Blues 4, Whites 2
August 17, 1957
Practice Game
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. J. Mitchell
Goals; Temple (2), Williams (18), Harris (B) (55) ( ), Kirby (58), Keeley (80)
Teams
Blues (2-3-5) Dunlop (a); Donovan (d) (captain), Tansey (j); Birch (k), Jones (te), Meagan (m); McNamara (t) (J. Harris 45), Temple (d), Hickson (d), Fielding (w) (W Haughey 45), Harris (B) (G. Williams 45).
Whites (2-3-5); O’Neill (j) (g Griffiths 45), Sanders (a), Leeder (f) (B Griffiths 45); King (j), Labone (b), Farrell (p) (captain), Harris (j), Thomas (e), Kirby g), Haughey (w) (Mackey 45), Harris (b) (j Keeley 46)
Att 14,997

Everton 1, Wolverhampton Wanderers 0
August 24, 1957
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. G. Black
Goal; Harris (70) (Assist Temple)
Teams Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Donovan (d) (captain), Tansey (j); Birch (k), Jones (te), Meagan (m)(Debut, Everton junior) ; Harris (j), Temple (d), Hickson (d)(2nd Debut, signed from Huddersfield) , Fielding (w), Williams (g), Coach Ian Buchan
Wolverhampton Wanderers (2-3-5); Finlayson; Stewart, Harris (g); Clamp, Wright (captain), Flowers; Deeley, Booth, Murray, Broadbent, Mullen
Att 58,229

Manchester United 3, Everton 0
August 28, 1957
League Division One
Old Trafford
Goals; Taylor (44), Jones (te) (own goal 53), Violett (61)
Teams
Manchester United (2-3-5); Wood; Foulkes, Bryne (captain); Coleman, Blanchflower, Edwards; Berry, Whelan, Taylor (t), Violett, Pegg, manager Matt Busby
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Donovan (captain), Tansey (j); Birch (k), Jones (te), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Temple (d), Hickson (d), Fielding (w), Williams (g), Coach Ian Buchan
Att 59,103

Aston Villa 0, Everton 1
August 31, 1957
League Division One
Villa Park
Referee; Mr. G. Aston
Goal; Temple (23) (Assist Hickson)
Teams
Aston Villa (2-3-5); Simms; Lynn and Aldis; Crowther, Dugdale, Saward; Southern, Sewell, Myerscough, Dixon, McParland
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Donovan (d) (captain), Tansey (j); Birch (k), Jones (te), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Temple (d), Hickson (d), Fielding (w), Harris (b), Coach Manager Ian Buchan
Att 37,759

Everton 3, Manchester United 3
September 4, 1957
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee Mr. Westwood
Goals; Violett (13), Berry (30), Temple (38) (Assist –J Harris) (78) (Assist Hickson), Whelan (40), Harris (j) (58) (Assist Fielding).
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Donovan (d) (captain), Tansey (j); Birch (k), Jones (te), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Temple (d), Hickson (d), Fielding (w), Harris (b), Coach Ian Buchan
Manchester United (2-3-5); Wood; Foulkes, Byrne (captain); Coleman, Blanchflower, Edwards; Berry, Whelan, Taylor (t), Violett, Pegg, Manager Matt Busby
Att 72,077

Everton 3, Chelsea 0
September 7, 1957
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. R. Wood
Goals; Fielding (w) (assist Hickson), Temple (21) (assist B. Harris), Hickson (44) (assist J Harris)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Donovan (d) (captain), Tansey (j); Birch (k)(retired 50), Jones (te), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Temple (d), Hickson (d), Fielding (w), Harris (b), Coach Ian Buchan
Chelsea (2-3-5); Matthews; Sillett (p), Bellett; Mortimer, Dicks, Saunders; Brabrook, McNichols, Allen, Greaves (j), Lewis
Att 45,166

Arsenal 2, Everton 3
September 10, 1957.
League Division One
Hughbury
Goals; Harris (j) (26) (solo free kick), Hickson (36) (assist B Harris), Groves (37) (70), Fielding (89)
Teams
Arsenal (2-3-5); Kelsey; Charlton, Evans (captain); Holton, Dodgin, Bowen; Clapton, Herd, Groves, Bloomfield, Haverty
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Donovan (d) (captain), Tansey (j); Rea (k), Jones (te), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Temple (d), Hickson (d), Fielding (w), Harris (b), Coach Ian Buchan
Att 42,010

Everton 3, Sunderland 1
September 14, 1957
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. T. Jepson
Goals; Hickson (1) (assist Fielding) (7) (assist Donovan), O’Neill (38), Meagan (72)
Missed penalty TE Jones (87) saved for corner, after Hedley grassed Brian Harris
Teams
Everton (2-3-5) Dunlop (a); Donovan (d) (captain), Tansey (j); Rea (k), Jones (te), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Temple (d), Hickson (d), Fielding (w), Harris (b), Coach Ian Buchan
Sunderland (2-3-5); Bolland; Hedley (j) (ex-Blue), McDonald; Anderson, Aitken, Elliott; Bingham (w) (future blue), Revies, Fleming, O’Neill, Goodchild
Booked; Hedley foul (87)
Att 47,119

Luton Town 0, Everton 1
September 21, 1957.
League Division One
Kenworth Road
Referee; Mr. G. McCabe
Goal; Fielding (83) (assist Meagan)
Teams
Luton Town (2-3-5); Baynham; Dunne, McNally; Groves, Owen, Pearce; Cullen, Turner, Morton, Brown, McLeod
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Donovan (d) (captain), Tansey (j); Rea (k), Jones (te), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Temple (d), Hickson d), Fielding (w), Harris (b), Coach Ian Buchan
Att 19,797

Everton v. Blackpool
September 28, 1957
League Division One
Goodison Park
Game Postponed because of Influenza to Everton players

Leicester City 2, Everton 2
October 5, 1957
League Division One
Filbert Street
Referee; Mr. H. Webb
Goals; Gardiner (8), Hickson (37) (assist Temple), Fielding (65) (assist J Harris), Hogg (74)
Teams
Leicester City (2-3-5); Anderson; Milburn, Ogilvie; Russell, King, Appleton; McDonald, Doherty (Debut), Gardiner, Rowley, Hogg, Manager Dave Halliday
Everton (2-3-5) Dunlop (a); Donovan (d) (captain), Tansey (j); Rea (k), Jones (te), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Temple (d), Hickson (d), Fielding (w), Harris (b), Coach Ian Buchan
Att 28,992

Everton 2, Liverpool 0
October 9, 1957.
Liverpool County F.A. 75th Anniversary Floodlight Match
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. Micthell
Goals; Thomas (52) (65)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Donovan (d) (captain), Tansey (j); Birch (k), Jones (te), Meagan (m); McNamara (t), Temple (d), Hickson (d), Fielding (d) (e Thomas 45), Williams (g), Coach Ian Buchan
Liverpool (2-3-5); Younger; Molyneux, Byrne; Campbell (d), White, Twentyman; Jackson, Wheeler, Arnell, Rowley, Morrissey (j) (future blue), Manager Phil Taylor
Att 58,771

Newcastle United 2, Everton 3
October 12, 1957
League Division One
St James’s Park
Referee; Mr. D. Martin
Goals; Harris (b) (assist McNamara), Curry (44), Davies (46), Keith (own goal) (assist Thomas), Hickson (83) (assist Temple).
Newcastle United (2-3-5); Simpson; Keith, Batty; Scoular, Stokoe, Franks; White, Davies, Curry, Keeble, Punton
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a), Donovan (d) (captain), Tansey (j); Birch (k), Jones (te), Meagan (m); McNamara (t) (last apps, sign for Liverpool), Temple (d), Hickson (d), Thomas (e), Harris (b), Coach Ian Buchan
Att 30,360

Everton 2, Arsenal 2
October 16, 1957
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. Ellis
Goals; Bloomfield (26), Thomas (76) (assist Birch), Herd (78), Harris (B) (assist Temple)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Donovan (d) (captain), Tansey (j); Birch (k), Jones (te), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Temple (d), Hickson (d), Thomas (e), Harris (b), Coach Ian Buchan
Arsenal (2-3-5); Kelsey; Charlton, Evans; Holton, Dodgin, Bowen, Nutt, Swallow, Herd, Bloomfield, Tiddy
Att 54,345

Everton 1, Burnley 1
October 19, 1957
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Alf Bond
Goals; Cheeseborough (47), Temple (56) (assist Hickson)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Donovan (d) (captain), Tansey (j); Birch (k), Jones (te), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Temple (d), Hickson (d), Fielding (w), Harris (b), Coach Ian Buchan
Burnley (2-3-5); McDonald; Smith, Winton; Seith, Adamson, Shennan; Newlands, McIlroy, Pointer, Cheesebrough, Pilkington
Att 44,924

Everton 2, Red Star 3
October 23, 1957
Friendly Match
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. L.J. Hamer
Goals; Cokic (5) (40) ( ), Ashworth (30) (89)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Donovan (d), (captain), Tansey (j), King (j), Jones (te), Gannon; Harris (j), Ashworth (a), Hickson (d), Thomas (e) (j Gauld 45), Coach Ian Buchan
Red Star (2-3-5); Beare; Tomic, Zekovic; Popovic, Spajic, Tasic; Mitic, Clkic, Toplak, Cokis, Durkoic
Att 32,405

Preston North End 3, Everton 1
October 26, 1957
League Division One
Deepdale
Referee; Mr. E. Crawford
Goals; Mayers (24) (85), Harris (j) (assist Fielding), Finney (73)
Teams
Preston North End (2-3-5) Else; Cunningham, Watson; Docherty, Dunn, O’Farrell; Mayers (d) (ex-blue), Thompson, Finney, Baxter, Taylor, Manager Cliff Britton (ex-Blue)
Everton (2-3-5) Dunlop (a); Donovan (d) (captain), Tansey (j); King (j)(Debut, Junior Blue), Jones (te), Meagan (m), Harris (j), Temple (d), Hickson (d), Fielding (w), Harris (b), Coach Ian Buchan
Att 31,448

Liverpool 3, Everton 2 (agg 3-4)
October 30, 1957
Liverpool Floodlight Cup second Leg
Anfield
Referee; Mr. D. Lovelady
Goals; Liddell (penalty 16) (17), Morrissey (23), Hickson (38), Harris (J) (82)
Teams
Liverpool (2-3-5); Younger; Molyneux, Moran; Wheeler, White, Campbell (d); Jackson, Rowley, Liddell, Melia, Morrissey (j) future blue), manager Phil Taylor
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Donovan (d) (captain), Tansey (j); Rea (k), Jones (te), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Temple (d), Hickson (d), Fielding (w), Williams (g), Coach Ian Buchan
Att 46,724
Additional; Penalty Jones and Liddell bumped in an air challenge

Everton 1, West Bromwich Albion 1
November 2, 1957
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. K.A Collinge
Goals; Griffin (20), Harris (b) (30)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Donovan (d) (captain), Tansey (j); Rea (k), Jones (te), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Temple (d), Hickson (d), Fielding (w), Harris (b), Coach Ian Buchan
West Bromwich Albion (2-3-5); Saunders; Howe, Williams; Setter, Kennedy, Barlow; Griffins, Robson, Allen, Kevan, Horobin
Att 53,679

Everton 2, Army 3
November 6 1957
Friendly Match
Goodison Park
Goals; Charlton (5) (45), McNamara (penalty 41), Thomas (43), Newman (47)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); O’Neill (j); Sanders (a), Leeder (f); Birch (k), Donovan (d) (captain), Rea (k); McNamara (t), Thomas (e), Kirby (g), Mackay, Williams (g), Coach Ian Buchan
Army (2-3-5) Duff (Army); McIntosh (Falkirk), Whelan (Blackburn); Sharp (Reading), Spier (Reading), Appleton (Leicester); Harris (b) (Everton), Newman (Porrtsmouth), Curry (Newcastle), Charlton (Man United), Jones (Swansea).
Att 5,485

Tottenham Hotspur 3, Everton 1
November 9 1957
League Division One
White Hart Lane
Referee; Mr. C.W Kingston
Goals; Harmer (penalty 23), Brook (0-2), Temple (81) (assist Rea), Smith (90)
Teams
Tottenham Hotspur (2-3-5); Ditchburn; Baker, Hopkins; Blanchflower, Norman, Ryden; Medwin, Brook, Smith, Harmer, Robb, Manager Jimmy Anderson
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a)(Debut, Everton junior), Tansey (j); Rea (k), Donovan (d) (captain), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Temple (d), Hickson (d), Fielding (w), Harris (b) Coach Ian Buchan
Att 39,999
Additional; Penalty –Donovan pushed Smith

Everton 0 Birmingham City 2
November 16, 1957
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. C.A Wood
Goals; Murphy (39) (83)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Tansey (j); Rea (k), Donovan (d) (captain), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Temple (d), Hickson (d), Fielding (w), Harris (b), Coach Ian Buchan
Birmingham City (2-3-5); Merrick; Hall, Farmer; Watts, Smith, Neal, Astall; Orritt, Brown, Murphy, Govan, manager A. Turner
Att 34,885

Everton 0, Blackpool 0
November 20, 1957
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. L. Tirebuck
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Tansey (j), King (j), Donovan (d) (captain), Rea (k), Harris (j), Temple (d), Hickson (d), Thomas (e), Harris (b), Coach Ian Buchan
Blackpool (2-3-5); Farm; Armfield (captain), Wright; Kelly (j), Gratrix, Kelly (h), Matthews (s), Peterson, Mudie, Durie, Parry, Manager Joe Smith
Att 47,665

Portsmouth 3, Everton 2
November 23, 1957
League Division One
Fratton Park
Referee; Mr. PJ. Smyth
Goals; Temple (2) (assist J Harris), Sanders (own goal 3), Dougan (5), Gordon (58), Thomas (74) (assist B Harris)
Teams
Portsmouth (2-3-5); Uprichard; Gunter, Wilson; Albury, Rutter, Dickinson (captain); Harris, Gordon, Dougan, Mansell, Henderson, Manager JE Lever
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Tansey (j); Rea (k), Donovan (d) (captain), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Temple (d), Hickson (d), Thomas (e), Harris (b), Coach Ian Buchan
Att 27,015

Everton 1, Sheffield Wednesday 1
November 30, 1957
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. RH Mann
Goals; Temple (2)(assist Thomas), Finney (31)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Tansey (j); Rea (k), Jones (te) (captain), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Temple (d), Hickson (d), Thomas (e), Harris (b), Coach Ian Buchan
Sheffield Wednesday (2-3-5); McIntosh; Stanforth, Curtis; McAnearney (t), O’Donnell, Hill; Wilkinson, Quixall, Ellis, Froggatt, Finney
Att 31, 011

Manchester City 6, Everton 2
December 7, 1957
League Division One
Maine Road
Referee; Mr. RJ Leafe
Goals; Barnes (penalty 15) (penalty 24) (penalty 49), McAdams (35) (70), Harris (j) (42) (assist Sanders) (44), Hayes (73)
Teams
Manchester City (2-3-5); Trauntmann; Leiver, Sear; Barnes, Ewing, Warhust; Barlow, Hayes, Johnson, McAdams, Fagan
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Tansey (j); Donovan (d) (captain), Jones (te), Rea (k); Harris (j), Temple (d), Hickson (d), Thomas (e), Williams (g), Coach Ian Buchan
Sent off; Dave Hickson (70); second yellow, for dissent after McAdams , he though it was off side
Att 20,204
Additional Penaltys, 1st –McAdams grassed by Sanders, 2nd Hayes was grassed by Tansey, 3rd Hayes grassed again by Tansey

Everton 1, Nottingham Forest 1
December 14, 1957
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. ES Oxley
Goals; Gray (40), Harris (j) (46) (assist Temple)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a)(50th Lge apps); Sanders (a), Tansey (j); Donovan (d) (captain), Jones (te), Rea (k); Harris (j), Temple (d), Llewellyn (h) (retired 80)(Last apps, sign for Crewe), Fielding (w), Harris (b), Coach Ian Buchan
Nottingham Forest (2-3-5) Thomson; Whare, Thomas; Morley, McKinlay, Burkitt; Gray, Quigley, Wilson, Bailey, Imlach, Manager Billy Walker
Bookings; Warhust (foul), on Temple
Att 28,999

Wolverhampton Wanderers 2, Everton 0
December 21, 1957
League Division One
Molinuex
Referee; Mr. BAE Buckle
Goals; Clamp (31), Murray (81)
Teams
Wolverhampton Wanderers (2-3-5); Finlayson; Stuart, Harris (g); Clamp, Wright (captain), Flowers; Deeley, Slater, Murray, Mason, Mullen, Manager Stan Cullis
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Tansey (j); Donovan (d) (captain), Jones (te), Rea (k); Harris (j), Temple (d), Kirby (g)(Last app, sign for Sheff United), Fielding (w), Harris (b), Coach Ian Buchan
Att 29,447

Everton 1, Bolton Wanderers 1`
December 25, 1957
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. F.H. Gerrard
Goals; Birch (10) (assist Donovan), Kirby (34)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5) Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Tansey (j); Donovan (d) (captain), Jones (te), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Kirby (g)(last apps, signed for Sheff Wed), Harris (b), Coach Ian Buchan
Bolton Wanderers (2-3-5); Hopkinson; Hartle, Banks; Hennin, Higgins, Edwards (gb); Birch, Stevens (d) (future blue), Lofthouse, Parry, Holden, manager Billy Ridding
Att 29,584

Bolton Wanderers 1, Everton 5
December 26, 1957
League Division One
Burnden Park
Referee; Mr. F.H. Gerrard
Goals; Keeley (3) (assist J Harris), Harris (b) (18) (70), Harris (40), Hickson (68), Lofthouse (85)
Teams
Bolton Wanderers (2-3-5); Hopkinson; Hartle, Banks; Hennin, Higgins, Edwards (gb); Birch, Stevens (d)(future blue), Lofthouse, Parry, Holden, manager Billy Ridding
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Tansey (j); Jones (te) (captain), rea (k), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Keeley (j)(Debut, Everton Juniors), Harris (b), Coach Ian Buchan

Everton 1, Aston Villa 2
December 28, 1957
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. JS Pickles
Goals; Hitchen (13) (61), Harris (b) (63) (assist J Harris)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Tansey (j); Rea (k), Jones (te) (captain), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Keeley (j), Harris (b), Coach Ian Buchan
Aston Villa (2-3-5); Sims; Lynn, Aldis; Crowther; Dugdale, Sward, Smith; Sewell, Hitchen, Dixon (captain) (retired 83), McParland
Att 42,295

Sunderland 2, Everton 2
January 4, 1958
F.A Cup Round Three
Roker Park
Referee; Mr. Arthur Ellis
Goals; Hickson (12) (assist Thomas) (50) (assist Tansey), Bingham (19), Fogarty (62)
Teams
Sunderland (2-3-5); Fraser; McDonald, Elliott; Anderson, Hurley, Reed; Bingham (future blue), Fleming, Revie, Fogarty, Godhold, manager Alan Brown
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sander (a), Tansey (j); Rea (k), Jones (te) (captain), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Keeley (j), Harris (b), Coach Ian Buchan
Booked Fogarty (foul) on Dunlop
Att 34,602

Everton 3, Sunderland 1 (AET)
January 8, 1958
F.A Cup Round Three Replay
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. Arthur Ellis
Goals; Keeley (3) (assist Thomas) (93) (assist Hickson), Fleming (24), Hickson (106)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Tansey (j); Rea (k), Jones (te) (captain), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Keeley (j), Harris (b), Coach Ian Buchan
Sunderland (2-3-5); Fraser; McDonald, Elliott; Anderson, Hurley, Reed; Bingham (future blue), Fleming, Revie, Fogarty, Grianger, manager Alan Brown
Sent off; Ambrose Fogarty (89) for a lunge at Alan Sanders
Booked Forgarty
Att 56,956

Chelsea 3, Everton 1
January 11, 1958
League Division One
Stamford Bridge
Referee; Mr. J.A Barradell
Goals; Harris (j) (16) (assist Williams); Greaves (40) (86), McNichols (52)
Teams
Chelsea (2-3-5); Matthews; Sillett, Bellett; Casey, Mortimer, Saunders; Brabrooks, McNichols, Tindall, Greves, Lewis
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Leeder (f)(only apps, signed for Darlington); Rea (k), Jones (je) (captain), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Keeley (j), Williams (g), Coach Ian Buchan
Att 29,490

Sunderland 1, Everton 1
January 18, 1958
League Division One
Roker Park
Referee; Mr. A. Murdoch
Goals; Revie (14), Thomas (64) (assist Temple)
Teams
Sunderland (2-3-5); Fraser; Hedley (j) (ex-blue), Elliott; Anderson, Hurley, Aitkens; Bingham (w) (future blue), Fleming, Revie, Forgarty, Grainger, Manager Alan Brown
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Donovan (d) (captain); Birch (k), Jones (te), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Temple (d), Keeley (j), Williams (g), Coach Ian Buchan
Att 26,500

Everton v Blackburn Rovers
January 25, 1958
FA Cup Round Four
Goodison Park
Postponed, Icy pitch

Everton 1, Blackburn Rovers 2
January 29, 1958
F.A Cup Round Four
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. R. Crawford
Goals; Dobing (10), Megan (own goal 19), Harris (j) (31) (Assist Donovan)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Donovan (d) (captain); Birch (k), Jones (te), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Temple (d), Keeley (j)(last apps signed for Accrington), Harris (b), Coach Ian Buchan
Blackburn Rovers (2-3-5); Leyland (h) ex-blue); Taylor, Eckersley; Clayton (captain), Woods (m) (ex-blue),McGarth; Douglas, Stephenson, Dobing, Vernon (r) (future blue), McLeod, Manager Jack Carey (future manager).
Att 75,818

Everton 0, Luton Town 2
February 1, 1958
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. BM Grifiths
Goals; Gregory (31), Turner (59)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Donovan (d) (captain); Birch (k)(Last apps, signed for Southampton), Jones (te), Meagan (m); Harris (b), Thomas (e), Harris (j), Haughey (w)(Last apps, signed for Falkirk), Williams (g), Coach Ian Buchan
Luton Town (2-3-5); Baynham; Dunne, Hawkes; Morton, Owen, Pacey; Adams, Turner, Gregory, Groves, Mcleod, Manager Daily Duncan
Att 26,908

Blackpool v Everton
February 8, 1958
League Division One
Postponed, dangerous state of ground, 2 inchs of snow, which thaw and left patch icy

Everton 2, Leicester City 2
February 15, 1958
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. GW Pullen
Goals; Walsh (11) (66), Harris (j) (35) (assist Thomas), Thomas (53) (assist Meagan)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Donovan (d) (captain), Tansey (j); Rea (k), Jones (te), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Temple (d), Harris (b), Coach Ian Buchan
Leicester City (2-3-5); Anderson; Cunningham, Baillie; Morris, King, Russell; McDonald, Walsh, Walker, Hines, Hogg
Att 23,460

Everton 1, Newcastle United 2
February 22, 1958
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. Arthur R Holland
Goals; Thomas (45) (assist Meagan), Botton (47) (62)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Donovan (d) (captain), Tansey (j); Rea (k), Jones (te), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Temple (d), Harris (b), Coach Ian Buchan
Newcastle United (2-3-5); Mitchell (s); McKinsey, McMicheal; Scoular, Stokoe, Franks; Tait, Eastham, Curry, Botton (debut), Mitchell (r)
Att 22,448

Burnley 0, Everton 2
March 1, 1958
League Division One
Turf Moor
Referee; Mr. KR Tuck
Goals; Thomas (11) (assist Hickson) (58) (assist B Harris)
Teams
Burnley (2-3-5); McDonald; Angus, Winton; Miller, Adamson, Shannon; Newlands, Connolly, Pointers, Cheeseborough, Pilkington., Manager Harry Potts (ex-Blue)
Everton (2-3-5); O’Neill (j); Sanders (a), Tansey (j); Rea (k), Jones (te) (captain), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Fielding (w), Harris (b), Manager Ian Buchan
Booked; Fielding (foul), Shannon (foul)
Att 19,657

Everton 4, Preston North End 2
March 18, 1958
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. TH Cooper
Goals; Thomas (15) (assist Rea) (43) (assist B Harris) (53) (assist Hickson) (83) (assist Fielding), Finney (penalty 45), Bayter (87)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); O’Neill (j); Sanders (a), Tansey (j); Rea (k), Jones (te) (captain), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Hickson (d), Thomas (e), Fielding (w), Harris (b)(50th Lge apps), Coach Ian Buchan
Preston North End (2-3-5); Cunningham; Walton, Docherty; Mattinson, O’Farrell (f), Farrell (a) (ex-Blue); Mayers (d) (ex-Blue), Thompson, Finney (captain), Baxter, Taylor, manager Cliff Britton (ex-Blue)
Att 43,291
Additional penalty –Jones grassed Finney

West Bromwich Albion 4, Everton 0
March 15, 1958
League Division One
Hawthorn
Referee; Mr. RH Windle
Goals; Robson (15), Kevan (45) (86), Allen (penalty 81)
Teams
West Bromwich Albion (2-3-5) Saunders (g); Howe, Williams; Dudley, Barlow (captain), Drury; Whitehouse, Robson, Allen, Kevan, Horobins, Manager Vic Buckingham
Everton (2-3-5); O’Neill (j); Sanders (a), Tansey (j); Rea (k), Jones (te), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Fielding (w), Hickson (d), Thomas (e), Harris (b), Coach Ian Buchan
Booked; Barlow, Hickson
Att 28, 915
Additional –Penalty Alan Sanders grassed Robson

Everton 2, Shamrock Rovers 0
March 19, 1958
Friendly Match
Goodison Park
Goals; Hickson (45) (72)
Teams
Everton (2-3-); O’Neill (j); Sanders (a), Tansey (j); Rea (k), Donovan (d) (captain), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Ashworth (a), Williams (g), Coach Ian Buchan
Shamrock Rovers (2-3-5); O’Callaghan; Burke, Keogh; Nolan, Mackay, Hennessy; McCann, Hamilton, Ambross, Caod, Tuchy
Att 8,656

Everton 4, Portsmouth 2
March 22, 1958
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. TS Blenkinsopp
Goals; Harris (P)(33), Williams (53) (assist Fielding) (81) (assist Fielding), McClellan (57), Thomas (78) (assist Fielding) (86)(assist Fielding)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); O’Neill (j); Sanders (a), Tansey (j); Rea (k), Jones (te) (captain), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Fielding (w), Williams (g), Coach Ian Buchan
Portsmouth (2-3-5); Uprichard; McGhee, Gunter; Phillips, Ruther, Dickinson (captain); Harris (p), Gordon, Douglas, McClellan, Govan, Manager Eddie Lever
Att 23,179

Everton 2, Liverpool 0
March 25, 1958
Liverpool Senior Cup Final
Goodison Park
Goals; Williams (59), Thomas (75)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Tansey (j); Rea (k), Jones (te) (captain), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Fielding (w), Williams (g), Coach Ian Buchan
Liverpool (2-3-5); Younger; Molyneux, Moran; Wheeler, White, Wilkinson; Simpson, McNamara, Liddell, Melia, A’Court
Att 30,352

Birmingham City 2 Everton 1
March 29, 1958
League Division One
St. Andrews
Referee; Mr. Arthur Ellis
Goals; Hooper (35) (41), Thomas (61) (assist J Harris)
Teams
Birmingham City (2-3-5); Scholfield; Hall, Green; Walls, Smith, Neal; Astall, Larkin, Brown, Orritt, Hooper
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Tansey (j); Rea (k), Labone (b)(Debut, Everton Junior), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Fielding (w), Williams (g), Coach Ian Buchan
Booked; Harris (foul)
Att 21,628

Everton 0, Leeds United 1
April 4, 1958
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. W. Clements
Goal; Baird (17)
Missed Penalty (jimmy Harris (20) saved shot and rebound after Gibson handled.
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Tansey (j); Rea (k), Jones (te) (captain), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Temple (d), Fielding (w), Williams (g), Coach Ian Buchan
Leeds United (2-3-5); Wood; Dunn, Hair; Gibson, Charlton, Kerfoot, Crowe; O’Brien, Baird, Forrest, Overfield, Manager Raich Carter
Att 32,796

Everton 3, Tottenham Hotspur 4
April 5, 1958
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. G. McGhee
Goals; Clayton (9) (50), Smith (16) (22), Hickson (58) (assist Williams) (77), Thomas (62) (assist Harris)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Tansey (j)(captain); Rea (k), Labone (b), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Temple (d), Williams (g), Coach Ian Buchan
Tottenham Hotspur (2-3-5); Ditchburn; Hill, Henry; Blanchflower (captain), Norman, Ryden; Medwin, Harmer, Smith, Clayton (debut), Jones.
Att 30,148

Leeds United 1, Everton 0
April 7, 1958
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. RJ Leafe
Goals; Forest (83)
Teams
Leeds United (2-3-5); Wood; Dunn, Hair; Cush, Charlton, Kerfoot; Meek, Forrest, Baird, O’Brien, Overfield, manager Raich Carter
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Tansey (j); Rea (k), Donovan (d) (captain), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Temple (d), Williams (g), Coach Ian Buchan
Att 25,188

Sheffield Wednesday 2, Everton 1
April 12, 1958
League Division One
Hillsborough
Referee; Mr. JW Topliss
Goals; Quixall (53), Curtis (63), Harris (j) (86) (assist Williams)
Teams
Sheffield Wednesday (2-3-5); Springett; Johnson, Curtis; Gibson, Swan, O’Donnell; Wilkinson, Quixall, Shiner, Fantham, Finney.
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Tansey (j); Rea, Donovan (d) (captain), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Ashworth (a)(Debut, Everton Juniors), Williams (g), Coach Ian Buchan
Att 18,715

Everton 6, Fortune FC 1
April 16, 1958
Friendly Match
Goodison Park
Goals; Hickson (8), Harris (J) (2-0) (3-0) (77) (78) (80), Haues (55)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Tansey (j); King (j), Donovan (d) (captain), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Ashworth (a), Harris (b), Coach Ian Buchan
Fortune FC (2-3-5); Belski; Dormans, Rabuda; Notermans, Van Der Hart, Munster, Angenent (Haves 45) Ravestein, Appel, Jungen, Cater.
Att 7,798

Everton 2, Manchester City 5
April 19, 1958
League Division One
Goodison Park
Goals; Ashworth (1) (assist Thomas) (3), Hayes (23) Harte (43) (49), Sambrook (54), Barnes (penalty 60)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Tansey (j); King (j), Donovan (d) (captain)(Last apps, sign for Grimsby), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Ashworth (a), Williams (g), Coach Ian Buchan
Manchester City (2-3-5); Trauntmann; Branagan, Sear; Barnes, Leievers, Warhurst; Fagan, Barlow, Hart, Hayes, Sambrook, Manager Leslie McDowell
Att 31,433
Additional; Penalty Alan Sanders grassed Hayes

Blackpool 0, Everton 1
April 23, 1958
League Division One
Bloomfield Road
Goal; Ashworth (38)
Missed Penalty ; Hugh Kelly (15) saved by O’Neill after Ashworth was grassed by Charnley
Teams
Blackpool (2-3-5); Farm; Snowden, Martin; Kelly (j), Gratrix, Kelly (h); Peterson, Hauser (debut), Charnley, Durie, Perry, Manager Joe Smith
Everton (2-3-5); O’Neill (j); Sanders (a), Tansey (j); King (j), Labone (b), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Fielding (w), Thomas (e), Ashworth (a), Harris (b), Coach Ian Buchan
Att 12,981

Nottingham Forest 0, Everton 3
April 26, 1958
League Division One
City Ground
Referee; Mr. SW Baxter
Goals; Harris (j) (56) (assist Fielding), Harris (b) (75) (assist J Harris) (80) (assist J Harris)
Teams
Nottingham Forest (2-3-5); Thomson; Whare, (Retired 60), Thomas (g); Farmer, McKinlay, Burkitt; Gray, Quigley, Wilson, Bailey, Imlach, Manager WH Walker
Everton (2-3-5); O’Neill (j); Sanders (a), Tansey (j) (captain); King (j), Labone (b), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Fielding (w), Thomas (e), Ashworth (a), Harris (b), Coach Ian Buchan
Att 16,730

Southport 0 Southport 0
May 10, 1958
Liverpool Senior Cup Final
Haig Avenue
Referee; Mr. DC Lovelady
Teams
Southport (2-3-5); Richardson; Dodd, Rankin (g) (ex-Blue); Kingloch, Taylor, Parkinson; McDermott, Gryba, Bromilow (g), Baker, Lee (a).
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Tansey (j) (captain); King (j), Labone (b), Meagan (m);l Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Ashworth (a), Harris (b)
Att 2,543
Additional; Cup Shared