stewart shot into Sutcliffe's hands. Holt put in good work, but his forwards could not get going. The light became very bad towards the close, but in the last quarter of an hour Everton had undoubtedly the better of the game. Sutcliffe was several times called upon, and on one occasion he cleared in splendid style a grand shot from Chadwick. Although they gained a couple of corners, the movements of the Everton forwards lacked finish, but towards the end of the game Sutcliffe was lucky, when on the ground, to clear a fine shot from Taylor. Nothing further was scored, and the Wanderers won by 2 goals to nil. On the day's play Bolton were the better team, in as much as they were always dangerous when on the ball. Still the two goals were decidedly lucky, for the first was a comparative gift, as Thomson was palpably offside when he passed to Jack, and had Menham kept his position there was more than a probability that his charge would not have experienced a second downfall. Still, he played on the whole a grand game, and displayed plenty of resource and cool judgement. Cameron and Bell were not up to their normal standard, and Boyle was also weak, whilst Storrier was the better of the backs. The Wanderers halves were a very clever trio, and though Somerville and Jones were at times shaky, they gave little quarters while in goal Sutcliffe was, as in the first engagement, at his best.

BOLTON v  EVERTON
The Liverpool Daily Post-Tuesday December 8, 1896
Weather of a very unfavourable character prevailed at Bolton yesterday for the replaying of this League match, which was abandoned on Nov 8. Last in consequence of fog. Pools of water lay on the ground, rain having fallen in the neighbourhood throughout the morning, and was drizzling in nasty fashion when the players made their appearances. Everton won the toss, and had a slight wind their backs, but the first attack came from the Bolton right wing. Then the play settled down in midfield, but the men were terribly hampered with the slush, and the kept floundering about the result being that wing play was impossible. Nicol made several efforts to get away in the centre, but he could never find a chance to shoot, Holt and Arridge always being a check. Chadwick made a lot of ground, and opened up the opportunity for a sustained attack on the home goal without any real danger until the referee awarded the visitors a free kick, which Stewart took and passed the ball across the goalmouth, but Bell just managed to miss heading in. Chadwick later on put in a fine long kick for Sutcliffe to handle. Everton could not be shaken off, and several corners ensued, one of which was nearly resulting in the downfall of the Bolton goal Everton later on tried to rush a point. Bell charging Sutcliffe, but the latter had the best of the move, though a corner kick fell to the visitors, when Taylor all but manipulated the final touch with his head. At last the desired relief came from the home left. Wright and Jack subsequently running the leather down to Menham’s end. The struggle in the vicinity of the Everton goal was only momentary, as Arridge soon relieved but Jones played the ball back to midfield where Thomson took it up. The latter centred nicely in front of Menham, and it looked as though the Wanderers were going to score. Menham however, got well up to the ball, and though for the moment it looked doubtful whether he would save, he just managed to keep his feet and kick clear. The weather was rapidly brought back by the right wing, and Nicol had a splendid opportunity of scoring if he had only stuck to the ball. He preferred fortunately for Everton, to try a screw shot, which gave Menham a chance to clear. The ball now kept travelling up and down the field, but it seemed terribly hard work for the players, the slippery ground handicapping then severely. Everton, however, maintained the upper hand, but nothing more tangible resulted than a fruitless bully round Sutcliffe’s charge. Jack several times tried to rush away, but he was well looked after by Boyle and Holt. By degrees however, the Wanderers got down, principally through Storrier being penalised for a trip. A bit of a scrimmage took place in the Everton quarters, a free kick against Jack, however, nullifying the chance of the homesters scoring. With such dismal  weather and the heavy going, it was impossible to get up much excitement, and half time arrived without either side scoring. It was hoped that the rain would clear off and a much-increased attendance be seen at half time, but at the restart there were only a few hundreds spectators present. From the kick-off Everton got down, and Bell forced a corner. This was cleared, and the Wanderers’ left got off. Thomson centred to Jack, who rushed up and put the ball past Menham. This all happened within about a minute. Menham made a strong appeal for off-side, but the referee, after consulting with the linesmen, allowed the goal. This bit of luck for Bolton took Everton completely by surprise, and a few minutes they pressed hard for an equalising point, but Sutcliffe was not to be caught napping. The homesters were now pressing, and got Everton packed round their charge, McGeachan put in a low raking shot which feed its way safely between the legs of the defenders but Menham had his eye open, and brought off a splendid save by throwing himself on the ground. From the corner kick Wright sent the leather back. Menham unfortunately ran out, and although be stopped the shot with his knees he could not clear, and Gilligan stepped in and put the ball into the net-two goals in ten minutes. Everton for the moment appeared demoralised, and made frantic efforts, but when they settled themselves the Wanderers were forced back, and Stewart gave Sutcliffe a handful. Thompson then ran the ball up to the Everton end, where Arridge effected a grand clearance. This placed the Bolton men on the defence, but the visitors could not do any good in the mud. Holt and Bell put in such stout work, but they had finally to give way, and time after time the Wanderers raided the Everton ground. Nicol and Thomson found another opening, but as the first-named, who was right in front of goal, was about to shoot, Storrier jumped in front and the shot went over the cross-bar. So far in this half the Everton forwards had shown very poor form. There seemed to be an entire absence of combination in the line, and the consequence was the halves were all at “sea.” On the other hand, the Wanderers, with two goals in hand, were full of determination and the visitors were almost continually on the defence. Once or twice Everton found an opportunity to get down to Sutcliffe’s end, and as often as not they nullified their chance by offside play. Chadwick them put in a good shot, which brought out Sutcliffe’s qualities. Towards the finish of the game the light became very bad, and the rain, which had not once caused, came down heavier and as one was sorry when the final whistle went, leaving Bolton winners by two goals to nil. With regard to the first goal scored it was freely commented on after the match was over, and the consensus of opinion was that there was not the slightest doubt about it being offside. This was explained by the fact that one of the linesmen appealed for offside, but the referee ignored his. This was explained by the fact that one of the linesmen appealed for offside, but the referee ignored him. This was only one of the many funny decisions Mr. Green gave. Teams;- Everton.- Menham, goal; Storrier and Arridge, backs; Boyle, Holt, and Stewart, half-backs; Taylor, Bell, Cameron, Chadwick, and Schofield, forwards. Bolton Wanderers.- Sutcliffe, goal; Jones and Somerville, backs; Freebairn, McGeachan, and Paton, half-backs; Jack, Wright, Nichol, Gilligan, and Thomson, forwards.

EVERTON v SUNDERLAND
The Liverpool Daily Post- Wednesday, December 9, 1896
In the League match between the above, which takes place at Sunderland on Saturday, the following will represent. Everton;- Menham, goal; Storrier and Arridge, backs; Boyle, Holt and Stewart, half-backs; Taylor, Bell, Cameron, Chadwick, and Milward, forwards.

ECHO AND EXPRESS v OVERHEAD RAILWAY
The Liverpool Daily Post- Wednesday, December 9, 1896
This match arranged as a forerunner to the forthcoming charity match on Boxing Day, was played on the ground of the Kirkdale Club yesterday and afforded the players excellent practice. Teams;- Echo and Express; Nelson; Swan and Dixon; Cullen, Jordan, and Swift; Davies, Evans, Hughes, Matthews, and McGinnis. Press were defeated 2-0. Notes only.

TEAM ARRNAGEMENTS FOR THIS DAY
The Liverpool Daily Post- Saturday, Saturday December 11, 1896
Everton v Sunderland, at Sunderland; 2.15; Everton; Menham, goal; Storrier and Arridge, backs; Boyle, Holt and Stewart, half-backs; Taylor, Bell, Cameron, Chadwick, and Milward, forwards.
Everton Combination v Northwich Victoria, at Goodison park; 2.30.
Everton Combination.- Palmer, goal; Henderson and McDonald, backs; Nash, Hughes, and Robertson, half-backs; Williams, Maley, Banks, Campbell, and Schofield, forwards.

SUNDERLAND 1 EVERTON 1
Decemebr 14 1896. The Liverpool Mercury
The Everton team accompanied by Messrs. Prescott, Kelly, and Cuff, directors of the club, and R.Molyneux, secretary, left Liverpool on Friday for the north to engage with Sunderland in the first of the season's League engagement. As is customary, the party spent a most pleasant evening at Durham, and entrained the following morning, arriving, at Sunderland about noon. There was not a great amount of interest centred in the meeting, for on arrivaL at the ground, there was ample room to preamble in comfortable fashion, and this is rather an unusual occurrences when Everton are visitors to the Newcastle road ground. The teams were strongly representative, as will be seen from the following list: - Everton: - Menham, goal, Storrier, and Arridge, backs, Boyle, Holt, and Stewart (captain), halfbacks, Taylor, Bell, Cameron, Chadwick, and Milward, forwards. Sunderland: - Doig, goals, McNeill, and Gow, backs, Ferguson, Dunlop, and Wilson halfbacks, Gillespie, Hartness, Campbell, Hannah (d), and Johnston, forwards. Sunderland won the toss, and after Cameron had set the ball going the visitors settled down to a warm pressure on the Sunderland goal. Gow met several ugly rushes, and eventually cleared, but a free kick, taken by Stewart looked likely to produce something tangible when the ball was placed over the bar. From the goal kick, the ball was worked nicely down the home right, and Menham was twice called upon in quick succession, dealing with both shots in most capable fashion. Following some stubborn play in midfield, Gillespie made off, and centering nicely Campbell drove hard at Menham, only to find the ball well handled and cleared. Eventually Storrier and Arridges were hard pressed, and after several attempts had been made to break through Johnston sent the ball across, and Hannah being well up, headed into the net without affording Menham the slightest chance to save, the game having been in progess 20 minutes. So far Sunderland had much the best of the play, for the visiting forwards rarely got into their stride, but one fine movement along the right, in which, Taylor was prominent, looked like ending successfully, when Gow intercepted, and placed his forwards once again in fine position. Holt got his head in the way, of a dropping shot, and immediately afterwards Hartness only missing the mark by the nearest shave, Johnston afterwards putting through, but was ruled offside. Then Everton had a turn at attack, but were never allowed to get close in, and the interval arrived with Sunderland leading by a goal to nil. On resuming Bell displaced Cameron and at once the change worked well. Doig was early called upon by Cameron and following a steady pressure Gow conceded a corner, but nothing came of it, and after Storrier had given a similar chance at the other end, and the Evertonians settled down to serious work. Milward and Chadwick were busy on the left, and on the latter's placing to Bell the ball was put past Doig, but the point was not allowed. Then Campbell got away, and Dunlop finished up with a shot that struck the crossbar but 20 minutes from time, Holt met a pass from the left, and seizing his opportunity drove hard, and straight from long range, Doig making no effort to reach the ball, he being completely taken by surprise. Following the point Sunderland put on severe pressure and Menham for some minutes was kept busy in clearing. The play towards the close was most exciting, and each team strove desperately to obtain the lead but scoring was not forthcoming and the game ended in a draw of 1 goal each.

EVERTON RESERVES 7 NORTHWICH VICTORIA 0
December 14 1896 the Liverpool Mercury
At Goodison park. Northwich started, and Everton began to press. Robertson, Banks, and Campbell scored in the first quarter of an hour. Everton had all the play to the interval. Schofield, Banks, and Maley added further goals, and at half time they led by six goals to nil. The visitors defence improved greatly on resuming and Northwich put in several good attacks. Everton however, were much the smarter, but only added one more point, Result Everton 7 goals, Northwich Victoria nil. Everton: - Palmer (j), goal, Henderson (w), and Mcdonnell, backs Nash, Hughes (e), Robertson (j) halfbacks, Williams (w), Maley (w), Banks (h), Campbell (wc), and Schofield (a) forwards. (Game 10, won 8, lost 0 draw 2, for 42 against 9, points 18)

EVERTON REVIEW
December 14 1896. The Liverpool Mercury
The Everton team offered a very feeble resistance to the Bolton Wanderers on Monday last. The occasion was the replayed League game, and at Burden Park was as its worst, the play was not of a very attractive character. Everton had the wind to assist in the first half, but despite this advantage they could not make headway, and made but little impression on the Bolton defence. After keeping their goal it tact during the initial period, it was only to be expected that chance would favour the Wanderers on turning round, and such turned out to be the case, for they twice found the net and defeated Everton pointless. Still, the first goal was palpably offside, and one to nil would more accurately have represented the general run of the play. Cameron and Bell were not up to their usual form and though Schofield played fairly well in the first half he failed to stay the second, and the services of Milward were thus badly missed. Boyle was also off colour, but further behind both Storrier and Menham played a fine defensive game.
Since the institution of League games with Sunderland the prospects of the Evertonians to secure at least one point on the Newcastle road ground were never of a brighter character than they were on Saturday last. It has almost invariably happened when the exacting trip to the north has come round that one or more of our local teams have been unfortunately in a crippled state, and hence-Sunderland a long run of succcesses at home. On Saturday last however, were no deterrent circumstances to cause anxiety for one moment beyond this sodden nature of the ground, which rendered exceptionally heavy owing to recent copious down pours, tended materially to benefit the home team. Had the ground been even moderately dry there could have been no question as to the ultimate issue of the match, and when it is stated that more than one very questionable decision was given against the visitors. Critical periods of the game it can readily be grauted that Everton were unfortunate in not securing full points. Every follows of the pastime is prepared to admit that the team that score first has a powerful incentive to spur it on to success and almost without doubt this should have been the reward of Everton in the first five minutes when the referee overlooked a most glaring case of tripping within the limit line. Consulting linesmen is all very well in the way, but when it is borne in mind, that the rules of the game in this one was on the spot, and was therefore in the best position to judge for himself, it must be conceded that to me absolutely unnecessary, and unreasoning to relegate his powers to others. Besides at subsequent events proved, the wielders of the flag, one in particular did not display any great efficiency in dealing with the lower important points of the game, and fortunately the referee grasped the situration more strongly and gave he decision more independently after the earlier stages had passed over. They heavy ground favoured the home team, and after obtaining a goal which was admirably worked out, they played all over like a winning team up to the interval. During the initial half the Evertonians were most ill at ease especially in the forward line, where a glimpse of true form was a positive rarily. On the heavy ground, Cameron fell an easy victim, consequently the movements of the line were most disjointed, and towards the end of the first half the wing men resorted almost absolutely to individual efforts rather than free and comerted action, all along the line. A change was decided upon a during the interval, and the wisdom of adopting this course was at once manifest on the resumption of play. Bell was far more effective in the centre than he had hitherto been at inside right, and Cameron, in conjunction with Taylor, maintained the standard of right wing play, so that there was every prospect of recovering lost ground. Combination this now a feature of Everton's play, the Sunderland halves and backs having to keep themselves extended to their best, and when matters were running rather adorably with them they were not too particular in the methods they adopted to keep out their opponents. After the scores were made equal the Wearsiders went about their work in most determined fashion, and both Storrier and Menham were subjected to rough treatment while on the other hand, Taylor came in for an unacceptable share of the attention from the Sunderland backs. However, Everton were not to be again beaten and they are to be congratulated upon obtaining a point which, was scarely looked for, allowing their feeble display at Bolton on Monday last. Coming onto the players, Gilliespie was without doubt the most dangerous forward on the field. His flashes along the wing, and admirable centres often put Everton defenders in difficulties but fortunately they were at the right spot, and in time to relieve the custodian from ugly assaults on his charge. Hartness created a good impression and put in many fine shots, while Hannah was prominent as usual and was credited with Sunderland's goal. Campbell in the centre was a powerful opponents for Holt to deal with, but he rarely had much quarter from the Everton centre half, and most of his efforts were directed to keeping his wings at work, though there were times when he sent in several fine shots at Menham that would not have occasioned much surprise had some taken effect. It was only in the second half that the Everton forwards reached a high standard of play, and Taylor must be again accorded the palm by reason of his consistently good work throughout the whole of the game. Bell was far more effective in the centre, and when in this position those on either side of him played all over like a winning team. Chadwick and Milward were opposed to an almost impenetrate defence but despite this, both of them would probably have found the net in the first half had they received ordinary support. Honors of halfback play were fairly well divided. Wilson, Dunlop and Ferguson the first named especially were a powerful trio in the opening half, but they were somewhat unhinged in the later stages when the Everton forwards got properly into the stride, Boyle Holt, and Stewart got through plenty of work, and the little man as usual stuck to the burly Campbell in a particularly close manner that the latter did not altogether relish. These were, however, opportunities afforded when it would have been more profitable for the halves to test Doig, than to put the ball to their forwards especially as the latter were continually hugely the home trio, and on attempts in the direction by Holt from a long range was rewarded as the custodian was altogether taken by surprise. Gow and McNeill were a study pair of backs and nothing could have been finer than the cool manner in which the veteran met almost every attempt to break through, and eventually clear. Arridge had a tough wing to deal with, and got through his work in finished fashion while Storrier rather surprised the Wearsider by the cool and effective way that he sent them on the right. They covered each other admirably, and never gave occasion for advance criticism. Menham gave an excellent display in goal, and has apparently got over the nervousness, that was noticeable in previous matches. He struck to his post well, dealing with all kinds of shots in good fashion, and cleared well, one save in the first half from Campbell being simply marvelous, as the ball was sent in low with terrific speed from close range. Taking the game all through a draw was the fitting conclusion to arrive at on the total play.

THE LIVERPOOL DISTRICT NEWS
The Athletic News- Monday, December 14, 1896
By the Loiterer
Everton did not manage to win at Sunderland, but they came away with a draw, which is something, and a feat they have not accomplished before. It is a distinct advance on last season’s result, when a week team did duty, and were beaten by the Northerners by three goals to none. That was the heaviest defeat the team ever received at Sunderland, as previously a goal only separated the two teams. There has always been a keen struggle between these teams, and the rivalry that has existed for some seasons has been due to the always doubtful results of the games more than anything else. There is nothing like the rivalry an exists between such clubs as Liverpool and Everton, but when Sunderland are engaged with Everton the public take more than ordinally interest in the match. The apparent falling off in the play of the two great teams has not affected the interest in the least, as in this respect there is not much to choose, and, as was anticipated, each side rose to the occasion, and the result is a draw, which, as I have said, is one better than Everton have ever previously done. Well, each team can do with the odd point.
Northwich Victoria have come down considerably of late from what they used to be when they visited Bootle some few seasons ago. The descent has been gradual, but none the less sure. Yet I hope they will manage to hold their own in the circle they are in. The Everton Combination, however, had little difficulty with them on Saturday, as will be seen from the scoring in the first half, when six goals were registered against them. They did better in the second half, or rather their opponents were more lenient, as though only another goal scored, the home team had their own way.

SUNDERLAND DRAW WITH EVERTON
The Athletic News-Monday, December 14, 1896
By Tom Tiddler
Saturday’s was the twenty-first meeting between Everton and Sunderland. In all Sunderland have beaten the “Toffee Boys” 14 times and lost four. Wanting points as badly as the locals, the visitors travelled to Durham the day before the match, arriving in Sunderland soon after noon. Both sides were strongly represented, as will be seen from the following list;-
Everton.- Menham, goal; Storrier and Arridge, backs; Boyle, Holt and Stewart (Captain), half-backs; Taylor, Bell, Cameron, Chadwick, and Milward, forwards.
Sunderland,- Doig, goal; McNeill and Gow, backs; Ferguson, Dunlop, and Wilson, half-backs; Gillespie, Hartness, Campbell, Hannah, and Johnston, forwards. Referee, Mr. J. West, Lincoln. The afternoon was dull and threatening, the second half, in fact, being played in a drizzling rain. All things considered, there was a capital attendance, the gate receipts falling just a trifle short of £150. Cameron set the ball on its journey, and the Wearsiders were speedily making free with it. They drove back a breakaway by the strangers, and gave Menham a couple of hot shots to deal with. Campbell sent in the first, and the custodian had just cleared when “Wee” Johnston toppled him over. Sunderland kept it up, their movements being characterised by a freedom of action that was refreshing to see. For the first quarter of an hour the home team had nearly all the play, the Everton forwards vainly waiting for the ball to come out to them. Then Holt enabled Cameron to get away, but Wilson checked him, and the Wearsiders becoming dangerous, Gillespie had an opening and shot in. the ex-soldier promptly cleared, but Johnston collared, and lifting to the front of the goal month. Hannah received the ball on his cranium, and headed in a beautiful goal just nineteen minutes from the start. It was a well-earned goal without a doubt. Everton assumed a formidable attitude after the restart, their effort, however, being a short-lived one, and for the next few minutes the locals were busy at the other end. Some capital shots were put in, and while a few were a shade wide the remainder were cleverly steered away, Storrier driving into touch- and out of the field once or twice-on every opportunity. As the interval drew nigh the visitors gave us a taste of their quality, the forwards travelling with the ball at a great rate. A fine run by Bell and Taylor ended in the latter centring finely. Cameron met the ball, and made a grand attempt to score, but the ball struck one of the uprights and rebounded into play. The succeeding item was the placing of the ball into the net by Johnston, but he was so clearly offside that the referee had no doubt as to where the next kick should be taken. The interval was sounded directly after with Sunderland leading by a goal to none. The spell was a short one, and the teams were soon at it again. Sunderland were the first to show up, but Everton speedily nipped them up, and pressed vigorously for some time. Taylor had a good shy, and Cameron followed suit, each without effect. A free kick was conceded the attackers close in, and from this the ball was “skied” over the bar. Once more the fortunes of the game veered to Sunderland, but Everton seemed now in earnest and, quickly driving them back, had the best of the deal for a short period. On one occasion Doig, while clearing, was lifted right up off the ground, yet he got the leather away before he fell. Everton kept pegging away, and about half an hour from the turn round, Holt scored with a knot of players in front of him. Doig tried a effort to stop the ball, the shot in itself was a simple one, and even Holt seemed surprised when it went through. Sunderland gamely rallied under this sudden and unexpected reverse, and in the closing stages pressed determinedly. They could not score, however, and a hard-fought game was left drawn with a goal each. In the first half the Wearsiders had by far the best of matters, but on turning over the visitors got more than the half-share. Taking the game as a whole there was not much in it, but what there was decidedly in favour of the locals. The forwards were not as speedy as Everton. Still, they combined more effectively. Campbell played grandly in the centre, and had hard lines at least twice with his final shots. The wings were, however, not so dangerous, yet it is only fair to state that they worked unselfishly. Holt was all over the shop, at one time relieving and at another placing the ball neatly, his only fault being a tendency to roughness. Stewart’s throws-in were a bone of contention all the afternoon and the referee ought to have pulled him up oftener than he did. The defence was good. Menham shaped well. On the home side Doig only made the one mistake that ended so disastrously. Gow was prone to wander, yet he and McNeill did yeoman service. The halves were the mainstay of the team, and fairly bottled up the opposing five, with the exception of Cameron. Johnson and Hartness were not quite up to the standard of the other three. Still, the line as a whole left little room for complaint. All did well all things considered, and had they but won their happiness would have been complete.

EVERTON v  SUNDERLAND
The Liverpool Daily Post- Monday, December 14, 1896
THE Everton team left Liverpool on Friday afternoon, accompanied by Messrs, Cuff, Kelly, Molyneux, and Prescot, for Sunderland with the object of playing the first League match with Sunderland during the present season. The party reached Durham about half-past seven on Friday night, and here a stoppage was made, the Cathedral city being the breaking stage of the journey. Saturday morning turned out fine, after a somewhat foggy opening, and the appearances altogether were favoruable for an enjoyable afternoon. Everton kicked off, and on two occasions Doig was troubled to the utmost extent keeping out Chadwick and Milward. Shortly afterwards Johnson got in and Menham saved. A free kick let in the Sunderland boys, but hands against Johnson served the Everton men nicely, though the final effort from Chadwick went over the bar. End to end play ensued, until Wilson made a fine clearance, but Taylor replied cleverly. After Stewart had been beaten, Holt served up. This advantage came to nothing, the home players coming up, but at the last moment Holt saved an almost certain goal from Hartness. A foul against Storrier was very dangerous, but the ball was propelled into the net without touching a second player, Wilson taking the free kick. Sunderland still kept up the pressure, and a second free kick having been replied to by Menham and Storrier, Johnson headed in, Hannah scoring the first goal for the home team after twenty minutes’ play. The Everton players then exerted themselves, first McNeill and then Gow being noticeable in the way of splendid defence; and the result was that the home side came away again, Hartness getting in a fine shot which just missed the mark; a corner followed, Hannah coming on next with a daisy cutter which Menham coped with. Gillespie then sent in a grand shot which Menham headed away, but after a temporary visit to the home quarters. Johnson got in again, Holt rendering splendid services in the saving line. The Everton right them worked down very prettily, and Taylor gave a grand centre, which Bell failed to turn to account. The home players soon returned the compliment, Campbell getting in a great shot. The left wing now for about the first time became prominent. Shortly afterwards Taylor sent in a long shot, which, however, did no harm, and then Gow rushed across and stopped another raid. The Everton defence was then troubled to some extent, Menham heading away, but this was followed by a clear run on the part of Taylor and Bell, who worked the leather down only to be spoiled by Doig, who handled the ball in queer fashion, but finally had time to clear. A couple of attacks by the home players culminated in a good shot from Hartness going high over the bar. The Everton players then commenced to assert themselves to a high degree, Taylor running down and centring, but Cameron missed a splendid opportunity by shooting wide. A corner at the other end came to nothing, and subsequent pressure by the home side was fruitless, an offside goal being sent in by Johnson. This terminated the first half, during which the Sunderland players had much the best of the game, crossing over with a lead of a goal to nil. The opening of the second half was signalised by the Wearsiders being prominent once more, Arridge at once clearing. The visitors were not slack in turning the tables, Taylor and Bell each having shots at the Sunderland goal. A throw in by the homesters was met and sent across to Milward but the ball was again sent out of play. The Everton men again came up at the double, and shots from Taylor and Bell were very troublesome to Doig. A foul against Wilson gave the visitors another look in, but nothing came of the effort. Stewart played splendidly against the home side when they moved down, and Menham just saved from Campbell, Taylor forced a corner which was unproductive, and then McNeill got the better of Chadwick. Just before this stage of the game Bell changed places, with Cameron the result being a much springthlier game on the part of the Everton men. Hands against the visitors gave the Wearsiders a further look in, Johnson claiming a corner, but Everton came out of the ordeal with flying colours. Heavy pressure was put upon Gow, who yielded what proved to be a barren corner, and just afterwards Chadwick sent across, Taylor shooting into the net, but from an offside position. Holt fouled Campbell, and the home side got well down from the free kick, Dunlop striking the crossbar a minute later. End to end play ensued, each defensive line being taxed to the utmost, but after about twenty-five minutes’ play Holt got the better of his opponents, and from over a score yard range shot in and equalised the score. On one or two subsequent occasions the Evertonians experienced hard lines, but Sunderland made some desperate efforts at the finish, and just missed three times. The result was a draw-1 goal each. Teams;- Everton;- Menham, goal; Storrier and Arridge, backs; Boyle, Holt and Stewart (Captain), half-backs; Taylor, Bell, Cameron, Chadwick, and Milward, forwards. Sunderland;- Doig, goal; McNeill and Gow, backs; Ferguson, Dunlop and Wilson, half-backs; Gillespie, Hartness, Campbell, Hannah, and Johnson, forwards.

EVERTON FOOTBALL CLUB TO-MORROW’S MATCHES
The Liverpool Daily Post-Friday, December 17, 1896
Tomorrow the League team meet Stoke at Goodison Park in the League competition. No matter how badly they may be running in the fight for points, they always manage to give Everton a good game whenever they meet. On Saturday last they beat West Bromwich Albion at West Bromwich, and we may be sure that this will give them every confidence for the present game. So Everton had better be prepared for a big struggle. It is said that the Stoke left wing is the strongest in England, and their new goalkeeper is a fitting successor to the great Rowley. The Everton executive are replying on the same team that did so well at Sunderland last Saturday, and no doubt the crowd will give them every encouragement. Especially in the case of Menham, who played a grand game in goal against Sunderland. The kick-off is at 2.15, and the following have been selected to represent Everton.- Menham, goal; Storrier and Arridge, backs; Boyle, Holt, and Stewart, half-backs; Taylor, Bell, Cameron, Chadwick, and Milward, forwards. Reserve- Hartley.
Everton Combination v Chester, at Chester; kick-off at 2.30.
Everton Combiantion.- Palmer, goal; Barker and Molyneux, backs; Goldie, Hughes, and Robertson, half-backs; Williams, Maley, Banks, Campbell, and Schofield, forwards.
NEWSBOYS CHARIRTY MATCH
“EXPRESS” AND “ECHO” v UNITED RAILWAYS
A correspondent, writing from Waterloo, says;- “During the next few days the generous and kind-hearted will be giving practical sympathy and help to many,” and then desires to say a word on behalf of the boys and girls who sell newspapers, who he seems to imagine are forgotten. Now we wish to call attention to the above charity match, which will take place on Boxing Day, at Goodison Park, the kick-off being timed for 10.30, and the proceeds of which go to give the newsboys and girls a good Christmas meal. The Lord Major is in practical sympathy with the movement, and has promised a donation, besides kicking off on the eventful morning.
CHRISTMAS DAY FOOTBALL IN LIVERPOOL
TO THE EDITOR OF THE DAILY POST
Sir,- having heard it rumoured that Everton were going to play their match with Celtic in the morning in order to avoid clashing with the League match at Anfield, I would point out that, while that would do all well enough as far as those two are concerned, the charity match would be very poorly attended. I think the difficulty could be overcome by Everton playing in the morning and postponing the Charity match till Boxing Day, immediately before the Sunderland match. They might also charge- say 3d extra to all parts of the ground, as the spectators would see two matches. They could count 3d each for the estimated number present as the portion to go to charity, which I think, would get more by this means than the ordinary course. If they did this, I think it would be to the benefit of all concerned.- Yours, &c., EVERTONIAN

EVERTON 4 STOKE CITY 2
December 21 1896. The Liverpool Mercury
The first of this season's League games between these two clubs, was played at Goodison Park on Saturday, before 10,000 spectators. The sides were as follows : - Everton: - Menham goal, Storrier, and Arridge, backs, Boyle, Holt, and Stewart (captain) halfbacks, Taylor Bell, Cameron, Chadwick, and Milward, forwards. Stoke - Johnstone, goal, Clare, and Dunbar backs, Fearns, Grewars, and Rowley halfbacks, Eardley, Bentley, Maxwell (a), Maxwell (w), and Schofiled, forwards.
Immediately on starting Schofield ran nicely down the Stoke left, and threatening between the home backs opened out a fine chance for A.Maxwell who in most unaccountable fashion put the ball outside. Chadwick got away from the goal kick, and after repassing with Milward the maide man centred accurately, and Cameron headed through, this success coming after one minute's play. Getting to work again, the home team was bust attacking, and as Clare missed his kick further disaster threatened, but the ball was put behind. A long kick by Arridge caused Johnstone to handle, and as he did not clear effectively Bell was quickly up and notched a second point, after play had been in progess eight minutes. The Everton forwards were very keen on the ball, and as the Stoke defenders were at this period often penalised there appeared every prospect of the home side substantially increasing their lead. However the visitors livened up considerably, and Maxwell levelled a shot that went slightly wide, and then Boyle got in the way of a clinking drive from Schofield that looked certain to reach the net. At the other and Taylor finished up well, Johnston with a flying kick just keeping him out, and for the next few minutes Menham had a trying time, as shot came from Bentley. A.Maxwell and Schofield that only just missed the mark. Attacking again Bentley struck the crossbar, and Schofield put behind, but a further movement met with better success, as W.Maxwell shot between the backs and scored. Play was no sooner resumed than Taylor took up the running and centring to Chadwick the ball rebounded off the latter player, and the outside right with a side touch placed it past Johnstone, this being the last point scored up to the interval, when the scored stood-Everton 3 goals Stoke 1. On resuming the visitors were the first to become prominent, and a low shot from A.Maxwell looked like taking effect, when Menham got down to it and cleared well. Still Stoke maintained the upper hand, and following a further attack, which Storrier accounted for, Grewar essayed from a long range and struck the bar, Boyle eventually clearing. ‘'Hands'' in the Everton goal looked ominous, but a save was effected at the expense of a corner, and getting well under weigh Chadwick sent in a clever shot which cannoned off Dunbar and Johnston, and was easily cleared. Meanwhile Holt had been exceptionally bust, his work calling for frequently plaudit from the crowd as he tackled first one and than another of his opponents with complete success. Closely following Bentley was in grand position, and shot hard at Menham who brought off a good save, and for the next five minutes the Stoke forwards were masters of the field. Chadwick and Milward broke the monotony of pressure, and than Johnstone saved luckily from Cameron after Taylor had made the running on the right. Play was again at the Everton end, and W.Maxwell shot hard at Menham, who failed to get the ball away, and Bentley rushed up and Scored. There were now prospects of a drawn game, as Stoke hovered round the Everton goal, and Menham was distinctly lucky on two occasions, but eventually the Everton forwards forged ahead, and on Storrier placing a free kick beautifully, Bell headed through, and the final result stood Everton 4 goals Stoke 2.

CHESTER 1 EVERTON RESERVES 2
December 21 1896. The Liverpool Mercury
At Chester. In the first half Chester through splendid goal keeping by Coventry, kept Everton out for 35 minutes and then banks scored twice for Everton in rapid succession. Chester forced the play in the second half, but the Everton defence was sound. Turner scored for Chester, who had hard lines in not equalising. Result Everton 2 goals, Chester 1. Everton: - Palmer (j), goal, Barker (g), and Molyneux (g), backs, Goldie (h), Hughes (e), and Robertson (j), halfbacks, Williams (j), Maley (w), Banks (h), Campbell (wc), and Schofield (a) forwards . (Game 11 won 9 lost 0 draw 2, for 44 against 10, points 20)

EVERTON REVIEW
December 21 1896. The Liverpool Mercury
Everton are slowly but surely giving evidences of improvement, and if they but tide over the holiday fixtures without a repetition of accidents that have almost invariably marred their progess in previous seasons at this time of the year, they may yet run their near neighbours a close race for local honours. The game on Saturday was well supported, and notwithstanding the slippery nature of the ground, the play on the whole reached a high standard, and was vested with a plethora of exciting incidents that served to keep up the temperature of the crowd during the whole of the contest. From the outset the Stoke centre had the Everton goal at his command, and missed scoring in most unaccountable fashion, the excitement having scarely subsided till it was again renewed as Cameron opened the home account after a minute's play. There was no staying the progess of the home lot after this, and when seven minutes later the margin had been increased, there were visions of a substantial addition to the home goal average. However, Stoke gradually improved, and though they were scarely ever superior to their rivals in the first portion of the game, they often held a more commanding position in the later stages, and sided by a spice of luck, might easily have put a different aspect upon the game. The closing incidents of play were plentiful of excitement, as during the last five minutes both custodians had a most anxious time with shots that were levelled from close quarters, and through both Menham and Johnston were once beaten in this period they might easily have been forgiven had they experienced further disasters. On the whole, the Evertonians had slightly the better of play, and their success was mainly clue to the fact that they maintained a better foothold on the slippery ground than their opponents. The home players got about in their rubber boots with comparative ease and when making for goal, their movements were in marked contrast to those of the visitors, who were on many occasions most ill at ease. The Stoke backs experienced great difficulty in this respect, and were often faulty, consequently there was more latitude allowed to the home forwards to get in shots than one is accustomed to see under high-pressure football. The Everton forwards played a forcible and well-combined game, in which, the wingmen had a most important part. As an outside right Taylor could scarely have been beaten so accurate were his centres and deliberate aim at goal, despite the fact that he was the subject of repeated attentions from the Stoke halves and backs. The goal scored by him was a beautiful effort, and there can be no question that he has become a tower of strength in the Everton attack. Bell showed improvement upon late displays. Still he has yet attained his standard of excellence, but should this be soon forthcoming opponents will have a warm task set them in order to keep down the scoring. Cameron's mission appeared to be to keep the wings well employed, and in this direction he succeeded admirably. Inside play was often, adopted and with marked success, for the Stoke defenders were frequently lured to the centre, with the result that the opposing wingers with a wide pass, were left in a commanding position. Milward and Chadwick played admirably together and if their final efforts did not meet with success they nevertheless gave a sound exposition that thoroughly delighted the spectators. At halfback the home side was exceptionally strong and once again Holt came in an easy first. His tackling was superb and throughout the whole of the game he never knew what it was to be beaten, as he followed up his men and invariably obtained their measure at the finish. Boyle showed district improvement upon recent displays, and Stewart always about when danger threatened, and rarely beaten. The full back positions were not so ably maintained, for neither Storrier nor Arridges gave one an impression of confidences. Still they executed their work without serious blemish, and Menham in goal, came through the ordeal very celibately, though in the last few minutes, when Stoke looked like equalising, he appeared to lose himself, and fortunately for him luck came his way. The Stoke forwards, after the first quarter of an hour was a distinctly good lot, and in the second half especially did they keep the home trio and backs extended to their very best efforts. With a more capable centre than Allen Maxwell, the quendum Liverpool player, they must have run the Evertonians a very tight race indeed for, in addition to the chance afforded him immediately after the opening of the game, there were many fine passes from the wings that should have been better utilised. Schofield and W.Maxwell formed a powerful left wing and it was from this quarter that most of Stoke attack was levelled. The outside man was very speedy and resourceful, and it took Boyle and Storrier all their time to keep him in check. At the other end of the line. Bentley was always a prominent figure, especially when in the neighbourhood of goal. Grewar played a fine centre half game, both in keeping his van well employed and in attending to the Everton inside men, while Clare best represented the full back division. Johnston in goal had a bust time, particularly in the first half of the game, and the shots that beat him were altogether out of his reach.

EVERTON WIN AT HOME
The Athletic News- Monday, December 21, 1896
By the Loiterer
I think it is a long time since Stoke won a match at Everton or in Liverpool. At Bootle in the old days they did not do badly, but somehow they are looked upon as easy victims at the present time. It is another thing when they are tackled on their own ground, as both Everton and Liverpool have found out in the past, but generally speaking Everton have had the pull in the League games, Stoke being content to spring a surprise in the Cup ties. A large number of the Everton supporters are prepared for anything nowadays, and a win for Stoke would hardly have upset them, so accustomed have they become to be disappointed. On the other hand, the ground opinion was the team would obtain two points, for indifferent as Everton have done Stoke are even worse off in the League table. The teams turned out up to time, and at their best, as will be seen from the following list of players;-
Everton;- Menham, goal; Storrier and Arridge, backs; Boyle, Holt, and Stewrat (Captain), half-backs; Taylor, Bell, Cameron, Chadwick, and Milward, forwards. Stoke.- Johnstone, goal; Clare and Durber, backs; Fearns, Grewer, and Rowley, half-backs; Eardley, Bentley, A. Maxwell, and Schofield, forwards. Referee, Mr. Green. The opening was rather startling, and Schofield was prominent right from the kick-off, a good run and centre being badly thrown away by A. Maxwell missing a good opening. The home team improved on this, for Cameron was more successful with the assistance of Chadwick and Milward, and before the game was two minutes old the home side were one up. Their success did not end here, for in another five minutes Bell had added another. The play for some time was in favour of Everton, and the general run of the game was such as to give their supporters every confidence. The Stoke forwards could not get going at all, so well were the home halves playing, but Schofield had more than one try, and appeared to be biding his time. The other lot were more business-like in their endeavours, and kept pegging away, and presently they had their reward, for the game took a turn, and the Everton goal was the scene of operations. Allan Maxwell had hard lines in heading wide after Bentley had hot the crossbar. They were soon back again, and this time W. Maxwell scored. The advantage was not held for long, as the Everton forwards went away from the kick-off, and before we hardly knew the game had started Taylor had netted the ball a third time. With a comfortable lead of two goals the home team started the second half easily, but the visitors did not take this view of the situation. For some time Everton ahd the best of the play without doing anything brilliant. The shies at goal were not bad considering the slippery state of the ground, but with the fewer chances Stoke proved better marksmen, and Menham had several ticklish shots to stop. Johnstone had also more work on hand as the game went on, Cameron on one occasion testing him with a low one, followed immediately with one from Milward. But at this stage there was always something interesting going on, for the attacks on the goals alternated, and were pretty frequent. The concluding portion was intensely exciting, as Bentley scored a second goal, and Stoke looked all over equalising, for the ball was soon back again, and an exciting scrummage took place in front of the Everton goal. Holt, however, relieved, and the next minute Bell scored a fourth goal from a free kick. Stoke did not give up after this disaster, and Bentley ought to have improved the appearance of the game by scoring. Anyway, he didn’t, and the game wound up with a grand finish, Everton winning by four goals to two. Stoke played a better game than any I have seen them. Yet they are weaker in defence, Johnstone was all right in goal, and kept out some grand shots, but the backs were not at all reliable. They seemed too slow to tackle their opponents in the open, and when they were pressed they play a scrambling sort of game. The half-backs were good, Grewer especially, and a lot of credit is due to Fearns and Rowley in keeping the home forwards from doing damage. In addition to defensive work, they assisted their forwards and had a hand in every attack. The forwards played by fits and starts at one period being indifferent and the next doing well. They certainly played a hard game, and made good use of their opportunities. The two Maxwells were always prominent, and Schofield did well several times, but in his case the work was found for him. On the Everton side, Menham gave every satisfaction, and he had some exacting work. He must, however, carry the ball less, or he will put his side in a pickle someday. The backs were like Stoke’s pair, unreliable, due, no doubt to the slippery state of the ground. They appeared to be rather easily beaten when once the half-backs were passed, and it is just as well the Everton trio were in good form. Holt was in splendid trim, his success throughout the game being apparent to all. Stewart in defence was grand, and Boyle was little behind. Forward, Taylor played a dashing game, and was ahead of the others. Chadwick put in some rare good shots, and he and Milward combined well. Cameron at times seemed hampered by the state of the ground, and was not near so sure footed as the others, or more goals would have been put on, and Bell was not at his best by a long way.

EVERTON v STOKE
The Liverpool Daily Post- Monday, December 21, 1896
The first match this season between the above was played at Goodison Park, by way of a change the day was a gloriously fine for football, but spectators found the wintry weather somewhat cold. However, it was quite a treat to have the sun shining during the proceedings. The spectators, however, were very late in putting in an appearance, and at the start there would not be more than 5,000 present, though the turnstiles at that time were particularly busy. The ground was in perfect condition, and favoured a fast game, and consequently it was anticipated that Everton would be seen to advantage. Cameron started the game, and Schofield at once dashed away and centred, Holt not being able to get up in time to check, and Allan Maxwell shot in strongly, just missing by a couple of feet. From the goal-kick Everton got well down on the left, and Chadwick judiciously passed to Cameron, who had no difficulty in beating Johnstone a minute from the start. Nothing daunted at this reverse, Stoke went straight away from the centre, Schofield and A. Maxwell making off at a tremendous pace, and securing a free kick in a favourable position matters looked somewhat ominous for Everton. Holt and Milward, however, gave the necessary relief, Everton making a raid, which was of a somewhat prolonged character, Chadwick, Bell, and Taylor each putting in fine shots, but, fortunately for Stoke, their backs were in fine form. The greasy state of the ground was responsible for one or two misses by Taylor, but at last the Everton men bored their way in and forced a corner, which was cleared, although subsequently Arridge sent well forward, the leather being finely headed outside the goal post. The Stoke men were only just allowed a passage over the half line before the Everton left came away with a swing. Milward shooting wide of the mark. Then the right wing got to work, Taylor performing wonderfully well and centring finely, Cameron on one occasion not being able to get up in time, when a splendid opening was apparent. At length the efforts of the home team were rewarded, as after the ball had been kept dangerously near the Stoke goal for some moments, Bell chipped in and scored the second goal. This further success naturally placed Everton on exceedingly good terms with themselves, and following the centre kick they made a terrific raid on Johnstone’s charge, but a couple of abortive corners were the only result. Everton, however, still continued to have by far the best of the argument, the game being almost exclusively contested in close proximity to the Stoke goal, but though many good attempts were made no score came. A likely move by the Stoke right followed, but Arridge proved a very hard nut to crack. Then Rowley took up the cudgels on behalf of his side, and served up beautifully on two occasions, besides which he did a bit of forward work which resulted in a corner being granted. This certainly come to nothing, but Storrier had to work desperately to clear. Cameron and Milward each missed at the other end, and then Schofield came clean away, tricked Boyle, and, although very much hampered by Holt, effected a splendid centre, which was met by Allan Maxwell, and banged forward only to stroke the crossbar. The ball was sent in again, and then Menham came out in champion form and saved his charger. Stoke for a few minutes had a monopoly of the play, and Everton were kept busy defending. Storrier, however, was in a great form, and twice repulsed in fine fashion. His second clearance was the means of placing Everton once more in an aggressive position, Chadwick putting in a splendid piece of work, and finishing up with a grand shot, which missed the mark. Stoke, however, were by no means idle, and at length found a footing in Everton’s half. Here some smart finishing was shown by the visiting front rank, and after Storrier had once cleared W. Maxwell got hold and defeated Menham, who had scarcely a fair chance of getting to the ball. Another surprise was in store for the Potters, which came in the shape of splendid run by Taylor, after Bell had given his partner a pretty pass. This the outside right turned to splendid account, as after running up and centring, he dashed to the front when one or two of his comrades had missed, and scored the third goal. Everton had the better of the argument subsequently, although Johnstone was playing a sterling game, Holt coming in for recognition, and Menham saving a sand-grounder. Just on half-time Everton gained a corner, and the score at the interval was 3 goals to 1 in Everton’s favour. When the second half was commenced the attendance had been materially increased. The Potters made the first show, but the homesters quickly retaliated, and Chadwick nearly got in through Durber missing. Schofield then made his presence felt, and Storrier was constrained to give a corner. This proved a near thing for Everton, as Grewer struck the crossbar, and the ball rebounding it was difficulty that the leather was got away. Just afterwards Bentley shot across the goalmouth, and Stoke continued to press. A foul resulted in another corner, but the ball was sent behind the goal, Everton by degrees got into Stoke’s territory, Milward trying a good shot but the ball was driven over the line. Bell tried a long shot, which Clare cleared, and then Chadwick put in a terrific shot, which almost knocked Johnstone off his pins. He, however, got the ball away to the accompaniments of loud cheers, and then Stoke, who were playing better than in the initial stage, got well down, but Holt and Boyle, who were giving a splendid account of themselves, relieved on two occasions grandly. The Staffordshire men, however, still kept up the attack in a vigorous style, Menham luckily saving from Allan Maxwell. A moment later and the Everton right made headway, the result being a strong shot from Cameron, this being followed by some yeoman service on the part of both Stewart and Bell, who each had hard lines. A very pretty move by Schofield was first checked by Boyle, but on the rush being continued the Everton goalkeeper by a grand effort saved his charge. The Stoke men came back on the right, but Bentley missed, and Eardley met with no better success when he tried his prentice hand. Everton now combined better, and as a result they kept Stoke defending for a while, but the only attempt worthy of mention was one by Bell, which just went the wrong side of the post. For some time after this the game went all in favour of Everton, who constantly assailed the visitors’ goal, but though several good attempts to increase the score were made, the backs proved too good, Clare particularly playing a fine game. Stoke in an offside position, shot in, Storrier just touching the ball to Bentley, who had no difficulty ins coring Stoke’s second goal. Everton vehemently protested against the point, but all to no purpose, the referee pointing to the centre. Stoke played up after this, and almost scored again. A sudden rush by Everton resulted in a free kick, Stewart placing the ball close into goal, and Bell headed a fourth goal, Everton winning by 4 goals to 2. Teams;- Everton.- Menham, goal; Storrier and Arridge, backs; Boyle, Holt and Stewrat, half-backs; Taylor, Bell, Cameron, Chadwick, and Milward, forwards. Stoke.- Johnstone, goal; Durber and Clare, backs; Fearns, Grewer, and Rowley, half-backs; Eardley, Bentley, A. Maxwell, Schofield, and W.S. Maxwell, forwards.

THE EVERTON CLUB
The Liverpool Daily Post- Thursday, December 24, 1896
The Everton Football club have arranged a couple of most attractive fixtures for the Christmas holidays, and no doubt they will be rewarded by tremendous gates on both Christmas and Boxing Days. The executive have departed from their usual custom in the matter of time of kick-off on Christmas Day. In the past these fixtures have always been brought off in the afternoon, but as many of their supporters complained that the famous institution the Christmas dinner was spoiled owing the to kick-off being fixed for so early in the afternoon, the committee decided upon a change, and the game will commence at 10.45 a.m. Celtic are bringing down their best team, including Doyle, who is playing better than ever, and McArthur, their crack goalkeeper. King, the international, whom many English League team endeavoured to capture, will play, as will Russell, the fair-headed laddie who played for North end a couple of season ago. Everton are finding places for Molyneux (left back), Robertson (left half) and Banks and Maley (forwards) all of whom have earned a trial with the first team. No doubt great interest will be taken in their debut and every encouragement given to these young players. Everton will be at full strength when they meet Sunderland on Saturday, in their return League game and they will need to put on all they know, as Sunderland have the knack, no matter how badly they may be doing, of rising to the occasion when they meet Everton. They did so the other week, when the teams net at Sunderland, and will, no doubt repeat the performance on Saturday, at Goodison Park.
The following are the Everton team arrangements for the week-end.
Christmas Day v Celtic, at Goodison Park; 10.45
Everton;- Menham, goal; Storrier and Molyneux, backs; Goldie, Boyle, and Robertson, half-backs; Taylor, Maley, Banks, Cameron, and Milward, forwards.
Christmas Day v Tranmere Rovers at Tranmere; 2.30
Everton Combination-Palmer, goal; W. Balmer and McDonald, backs; Nash, Hughes, and Elliott, half-backs; J. Balmer, Williams, Hartley, Campbell, and Schofield, forwards.
Saturday v Sunderland at Goodison Park;2.15
Everton.- Menham, goal; Storrier and Arridge, backs; Boyle, Holt, and Storrier, half-backs; Taylor, Bell, Cameron, Chadwick and Milward, forwards.

EVERTON v  CELTIC
The Liverpool Daily Post- Saturday, December 24, 1896
For their Christmas engagement, the Everton Club invited Celtic to pay them a visit, and yesterday morning an interesting friendly game was indulged in. the weather fortunately was beautifully fine and mild, and as a consequence there was a very fair crowd of spectators present, when the teams faced each other in the following order;- Everton; Menham, goal; Storrier and Molyneux, backs; Goldie, Boyle, and Robertson, half-backs; Taylor, Maley, Banks, Hartley and Milward, forwards. Celtic;- Cullen, goal; Orr, and J. King, backs; Russell, Farrell, and A. King, half-backs; half-backs; Morrison, Blessington, Docherty, Henderson, and Ferguson, forwards. Losing the toss, Everton started, and getting the best of the opening exchanges, the home forwards firmly established in Celtic territory. A beautiful bit of passing on the part of the home quintet terminated in Hartley shooting strongly, but Cullen was equal to the occasion and cleared beautifully. Then Taylor was given a nice opening, but he sent wide, and the visitors’ left wing raced away, Ferguson centring smartly, but the movement came to nothing, Keeping up their pressure the Celtic men cut out the work for the Everton backs, the left wing proving particularly dangerous. At length, a corner was forced and a goal seemed certain, when Molyneux rushed in and cleared. Another bombardment of the home goal was succeeded by Hartley and Milward racing off. The former shaped splendidly, and he was in capital position when Orr spoiled his chances of getting through, Banks was then responsible for a further attack on the Celtic goal, and some pretty work was done by the Everton forwards, who, however, were wretched at shooting, and they were finally put to the right-about without piercing Cullen’s charge. The visitors them got off nicely, and Morrison sent in a stinger, but Menham had little difficulty in accounting for it. Then Everton once more aggressive, Taylor and Maley putting in a magnificent bit of work, which terminated in the last-named sending in a beautiful shot, which was, however, smartly saved. Then the Everton right wing again took up the attack, and Taylor sent in a fine shot that found its way past Celtic custodian. The home team were now having decidedly the best of matters, and the visitors; defence was given a lot of warm work, King and Orr having to exert themselves to the utmost. The Evertonians, however, would not be denied, and a pretty movement ended in Milward scoring a second goal. A burst away on the part of the visitors looked very like proving dangerous, the centre half being given a grand opening, but his shot went over the bar. Coming to the attack again, Blessington had a shie, but the ball wen t wide of the mark. The Celtic right then raced strongly away, and when a goal appeared imminent Morrison was at fault, in this respect. At the other end Taylor sent in a magnificent dropping shot which Cullen capably dealt with, and then followed a period of pressure in which Taylor and Maley were prominent, the Combiantion player showing great aptitude in partnering Taylor. After a further attack on the Celtic citadel Boyle succeeded in defeating Cullen with a high shot. Both ends were then visited, but nothing further took place up to half-time, when the score stood; Everton 3 goals, Celtic nil. The second half opened very evenly, and eventually Milward had an excellent chance from Banks, but it was badly utilised. The Evertonians kept up the pressure, and the Celtic goalkeeper effected a magnificent save from Taylor. For quite ten minutes the attack was kept up, and the visiting backs were given a most anxious time. The Scots then raced away, and Storrier saved when Menham was beaten, and from a quick return shot in, but the ball cannoned to Maley, who put it into the corner of the net. Docherty then led in a fine movement, but final success was denied him, and the homesters racing off Taylor succeeded in adding a fifth for Everton. A moment later a further rush was made on the visitors; defence, and a sixth goal was added by Banks. Later on Morrison defeated Menham, and with play even to the finish of the game, Everton ran out very comfortable winners by 6 goals to one.

EVERTON 6 GLASGOW CELTIC 1
Decemeber 26 1896. The Liverpool Mercury
About 3,000 spectators attended the friendly match between these teams yesterday morning-10-45 at Goodison Park, and the occasion served to introduce several of the Everton Combination players to regular followers of League football. The Celts also were not at their best, but a very serviceable team took to the field, and a little after the advertised time the sides faced as follows: - Everton: - Menham, goal, Storrier, and Molyneux backs, Goldie, Boyle, Robertson, halfbacks, Taylor, Maley (w), Banks (h) Hartley, and Milward, forwards. Glasgow Celtic: - Cullen, goal, Orr, and King (j), backs, Russell, Farrell, and King (a) halfbacks, Morrison, Blessington, Docherty, Henderson and Ferguson forwards. Everton opened the play, and at once established themselves in the Celtic half. A fine sequence of passing resulted in Hartley driving in from close quarters, and Cullen, the Celtic custodian, brought off a brilliant save. Immediately following Taylor had a grand chance to open the scoring, but put the ball wide, and then the Celtic left forged ahead, and Ferguson put in a couple of grand centre that should have been put to good account. Celtic was now having quite as much of the game as their opponents, and most danger emanated from their left wing. A corner kick splendidly taken, was on the point of being converted when Molyneux chipped in almost under the bar, and the Everton backs experienced an anxious two or three minutes. Hartley and Milward broke away, and in the movement the former his played much of his old resource. Orr eventually accounted for him, but Banks was instrumental in initiating a further attack but some clever passing with the inside men. Shooting however, was at a discount, and once again the Celtic forwards got under weight, Morrison eventually getting in a shot, which did not cause Menham much anxiety. The followed the finest bit of attack so far in the game, the executante being Taylor and Maley the combination players in the movement fairly delighting the crowd, by the manner in which he trickled the halves and backs, and finished up with a splendid shot, which unfortametely for his side, was cleverly saved. The ball had no sooner been in play than the home right, kept well employed by Banks was again in evidence, and Taylor finished up with a grand shot that completely defeated Cullen. J.King and Orr had most trying time in attempting to keep the Everton forwards out, and succeeded fairly well, but Orr was at length beaten, and Milward added a second goal. Celtic had now a grand chance to reduce the margin, as the centre half had a clear opening from Ferguson, but shot high, and on returning again Blessington put the ball slightly wide of the net. After Banks had been at fault at the other end the Celtic right had the better of Robertson and Molyneux, and a goal looked certain as Morrison finally lay in good position; but shooting which all through was not a strong point on the Celtic side, was again a failure, and in a trice, Taylor was in possession, Cullen keeping put a high dropping shot with capital judgement. A king could do little or nothing with Taylor and Maley, the latter of whom combined with the Leaguer with all the air of long acquaintancentship, and was a general favorable with the crowd. Following a further attack by Hartley and Milward against whom Orr was at last successful, the inside men put the ball back to Boyle, who from a long range defeated Cullen with a high swift shot. Nothing further was scored up to half time, when Everton were leading by three goals to nil. On resuming play for a few minutes was of an even character, the only item of exceptional merit coming from Banks, who sent in a clever, shot, which went slightly wide of the mark. Maley followed with another, which Cullen secured, and then Milward had a couple of chances, but both were badly utilised. Immediately afterwards a marvelous save was effected from Taylor, and following the clearance the monotony of pressure was broken by the Celtic right who bore away and finished up well, but when Menham was beaten, Storrier nipped in and kicked powerfully out of the goalmouth. Milward then broke away and passed to Banks whom shot cannoned off one of the backs to Maley, who put the ball into the net at the corner. On restarting the best sequence of passing from a Celtic point of view was witnessed. The whole quintet participated in the movement, which was well sustained by Docherty, and his final efforts merited better success. Taylor then put on a fifth goal, and immediately following Banks added a sixth from a shot by Milward play took an even form for some minutes, and following an abortive shot from Ferguson, Morrison had the better of a tussle with Milward, and with a swift shot scored the first goal for Celtic. Cullen scooped out a fine shot from Robertson and the time was called immediately afterwards with Everton leading by 6 goals to 1. The score quite represented the run of the game.

TRANMERE ROVERS v  EVERTON COMBINATION
The Liverpool Daily Post- Saturday, December 26, 1896
Tranmere Rovers’ ground was lined by over 2,000 spectators yesterday afternoon, when Everton Combination team visited the Rovers. The visitors played a pretty game, through the ground was very heavy, and during the first half Campbell and Billie Williams scored for them. In the second half the game was more evenly fought, and Raby, receiving from some very pretty passing, a shot a capital goal, the final score being- Everton 2 goals, Tranmere Rovers 1 goal.

TRANMERE ROVERS 1 EVERTON RESERVES 2
December 26 1896. The Liverpool Courier
Fully 3,000 people witnessed this match at Prenton Park yesterday. Douglas kicked off for Tranmere, who were immediately compelled to defend their goal. A few minutes later some exciting play took place in front of Brolay, which ended in Campbell scoring the first point for Everton. resuming the Everton forwards, were often in dangerous proximity to Broley and eventually Williams scored against his old club. Some effective play by the Rovers forwards nearly ended in the capture of the Everton goal. While just before the interval Baby Lloyd Lee, and Douglas each had good but ineffectual shots. Half time Everton 2 goals Rovers nil. On changing ends Williams twice had the goal at his mercy, but he sent the ball a trifle wide on each occasion. During the last quarter of an hour, the Rovers played in irresistible style and at length Lloyd scored. Everton once more tested the Rovers defence, the final result being Everton Reserves 2 Tranmere Rovers 1. Everton: - Palmer (j), goal, Balmer (w), and McDonell, backs, Nash, Hughes (e), and Elliott (j) (captain), halfbacks, Balmer (j), Williams (w), Not Known, Campbell (wc), and Schofield (a), forwards.

EVERTON V. SUNDERLAND
December 28, 1896. The Courier & Argus
At Liverpool, before 30,000 spectators. From the start Everton pressed, and scored twice. From a sudden spurt, Cowan scored a soft goal for Sunderland. Early in the second half a penalty kick was awarded against the visitors, and Milward scored, and Bell added a fourth point. Sunderland retaliated, and Raisebeck scored. The closing stages of the game were desperately contested, and Everton again scored. Result; Everton, 5 goals; Sunderland, 2.

EVERTON 5 SUNDERLAND 2
December 28 1896. The Liverpool Mercury
The return League engagement between these clubs on Saturday last at Goodison Park brought together a crowd of over 35,000 spectators. These were several changes in the teams. Hartley, Goldie, and Molyneux, being drafted into the home ranks, and Sunderland included Morgan and Cowan. The sides were as follows: - Everton: - Menham goal Storrier, and Molyneux backs, Goldie, Boyle and Stewart (captain), halfbacks, Taylor, Bell, Hartley, Chadwick, and Milward, forwards. Sunderland: - Doig, goal, McNeill, and Gow, backs, Ferguson, Dunlop, and Wilson, halfbacks, Gillespie, Cowan, Morgan Campbell, and Hannah, forwards. The game opened briskly with Everton strongly attacking, Hartley being prominent in an effort to beat Doig. Taylor eventually shot into the custodian's hands, and after Gillespie had tested Menham, the home forwards moved steadily to the other end. Taylor struck the bar with a strong shot, and after Doig had saved from Chadwick the latter quickly pounced upon the ball, and opened the scoring after play had been in progess three minutes. Getting to work again, Bell and Hartley made off, and following some clever play on the left, Milward sent across, and Bell meeting the ball added a second goal. Following some even play about midfield, Hartley headed in from a pass by Taylor and Doig was lucky in saving at the expense of a corner. A steady pressure was kept up on the Sunderland backs, who at times were hopelessly beaten, and had it not been for the superb efforts of the custodian the scoring must have been heavy. Hartley put in a swift shot, as Doig along the ground, and Chadwick and Bell also tested him, but all were nicely cleared, and Dunlop eventually put his forwards in possession. Molyneux was at fault, and let in Cowan, who scored a rather simple goal. Following this point. Sunderland played up with increased vigour, but nothing further was scored up to the interval. When Everton held a lead of two goals to one. On resuming, the high pace of the first half was still maintained, and play was generally even. Eventually Everton got well down, and following a melee, one of the Sunderland backs handled the ball in its passage to the net, and a penalty kick , being awarded Milward scored. Sunderland then put on pressure, but could rarely get in a shot, and from a free kick Goldie placed the ball beautifully to Bell, who added a fourth goal. Shortly afterwards Hannah centred nicely and Cowan headed in, Menham bringing off a capital save, but following the clearance, Sunderland returned again and Gillespie scored from a smart centre by Campbell. There was now little to chosen between the teams, but unfortunately for the northerners, they were weak in final efforts. Hartley put in a grand shot from a pass by Chadwick, and Taylor immediately headed outside. At the other end Gilliespie troubled Menham and then Taylor and Bell made off the former shot taking effect close on time. Nothing further was scored, and Everton won a grand game by 5 goals to 2.

EVERTON REVIEW
December 28 1896. The Liverpool Mercury
The visit of the Celtic team to Goodison Park on Christmas morning did not arouse as much interest as was general expected for at no period during the game were there above 3,000 spectators present. Neither of the teams were at full strength and the changes on the home side were made in order to introduce several of the Combination players to followers of League football. The game turnout one sided in character and with Everton forwards in good scoring condition the Celtic suffered a heavy defeat. Had their custodian at all wanted in resource a much heavier reverse than six goals to one would have been in store for the Scottish Leaguers. Most interest was of course centred in the movement of Banks, and Maley, the two new combination forwards and they were both an unqualified successes. Banks in the centre kept the wings going with capital judgement, and at times showed evidences of being a deadly shot at goal. Maley partnered Taylor and was conspicuous player throughout the whole of the game. He adopted his play to that of the outside man right from the start of the game, and with a little experience he should be class enough for any League team. Robertson played a good halfback game, and Molyneux who filled the left back position did exceptionally well. The Celtic team were seen at the best during the first portion of the game, but they were rarely allowed to trouble Menham much. The forwards were fitful, and the backs had but little chance to cope with the Everton wingers who were speedy and generally accurate in their final efforts.
The return League match between Everton and Sunderland created an enormous amount of interest for long before the advertised time of commencing operations the enclosure appeared comfortably filled, and when the game started there would not be less than 30,000 present. The vast crowd and the general excitement that prevailed remined one forcibly of the meeting, with Liverpool early in the season, and doubtless much of the instinted support was the outcome of the fine performance of the Wearsiders at Blackburn on the previous day, for when a close game is in prospect Liverpool followers of the code are always strongly represented. The game opened in rather sensational fashion for within ten minutes the Evertonians were leading by a couple of goals, and following their success up to the interval the class of play was brilliant in the extreme. Exciting incidents were brimful, and the Wearsiders left nothing undone whereby to recover ground. With both teams fully extended, and backed up by the spectators, the pace was lively enough to suit the most captions and when after changing ends with but one goal dividing the teams, general interest was, if anything increased. Gradually, however the Evertonians draw ahead and late on left Sunderland hopelessly behind, and won comfortably by 5 goals to 2. The home forwards combined beautifully, and except in one quarter the individual play was much in advance of previous performances this season. The reinstatement of Hartley resulted in complete success for during the first half of the game he played with all his old cleverness, and in the second portion he was always about whenever there was the slightest chance of making headway. The wings were kept well employed, and the sharp, nippy movement of the right wing especially was feature greatly admired by the hugh crowd. Taylor was again a warm favourate, and Wilson and Gow, had a rather reverse afternoon's work in endeavoring to keep this very accomplished player in check. Bell improved greatly upon his late performance and should he reach his former standard of excellent opponents may expect an anxious time from this quarter. As mentioned above, Hartley gave a sound display in the centre, and as this followed upon a capital performance on the previous day against Celtic, he is likely to have further trisle. Chadwick also played a strong game, but Milward though never easily beaten, did not reach the level of his confreres. At halfback, both Goldie and Boyle were always well employed, and accounted for the Sunderland forwards on several occasions when disaster appeared certain. Storrier was better of the backs though Molyneux shaped very well against such a clever right wing as Sunderland posses. Doig gave a capital display in goal, and Dunlop at centre half was the most successful of the backs, who rarely placed the ball to the forwards with any approach to accuracy. It was in this respect that the Sunderland van was greatly handicapped, and most of the play that was likely to cause trouble was mainly the result of individual efforts by Gillespie and Hannah the two outside men. Taking the game all round, Everton fully deserved victory, and much of their success was due to the fine placing of the halfbacks who thus gave the forwards many opportunities to shine.

EVERTON v SUNDERLAND
The Liverpool Daily Post- Monday, December 28, 1896
Goodison Park on Saturday afternoon presented a much more animated scene then has been the case for several weeks past, a crowd of tremendous proportions assembling to witness the return game with Sunderland. It is a well-known fact that the Wearsiders have this season fallen from their high estate; but still their name is magic to Liverpool football followers, who can always reply upon seeing something out of the common when Everton are opposed to Everton. The last game at Sunderland a few weeks ago is still fresh in the memory, whilst the grand victory of the Northerners against Blackburn on Friday added fresh interest to Saturday’s encounter. There was a tremendous rush at the entrances about half an hour prior to the start, and it required great vigilance on the part of the officials and police to regulate the crowd. This, however, was successfully accomplished, and when hostilities commenced the vast majority of the onlookers had taken up their positions, though great numbers were still flocking in. The day was much too genial for the time of the year, and doubtless this in sone measure accounted for the immense attendance. Though in places the ground appeared somewhat on the soft side, take a altogether it was in good condition, and favoured just the kind of game these teams delight to indulge in. as will be observed from the list of teams, there were four alterations in the Everton eleven from that announced earlier in the week, Holt being unwell, and Arridge’s ankle having given way. Molyneux took the place allotted to the Welsh international, Goldie played right half instead of Boyle, who went centre half, and Hartley appeared in lieu of Cameron. Although there were one or two strange faces in the Sunderland ranks the team was supposed to be a strong one. Each set of players received a flattering mark of approval as they made their appearance and took up their positions. Everton won the toss, Morgan starting the game in the presence of 25,000 spectators. The home men at once took up the attack, making a most determined raid, Boyle serving up grandly to Bell, who crossed at the right moment to Taylor, the latter’s shot just topping the bar. The game was exceedingly fast, both teams seeming in a determined mood, whilst the excitement amongst the onlookers was most intense. After further pressure by Everton, Sunderland took up the running, and Menham was called upon, clearing away a beautiful shot from Campbell. A huge cheer greeted Molyneux as he subsequently sent the ball flying down the field, and Milward at once took up the running, but was sadly hampered by McNeil. However, Chadwick brought the leather back, and gave Hartley a sparkling chance, which he mulled. Then Bell caused Doig to make a great effort, and afterwards the same player struck the crossbar, but a splendid tit-bit came a moment later, when Chadwick nipped in and scored first goal for Everton after a few minutes’ play. A burst by the Sunderland men followed, but this was of short duration, as the Everton players dashed to the other end, and Milward claimed a corner, which was cleverly disposed of by Doig, who fisted clean away. Sunderland for a few minutes had the upper hand after this, but fortunately the home defence proved very steady. A corner, however, was forced, but this was cleared in fine fashion, after which Everton get down. Hartley and Chadwick careering away in fine style, and leaving Bell with a clear opening, the latter defeated Doig for the second time. The Everton men were now beside themselves with joy, the crowd cheering lustily. The players were also imbued with their success, Sunderland being compelled to act almost exclusively on the defensive. The home forwards were simply irresistible. Taylor on one occasion going right through, but his attempt went just wide. Though Everton were unquestionably displaying superior tactics, Sunderland were by no means idle, and twice Morgan initiated attacks on the home goal, Molyneux on one occasion clearing finely. A free kick to Sunderland jeopardised the Everton goal, but Stewart was in evidence, and cleared away to the centre. Here Goldie became busy, serving his forwards well, Taylor and Bell rushing away, the ball eventually coming to Hartley, who tried a shot which almost proved successful. Doig, however, saved at the expense of a corner, from which Milward sent high over the bar. Just after the kick out the Sunderland left sprinted to the front, but were pulled up by Goldie, who tipped the leather across to Molyneux, the latter having no difficulty in clearing. The homesters pressed forward, and Hartley gave Doig trouble, and a moment later Chadwick sent a red hot shot to the Sunderland custodian just as a foul was given against the Wearsiders. Boyle took the kick and shot straight into the net, but without the leather touching a player. Subsequently the play tamed down a little, but what there was Everton had the best of. A brief breakaway by Sunderland followed, but this was soon accounted for, and Stewart answered with a low shot, which just missed the mark. Then Boyle sent up, but when Chadwick tried to get at the ball Ferguson fouled him, and from the ensuing kick Doig fisted away in a beautiful manner. Chadwick followed with a couple of sprightly shots, which Doig made light of, but for some time afterwards the home players kept up a brilliant attack, and it was a matter for wonder that they did not increase their score. A further shot from Chadwick missed the mark, and then Hartley let slip a possible chance, but in this case not much blame could be attached to the Everton forward. The game had been so fast up to this stage that it was not surprising that it toned down somewhat. Still, however, it proved most interesting. Everton with a strong wind in their favour still having the best of matters, but could not increase their lead. Then Sunderland asserted themselves, the ball being sent from left to centre, where Dunlop passed to Cowan, who beat Menham, who altogether misjudged the ball, the pint being an exceedingly “soft” one. Everton claimed for offside, but all to no purpose, Mr. Strawson pointing to the centre. Both sides now played up in desperate fashion, and each goal was the scene of exciting work. Sunderland having at this stage slightly the best of the exchanges. A nice bit of combination on the part of the Sunderland front rank was broken up by Stewart, but after the ball had gone out of play off Milward, the Wearsiders came back and gained a corner, which was headed clear by Milward. Then Boyle saved, and after the sphere had been sent across Taylor darted away down the wing at top speed, and instituted another brilliant attack on the Sunderland stronghold. One shot from this player nearly took effect and the onslaught was only brought to a close when Hartley passed back to Taylor, who shot into the net, but was at once pronounced “offside.” A series of throws in ended in favour of Everton, who were conceded a free kick close in, but though Boyle twice played the ball well into goal. Gow on each occasion finely headed away, play afterwards following at the centre, until a long shot resulted in a goal kick. Excellent head work by Everton was next witnessed, but the game now was neither very interesting nor exciting. The interval was announced soon afterwards with Everton leading by 2 goals to 1. When the teams reappeared the attendance was of enormous proportions, it being computed that between 35,000 and 40,000 people were present. Chadwick reappeared with his leg bandaged up. Hartley sent the ball again on its mission, the opening stages being in favour of Everton. Campbell and Hannah got down, but were splendidly repulsed by Goldie. Then Everton assumed the upper hand, a couple of free kicks placing the visiting goal in jeopardy, but Gow was in fine form, twice repelling shots by Bell and Chadwick. Everton continued to have most of the play, and from a throw in the Everton players worked up, but a grand opportunity was lost when Hartley tumbled head over heels when he was preparing to shoot from a good position. At the other end Storrier did well to keep out Hannah, but Taylor almost immediately returned the compliment by means of a fine run and splendid centre, which Bell failed to turn to good account. Then Boyle took a free kick which caused Doig to use his hands, and the ball was immediately headed back into the net. But while this was in progress McNeill deliberately fouled Hartley close in the line, and for this lapse of good manners Mr. Strawson gave Everton a penalty kick, which was entrusted to Milward, and after a faint or two Alfred found his way past Doig, and earned a rousing cheer for scoring. After this further reverse Sunderland put on some pressure, and Goldie, in trying to repel an attack from the visiting left, was injured, the game for a time being suspended. On resuming Sunderland continued to attack, some fine forward work being shown, and just when Morgan had a splendid opening he was pulled up for offside. The free kick caused Sunderland to set on the defensive, the home men showing fine combination, but they were met with a stubborn defence, Gow being particularly effective. Wilson at length put his side on the attack, Ferguson making a good but futile attempt to neat Menham. More dirty play by the Sunderland side resulted in Bell being fouled, the ensuing free kick being sent well into the mouth of goal by Goldie. After a moment’s suspense Bell succeeded in again finding the way into the Sunderland net, thus scoring the fourth point for Everton a raid a regular salve of cheering from the immense concourse of spectators. Some excellent work by Sunderland resulted in Hannah giving a brilliant centre, from which Cowan headed is, but Menham was on the alert, and saved splendidly at the expense of a corner, this being finally sent clean away by Storrier, who a moment later was again called upon to clear his lines. Sunderland, notwithstanding the heavy score against them, did not lose heart; on the other hand, they played up in surprising fashion, keeping the Everton backs defenders for several minutes. Menham twice repelled good shots, but he was at length beaten. Campbell sending the ball across to the opposite wing and Gillespie, pouncing upon it, had it past Menham almost before the latter was aware of the fact. From the centre Everton made a tremendous spurt, giving the visiting defence plenty to do, but ultimately the ball was driven over the line. After a lot of slack play the visitors suddenly brightened up, and gained a corner on the right, but this was not turned to good account. The next item was a sprightly run by Taylor, but it was left for the opposite wing to take the ball up to the mark, Doig saving grandly at the expense of a corner which came to nothing. The Sunderland men were soon back at the other end, but there was nothing done, and the play once more became dull and uninteresting. Gillespie roused the interested by shooting strongly, but Menham was not to be caught napping and saved in fine style. A free kick gave the Everton players a further chance, and a little later a fine serve by Goldie enabled the homesters to work up close to Doig, but in a trice the Wearsiders rushed to the other end, where Hartley gave a corner, and then Stewart accounted for a couple of his opponents in champion style. The home right came swinging away, and the ball was centred, Doig saving, but Hartley got in and scored another goal. Shortly afterwards the end came with the score- Everton 5 goals, Sunderland 2 goals. Teams;-
Everton.- Menham, goal; Storrier and Molyneux, backs; Goldie, Boyle, and Stewart, half-backs; Taylor, Bell, Hartley, Chadwick, and Milward, forwards.
Sunderland;- Doig, goal; McNeill and Gow, backs; Ferguson, Dunlop, and Wilson, half-backs; Gillespie, Cowan, Morgan, Hannah, and Campbell, forwards.

A GOOD GAME AND GATE AT EVERTON
The Athletic News- Monday, December 28, 1896
By the Loiterer
There was quite a holiday crowd at Goodison Park on Boxing Day, the number not being so large at the commencement as one would expect, but at the time of the kick-off the turnstiles were going merrily, and half an hour afterwards there would be 30,000 people present, the taking totalling close on £800. Sunderland are always a big drawing team at Everton, and the reason is not far to seek. Ever since they were admitted into the League the greatest rivalry has existed between the teams, and the only advantage Everton have obtained has been secured in Liverpool. They have scored heavily on one occasion, but as a rule the games have been as open as could be wished, whilst Sunderland have achieved many successes on the banks of the Wear. Neither side have come up to expectations this season, Everton having only done so-so, while Sunderland have fared badly until Christmas Day, when they beat the Blackburn Rovers. This feat perhaps gave a fillip to the meeting, if any were need, but he this as it may, a great crowd was present, and they witnessed a fine and exciting game. Each team included new faces, the men lining up as follows;-
Everton.- Menham, goal; Storrier and Molyneux, backs; Goldie, Boyle, and Stewart, half-backs; Taylor, Bell, Hartley, Chadwick, and Milward, forwards. Sunderland;- Doig, goal; McNeill and Gow, backs; Ferguson, Dunlop, and Wilson, half-backs; Gillespie, Cowan, Morgan, Campbell, and Hannah, forwards. Referee. Mr. J. H. Strawson. The game was fast from the start, Doig being early called upon, and then Menham handled a header from Gillespie, and did not clear well. The Everton forwards soon settled down to business, and it was evident they would want some stopping. Doig did very well for a time, but they would not be denied, and Hartley hit the bar, and following up Bell shot in Doig’s hands, Chadwick taking the rebound and scoring. The home forwards continued to play grandly, rarely making a faulty pass, and Milward slipped in, and from his centre Bell added a second goal. The Everton men never slackened their efforts, and it was due to Doig’s splendid work that the score was not larger. The visitors made a poor show against their opponents, who continued to pass cleverly, and kept going in the right direction all the time, and what is more, they finished with a good attempt at goal. The Sunderland forwards were not near so sprightly in their movements, but they kept pegging away, and a long pass from the left caught young Molyneux napping, and then to make matters worse Menham allowed a slow shot to score. And this was the state of the game at the interval. With only one goal in hand, and to face a strong wind the chances of Everton were none to rosy, and the opening bouts certainly did not give their supporters much encouragement. The player however, soon settled down, and as before, their passing was nearly faultless, and the Sunderland defence had a lively time of it, so much so, that McNeill usurped the functions of the goalkeeper, and from the penalty kick Milward placed a third goal. The Sunderland men played up harder than ever, and the ball was often in the home half, yet the home defences was seldom fully tested, and the only a shot of note came from Gillespie. Hannah swung the ball in well several times, but his efforts were not responded to. The Everton men, on the other hand were scarcely ever at fault, and on the whole they made good use of the chances that came their way, for, aided by a couple of free kicks, Bell put on the fourth goal. After having rather the worst of the play for the last quarter of an hour these reverses only seemed to infuse more vigour into the visitors, and for a time they gave the Everton backs the warmest bit of the match. Hannah was useful, and after Cowan had a fruitless try Gillespie was more fortunate with one of his centres. We have had some exciting finishes with these teams, and there was time yet for startling development, for Sunderland were playing desperately, however, the home teams were not done with, and a fine individual effort of Taylor’s met with its reward, and Everton won by five goals to two. The scoring is heavy for two such teams, and I should say the seven goals is a good second to the 7-1 put on by Everton against the same club three seasons ago. There is no question as to which was the better team. Menham started badly, and at a critical time Molyneux was at fault, but these were about the only blemishes on the part of the home team, and the players named fully redeemed themselves by later efforts. The team, on Saturday’s form, were good enough for anything, and their movements were as near perfect as possible, and they were evenly balanced. Taylor of the forwards, perhaps, stood out prominently by reason of the consistently good play he showed, backed up, as it was by either doggedness to obtain the ball. He had a champion partner in bell, who was also a glutton for work, and I should say the latter got through more on this occasion than several matches put together. Then there is Hartley, and he did not taper off from the right wing in the least. He was just as energetic, and some of his passes were masterpieces, Chadwick and Milward were scarcely any behind. The five forwards, with the half-backs, were well balanced and moved together with a swing that the Sunderland men could not stop. Boyle played a great game in the centre, and Morgan had not much chance to shine, Storrier was all right, and the defence generally left little to be desired, Molyneux doing well for a first appearance. On the Sunderland side Doig did splendid work, and I thought McNeill was the safer back, as Gow was inclined to take matters easily, and this did not come off with the Everton forwards going so strongly. Dunlop worked unceasingly, and so did Ferguson, but they were often bewildered by the quick following up and correct placing of the ball by the Everton men. They were handicapped, too, by the dilatoriness of the men in front of them, and a pass intended for a forward movement was often snapped up by an opponent. The Sunderland forwards were not near so active as the Everton five. Their intentions in combining were all right, but to carry this out satisfactorily an effort must be made to get at the ball, not wait for it to come to you, and this was the principal difference between them and Everton. The home lot were much the quicker, and though Sunderland worked hard they were often slack in aiding one another, and the shooting at goal might have been better.

EVERTON v  SHEFFIELD UNITED
The Liverpool Daily Post- Wednesday December 30, 1896
This match, which is fixed to be played at Sheffield on New year’s Day, will no doubt be attended by a large number of the home supporters of Everton, and for their conveniences Messrs Thomas Cook and Son, excursion agents, are running a cheap fast train from the Central Station, Ranelagh-street.
EVERTON FOOTBALL CLUB
The following team will represent Everton on Friday next at Sheffield, and on Saturday at Stoke; kick-off at 2.15 each day.
Everton; Menham, goal; Storrier and Arridge, backs; Boyle, Holt and Stewrat, half-backs; Taylor, Bell, Hartley, Chadwick, and Milward, forwards.