| Everton v Plymouth Argyle Goalscorers and Results (FA Cup) | |||||
| No | Season | Ground | Score | Everton Scorers | Plymouth Argyle Scoerers |
| 1 | 1930-31 | Home Park | 2-0 | Stein, Dunn | |
| 2 | 1974-75 | Home Park | 3-1 | Lyons (2), Pearson | Vassalo |
| 3 | 1988-89 | Home Park | 1-1 | Sheedy (Pen) | McCarthy |
| 4 | 1988-89 | Goodison Park | 4-0 | Sharp (2), Nevin, Sheedy | |
| 5 | 2004-05 | Home Park | 3-1 | Osman, McFadden, Chadwick | Gudjonsson |