| Everton v Sheffield Wednesday Goalscorers and Results (FA Cup) | |||||
| No | Season | Ground | Score | Everton Scorers | Sheffield Wednesday Scorers |
| 1 | 1892-93 | Goodison Park | 3-0 | Chadwick, Geary, Kelso (Pen) | |
| 2 | 1894-95 | Away | 0-2 | Brady, Ferrier | |
| 3 | 1895-96 | Hillsbrough | 0-4 | Brash (2), Bell (L) (2) | |
| 4 | 1905-06 | Goodison Park | 4-3 | Sharp, Taylor, Bolton, Booth | Simpson, Bartlett, Davies (Pen) |
| 5 | 1906-07 | Crystal Palace | 1-2 | Sharp | Stewart, Simpson |
| 6 | 1920-21 | Goodison Park | 1-1 | Parker | Taylor |
| 7 | 1920-21 | Hillsbrough | 1-0 | Crossley | |
| 8 | 1936-37 | Goodison Park | 3-0 | Britton (Pen), Dean, Coulter | |
| 9 | 1946-47 | Hillsbrough | 1-2 | Wainwright | Froggatt, Tomlinson |
| 10 | 1953-54 | Hillsbrough | 1-3 | Hickson | Shaw, Sewell, Woodhead |
| 11 | 1964-65 | Goodison Park | 2-2 | Rogers (og), Pickering | Fantham, Quinn |
| 12 | 1964-65 | Hillsbrough | 3-0 | Pickering, Harvey, Temple | |
| 13 | 1965-66 | Wembley | 3-2 | Trebilcock (2), Temple | McCalliog, Ford |
| 14 | 1985-86 | Villa Park | 2-1 | Sharp, Harper | Shutt |
| 15 | 1987-88 | Hillsbrough | 1-1 | Reid | West |
| 16 | 1987-88 | Goodison Park | 1-1 | Sharp | Chapman |
| 17 | 1987-88 | Goodison Park | 1-1 | Steven | Worthington |
| 18 | 1987-88 | Hillsbrough | 5-0 | Sharp (3), Heath, Snodin | |
| 19 | 1989-90 | Hillsbrough | 2-1 | Whiteside (2) | Hirst |
| 20 | 2020-21 | Goodison Park | 3-0 | Richarlison, Calvert-Lewin, Mina | |