| Everton v Aston Villa Goalscorers and Results (FA Cup) | |||||
| No | Season | Ground | Score | Everton Scorers | Aston Villa Scorers |
| 1 | 1896-97 | Crystal Palace | 2-3 | Bell, Boyle | Devey, Cowan (John), Wheldon |
| 2 | 1904-05 | Victoria Ground | 1-1 | Sharp | Hall |
| 3 | 1904-05 | Trent Bridge | 1-2 | Sharp | Garrett (2) |
| 4 | 1952-53 | Villa Park | 1-0 | Hickson | |
| 5 | 1958-59 | Goodison Park | 1-2 | Hickson | Wyle (3), McParland |
| 6 | 1972-73 | Goodison Park | 3-2 | Belfitt, Buckley, Harper | Vowden, Harper |
| 7 | 1977-78 | Goodison Park | 4-1 | King, Ross (Pen), McKenzie, Latchford | Gray |
| 8 | 1999-00 | Goodison Park | 1-2 | Moore | Stone, Carbone |
| 9 | 2008-09 | Goodison Park | 3-1 | Rodwell, Arteta (Pen), Cahill | Milner (Pen) |