EVERTON v. STOKE.
Nottingham Evening Post - Saturday 02 November 1901
This League match was played at Goodison Park, in splendid weather, before 12,000 people. Everton played Clarke for Wolstenholme, who is ill, while Stoke had Roose, the International amateur, in goal, and Harris for Higginson. Play was of a pretty even description, neither side playing really good football. Both goalkeepers were called upon, but was not until near the interval that Sharp scored with a fine individual effort. Half time:—Everton, one goal; Stoke, nothing. In the second half play opened with a vigorous attack but afterwards Stoke had their full share the pressure, shooting both sides was weak. Young and Paterson for Everton and Watkins for Stoke missing fine openings. Roose cleared a wonderful shot from Sharp, and though Stoke tried hard they failed equalise. Result.: Everton 1 Stoke 0
TURTON v. EVERTON RESERVE.
Lancashire Evening Post - Saturday 02 November 1901
At Turton. In the opening Tauton commenced brilliantly, and Muir's defence was seriously threatened. From the first run up Everton scored through Chadwrick, the home custodian failing and allowing the ball to escape into the net. Turton equalised by Walker. Even play followed, both custodians having to handle, but of the two Lill had by far the worst, to cope with. Result—TURTON 1. EVERTON RESERVE 1.
TODAY TEAM NEWS
Liverpool Daily Post - Saturday 02 November 1901
EVERTON v STOKE
League match, at Goodison Park; 3.
Everton; Kitchen, goal; Balmer and Watson, backs; Clarke, Booth and Abbott, half-backs; J. Sharp, Paterson, Young, Settle, and Bell, forwards.
EVERTON COMBINATION v TURTON
Lancashire Combination match, at Turton; 3
Train leaves Exchange Station at 1.10.
Everton Combination.- Muir, goal; Eccles and Sharp, backs; Brown, Boyle, and Blythe, half-backs; Daly, Rankin, Proudfoot, Bone and Chadwick, forwards.
November 4 1901. The Liverpool Courier
Delightful weather prevailed on Saturday when Stoke paid the first visit of the season to Goodison Park. They included no fewer than three amateurs in their team, a fact of which no other League club can boost. The Welsh International, Roose, was in goal, and the other amateurs were Hales and Ashworth. At three o'clock the teams faced as follow: -
Everton: - Kitchen, goal, Balmer and Watson, backs, Clarke, Booth (captain), and Abbott half-backs, Sharp Paterson, Young, Settle, and Bell forwards. Stoke: - Roose goal, Meredith, and Clarke, backs, Capwell, Helford, and Ashworth halfbacks, Johnson, Halse, Watkins, Harris, and Lockett forwards. Referee. Mr.T.Kirkham.
Stoke won the toss, but gained little advantage thereby. Young started the game, and the opening stages were pretty even. Both Balmer and Meredith got in timely kicks, and then through Clarke fouling Lockett the visitors invaded Everton's territory. Sharp put in some nice work, and Young missing a chance, the Stoke Clarke cleared. Roose was called upon to handle, but the Evertonians were soon back again. Bell made a desperate effort to force his way through, and with Meredith practically beaten, Settle had a pop at goal a low shot going the wrong side of the upright. Both ends were visited in turn, the forwards on both sides seeming to have little idea of where the goal lay. Twice in quick success Kitchen had to clear his lines, and at this stage the visitors were very persistent. Hales narrowly missing the mark. The quaility of the play was disappointing. At length there was a decided change for the better from an Everton point of view. Sharp received from Paterson, and after outwitting Clarke, he raced away, and, though troubled by two opponents, managed to get in a fast low shot, quite out of the reach of Roose. It was a fine individual effort, and deserved the applause with which it was received. Roused by this reverse, Stoke attacked vigorously. They obtained a fruitless corner, and being driven back, Booth shot in, the ball going off the head of a Stoke player over the line. Everton continued to press severely, and following a corner, Paterson headed into goal, but he was adjudged off side, amid groans from the crowd. A moment later the whistle blew for the interval. Half-time Everton 1 goal, Stoke nil.
When the game was resumed, before 15,000 people, there was a smart attack by the Everton right wing, which, however, came to nothing, and equally unsuccessful was a counter move by the visiting left, whose forwards quite early on showed much improved form. Johnson was inaccurate with a well designed centre, and then came a brisk attack by the Evertonians, Settle missing an opening through dawdling, while Paterson going one better, put in a really fine effort, the ball, unfortunately for him, being sent straight at Roose. The ball was kept in the vicinity of the Stoke goal for some time, but there was a lack if incisiveness on the part of the home forwards. The game was vigorously contested to the finish, but nothing more was scored, and Everton won by one goal to nil.
TURTON 1 EVERTON RESERVES 1
Novemeber 4 1901. The Liverpool Courier.
Lancashire Combination
At Turton. Play was soon in the vicinity of Muir, Eccles cleared. Chadwick secured and with a fine shot caused Hill to handle. The home custodian slipped, and allowed the ball to roll into the net. The reverse stimulated the home team, but weak shooting spoiled many chances to equalise, and after twenty minutes play, Everton still led. Slackness in front of goal by the home forwards, lost many chances. Proudfoot at the other end was equally at fault, and sent over the bar when in a favorable place. Turton again got in front, and Walker beat Muir, with a grounder, which gave the custodian no chance. From the restart, play ruled in the vicinity of the visitors goal, and at half time the score stood 1 goal each. With the resumption, Evertpn attacked strongly, but all their attempts proved futile. Howarth raised the siege, and Muir had to run out to kick clear. Final result Turton 1 goal, Everton 1. Everton: - Muir, goal, Sharp, and Eccles, Brown, Boyle (captain), and Blythe, half-backs, Daly, Rankin, Proudfoot, Bone, and Chadwick (j), forwards.
EVERTON REVIEW
November 4 1901. The Liverpool Mercury
After a feeble and invertebrate exhibition of football the Everton team succeeded in gaining two points from Stoke, and as four weeks had elapsed since the last victory, it was just about time that some change of result should be registered. But when one comes to speak of the manner in which this one goal success was gained, it becomes a most question whether the visitors were not entitled to greater credit than the home players. As is well known the Stoke team is being run this year on very fine lines, and having dispensed with their highly priced professionals, the executive have filled the various breaches thus caused by the adoption of local talent. Three amateurs figured in the side, which disported itself at Goodison Park, these being Roose in goal, Ashworth at left back, and Hales, the inside right. That this combination managed to run Everton to a goal on their own ground, is a feat which deserved commendation, for on the face of it, it did not appear that the “Potters” had much chance of achieving such a distinction. There was no mistaking, however, the earnest nature of their work, and though results did not always work out, as they could have desired, their intentions were good, and they were genuine triers until the whistle blew. The intermingling of amateurs of the type of Hales and Roose, in a team otherwise professional, is a feature which is bound to produce beneficial effects, men who throw all their heart into their work, and so infuse their comrades with equally stimulating methods. Their play against Everton certainly did not reach a very high standard, but it was equal to that shown by the home team, though it is doubtful weather the former would esteem this, as a compliment. Indeed, the game under notice will rank amongst that rapidly increasing class, which can only be dubbed as utterly feeble and altogether unsatisfactory. The anticipated superiority of Everton could occasionally by means of the keenest scrutiny, be discerned, but it was a ragged exhibition at the best, and sufficient to effectually damp the ardour of the most enthusiastic follower on the game. Everton's performance might aptly be termed as a negative one, noticeable mostly for what was not done, rather than for what was actually accomplished. If Saturday's display be any critrsion of what the team is really possible of achieving, the disastrous reverse at Nottingham and Blackburn are explained at once. There was no cohesion whatever, between the various branches of the side; the forwards were chiefly engaged in aimlessly roaming about, and they were not overpowered by the attentions of the half-backs. In the front rank was the chief weakness noticeable, the left wing being particularly culpable, and strangely enough, this, which proved the feeblest part of the attacking force, was provided with the greatest amount of work. The right wing was sadly neglected and Sharp, who only got the ball at rare intervals, was the chief source of danger to the Stoke defenders. A skilful display of masterly inactivity was furnished by Settle and really, one might be pardoned for wondering whether the ex-Bury player has lost all his skill. His partner, Bell, was also extremely work, particularly in the finishing touches at the close of his sprints. In the centre Young appears to have reached the end of his improvement, and there is a lack of aim and intention in his movements. Paterson like his confreres made some sad blunders, and altogether the Everton front line shaped about ad badly as could possibly be conceived. To consider them as being off colour is simply begging the question, and in their last three of four games they have distended with startling rapidity the scale of ability and their present position would register somewhere near zero. At half Clarke gave a useful display and for a first appearance, gave promise of something better, while Abbott worked hard, without his customary efficiently. Balmer rendered excellent service, his kicking and tackling repeatedly causing discomfiture to his opponents, and Kitchen had really only to exert himself for a brief period in the second half, when he fisted away a shot, which seemed certain to score. On the Stoke side Johnson was a long way ahead of the remainder of the team, and his continuous centres were very badly utilsied by the rest of their line. He was the chief leader, in every attack, and his worked deserved a better fate. Of the others Hales was often noticeable, and Roose kept goal well, though there was a tendency to rashness in some of his clearances. However Stoke have no reason to be downcast, at the result, which was a decided improvement upon that of last season, when they went under by three clear goals. Weakness in shooting, lost them many chances, and had they managed to score the game might have been afterwards more intelligently contested. What credit Everton can extract out of the day's proceedings it is difficult to imagine, one thing, however, it clear enough, if they change it cannot be for the worse.
EVERTON v STOKE
Liverpool Daily Post - Monday 04 November 1901
Glorious weather again favoured the devotees of the great winter pastime in this district, and as a consequence the attendance at Goodison Park, where Stoke were the visitors, was of the usual largeproportions. Concerning the teams, Wolstenholme was unable to turn out on behalf of Everton on account of indisposition. Clarke appearing for the first time in League game. Roose, the Welsh international, appeared in goal for Stoke, Hales operating inside right, vice Whitehouse. Teams: Everton. Kitchen, goal; Balmer and Watson, backs; Clarke, Booth (Captain), and Abbott, half-backs; Sharp, Paterson, Young, Settle, and Bell, forwards. , Sloke.—Roose, goal; Meredith and Clarke, backs; Capewell, Holford,and Ashworth, half backs; Johnson, Hales, Watkins, Harris, and Lockett, forwards. . Booth was unsuccessful in tossing for choice of positions, and Young kicked off towards the Park goal. During the first few minutes the Evertonians carried everything before them, but the only result of the pressure was an outside shot by Settle. A nice move by the visitors’ right wing terminated in Johnson being neatly robbed by Balmer, but following this the homesters again pressed forward, a header from Settle going near the mark. A second rush by the Stoke men on the right was finished by Watkins, who was splendidly beaten Balmer when right in front of goal. The Evertonians again dashed away, and a rasping effort was made by Settle, but Paterson was just too late to improve the occasion. Keeping up the pressure, however, Clarke made a meritorious attempt, the sphere just topping the bar. Stoke gradually worked their way up after this, and several shots were put in to Kitchen from long range, but none of them had the slightest chance of taking effect, as Kitchen was always given plenty of scope for clearing. Later one good attempt was made by Hales, who missed by about a foot. From the goal kick Stoke worked up on the left, Lockett's centre causing some uneasiness in the home camp. Kitchen saved once, but the ball was thrice again shot in as many seconds.Hales having an almost perfect chance, but luckily for Everton Abbott cleared his charge in great style. Midfield was the order for a time, following which Everton forced the game, but Clarke passed forward faultily, and the ball travelled harmlessly over the line. exchanges between the respective elevens were not very exhilarating, throws in and wild kicking being the order for fully five minutes, and Sharp put a twisting ball over the line. Booth replied to the goal kick, and after being nearly beaten, passed out to Settle and his partner, Bell being easily checked. On the opposite wing, following a throw in by Sharp. Settle skied the ball over the crossbar. Then Johnson removed play into the home half, and, after Watson had checked the right-winger, Capewell tried his hand at goal-potting, but failed. Slow play in the centre ensued, but suddenly Abbott sent forward between Holford and Ashworth, and Sharp captured the travelling sphere and assisted its progress up the field. Clarke and Meredith commenced to close in upon the flying Jack, but Sharp was a little bit too ‘‘slim” for the pair backs, and succeeded in sending the ball Into the Stoke net—Everton’s first goal coming after forty minutes’ play, and being loudly applauded. Bell “screwed” his way through beautifully, and passed back to Booth, who forced a corner, from which Settle tried to shoot into the net, but without result. Another couple of corners came to Everton a moment later, Paterson and Sharp in each case being the chief movers securing them both of which, however, proved abortive. A third corner came, from which the ball way forced into-the net, but for somereason, evidently impeding the goalkeeper, the point was disallowed. Half-time score;- Everton 1 goal, Stoke nil. Watkins commenced the second half, before a slightly-increased attendance. The opening moves were certainly vigorous, but the so-called first-class football contrasted very strangely with the exhibitions with which the old warhorses of the Evertonian club used to delight their enthusiastic followers. Lockett beat Watson, and shot in, but missed, and at the opposite end some pressure was put upon the Stoke defence owing to a move by Settle and Bell, but after a good deal of thoroughly useless manoeuvring Settle finished the “grand attack” by gently propelling the sphere somewhere in the direction of goal. From one hot onslaught by Stoke Abbott, Clarke, and Balmer came out with flying colours, the latter ultimately compelling a precipitate retreat. This led up to an attack on Roose’s charge, but beyond a weak attempt by Abbott, Everton were not really dangerous. Generally, the play was of the most scrambling nature, ell method and the finer touches of the game being absent. Scientific football was absolutely nil throughout, and the spectators must have been thoroughly disgusted, and certainly a belter display was expected, at least from the home team. The closing stages were fought in semi-darkness. After a lot of uninteresting play Stoke livened up the proceedings by a most determined raid, and Kitchen and his co-defenders had a warm time for a few minutes. The custodian saved in brilliant style from Watkins, following which his charge proved impregnable from successive attempts at close quarters. At last the invaders were beaten back, and Everton forged ahead, Bell and Settle having abortive shies, and a little later a grand opening came, Young, Paterson, and Settle failing to take advantage of if. The remaining few minutes were stubbornly contested, but no further scoring was done, and a poor game ended in Everton’s favour by 1 goal to nil.
NOTES ON SATURDAY’S FOOTBALL
Liverpool Daily Post - Monday 04 November 1901
It was more by luck than good play that Everton managed to secure their couple of points from Stoke on Saturday afternoon at Goodison Park. Not one of the twelve or fourteen thousand spectators who witnessed the game felt satisfied or impressed with the football they had seen, for on leaving the ground the general comment was “a poor game-very poor, indeed for two such organisations, and Stoke might just as easily have had the points as Everton (with a good bunch of goals into the bargains) of they had shown anything like shooting or judgement.” This is quite correct, for it was not Everton’s superiority that won the game- rather Stoke’s miserably poor show when in front of goal. A worse lot of forward play than was witnessed in this match it would be difficult to conceive, both sides being equally to blame. If the ground or weather had been bad, there might have been some excuse, but both were grand. For the first month the Everton team held out great hopes of a signal success this season, but, as was pointed out last week, they have collapsed, like a punctured windbag. The forward line will not play together-anything rather than combination- and the consequence is that when one player gets the ball he is always “on his own,” and is allowed to go as far as the opposition permits, and then the ball is transferred back again for another player to experiment with. Surely the directors of the club must see this, and, having seen it, it is a wonder they do not try to make an alteration in the tactics of the players. Perhaps the inside management is akin to the work on the field- all at sixes and sevens. There are several good theorists we know on the board of directors and probably this fact has something to do with the present displays made by the team- the forward line in particular. Surely the directors are able to point out what is good, bad, or indifferent football; if not the “man in the street” should be called in to give them advice. In times gone by the Everton directors have frequently been blamed for “experimenting” with their players. If they were to try a little now, they would no doubt be forgiven.
EVERTON IN EXTREMIS
Athletic News - Monday 04 November 1901
By The Loiterer
Despite the victory of the previous week at Grimsby, the visit of the Stoke team to Liverpool did not attract a large assemblage, and at no part of the proceedings would there be more than 12,000 spectators. The game itself did not warrant a large attendance, and a more feeble exhibition of football has not been witnessed in the city this season. Stoke could never really extend the home players, and the latter easily drifted into a lackadaisical style, with the result that to arouse any enthusiasm in the game required some decisive effort. A dull, dreary drowsiness permeated the varying fortunes of the contest, and as a specimen of present day football the combat must be ranked as somewhat below feezing point- the further down the better. To Stoke must the chief credit be due, for keeping down the defeat to such a small margin, and maybe more finished efforts ion their part would have drawn forth the supposed superiority of their opponents to a greater degree. Be that as it may, the quality of the football shown was of a decidedly inferior equality, and though Everton perhaps deserved their victory in one sense of the term, they certainly did not display anything like the ability which one might naturally expect from a team of such high standing.
THE GAME
There was absolutely nothing in the proceedings which could call for special comment. Stoke never looked like scoring, and as a matter of fact neither did Everton, and it was a haphazard sort of shot from Sharp which decided the fortunes of the afternoon. The “Potters” had pegged away all to no purpose, and the home forwards had not done so, with a like result, for about twenty minutes, when the ball was sent to Sharp by Paterson. The former got the better of a tussle with Clarke, and running forward, sent in a ground shot which managed to find the net, although Roose made a gallant attempt to stop its progress. The Stoke custodian made several creditable clearances in the second half, and one hot drive from Sharp was finely met and thrown away, but the number of passable attempts to score might with ease be counted on the fingers of one’s hand. It was in the second half that Stoke made their only desperate rally, and then Kitchen saved thrice in rapid succession-once from almost under the bar -their strongest efforts thus resulting fruitlessly. It would serve no useful purpose to dilate upon the remaining features of the game, which were devoid of interest, and which could not enhance the reputation of either side. Johnson, on the Stoke right, was the most dangerous forward on the field, but he was badly supported, and time after time his crosses went all astray, simply by reason of the weak attempts of the remainder of the line to utilise them. But Everton were not one whit superior. Their forward work was feeble in the extreme, for Paterson missed more chances than would have gained a trio of victories, whilst the left wing simply revelled in a mass of tangled incompetency.
EVERTON’S EXHIBITION
A worse display of football has seldom been given by the Everton team. For four weeks they have not tasted the sweets of victory, and their most recent performance will not increase the sanguine anticipations of their supporters; rather will it depress them. There was absolutely no cohesion between the individual members of the team; each appeared to be working for his own ends, and that in no efficient fashion, the result being that the movements of the side were characterised chiefly by straggling endeavours, ragged and fistful, with a paltry inconsequent efforts as a fitting termination. The Stoke custodian had a few puzzling shots to deal with, but his task was comparatively easy, and with the exception of a couple of hard drives from Young, the only danger arose from Sharp, who, however, was allowed few opportunities to demonstrate his ability owing to the negligence of his partner. The weakest part of the Everton forward line was the left wing, which, to all intents and purposes, was a practically useless branch of the side. Rarely has Settle given a more faulty display, and what he accomplished in this depressing game might be registered at some considerable distance below zero. His partner, Bell, was little better in fact, the infection seemed general all along the line, for Young muddled about in the centre, and Paterson was more conspicuously faulty on account of the easy chances which came his way, and which were so ruthlessly bungled. At half-back there was no improvement manifested, and Abbott was an easy first in this latitude. Clarke did not shape badly for a first appearance, and will, no doubt, improve, his faults being due more to intense anxiety to do well than inability to do at all. Further behind, Balmer came in as a welcome safe anchorage, for here at least one could depend upon some sterling work, and to his sound defence alone must the chief credit of the day’s honours be apportioned. Owing chiefly to his stubborn resistance, Kitchen was rarely troubled, and out of the incongruous intermingling of ineptitude the work of Balmer, Abbott, and the stray efforts of Sharp stand out with striking effect.
STOKE’S SAMPLES
The “Potters” gave a very ordinary display, and on the form shown it would not have required a particularly smart team to have soundly thrashed them. Their front rank was a very straggling combination, their worst work being seen when near goal. There was no method in their movements, and Johnson towered head and shoulders above his comrades. He repeatedly got the better of his opponents and sent across some beautiful centres, but all to no purpose, for the inside men could not utilise them. The left-wing was terribly weak and balanced the Everton left beautifully, in and danger from these quarters was never forthcoming. The “halves” did not show to advantage, though out of a moderate trio Ashworth was equal to the best. The full-backs shaped much better than the men in front of them, and Roose, in goal, has the makings of a capital custodian. There was a certain rashness about some of his clearances, but of his intentions there could be no doubt, and as matters go at present it is decidedly more refreshing to see a player rashly enthusiastic than skilfully diffident. Teams;-
Everton; Kitchen, goal; Balmer and Watson, backs; Clarke, Booth (Captain), and Abbott, half-backs; Sharp, Paterson, Young, Settle and Bell, forwards.
Stoke.- Roose, goal; Meredith and Clark, backs; Capewell, Holford, and Ashworth, half-backs; Johnson, Hales, Watkins, Harris, and Lockett, forwards. Referee.- T. Kirkham, Burslem.
LIVERPOOL AND DISTICT NOTES
Athletic News - Monday 04 November 1901
AN EVERTON NOTE
By The Loiterer
Cup-tie are now the rage with the seasonso young. Everton journeyed to Barrow last Monday, and a miserable day they had. There was a launch of big battleship, and this function served to attract some 5.000 people to witness the Lancashire Cup tie between the clubs, and that is some consolation. Everton won, and that is another item for congratulation. A classic encounter seems to be a rarity in this district, and we seldom witness a more than passable affair nowadays. Some four seasons ago and later than this period the Everton team could always depended upon to give a good exposition of foothill, even if they lost, but with a win,such on Saturday, very little satisfaction can be derived from it, only that the victory means two points. The Everton men have had a busy week for, following the Barrow match, they went to Whalley on Tuesday and gave the Stoneyhurst College boys a treat.
EVERTON v STOKE
Liverpool Mercury - Monday 04 November 1901
The above League match was decided at Goodison Park before 12,000 people. The home team started, and after some alternating play Settle sent outside the upright. Watson neatly dispossessed Johnson and the Everton front rank again presaged danger, but Paterson, with a nice opening, failed to shoot in time and a corner resulted, which proved futile. A capital centre from Johnson was met by Watkins, but Balmer cleared finely, and after Bell had tested Roose without effect the visitors came away, and Hales sent slightly wide. From a corner Watson drove against the net with great force, and Roose cleared smartly from Young. Play was very scrambling however, and the attempts to score feeble. From a pass by Paterson Sharp beat Clarke, and running in scored the only goal of the match. A second point, from a corner was negatived by the referee for off-side. In the second half Stoke were more persistent and Hales from short range shot strongly a drive from Ashworth struck the upright. Then Roose threw away from Young, upon which Stoke bore down, and three shots were levelled at Kitchen, who cleared splendidly. Sharp received from Paterson and shot with great force, but Roose saved, and Paterson was twice at fault with a fine opening.
Result; Everton 1 Stoke 0
Teams;- Everton; Kitchen, goal; Balmer and Watson, backs; Clarke, Booth (Captain), and Abbott, half-backs; Sharp, Paterson, Young, Settle and Bell, forwards.
Stoke.- Roose, goal; Meredith and Clark, backs; Capewell, Holford, and Ashworth, half-backs; Johnson, Hales, Watkins, Harris, and Lockett, forwards. Referee.- T. Kirkham, Burslem.
LIVERPOOL CATHEDRAL
Liverpool Daily Post - Tuesday 05 November 1901
THE EDITOR THE DAILY POST.
Sir. The committee's decision in favour of St. James's Mount allows concentration of attention in practical manner upon a location, which certainly seems an ideal one,possessing acceptability and centrality, combined with picturesque surroundings incomparably finer than any other site which has had prominent consideration. If there is not yet entire concurrence in its suitability, there would surely be fuller acquiescence if its great possibilities were more studied and better understood. While the location is admittedly good, what appears to have been so far apportioned as the actual site has several objections urged against it, which may be briefly summarised:-
2. The height of the artificial Mount, many feet above the natural surface contour of St. James-road, offers difficulties in the way of easy approaches
3. The threatened absorption or curtailment of a public open space raises much opposition.
All these objections may be effectually met if we can boldly determine to do a much needed work of public improvement through the municipality acting harmoniously in conjunction with the Cathedral Committee.
If that might be the case, it may perhaps by worth considering how an extension of the site can made westwards, by crossing St. James-road, clearing out the old, congesteddistrict, and remodelling it into a wholesome new breathing space down to Great George-street. Within this area some most dilapidated and insanitary property, ripe for demolition for necessary public improvements, and it is incredible that it would be allowed long to remain in its present condition in such close proximity to the cathedral. To deal with its removal now, so much of it would assist the cathedral scheme, could probably meet most of the objections, solve many of the difficulties and provide a site as fine as could be wished, having ample space and margin for the cathedral and its approaches from all sides, and providing room for all ordinary and special public occasions.
From a practical point of view, some such general scheme is here indicated would permit the commencement of the choir and eastern portions of the Cathedral almost at once, afterwards to gradually acquire old and dilapidated properties, as leaves fell in and other tenancies expired, proceeding to erect the nave and western parts of the edifice as funds gathered for such purpose, and in course of time open out the site to Great George-street, and connect it to the main line of thoroughfare between north and south, finally to form the promenades and plant the avenues and open spaces, as indicated on the accompanying sketch plan.
In the very comprehensive report upon the Cathedral sites question, made last May by Mr. George Bradbury, the diocesan surveyor. Mr. Emerson’s premiated plan of the 1886 competition is placed on the various sites that came under consideration, by way of comparing their capabilities. It is a noble and well thought-out plan, and is, perhaps, the best that can atpresent be instanced, as containing the requirements and main dimensions of a Cathedral for Liverpool. In this sense it is adapted here to indicate scale of building in relation to site. Without encroaching upon the St. James Cemetery, its existing picturesque character is preserved and continued by planting all-round the building. Between Upper Duke-street and Upper Parliament-street on this plan is a large area of mean properly, about Rathbone-street,convenableto good sites for chapter house, clergy residences, and similar buildings needed within the precincts of the Cathedral close. These would naturally improve the neighbourhood, increase its value, and assist to compensate for portions of the area devoted to pubic purposes. Instead of alienating the sympathy of a large section of the population by curtailing the recreative ground on the Mount, this plan proposes increase of garden space and avenues to more than double its present area.
Seeing that the picturesque aspect St. James Cemetery, as it exists, accords so well with this suggested scheme, it would seem, perhaps, unnecessary to acquire land on that eastward side. Taking cathedral foundations down into the depths of this old quarry, and the consequent disturbance of graves, would undoubtedly prove a very troublesome and expensive affair, and funds would assuredly be wasted there which might more profitably be out-layed in extension of the site westward. At the same time, the suggestion which has been made to throw a bridge from Hope-street across the pretty ravine to the cathedral platform would make, without any great extravagance, a fine addition to the general scheme of the site. One word as to the ground levels, or rather gradients. Very obviously, the original surface face contour sloped before the quarry was dug from Hope-street to St. James-road, and continued down to Great George-street. Good rock foundation will be found throughout within a few feet the original surface. The artificial “Mount”is probably composed mainly of debris from the quarry. It may be deemed advisable to reduce this in part to the original surface, and the cathedral floor, if placed near upon the St. James-road level, would have easy approach to north and south transept entrance and the further drop in the ground would be met by the flight of steps rising at the western entrance to the nave, making a stately approach from the open square or "place,” retired off the great main thoroughfare. In concluding these remarks, I express the hope that all classes of the community may be enlisted to concentrate their energies towards obtaining the noblest building of its time upon the finest and most perfect site it is possible to make.- Yours, &c., H. Bloomfield Bare, F.R.I.B.A. 12, Prince’s-road, Liverpool, Oct 23, 1901.
STOKE FAIL TO SCORE FOR THE FIRST TIME THIS SEASON
Football Chat and Athletic News- Tuesday, November 5, 1901
The somewhat erratic, and hence somewhat inconsistent and disappointing Everton team bad as visitors to Goodison Park the Potters from Stoke, who travelled to Merseyside rightfully proud of the distinction that they alone of the First League representatives had managed to find the net "every time out" since the curtain was rolled up two months before. Their 2to I victory at Grimsby on the previous Saturday augured well for a continuance of the good work, particularly as the Toffee men had been moving" rockily" for some time past, having won but one of their last seven League events. The home eleven was altered in but one instance from that which lost to the Rovers, Wolstenholme, the right-half, being indisposed, and a trial was given to Clark, who is really a centre-half. A finely built young fellow of twenty-three, standing 5ft 9 ½ in, and weighing 11st 10lb. Clark attracted Everton’s attention towards the dose of last season by his dashing and clever play on behalf of Hamilton Academicals, for whom he had played three seasons.- Taylor was still absent. Stoke made two changes in the team that won at Grimsby, Wilkes (goal) and Whitehouse (inside -right) giving way to L. R. Roose and Len Hales respectively, so that the Potters had their amateur trio on show. The conditions when the game started were really ideal in character; but unfortunately one cannot write in the same strain concerning the football served up by both sets of combatants the major portion of the allotted ninety minutes. In the first half this was particularly the case, for with the Stoke chaps failing to get into their stride, the home eleven in the majority of instances played very slovenly football, and the work of some of them seemed to be stamped with a we-can-put-on-goals-at-any-minute sort of notion. The consequence was that the exhibition to half-time was anything but exhilarating, and the crowd several times marked its disapproval anent the want of real fighting spirit and lack of effective football shown by their representatives. True Roose was called upon several times to exhibit his sprightliness, and a lively customer, he proved himself too. But shortly before the crossover the lengthy London Welsh keeper had to acknowledge himself beaten, this coming from a lovely shot by Jack Sharp who had sprinted across to the centre of the field in a race with Clarke (Stoke) to secure a square pass. Sharp won, and then, beating a Potter who tried to dispossess him, let drive with terrific force, Roose having no chance. The latter was again beaten following a corner, but some infringement nullified the point. In the second half Stoke made steady improvement all round; whilst Everton remained as before. The result was that the last thirty minutes were about as uncomfortable for the crowd and the Toffeemen as they well could be. The visiting backs and halves tackled, kicked, and fed as occasion arose with fine determination, and nobly did the forwards respond, and although the end came without any tangible proof of their goal-scoring consistency, they have the satisfaction: of knowing that they "died fighting." Space does not permit a lengthy criticism, but this much can be said: Everton must needs do infinitely better if they are to win many matches in future. Three positions in the team require strengthening. Whilst on Saturday's form three or four of the recognised “indispensables" need a big dose of 'bucking up" mixture. Kitchen, Abbott, Sharp, and particularly Balmer one has not a word to say against. Balmer truly was Everton's saviour two days ago. Sharp was in grand form, too, but was almost completely "starved." Clarke, for a first appearance did a number of good things, but as yet is a bit lacking in speed. Settle and Paterson made a lot of mistakes with their passes; whilst Young and Bell were shadowed too well to shine. Booth was off colour. On the Stoke side there wasn't a weak spot Roose is a keeper after the Fryer order. The backs gave nothing away, Meredith being the better; whilst at half, Capewell and Holford were seen to great advantage. The former should easily keep his place in the team. The forwards were splendid in the last half. Johnson was really brilliant. Hales made him a rattling partner. Watkins was clever in the centre and Lockett developed both in speed and resource wonderfully as the game advanced.
Captaincy Its Responsibities
Lancashire Evening Post - Saturday 09 November 1901
The severe censure which the Captaincy: Emergency Committee of the Football Association have passed on T. Booth, the Everton captain, will probably open the eyes of not a few his fellow leaders of first class team?. Captains, as a rule,have not any large idea of their responsibilities. Most of them consider it their duty to set a good example by playing a hard, determined game; some few even may go so far as to give occasional hints as the best methods to bo adopted, and exert a real influence in controlling the play of tho side; and a cool, level-headed skipper, will now and again try to tone down any rising passion among his men. But something further may required of the captain as the ruling of the Emergency Committee in Booth's case indicates. Let us hark back to the incident which gave rise to the case. Close followers of first class football may remember that in the match at Aston between the Villa and Everton Lloyd was ordened off the field for kicking an opponent. Mr. Bye, as on the occasion of the Bolton trouble a few weeks since, was the referee, and here too he appears to have missed the original offender and caught only the retaliator. But though he failed to catch theorininator of the incident he endeavoured to ascertain who it was, and to that end asked Booth, the Everton captain, to disclose the name of the particular member of his team who had started the trouble. Booth refused, and hence the severe censure. After this warning captains will see that it is their duty, according the governing 'body in Chancery-lane, to give the referee such information as he may require in cases of this sort, and refusal to do so in the future may bring more severe punishment than a censure. It, is just as well that we should 'have this definite idea of th views held officially on the point, for until such an expression was forthcoming captains naturally had decided antipathy to what some might have called “peaching" a comrade. But when the F.A. requires a thing, and punishes refusal, the captain is safe from any charge this character..
Harry Singleton, sign from Bury to Everton,
TODAY TEAM NEWS
Liverpool Daily Post - Saturday 09 November 1901
EVERTON v GRIMSBY
League match at Grimsby; Kick-off 2.45.
Everton;- Kitchen, goal; Balmer and Eccles, backs; Clarke, Booth, and Blythe, half-backs; Sharp, Proudfoot, Young, Settle, and Bell, forwards.
EVERTON COMBINATION v NEWTON HEATH RESERVE
Combination match at Goodison Park; Kick-off 3.
Everton Combination; Muir, goal; Sharp and Watson, backs; Brown, Boyle, and Makepeace, half-backs; Daley, Malley, Rankin, Bone, and Chadwick, forwards.
EVERTON v GRIMSBY
The Liverpool Football Echo- Saturday, November 9 1901
There was a large crowd to greet the Evertonians on this their first visit to the fishing town in a League fixture this afternoon, the gate numbering 10,000. The ground was somewhat heavy, and good scientific football was at a discount. The Evertonians won the toss, the teams leading up as follows;-
Grimsby;- Tennant, goal; Martin and McConnell, backs; Hemingfield, Gray and Helms, half-backs; Dear, Stevenson, Ronaldson, Harper, and Lee, forwards.
Everton;- Kitchen, goal; Balmer and Eccles, backs; Clarke, Booth (Captain), and Blythe, half-backs; Sharp, Proudfoot, Young, Settle, and Bell, forwards.
There was little wing to trouble the players, and the winning of the toss did not mean much to the successful team. After the homesters had paid a visit to the other end and the visitors, led by Young, began a united attack on the home goal, which would have been dangerous had not Tennant been particularly alert. The home team forced their opponents back, and from a nice pass by Gray. Ronaldson put the ball to Clark instead of his own colleague. Again the Liverpool men came down, only to be forced back on their own line. The Fishermen became dangerous. Ronaldson shot and Kitchen only succeeded in tipping the ball over the bar. The homesters still pressed and Stevenson just missed the post Kitchen saved a low shot from Stevenson and directly afterwards had to repel a similar attention from the home left wing. The visiting halves fell back, and it was not long before Bamber had to tackle Harper who had thrown himself at the ball, and the leather went spinning over the bar. The visitors then tried to get away but failed to pass Tennant. The homesters were playing a more dashing game, but the passing of the visitors was exceedingly. Well timed, and at the other end a corner was headed over, and once more the game waged in midfield. The game continued very even, Everton having had a little the better of the exchanges. A race between Lee and Clark resulted in the former overrunning the ball, which went harmlessly over the line. Assisted by a free kick from a foul, the homesters once more swarmed down. Donaldson sending in a stinging shot, only to find the head of Eccles in the way. Proudfoot shot rather neatly, and the defenders were then enabled to repel them. Bell got in a good run, he and Settle going the whole length of the field, but Bell’s centre, which was capitally placed right across the goalmouth, was met by Proudfoot when lying offside and the referee’s whistle blew. Dean raised the hopes of the crowd with a dashing run, but Blythe quenched them, knocking Dean off the ball. For some time play was in midfield. Then Bell had a rush for Everton, and Mountain kicked out. In close quarters Young received a pass from Clarke, who transferred to Mountain, but the latter failed to get in his shot. The visitors’ goal was for a moment in danger, but the ball went behind. Play was now transferred to the other end, where Proudfoot with a long shot, sent the ball flying over the line. Both teams had turns of passing, but the ball rarely got past the half backs. For a time after this play was of a quiet character, until things were livened by a dashing run of the home forwards which was skilfully repelled.
EVERTON LEAD AT THE INTERVAL
VICTORY FOR EVERTON
“Two points we give you,” said Grimsby Town.
“And well drink your health in- coffee!”
“Thank you, said Everton, “In return “Accept a box of Toffee!”
Some pretty dribbling by the Everton right wing, and the ball was sent across. It was met by Settle, who rushed in and sent it past Tenant into the net. Thanks to some clever play by Lee and Harper and the latter centreing well. Ronaldson shot. Kitchen caught the ball and nearly charged into his own goal by Harper. Now the visitors forced the pace and the homesters were hard pressed on several occasions. Young was tripped when he ahd a clear course, but was outside the penalty limit, and the free kick was of no advantage to the Evertonians. The visitors worked several good openings, but their shooting at goal was decidedly off, and several; rosy chances went a begging. The Fishermen, realising their position, infused more life into their play, and there were several desperate onslaughts on the Everton goal, which was ably defended, Kitchen fisting and throwing away alternately with excellent judgement. Again the homesters broke away, Grey getting along the left and passing to Lee, but the ball was finally shot over the bar. The pace was now very warm, and the rapidity with which the sphere travelled from end to end kept the spectators up to the highest pitch of excitement. From a long range effort which Bell strove hard to reach. Tennant ran out and lifted the ball up the field. The visitors came again to the other end when splendid spirit and a judicious pass from Settle to Bell was turned to advantage. The visitors were playing a rattling game, and kept the attacking line well in check up to the interval, which arrived with the score- Half-time score;-
Everton 1 Goal, Grimsby Town nil.
After a rest, Watkins set the ball rolling, dean got down and centred right across goal, but no one was up, and the ball went outside. A corner soon after proved unproductive. Young, holding his wing together, made off, and Bell got in a capital run, and closing in, shot hard and straight, but Mountain kicked it back, and in essaying a long shot. Booth put the ball over instead of under the bar. Booth and Clarke broke up several runs by the home right wing. At the other end Gray kept a close watch over the movements of the energetic Everton centre, and allowed him little latitude as possible. A well-intentioned shot was sent in to Kitchen, who was however, equal to the occasion, and gathered it up and threw it away in the nick of time. Things livened up a bit, Ronaldson and Lill giving him some clever work, while Dean got in a good centre but deserved a better fate than being spooned over the bar. After Eccles had proved useful in keeping out a shot from Stephenson the ball went to the toe of Sharp who went off to the other end, exhibiting a rare turn of speed. He slipped, however, when steadying himself for a shot, and was promptly relieved of the shot by Yelmes. The work of the visiting halves was somewhat uneven at times, brilliant at others. Stephenson got penalised for allowing off-side, and a shot later from the toe of Harmer narrowly missed the net.
Result Everton 2 goals, Grimsby Town nil
EVERTON v NEWTON HEATH
The Liverpool Football Echo- Saturday, November 9 1901
LANCASHIRE COMBINATION
Fine weather favoured the meeting of the above clubs at Goodison Park this afternoon, and a goodly number of spectators put in an appearance. The following were the teams. Everton.- Muir, goal; Sharp and Watson, backs; Brown, Boyle and Makepeace, half-backs; Daly, Malley, Rankin, Bone and Chadwick, forwards. Newton heath;- Saunders, goal; Whinney and Erents. Backs; Frost, Barker, and Dawson, half-back; Rudman, Wallach, Giles, Johnston, and Booth, forwards.
Newton Heath won the toss, Rankin kicking off for Everton, who at once made straight for the Heathens’ goal Erents robbing Malley and turned the invaders to the right about. After some desultory play Chadwick got away, but was pulled up by Whinney, the Heathens taking the ball up the field. Play was not destined to remain there long, however for the home quintet getting possession moved nicely down the field, but Daly, when in a good position, shot weakly, the danger being easily cleared by the Newton defence Everton were not to be denied however and kept up a persistent pressure on Saunders’ charge. Rankin had a splendid opportunity but shot miserably. Chadwick next tried his luck without result. Then Rankin got another good opening, and defeated Saunders with a capital shot. This was the means of levelling up play considerably the Heathens making determined efforts to equalise, and the home team to increase their lead. The Everton quintet moved down nicely. Chadwick came within an ace of scoring, the ball skimming the bar. A fruitless corner fell to them, Newton by good play got into Everton quarters, and kept the “Blues” defending for a time. Rudman was conspicuous in the forward line, and gave the home defenders some trouble. Everton, however, showed good service, and eventually removed the scene of hostilities to midfield. Newton came again, and Muir was called upon to handle a shot from Johnston, Booth causing the home custodian to save again within the next minute. Paly was then taken to the other and, but nothing of moment occurred. A foul in favour of Newton enabled them to get close in, but Everton getting possession raced down the field, Rankin shooting in strongly, right into Saunders hand. A free kick against Newton close in looked ominous, but the danger was nicely averted, and the heathens took the ball up to the front of Muir, a corner being forced, from which, however, nothing tangible resulted. A smart sequence of passing by Everton was next witnessed and aided by a free kick they got in close proximity to Saunders, the visiting custodian having rather an anxious time of it. The pressure was kept up by the Evertonians, but try as they would they could not net the ball a second time before the interval. Half-time;- Everton 1 goal, Newton nil.
Resuming Rankin prettily to Chadwick, who in turn, shot across to Malley, who defeated the Newton custodian. During a scrimmage in the goal mouth the ball was handled by one of the Heathens, a penalty kick ensuing. This was taken by Boyle, who added a third goal.
Final,- Everton Res 3 goals, Newton Heath nil.
GRIMSBY TOWN 0 EVERTON 2
November 11 1901. The Liverpool Courier
This match was played at Grimsby before 20,000 spectators in fine weather. The teams were as announced: -
Grimsby Town: - Tennant, goal, Mountain, and McConnell, backs, Henningfoeld, Gray, and Milnes, half-backs Dean, Stevenson Ronaldson, Harper, and Lee, forwards. Everton: - Kitchen, goal, Balmer and Eccles backs, Clark, Booth (captain), and Blythe, half-backs, Sharp Proudfoot Young, Settle, and Bell, forwards.
Everton won the toss, and set their opponents to face the wind. Ronaldson started the ball for the home eleven. Some excitement was caused by a race between Settle and Henningfield. The former had the ball at his toe, but unfortunately when trying clear past Mountain, he allowed the ball to go outside. A corner to the home side now occurred, and Sharp was pulled up for offside. Shortly afterwards a foul in midfield gave the visitors a free kick, but they did not get far, as Gray tackled and beat Young, before he could pass to his wing. To and fro the battle waged. Excitement was intense, the spectators yelling whenever a local man succeeded in beating his opponents. Proudfoot gained applause by a splendid piece of work in front of the home goal. He tricked two men, and then took a fast shot, apparently with his left foot, the ball just going over. This was hard luck. Some smart work by the Evertonians resulted in the ball being brought to the Grimsby goal, and Settle rushed away and bagged the ball into the net, securing the first goal for Everton. A corner a few minutes afterwards was unproductive, and Dean fouled Blythe. The Evertonians now swept down the line, showing some pretty combination, and for a few minutes things looked dangerous round the home goal. Settle got in a shot, which Tennant fisted away. Booth returned it, and Young tested Tennant with a hot one, but he proved equal to the occasion. Sharp had a rush, but was dispossession and the ball was promptly returned. Not to be denied, however, that player came again, and passed it broadly to the outside wing, where a clear course, Bell made off, and got into the corner, centring well, but Mountain's head was in the way. Settle and Bell got in some clever dribbling, but did not cover much ground before being robbed by Henningfield, who rushed neatly between, taking the ball with him. Half-time Everton 1 goal Grimsby Town nil. On resumption of play, the home right wing was conspicuous, but Kitchen had no difficulty in reaching a long-range shot. Henningfield was winded for a time, but he soon resumed, the visitors having a narrow escape. Kitchen saved cleverly from Leigh, when greatly hampered. After this close shave, the visitors gave nothing away, but getting into line, Bell put in a lovely centre, which Young just touched over the bar. The visitors were playing much the better football of the two teams, but the home team were vigorous and determined, and now he had a good innings, the visitors defence being severely taxed. At length Settle scored a second. Final score Everton 2 goals Grimsby Town nil.
EVERTON RESERVES 3 NEWTON HEATH RESERVES 0
November 11 1901. The Liverpool Courier
Lancashire Combination
Fine weather favoured the first meeting of these teams at Goodison Park. Everton lost the toss, and Rankin kicked off before a fair number of spectators. Everton were the first to make headway, Chadwick being wide with his centre. The Heathena retaliated, Rudman's shot just topping the bar. Everton pressed severely and Bone tested Saunders with a fine shot, which the custodian saved cleverly, the ball travelling to the other end, where Lappin with an open goal, shot wide. At length the Evertonians were rewarded with a goal, Rankin giving Sanders no chance. The game was very vigorously contested, both sides giving nothing away, and for a time the Evertonians could not make anything of the visitor's defence. Half time Everton 1 goal, Newton heath nil. Final Result Everton 3 goals Newton Heath nil. Everton: - Muir goal, Sharp, and Watson backs Brown, Boyle (captain) and Makepeace, half-backs, Daly, Malley, Rankin, Bone and Chadwick (j), forwards.
EVERTON REVIEW
November 11 1901. The Liverpool Mercury
The Everton team accomplished a smart performance in visiting Grimsby and obtaining full points, and this following as it does an unsatisfactory experience both at home and away in recent games, should do much towards resuscitating interest at Goodison park, most visitors to the fishing town are prepared to admit that even to share the honours of a League game requires a tremendous output of effort, for there can be no question that the new Leaguers, whatever they accomplish away, are simply redoubtable on their own heath. At the outset of the game the play was marked by a determination that savoured of a desperate struggle for points, and it is pleasing feature to record that where the Everton team have of late been lacking there was a big improvement, and there can be no doubt that they were much the smartness team in attack. This comes as interesting reading after the lackadaisical display one has witnessed, and a victory, so well earned, is but what he may expect from players with his credentials. There were enforced changes in the constitution of the Everton team owing to their Inter League contest, and it may at once be stated, that the newcomers proved themselves most efficient substitutes. In close quarters were the visiting backs seen to great advantage and their tackling and judicious kicking were features that stood out prominently in a hard-fought game. The Everton forwards gave a capital display, and nowhere was there improvement more notable then on the left wing, where demonstrated some of his well known ability. The result of the game reflects great credit on the Everton team, who were the superior side on the day's play.
Herbert Banks
Western Daily Press - Monday 11 November 1901
City supporters will be delighted to learn that Mr. Hollis on Saturday secured the services of Herbert Banks, who it will be remembered, was known as the penalty king when he played for Millwall Athletic prior to signing on for Aston Villa, from which club he has just been transferred to the City. He learned his football with the Seaforth Highlanders, and then played for Everton. After a season with them, and two and a half years with the Third Lanark, he was secured by Millwall, and a very fortunate capture he proved for them, his palcing of penalty kicks earning him the title referred to. Banks has had a few unique experiences, and one is that he was first Englishman to receive a medal for the Glasgow Cahrity Cup, whilst he is also the possessor of an inter-city cap, having been chosen to represent the pick of Glasgow. In the latter game he ought never to have played, as he had no qualification whatever to assist any scotch teams in representative matches, but the invitation was extended to him, and he played.
EVERTON v GRIMSBY TOWN
Liverpool Mercury - Monday 11 November 1901
Played at Grimsby, before 50000 spectators. The home side played their usual team, but Everton had several alterations, Eccles displacing Watson at left full back, while Abbott’s position was filled by Blythe, and Proudfoot reappeared as a partner to Sharp. Misty weather prevailed, and the early stages of play were evenly contested. Both ends were frequently visited, but in every case the defence prevailed, though the home side at times narrowly missed scoring. The Town club put on pressure, and Harper narrowly missed the mark, but after 30 minutes play Settle opened the scoring, and at half-time Everton led by a goal to nil. On resuming Grimsby forced the game, and Dean twice missed the Everton met by the merest chance, the visiting backs being kept extended to their best efforts for some time. Retaliating, the visiting forwards got well down, and a capital long shot by Settle completely beat Tennant. The Everton forwards playing a much improved game were now dangerous, but towards the finish the ball was only followed with difficulty. Play alternated at each end, both custodians having to deal with some well-judged shots, but nothing further was scored, and the game ended- Everton 2 Grimsby Town 0
PLAY THE GAME
Athletic News - Monday 11 November 1901
By John Lewis
I notice that, as a result of the fracas during the Aston Villa v. Everton match, the Emergency Committee of the F.A. have severely censured Booth, the Everton captain, for not ascertaining the name of the player who was said hare kicked Lloyd, while Watson, the player in question, was also severely for censured for violent conduct and not disclosing himself Mr. Bye, the referee. I was assured, while travelling with some the directors the other week, that the question put by Mr. Bye to Booth was “Who was theman?” to which Broth, in utter ignorance of what happened, replied asking another-“ What man?'’ Whether Booth was quite so innocent as this would make him appear, or whether, as has been stated elsewhere, he point-blank refused to help the referee to get the offending player’s name. I don't know—probably the truth lies between the two statements. Had Booth actually refused to assist the refereehe would, I think, have received something more than a censure, for he would have been guilty not only of meaning of Law 12, but of a betting Watson in what I regard as his most unsportsmanlike attempt to shirk responsible for his illegal action. Watson must be regarded as very fortunate in getting off with the same sentence as his captain, after being found guilty of two offences. I cannot, however, congratulate him upon his idea of the proper way to “play the game,’* which involved the dragging of his club and his captain into trouble for an offence which he should have been manful enough to take upon his own shoulders.
EVERTON FOOTBALL PLAYERS CENSURED.
Liverpool Evening Express - Monday 11 November 1901
Mr. John Lewis, the well-known referee, writing in the “Athletic News,” says :—I notice that, as a result of the fracas during the Aston Villa v, Everton match, the Emergency Committee of the F.A. have severely censured Booth, the Everton captain, for not ascertaining the name of the player who was said to have kicked Lloyd, while Watson, the player in question, was also severely censured for violent conduct and not disclosing himself to Mr. Bye, the referee. I was assured, while travelling with some of the Everton directors the other week, that the only question put by Mr. Bye to Booth was, “Who was the man ?” to which Booth, in utter ignorance of what had happened, replied by asking another—‘‘ What man ?”’ Whether Booth was quiteso innocent asthis would make him appear, or whether, as has been stated elsewhere, he point-blank refused to help the referee to get the offending player’s name, I don’t know —probably the truth lies between the two statements. Had Booth actually refused to assist the referee he would, I think, have received something more than a censure, for he would have been guilty not only of “ungentlemanly conduct” within the meaning of Law 12, but of abetting Watson in what I regard as his most unsportsman-like attempt to shirk responsibility for his illegal action. Watson must be regarded as very fortunate in getting off with the same sentence as his captain, after being found guilty of two offences. I cannot, however, congratulate him upon his idea ofthe proper way to ‘' play the game,”” which involved the dragging of his club and his captain into trouble for an offence which he should have been manful enough to take upon his own shoulders.
NEWTON HEATH AT GOODISON PARK.
Athletic News - Monday 11 November 1901
Newton Heath were the visitors at Goodison Park, and from the outset looked like doing big things, but a fine defence was set up against them. Whinney and Saunders battling manfully. The Everton centre (Rankin) had a magnificent opening on one occasion, but much to the chagrin of the home supporters he shot miserably. However, he made amends for his poor display a few minutes afterwards by defeating Saunders with a well-judged ball. From this to the interval Everton had the best of matters, but the Newton defence of a stonewall character. On resumption, Newton went away pretty much in the same fashion as in the initial stages of the game, and then their play deteriorated, Everton adding another goal through the agency of Malley. During a scrimmage in the Newton goalmouth one of the visitors handled, and from theensuing penalty kick taken by Boyle another goal was registered. Chadwick, for Everton, played a fine game, while Rudman for the visitors worked hard, as did both Erentz and Barker.
GRIMSBY AGAIN BEATEN AT HOME
Athletic News - Monday 11 November 1901
By The Mariner
The recent failures of the Grimsby team are apparently affecting the gates at Blundell Park, and the attendance on Saturday was the smallest of the season, although the threatening weather had also something to do with this falling off. The home club relied upon exactly the same side as the previous week at Wolverhampton, but the visitors had three alterations, Eccles, Blythe, and Proudfoot displacing Watson, Abbott, and Paterson respectively.
A CAPITAL DISPLAY
The game resulted in a win for the “toffee” men by two goals to none, and was therefore somewhat of a blow for the spectators. But, all things considered, they must have gone away well satisfied that they had their money’s worth. Without a doubt the match provided the best display of football from both sides we have had at Grimsby this season, the forward work of both teams being exceptionally clever. The game was fast from beginning to end, and had the Grimsby forwards accepted half their c chances in the first portion they would have had a substantial lead at the interval. However, they did not do so, and all three inside men were at fault in this respect. Settle opened the scoring for the visitors after some tricky work in front of goal. Just prior to this the home team had claimed very strongly for a penalty kick for handling and from the Press box it certainly looked a clear came in which the utmost penalty of the law should be put into force. Mr. Bye, after a lengthy consultation with his linesmen, threw the ball up, and it was the result of a breakaway from this that the first goal of the match came.
GRIMSBY’S MISFORTUNES
It seems quite impossible for the Town to get through a League match now without having a player hurt, and on Saturday Leigh kept up the record by getting so badly hurt as to be of little use to his side afterwards, and Hemmingfield was so severely kicked as to be greatly handicapped. The second half saw some beautiful work by both sets of forwards, and the visitors particularly so, but it looked odds on the home team equalising at any moment. It was not to be, however, and when Settle put on the second goal with a fine long shot, but one which Tennant might have saved, it looked an over bar shouting. From this time the visitors played a winning game, and though the “Fishermen” tried hard, Harper and Dean being very conspicuous with some grand runs, they could not reduce their opponents lead, and Everton won as stated.
SOME REFLECTIONS
The visitors deserved to win if only by reason of the fact that they took advantage of their chances, although I am bound to say that had the goalkeepers been reversed the result too would probably have been reversed. Tennant’s display was the poorest that the old “Wolf” has given this season, and he should certainly have saved the second if not the first goal, for some of his clearances were very gingerly done. His vis-à-vis was exactly the opposite, and did some splendid work. In other departments there was not a great deal to choose between the teams, and the home forwards certainly showed the best form of the season, and on this display should yet do well in the League. The half-backs for once found the opposing forwards, too clever for them, and Nelmes alone did himself justice, though Hemmingfield’s injury must be taken into account. Dean and Harper were the best of the forwards, and the latter especially covered himself with glory, and the work of the quintette as a whole was a distinct improvement. For the Everton team I have nothing but the highest praise, and they showed first-class form in every direction. Eccles played soundly at back, and Booth was great at half-back, but it was the forwards who showed to the most advantage, little Settle and Jack Sharp playing brilliantly. On Saturday’s form Everton are a great side. Teams;-
Grimsby.- Tennant, goal; Mountain, and McConnell, backs; Hemmingfield, Gray, and Nelmes, half-backs; Dean, Stevenson, Ronaldson, Harper, and Leigh, forwards.
Everton.- Kitchen, goal; Balmer and Eccles, backs; Clarke, Booth, and Blythe, half-backs; Sharp, Proudfoot, Young, Settle, and Bell, forwards. Referee; F. Bye, Sheffield.
EVERTON v GRIMSBY TOWN
Liverpool Daily Post - Monday 11 November 1901
Played at Grimsby, before about 10,000 spectators. The Evertonians won the toss, the teams lining up as follow;- Grimsby; Tennant, goal; Mountain and McConnell, backs; Hemingfield, Gray, and Helms, half-backs; Dear, Stevenson, Ronaldson, Harper, and Lee, forwards. Everton; Kitchen, goal; Balmer, and Eccles, backs; Clark, Booth (Captain), and Blythe, half-backs; Sharp, Proudfoot, Young, Settle, and Bell, forwards. There was little wind to trouble the players, and the winning of the toss did not mean much to the successful team. After the homesters had paid a visit to the other end, the visitors led by Young, began a united attack on the home goal, which would have been dangerous had not Tennant been Particularly alert. The home team forced their opponents back, and from a nice pass by Gray Ronaldson put the ball to Clark instead of his own colleague. Again the Liverpool men came down, only to be forced back on their own line. The Fishermen became dangerous. Ronaldson shot and Kitchen only succeeded in tipping the ball over the bar. Bell got in a good run, he and Settle going the whole length of the field, but Bell’s centre, which was capitally placed right across the goalmouth, was met by Proudfoot when lying offside and the referee’s whistle blew. Dean raised the hopes of the crowd with a dashing run, but Blythe quenched them, knocking Dean off the ball. For some time play was in midfield, but was transferred to the other end, where Proudfoot with a long shot, sent the ball flying over the line. Both teams had turns of passing but the ball rarely got past the half backs. For a time after this play was of a quiet character, until things were livened by a dashing run of the home forwards, which was skilfully repelled. Some pretty dribbling by the Everton right wing resulted in the ball being sent across. It was met by Settle, who rushed in and sent it past Tennant into the Grimsby net. The visitors worked several good openings, but their shooting at goal was decidedly off, and several rosy chances went a a-begging. The Fishermen, realising their position, infused more life into their play, and there were several desperate onslaughts on the Everton goal, which was ably defended. Half-time; Everton 1 goal, Grimsby nil.
After a rest, Watkins set the ball rolling, Dean got down, and centred right across goal, but no one was up, and the ball went outside. A corner soon after proved unproductive. Young, holding his wings together, made off, and bell got in capital run, and closing in, shot hard and straight, but Mountain kicked it back, and in essaying a long shot, Booth put the ball over instead of under the bar. Booth and Clark broke up several runs by the home right wing. At the other end Gray kept a close watch over the movements of the energetic Everton centre, and allowed him as little latitude as possible. A well-intentioned shot was sent in to Kitchen, who, was however, equal to the occasion, and gathered it up and threw it away in the nick of time. The Everton backs here played a judicious game, and Settle, with a long shot, succeeded in putting on another goal for the visitors. Everton now pressed to the finish, but the light was bad, and the game could only be followed with difficulty. Result; Everton 2 goals, Grimsby nil.
EVERTON v BLACKBURN ROVERS.
Liverpool Evening Express - Monday 11 November 1901
(Lancashire Cup.- semi-final Tie.)
This afternoon Blackburn Rovers appeared at Goodison park to play Everton a semi-final tie in the Lancashire cup competition. It was unfortunate that the weather was so unfavourable, a drizzling rain having fallen for some hours before the game commenced. Consequently the attendance was only moderate, though the Rovers brought with them anenthusiastic contingent. When the teams met at Blackbarn a fortnight agoin a league match ’Evertonwere badly beaten by three goals to one. Wolstenholme reappeared in place of Clarke on the Everton side. Thea teams were as follows :—Everton.—Kitchen, goal ; Balmer and Eccles. backs ; Wolstenholme, Booth, and Abbott, half-backs ; Sharp, Proudfoot, Young Settle, and Bell, forwards. Blackburn Rovers,—McIvor, goal ; Crompton and Eastham, backs; Howarth, McClure, and Houlker, half-backs ; Whittaker, F. Blackburn, Dewhurst, Morgan, and Gate, forwards, The visitors kicked off, and after smart work by Settle the ball went to Proudfoot, who shot wide. Sharp afterwards ran down the wing nicely, and Houlker conceded a corner, which was not Improved upon. The Everton forwards infused plenty of life into their play, and the Rovers' defence was kept busily engaged. Bell was fouled when in a nice position, and the free kick yielding no advantage, Dewhurst tried to get away on his own, only to be pulled up by Booth. Then Everton again maintained a- persistent pressurewithout troubling McIvor. Suddenly theRovers rushed to the other end, and Whittaker, lying well up, received a long pass, and directed a shot low at Kitchen, who cleverly saved at the expense of a corner. This led to further pressure by the Rovers, but there shots were wide of the mark. Interest in the game was well maintained, each side pressing in turn, Both Bell and Sharp made good attempts to open the score, and for some time play was in midfield. Eccles got in some timely kicks, but the Rovers becomingaggressive forced a couple of further corners, A free kick brought relief to Everton, whose forwards were making nice progress when a faulty pass by Young spoiled the movement. Kitchen saved smartly from Dewhurst, and Everton had another spell of attack, Proudfoot with a header testing McIvor, who conceded an abortive corner. Half-time; Everton 0 Blackburn Rovers 0.
EVERTON v. BLACKBURN ROVERS
Leeds Mercury-Tuesday 12 November 1901
In this Lancashire Cup-tie semi-final, played at Goodison Park yesterday in wretched weather, both teams were strongly represented. In the first half the game was evenly contested, both goal keepers making clever saves. After the interval Everton attacked without success, and Morgan opened the scoring for the Rovers. Everton made dfesperate efforts to equalise, but were met with a stubborn defence, the Rovers winning good game one goal to nothing.
EX-EVERTON FORWARD AVAILABLE.
Dundee Evening Post - Tuesday 12 November 1901
Gray, the ex-Everton left winger, has not yet, is believed, signed for any other club. A correspondent states wrote the Manchester City secretary during the past season, mentioning the fact that a smart player in Gray was available. Gray, who yet but 23 years age, stands 5 feet 8 inches, and weighs about 10 stone 12 lbs. He is equally clever as inside or outside left, and has more than once been absolutely the finest forward the field League events for the "Toffees." Doig, the great International goalkeeper, says that he was one of the most, dangerous forwards in the English League, and one to whom the greatest respect was paid. This is a capital opportunity for Dundee getting hold of a good forward. We give them the tip.
Everton v Blackburrn Rovers
Lancashire Evening Post - Tuesday 12 November 1901
At Goodison Park, yesterday .the Rovers threw Everton out of the semi-final the Lancashire Senior by the only goal scored in hard match. The Everton men were, at the start, confident of victory. In fact before the match Tom Booth remarked, “It is our turn to-day,” but not one of the 7,000 who stood in the drizzling rain and watched the match, will deny the Rovers full credit for a fine performance. Looking back on the match it is hard to realise how the Rovers managed to play fine a game, both in defence and in attack, for Fred Blackburn was a failure at inside right. Gate was not big success on the left wing, and the 18-years-old Eastham was often wild his kicking. The Everton forwards played prettily, but were not effective as the Rovers, of whom Whittaker, Morgan, and Dewhurst played finely. Both sets of halves showed excellent form, Houlker and Booth being the two best half-backs on the field, but when it came to back play there was only Crompton in 'it. Against Settle and Jack Bell the Rovers captain played perhaps the greatest game hie life, despite attack of influenza. In fact the meetings between Crompton and Bell were the great features a fine game, but the Rover always came out with the ball. Bell fighting very shy of the burly shoulders of his opponent. Morgan scored the goal that won the match cleverly, after 15 minutes' play in the second half. The disappointment at Everton was great, but the players afterwards admitted that the better team won.
LANCASHIRE CUP SEMI-FINAL
Liverpool Daily Post - Tuesday 12 November 1901
EVERTON v BLACKBURN ROVERS
Unfortunately for this match, the weather turned out most unfavourable, a drizzling rain and a thick murky atmosphere prevailing. Consequently the attendance, was only a meagre one. The Rovers played the same team which defeated Small heath on Saturday and the only change in the Everton side from that which successfully visited Grimsby was Wolstenholme in place of Clark. A prompt start was made, the visitors kicking off, and in the first few seconds the Rovers’ goal had several close shaves. Proudfoot nearly doing the trick on the first occasion, and then the left wing. The Everton half backs played very smartly to their front line, and for the first ten of fifteen minutes the ball was scarcely out of the visitors half. Then from a goal kick the Rovers’ right got off, and Whittaker, after a fine run, steered the ball for the home goal, which only escaped downfall by Kitchen’s alertness, saying at the foot of the post. This turned out to be only a fugitive visit, as Everton were immediately back in the Rovers’ quarters but the latter’s defence proved very safe. Some long exchange kicking took place, from which no advantage accrued. During the first half-hour of play the visitors’ front line made several dashing bids for a goal, and when they once got up there was generally anxiety in the Everton camp. Play settled down for a short spell in front of the home goal, when Dewhurst missed a rattling chance of opening the score, and allowing Kitchen to clear. Then Proudfoot put in a high shot, which McIvor only just managed to save by tipping the ball on to the top of the crossbar. The Rovers sped away again, and McClure shot outside. Everton kept up the pressure for some time on the visitors’ goal, but there was little sting in the attack. Some time later the Rovers’ forwards made two strong rushes led by Whittaker on the right outside, and in the first of these raids Kitchen only saved his goal by throwing himself prone on the ground amongst the feet of some half-dozen players. It was a capital bit of goalkeeping, and well deserved the applause it received. When the pressure was relieved the Everton right wing got away, Proudfoot again testing McIvor. Play, however, had hovered about midfield, where some attractive football had been shown. Up to the interval neither side had obtained any advantage, and ends were changed with the game standing at-
Everton nil, Blackburn nil.
On starting the second half no improvement was visible in the weather, the drizzle and haze being still in strong evidence. Everton again commenced the attack. The left wing made an excellent attempt to score. McIvor beat back the ball from almost underneath the crossbar, and then Sharp shot over. Coming back, Young put in “ a straight up” which was easily negotiated. So far the game had been distinguished by excellent play on the part of the home half-backs, Kitchen’s goalkeeping, and some grand defence on the part of Crompton, the Rovers right back and Whitaker’s single-handed runs on the right outside. McIvor had nothing like the work to perform that Kitchen had, the pops at goal on the Rovers’ part being made with greater effect than those by Everton. As a change Bell sailed away along his wing, and finished with a shot which went too high. At length the Rovers’ perseverance was rewarded by success, a Morgan managed to put the ball through somewhat luckily after the second half had progressed some twenty minutes. This performance was the means of showing that the spectators were made up of a very strong contingent of Blackburnians who jubilated over their team’s success. The light now was getting very bad. Calls were made to the home side to “play up” they seemed incapable of responding, as the Rovers for a time penned them up but even when the Evertonians found release the splendid defence shown by the visitors rendered the home attack futile and simple. The home left made an attempt to break through, but found it impossible to get past Howarth and Crompton. Once the ball bushed the mouth of goal, but McIvor picked it up and cleared, and then Kitchen was given another turn the home custodian clearing off the attack for a time. Several times as the visitors were making for the home goal they were put off side. The Rovers now decidedly held the advantage, and as the game neared a close showed themselves full of going and attack, and ultimately left the field victorious by 1 goal to nil. Teams;-
Everton; Kitchen, goal; Balmer and Watson, backs; Wolstenholme, Booth (Captain) and Abbott, half-backs; Sharp, Proudfoot, Young, Settle and Bell, forwards.
Blackburn Rovers; McIvor, goal; Eastham and Crompton (Captain), backs; Houlker, McClure, and Howarth, half-backs; Gate, Morgan, Dewhurst, F. Blackburn, and Whittaker, forwards.
EVERTON PRESSING STRONGLY TOR CHAMPIONSHIP HONOURS.
Football Chat and Athletic World- Tuesday, November 12 1901
Everton will be one of the teams that will do well everywhere they go, for their forwards know whereabouts the goals are fixed up, and that the ball requires placing under the bar, and not over the top ala Rugby. Only one team in the League is credited with a greater number of goals, and they had the advantage of an extraordinary score of eight against a custodian who ever since has been resting from his club's first team. Everton was strong in all positions on Saturday, and it was only the sterling defence of their rear division, Kitchen, Eccles, and Balmer that kept out the Grimbarians' front rank, Dean playing tremendously hard for goals that could not be won from the defenders named. Sharp and Settle were the two most prominent players in the Everton front rank but all played with gritty determination for the full brace of points. Result:— Everton 2 Grimsby 0.
Goal scores; Settle (two) Teams : Grimsby. —Tennant; Mountain and McConnell; Hemmingfield, Gray, and Nelmes ; Dean, Stevenson, Ronaldson, Harper, and Leigh. Everton.—Kitchen; Balmer and Eccles; Clarke, Booth, and Blythe; Sharp, Proudfoot, Young, Settle, and Bell. Referee: F. Bye, Sheffield.
Bolton and Ex-Everton players
Dundee Evening Post - Wednesday 13 November 1901
Bolton Wanderers have no need to regret their Everton captures during the past few seasons. "Larry" Bell has proved a perfect treasure; Halliday and Struthers have shown themselves sterling backs; and at the first time of asking Taylor of Everton Combination gave ample evidence of first-rate abilities. it is rather strange that neither Taylor nor Halliday was ever highly thought of at Goodison Park and Struthers quite failed to catch the eye there. Then bell was not a constant erformer in the Toffees' League team
A good tip was given to the Dundee Club last night by the "Evening Post," Gray, of the Everton a crack forward, is at present "for sale" He might be worth looking after by the Dens Park men.
EVERTON 0 BLACKBURN ROVERS 1
November 13. The Liverpool Mercury
Lancashire Senior Cup Semi-Final
The Holders of the above trophy put in an appearance at Goodison Park yesterday, but the weather was most unpropitious, and the attendance in consequence was limited, the crowd being estimated at 4,000. At 2-45, the sides faced as follows: -
Everton: - Kitchen goal, Balmer, and Eccles backs, Wolstenholmes, Booth (captain), and Abbott half-backs, Sharp, Proudfoot, Young, Settle, and Bell, forwards. Blackburn Rovers: - McIvor, goal, Eastham, and Crompton (captain), backs, Houlker, Mcclure, and Howarth, half-backs, Gare, Morgan,, Dewhurst, F.Blackburn, and Whittaker, forwards. Referee E.Sutcliffe. The Rovers kicked off, and Everton were soon attacking Crompton coming to the rescue in good style, and sending to Gate and Morgan, who were promptly pulled up by Booth. Shots on the Rovers goal were rained in by Young, Proudfoot, and Settle, but without effect. A diversion was caused, after Crompton had cleared by a determined dash by the visiting forwards, the culminating in a corner, Blacburn sending outside. Next the Rovers were penalised, but, playing a more aggressive game at this period, the cup holders returned to the attack, Kitchen running out to save from Dewhurst. On a return being made to the other end, Abbott took a free kick, and Sharp heading, caused McIvor to concede a corner, Eastham clearing. Everton were fortunate in not having their colours lowered, and at the other end Bell twice in rapid succession sent wide of the mark. An exciting time then followed in front of the home goal. Balmer proving the saviour of his side, the Rovers being far more dangerous in front than their rivals. McIvor punched out a shot from Bell, and kicked away an attempt by Sharp, Young and Proudfoot, also having futile shots. Play was of an end to end character, and always interesting, and at the interval there was no score. On resuming the “Blues” again assumed the aggressive, and from a centre by Settle, Sharp shot hard, but was a little too high, and from the subsequent goal kick Whittaker and Blackburn made play to the other end of the field. Balmer nipping in and clearing smartly Gates forced the corner, but Abbott got the ball away, and Bell from 20 yards range sent in lighting shot, which just topped the bar, the efforts being deservedly applauded. Crompton was a conspicuous member in the Rovers defence on further attacks being made by Everton, and with the ball at the other end, Morgan defeated Kitchen from a pass by Dewhurst, the custodian having no chance of saving. Needless to say. This success coming 15 minutes after the resumption was hailed with manifestations of delight by the Rovers supports-who were present in large numbers-and stimulated thus the cupholders went to work with renewed vigour, the Everton goal being the scene of many a warm tussle. Fortunately Balmer and Eccles were playing a sound back game, and further disaster was starved off, the Rovers however, unquestionably being the better side. Nothing further was scored, and victory reamed with the Rovers by a goal to nil.
EVERTON FOOTBALL TEAM
Liverpool Evening Express - Thursday 14 November 1901
TO THE EDITOR OF THE EVENING EXPRESS.
Sir,—Will you allow me to offer a few suggestions to the Everton directors? The defence as it stands at present cannot be improved, but in the forward line it is evident we require men who can shoot. I think a trial should be given to Rankin, who certainly possesses that qualification, has a good command of the ball, and moreover is speedy. The forwards, I suggest, should be placed as follows : —Sharp, Rankin, Young, Settle, and Chadwick. The reason I substitute Chadwick for Bell is because the latter requires wakening up a bit, and the former is in splendid form at present. EVERTONIAN. Nov. 13, 1991.
TODAY TEAM NEWS
Liverpool Daily Post - Saturday 16 November 1901
EVERTON v SUNDERLAND
At Sunderland, Lime Street Station 2. Friday.
Everton;- Kitchen, goal; Baer and Eccles, backs; Wolstenholme, Booth and Abbott, half-backs; Sharp, Proudfoot, Young, Settle, and Bell, forwards.
EVERTON COMBINATION v GLOSSOP NORTH END RESERVE
At Goodison Park, kick-off 2.45
Everton; Muir, goal; Watson and B. Sharp, backs; Brown, Boyle, and Blythe, half-backs; Roche, Rankin, Caldwell, and Singleton, forwards.
A GOODALL
Southern Echo - Saturday 16 November 1901
The Goodall’s have done much to improve Derbyshire football, and now both Archie and his brother are in the sere and yellow leaf they still continue to do good work by coaching. The younger brother has a good appointment with Glossop thanks to the generosity of Mr. S.H. Woods, the ex-captain of the county cricket team and entirely through his very capable coaching the Derbyshire team is slowly but surely regaining its position in the League. Return to the First Division is merely a question of time.
EVERTON v SUNDERLAND
Liverpool Football Echo- Saturday November 16, 1901
EVERTON TOP THE LEAGUE AGAIN
The defeat of Sunderland at Stoke caused the directors a considerable amount of anxiety over the selection of their team for to-day. A “shuffling of the cards,” however, was evidently not necessary, and rigid training throughout the week had been rigorously insisted upon. The selection of the actual team was postponed to the last moment. The ground was in a bad condition, and when the teams entered the field the weather was very misty. After the usual preliminaries, the teams lined up as follow;-
Sunderland; Doig, goal; McCombie and Watson, backs; Ferguson, McAllister, and Jackson, half-backs; Craggs, R. Hogg, Miller, Searmell, and McLuckie, forwards.
Everton;- Kitchen, goal; Balmer and Eccles, backs; Wolstenholme, Booth (Captain), and Abbott, half-backs; Sharp, Proudfoot, Young, Settle, and bell, forwards.
Sunderland won the toss, and the visitors had to kick off against the wind. A few minutes after the advertised time Young set the ball rolling for the Evertonians, who pressed, Settle nearing scoring in the first minute. Then Sunderland had a look in, and, receiving a good pass, Gemmell closed in and shot the ball past Kitchen after six minutes’ play. The visitors got away by the aid of Young, but McAllister, rushing up, dispossessed him of the ball, and transferred to Gemmill, who got his left wing going. The ball was quickly sent back to the centre where Craggs, who was lying well up the field was quick to seize upon it, and essayed a shot, which Eccles anticipated, but only partially cleared, and Balmer, running across kicked the ball well into the centre of the field. Bell received it, and, running down the wing, gave to Young, who was cheered for getting the ball of Ferguson. McCombie rushed in, and by a timely kick released the pressure, but Settle, who was playing in dashing style, quickly put the ball back again, giving Young possession. After a stubborn tussle Settle bested Ferguson, and got in a nice centre. Proudfoot and Sharp attempted to head the ball together, but the home back jumped higher in the air and got his head to the ball first, play being transferred to midfield. A tricky bit of work by the home forwards looked dangerous, but Wolstenholme who was paying close attention to the left wing, broke up the combination and sent the ball almost immediately to the centre, where McAllister sized upon it and kicked it up the field. Play showed down considerably, and for a little time succeeded in covering much ground. A quick run down by the visiting forwards, and Sharp ran the ball over the line. Bell was pulled up for offside, and Sharp and Proudfoot in turn got possession, going well up the field, but the latter was knocked off the ball by Jackson. A throw in to the homesters followed, but Balmer cleared his lines. Another throw in ended in a run and centre by R. Hogg, succeeded by a foul, the free kick being taken by McAllister, who sent the ball wide of the posts. A breakaway by the home left followed, and McLuckie scudded away finely, getting well up, but his final pass was not utilised, and the ball went harmlessly outside. After some desultory midfield play the visitors got possession, and a brisk run was made into the home territory, and but for the sound defence of McCombie and Watson, a goal must have resulted. As it was it had a very narrow escape, the ball being finally sent over the line within a few inches of the upright, the ensuing goal kick bringing welcome relief to the home team. The homesters now once mere took up the running, and as a result of some good wing work Craggs got close up, and shot with terrific force into Kitchen’s hands, that player clearing cleverly. Play now slowed down for a little time, the half backs monopolising the ball. At last, the visitors broke away, their right wing working the leather prettily along. Jackson tried in vain to arrest their progress, but they ran completely around him, and tricking Watson, got into the corner, where Sharp slung the ball across the goal for Young to head it over. After some clever dribbling by the visitors’ left, Settle ran round McCombie, and “ticing” out Doig, shot the ball past him into the net, making the score equal. An attack on the home goal, in which Young shot into the custodian’s hands, that was staved off, and more activity of the home forwards led to a fine clearance by Eccles, from which the sphere was flung over to Bell, who went in dangerously. Doig went out to meet him, and his final effort went wide of the post. More dangerous work by the Evertonians followed, and the downfall of the home goal was only saved by the alertness of the custodian, who smartly stopped a fine shot by Proudfoot. Then the home right wing made its presence felt, and caused Kitchen to handle. As a centre forward Miller was putting in some excellent work, dribbling cleverly and keeping his wings well in touch, and his passes also were smart and to the point. McLuckie shot the ball in, but Kitchen saved. A bad foul by one of the home halves was justly penalised, and soon after play was suspended for a moment or two, one of the players being winded. He was soon up, and the game was renewed with fresh vigour. McCombie fouled close to the penalty line, but, fortunately for the homesters just outside the mark, the free kick proving unproductive. At the other end Eccles was forced to concede a corner. This was taken by Craggs, and the ball was well placed in front of goal. Miller tried to rush it through, but was not quick enough, as Kitchen fisted it away. A run by the Evertonians led to Young making the spectators hold their breath but a sigh of relief went up as they saw the ball sent in with terrific force by Proudfoot tipped over the bar by Doig.
Half-time score; Everton 1 goal, Sunderland 1 goal.
After the change of ends the game, which so far had been very lively, at once opened fast and furious, and after a rush to the other end Everton sent the ball flying over the Sunderland crossbar.
Final Result; Everton 4 goals, Sunderland 2 goals.
SUNDERLAND 2 EVERTON 4
November 18 1901. The Liverpool Courier
Great interest centred in this match between Everton and Sunderland on Saturday by a reason of the fact that they occupy the two foremost places on the League list. A win to Everton meant that they would reach the top of the League ladder. The Evertonians travelled to the northern town on Friday, and stayed the night at the Grand Hotel, Sunderland. The teams were as follows: - Everton: - Kitchen goals, Balmer and Eccles backs, Wolstenholmes, Booth (captain) and Abbott half-backs, Sharp, Proudfoot, Young Settle, and Bell, forwards. Sunderland: - Doig, goal, McCombie and Watson backs, Ferguson, McAllister, and Jackson, half-backs, Craggs, Hogg (r), Millar (captain), Gemmell, and McLatchie, forwards. The visitors met with a cordical reception on stepping on to the field from a large crowd. Miller beat Booth in the spin of the coin. Young set the ball rolling. The visitors were early prominent, the right wing being very aggressive. In the first few minutes. Doig was called upon to defend his charge. Away went Sunderland to the other end, where Gemmill had an unsuccessful try, Balmer turning the ball wide of the post. The leather travelled rapidly to the other end, the visitors going about their work with a very business like air. They were soon repelled, and the Wearsiders attacked. McLathie causing some trouble. A good combination run by Sunderland was the next feature of interest, and Hogg passing broadly across to the left Gemmill seized upon it, and closing in sent in a stringing shot, with which Kitchen had not the least chance. Still the visitors right wing was very persistent, and McCombie and Watson had a few busy moments. An attack on the home goal, in which Young shot into the custodian's hands, was staved off, and more activity by the home forwards led to a fine clearance by Kitchen, from which, the sphere was swung over to Sharp, who raced in dangerous, but as the back came out to meet him his final effort went wide of the post. More dangerous work by the Everton men followed, and the downfall of the home goal was only saved by the alertness of Doig, who smartly stopped a fine shot, by Settle. A trip against the visitors proved but of temporary advantage. Booth shot over the bar, and the visitors right were coming along merrily when a collision occurred, a Sunderland man being momentarily winded. Away went Sunderland, Craggs and R.Hogg working prettily together, and for a foul a free kick was awarded them. Then Miller essayed a shot that went a trifle too high, while McLathie was cheered directly after for a very nice centre. The Evertonians now made a determined effort and Settle with a neat shot, put his side on even terms after a brilliant run. The visiting teams still maintained the upper hand and kept the home defence busily engaged. At length the pressure was relieved and twice the Everton goal had narrow escape from capture. Kitchen negotiating one shot, while offside neutrialised the other. Then a change came over the play, which brought the hearts of the home supporters into their mouths. The visitors got well away, and Sharp carried the ball along and passed to Young, who transferred to Settle. The ball was at the foot of the post, and there looked to be a certain score for the visitors. A scramble of half a dozen players round the goalmouth followed, but after a few moments intense anxiety a Sunderland man was seen kicking the ball out into midfield again. The home team did a lot of pressing, and Kitchen and his backs had a lively time of it. Twice the ball was dropped into the mouth of the goal, and twice was it returned, and after a corner the ball was fortunately cleared away. Half-time Everton 1 goal, Sunderland 1.
On the resumption of play, Miller restarted the ball, and the visitors made an onslaught on the home goal, the ball going outside. The home men took the ball well down, but it went out, and Everton were again attacking. Ferguson stopping a dangerous run by Settle. When nicely placed Young passed the ball to Ferguson, and the visitors were again making tracks for the home goal, when Jackson relieved. Kitchen was called upon to clear a good shot from the left, and Booth was conspicuous with a splendid bit of play, following this up with a long shot at goal, which, however, was fouled by Watson. Some grand work by Craggs afterwards imperiled the Everton goal, and once he sent hard at Kitchen, who saved while on the ball with Craggs falling over him. A firm appeal for the referee negatived a goal after consultation with the linesmen. A moment later Settle retaliated by sending the ball into the net beating Doig neatly. Play centred for a time round the home goal, and Young had hard lines, with a low, swift shot, which struck McCombie's foot and was diverted, to a place of safety. Aided by several throws in the visitors forced the leather down into the home half, where from some little distance an Evertonians tried a long shot, the ball cannoning of Watson over the line. After Kitchen repulsed the attentions of Jackson, the visitors left got going, without success. Then after even play Sharp made off, and after a splendid bit of dodging he sent the ball flying into the net, thus securing the third point for Everton. A foul on the halfway line gave them a further advantage. The ball was dropped nicely into the mouth of the goal, but the Wearsides proved quite equal to the occasion, Doig brilliantly saving the situation. A corner to the home side proved barren. A scrimmage ensued, but a free kick, brought the visitors relief. Watson fouled Bell, and a penalty kick was awarded. Abbott took the kick and put the ball into the net. Five minutes before the finish McLatchie scored for Sunderland. Final result Everton 4 goals Sunderland 2.
EVERTON REVIEW
November 18 1901. The Liverpool Mercury
Everton's great victory at Roker Park must have come as a somewhat welcome surprise to their many supporters, especially following so inglorious a display as that witnessed at home on Monday last against the Rovers in the semi-Final tie for the Lancashire Cup. These in-and-out performances have furnished a topic for much discussion, and the two recent League victories away from home have somewhat atoned for previous failures. That the team possess the ability to hold their own among the strongest opponents cannot now be denied, and possibly the great revolution has come about owing to a desire on the part of the directorate to see new talent. Be that as it may, the best efforts of the side were seen at Sunderland, and their clever victory should do much towards increasing the gates at Goodison Park. It was the first time in the career of the club that full points had been extracted from Sunderland at Wearside, and that they won in such substantial fashion, simply astonished the natives. They fully deserved their victory, which was obtained as the result of superior play in every department, and they now figure at the head of the League table. The Sunderland team lacked the qualities, which brought them to the top of the League, while the forwards retained their great weakness that of failing to shoot when in favourable opportunity presented itself. In the field their dash and combination had fallen off while Everton, on the other hand, were evidently in their best humour, for a man they played with a strength and swiftness that carried all before them. Kitchen in goal stopped several difficult shots in a marvellous manner, though most of the efforts of the Sunderland forwards went wide. Eccles and Balmer played a sound game throughout their tackling and clearing being among the foremost features of the game. The half-backs, too, gave a capital exposition of how to break up opposing combination, and the failure of the home forwards to take advantage was due in great measure to the close attentions of Booth, Abbott, and Wolstenholmes. In conjunction with the forwards they formed a most powerful attacking side, and the work of the van in particular was eminently satisfactory. They were admitted on all hands to have been the fastest quintet that had been seen on Roker Park this season, and, as the score would indicate, they had a capital notion as to the locality of the net. The effort that led up to Sharp scoring the third goal was magnificent. Settle broke through the Sunderland ranks unaided, and whipped the ball across to the right wing with accompanying success. Many of the crowd were under the impression, that Sharp was offside, and from the attitude of Doig, it seemed as though he shared the general opinion. Sharp however, though behinds the backs, did not infringe the rules, as he was onside, when he received the ball. With Sunderland thus left further behind, tremendous efforts were put forward to reduce the lead, and right to the close the high pace which had prevailed all through did not flag in the least. The home defenders were somewhat too desperate when matters were hard against them, and the penalty kick by which Everton scored their last goal was the climax to a continuance of over-vigorous play by Watson. The Goodison Park habitues will be pleased to note that in the last two matches, at Grimsby and Sunderland respectively, Settle has been demonstrating some of that form which a season or two ago gained for him international honours, and that he now heads the list of goal-scorers with ten to his credit.
SUNDERLAND v. EVERTON
Liverpool Mercury - Monday 18 November 1901
In bright, cold weather this match was played at Sunderland, before about 13,000 spectators. Everton kicked off, and play for a time was fairly even. After 18 minutes’ play Wimmell scored for Sunderland, and immediately afterwards Settle equalised. As the interval approached Sunderland pressed very severely, Kitchen having several shots to deal with, but the defence was brilliant. Half-time; Sunderland, 1 goal; Everton, 1. For some time after the resumption of the game Sunderland had most of the attack, but eventually the visitors got going, and in quick succession put on a couple of goals. Settle cleverly scored the first of these, and Sharp the other, Doig making no effort to save, thinking the player off-side. Abbott scored a fourth for Everton from a penalty, and McLatchie put a second on for Sunderland. Result;- Everton 4 Sunderland 2. Teams’-
Sunderland.—Doig; McCombie and Watson; Ferguson, McAllister, and Jackson; Craggs, F. Hogg, Miller, Gemmell, and McLatchie.
Everton.- Kitchen; Balmer and Eccles; Wolstenholme, Booth (Captain), and Abbott; Sharp, Proudfoot, Young, Settle, and Bell.
LIVERPOOL AND DISTRICT NOTES
Athletic News - Monday 18 November 1901
By the Loiterer
EVERTON AT THE TOP
Meanwhile Everton are at the head of affairs, and are to be congratulated on so confounding the critics, for most people on Saturday expected that Liverpool would be alongside them in league points. This was Everton’s first victory at Sunderland, but pronounced enough for anything. Further, it will do much towards popularising the team amongst the lukewarm portion of their followers.
EVERTON’S FIRST WIN AT SUNDERLAND
Athletic News - Monday 18 November 1901
By Tom Tiddler
Fine, frosty weather favoured the meeting of Sunderland and Everton at Roker Park, and 13,100 paid to see the match which ended in favour of Everton by four to two. Sunderland made two changes from the side that performed so disastrously at Stoke. Craggs and Miller displacing W. Hogg and Prior. Craggs is local lad, and has obtained a good schooling with the "A" team, and against Evertonhe made his debut in League football. The visitors were, as usual, excepting that Wolstenholme took the place of Clarke. When about twenty minutes had gone by Craggs put in fine centre from the goal line. Gemmell and Miller rushed up to meet it, and the former pouncing upon the leather gave Kitchen no chance clearing. Everton went straight down from the centre kick, and after a few exchanges in front of the home goal Settle sent in an oblique shot. Doig evidently thought that Watson would clear it, but he did not, and when the custodian jumped to the ball it just caught his hand, and dropped through. Sunderland played up splendidly this, and some five minutesfrom the interval Craggs netted the ball, but the whistle had just previously blown for off side.
A DISPUTED DECISION
Almost directly afterwards Miller shot in, and before Kitchen could clear Craggs bundled him and the ball into the net. Everton vigorously protested against a goal being allowed, and Sunderland just as strenuously claimed for one. The referee, after consulting the linesmen, decided in favour of Everton and awarded them a free kick. The decision was badly received by the spectators, and they loudly hooted Mr. Kirkham. The interval was called directly afterwards with the teams one each. Twelve minutes after the cross over Settle secured from a throw in, a dodging McCombie scored a clever goal. Two minutes later the same player made another fine run, and passing out to Sharp, the latter ran few yards, and when about ten yards away, he shot. The ball struck the upright, and glanced into the net. Doig making no effort to save. In fact he was appealing for off-side at the time. Though two goals to the bad, Sunderland were no means done with, and for a longish period their opponents were kept on the defence. Some eighteen minutes from the close Bell was brought down by M'Combie within the twelve yards mark, and the referee promptly awarded a penalty. Abbott took the kick, and drove the ball clear into the net. Straight from the centre kick, Craggs got possession, and placing the ball across the Everton goal. McLatchie registered the second point for his side, and completed the scoring.
PRAISE FOR THE WINNERS.
There was no doubt as to which was the better team, viewing the game as a whole. In the first half the play was fairly even until near the interval, when Sunderland penned up their opponents, and had distinctly hand lines in not being goal up. After the turn round, however, the visitors excelled in the finer points of the game and they richly deserved the victory. There has not been a cleverer exhibition of forward work at Sunderland this season than that given by the Everton front rank. To finish well is almost invariably a weakness among forwards, but there was nothing of that about the Evertonians. When they got in front they were dangerous, and in this respect presented a striking contrast to Sunderland. The latter indeed were the more aggressive of the two, but lacked the ability to put on the finishing touch. In the early stages the visitors adopted the close pasting game, but the opposing defence easily broke them up, and went in for open work. Settle was the most dangerous man on the field, and did a rare lot of fine things. Sharp and Bell were also noticeable for cool and clever play, and the remaining two were capital. Of a sturdy plodding half-line Abbott was perhaps the pick. The backs tackled resolutely and kicked with a splendid length, and Kitchen kept a safe goal. Taken all round they are a smart lot of fellows. The home forwards worked hard, but, as before indicated, they lacked method. Miller was the best of the line, and had ill-luck with at least two of his parting shots. Craggs made a surprisingly good start, improving as the play went on. Both goals were got from his centres, and that is something for a youngster. McAllister was the best of the halves, who, as a line, were not speedy enough for the opposing quintette. The backs did not come up to expectations. They were unsteady, their clearances at times were weak, and they failed to time the rushes. Doig had not much chance with the shots that beat him, but I have seen him do better. Teams: Sunderland.—Doig; McCombie and Watson; Ferguson, McAllister, and Jackson; Craggs, F. Hogg, Miller, Gemmell, and McLatchie.
Everton.- Kitchen; Balmer and Eccles; Wolstenholme, Booth (Captain), and Abbott; Sharp, Proudfoot, Young, Settle, and Bell. Referee- T. Kirkham, Burslem.
Notes Page 1
The Everton-Sunderland match was a grand struggle, and at the interval the scoring was level- one all- Mr. Kirkham having disallowed a goal to the home team apparently on the ground that Kitchen was charged in the act of playing the ball. It seems strange that neither players nor spectators can grasp the fact that a goalkeeper can only be charged when he is holding the ball, obstructing an opponent or is outside the six yards circle. Settle, with his ninth goal this season, gave Everton the lead, while Sharp added a third, and a fourth accrued from a penalty kick given against McCombie. This is the second time this season that Sunderland, with Doig in goal, have been quilted to the extent of 4-2, for the “Wolves” had this margin on September 14. Everton played a splendid forward game, especially near goal, and thoroughly deserved their points. Craggs a youth from the Reserve team, who took the place of William Hogg, created a most favourable impression.
EVERTON v SUNDERLAND
Liverpool Daily Post - Monday 18 November 1901
This League fixture at Roker Park, Sunderland attracted 14,000 spectators. The game was played in bright, frosty weather. Sunderland made two changes from last week, dropping W. Hogg and Prior for Craggs (a local player) and Miller. Everton made one change, substituting Wolstenholme for Clark. Teams;-
Sunderland.- Doig, goal; McCombie and Watson, backs; Ferguson, McAllister, and Jackson, half-backs; Craggs, R. Hoggs, Miller, Searmell, and McLatchie, forwards.
Everton.- Kitchen, goal; Balmer and Eccles, backs; Wolstenholme, Booth (Captain), and Abbott, half-backs; Sharp, Proudfoot, Young, Settle, and bell, forwards.
Sunderland won the toss, and a few minutes after the advertised time Young set the ball rolling for the Evertonians, who pressed, Settle nearly scoring in the first minute. Then Sunderland had a look in, and, receiving a good pass, Gemmell closed in and shot the ball past Kitchen after six minutes’ play. The visitors got away by the aid of Young, but McAllister, rushing up dispossessed him of the ball, and transferred to Gemmill, who got his left wing going. The ball was quickly sent back to the centre, where Craggs, who was lying well up the field, was quick to seize upon it, and essayed a shot, which Eccles anticipated, but only partially cleared, and Balmer, running across, kicked the ball well into the centre of the field. Bell received it, and running down the wing, gave to Young, who was cheered for getting the ball off Ferguson. McCombie rushed in, and by a timely kick released the pressure, but Settle who was playing in dashing style, quickly put the ball back again, giving Young possession. After a stubborn tussle Settle bested Ferguson, and got in a nice centre. A quick run down by the visiting forwards, and Sharp ran the ball over the line, Bell was pulled up for offside, and Sharp and Proudfoot in turn got possession, going well up the field, but the latter was knocked off the ball by Jackson. A throw in to the homesters followed, but Balmer cleared his lines. Another throw in ended in a run and centre by R. Hogg. A breakaway by the home left followed, and McLatchie scudded away finely, getting well up, but his final pass was not utilised, and the ball went harmlessly outside. After some desultory midfield play was visitors got possession, and a brisk run was made into the home territory, and but for the sound defence of McCombie and Watson, a goal must have resulted. As it was it had a very narrow escape, the ball being finally sent over the line within a few inches of the upright, the ensuing goal kick bringing welcome relief to the home team. The homesters now once more took up the running, and as a result of some good wing work Craggs got close up, and shot with terrific force into Kitchen’s hands that players clearing cleverly. Play not slowed down for a little time, the half backs monopolising the ball. At last, the visitors broke away, their right wing working the leather prettily along. Jackson tried in vain to arrest their progress, but they ran completely around him, and tricking Watson, got into the corner, where Sharp slung the ball across the goal for Young to head it over. After some clever dribbling by the visitors’ left, Settle ran round McCombie, and “ticing” out Doig, shot the ball past him into the net, making the score equal. An attack on the home goal, in which Young shot into the custodian’s hands, was staved off, and more activity of the home forwards led to a fine clearance by Eccles, from which the sphere was flung over the Bell, who went in dangerously. Doig went out to meet him, and his final effort went wide of the post. A bad foul by one of the home halves was justly penalised, and soon after play was suspended for a moment or two, one of the players being winded. He was soon up, and the game was renewed with fresh vigour. A run by Doig. Half-time;- Everton 1 goal, Sunderland 1 goal.
Sunderland opened the second half in fine style, forcing a corner which McLatchie placed behind. Miller tested Kitchen with a beauty. Even play followed, and Proudfoot and Sharp went clean away, but lost over the goal-line. Settle next got through, sending outside. Bell broke away, and sent in a long shot, which Doig easily kicked away. Sunderland then had a turn, forcing a fruitless corner. Gemmill from close in headed over. Thirteen minutes from the close over Settle finished up a fine run by giving Everton the lead, Doig having no chance of saving. Three minutes later Settle made another fine run, and passing over to Sharp, the latter put on the third goal. Sunderland appealed for offside, but the goal was allowed. Eighteen minutes from the finish Abbott scored from a penalty kick. McLatchie scored a minute later. Result; Everton 4 goals, Sunderland 2 goals.
SATURDAY’S FOOTBALL
Liverpool Daily Post - Monday 18 November 1901
Sunderland was one of the favoured districts where our Everton club had journeyed to play their League fixture with the “Wearsiders.” The weather in the north was bright, but frosty, and the attraction of the game drew together about 14,000 spectators to what proved a fine game, in which the Everton players created quite a surprise by defeating Sunderland 4 goals to 2. This is a record so far as this fixture is concerned, and probably no one is more surprised at the result- and we hasten to congratulate them-than the players on the winning side. How they did it is not to be told, for nobody knows, not even the Evertonians themselves. Settle scored two out of the four goals for his side, Sharp and Abbott the others. These make ten goals Settle has scored in league matches this season for Everton, and as the club has only registered twenty-three in all, the ex-Bury player has had a big share in the picking. Although he is properly blamed for trying too much individualism, it has paid in a sense, though we cannot help having the opinion that if the front Everton line showed more combination the result would be more satisfactory. The victory-which no one could possibly have anticipated after witnessing Everton’s almost despicable play against Blackburn Rovers on Monday last at Goodison Park in the Lancashire Cup Competition -has planted them once more on the top of the league pedestal, but whether they remain there is another thing- time only will show.
THE ANIMATED PHOTOGRAPHS.
Sunderland Daily Echo and Shipping Gazette - Tuesday 19 November 1901
The Edison and North American Animated Photo Company have entered upon the last week of their stay in Sunderland. During the past three weeks the pictures have created quite a stir in the town, the one question asked on all hands being "Have you seen the pictures? and few entertainments could have drawn such crowded audiences to the Victoria Hall for so many nights, especially in such weather as we have been experiencing. The reproductions are as perfect as it is possible to get them, they are quite clear and distinct, and the objectionable flickering so trying to the eye is entirely absent. Many new photos have been added this week. The reproduction of the Sunderland and Everton match at Roker on Saturday was quite success last night, and though the audience was perhaps not so enthusiastic about it as they would have been had the score been reverseds.
Sunderland v Everton
Dundee Evening Post - Tuesday 19 November 1901
Of the four Association matches that were decided three provided surprising results. Sunderland were beaten for the first time this season on their own ground—a terrible fall, by which Everton. who beat them, take their place at the head of the League table. Curiously enough, Everton's near neighbours are the only other club that have gained a point at Wearside since the beginning of September. Who Scored?—Gemmell scored for Sunderland after 17 minutes' play. Settle equalised tor Everton a few minutes afterwards. A quarter of an hour after the interval Settle put on Everton's second goal. Sharp scored Everton's third goal five minutes afterwards. Abbot scored for Everton, from a penalty, a quarter of an hour before the finish. M'Latchie scored for Sunderland about a minute afterwards.
EVERTON TRIUMPHANT AT LAST IN THE FAR NORTH
Football Chat and Athletic News- Tuesday November 19, 1901
Although Sunderland have come more than one ugly cropper at Goodison Park in League struggles with Everton, it is the fact that the Toffees have but seldom received any change out of the shillings either at the old Newcastle Road ground or the more recent, and more up to date, Park. Never had victory, prior to Saturday, gone the way of the Marine representatives, who in the far North have almost invariably proved Sunderland's defence an unsurmountable quantity, this rather than prolific scoring being responsible for Everton’s failure to achievesuccess. On Saturday the " blues " had yet another---successful as it happened-try, and in addition to the curiosity evidentas to the outcome of this latest Lancashire attack, interest in the proceedings was whetted by the fact that the pair ranked Nos. I and 2 on the " table," and that victory to the visitors would mean their stepping, for the time being at least, to the topmost rung. Everton relied upon the team which Blackburn Rovers threw out of the Lancashire Cup the previous Monday, Clark and Blythe of the eleven victorious at Grimsby thus giving way in their half-back to Wolstenholme and Abbott, Taylor, their hardest working forward, being still an absentee. Sunderland did not retain the , ex-St. Bernard centre-forward Prior, who, however, was reported their most successful van-guarder in the disastrous Stoke match, and Miller came in again. W. Hogg, too, was dropped for J. Craggs, a local, and Young. it may be added were making their initial appearance at Wearside. There was a big crowd present when Referee Kirkham signalled the start, young doing this necessary part of the business. Little did the audience imagine what dire disaster was in store for the natives, who witnessed Sunderland defeated at Roker for the first time this season. Six goals in all were scored, the first and last going to the Wearsiders, with Everton monopolising the middle cute. All appeared rosy when Gemmell slammed the ball past Kitchen early on, but are the interval Settle had put on an equaliser, and so well were the visitors moving all the time, that nothing less than brilliant defence on the part of Doig and his henchmen had stemmed further disaster. The second half, however, brought Ita tale of woe, for soon Settle, with a view possible to keeping at the head of the League's goal-getting list, put his side although just before this Sunderland claimed in vain for a goal as Kitchen barely saved with Craggs on top of him. The best goal of the match followed, Jack Sharp getting in a brilliant run in which Jackson, Watson and another in turn were beaten, and winding up with a splendid shot that Doig couldn't look at. All now appeared over, particularly when Watson was mulcted in a penalty from which Abbott negotiated the visitors' fourth goal. Just before the close McLatchie lessened the gap by scoring Sunderland's second goal. Needless to add the defeat came as a great surprise to all Wearside, although it must not be overlooked that the Roker team had played disappointingly in their three previous matches. For once in a way Sunderland's defence found itself mastered by Everton at home. The winners quite deserved their success. Kitchen is a clever custodian and Balmer knows his way about as a defender. Eccles, too, worked hard. Booth was the best of the halves, and forward Settle and Sharps were brilliant. Young I look upon as a promising centre. In the Sunderland ranks the halve were up to concert pitch, whilst McCombie and Watson were none too reliable under pressure. Forward. Craggs made a creditable debut, but W. Hogg would have been better for a match of such importance. R. Hogg was off colour, and a trial might be given to Miller here with Prior centre. The Liverpool clubs have done well at Wearside this season. Result : Everton 4 Sunderland 2. Attendance, 18,000. Teams : Sunderland.—Doig; McCombie and Watson ; Ferguson, McAllister, and Jackson; B. Hogg, Killer, Gemmell and McLatchie. Everton.—Kitchen ; Balmer and Eccles; Wolstenholme, Booth, and Abbott; Sharp, Proudfoot, Young, Settle, and Bell. Referee : T. Kirkham, Burslem.
EVERTON’S COMPLAINT AGAINST A REFEREE
Liverpool Daily Post - Thursday 21 November 1901
The commission appointed by the Management Committee of the League to inquire into the complaint made by the Everton club against Mr. Fred Bye, a League referee, will meet at Manchester to-morrow.
COMMENTS ON SPORT
Liverpool Daily Post - Thursday 21 November 1901
By Lynx II
Fog and football are not negotiable quantities. This was strongly demonstrated in Liverpool and the vicinity on Saturday last, when the great winter pastime was for the time being practically annihilated. The dank, depressing vapour rolled in dense clouds Anfield-wards, and at three o’clock, when the game between Liverpool and Grimsby Town ought to have been in full swing, one could not see more than yard ahead. There was, of course, alternative but to postpone the meeting, and the large crowd that had assembled outside the enclosure proceeded disconsolately to grope its way homeward. At Sunderland, on the other hand, the weather was surprisingly fine—though this was not half so surprising as the result the encounter between Everton and the Wearsiders. Up to Saturday the Goodison Park brigade had never won a game at Sunderland, but on this occasion they made up for lost time, running out handsome victors by 4 goals to 2. A famous Scottish international who saw the game tells it was one of the best Everton has ever played, and that they might easily hare won by an even greater margin goals. The Sunderland players evidently thought too lightly of their visitors, and were consequently taken completely by surprise. On Saturday next Everton meet Small Heath at Goodison Park, while Liverpool are due at St. James’s Park, Newcastle.
EVERTON AND MR. BYE
Lancashire Evening Post - Saturday 23 November 1901.
A commission of the Football League was held at Manchester last night to consider the complaint by the Everton club against the manner in which Mr. Bye, the referee, conducted the game at Birmingham between Aston Villa and Everton. The following decision was arrived at:—“ That the referee, Mr. Bye, acted fairly, honestly, and accordance with the laws the game, and that the complaint made against him was not justified; that Everton club pay all the costs of the meeting."
LANCASHIRE COMBINATION.
Lancashire Evening Post - Saturday 23 November 1901
Everton Reserves v. Oswaldtwistle
Everton Reserve brought a powerful team to oppose Oswaldtwistle Rovers. A capital display was seen, the home team playing their best game this season- Everton were the first score, Boyle putting the ball beyond the reach of Piatt. The home team equalised through Pope. A minute later, Fletcher scored a second. The same player put his side further ahead from a lovely centre by Longworth. Platt made a miraculous save. Hail-time—Rovers 3, Everton 1
In the second half Everton adopted kick and rush tactics, and Platt had had to clear three hot shots in as many minutes. Play was not so interesting as in the first half. Everton pressed continually, but Smith, Hargreaves, and Platt played magnificently. A hot shot from Rankin was splendidly cleared by Platt. Sharp fouled Longworth when the latter was dangerous. Pope shot weakly. The home team gradually assumed the aggressive. Result—ROVERS 3. EVERTON RESERVES 1.
APPEAL BY EVERTON OVERULED
Liverpool Daily Post - Saturday 23 November 1901
A special sub-committee of the Football League, consisting of Messrs, Bentley, Lewis, and Sutcliffe, met in Manchester last evening. The chief business was the consideration of a complaint laid by Everton against Mr. F. Bye, of Sheffield, the referee in the match with Aston Villa on September 28. The allegation was practically that Mr. Bye allowed a goal which was illegally obtained, but after hearing the evidence, it was decided that Mr. Bye acted in accordance with the rule, and that Everton pay the costs of the inquiry.
TEAM NEWS TODAY
EVERTON v SMALL HEATH
At Goodison Park; Kick-off 2.45.
Everton;- Kitchen, goal; Balmer and Eccles, abcks; Wolstenholme, Booth and Abbott, half-backs; Sharp, Proudfoot, Young, Settle, and Bell, forwards.
EVERTON COMBINATION v OSWALDTWISTLE
At Oswaldtwistle; kick-off 2.30.
Everton;- Muir, goal; Sharp, and Watson, backs; Brown, Boyle, and Blythe, half-backs; Roche, Paterson, Rankin, A. Chadwick, and Singleton. Forwards.
PERTAINING TO PROMINENT PLAYERS
Lancashire Evening Post - Saturday 23 November 1901
H.P. HARDMAN
By Perseus
H.P. Hardman, the Blackpool outside left, struck me on the one occasion I had the pleasure of watching him as a player of very marked ability. Distinctly fast, he ought to outpace 75 per cent of opposing halves and backs. Atherton, the right extreme in the successful Southport Central team, is one of the speediest of footballers, but in a recent Cup tie he tried in vain to get away from Hardman, who at a critical point had fallen back to assist the defence. And while as fast as the Sandgrounder Hardman is certainly cleverer, for he controls the sphere with exceeding skill; he dribbles neatly, and centres with judgement, besides which he is pluckier than Atherton. I have chosen the latter as a basis for comparison, because he is known not only to Prestonians through his former connection with North End, but to a very wide circle of Platine football through his play in the Lancashire League. On all points except speed, in which the two are probably almost on a level. Hardman appears the more accomplished player, and it is all in his favour that he is only 19 years of age. Blackpool people know well enough, but outsiders may not, that Hardman plays as an amateur, that his father is a Manchester solicitor, and that he learned his football at the South Shore High School, where he won the running championship several years in succession.
EVERTON v SMALL HEATH
Sports Argus - Saturday 23 November 1901
HOMESTERS EARLY TAKE THE LEAD
AND KEEP IT
By “The Heathen.”
The team representing Small Heath at Everton this afternoon was the strongest put on the field this season. The defence was slightly altered. Adey once more being substituted for Walton, who went along with the team as reserve. In the forward rank McMillan made a welcome appearance at inside left, while the other inner position was filled by Bennett. The Everton team, too, were strong. The following players faced each other;-
Everton; Kitchen; Balmer, Eccles; Wolstenholme, Booth (Captain), Abbott, half-backs; Sharp, Proudfoot, Young, Settle, Bell.
Small Heath;- Robinson; Goldie, Archer; Adey, Wigmore, Leake (Captain); Athersmith, Bennett, McRoberts, McMillan, Wharton. Referee. Mr. Sutcliffe (Bolton).
The weather was not as good as could have been wished for, a mist being over the ground and threatening to develop into a thick fog as time went on. Great interest was taken in the match in Liverpool, as was proved by the large gathering which assembled long before the kick-off. This was fixed rather later than seemed convenient, namely 2.30. At the start there must have been some 20,000 people present. One change was made at a late moment in the Everton team, Eccles taking the place of Watson, who had been advertised to partner Balmer at back. Small heath won the toss, which, however, gave little advantage. The game began right briskly, both teams showing plenty of energy. After a short spell of midfield play, Small Heath, who were playing in white shirts, attacked the Everton goal, which was defended by Royal Blue shirts. They failed to penetrate the defence. Sharp was chiefly responsible for a retaliating onslaught by the Everton forwards. Working in good combination they gave the visitors defence cause for anxiety, and three minutes from the kick-off Bell shot into the net, scoring the first goal for his side. Again the home side came down in capital style, only to run the ball over the line. Goldie, repelling another assault put the ball into goal, but Kitchen found no difficult in clearing. Young seized on the ball as it came down the field, tricked Goldie and tried to get a shot himself. Finding this impossible he transferred to Bell, who kicked wide. The Everton left-wingers were very troublesome, and kept Goldie fully employed. Proudfoot, however, was the next to give his side a chance of becoming really dangerous. Running past Archer he centred across goal, where Settle was so hampered by his own companions that he could not shoot to advantage. The Small heath goal was undergoing a siege. Goldie stopped Bell while in the act of kicking, and then Abbott made an attempt, sending the ball a yard or two wide. Booth put in the next “crooked” shot, and the ball kept hovering about Robinson in a way that could hardly have been pleasant. Yet he had no opportunity of using his hands, as the ball went anywhere but between the posts. At last the visiting forwards broke the spell, Wharton raced along his wing, hotly pressed by Balmer, who, charging just as he was centring, tumbled his headlong. A pass from Booth gave Sharp what looked like a good opening, but Archer intervening spoilt it completely. Nevertheless, most of the play continued in the Small heath portion of the ground, and if the Everton marksmanship had not been very poor the score must have been increased. McRoberts passed neatly to Wharton, who tried his best to make the most of his chance. But Balmer was playing on him too strenuously, making it impossible to centre with any accuracy. So the visitors had to suffer the mortification of seeing their opponents returning to the other end, and making things warm for Goldie, Archer and Robinson. A centre from Sharp was headed away by Wigmore, and Leake took the ball from Proudfoot. Booth was enabled to put in a long shot, which compelled Robinson to jump up and fist out smartly. Leake headed a centre from Bell out of the very mouth of goal. Then followed one of the best attempts Small heath had been able to make so far. Athersmith got in a long centre, and though Eccles endeavoured to kick down the field, McRoberts was in time to shoot hard and straight at Kitchen. Unfortunately- for the visitors-his foot was too much under the ball, which sailed a foot or two high over the crossbar. This effort, ineffective as it proved, appeared to put heart into the Small heath forward line, and for quite a respectable time they stayed near the Everton goal, failing to score, but equalising the appearance of the game somewhat. A sharp shot from one of the home forwards almost beat Robinson. He only just managed to scrape the ball out, and the next moment was called upon to bestir himself still more energetically. Half-time came with the score;-
Everton 1 Small Heath 0
The second half began as the first half ended—wish Everton in the ascendant. But soon Athersmith and Bennett worked their way down the right and looked like becoming dangerous when Eccles took the ball from their feet. Archer had to pull up the Everton left wing, and then Goldie was troubled by Bell and Settle, who came for goal in dashing style. The ball went to Proudfoot, who shot to the side of the post. Retaliating, the visiting forwards put some energy into their work with the result that Balmer and Eccles had quite as anxious a time as the rival backs had been suffering from. Adey put an end to Small Heath's hopes by shooting over the bar. The visitors were now having decidedly more of the game than they had enjoyed hitherto. They made one or two most promising attacks, which took the Everton defenders all their time to defeat. Bennett ended tricky work between himself and Athersmith by shooting out some twenty yards from goal. Severe, but amusing, tussles were seen between the Small Heath right wingers and Abbott, ending more than once with the latter coming off victorious. Bell and Settle gained applause for a fine passing run, which ended in Bell centring judiciously across the goal, and Archer landing the ball out of danger. Everton attacked again the next moment, again without success. Afterwards Small Heath made a promising rush to the other end, which came, to nought. A free kick to the visitors near goal led to a sustained tussle before Kitchen, who was stoutly defended by his backs, and finally relieved from anxiety by Abbott. Athersmith next had a corner to manipulate and kicked the ball weakly out. Tremendous excitement was caused by a prolonged struggle before Robinson, the consequence of a corner kick to Everton. Another freekick roused the hopes of Small Heath supporters, but the ball was badly played to the side of the post, and, despite the strenuous effort of the visitors to the very end and the touch ended with the score— Everton 1 Small Heath 0
COMMENTS ON THE GAME
More fog! It hung round Goodison Park in a threatening, rather than a sternly practical, manner—which was something to be thankful for, at any rate. Nevertheless the threat was quite sufficient to make things uncomfortable and doubtful. At the kick-off the chances of the game being properly finished seemed very remote, but happily at the first half progressed, the gloom did not deepen as might have been expected. The first goal came three minutes from the start, appeared to dishearten the Small Heath men, who played as though they had small hope—if great desire—to open their account. For the greater part of the opening half, they were compelled to act on the defensive, and when they did manage to get within shooting distance of the home goal, which was not more than half a dozen times, their attempts were rather easily spoilt by Balmer and Eccles. Everton, to tell the truth were distinctly the better team at the beginning. Back and forward they were quickest on the ball, knew better what to do with it when they had it at their feet, and worked together more ingeniously. But their shooting was shockingly bad! When the whistle sounded for the interval, Robinson had to use his hands very seldom, despite the fact that quite three quarters of the play had taken place in his vicinity. The complexion of affairs was changed considerably at the opening of the second half, Small Heath attacked in real earnest, seeming determined to make up arrears. The game was far more open than it had been, but Small heath enjoyed what advantage there was. The attacks were of a substantial kind on both sides. Both teams warmed to their work, and were more vigorously correct in their methods. At the same time, it cannot be said that either goal was often in very great danger. So far- and no farther, might be a record of their struggle. Till they got within shooting distance the work of the forwards was promising; when the time came to shoot that adjective was no longer deserved. Everton remained slightly superior to their opponents in the cleanness of their football, but the superiority was by no means so great as it had been. Moreover, Small heath improved greatly in dash and cleverness, and thoroughly deserved a goal to reward them for their efforts in the latter portion. The way they went for Kitchen was often a treat to witness after the comparative weakness of the first half. There was nothing of disgrace about their defeat; it was a good game, well contested, and a draw would have been no unfitting conclusion. The fog, by the way, kept off splendidly. The last stages of the game was played in a somewhat murky atmosphere, which, caused the rising moon to seen a necessity. But, fortunately, the reason was found for the game being brought to a premature conclusion.
EVERTON v SMALL HEATH
The Liverpool Football Echo- Saturday, November 23, 1901
LEAGUE DIVISION 1
BELL SCORES FOR EVERTON SOON AFTER THE START
VICTORY FOR EVERTON
A HARD GAME
By Pigeon Post and Telephone
The weather in Liverpool was again of a wintry nature, frost and fog prevailing, but fortunately the experience of last week was absent, and it was at least possible to commence the game. With the object of finishing the match against Small Heath it was started five minutes before the advertised time. After the brilliant performance of Everton against Sunderland a great crowd assembled to welcome them. Small Heath ingratiated themselves when they appeared at Anfield-road a few weeks ago, and a good game was anticipated to-day. No change was made from the advertised teams, who faced as follows before 15,00 spectators;-
Everton.—Kitchen, goal; Balmer and Eccles, backs; Wolstenholme, Booth (Captain), and Abbott, half backs: Sharp, Proudfoot, Young, Settle, and Bell, forwards. Small Heath.—Robinson, goal; Archer and Goldie, backs; Leake (Captain), Wigmore, and Adey, half backs; Wharton, McMillan, McRoberts, Bennett, and Athersmith, forwards.
Everton having lost the toss, Young started operations a couple of minutes before the advertised time. Sharp made a couple of dashes, but on each occasion was pulled up by Archer, and three minutes after the commencement of the game Everton had a free kick, from which Bell scored. From the centre Athersmith and his partner became very busy, were utterly routed by Eccles. On the other wing Wharton ran up, but Kitchen cleared well. Free kicks fell to either side, but neither proved of much advantage. Exceedingly pretty play by Young in the centre had the effect of pressing back the visitors, Bell at the finish coming in and shooting very strongly the ball going high over the crossbar. Play for a time after this was contested in neutral ground, following which Small Heath attacked on the right and left, but did not become really dangerous. Bennett ultimately shot wide. From the goal kick the Everton left made rapid progress, Young making a futile bid for goal. Pretty exchanges between Sharp, Proudfoot, and Young rendered matters very uncomfortable for the “Heathens,” Bell and Young each having abortive shies. The pressure by Everton was kept up in praiseworthy fashion, the passes among the front rank being crisp and clean, and as a consequence the visiting defence was sorely troubled. Sharp gave Settle a chance, but he failed, coming down again Abbott ran right through, and shot by the side of the post. McMillan and Wharton made off, but were beautifully checked by Balmer with a nasty header, and then Sharp made tracks for the other end, but was tripped. However, Proudfoot passed to the centre, and Booth had a long shot at goal. The Evertonians still pressed forward, and Abbott hand another strong shot at goal, but missed. Wharton passed to the centre man, who was robbed by Abbott, and then Everton gained a corner on the right, but this led to nothing tangible. Wharton again sprinted, but was followed, and splendidly beaten by Balmer, who checked the visitors again a moment later; but the Heathens came again and McRoberts shot by the side of Kicthener’s charge. From the goal kick the Heathens got to half-way, where Booth became very prominent, twice checking dangerous moves, following which Proudfoot was penalised for a foul. The free kick, however, yielded little advantage to the visitors, as Everton were back in a trice, Settle having a glorious opening, but he shot yards over the bar. A little later Young had a “pop” which again proved abortive, and a fugitive visit to Kitchen’s end was similarly fruitless. Play at this stage was not very exciting, and the only notable incident was a long futile attempt by Young. Following this, the visitors had more of the game than previously, and numerous attempts by the Small Heath left wingers were made, but on each occasion they were attended to by Balmer in a workmanlike manner. Then they tried on the right, and were more successful, Eccles letting them in, and Bennett and McRoberts each having futile shots at goal. Beautiful passing by the Everton forwards was spoiled by Archer, but a moment later, Bell had a grand shot, which was well saved by Robinson, Settle finishing the move by shooting by the side of the post. From a move on the part of the left wing, Young beautifully dodged through his final attempt, however, being wrongly directed, and as a consequence an easy clearance was effected. The game for some time was by no means brilliant, the only “spicy” move being one by Small Heath, which resulted in McRoberts shooting about a yard over the bar. Play of a quiet nature ensued, and both sides failed to display that dash and energy which was expected of them. The spectators loudly shouted “Play up, Everton!” and in response to these appeals the home side became more spirited. At the other end Bell just missed, and Robinson saved from Sharp. Towards the close of the first half the visitors attacked, but they could make no impression on the Everton defence.
Half-time; Everton 1 goal; Small Heath, nil.
McRoberts resumed, and the light even at this early stage, was none of the best. The first move was made on the home right, but nothing came of it, and a moment later the game was suspended on account of an injury to Young. On resuming, Everton took up the play, and a scrimmage occurred in the visitors’ goalmouth, but the home front side failed to pilot the sphere into the net, Goldie ultimately effecting a clearance. Midfield work of a quiet nature followed, after which Bell and Proudfoot tried an attacking move, which, however, was of no avail, Leake breaking up the Combiantion, and the ball was driven outside. End to end play ensued during which Athersmith found himself well placed, but lost the leather over the touch-line. The homesters went down on each wing, a really good move by the left ending with a shot from Settle, but it failed to take effect. Effecting passing by the Small heath quintette culminated in Bennett having a shot at goal, after which Athersmith and Bennett were busy, but Balmer came across and compelled a retreat. Leake made a bold bid to lower Kitchen’s colours, the Everton custodian, however, catching it and clearing finely. After a spell of even work Small Heath attacked in spirited style, Balmer displaying great form in checking the fast rushes of the opposing front rank whilst clearances were of advantage to his side. After Eccles had pulled up Bennett and Athersmith the Heathens again returned to the attack, but their attempts to score were very mediocre. A pretty bit of work between Bell and Settle ensued, the former centring very finely. But Sharp could not get at the sphere, Goldie clearing. Balmer headed away a very hot shot in splendid fashion, but the Midlanders would not be beaten back, and a free kick to them looked ominous from an Evertonian point of view. The only result, however, was an abortive corner, Kitchen effecting a magnificent save. The remaining stages of the game were difficult to follow on account of the falling light. Final Result; Everton 1 goal, Small Heath Nil.
OSWALDTWISTLE ROVER v EVERTON COMBINATION
The Liverpool Football Echo- Saturday, November 23, 1901
Lancashire Combination
Played at Oswaldtwistle. At the interval the score read;- Oswaldtwistle 3 goals, Everton Combination 1 goal.
AT GOODISON PARK
Empire News & The Umpire - Sunday 24 November 1901
ANOTHER VICTORY FOR EVERTON
PLUCKY DISPLAY BY SMALL HEATH
By The Impressionist
Football at Goodison Park is carried out in a style something surely approaching perfection. Certainly it would be hard to find an enclosure where the general conditions, applied alike to player and spectator, are more satisfactory, and the energy, tact, and foresight of the officials must have something to do with the huge attendances of which the Everton club can beast, quite apart from the attractiveness of the football feasts provided. When I left Manchester on Saturday at noon I didn’t feel at all cocksure as to whether there would be any football in Liverpool or not. Frost succeeding on heavy rain generally plays havoc with the atmospheric conditions, and all along the route through Irlam and Warrington the air was misty in the extreme, despite the efforts of his solar majesty to dispel the clouds of vapour. However, as we approached Liverpool things brightened up very considerably, and on arrival there I was agreeably surprised to find the outlook as bright as one can reasonably expect in the dark, dreary month of November. It, however, didn’t look too promising at Goodison Park, and many were of opinion that a 2-30 kick-off would have been desirable under the circumstances. Strangely enough, the light improved as the second half was entered upon., though towards the close of shades of mis-eve were rapidly closing in, the game itself was carried through without the slightest difficulty or hitch, and most present could follow the movements of the players quite easily during the whole 90 minutes. Naturally, after the brilliant performance of Everton in the far north a week ago, there assembled a goodly crowd to cheer on their pets to further victory. But from the coign of vantage in front of the cosy offices it was very difficult to estimate the numbers, the opposite stands being shrouded in gloom. A good judge, however, informed me that at least 17,000 were present, and this, if not up to the standard of some Evertonian gatherings, was at least a “gate” for which many clubs would be profoundly grateful. It was certainly a compliment to the Small heath team and, to tell the truth, I do not know a team more deserving. To tell the history of the Small Heathens in anything like complete fashion would take up far more space than I can possibly spare. But most people who take an interest in football at all know of their plucky struggles over a lengthy period. They have had times of adversity deep enough to thoroughly dishearten if not entirely swamp many organisations, but thanks in a large measure to the sterling dogged enthusiasm of Mr. W.W. Hart, they have risen superior to all doubts and difficulties and have now, as all the world knows, occupy a position in the First League creditable to a degree. It was the first opportunity I had this season of watching Leake and his team disport themselves, and I am glad that when the chance came it should be against so powerful a combination as the Evertonians have proved themselves to be. Except, of course, that Everton still bemoan the absence of Toman, who one is glad to learn is progressing nicely, both teams can be said to have been at full strength, and the visitors were not without hopes of bagging a couple or at least one point- hopes, alas! for the, doomed to be blighted, singularly enough the goal which did all the mischief, from a Heathen point of view, happened in the first few minutes of the game. Straight from the start Sharp on the Everton right endeavoured to get away only to be pulled up by Archer. Then the visitors left wing were in evidence, for Balmer to clear in the nick of time, and enable his side moreover to gain a footing well towards their opponents’ goal. Here Young was fouled by Wigmore just outside the penalty line. The free kick was taken, the ball finessed about a bit and then, in much less time than it takes to tell, Bell had gone clean through with the ball at his toes, and Everton were a goal in front. It was rather a singular performance, as the defenders seemed to be watching everybody but Bell, and he in the coolest manner seized the opening, and as it turned out, won the match for his side. Following this point, received, of course, with rapture, the home team were all over their opponents, and how they missed adding to the score is almost a mystery. Every moment one felt that another goal was almost sure to come as the Everton front rank swarmed round the goal; but it must be confessed the final efforts were in several instances astonishingly weak, and it was but seldom that Robinson was called upon to handle the ball. Meantime, Wharton and McMillan on the Heathen left wing were making determined efforts to put a different complexion on the game, but Balmer, and in front of him Booth and Wolstenholme were in such capital form that Kitchen was not troubled and the attacks on the Everton goal were not at this stage what might be termed really troublesome. At the other end Proudfoot contributed a pretty bit of work without any tangible result, a like fate awaiting a well-meant effort by Settle and Bell a moment later. Try as they would the Heathen backs could not effect anything like a real clearance, and shots of a sort poured in for several minutes. Some went wide, some caught the heads of desperate defenders, whilst yet others sailed high over the crossbar, and fell amongst the throng of spectators behind the net. A corner, owing to a miskick by Archer, was well placed, but the ball was got away, and in the next minute Robinson safely dealt with a long shot which might easily have beaten a less vigilant keeper. Gradually yet surely the Everton attack slackened. Wigmore and Leake in particular were working like trojans to remove the pressure, and were at last successful. An incident which thoroughly delighted the crowd here occurred a great race between Wharton and Balmer for possession ending in the latter charging the flying left-winger and sending him head over heels in good old-fashioned style. Succeeding play was of a more even character, though Everton continued to have just a shade the best of matters. Booth was sorely bothering the Small heath attack, and several times broke up promising movements in masterly fashion. The visitors’ right wing scarcely seemed to get going properly, and for a time Athersmith was very much neglected. He and Bennett did once get past Eccles and from the succeeding centre McRoberts had a shot at goal without result. The last named, however, came pretty near achieving his object soon after when he banged the ball just over the bar; but taking it altogether the game had quietened down considerably from the earlier stages, and exciting incidents were now few and far between. The crowd were quick to recognise this, and in response tot heir appeals the home team once more made a vigorous attack, Bell just missing the desired haven, and Robinson having to save from Sharp. Just before the interval Small Heath livened up again, but they met with a staunch and sturdy defence and when the interval arrived Everton were still leading by a goal to nothing. On the whole, it had been an interesting display, with Everton fully deserving their lead of a goal. For a brief space after resuming they looked like keeping it up, Goldie getting the ball away when another goal looked uncommonly likely. Then the visitors seemed to fairly pull themselves together, and commenced a series of aggressive movements, any of which might have ended in their drawing level. In fact it was very similar to the play at the same end in the opening half, with, of course, the position of the teams reversed. More than once it seemed a good shade of odds on a goal, but something or someone, generally Balmer, turned up at the critical moment and prevented the fulfilment of the Heathens’ hopes. Leake came nearest to actually finding the net, but Kitchen was all there when the shot came, as time went on and the Small Heath men failed to utilise favourable opportunities the somewhat depressed spirits of the onlookers gradually brightened. But it was indeed an anxious time for the home lot, and there was no getting away from the desperate character of the visitors’ attack. Once over, Balmer headed out a particularly hot one from McMillan, whilst in the next minute Kitchen had again to save as the ball came grandly across from Athersmith, and was promptly banged into goal. As will have been gathered, for quite a long period play had bene almost entirely confined to the home quarters. Once or twice the Everton front rank broke away, but it was getting well on towards “time” when they again began to play in something like business fashion, a pretty bit of work by Bell and Settle meriting and receiving much applause. The struggle continued keen and exciting right to the close. Naturally enough the home defenders didn’t hesitate to kick out whenever their lines in danger. The Heathens continued to struggle in manly fashion for an equalising point, but it was not to be, and when Mr. Sutcliffe gave the signal to cease hostilities Everton had won a fine game by 1 goal to nil.
If lacking in any extremely brilliant incidents, it was yet a game well worth witnessing. In the first twenty minutes or so it looked as if the home team would win by four of five goals, as there was simply no holding them. In the second half matters were quite the reverse, and for a long time Small Heath were distinctly the better team, and with a shade of luck and a bit better judgement near goal might easily have drawn level. At the same time the Everton defence was sound in the extreme and better work than Balmer accomplished I have not seen for a long time. Eccles too, did well, though once or twice he found Athersmith too fast for him. At half-back Booth was in capital form, his placing being especially good, whilst he never ceased to persevere whenever the speedy men opposed to him by any means got away. Abbott also seemed to revel in upsetting the plans of his comrades, whilst on the right wing Wolstenholme got through a lot of work in effective fashion. The front rank seemed to work in fits and starts. Early on they seemed irresistible, and the goal of Bell’s was a gem in its way. But they had a very slack time midway through the game. Settle and Bell put in many pretty touches; Young kept his wings fairly well together; and Sharp and Proudfoot were often dangerous; but the line as a whole were many times very weak near goal, some of the attempts to find the net being almost indicrous. They won of course, so that criticism is disarmed to some extent, but for all that I do not think the Everton forwards were quite up to what one expects from a team with strong hopes of carrying off the championship. As for the Heathens, they for a time seemed thoroughly upset by the goal scored in the first few minutes and looked all over a beaten team. Afterwards they rallied finely, and gave a very clever and taking exhibition. There is no doubt they are a real good side, and will want a lot of beating whoever they come across. At full back Goldie was by far the most successful, and Archer did not play nearly so well as I had been led to expect. Still, all men are off colour occasionally. At half the team is exceptionally strong. Leake is a sticker indeed, and withal such a cheery fellow and good captain that no wonder everyone likes him. Wigmore, at centre-half, got through a tremendous amount of work in most taking style, and the ex-Gainsborough player is well worth his place in any company. So far as the forwards are concerned, I liked the left wing a long way the best. Wharton and McMillan were always on the go, despite Balmer’s brilliant defence, but on the other wing Athersmith got comparatively few changes, and I was not at all struck with his partner’s show. In the centre, McRoberts was often prominent with tricky and skilful play, and against a less experienced centre half than Booth he would be indeed a dangerous customer. It was a thoroughly pleasant game, and I was glad to notice that fouls were mainly conspicuous by their absence.
OSWALDTWISTLE ROVERS 3 EVERTON RESERVES 1
November 25 1901. The Liverpool Courier
Lancashire Combination
At Oswaldtwistle. Everton scored through Platt slipping when attempting to save. The home team equalised from a corner, Stewart heading through. Keeping up the pressure, the home team put on a second goal, Fletcher banging the ball through. When pressed Oswaldtwistle displayed splendid form, and from a capital centre by Longworth Fletcher dashed through a third. Half time Rovers 3 goals, Everton 1. In the second half the sides adopted the kick and rush tactics, and no more goals were score. Everton: - Muir, goal, Sharp, and Watson, backs, Brown, Boyle (captain), and Blythe, half-backs, Roche, Paterson, Rankin Chadwick (j), and Singleton forwards.
A LUCKY VICTORY FOR EVERTON
Birmingham Daily Gazette - Monday 25 November 1901
The weather in Birmingham on Saturday morning was all that could be desired for football, but as the London and North-Western express bowled along towards Liverpool fears arose in my mind that the visit of the Small Heath team to Goodison Park would end in a similar fiasco to that which occurred at Coventry Road and elsewhere a week ago, for the fog was so dense at Runcorn that one could not see more than a few yards. Fortunately Liverpool escaped, and though the afternoon was dull, by kicking off about five minutes earlier than the time fixed it was just possible to get through the game. Small heath made themselves favourites in Liverpool by their play at Anfield a few weeks ago, and as Everton brought off a coup at Sunderland the week before it was not surprising to see a crowd of something like 20,000 people present. The good opinion secured by Everton at Roker Park looked like being confirmed in the early part of the match at the expense of Small Heath. Securing a lucky goal- we say lucky goal because opinions were very much divided as to its legitimacy -three minutes from the start as the result of a free kick, the home team made the visitors look very small indeed by the superiority of their tactics. To use a vulgarism, Everton were “all over” small Heath for the first half hour. Their forward and half-back play was delightful, lacking only in one particular to make it perfection. That shortcoming was, however, the most important one of shooting for goal. It may appear strange, but it is none the less a fact that in spite of all this marked superiority of Everton they only gave Robinson a couple of shots to handle before the whistle blew for the interval. Ten minutes before half-time Small Heath became more settled, and made several promising attempts on the home goal, an improving feature, so far as the visitors were concerned, which was more than maintained in the latter half of the proceedings. As a matter of fact, the brilliance of the Everton professors was dimmed- one might almost say it was put out- by the vigour and skill of the Small Heath defenders, and it became the turn of the visiting forwards to show the crowd how good combination could bring danger to an opponents’ goal. This last half was, indeed, most exciting and interesting, and Everton were sorely pressed to keep their charge from downfall, the ball very frequently being recklessly kicked out of play in the last few minutes. Mr. Clayton, the Everton chairman, only voiced a pretty unanimous opinion when he said that Small Heath were a very fine team who had given a capital display. Unfortunately they did not get their deserts, for they well deserved to divide the points, and I should imagine the winners will look back upon Saturday’s match as one in which Dame Fortune was exceedingly kind to them, Everton were represented by a capable and well-balanced eleven- probably the best eleven Small Heath have met this season. Watson was an absentee as back, Eccles taking his place, and Balmer must be accorded full honours in this division for some excellent defensive work. At the same time, he has a dangerous method of clearing the ball which we did not like, and which some opponents are bound to resent. Abbott was about the best of the three very good half-backs, combing better with his forwards than either. Booth a=or Wolstenholme, Settle and Bell made the better wings, their play in the first half hour being splendid, but Young was a centre-forward with the right ideas, and Sharp, well fed by Proudfoot, often got in a dangerous run and centre from outside right. Kitchen had slightly more work to do than Robinson, but neither goalkeeper was highly tried. The whole of the Small heath players are to be commended for playing their powerful opponents so strong a game. I rather fancy Everton were a bit surprised at the stout resistance of the promoted Second Leaguers. Archer was in great form at back, punting with strength and judgement and tackling effectively, while Goldie in a quieter way rendered good service to his side. Wigmore was the best half-back, taking the game all through, if indeed he was not the best half-back on the field. Leake came in a good second, a little unsteadiness in the first half losing him first place, and Adey was at his best near the close of the game, when his bustling tactics were often successful. With Wharton and McMillan back again the front rank gave a better show than they have done for some time. McRoberts was the pick of the line, but Athersmith and McMillan did some excellent work, the latter having hard luck in the last ten minutes in not equalising with a grand shot that was luckily- for Everton- intercepted by an opponent’s head. Bennett made a fairly good inside right, and Wharton had too much attention paid him to be as dangerous as usual. It is the best game Small Heath have played for some weeks, and Sunderland may expect a hard match at Coventry Road next Saturday if this form is maintained.
EVERTON v SMALL HEATH
Liverpool Mercury - Monday 25 November 1901
These teams met at Goodison Park for the first time this season, before an attendance numbering nearly 20,000 persons. Both sides were represented by their strongest combinations. Everton started, and after three minutes’ play Young was fouled just outside the penalty line. The free kick was nicely placed, and Bell dashing up scored the only goal of the match. For some time the Everton forwards could not be kept in check, and the visitors’ defence was severely taxed. Several shots were sent in, but most were charged down ere they reached the custodian, and eventually the siege was raised. A smart run by Athersmith gave McRoberts an opening, but he shot over, whilst a dashing dribble by McMillan was ended by Bennett sending against the net. There was no further scoring up to half-time, but immediately on resuming Everton ran down, and Robinson saved in the goal mouth from a host of opponents, who had brought him to the ground. The visitors gradually improved, and Adey shot wide from a favourable position. At the other end, Settle and Young were faulty in shooting, and the Heathens afterwards brought considerable pressure to bear on the home goal. Balmer defended grandly, and Kitchen was therefore rarely troubled. Try as they would, the Midlanders could make no impression, and the result was;- Everton 1 Small Heath 0. Everton.—Kitchen, goal; Balmer and Eccles, backs; Wolstenholme, Booth (Captain), and Abbott, half backs: Sharp, Proudfoot, Young, Settle, and Bell, forwards. Small Heath.—Robinson, goal; Archer and Goldie, backs; Leake (Captain), Wigmore, and Adey, half backs; Wharton, McMillan, McRoberts, Bennett, and Athersmith, forwards.
EVERTON v SMALL HEATH
Liverpool Daily Post - Monday 25 November 1901
Played Goodison Park, before about 15.000 spectators. The teams were Everton.—Kitchen, goal; Balmer and Eccles, backs; Wolstenholme, Booth (Captain), and Abbott, half backs: Sharp, Proudfoot, Young, Settle, and Bell, forwards. Small Heath.—Robinson, goal; Archer and Goldie, backs; Leake (Captain), Wigmore, and Adey, half backs; Wharton, McMillan, McRoberts, Bennett, and Athersmith, forwards. Everton having lost the toss, Young started operations a couple of minutes before the advertised time. Sharp a couple of dashes, but on each occasion was pulled up by Archer, and three minutes after the commencement the game Everton had a free kick, from which Bell scored. From the centre Athersmith and his partner became very busy, and, after getting in front of Kitchen, were utterly routed by Eccles. On the other wing Wharton ran up, but Kitchen cleared well. Free kicks fell to either side, but neither proved of much advantage. Exceedingly pretty play by Young in the centre had the effect of pressing back the visitors. Bell at the finish coming in and shooting very strongly, the ball going high over the crossbar. Play for a time after this was contested in neutral ground, following which Small Heath attacked on the right and left,but did not become really dangerous. Bennett ultimately shot wide. From the goal kick the Everton left made rapid progress. Young making a futile bid for goal. Pretty exchanges between Sharp, Proudfoot, and Young rendered matters very uncomfortable for the “Heathens,” Bell and Young each having abortive shies. The pressure by-Everton was kept up in praiseworthy fashion, the passes among the front rank being crisp and clean, and as a consequence the visiting defence was sorely troubled. Sharp gave Settle a chance, but he failed. Coming down again Abbott ran right through, and shot by the side of the post. Young had a "pop,” which again proved abortive, and a fugitive visit to Kitchen’s end was similarly fruitless. Play at this stage was not very exciting, and the only notable incident was a long; futile attempt by Young, Following this, the visitors had more of the game than previously, and numerous attempts by the Small Heath left wingers were made, but on each occasion they were attended to by Balmer in a workmanlike manner. Then they tried on the right, and were more successful. Eccles letting them in, and Bennett and McRoberts each having futile shots at goal. Beautiful passing by the Everton forwards was spoiled by Archer, but a moment later, Bell had a grand shot, which was well saved by Robinson, Settle finishing the move by shooting by the side the post. Play of a quiet nature ensued, and both sides failed to display that dash and energy which was expected of them. The spectators loudly shouted “Play up, Everton!” and in response to these appeals the home side became more spirited. At the other end Bell just missed, and Robinson saved from Sharp. Towards the close the first half the visitors attacked, but they could make no impression on the Everton defence.
Half-time: Everton. 1 goal; Small Heath, nil.
McRoberts resumed, and the light even at this early stage, was none of the best. The first move was made on the home right, but nothing came of it, and moment later the game was suspended on account of an injury to Young. On resuming, Everton took up the play, and a scrimmage occurred in the visitors’ goalmouth, but the home front side failed to pilot the sphere into the net, Goldie ultimately effecting a clearance. Midfield work of a quiet nature followed, after which Bell and Proudfoot tried an attacking move, which, however, was of no avail, Leake breaking up the combination, and the ball was driven outside. End to end play ensued, during which Athersmith found himselfwell placed, but lost the leather over the' touch-line. After a spell of even work Small Heath attacked in spited style, Balmer displaying great form in checking the fast rushes of the opposing front-rank whilst clearances were of advantage to his-side. After Eccles had pulled up Bennett and Athersmith, the Heathens again returned to the attack, but their attempts to score were very mediocre. A pretty bit of work between Bell and Settle ensued, the former centring very finely. But Sharp could not get at the sphere, Goldie clearing. Balmer headed away very hot shot in splendid fashion, but the Midlanders would not be beaten back, and a free kick to them looked ominous from an Evertonian point of view. The only result, however, was an abortive corner, Kitchen effecting a magnificent save. The remaining stages of the were difficult to follow on account of the failing light. Final result: Everton. 1 goal, Small Heath nil.
FOOTBALL NOTES
The Liverpool Daily Post- Monday, November 25, 1901
By their victory over Small Heath-a close one, it must be admitted-Everton now stand two points in advance of Sunderland, who at present occupy second position in the League tourney. Recently the Goodison Park team have had a good run of luck in the competition, and it is some consolation to find they have got back to the fine form which distinguished their play in the first month of the season. When in the mood they can give as fine an exposition of football as any team in the country, but unfortunately they are not always moved to that desire. They gave a grand display on Saturday against the dashing Midland combination led by Athersmith, who turned a stubborn defence on the Everton attack, and so close was the finish of the game that the final whistle of the referee came as a positive relief. The match could have been lost to Everton almost at any period of the game if the visitors had been favoured with the smallest possible bit of luck; for one thing their shooting was decidedly bad- probably spoiled by anxiety. Young has improved a lot in his work at centre, and makes a capital pivot for his wings and shows excellent discernment, especially in playing to Bell and Settle, whom he appears to mainly depend upon for results. It ought to have been more than a one goal victory, and in this respect the visitors came off very fortunate as many of the clearances were merely accidental. However, the early goal by Bell gave Everton two points, and if a dozen goals had bene booked the victory could not have counted more.
EVERTON SUPRPRISED
Athletic News - Monday 25 November 1901
LANCASHIRE COMBINATION
Oswaldtwistle Rovers surprised even themselves by the smart manner in which they defeated Everton Reserve, the Combination leaders. Three goals to one was the result, and, moreover, the victory, even by such a majority, was deserved. Matters looked none too rosy for the Rovers when Everton scored the first goal within ten minutes from the opening. But from then up to half-time there was only one team in it, and that was not the “Toffee” representatives. After a couple of corners, Pope headed the first goal for the home team, and immediately after Fletcher scored a second, and the same player put on a third- the best of the match. In the second half the visitors adopted the kick-and-rush game, but try as they would they could not penetrate the Rovers’ Watson, Boyle, Roche, Chadwick and Patterson were the best. The home team was best represented by the defence, who played well to a man. Platt, the goalkeeper made many miraculous saves. Of the forwards, Fletcher and Longworth were the best.
EVERTON STILL LEADING
Athletic News - Monday 25 November 1901
By Harricus
By their exceedingly clever victory at Sunderland Everton placed themselves at the head the pf the League table, and on Saturday they further strengthened their position as leaders by beating Small Heath at Goodison Park by one goal to nothing, not a great margin certainly, but sufficient to give them the two points. There was, of course, a great crowd welcome the conquerors of Sunderland, 15,000 paying for admission, so that there have been 17,000 spectators, and this despite the fact that there was a certain amount of fog to be contended with, which caused therefereeto start the game five minutes before the advertised time kick-off. It was as well that he did so, as the light was none too good in the closing stages. So far I could see both teams were at their best strength, and a good game was anticipated.
THE ONLY GOAL
The match was destined to be won and lost in the first five minutes, for that period had scarcely been completed when the only goal of the afternoon was notched. It was an easy and yet a good goal. A free kick had been given against Small Heath about 25 yards from goal. When it was taken every Evertonian was marked except Bell, who was evidently not considered dangerous enough in has old age. This was just where the mistake was made, for the unexpected happened, and Bell made no mistake of the opportunity,which was presented to him, for he scored a goal in splendid fashion. Small Heath put in a claim for offside, but many good judges, including the President of the League, were of the opinion that the referee's decision was quite correct. The game was very evenly contested after this, Everton showing the better football, though their opponents were always dangerous when under weigh, and the smartest piece of work of the day was accomplished by McRoberts, who skipped opponents' feet and danced round them in so tantalising a fashion that the only way to rob him was to commit a breach of the law governing fouls. The second half was just as interesting as the first, the “Heathens” commencing in a manner winch showed that though the score was against them they were not disheartened, but for all that they had submit to a defeat, for kitchen kept his charge intact to the end of the game.
A CRITICISM
The game was sufficiently interesting to keep the crowd from expressing disapproval, yet there were never any of those really exciting incidents which rouse the enthusiasm of a big crowd to a high pitch. Personally I enjoyed the hour and half, despite the absence of too much of what is known as the Aston Villa finesse. Everton people, one would doubtless be satisfied so long as themaximum number of points accrued, while I should fancy that Small Heath will consider that they did not do so badly to run the leaders to a goal at home, even though they do hold an opinion which does not tally with that of the referee that that one goal was not of the genuine order. The “Heathens” attack; perhaps not so nippy as in the days of Hallam, Walton, Mobley, Wheldon, and Hands, but all round they are a very serviceable side, and I should fancy that they left a good impression behind them. The goalkeeper is not the star he has been made out, but both backs shape well, and though Archer was the better of the pair Goldie would surprise his old Liverpool friends with his display. By the way. what a stumpy lot the “Heathens” are, to be sure. Their all white costume doubtless made their bulk all the more apparent, but Archer is almost as broad as he is long. So, too, is Adey and one or two others. Adey, by the way, played a vigorous game at right half. Wigmore, too, was here, there, and everywhere, and Alex Leake completed a very useful trio. Of the forwards Athersmith showed that he is not so nimble as he was, though Bennett, his lengthy partner, did his best for him. McRoberts was pretty fair in the centre with some class work, and though the strong left wing possessed by the “Heathens” was better than right they were not overpowering.
THE WINNERS
Everton are evidently an improving side, and I don’t suppose they will give up the position of honour yet awhile. Kitchen is a good goalkeeper, and I don’t know who is the better man, he or Muir. Balmer is one of the best right backs in England, and will be a candidate for International honours while Eccles plays football as it shouldbe played, gentlemanly and clean. He is certainly a better man than Watson. Perhaps the strength of the side is in the half-back division, and in Wolstenholme, Booth,and Abbott the club have the best trio at their disposal, and should make no charges. They play the half-back game as is should be played. The forwards gave a much better display than I have seen from them previously this season. For one thing Young is improving as a centre forward, which I am pleased to write, for he did not impress me greatly when I first saw him. He plays good football, and has no tricks which would bring him under the ban of the referee. Then, too, both Sharp and Settle played up to their reputation, which is something beyond the ordinary. Bell was not noticeable; for one thing he was not fed too much, but as he scored the goals which gained his side two points any failings will be excused. The teams were—
Everton.- Kitchen; Balmer, Eccles; Wolstenholme, Booth (Captain), Abbott; Sharp, Proudfoot, Young, Settle, and Bell.
Small heath.- Robinson; Archer, Goldie; Leake (Captain), Wigmore, Adey; Wharton, McMillan, McRoberts, Bennett, and Athersmith. Referee; C.E. Sutcliffe, Rawtenstall.
LIVERPOOL AND DISTRICT NOTES
Athletic News - Monday 25 November 1901
By the Loiterer
Owing to some accident when arranging the Lancashire Combination fixtures both our clubs were away in East Lancashire—and in passing I say Everton were beaten by OswaldtwistleRovers and Liverpool by Burnley—so that the Anfield ground was for once in a way at liberty. But not for long, as the Liverpool Casuals soon obtained permission to play the Brighton Tower Amateurs an I Zingari League match. The Town Amateurs would be quite at ease on the classic turf, as they disport themselves when at home on quite as up to date a ground, for the Tower enclosure wants lot of beating. I notice the match resulted in a draw two goals each, and speaking of the Casuals this act on the part of the Liverpool F.C.. or, to be more correct. Mr. Houlding, is only one of many kindnesses the club have received at their hands. Two reasons ago they were banished from their old pitch, and had to trek out Arkles Lane way, but could not find shelter, and so, of course, Mr. Houlding was approached, and they dress at the Sandon Hotel of historic fame.
EVERTON STILL ON TOP
Football Chat and Athletic World- Tuesday, November 26, 1901
A SPLENDID GAME AT GOODISON
By Merseyman
The Everton—Small Heath match drew a splendid gathering at Goodison. The cause was a twofold one. First, Everton had a week before secured a brilliant, and likewise totally unexpected, victory at Sunderland, thereby depriving the Wearsiders of the League leadership; second, Small Heath had served up spirited and interesting football when at Anfield Road earlier in the season, and in general have subsequently proved themselves well up to the requirements of a recognised first-class organisation. The Toffees stuck to the team which covered itself with glory on the banks of the Wear, but Small Heath came with a slightly organised side. Thus Walton, their veteran half-right, gave way to an all-round man in Adey, who had previously assisted the Midlanders to pick up five out of a possible six points against the two united clubs of Division 1. and Notts Forest. Forward, their chief goal scorer, Aston, was dropped. Jones this time was not selected as his successor, the choice falling upon Bennett, who had been off League duty ever since the Heathens opening match with Liverpool on September 1. Bennett is an extremely tall 'un, and is considered one of the most speedy men in the League. Outside-right is his recognised position, however, and it was the injury sustained by Bennett in this Liverpool match which made it necessary for the Coventry Road management to hurry on negotiations with the Villa for Athersmith's transfer. Amongst the interested onlookers, it may be mentioned was none other than the respected League president, Mr. J. J. Bentley. Those who arrived on the scene a minute after the advertised tine for the commencement of operations curiously enough missed the one goal of the match, which was obtained by Jack Bell in a rather unexpected manner from a free kick. Bell. by-the-by, twice found the net for Everton in their opening match v. Manchester City, since which he has not once experienced the pleasing sensation of providing a " finishing touch" until the highly valuable point now under notice. Thus the mammoth crowd was early placed on very satisfactory terms with itself. Directly the ball had been restarted the game raged terrifically fast, and the Evertonians particularly appeared to move in their very finest style. The backs cleared out the visiting vanguard as cleanly as that were well-nigh possible, although Booth and his line companions but seldom allowed Wharton and Co. to I seriously menace Kitchen's citadel. Then, at the other end of the picture, Sharp, Proudfoot, and Settle were time and oft responsible for really plaudit-drawing manoeuvrings, which took an immensity of coping with—so much so, in fact, that it redounds to the credit of the Midlanders rear-guarders that a second goal, at least, was denied the League leaders. For quite a lengthy period Everton monopolised the honours, and a more decided lead to them looked extremely imminent. As the interval approached the game became a little more even in character, but not one whit more interesting, for the ball had incessantly been kept on the move. At last, however, that speed-merchant Wharton was witnessed careering along at lightning rate, with Balmer in close attendance, and the former finished up with a characteristic centre, which, however, was robbed of more than half its usual danger in consequence of Balmer's well timed "nudge." Athersmith, on the other extreme, several times got in rather ominous centres, but the interval arrived with Everton a well-earned goalin front. The second half for a considerable period witnessed less exciting scenes, and at this stage the referee l thought was scarcely happy in one or two rulings, and this marred to some extent the pleasure one likes to derive from a First Division League match. In contradistinction to their exhibition when at Anfield Road, the Heathens improved as time advanced, and it because patent that Everton must be up and doing if that one goal was to suffice. McMillan on one occasion propelled a really magnificent shot, but Balmer, who was hero of the day, intercepted it, as he did later, with his head, when all else were beaten, and the hall was about to enter the far corner of the net. Right to the end the pace was a trimmer, but nothing Further in the goal-scoring line, Everton winning deservedly, although narrowly, their fourth victory in succession. It was Everton's best home exhibition of the season, and those who averred at the close of the Stoke match ( I noticed them in their usual places again!) that they had spent their last “tanner" on Everton, must have gone home satisfied on this occasion. Balmer, as aforesaid, was the hero of the day, his performance overshadowing that of Crompton (Rovers) here recently. Abbott and, Wolstenholme played finely at half, and Sharp, Settle, and Proudfoot were the best of the forwards. Mention of Everton's " finest performance, &c.," 'must be taken as a compliment to Small Heath, who are a rattling good lot. Of this good lot commend me on Saturday's form to Goldie Archer, Wigmore, Bennett, and McMillan. Result:— Everton 1 Small Heath 0 Attendance, 20,000. Teams.—Everton: Kitchen; Balmer and Eccles ; Wolstenholme, Booth, and Abbott; J. Sharp, Proudfoot, Young, Settle, and Bell. Small Heath: Robinson; Goldie and Archer; Adey, Wigmore, and Leake ; Athersmith, Bennett, McRoberts, McMillan, and Wharton.Referee: Mr. C. E. Sutcliffe, Burnley.
ANOTHER SCOTTISH FOOTBALL SENSATION.
Dundee Evening Post - Wednesday 27 November 1901
JOHN GILLESPIE TO PLAY FOR EVERTON
A BLOW TO AMATEURISM.
A Glasgow football correspondent writes that he is informed, on the authority of well-known personage at Hampden Park, that John Gillespie has signed a League form for Everton. Mr Gillespie returned from the front some six months back, after serving with the Imperial Yeomanry. In the Queen's Own Yeomanry he gained a reputation for daring horsemanship at the annual race meeting on the Ducal policies, and on the football field his courage was not the least pronounced feature of his play at half-back and back. He never allowed an opponent much rope, and in form was hard to beat. Always of an obliging disposition, he turned out for Queen's Park on many occasions when the ordinary player would have rested for weeks. But Gillespie is of the type that can always battle tbicugh somehow, and was a matter surprise to the grand stand patrons if he appeared on Hampden Park free of the trainer's bandages. He never spared himself while playing for Queen's Park, and was one of the pillars of the team during a spell of adversity. We understand the popular Yeoman will continue to play as an amateur. He has figured in the Q.P. team on few occasions this season, but with training seems as fit as ever to play an effective game. Coming so close as does after M'Coll's departure from Scotland, this announcement will cause a great sensation in Scottish football circles.
NEW BACKFOREVERTON
Liverpool Evening Express - Wednesday 27 November 1901
Important Capture. (SPECIAL TELEGRAM.)
Following on the departure of McColl and Stewart to Newcastle Queen’s Park supporters were somewhat surprised to-day on reading the statement that John Gillespie, the stalwart amateur back, had signed a League form for Everton. It is trusted that the calls of the Everton Club on him will be few, as the Glasgow club is likely to need his services for the Scottish ties. Gillespie recently returned from South Africa, where he served a term in the Yeomanry, and is very fit at present.
NEW PLAYER FOR EVERTON
November 28 1901. The Liverpool Mercury
Following on the departure of McColl and Stewart to Newcastle, Queens Park supporters were somewhat surprised yesterday on realizing that a statement that John Gillespie the Stalwart amateur back, had signed a League form for Everton. It is heard that the call of the Everton on him will be few, as the Glasgow club is likely to need his service for the Scottish cup-ties. Gillespie recently returned from South Africa when he served a term in the Yeomary, he is very fit at present.
EVERTON’S NEW BACK
Liverpool Daily Post - Thursday 28 November 1901
Following on the departures of McColl and Stewart to Newcastle, the Queen’s Park supporters were somewhat surprised yesterday on reading the statement that John Gillespie, the stalwart amateur back, had signed a League form for Everton. It is trusted that the calls of the Everton club on him will be few, as the Glasgow club is likely to need his services for the Scottish ties. Gillespie recently returned from South Africa, where he served a term in the Yeomanry, and is a very fit at present.
John Gillespie
Sunderland Daily Echo November 30 1901
It is stated that John Gillespie, theb Queen's Park footballer, who recently returned from the war, has signed a League form for Everton. He will play as an amateur.
TODAYS TEAM NEWS
Liverpool Daily Post - Saturday 30 November 1901
EVERTON v DERBY COUNTY
At Derby; Central Station 9.35; Kick-off 2,30
Everton;- Kitchen, goal; Balmer and Eccles, backs; Wolstenholme, Booth, and Abbott, half-backs; Sharp, Taylor, Young, Settle, and Bell, forwards.
EVERTOM COMBINATION v ACCRINGTON STANLEY
Everton; Muir, goal; Sharp, and Watson, backs; Boyle, Clarke, and Blythe, half-backs; Roche, Paterson, Rankin, Bone, and Singleton, forwards.
EVERTON v DERBY COUNTY
The Liverpool Football Echo- Saturday November 30 1901
EVERTON LEAD AT HALF-TIME BUT GET BADLY BEATEN
The Everton team travelled to Derby this morning in order to meet the County Club. The weather was fine and mild, and an excellent game was anticipated, inasmuch as the visitors had generally done well on the baseball ground. The Midland town was reached in good time, and the players were given ample leisure to view the sights of the place before turning their attention to business. There was one change from last week in the composition of the team, Taylor, now recovered, making a tardy reappearance as a partner for Jack Taylor, while Proudfoot of course, stood down. The home eleven were represented by their best available strength. Prompt to time, the men lined up as follows; Everton;- Kitchen, goal; Balmer and Eccles, backs; Wolstenholme, Booth (Captain) and Abbott, half-backs; Sharp, Taylor, Young, Settle, and Bell, forwards.
Derby County;.- Fryer, goal; Methven and Morris, backs; May, Goodall, and Leckie, half-backs; A, Warren, Bloomer, Boag, B. Warren, and Middleton, forwards. Referee; Mr. J. Adams.
There were about 10,000 people present when Everton having lost the toss, kicked off against a stiff breeze. After the opening exchanges Sharp was prominent on the right wing, but Morris checked and the home eleven at once made ground, May sending in a long, dropping shot which fell into Kitchen’s arms. Balmer lent additional and in clearing, and a nice piece of work ended in Booth sending in a long shot, which Fryer succeeded in throwing away. After this the visitors still paid attention to the Derby custodian, but without success, and then a breakaway on the home right nearly ended in disaster, for May again sent in a fine shot, which was cleared rather luckily. A brief spell of midfield work ended in the Derby forwards again swooping down upon Kitchen with terrific force, and Bloomer from short range sent the ball only a few inches wide of the mark. After this the Everton left wing was extremely busy. Bell on two occasions being prominent, but Settle was unable to profit by the centres. Continuing the attack, the visitors pressed the home defence, and Taylor sent in a fine shot which Fryer dealt with very cleverly. The County men at length asserted themselves and both Balmer and Eccles were for a time given plenty to do, but the former eventually cleared by a huge punt, and for some time subsequently play was contested in midfield. The home forwards gradually worked their way down, and Ben Warren sent in a swift low shot, which Kitchen got rid of every smartly. The Everton men were now playing an exceedingly strong game, and a break-away on thew right ended in a warm passing beautifully to Boag, who shot in at top speed, but to the astonishment of the crowd, Kitchen got his foot to the ball and cleared. The spectators were not slow to appreciate this wonderfully smart bit of play, and they cheered the Everton custodian lustily. Meanwhile country men were continuing their attentions, and both Balmer and Eccles were more than once clearly beaten, inaccurate shooting alone saving the visitors from disaster. At length the Evertonians got down, and Young tried a shot, but the attempt was very feeble, and it was not long before the home forwards were again swarming round. Kitchen. A Warren ran the ball along the wing and shot towards goal, and Boag rushed up the ball into the net, but the referee for some reason not quite apparent ruled the man off-side. In any case it was a let-off for Everton for the defence was certainly outplayed. The game now slowed down somewhat and after some uninteresting play the visitors moved along. Booth, from log range shooting over the bar. The Derby left then got away and Balmer was forced to give a corner which was safely negotiated. The next movements went in favour of Everton, Taylor and Sharp putting in some good work, but, as usual, it quite lacked the necessary finishing touch, and consequently nothing came of it. Settle on two occasions tried his luck, but Methven held him in check, and the first really dangerous shot came from Sharp, who sent in a clinker, which Fryer very cleverly put outside. It was not long before the home contingent were again busy, the front line advancing in fine combined array, which terminated in Boag sending in a swift low shot, which Kitchen saved with marvellous skill. After some midfield work the visitors again asserted themselves and a centre by Sharp was followed by Young and Fryer struggling for possession, the County goalkeeper just getting the better of the argument and throwing clear. A free kick in favour of Derby close in led to some exciting work, but Eccles finally cleared, and after an ineffective sprint on the part of Bell and Settle the home front line again return to the attack, Ben Warren sending in a fine shot, which Kitchen dealt with admirably. So far the game had been greatly in favour of the County team, and the visitors had only their goalkeepers to thank for continued immunity from disaster. The Evertonians at last weakened up, and moving along the left, Settle got between Methven and Morris, and netted the ball five minutes before the interval. This reverse stirred the County men to greater energy, and they literally bombarded the Everton goal, but the backs more by good luck than good management, contrived to keep the ball out, and the interval arrived.
Half-time score Everton 1 goal, Derby County Nil
In the beginning of the second half Everton went off with a great dash. Young twice sending in at long range, while on another occasion Bell came within an ace of scoring. After this, however, Derby awakened up, and from a splendid, combined attack Boag equalised. This gave the County renewed vigour and it was not long before Bloomer added a second goal. The following stages of the play were all in favour of the home team, who literally made rings round their opponents, and before the final arrived a third goal was added. All things considered, the County were the much better team, and fully deserved their victory. Final Result; Derby County 3 goals, Everton 1 goal
EVERTON COMBINATION v ACCRINGTON STANLEY
The Liverpool Football Echo- Saturday, November 30, 1901
LANCASHIRE COMBINATION
By Pigeon Post
Fresh interest manifested itself in this match at Goodison Park this afternoon, inasmuch as Accrington have not suffered defeat this season, and there was consequently a good attendance present when the following teams turned out. Everton.- Muir, goal; Sharp and Watson, backs; Boyle, Clarke, and Blythe, half-backs; Roche, Paterson, Rankin, Bone, and Singleton, forwards.
Accrington;- Walker, goal; Finney and Hardman, backs; D. Ashworth, Bradshaw, and Kenyon, half-backs; Wilmington, L. Ashworth, Oldham, Hargreaves, and Gardner, forwards. Accrington won the toss, Rankin starting for Everton the home team from the outset attacking. A free kick against Everton relieved the pressure, and Hargreaves defeated Muir who made a good attempt to save, hurting himself in falling. A cessation of players took place for a few minutes and after this the home custodian had been attended to put he some resumed. Both ends were visited in turn the backs on either side defending well. Everton forced a corner, Clarke heading wide. For fouling Paterson, Finney was penalised, but the ensuing free kick was cleared. A warm attack on the visitors goal was next witnessed, Singleton shooting in strongly. Paterson then got possession and sent in a good shot, Walker making a fine save. Singleton put the score level with a clever shot, which struck the bar and rebounded into the net. Both teams stove hard to get the lead, the Accrington forwards showed up to advantage on several times, Everton got close in, but failed to score. Half-time 1 goal each.
Full time; Everton Combination 2 Accrington Stanley 1.
OSWALDTWISTLE ROVERS v. EVERTON RESERVE
Haslingden Gazette - Saturday 30 November 1901
Played at Oswaldtwistle on Saturday afternoon in the presence of a good attendance. Teams;-
Rovers;- Platt, goal; Smith and Hargreaves, backs; Cunliffe, Livesey, and Calverley, half-backs; McGhee, Fletcher (right), Stewart (centre), Pope and Longworth (left), forwards.
Everton; Muir, goal; Sharp and Watson, backs; Brown, Boyle and Blythe, half-backs; Roche, Patterson (right), Rankin (centre), Chadwick, and Singlton (left), forwards. The home team won the toss, and Everton kicked off downhill. The Rovers commenced with ten men, but Calverley appeared after five minutes. The Rovers worked an opening, but Longworth slipped when shooting, and the ball went wide. Boyle then scored with a long shot, which Platt could not reach, and a minute later a long shot from Singleton dropped on the top of the net. The Rovers were applauded for some nice combination, and still pressing, they gained a corner, which Longworth placed behind. Another corner was secured, from which the Everton goal had a narrow escape. Fletcher shooting wide. Muir caught and threw out a beautiful long shot from Cunliffe. The home team were outplaying the visitors, and Muir again had to be smart to clear his lines. A nice opening was made by and Fletcher tested Muir. Everton got away, and Patterson missed a lovely chance. Going away again, Stewart did some good work, and the gained a corner, from which Stewart equalised. The home team again made for goal, and Fletcher banged a second goal through. Soon afterward. Sharp was lucky to stop a shot from Pope. McGhee and Fletcher on the home right played fine football. The visitors then took upthe running, but Smith and Hargreaves were equal to all demands. Again the home team gained the upper hand, and from a centre by Longworth Fletcher again put the ball into the net. Play opened out somewhat, and Everton troubled the home defence a little, but Platt made a marvellous save from a lightning shot. In the first instance he was only able to knock the ball down to the feet of ail opponent, but Ihe dashed out and turned the shot out, Half-time—Oswaldtwistle 3, Everton Reserves 1. On resuming Everton attacked, and Platt had to clear three hot shots in as many minutes. Everton went down on several occasion, but shot wildly. Boyle oncesending yards over. Everton had adopted entirely different tacti, and went in for rushing. Cunliffe made a capital effort with a long shot, and then Longworth sent a fast one just wide of the upright. Everton quickly dashed to the other end, and Patterson shot hard and fast, only to see Platt again distinguish himself. The siege ended by Patterson shooting right across the goal Play down somewhat. The Everton right played a big game, but Hargreaves was always a thorn in their side. Cunliffe intercepted some passes very cleverly. Smith cleared in fine style when Everton looked like scoring. Platt kept goal remarkably well, and saved a hot shot from Rankin which seemed certain to find the billet. Everton strove desperately to score. Longworth made a fine run, but was harassed when shooting. Sharp raised the ire of the crowd by fouling in a nasty fashion. Final: Oswaldtwistle 3: Everton Reserve 1.
OUR PORTRAIT GALLERY
Southern Echo - Saturday 30 November 1901
JOE TURNER A POPULAR SOUTHAMPTON PLAY
I fancy ! hear someone saying “Joe Turner has appeared in the gallery before;” so he has, and twice to my knowledge, but under different circumstances and in other poses. The above sketch is taken from one of the latest photos taken of the popular outside left by Mr. F. G. O. Stewart, of Southampton, and is, I venture to assert, an excellent likeness for a newspaper portrait printed on an exceedingly rapid machine. There is no need for me to recapitulate facts about Joe's birth-place, age, height, weight, and all those other items which go to make interviews so monotonously alike. Everyone in Southampton who follows the winter game knows all about Joe, and don’t need any reminder. There are thousands who will remember with delight those dear old days on the County Ground when Joe Turner and Wattie Keay used to provide exhibitions of the most superb football equal to these shown by any international wing I have seen of late years. Would that Wattie were as young and agile now as then! Great Scott, what a left wing we should have! I think Joe would be the first to admit that his best football has been played with the Saints ; in fact, I am one of the many who aver that Wattie Keay made him the great player he undoubtedly Is. After being the popular idol for some time Joe forsook his old love and went to Stoke, and thence to Everton, but with neither of these combinations did he show that dash and skill which always characterised his play for the Saints, but, nevertheless, we down South were very glad when we heard that he was returning to the Saintly fold, and hearty indeed was the welcome accorded the wanderer. — Although at first Joe seemed to have lost his old-time “devil” and skill, he is now, since a temporary. “rest,” whilst Harrison took his place, playing in tip-top form, and we have the opinion of the great Charles Fry that Turner is one of the fastest and most dashing wingers in the country. Edgar Chadwick and he have at last fallen into each other's style of play, and bid fair to make one of the most effective left wings in the country. A feature of Joe’s game at present is the smart manner in which he takes the long swinging centres of his namesake on the opposite wing, Arthur Turner to wit, and from these he has scored several goals already. There are thousands of enthusiasts in Hampshire who would like to see Joe “ capped.” I know he has an ambition that way, and that it may be realised this season is the heartfelt -wish of VECTIS.
