November 1889

LIVERPUDLIANA; BY RICHARD SAMUEL
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 02 November 1889
UP AND DOWN
After a long spell of absence the Everton team returned to their native heath at Anfield-rd, last Saturday, and to be sure a very big gathering of their sympathizers was prepared to give them a very warm reception.  Still the affair turned out rather a cold house warming.  You see it was this way.  A some-what discredited League team was to be the thank-offering for the occasion; and the Everton gods were to be propitiated by then sacrifice of the Reds of Accrington.  These latter have always given the Everton team an opportunity of doing great things, as they have generally been in a very accommodating mood at Anfield-rd., and in their hour of weakness, with the Achilles in the person of George Howarth, sulking in his metaphorical tent, the triumphant “toffees” looked forward to their latest league engagement with something like complacency.  The sequel was sad from an Everton point of view.  They did not propitiate the gods.  Nay, certain of the latter look askance at their servants, and the consequences may be had for the Stoke eleven today. In plain parlance, Everton thought to have beaten Accrington, as they were of defeating Notts County on the previous Saturday, and that they failed in both them Instances has caused a chill of the fevered enthusiasm of their supporters. Some alarm has been excited by the deterioration of Geary, which reported from Notts was not credited but which could not be mistaken at Everton last Saturday.
EVERTON FALL TO SECOND PLACE
As I asserted last week,  it was a firm conviction in Everton circles that the first in the League list would held by their team at least until Xmas, and that the four matches—Notts County, Accrington and Stoke home and home –would each add two points to the Everton record. Half these games have been got through, but as you only one score has been made, and meanwhile the sensational victory of Wolverhampton Wanderers at Deepdale has enabled the Wolves to win the supreme position, and to send Everton to second place.  The Accrington team has fared badly of late, and it was a rather poor looking team, on paper, which caused a turn in the tide of the disastrous flood which was apparently carrying the Reds into the company of their two disconsolate Lancashire neighbours at the bottom of the League list.  Gallocher was tried at half-back a happy inspiration as matters turned out, and the forwards were quite a new lot with Entwistle and Prendergast introduced.  Everton had their best available eleven, and a big gate, a bright day; a great reception may well have inspired the hometsers with confidence as they came out.  But there was an early and a rude shock to the confidence of the crowd.  The visitors did not at all start like a disconsolate or a discredited side.  Oh dear, no.  Quick and eager and determined, they kept their heads down and their lips set and their nervous taut, and soon gave an earnest of their serious intentions by scoring the first goal.  It was a long time before Everton recovered, and when Latta shot an apparent goal the cheering was tremendous for everyone now felt that the struggle was going to be a hard one. Judge then of the revulsion, when the referee quietly disallowed that dearly cherished point.  Well, a football crowd is a miscellaneous one, and philosophy is not one of its characteristics. That Everton crowd was very unhappy. That unfortunate official was the recipient of such overwhelming favours as one might imagine to be showered upon Mr. Balfour, addressing a meeting of Nationalists on the benefits of the ‘‘Twenty  Years’ Firm Rule.”  But, my friends, the ball was kicked from the goal.  At length, after much excitement and turmoil, Geary shot a genuine goal, and something like equilibrium was restored.  The teams crossed over on level terms.
THE END
As before, the Reds went off, on business sternly bent. So did Everton. There is nothing more exciting than the struggle between such clubs in such Mood.  The defenders on both sides had a long innings, but Chadwick, for Everton, was first to take a wicket.  He bowled Lindsay with a long high one, which the goalkeeping did not see evidently, for he calmly placed the ball for a kick from goal, and looked very much hurt as it was carried to midfield at the inexorable word of the referee.  Two blacks do not make a white, though Accrington.  Just balances that adverse first decision, reflected they of the part of Everton.  Not beaten yet.  The Reds came up in a style worthy of their best traditions, and a really splendid run and centre by Kirkham were consummated in a masterly fashion by Barbour, and again the game was even.  And so it remained to the end of the chapter, and the game was drawn.  Honours may be decided “easy.” Everton had certainly the pull in the early stages, but Accrington were going splendidly at the finish.
FURTHER
“Mickey’s” flagellations will need further application. The “bhoys” are certainly “bad” just now. Geary was closely watched, and could not escape his shadow. That was a new experience for Evertonian,. He was as difficult, heretofore, to fix, as any shadow; and against Dewar of the Rovers, Milne of the Wanderers, Allen of the “Wolves”, Lang of Burnley, he was equally slippery at Everton, and every single word of admiration of his play which has emanated from these quarters, will no doubt be attested by those who have seen him in all these games, as they were borne out by the Scotch critics Glasgow. There was not much wrong with the other forwards, but the half backs were not in great form. Doyle, Hannah, and Smalley were none of them superlative, but all good. As for the Reds, there is much praise for the forwards, plenty of encouragement in the display of the youngsters. Gallocher has evidently a new career before him when apparently played out, for he was a champion half-hack. Whilst McLellan and Stevenson were sturdy backs, Lindsay was a grand custodian. Accrington’s fate is not yet sealed on last week’s display.

A DISAPPOINTMENT AT EVERTON
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 02 November 1889
By Mickey Free
I believe I expressed wonder whether the Reds would reverse the form which they whether against Notts County, and sure enough they did. Had they defended so well against that club as they did against Everton, the Lace County might have had another tale to tell.   Geary’s play was talked much of in the earlier matches, and very little wonder, as he played splendidly, making all the use he possibly could of his great-speed; but after all it was only a question of tactics to spoil him.  Burnley were the first to recognize this, and not Lang to watch him.  Notts County followed this up more successfully, as Geary feather-weight was as nothing to his stalwart opponent, and so it was on Saturday.  Although Gallacher is not a giant he is what you would call a “big little ‘un,” and he fairly non-plussed Fred time after time. 
WHAT DOES IT PROVE?
Why, that instead of depending on one man to do all the scoring the tactics of the forwards will have to be changed, and let both wings be fed more equally and allowed chances to shoot.  The right wing so far this season has not had half the chances of the left, although, I dare say, there is hardly a better screw shot in the country then Latta.  Anyone who doubts this, let them tell me what they thought of that goal on Saturday, for goal it was despite of Mr. Referee, By-the-bye, speaking of that gentleman, he was not as happy as usual in his decisions, so suppose even referees get out of form? It is very awkward when your opponents’ goalkeeper admits after the match that it was a fair goal.  Previous to this “hands” off Milward caused a diversion in favour of the Reds which ended in Entwistle drawing first blood.  As soon as the Evertonians settled down to their work again, Lindsay had his hands full as shots came in from Chadwick and Kirkwood. Latta next put in a fine run but failed at the finish.  Again the Evertonians were somewhat unhinged by Party claiming a foul which the referee ruled against him, but getting enraged the boys fairly swarmed round the Reds’ goal, but it was not until the ball had gone in end out three times that Geary at last got it past Lindsay. Eutwistle last a chance through selfishness and then Latta gave Lindsay a warm fistful. Directly after, the same player passed prettily to Geary, who was not nearly so vigorous as usual with his shot. Apparently his foot was somewhat injured. Hannah and Doyle kept their end well clear, and so the Everton forwards had plenty of chances to get away, yet luck was against them, until Chadwick scored with a long lob. A pretty pass by Kirkman enabled Barbour to equalize, and so the game ended in a draw, which should have been a win by three to two. The players all round did well, but the game, taken in its entirety, was far short in the matter of scientific football of several which we have had this season. I hope the next couple of matches will again leave us at the top of the League.

EVERTON V STOKE
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 02 November 1889
This the first League match between these clubs took place at Everton, before about 12,000 spectators.  The ground was very heavy, owing to overnight and morning’s heavy rain.  Everton tried two changes in their team, Brady partnering Latta vice Kirkwood, and Cain was tried at half vice Farmer.  The visitors team was as follows;- Stoke; Rowley, goal; Clare and Underwood, backs; Montford, Hendry, and Smith half-backs; McCormick, Gee, Baker, Ramsey, and Couper, forwards. 
Everton won the toss, playing with the wind.  Baker kicked-off and Stoke at once broke away, but they were quickly pulled up by Holt who gave the ball to Chadwick whose shot went behind.  Five minutes had barely passed when Brady brought about the downfall of Stoke.  This was, not long afterwards, followed by a second from Latta, the same player from a pass by Geary adding a third, and Geary from a corner scored a fourth.  The passing of the Everton forwards was splendid, the ball travelling from one player to another with lightning rapidity, and the shooting was all that could be desired.  Stoke seemed at times to be completely disorganized, the right wing and goalkeeper being the only shinning lights of the team.  Rowley was a fifth time defeated by Brady, whose struck the bar, the ball just glancing under.  Number six was added by Milward.  On resuming an invasion of the Stoke goal was at once commenced, but the visitors now appeared to liven up, although they were prevented from becoming dangerous by the sterling defence of the Everton back division.  Geary again became conspicuous for a good dribble, ending with a shot which raised the total up to seven goals.  Rowley was later on deservedly cheered for his display in goal after stopping some most difficult shots.  Final result; Everton 8, Stoke 0. 

NUGGETS
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 02 November 1889

  • Hannah played a grand back game for Everton on Saturday.
  • Now was it that George Howarth did not play for Accrington against Everton?
  • Farmer, it is said, will accommodate Cain and Danny Kirkwood will make room for Brady.
  • Geary was out-Gear-ed last Saturday.
  • The Everton centre second stopped on Saturday.
  • Have Everton with their revised team beaten Stoke 6-0?
  • ‘Twill be a good day for Everton when the Brooks dry up.
  • The Everton crowd and the referee did not hit it last Saturday.
  • J.J.B is too thick skinned to be even wounded by Everton sportsmen (?)
  • According to Mr. Barclay’s vote, Everton’s centre forward is everything he ought to be and nothing that he oughtn’t, oh!
  • What an Evertonians ex-secretary of football players; “Their language has not that repose that stamps the talk of Geary here.”

EVERTON 8 STOKE 0 (Game 32)
November 4 1889. The Liverpool Courier
To witness this tenth league encounter for the Everton team there were a large number of Spectators at Anfield. The Everton team underwent a couple of important alterations. Cain taking Farmers place at right half back. Brady made his first appearance since his suspension, and displaced Kirkwood as inside right. The remainder of the team was without change. The men from the Black County did not arrive until half an hour after the time appointed for the kick off, and the teams were composed as follows; Everton: - Smalley goal Hannah (Captain) and Doyle, backs, Parry, Holt, and Cains, half-backs, Latta Brady, Geary, Chadwick, and Milward forwards. Stoke: - Rowley, goals, Clare and Underwood, backs, Montford, Hendry and Smith, half-backs, McCormick, Gee, Baker, Ramsey, and Cooper forwardes. The visitors kicked off down hill, and after exchanges Everton forced the play. Latta made a nice tricky run and passed to Geary, who sent in a beautiful low shot along which missed the mark only by a few inches. Milward almost rushing the ball through, the homesters retained their position, and Latta made as good an attempt as Geary had done previously. Following this Brady received the ball from the wing companion, and kicked a goal when the game at this point being ten minutes old. The Evertonians attack was very strong, and shots from Geary, Chadwick, and Brady were unfortunately unsuccessful. Another admirable effort on the right wing terminated in a manner desired, Rowley being unable to prevent Latta shot from going through. Milward next distinguished himself by a speedy run and pretty play, a beautifully pass to Brady justmerely failing. Immediately afterwards Geary headed the globe over to Latta who scored the third goal. The Stoke boys at last forced their way into their opponents' quarters but it was only a transient visit, the home forwards making their way up again. Geary then brilliant placed the ball past Rowley, the point however, not being allowed. Owing to offside play. The visiting team looked dangerous on two occasions, through the exertions of the right wing, but Doyle stuck to his post manfully, and removed the play in a creditable manner. The Evertonians compelled their antagonists to concede a corner and Chadwick, taking the kick put the ball right into the goalmouth, Geary heading the fourth goal. The combination of the Anfield organization was something out of the usual order of things, and the improvement upon the play of the previous Saturday was remarkable. Shots after shots was put in, and the visiting custodian experienced a warm time. Milward and Chadwick gave Rowley a near shave, and Brady also offered him a handful. The staffordshire team now exhibited better movements, but did not succeed in giving Smalley any work to do, his position up to the period having being surecure. The Everton men again relief and two further corners were accept. Nothing having come of those, Brady got on the ball, and scored a fifth point, the ball striking the crossbar, and rendering it nearly impossible for Rowley to stop it. A few seconds later a slight scrimmage took place in front of the visiting goalkeepers, the result of which was that Milward added another notch, thus making the total to six goals to Stoke nil. The visitors played up with more dash, Baker and Ramsey being prominent, but a shot from the former was too wide of the upright. Half-time result; Everton 6 goals Stoke 0.
On the resumption of the game Brady rushed away, and passed over to Latta, who exchanged with Milward, this player striking the upright with a fast shot. The play of the home forwards diminished somewhat, and the Stoke left taking the ball well up compelled Doyle to kick behind, the corner kick, however, being fruitless. Geary kicked a second off-side goal, but the Evertonians made amends for this by obtaining a tangible point almost immediately afterwards, Geary again being the means of doing this by a pass from Brady. Rowley then received hearty applause for a marvellous save, from Milward, and following this McCornick put in a grand run which did not attain the end so much desired. Notwithstanding the heavy score against the, the Stoke lads played up pluckily and showed much more finish than in the first half. The vistors were now fairly holding their own, and the backs tackling and kicking finely, assisted in keeping the ball well in the Everton territory. Darkness coming on now it was somewhat difficult to see the ball. Final result Everton 8 goals Stoke 0.

EVERTON REVIEW
November 4 1889.
The Liverpool Mercury
Everton beat Stoke in gallant style on Saturday, and are now in great joy, for the Wolverhampton Wanderers, were discomfited at Perry Barr, and Everton resume the lead of the Leaguers. Special interest centred in the match or account of Brady's reappearance, and in the debut of Cain at half-back in a league contest in place of Farmer, who is at present serving a couple of week's suspension. Stoke arrived late, and kept the home players waiting fully half an hour. In the meantime curiosity on the new men, who were both received with an ovation by the 10,000 spectators. The ground was on the heavy side, and a good deal of wind was manifest, though it did seem to inconvenience the player as much. Winning the toss, Everton had the hill against them, but they made little of this impediment, and at once grouped themselves round about Rowley, good shots by Geary, and Latta being no avail with such a custodian in goal. Doyle next cut McCormack up short when running powerfully and then began the fun. Latta and Brady went up in a pretty passing movement, and the latter at length finding himself, within range sent the ball at a terrific speed, and scored a real gem of a goal. This, of course'brought down the house and made Brady a hero before the game was ten minutes old. Fairly nonplusing the Stoke backs by their well concerted passes, Everton returned to the attack, and were not long before they again baffled the active and watchful Rowley, Latta this time shooting through, a performance he early on repeated. Everton continued masters of the situation, Stoke only occasionally getting away for short spurts. Geary, Brady, and Milward followed with goals, the total at half-time being a good half-dozen. Play afterwards was less spirited, but it went consistently in favour of Everton, who finally won by 8 goals to nil. A defeat which must have brought recollections to Stoke of that 10 goal mishap at Deepdale. Now for a word or two about the actors in this glorious rout. Smalley had next to nothing to do, but the little bit of business he had attended to was sufficient to show that he could if called upon maintain the great form evident throughout the season. Doyle had the strongest wing to combat with, and was very reliable whilst Hannah did his share of hard work in a polished and clever way, Holt Parry, and Cain made a strong trio at half-back. This department was of a very different character from that of the two previous weeks, and to their effectiveness is due in a great measure the heaviness of Stoke's defeat. Cain had to face McCormack, as international man, and a sprinter to boot and foiled his man in a most competent manner, making a judicious use of his weight, and feeding his forwards well. The general verdict is that Cain will do and will permanently establish his claim to Farmer's position. The forwards all played nicely together, bent on winning, but Latta and Brady whose shooting was of the electrifying order, made the most friends, and worked with such thorough understanding as to place the right in advance of the left wing though Chadwick and Milward contributed much solid help. Geary showed great improvement and was at times brilliant, notwithstanding that the ground was not quite to his liking. In short the downright good shooting and passing of the home forwards beat Stoke. Rowley was in his usual form, but was fairly staggered with the incisiveness of the shots. Clare and Underwood could seldom cope with the invaders. Hendry and Smith were at times smart in tackling and of a fairly good lot of forwards McCornack and Gee on the right were the best and the most dangerous. Everton have a lot of business on hand just now. To-day they visit Burnley and on Wednesday play the cup tie with Witton at Anfield the Lancashire Exeutive having granted an extention of time rather than santions a walk over for Witton.

LIVERPOOL AND DISTRICT NOTES.
Athletic News - Monday 04 November 1889
EVERTON ON THE WINNING TACK
By the Loiterer
The visit of Stoke to Anfield was generally looked upon as pretty nearly a gift for Everton; but the inclusion of Brady, after his suspension, and of Kane, who has been down here a week or two, lent an additional interest to the game. Both received a hearty welcome, and each were soon favourites, Brady especially putting in some good work, and the improvement in the play of the right wing was apparent. The game started 36 minutes late, owing to the unpunctuality of the train.
Baker started, and his right made a little headway, but the home team forced matters, and Milward only just missed his mark after a tricky run by Latta. The home team were pressing severely, and Brady placed the first goal. Everton were playing a grand .game, and their impetuosity altogether upset the visitors' defence, both Clare and Underwood kicking wildly. After Chadwick and Holt had abortive shots Baker spurted, but Parry took the pass and transferred play to the visitors half, and Hatton put in a capital shot which took effect. Everton still attacked, and, after having a couple of corners, Latta scored a third goal. From the kick-off Stoke paid their first visit to Smalley; it was only a burst, however, and the venue was soon changed. Geary, after placing an off-side goal, headed a fourth front a corner. The visitors could neither make headway nor stop the home team, and Brady put on a fifth, and soon after Milward a sixth goal. The Pottery men now rallied somewhat, and Ramsey caused Smalley to throw out. To the interval play was more even, Everton leading by six goals to nil.
On resuming, the home team went off with the same dash that characterized their movements in the first half, and for a start. Milward hit the upright. Everton took a corner, and for some time play was both slow and uninteresting. Geary put a bit of life into the game by making one of his fast runs, but it was only a flash, and play was now even. The visitors left showed good passing, and Baker forced a corner. This seemed to stir tile home team up a bit, as soon after Geary notched a seventh goal. Up to this, Rowley had shown us none of the form he displayed here last season, but be now saved grandly on two occasion.  The visitors played up pluckily and had slightly the best of matters, but they were awfully weak in front of goal. The defence, too, was better, but Everton again scored, after Rowley had saved several times. Darkness was now coming on, and it was difficult to follow the ball. Play, however, was even to the close. Everton winning by eight goals to none.
The result shows a wide margin, and as none of the goals were of the "fishy” kind, my readers can take it for granted that it is a true representation of the play. In the first half the home forwards played as they have never played before. Brady did some clever work, and signalized his reappearance in the team by scoring the first goal. His play also influenced Latta's, and never since he came down has Latta showed such form. To sum up, they ran in harness well, and should form a dangerous wing. Geary tried new tactics to day, and. like some of the Everton supporters, he has found out that passing to the wings is more useful if not quite so flashy, and, on the whole, he did well. In Milward and Chadwick the home team have a grand pair. I was pleased with their play the first time I saw them, and have complimented them before. Of the halves, Holt was in his element, and seldom failed to gain his object. Parry also was all there, and the opposing forwards know what that is. Kane was not so prominent as the other two, but for all that he was quite as effective. He appears to be very cool in his actions, and his style seems to be something like Hannah's. The other parts of the defence were all there, though Smalley never was seriously threatened. To judge of Rowleys previous performance on the same ground, it would seem impossible to put eight balls past him. The back, did not render him much assistance, and throughout the first half their tackling and kicking was weak in the extreme. True, the home men were full of go, but backs of the experience of Clare and Underwood ought to have made a better show. They certainly improved a lot in the second half. The halves, too, did not shine, and altogether the home forwards were too good for the defence. The forwards did scarcely anything in the initial half, but on crossing over they now and again gave us some tasty bits, the left-wing being about the best, although McCormick was the most prominent individually.

BURNLEY v. EVERTON.
Lancashire Evening Post - Tuesday 05 November 1889
At Turf Moor, on Monday, before 2,000 spectators. The home team were minus McFettridge, and Frank Sugg kept goal for Everton. The visitors kicked off, and play commenced very fast. Sugg was the first to fist out, and the ball was placed over the goal. Everton became dangerous, and kept up the attack from the left wing, Cox being kept busy. Hands against the visitors put the home citadel out of jeopardy. Breaking away, Caldow secured the sphere and passed to Heys, who sent to Murray, the latter beating Sugg with grand shot, amidst much enthusiasm. Responding to calls of “Play up,’' Burnley continued the attack, Sugg having a warm time of it. Everton made capital combined runs, and made dangerous tries, which ultimately ended in Everton equalizing. Burnley had another look in, and Caldow headed the ball through, but the referee disallowed the point, and was hooted. Burnley, amidst the greatest excitement, scored their second goal, and half-time the score was—Burnley 2, Everton 1.  On the resumption of play Everton began pressing, and play was for a time all in the home quarters. Cox having to kick and fist out Burnley broke away and received a corner, which resulted in nothing. Friel was then temporarily disabled and the game was suspended. Subsequently, on resumption of operations, Everton equalized. In a few minutes faulty kick by Lang gave the visitors’ left wing a clear course, and Kane scored easily with a low quick shot. Hands in front of goal gave Burnley a couple of good chances, but the ball was got away. Play here was again suspended through Campbell falling to the ground, Kane having deliberately kicked him the back on the pretense of kicking the ball, which was nowhere near him. When the game was again in progress Everton were penalized for a foul, and directly afterwards another Burnley player was lamed. Burnley failed to equalise, and the game ended— Everton 3, Burnley 2. Exasperated at the foul play of Kane, who had been penalized and cautioned repeatedly, the crowd at the close entered the field menacingly, and was with great difficulty that the offending players escaped a serious assault. Getting on the-verge of the crowd, Kane bolted at full speed, and had to dodge the waiting crowds to effect his escape.

BURNLEY 1 EVERTON 3
November 5 1889.
The Liverpool Mercury
The postponed match between these clubs was played at Burnley yesterday and after a good game, the result in favour of Everton by 3 goals to 1.

THE BURNLEY CROWD THREATEN AN EVERTON PLAYER
Burnley Express - Wednesday 06 November 1889
REFEREE ACKOWLEDGES A MISTAKE
The postponed match with took place at Turf Moor on Monday afternoon, and brought together a fairly good attendance of spectators. The home team was constituted the same as on Saturday with the exception that Keenan took the place of McFetridge, and the visitors placed a strong team in the field. Sugg re-appeared in the Everton ranks, and assumed a new role -- that of goal-keeper, and it must be said that he acquitted himself well. Included in the visiting team was " Young” Brady, who formerly played for Burnley, and who had been suspended. Burnley won the toss and played with the wind, and even play followed for some minutes, and White, Bury, and Friel having being noticeable, Haresnepe got possession and compelled Sugg to fist out. Brady had unsuccessful shot and then having saved well, after which Cox saved finely, while Lang put another in useful piece of play, and Caldow showed up nicely, causing Sugg to save. Directly afterwards Caldow passed grandly to Heys, who in turn transferred equally as well to Murray, and he beat Sugg about ten minutes from the start, the home success being greeted with cheers, after which Burnley pressed strongly for some time. Everton then obtained a corner, which was got away, and in coining down Burnley had a good opening, but Murray and Haresnape misunderstood each other. A corner, however, accrued, and then Burnley were driven back. Returning, by good passing, Haresnape put in a splendid shot which Sugg fisted out grandly, a foul against Caldow following. Both sides showed up in turn, but at the end of 25 minutes the visitors equalised, Cox, whose arm was lame, trying to turn the ball away for a corner. From a corner Everton pressed strongly, and Friel leaded out. Burnley took an aggressive attitude, and had a free kick for foul against Haresnape, but nothing resulted. About 35 minutes from the commencement Burnley pressed, and one of the defenders headed out from a shot by Campbell, but Caldow placed the ball through. The referee, however, disallowed the point, though the goal was as good as one of Everton's. Burnley pressed hard, and after Murray had missed a chance from a centre by Heys they renewed the attack, and Campbell sent through with a beauty, the ball travelling near the corner immediately under the bar. The home side kept the upper hand, Lang and White coming in for recognition, while the forwards executed a splendid combined movement, and when half time arrived Burnley were leading by two goals to one. On resuming Sugg had to use his hands from a free kick, and then Lang was noticeable from a run and save. Each had a free kick and Everton gained an unproductive corner from a well-executed passing run, Burnley having to act on the defensive for a while. Everton wrested corners and Cox saved splendidly two or three times while the backs were all there. Burnley getting off Haresnape received the ball from Murray, but Sugg kept out finely at the expense of a corner. Fast play ensued. Friel was hurt by Kain and the game was suspended for a few minutes. About 20 minutes from resuming Lang missed his kick while Bury only kicked feebly and from the succeeding struggle in front of the home goal the ball was sent through, and though the point was appealed against, and very properly so, for off side, it was allowed, but to say the least the point was very shaky. Murray put in a good run but nothing came of it and Burnley were pressed once more. Five minutes after the other point Lang only kicked feebly and Cox was beaten again. The home side spurted on two three occasions and then had hands near visitors' goal. They gained nothing from it while another severe struggle took place opposite the Everton goal. Directly afterwards Kain, the left half back, kicked Campbell in the back—it seemed deliberately —for which he ought to have been ordered off the field. More' pressure ensued on the Everton goal, and Burnley having been pressed, effected relief, and Holt was penalised again for a foul against Murray. Both ends were visited, but no further score took place, and when the whistle blew Everton were the victors in a well-contested game, in which the home side showed to better advantage than for some time, by three goals to two. The general verdict was that Burnley had done well, much better than was expected, and the game would have been a very enjoyable one but for the roughness imparted the visitors, for which Kain and Holt were entirely to blame, though the latter in only minor degree. The spectators were incensed at the conduct of Kain that an effort was made to mob him at the close, a very lamentable state of affairs, and but tor the protection of some Burnley players would have got severely handled. The culprit got away without being hurt, but Doyle, who it seems bears a resemblance to him, was not so fortunate. He was struck on the face with a missile and an ugly cut inflicted. Among those on the stand were two Everton gentlemen, both of whom agreed that Kain had played a very dirty game, and one, who spoke as a person in authority, in answer to a remark addressed to him by a reporter, declared that the Everton committee would know how to deal with the player named. Afterwards Kain was accompanied by a roundabout route in order to avoid any ill-treatment. Mr. Helme, of Farnworth, it is said, expressed himself that if he had to give the decision over again he would allow Caldow's goal, while Sugg also stated that the goal was a fair one. A report got spread about that the referee had been mobbed, but on inquiring we find that he stayed behind until all was quiet. He certainly was much to blame for the exhibition of feeling against Kain, whom, if he done his duty, he would have ordered off the field.

EVERTON 6 WITTON 0
November 7 1889.
The Liverpool Courier
Lancashire cup tie (3 rd Round)
This match was played to-day, on the Anfield road enclosure, in beautiful weather there being nearly 4,000 spectators present. The composition of the home team was the same as in last Saturday match, the teams as followers; Everton: - Smalley, goal, Hannah (Captain), and Doyle, backs, Parry Holt and Cain, half-backs, Latta, Brady, Geary, Chadwick, and Milward forwards. Witton: - Forrest, goal Tattersall, and Frankland, backs, Whiteside, Isherwood, and Flecher, half-backs, Dimmock, Shorrocks, Smith Turner, and Grimeshaw, forwards . The start was made 20 minutes late when Everton took the kick-off with the slope in their favour and the sun shining in their eyes. A little midfield play having taken place, Geary put in a couple of attempts at lowering the Witton colours, the first shot going over the bar and the other passing outside. Some neat play occurred on the home left wing, when Chadwick made a nice effort, which Forest rendered null, Latta heading past the upright. A foul in front of the Witton goal ensued, and Doyle taking the kick placed the ball between the sticks, no point accruing on account of the leather not having been touched. The visiting right wing then carried the ball up, and Smalley finely saved a couple of good efforts to break through his charge. Brady next, after a nice run by Latta, merely failed to score with a pretty kick and then the East Lancashire boys made a determinant onslaught on their opponents defence, the ball being several times cleverly cleared by Smalley. A couple of corners to the credit of the visitors rapidly followed, but both were unproductive the danger being eventually removed by a kick over the line. Milward had a fairly good opportunity but he shot over the bar, and in unsuccessful corner followed soon afterwards. The Everrtonians opened a fusillade on their antagonists goal, all the forwards trying to get through though without effect. The play for some little time was unattractive, until a grand passing movement amongst the Everton forwards assumed a threatening aspect, when Isherwood finely averted the danger and enabled his forwards to again move up the field, where they gave Smalley a further handful. The home team again made tracks for the other end, and Cain took a good long kick, which was not far from its mark, the goalkeeper in endeavoring to avert his downfall granting a corner. The attack of the homesters was now hard to resist, shot after shot being sent in, and corners obtained though without avail. The pressure was sustained, Geary being responsible for a pretty and low kick which almost beat Forrest, whilst Latta was unfortunate in a further try at goal. The Evertonians continued to hold the advantage with no better result, Forrest retaining his charge intact by some undoubtedly clever labour. An exciting scrimmage having taken place in front of the Witton posts half-time arrived without a point having been scored on either side. After the interval Everton ran up the field and Latta tamely kicked over the bar when but a few yards to the left of the goalkeeper. The Witton right wing, gaining possession raced away, and Alston kicked the ball magnificently from the touchline, Smalley only just being able to prevent it from going though. The Witton goal then had many narrow escape, Forrest having to put in all he knew. At length the homesters were awarded for their exertions by seeing the ball pass the goalkeeper from Latta's foot. This success was repeated, but a few minutes later by the same player Forrest not being able to reach the ball; and the Evertonians thus took the lead by two to nil. Holt neatly tricked his opposing wing, and gave the ball to Geary, who passed it over to Latta and this player handing over to Brady a resting-place was found behind the goal. There was but a short interval, when Chadwick imitated Brady's performace with an admirable long shot just over Forrest head. A corner fell to the lot of the home men, and the sphere being well placed in the goalmouth Geary headed it through and increasing the score to five goals in the homesters favour. Latta, Brady, and Cain were very unfortunate in several excellent attempts, but the shooting showed remarkable improvement on that of the preceding half. The Evertonians sustained the pressure the forwards combining well, whilst on the other hand the visitors up to this point had scarcely ever invaded their antagonists' half. On two occasions the “champions of the League” appeared as if they would score from a scrimmage' but the hopes of the spectators were not realised. Just before time however, Latta again got the ball at his toes, and shooting across Forrest was beaten for the sixth time. Shortly after which the game was brought to a close. Final result Everton six goals Witton nil.


Johnny Holt - (Right)

LIVERPUDLIANA; BY RICHARD SAMUEL
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 09 November 1889
A DISCREDITED LEAGUE CLUB
The Stoke team last Saturday made a ghastly failure to justify their reputations to a position alongside the leading clubs of the country, and their last appearance in Liverpool has made it more than ever a matter of astonishment that they have ever been able to secure a place in the League, or to provide sufficient reason for the fact that at the voting for places in the League, the Stoke club was more favoured than any other aspirant last back end of the football season.  A few more such displays as that at Everton last Saturday will be too much for the best disposed of Mr. Lockett’s friends, and Stoke will have to make way for better teams next season.  Their forward play was simply shocking in its feebleness.  Their half-backs were incapable, their backs moderate; and if Rowley is a goalkeeper of extraordinary parts, this fact is altogether insufficient to atone for the melancholy feebleness of the rest of the team.  It is not my first impression of the merits of the Stoke team.  Their last previous appearance was at Bootle last Good Friday, when they never had a look in with the Hawthorne-rd team.  They were beaten by eight goals to none last Saturday against one of the most perfect, perhaps the most perfect, side ever turned out under the title of the Everton team. 
AT LAST
Everton are nearer the goal of their ambitions than ever.  Their team last Saturday looked almost perfect.  Large deductions must be made from the merits of their display, in respect of the demerits of their feeble opponents.  But after all the subtraction has been performed, the performance stands out as a very fine one.  Eight goals cannot easily be wrung from any team with the smallest pretensions.  And to take them from Stoke, with a goalkeeper in charge of the brilliance of Rowley, and a pair of backs to pass of the caliber, or to put it at its lowest estimate, of the experience of Clare and Underwood, is a very fine performance indeed.  The front line was a formidable one indeed.  Latta and Brady went together as if they had been associated for years.  And as the young Dumbarton man has always appeared somewhat disappointing, it has naturally been concluded that he was only suffering the lack of a fit companion.  Geary was all there on this occasion, especially in the goal-getting line, and the sturdy left wing was not a whit less sturdy than it has of late proved.  All eyes were upon Kane or Cain.  Which?  George Farmer’s place is at last in jeopardy.  The new Scotchman proved of the right stuff, and along with Holt bore off the honours of the half-back division.  Of the others nothing need be said.  They were not hard-worked.  There have been some peculiarities of football form this season and Stoke may be in a desperate mood today.  But it matters not.  Everton will again head the League list tonight.  And then the big game.  The Rovers and North End match was a big thing.  But ‘twill be no greater an event than this.  Can Preston win?  I think so.  Will Everton win? Very probably.  Aston Villa can beat North End; so can the Wolves; and if Derby County may snatch a victory from the champions, it will go hard but Everton shall emulate the action of these three.  Much will depend on Hannah and Doyle.  If these two remain firm, if they play up to their best form, the rest of the team is good enough to win.  But both have an awkward knack of making slips, and these are the very fatalities which wreck the chance of any team in a big under-taking. 

STOKE STIFLED
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 09 November 1889
By Mickey Free
Eight to nothing. Oh, what a squelcher, and that too coming hot foot on the poor display the previous week against Accrington.  Well, Rowley, I feel sorry for you. There can be no question regarding you having done year best to minimise the defeat, but you were badly supported. The forward play of Everton was an eye-opener, and some short-sighted individuals were heard the expressing the opinion that the great change was due to the introduction of Brady. Bosh. It was due to the fact that Geary fed his wings, and so well did he do it, that the forwards have never been seen to better advantage this season. This is just the very thing I advocated in my notes last week. After a few shots at the Stoke custodian McCormick made a pretty dash along the right, and looked all over like scoring. There was, however, a sturdy piece of humanity in his way, I.e . Doyle, and as this player was in good form, he soon changed their aspect of affairs.  Latta and Brady pounced on the ball, and by pretty short passing were soon within striking distance, which Brady proved by sending the leather past Rowley in a most unmissable fashion.  Cheers loud and long followed this performance. 
Twice in quick succession
The same pair baffled all opposition, and in each case Latta shot through, thus sending the Evertonians into ecstasies.  Stoke struggled hard to turn the terrible tide which was overwhelming them, but all to no purpose, as the home defence was impregnable.  Great cheering again broke out when Geary added a fourth point from a corner kick. Everton now had Stoke at their own price, for the better the home played the more disorganized did Stoke become, and before half time Brady and Milward both scored.
IN THE SECOND HALF
Stoke had the benefit of the breeze, but it brought no tangible advantage. Latta early troubled Rowley, who saved grandly at the cost of a corner. Then Geary became busy, and put the ball through twice, but one point was disallowed. McCormick made a couple of frantic efforts to get through, but he was dispossessed, first by Kane (Cain) and then by Doyle. Had he been less selfish the result might possibly have been better. The same player in conjunction with Gee got well down, but they were checkmated by the ever cool Hannah. A great combined rush of the blue and white forwards brought about the eighth goal. Chadwick now made prodigious efforts to score, as he was the only forward who had not done so, but Rowley defied him and the end came. Let the boys keep this form up and I fear nothing creeping. I imagine I hear some people say, “Hello, Mickey is on the bounce.” Well, avick, I don’t often indulge in that kind of luxury, so just let me have my little innings.
EVERTON WERE AT BURNLEY
On Monday and won a rough match by three to two.  The Turf Mooritee began the vigorous business very early, but they made a slight mistake, as Everton were more than their match at their own game. This had the effect of arousing the ire of the spectators, who crowded round the narrow exit leading to the drawing rooms. Stones were thrown and a few rotten eggs.  Latte just ducked in time to escape one of these sweet-smelling arrangements. Discretion being advisable under the circumstances the team made a sudden detour and so arrived safe. The Burnley executive should make arrangements to prevent a show of this sort.
EVERTON CAPTAIN
It surprises me not a little at times to read the wonderful yarns in various football prints anent the players and the internal affairs generally of the Everton Club. The latest is that Hannah, who is not only popular as a player, but highly respected as captain, going back to Renton, and his place is to be taken by McManus. It is all bunkum, sir, there bring not a particle of truth in it
THE LANCASHIRE CUP TIE.
Witton turned up on Wednesday to settle their little differences with Everton, and for a midweek match the gate was very good. The ground was frightfully heavy, causing the shooting to be in the first half at least very defective on the part of the home forwards. The Witton boys, however, shot very well, and there is no disguising the fact that they had the best of the argument in that line during the first half, but Bob was not in the humour to let’em slide. So no score was the result. The change of ends brought about a startling change in the state of the game. Alston made a splendid bid for a goal and then Everton’s turn came.  Latta scored twice. Soon after this Holt placed the ball to Geary, he to Latta, who put it back to Brady, and the latter notched a third goal.   Chadwick followed suit. The game was virtually over now, as Hannah and Doyle were hardly ever further down the field than the centre line, whilst Smalley was well up the ground. Geary headed the fifth goal. Forrest was sorely pressed, but kept his charge very well. Coming close on time Latta got another chance, and away went the ball sailing through, making the total to six to none. This makes three wins in five days, with a goal score of, 17 to two.

EVERTON V STOKE
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 09 November 1889
THE TEAM WHICH DID SUCH GOOD SERVICE FOR Everton last Saturday started by the 9.45 train this morning for the purpose of bringing off the return League fixture.  The Stoke team was as follows; - Rowley, goal; Montford, and Underwood, backs; Ramsay, Hendry, and Christie, half-backs; McCormick, Gee, Coupar, Baker, and McReddie, forwards.  The ground was in a very fair condition, and although the weather was dull a good game was anticipated.  Everton won the toss, and by the time Stoke kicked off there would probably be 3,000 spectators present.  Coupar started the ball, but Holt as once tackled Baker, and gave the ball to Geary, who passed to Latta.  This player neatly centred, but Geary headed over the bar.  Stoke now by good combined play brought the ball down.  McCormick got possession and by a really good shot lowered the Everton colours amidst tremendous excitement and cheering.  Immediately after the Stoke half-back Christie, got hurt severely, and was carried off the field.  Everton’s play, about this time, was not what might have been expected after the splendid exhibition given on the previous Saturday, and it was not till Stoke scored that they began to liven up.  Geary now had a chance, but the ball was badly managed by the left, and Montford just had time to clear.  Half-time arrived with Stoke 1, Everton 0.  Final result; Everton 2, Stoke 1. 

NUGGETS
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 09 November 1889

  • Poor old Potters!
  • Everton 8, Stoke 0; Accrington 9, Port Vale 0
  • The Everton flyer cannot expect to soar without wings.
  • Holt was far away the best man at Everton on Wednesday.
  • George Dobson scored his first goal this season last Saturday-for the visitors.
  • It is reported that Everton have offered Perry, the Albion centre half, 200 pounds to join them next season.  He is taking time to consider.
  • Heard on the stand at Everton; That shot of Geary’s fairly made the goalkeeper Row-ley’s eyes about.
  • Now that Everton have their full team playing North end will have to look out.
  • Everton make no mistake about their match with stoke.
  • Brady strengthens the Everton forwards considerably.
  • Rowley had a hot time of it at Everton.
  • Everton v Blackburn Rovers is a good draw.
  • Burnley and Everton played a rough game on Monday.
  • Dicky Jones of Everton, is captain of the elevator Brigade
  • Fred Geary is put down as the “best all-round player,” Most people outside Everton think this belongs to N.J. Ross. 

THE STOKE TEAM IN LIVERPOOL
Staffordshire Sentinel - Saturday 09 November 1889
ANOTHER CRUSHING.
Everton eight goals. Stoke none. Rather heavy defeat to explain away, is it not ? However my Burslem comrade is no better off, so we will make a start at once, and finish speedily as may be. In the first place, a word or two as to the composition of the Stoke team. Saver, Christe, and McReddie were absent, Clare suffering from lameness, and really unfit to play. Knowing this, one did not hope even for draw, but a licking of eight goals was even more than the greatest pessimist prophesied. On the other hand, Everton were better represented than ever before this season. They had absolutely their strongest team, and when the number of players at their disposal is considered an idea what Saturday's team was like may be obtained. Brady donned the Everton colours for the first time, and, judging the way which he performed on Saturday, his enforced idleness has done him the reverse of harm. A new half-back in the person of Kain was also included in the team. “Comparisons are odious,” know, but the names of the teams that took the held may be interesting: — Everton; —Smalley, goal; Hannah and Doyle, backs; Parry, Holt, and Kain, half-backs; Latta, Brady, Geary, Chadwick, and Millward, forwards. Stoke; —Rowley, goal; Clare and Underwood, backs; E. Montford, Hendry, and Smith, half-backs; McCormick, Gee, Baker, Coupar, and Ramsey, forwards. The start was a very late one, owing to the train being considerably behind time. When the ground was reached, it was found to be packed to its utmost capacity, and owing to the courtesy (?) of presumably a member of the Everton Committee, the writer could not obtain a seat, and bad to get through his task (rarely a pleasant one) standing on the top of some steps, notebook in hand, and getting a glimpse of the game occasionally. Everton started with irresistible dash, and Brady signalized his appearance by scoring almost before the Stoke men realized that the game had commenced. Latta promptly added two more, and the score was Everton four goals, Stoke none, ere the Stoke men had found their feet. They improved a little, but not sufficiently to keep their antagonists at bay, and at half-time Everton had the substantial majority of six goals. On resuming, the Stoke men improved very considerably, and the half-backs managed to prevent a great deal of the pretty combination which had been shown in the first half. Stoke only had about two shots at goal in the first portion of the game, but afterwards they were frequently round the Everton goal, Ramsay almost scoring on one occasion with his head. However they could not break through, and Everton, adding two other goals, won in most easy fashion by eight goals to none. The game was finished in darkness. The Everton players deserve the highest praise for their display and if they only maintain Saturday's form, will easily keep their position at the top of the League. The capabilities of Smalley are well known, and in Hannah and Doyle they have two grand backs. Ross is not missed in any way, and though the before-mentioned players are very fond of following the forwards up the field, they have plenty of speed to assist them in getting back in time to rob the opposing forwards. The half-backs are also three excellent players, and it would be difficult to single out one for special mention. Of the forwards, Latta and Brady were the pick, though the others were little inferior. Latta is a grand outside, and Brady played brilliantly. Geary passed very unselfishly, in fact he seemed determined to keep the ball no longer than was absolutely necessary. Chadwick and Milward also are fine wing, and complete fine front rank. The strong point of the Everton forwards is their shooting, and in this respect they offer marked contrast to the Stoke players. For several seasons the Stoke forwards have been noted for their weak attempts at goal, and this year they are no better than before. One naturally comes to the conclusion that they seldom get any practice, and on Saturday this was more than ever in evidence from the fact that it took the majority of the players about half an hour to find their feet. People will say that Rowley could not have kept goal well when he allowed eight shots top pas him, but the “D.L.F”. Could not in any way be blamed for the heaviness the of defeat. The shots were such as no man could stop, though Rowley asserts that he put the ball over the bar on the occasion of the last point being scored, but this point I will not venture opinion. The back play was decidedly weak, though Clare must not be blamed,’ as he was really unfit to play. In fact Edgar Montford went with the intentions of playing full back, but owing to McKeddie being out of sorts Clare was prevailed upon to take the field. He was suffering from an injured ankle, but will probably be all right for to-day. Underwood was greatly off colour, and seemed to have a fancy for breaking bedroom windows. Hendry was best half-back, and it was owing to his attentions that Geary did not show up so conspicuously he frequently does. There is no reason why Hendry should not make name for himself at centre-half, if he will give his mind to it. Smith did not play at all a bad game, especially in the second half, and evidently “Father’' is a long way from being done with. Mountford stuck to his work well, and got in a few good kicks, (and receiving in return a few knocks), but be is seen too much greater advantage at full back. McCormick was undoubtedly the best forward, though very selfish. He put in some good runs, which elicited applause. The others were very moderate, Ramsey performing rather better than I expected in his novel position on the outside left. Coupar appears to do better on the inside than in the centre. The moral of Saturday’s match apparently is—keep the defence intact, whether there are any forwards or not. Without unduly reflecting on the players, there must be something wrong to allow any team to score eight goals. One thing is quite evident, the forward rank is not class enough, and unless there are some radical changes, Stoke will certainly occupy an unenviable position towards the bottom of the League table. It is not the slightest use getting moderate players from across the border. There are plenty of medium forwards in this district. What is wanted, are a few really first-class men—something like the Oswalds, Goodalls, Ross. &c.—and then may hope for better things. Until this is done, Stoke will go on losing with clock-like regularity, heretofore. To-day will give the local enthusiasts an opportunity of seeing the Everton team, and I venture to think that Stoke will hardly get eight goals rubbed in on their own ground.

EVERTON v. STOKE
Staffordshire Sentinel - Saturday 09 November 1889
Stoke 1, Everton 2
Stoke for the second time this season encountered Everton to-day at home, they having been defeated decisively week ago at Everton. The weather was miserable, and no doubt owing the poor form shown by Stoke, very little interest appeared to be manifested in the result, the attendance of spectators not being large. The Stoke team was slightly altered from the one of the previous week, and was a little stronger, the elevens being as follows: Stoke. —Rowley, goal; Montford and Underwood, backs; Ramsey, Hendry, and Christie, half-backs; McCormick, Gee, Coupar, Baker, and McReddie, forwards. Everton.—Smalley, goal: Hannah and Doyle, backs; Parry, Holt, and Kane, half-backs; Latta, Brady, Geary, Chadwick, and Millward, forwards. At ten minutes past three o’clock Stoke kicked off, and the ball hung in the middle for a time, until Latta and Brady got away with it up the left wing, and the ball was sent over the cross-bar. The Stoke half-backs repelled the second attack, but the home forwards were prevented from making an invasion into their opponents’ territory. The ball remained in the Stoke half, although the attack was not a very dangerous character, owing to the resistance the half-backs. McCormick and Gee, on the right wing, had a chance getting away with the ball, but it was badly passed, and Parry had no difficulty returning it. Geary now put in shot from the centre, which only just missed its mark. Montford soon afterwards cleared his lines. Play was very quiet for a time, until some good passing the Stoke goal was placed in danger, and Rowley, in defending his charge, gave the first corner to the visitors. The Everton forwards still surrounded the Stoke goal, and Rowley stopped a shot; but had it gone through, the goal would have certainly been an offside one. Everton got a second corner; but it was badly taken, and nothing came it. McCormick now made a grand run on the right wing, which wound with good shot, which Smalley stopped. This was the first time Stoke had really been dangerous. After a run on the part of the Everton forwards, Stoke from a foul invaded the Everton half. McReddie putting in a capital shot, which was followed by one from Coupar, the ball in this case just passing over the cross-bar. Stoke were now playing a little better, but there were one or two weak spots noticeable in the forward ranks, and the combination was greatly at fault. The visiting forwards however returned to the attack, but Moutford and Hendry on two occasions defeated the object of the visitors. The Stoke goal was now placed in great danger, and appeared to have the Stoke goal at his mercy, but Rowley cleverly caught the ball, and gave a corner. Nothing came this, and from a good pass by Ramsey, McCormick had a chance, but he shot too soon. Stoke still pressed, and gained a corner, but advantage was not taken of it, the ball being very badly placed. Everton again attacked, but the Stoke defence was very good, while the forwards were improving. McCormick got away on the right wing, and put in a shot which Smalley' caught, but he could not hold the ball, which dropped behind the goal line, and thus the first goal was scored for Stoke after a half-hour’s play, and amidst tremendous cheering. Smalley again had to save, and just at this 'point Christie got hurt, and had to be carried off the field. Stoke, imbued with their success, kept the ball in the Everton part the enclosure, while all attacks on the part the visitors were repulsed by the Stoke half-backs and backs. The visitors worked the ball up towards the Stoke goal, but it was sent out, and the danger relieved. Brady followed this up, however, with good shot from the centre, which only just went over the cross-bar. Rowley saved a second shot, while a third on the part one of the Everton forwards went wide. Stoke again got near the visitors’ goal, and very nearly scored, as did Millward for Everton a moment later. No further score, however, took place, and at half-time Stoke led one goal to none.
After the usual interval hostilities were resumed, and at once attacking, Latta scored for the visitors, and the game was thus very soon placed on equal footing. Stoke  now made a splendid run, and Coupar put in a swift low shot, which Smalley only just stopped in time. Underwood was now called upon to clear his lines, which he did effectively. McReddie at this point made a run the length of the field, and in saving the shot Hannah gave Stoke corner, but it proved of no avail. Stoke still kept the ball in their opponents’ half, and Coupar headed the ball right into the mouth of the goal, but Smalley was there. Ramsey sent in another shot, which just passed outside. Everton now got very dangerous, Latta taking the ball to the Stoke goal, but Underwood just managed to get it away. The game was now being more hotly contested, and the ball travelled very rapidly from end to end. Stoke got a foul close to the Everton goal, but the ball was headed away. Stoke, however, stuck to the attack, and compelled the visitors to act on the defensive. Stoke got another comer, the ball being dropped right in the mouth of the Everton goal, but Smalley caught the ball, and threw it away. Stoke got another comer, but nothing resulted, and the ball travelled to the other end of the enclosure, where it remained for some time, being ultimately- sent out. Each goal was in turn attacked, but the defence of both sides was very fine. Stoke, of course, were handicapped by the absence Christie, but they were playing most determined game. The ball was again taken to the Stoke goal, and Geary scored a second goal for the visitors. Everton got a corner after the ball had been re-started from the centre, but it proved fruitless. The Stoke forwards broke away, but they mulled the chance in front goal. Rowley directly afterwards saved in splendid style, but the expense of corner.  Nothing came of this, and McCormick made quick run up the right wing, but he shot wide. No further score took place, and the game ended in a win for Everton by two goals to one.

LIVERPOOL AND DISTRICT NOTES
Athletic News - Monday 11 November 1889
By The Loiterer
Everton Reserves gave Burnley Reserve their quietus, the score being six goals to nil in favour of Everton.
Everton are trying to beat Blackburn Rovers in the matter of gates receipts, and that magnet of the football world-Preston North End- will be at Anfield Road next Saturday.  The Attendance is certain to be on the large side, and if the ground will hold 20,000 there will be 20,000 there, notwithstanding the fact that the charge for admission has been doubled. 

NORTH STAFFORDSHIRE NOTES
Athletic News - Monday 11 November 1889
by the committee in the case of Stanford sonic years ago, and the sub-committee determined to leave What am I expected to say of the "form,” or rather want of it, shown by the two crack clubs of the Pottery district -Everton v. Stoke, 8-0: Accrington v. Port Vale, 9-0 ? Truly the mountain has given birth to the mouse, and no question! Never in the history of the game have we been in this plight, and the sooner an element is introduced into each committee that has some knowledge of the game, and, what is more, can make itself heard, the better for we sadly "mortified mortals," who, being identified with the (so called) football of the district, are necessarily made to undergo the "pleasant"-save the mark!- badinage which should by right belong to the "discriminating" committee who so ably "ably. Mismanage" clubs which only require to have a small measure of success to receive abundant and generous patronages.
The team—a subject of grave anxiety—was of the usual character, except that Clare (injured) gave way to Edgar Montford. The game does not require much description. Everton had a lot the best of the first quarter of an hour, but their shooting was very weak and erratic. Stoke gradually forced the game, and played in much improved style. Edgar Montfort, Hendry, and McCormick showing fine form. After several warm saves by Rowley, the Stoke forwards got well into the Everton quarters, and an easy shot by Baker was cleanly put through by Smalley —a very soft goal. Encouraged by success, Stoke played up, and the game was of a most interesting description until Christie accidentally sprained his ankle and had to be carried front the ground. Half-time arrived with the home team leading by one to none. Everton on the resumption showed fine form, but the Stoke defence was grand until Underwood, missing his kick, let in the opposing forwards, a “bully " in front ending in a first goal to the Liverpool team. (Soft thing No. 2.) Ten minutes vigorous play by both teams found Everton one in front, and though Stoke played up manfully with ten men they were not able to equalise, and the match resulted in a win for the visitors by two to one—a score which about represents the game.

STOKE 1 EVERTON 2 (Game 33)
November 11 1889.
The Liverpool Courier
The return League match between these clubs was played at Stoke on Saturday, in dull weather, there being about 3,000 spectators present. Everton played the team which was victorious over Stoke and Witton teams as follows: - Everton: - Smalley, goal, Hannah (Captain), and Doyle, Parry, Holt, Cain, half-backs, Latta Brady, Geary, Chadwick, and Milward. Forwards. Stoke: - Rowley goal, Mountford, and Underwood, backs, Ramsey, Christie, McCronack, Gee, Coupar, Baher, and McCreddie forwards. Referee Fitzroy Norris . Stoke took the kick off, at ten minutes past three, and some play in midfield ensued. Doyle put in a grand kick, which gave Brady an opportunity of shinning, he passed to Latta, and this player centred nicely in to the goalmouth, Geary heading over the bar. The wings of the visiting team played in capital order, and Parry and Holt supporting them well gave the backs considerable apprehension but notwithstanding this no vulnerable spot was discovered. A capital piece of combination on the left wing of the Evertonians brought the ball down on the opposing goal, where Latta getting hold gave Rowley some work which was executed in the goalkeepers usually neat style. A corner kick was obtained and taken by Parry the advantage however, being neutralized by Brady shooting wildly. The Stoke men at last forced their way down, McCornack making a tide good run, but Doyle came to the relief. Then Milward managed to sprint along equally as well as his opponents, and when near goal he passed the ball cleverly to Chadwick, who made a clever, endeavour to score but just failed. The home team being somewhat stronger than when they met their antagonists at Anfield, were playing a much better game, but could not on any occasion breaking away. A good movement amongst the Everton forwards nearly concluded in a goal, Latta putting in a regular teaser and Rowley to save his charge having to fist behind. The Stoke right wing at length dashed splendidly down, but nothing tangible came of them. A corner kick, which was gained on one occasion being wretchedly played towards the Stoke goal. McCornick again sprinted grandly and shot in, Smalley could not hold the ball and consequently a goal was scored. The home men now played up with great spirit, and the forwards again menaced the Everton goal, when Christie received a strain and had to be carried off the field. With their opponents thus weakened the Evertonians put a better complexion on their play and Brady almost lowered the Stoke colours. The Stoke men, however, held more than their own and Smalley was once only just able to relieve himself of the ball when three men were upon him. The ball was carried to the opposite end, and Milward ought to have scored but he passed over to Geary, and that player kicked wide. Half-time Everton nil; Stoke one goal.
On resuming play, the visitors made good headway, but could not for a few minutes and a loophole. Then the ball was passed to Milward, who was standing well towards the goal, and he shot in, Latta rushing up just in time to complete the effort and equalise the score. The game at this point was discontinued for a couple of minutes on account of an injury to Geary, which fortunately did not necessitate his removal from the field. Coupar carried the ball down the field and nearly scored with a fine kick, and a few minutes later McReddie followed his companion's example with a chucking run, and Doyle through a miskick conceded a corner. This was also of a futile character, but the Staffordshire boys continued their attacks and it was with some difficulty they were kept out. At length Latta was the hero of a grand run, and a scrimmage in front of goal ensuing it was by more chance that the sphere was cleared. The homesters, despite the fact that they were minus one of their team, were playing a remarkably good game, and were if there was anything in it, having the best of the game. Milward now played at centre-forward, Geary taking his position as outside left, and the last mentioned player was credited with a magnificent fast run along the line passing all his opponents and forcing Rowley to desert his post in order to remove the ball. For some reason Geary, and Milward reverted to their ordinary position a few minutes afterwards, and great pressure was exercised on the Stoke goal for some time with no better luck. Eventually Latta and Brady worked the globe down and passed over to Milward who kicked the ball in, Geary making doubly certain of it. Nettled by the reverse, the home men fought the battle with vigour, Doyle, however, proving a great thorn in their side. Milward again forced his way along and kicked to Geary, who sent the ball in so neatly that Rowley had to lie down in order to prevent it from going through. Everton at this point pressed all the time and could not be removed from the Stoke half. Final result Everton 2 goals Stoke 1 goal.

EVERTON RESERVES 6 BURNLEY RESERVES 0
November 11 1889.
The Liverpool Courier
This match was played on the Anfield-road enclosure before about 2,000 spectators, in dull weather. The Burnley team were late, and it was about 3-40 when Binns kicked off for Burnley. The opening exchanges were all in favour of Everton, who quickly tested McConnrell but found him all there. Everton made several attempts to open the scoring account, but could not break through, and Burnley had a turn their attacks sharing the same fate. Hibbert and Ducksworth put in good work, and from a pass Binns just missed his mark. Everton retaliated, and “Billy” Orr put the final touch on, and beat McConnell somewhat easily. Burnley had several chances, but could not shoot accurately their shots being very wide. The Burnley right wing was cheered for pretty passing, their efforts resulting in a corner, which was abortive. Binns caused laughter by claiming a goal where the ball was at least two yards wide, of course the claim was not entertained. Play continued fairly even, Burnley right wing and the home left putting in good work. Crabtree put in a grand run, but could not break through the home defence. Hammond effectually meeting his attack, Orr had hard lines with a grand shot, which McConnell kept out. Half-time arrived with the score Everton Reserves 1 goal, Burnley Reserves nil.

Burnley started with great dash, and after a fierce struggle in the home half Everton took up the attack, McConnell being called upon to use his hands. He could not clear, however, and Walton shot the ball past him for the second time. Everton were now having all the game and pressed their opponents hard, Walton again beating the Visitors custodian with a grand shot. Hardly had the cheers died away when Walton obtained a third goal, and made the score four to nil. Hammond was cheered for grand defence, robbing three of his opponents at a most dangerous time, and took the play into home territory and had hard lines, a grand shot striking the bar. Everton retaliated with better result, Abbott obtaining the fifth goal in rather an easy manner. It was now very dark and impossible to distinguish the players across the field, but Everton attacked fiercely, scoring the sixth goal amidst the cheers of the spectators. Final Result; Everton Reserves 6, Burnley Reserves nil.

EVERTON REVIEW
November 11 1889.
The Liverpool Mercury
Everton emerged from a hard week's work with flying colours. First Burnley were overthrown at Turf Moor on Monday by 3 goals to 1, then Witton at Anfield on Wednesday by 6 goals to 0, and to maintain the harmony, Stoke on Saturday again vanquished only with considerably more difficulty at home then when abroad, and Evertonians are reasonably happy. The return match at Stoke turned out to be a very different affair as it was generally expected to be than that of the previous week for the Potters invariably show up well upon their “native heath.” Still Everton managed to win by 2 goals to 1, which is an advance on the drawn game of last year. The visitors put the same team in the field as on Previous Saturday, whilst the home club made three changes the two prinicipal being Christie (half-backs), and McReddie (forward) vice Clare and Smith. A drizzling rain made the ground soft, and footing uncertain but Everton opened, with a good rush, and gave Rowley plenty of work, which he disposed of in his most skilful vein. The next incident was in Brady getting hurt, but he stood gamely to his guns, and Everton maintained a steady pressure though none of the forwards seemed to be in the humour for brilliant shooting just now. Stoke when they got away were more fortunate, as McCornick shot from a long range, and claimed successfully for a goal though Smalley, failing with the ball, he was fully a yard clear of the posts. Shortly afterwards a slice of bad luck befell Stoke as Chrristie twisted his leg, and was compelled to retire from the game. Everton aroused themselves on charging ends, but it was not until a lot of neat forwards play had menaced goal that Latta could secure an equalising point. Subsequently though Geary received a kick and then joined Chadwick on the wing. Stoke were thrown more or less on the defensive, the Nottingham man scoring the winning goal shortly before the finish of moderate game. The losers played much better than when in Liverpool especially in the defensive department, Mountford being very troublesome to pass. The halves all did well, and McReddie divided the praise for forward play with McCornick and Coupar. Smalley had very little to do, the backs and half-backs being too effective to permit of many encroachment on his preserve, Holt the more brilliant of them all. The forwards combined well in unselfish tactics but were not at their best owing either to the slippery state of the ground of the amount of hard work they have been called upon to do recently. Everton, by the by, have now reached the half-way milestone having won 6, lost 2, and drawn 3 of the eleven matches played, against 6 won, 4 lost, and 1 drawn at the corresponding stage last season.

EVERTON NOTES
Lancashire Evening Post - Saturday 16 November 1889
That the wildest rumours have been flying about Liverpool during the week ; that the Bootle goalkeeper was reported have fallen Into the clutches of the Everton committee; that he had succumbed to the temptation of a £5 week: that all this was pure fiction ; that no one was more surprised than Jardine when the news appeared Liverpool evening paper; that the Everton secretary went round the office of the paper, and the contradiction of the statement appeared the same afternoon; that an East Lancashire club has been approaching the Bootle goalkeeper, but Jardine is not so easily caught a certain player who went the same place, but was soon found passage back Scotland.
That Kane has been quickly dropped by Everton; that George Farmer comes back his place in the Everton team to-day; that the Everton committee will not tolerate anything laxity, and that Farmer is coming out of suspension pronounced against him for neglecting to train and practice according to instructions.
That the excitement in the district about to-days contest between Everton and North End is tremendous, and there is no end of confidence felt about the issue in Everton’s favour; that North End will have to put in everything they know to escape defeat.
That Burnley Reserves suffered defeat by six goals to two by Everton Reserve at Liverpool; that the match was very rough and most of the Burnley players were hurt; that Corrigan, a new man, played a good defensive game at back for the visitors, and may be drafted into the first team; that the poachers in Scotland last week were not very successful the only one bagged being Corrigan. 

THE EVERTON CAPTAIN.
November 16, 1889.
The Liverpool Football Echo.
AN INTERVIEW WITH HANNAH- HOW FOOTBALL IS PLAYED.
Andrew Hannah, unlike other distinguished footballists, was easily accessible to your “special.” Through the courtesy of the hon, secretary of the Everton Football Clue (Mr. R. Molyneux) I was introduced tom Hannah, and from the same gentleman I received an invitation witnessed to-day's great –probably taking things for all in all, the most important that has ever been arranged between the Olympians of English football. “Greek will meet Greek” to-day, and may I be there to see. Hannah at the moment may be regarded, from his position, as the Champion Footballist of Great Britain, I'll tell you why. He is the chief- the captain of the Everton, which has lowered the colours of the greatest clubs in Scotland, the birthplace and the nursery of this great and popular game, and which is at the present moment a point or two ahead in all the League matches of the season. Everton was pretty well known before its great victory in Scotland; but when, after travelling from Liverpool, in October, they played the famous Celtic, in Glasgow, on their own ground, and beat them by two goals to nothing, their reputation became universal. There is no club in the country where there are such “gates” as there are at Everton, and probably there never has been such a gate as there will be today, when fully 20,000 people will pack themselves into the enclosure an hour before the commencement of the match, and when fully another 20,000 would gain admission if they could, notwithstanding the double prices. This is the match against the Preston North End, who have beaten the Evertonians before, and who are acknowledged to be the finest combination team in existence. Their “playing together” and their “close passing” is always a marvel of science and skill and decision, and in this respect Everton has hitherto been behind them. There are some members in the Everton club who are fine individual players, and are looked upon as “brilliant” by the crowd of onlookers for individual and isolated feats of prowess, but as Mr. Hannah wisely and judiciously points out, these personal performances do not win a match, no matter how “pretty” they may look to the spectators. It is the combined action that asserts the superiority of the team, and in this quality the North Enders have been supreme. It is to be hoped that this time the great improvement of the Everton group, under Mr. Hannah's stringent discipline, will give the North End a particularly hard nut to crack, and that the gold medallists and others who have so great a temptation to show their personal skill at the expense of the combination will be so suffciently under the control of more experienced minds that they will no imperil the chances of the match. Let me here, before introducing the reader to Mr. Hannah briefly mention that this year's record of the team is a remarkable one. They have won twelve matches, lost two, and drawn three. Their have beaten Stanley, Earlestown, Blackburn Rovers (3-2), South Shore, Burnley (2-1), Bolton Wanderers (4-3), Earlestown, Celtic (2-0), Stoke (8-0), Burnley (4-3). They have lost against the Wolverhampton Wanderers (1-2), and Notts County (3-4), and drawn against the Wolverhampton Wanderers, Derby County, and Accrington. This is surely one of the most brilliant records that ever fell to the lot of a football club.

Mr. Hannah is a quiet unsumming gentlemanly young Scotchman without very much appearance of the professional athlete about him as he sits in his little parlour writing a letter home. He gives me a courteous welcome, and offers with pleasure to give me any information that I may think of interest to the readers of the Echo. Occasionally a trifle cautious in answering questions, and with the tact of his countrymen he likes to know the drift and measuring of them before he answers. He is, however, as keen as usual. I was born, he say at Renton, and I was twenty-five years of age on the 17 th of last September. I started football as early as I was well able to walk; but seriously when I was fourteen. I played first with the Renton Wanderers, along with Kelly, McNea, and McCall, who are celebrated players. I first played with the juniors, and I was induced to join the Renton combination when it started. We were all very young then, and you will remember that this team beat the North End last year. It held the Scottish Cup –which is equivalent in importance to the English Cup here –for three years. They held the “Charity Cup “ for four years. I have played “back” since ever I started football. I was a professional jumper for four years, but played football in the winter. I was the champion jumper of Scotland for two years, and I also went in a little for running. I won a few sprint races, but I was always at jumping. I have seven gold medals for football –chiefly in Scotland, and I have had a large number of other prizes, such as clocks and things. In athletics the prizes were chiefly in money. I daresay I have won £300 altogether at jumping. I am the right back of the team. I played left at first, but I got my left knee hurt, and I could not play on the left wing for some time, so I shifted to the right wing, and have played right ever since. (Mr. Hannah here explained very interestingly to an outsider like myself how it was that either the left or the right leg had to be used according to the side of the field the player is placed on.) I came here first, he continued, in September last, and this, therefore in my first year as a “professional.” I was made captain when I came N. J. Ross was captain last year. He came from Preston and has gone back there. I was elected captain by the committee. Of course they had seen me playing in Scotland often. The committee have full power. Of course the captain has certain power. I some times attend the meetings if they went my opinion. The club as a body consists of season-tickets holders, and they elect the committee to govern the club. The committee deals with the admission money. The average receipts for a match is probably about £160. Some matches have brought a £200 gate, and probably on Saturday, when the prices are to be doubled, the receipts will be £400. The income last year was between £4,000 and £5,000. Of this £1,000 was spent in improving the stand accommodation. The salaries of the players, who are all professionals, run to £3 a week, but some of the players get more than this. I have played in every match with the team, and in no matches outside it. Our best match was, I think, with the Blackburn, on September 7, when we won by 3 to 2. We beat the Celtic –the best team in Scotland –by 2 goals to nothing, and considering that we travelled from here to their ground I think that was a very good performance. We were accused of playing a bit rough, but they played quite as rough as we did. As a rule, they play rougher in Scotland than here; the umpires being not nearly so strict there. Sometimes a player on the spur of the moment may lose his temper. But generally after the match we are all friends again. “ I saw the match against Blackburn Rovers, “ I interposed, “and I saw a man ordered off the field. Do you think there was any real foul play, or that it was his fault?”

“ I don't think it was altogether his fault. He is a big, heavy chap, and sometimes a heavy man may play a bit rough without meaning it.” What do you think of the Association game as compared with the Rugby? –Well, the best critics know that the Association game is the more scientific. There is the least danger in it, and accidents are comparatively few. Any serious accidents in your experience? –I have known two or three at Renton, such as fellows getting their collar bones broken, but in the Rugby game you hear of legs and arms being broken every Saturday. As I said –they are much stricter here than in Scotland. As to the advantage of the Celtic when we went there, I consider a resident team playing on their own ground has the advantage of the visiting team by a goal against those who have had to travel. What is the most important position in the game: - Well, all positions so to speak are “most important.” Some way the half backs, because they are a kind of backs and forwards combined. A half-back has to stop the opposing forwards and feed his own forwards, so I think myself the half back is the most responsible position on the field. The captain: - Well, the captain, if he sees any weak points, may shift the left half backs over to the right, he can shift the team as he thinks right, to try and make up any defect. The Everton team may so far be regarded as a leading team, and I think we are ahead this year, so that so far we may be considered champions of the League. We have, however, not played half our matches yet. If we beat the North End on Saturday we will be top of the League.

How is your team as compared with the North End: - Well, I think, taking our men all round individually we are quite as good as the North End, but we have not got the same combination. They work together better than we do. The North End is the heavier team by far. I think they and Renton team are the two best for scientific play. The great art of football is the short passing game. It is better to tackle a man when they are all closed up than it is in long passing. The short passing is the best playing game right up to the gaol, when you have the best chance of shooting through. The best rule is to work well up to the goal, and then “Don't hesitate to shoot.” Trainor, of the North End, I think is the best goalkeeper, and then Lindsay of Accrington. Smalley is our best, and I think he is not far behind either of them. Some goalkeepers are clever with their hands, others with their feet. Trainor is a wonder with both hands and feet. He is 5 feet 9 inches, and can stop either high or low ones. As to our training, we train twice a week on our ground in private, of course. This week we have been out three times. Does your training and playing during the season involve any particular dieting? – No we, just take out own diet as usual. The Everton team are all most temperate men. None of them are very fond of strong drink, though we do not pretend to be altogether teatotal. That is the ruin of some of the Scotch teams –perhaps one or two of the players will get drunk previous to the match, and a man that drinks too much can't play football; I don't care who he is. In the course of our practice we run a couple of sprints –30 or 40 yards. We sometimes divide the team, and sometimes shoot for the goal and such like. I certainly think that speed is conducive to good football, though not always. Geary is apt to be too fast sometimes. If he gets clean right past the backs he can beat them, but it does not always come off; and the centre forward should feed his wing. Geary goes in sometimes for single-handed play, and it looks brilliant. It might come off twice in half-a-dozen times, but it can't always come off. This is a little defect that can always be remedied.

Who is the best all-round player? –Well, in my opinion the best all-round players are N.J. Ross, of the North End, and Drummond, or Oswald, of Notts County. But it depends on the position. Another man could not play in my place, and I could not play in Geary's place with the same satisfaction. Hannah added that he was 5ft 7in., and weighted 11 stone 7lbs. He is a dairyman by calling, was married eighteen months ago, and speaks with affectionate regard for the native place and his home. He made some strong remarks about the absurdity of the Scottish system of alleged “amateurism.” They are supposed to have no professionals in Scotland, but as a matter of fact (though he had never received six pence himself there) he knew many players who received pay in Scotland, and the regulation of the Scottish Association in this respect was set at defence. He though very strongly that they ought to legalise professional play in Scotland as in England. There was no mistake professionalism did exist in Scotland. He spoke most warmly of the Everton committee, by whom he had been handsomely treated. He had been told before he left Scotland “ that they would not pay him,” but he laughingly added that the committee had treated him in a thoroughly business-like manner. He thought they ought to have a good chance of winning on Saturday. Had seen good players “funk” before a match to such an extent that they were sick before going on the ground, but once they got experience they were as cool as a cucumber. He never looked as the crowd himself or took the slightest notice of cheers or hisses. Anyone who did would be “ put of his work.” Sometimes in the excitement of a game a player could not hear the shouts at all. Football was “the most popular game in Great Britain,” and he personally could not help playing it. Couldn't say what he would do without it. Where he came from the little boys of three and four played it, or tried to. Had never played cricket or baseball. At football there was sometimes a great advantage in choice of stations, especially if there was much wind. The Everton ground, he understood, would hold over 20,000 people, and it was the most perfect ground in the kingdom, particularly for accommodation. Your “special” took his leave, wishing the Everton captain and his team every success.

LIVERPUDLIANA; BY RICHARD SAMUEL
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 16 November 1889
CHANGE
Eight to none; Here is the difference between “home” form and “out” form.  No one in Everton believed that Stoke would beat the all-conquering team, but experience has not been lost upon these keen footballers, and there was even a trace of anxiety in the personal of the latest from the scene of operations.  That Stoke were compelled to play with ten men throughout the second half was unfortunate for them, and possibly made the difference to them of a lost match. But from one who was present, and not an Evertonian, I learn that the bearings of the game could not hare been altered by this untoward incident, end that it is most probable that- Everton would have won under any circumstances. In point of fact, that their superiority was manifest throughout.
LINERS-NOT ATLANTIC
Football Liverpool is in a ferment.  Dissensions Bootle?  Engagement by Everton of Jardine at £5 a week! Engagement of another famous player at £2OO the season!  In the choice diction of my Hibernian confrere it is bosh I Absolute rot!  And it is all along of those liners, those lying liners. A certain Bootle player is said have had a grievance with the Committee. He certainly felt aggrieved, but had no grievance. Mine honest gossip is a person of much objection at Bootle. He is given to solemn head-shakings, quiet whisperings, frequent knee-quakings, and evolves much from his inner consciousness. But he will soon become extinct. He is recognised, unmasked, and beheld as a humbug. No, there is no dissension at Bootle. The story of Jardine is a pure fiction. Davy enjoyed the joke immensely, and was not a little flattered at the fabulous price at which his services were estimated. Mr. Molyneux caught up the lie before it had got fairly started, And thereby scored a record. The Bootle Treasurer, too, got in hot pursuit of another lie, and proved himself a flyer. One word, gentle liner! Trust not the head-shaking, knee-quaking avbilations of the Bootle croaker, and thy lines may then he blessed with the unction of truth.

EVERTON AT STOKE.
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 16 November 1889
Y Mickey Free
Whether it was that the hard work of the previous week had told its little tale on the form of the Evertonians or that it was due to the Pottery men making a better fight on their own plantation it is hard to say definitely, so I’ll split the difference by concluding there was a trifle ‘of both. Undoubtedly the home team were stronger, but this was pretty well discounted by the loss of Christie after half-time, yet on the other hand it must be borne in mind that very early in the fight Brady got an ugly dig in the ribs which almost incapacitated him for the rest of the match, so with two to one we must be content. I’d be better pleased to able to able to record that score against the Deepdalians to-day. A sufficient interval elapsed between dinner and play, and the blue and whites were the first on the field. The ground looked all right, but before the game had grown very old it was manifest that the going was heavy, and consequently not suited for our forwards. Stoke soon followed, still it was nearly twenty minutes after time when Baker set the ball on the go, The home right pair were soon scudding off, Doyle tackled and sent the leather to the right, where Latte took it along and screwed across the goal-mouth, Geary heading over the cross-bar with a trifle too much “bottom” on. Hannah next checked a nice movement and Chadwick made a bad finish to good beginning.
Everton were pressing just now, Latta called on Rowley to clear a warm one. Again, from a free kick, Rowley just saved by conceding a corner. The ball was well placed, but Brady headed over. The next feature was a pretty run and shot by McCormick, but Smalley cleared. Doyle put the ball to Parry, he to Milward ; the left wing pair then dashed off, Chadwick shot, Rowley hit out, and again luck was against Everton, as Latta headed over. Some good play ensued between Parry, Geary, and Holt, but it was now Johnny’s turn to shine on the wrong side of the post, and then McCormick had another shy at Smalley. The latter slipped, and made a wheel round before throwing clear. A claim was made that the ball was carried through, and, much to Bob’s disgust, the point was allowed, and so Stoke were the first to score, and half-time saw Stoke leading. What a change on the previous Saturday! Just on the interval Christie appeared to get his ankle twisted, and had to retire. The boys now settled better to their work. Holt tried a long shot, and Rowley hit out; but Latta met the ball, and fairly carried it through at his toes, thus equalising.
GEARY NEXT GOT CRIPPLED
and went on the left. Milward coming centre. Stoke made a couple of brilliant dashes, and Smalley had two shots to negotiate. Then Doyle put the ball to Geary, who sprinted along and finished with a good shot. Rowley cleared, but Geary was soon back, and after a stiff tussle the ball was worked over the line. Hendry, Ramsay, and Montford were exerting themselves their utmost, but failed to prevent Everton gaining the winning point, as from a long pass by Latte, Geary scored the second goal. Several  corners now fell to Everton, but they were unable to break through the defence again.
THE PLAYERS.
Milward, Geary and Latte were up to form. So was Brady until he got hurt- Chadwick was, however much behind the others. Cain played a good steady reliable game, who appears to be getting faster every match. Holt was in splendid trim and worked hard. Hannah and Doyle were also in excellent form, as was Smalley. Taken all round the home team played a much superior game to what they did at Everton. The defence was stronger, and this gave Rowley a chance, and he was all about. The result leaves Everton again at the top of the League, but as other clubs who stand well have not played the same number of games it is not much to work on by way of comparison. Give us a fine day to-day, won’t there be a crush at the Anfield enclosure. Aye, that is certain, and we also ought to have the certainty of a game worth going to see. 

WITH THE LIVERPOOL JUNIORS
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 16 November 1889
By the Unknown
A respectable gate favoured the match between Everton and Burnley Reserve teams at Anfield-road. The home team were on the ground punctually at the advertised time, and, owing to the visitors’ late arrival, were able to Indulge in a little goal-getting practice. Binns set the leather rolling for Burnley, and an attack was at once made on the home defence, but Nidd was in grand form nod easily relieved the danger. Everton doing all the prosing experienced hard lines on more than one occasion, shots by Orr and Abbott being smartly cleared by the burly McConnell. At the interval Everton were in advance by one goal to nil.  On the resumption the home team’s neat short passing and pretty dribbling completely baffled the Bumley backs, after the fourth goal had been notched by Everton it was apparent that the pace was too much for the visitors, who failed to score a single point.  From now to the finish the home front rank were busy trying to beat McConnell, who kept goal remarkably well.  The result terminated in a win for the “blue and whites” by six goals nil. It was about the best game played this season by the Everton Reserve, and not a chance was thrown away by them. The tackling and kicking of the backs and half-backs was very good, and Joliffe in goal managed what little he had do without a flaw. The combination of the forwards was a lot better than what we have been accustomed to lately, Dean and Walton being the best of the bunch. Of the Burnley men one cannot speak too highly for the plucky manner in which they kept pegging away despite their continued reverses, some of their runs and centres being worthy of the first team, Crabtree of the forwards being a long way above the others in merit, and showed a grand turn of speed.

RE EVERTON V BURNLEY
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 16 November 1889
Dear sir,-“Mickey Free” is wrong in stating in his notes of last week that “Burnley began the vigorous business.”  Does he rely on what he sees, or what he hears?  If the former, then he is asserting what he knows to be untrue; if the latter, why, one lesson should have sufficed, vis, that learnt from believing the statement of a certain player, who declared he had not signed for Burnley,- I am sir, A Lover of Fairplay. 
A RECORD AT LIVERPOOL
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 16 November 1889
EVERTON V PRESTON NORTH END
Barnum’s boasted "Greatest Show on Earth” drew 15,000 spectators last Monday. To-day, Everton, attendance was nearer 18,000, so that I take it if public patronage is anything to go by, Barnum's colossal elephants must take a back seat, and concede the premier place to the more mammoth attractions of Football. This is not the time nor place to tell the history of Everton’s wonderful rise in popularity, and how the management have by sheer enterprise, pluck, and perseverance against many obstacles placed their club within a very short space of time in the front rank ; nor is it necessary to dwell on the extraordinary skill by which Preston North End has been built and maintained as the premier combination for the exposition of the Association game. Suffice it that to-day they were fighting for what is really the Eiffel Tower of the League, the summit of which is acknowledged to confer on the proud party in possession the distinction of champions of the world. The Everton Executive had fully recognised the importance of the occasion. Their arrangements were as perfect as human ingenuity could make them. Every inch available was utilised in the best manner to secure the greatest accommodation for the greatest number, and they had their reward in the tremendous assemblage which taxed their resources to the utmost. True, there were hitches as there always will be on such occasions. At one period, during a most exciting part of the game, considerable consternation was occasioned by a contretemps which it is hard see could have been avoided. The great open stand behind the goal at what may be termed the Liverpool end of the ground was packed to its fullest capacity. Everton were pressing, and indeed a shot was put in which all but scored. The pent-up excitement of the crowd could not restrain itself; the back rows surged forward like a great wave of the sea on to the front ranks; there was a momentary interval as they tried to resist the impact, but the weight was too heavy and the hoarding which separated the arena from the auditorium giving way, some hundreds in front were precipitated to the ground, those behind falling on top. The game was at once stopped, and it was feared that many must have been seriously crushed. Great relief was felt, however, as the majority attained their perpendicular, and as far as I could see the only individual requiring serious attention was a young lad, who had been crushed beneath the boards, and who was carried across the ground, and examined. Happily, as far as could be ascertained, his hurts were only of a temporary nature, and the game was resumed in comfort, after a delay of a few minutes. At another time I may have something to say about the assemblage insolent deadheads, who, by some means, had got possession of great portion of the accommodation provided for the Press, to the exclusion of some of the legitimate occupants. But at the present moment more immediate matters demand attention. The sun shone down brightly on the scene, with just a suspicion of haze, however, which foreshadowed fog later on. Soon after one O’clock the public began to arrive, determined to secure good places for the struggle which was fixed to commence at 2-45. Members of the Council of the Football Association, and other leading lights of the football world occupied seats on the reserved stand, and the crowd poured in steadily until long before the start there wasn’t a square inch of sitting, and scarcely standing room. Considering that the prices were doubled all round, this alone is remarkable testimony to the eager enthusiasm of the public and the immense popularity of the game. A reorganization of the Preston team was resolved upon for this match, Holmes being left out and N. J. Ross returning to his favourite position at full back: Everton : Smalley, goal ; Hannah and Doyle, backs; Parry, Holt, and Farmer, half-backs ; Latta, Brady, Geary, Chadwick, and Milward, forwards. North End; Trainer, goal; Howarth and N. J. Ross, backs; Kelso, Russell sad Graham, half-backs; Gordon, Ross junr. Thomson, Dewhurst and Drummond, forwards. Referee; Mr. F. T. Norris
THE GAME
Everton were first on the field at 2-35, and were greeted with a round of cheers. Five minutes later North End arrived, Graham leading the van and the “gallant 600,” who travelled by special from Preston, gave a ringing welcome—a special shout being reserved for Jack Ross. Then the referee walked on by himself and there was more applause. Up went the coin, and it was soon apparent that North End had won the toss for they placed themselves with their backs to the sun. Promptly to time Everson kicked off and Ross, junior, passed to Dewhurst, Doyle making a smart return. Then the Everton right was busy, and Ross, Sen., had plenty to do to check Latta. North End came again, but not for long, as Milward got away and passed to Geary, who, however, failed to reach the ball.  Some tricky play by Gordon and Ross, junr. in the corner followed, but they were closely tackled, and ultimately Ross kicked into touch. Play veered to the other side where North End had one or two throws in, after which the Everton halves were cheered. The ball travelled down and Geary was in a dangerous position, but the backs tackled in time and so averted disaster. Ross jun. tried to force his way through, but Doyle though passed got up again, and he stopped Thomson directly afterwards. Gordon screwed into centre from the corner and Dewhurst almost got up, Hannah conceding a corner. This came in beautifully, and North End were very dangerous, but by desperate efforts the backs cleared, their grand tackling being loudly cheered. Kelso was rightly penalized for a nasty trip, and Doyle taking the free-kick shot well into goal. The ball sailed over the heads of the players and was shot for goal. It was at this juncture that the hoarding gave way, at the back of the goal, precipitating the crowd on to the ground and stopping the game for time. On resuming it was seen that the referee had awarded a corner as the result of the Everton attack. This was put in and the ball came up the field very fast. Everton were penalized for fouling a man in front and Jimmy Ross took the kick. He passed to Drummond who centred, and Dewhurst first headed over. Then Everton again attacked on the left, followed by a rush up by the North End right, hands terminating the run. Ross, junr. passed to Gordon, who put in a terrific shot along the ground, Hannah meeting it capitally. Dewhurst then made a rather weak effort the ball going a lot wide against the boards. North End were now pressing hard, and Doyle saved another from Gordon. Relief came on the right, but Ross, senr. pulled up Latta.  He again got through, however, and crossing to Chadwick the latter took a shot, which rolled over. Again the crowd swayed forward as the struggle progressed in the corner, and the boards once more fell, but this time nobody came to grief. The Everton right were hard to shake off, and Brady was loudly applauded for a shot which just skimmed the bar. Veering to the other end Thomson took a long shot, which was not dangerous; nor was one against Trainer by Chadwick soon afterwards. The North End goal was doomed to be the first to fall, for after Geary had knocked the ball hard against a back, and Ross had prevented it going out, Brady rushed up and scored with a shot which went through at the corner. There was an appeal, but the referee upheld the goal to the delight of the Evertonians. Animated by this success Everton pressed like demons, and the North End defence was never more sorely tried as shot after shot went in. Relief came but it did not end in anything tangible for North End, Jimmy Ross finishing up an attack by kicking over. Give and take play was now the order of the day, the great speed of the first half, hour having told on the men. Jimmy Ross again shot over the goal, and Drummond was penalised for off-side. Then Everton again woke up and attacked on the right, Ross and Graham having a regular handful with Latta and Brady. At length Ross, Junr. just appeared to have the goal at his mercy as he passed to Doyle, but with nothing in front of him he once more shot right across the goal mouth. Coming down again Everton had a corner, which being cleared, Russell sent the ball forward and Gordon put in beauty which Smalley saved splendidly. He kept out another from Drummond, and had just cleared a third in equally good style when the whistle sounded for half-time with Everton leading one to nothing. A liberal consumption of lemons occupied the players during the interval, which owing to the indulgence of the referee was of generous proportions.  A continued buzz of conversation occupied the time the merits and chances of the respective teams being eagerly canvassed. Up to now honours were equally divided, and neither could claim have overmatched the other, although Everton had the goal to their credit. Once more the men got into line, and the signal was given for a resumption. North End at once assumed the offensive, and a shot was sent just wide of the posts. A lot of persistent work by the Preston centre and inside wings, to which the Everton defence responded manfully occupied some minutes, and it terminated to the joy, of the visitors in Thomson getting through and scoring the equalizing goal. The excitement consequent on this was only just simmering down when Everton were on the attack, and they narrowly missed improving on their position. Chadwick passed to Geary who had a splendid chance, but shot outside. Latta now made a brilliant run down the wing, but was prevented from shooting by Ross, the ball passing into touch. Drummond had a chance, but instead of shooting passed the ball to Thomson, who shot out.  A second goal was now secured by Preston, giving them the lead. A third followed almost immediately after, Gordon shooting from a pass by Ross, jun. The North End combination began to show itself, for a fourth was quickly added, followed soon after by No. 5. Continuing to press the North End right broke away, but Doyle spoiled their attempt, and the ball was quickly carried to the opposite end, where Ross, senr. just prevented Latta from scoring. Gordon now became conspicuous for a fine run, ending with a beautiful shot which, however, Smalley saved. The Everton left now got the ball well down, but Howarth prevented them from becoming too dangerous. “Time " was now called with Preston ahead by five to one. Final Result North End 5, Everton 1. 
SPECIAL
Stupendous crowds, feverish excitement, and splendid weather were the features at Everton. The game commenced at lightning speed, the tackling on both sides being superb. For some time the ball was kept in the centre, and then Preston, from well-placed corners, severely tested the Everton defence. A minute later Kelso gave a foul, and Doyle’s free kick resulted in a scrimmage. Trainer saved. The ball hit the crossbar, and had just got a few yards away when the barrier behind the goal gave way, and the game was stopped a few minutes. A foul to Preston nearly resulted in score, and then Dewhurst and Ross, junior, had shots. Chadwick had next a soft shot at the Preston goal, and Milward nearly scored. The game was extremely stubborn, Everton playing like demons. Ross not letting the ball out, Brady scored amid tremendous cheers. North End now severely pressed, but the Everton backs took quick and vigorous measures to save. Ross, jun., missed three grand chances, and splendid play followed on the Everton right. Smalley thrice saved magnificently, and then the interval arrived. Two shots in the first two minutes of the second half fell to Preston, and four minutes later Dewhurst equalised. The Preston citadel had two very narrow escapes. The individual play both sides was very fine, but the back play on both sides was too strong for the forwards. Smalley again saved grandly, and Doyle, Ross, and Howarth were applauded for fine kicking. The Preetonians were delighted when Russell scored the second goal, and brilliant shot by Gordon a third. Everton were now collared, and by rare combination North End made rings round their opponents. Russell scored the fourth and Ross, jun., the fifth. Five goals in 20 minutes’ is almost a record. Smalley and the backs were now much weaker, and Everton heavy-hearted. Trainer and Ross showed grand defence. The Preston football was much admired, and deservedly so, the crowd being quite satisfied as to the respective merits of the teams. Not much interest followed. North End nearly scored another goal, but all the players evidently had had enough. Spasmodic runs ruled supreme, and Everton retired badly beaten.
EXCITEMENT IN PRESTON
Intense excitement prevailed at Preston this afternoon, anent the big match at Everton.  Crowds assembled in the main street, in front of the newspaper offices, awaiting the result with feverish anxiety.  Vehicular traffic was carried on with difficulty.  When the result was posted up the crowd cheered excitedly, and an animated scene presented itself as they dispersed. 

PRESTON NORTH END RESERVE V. EVERTON RESERVE
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 16 November 1889
These powerful junior teams met at Deepdale before 1,000 spectators.  Everton brought a strong team, which included Joliffe, Kirkwood, Orr, and Nidd, erstwhile first team men.  North End played ten men, Inglis being away.  The game was very evenly contested, both goalkeepers being hard pressed.  Everton got one through a few minutes before half-time.  The second half was stubbornly contested, but no further score was made.  Final Result; Everton Reserve 1, North End Reserve 0. 

NUGGETS
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 16 November 1889

  • Which of the Everton players has been fishing in Scotch waters this week?
  • Everton think they were lucky to beat Stoke last week.
  • Mr. Clayton looks well after Everton reserve.  He is very popular with the players.
  • Everton Reserve have won 10 matches, lost 1, drawn 1, and scored 42 goals against 12.  Not bad this.
  • Have Everton defeated North End today!
  • Stoke gave Everton a good game at home.  It was not eight goals to none this time.

THE EVERTON HEROES.
November 16, 1889.
The Liverpool Football Echo.
During the past few years, the Association football has made giant strides, in Liverpool and district, as witness the existence and prosperity of such teams as those disporting themselves before thousands of spectators, week by week, at Everton and Bootle; also somewhat minor clubs of good standing, as the Stanley, Bootle Athletic, and a dozen teams, all capable of giving a fairly scientific exposition of the game. Ten years ago, a good game of Association football was not to be seen in the neighborhood, the field being almost entirely held by the Rugby Union men. But each year the circular ball had continued to assert a rivalry with the oval, till now the two clubs first named are the means of drawing more spectators than all the Rugby matches put together. And their comparative standing, too, is far ahead of the local Rugby clubs; for New Brighton, Birkenhead Park, Liverpool, or the Old Boys all occupy much lower positions in the world of Rugby football than do the Everton in the Association community. The Everton men can give the best teams in the three countries a good game; while the local Rugby fifteens make but a sorry show against such a team as the Fetter Loretto men, West of Scotland, Bradford, and the local champions hailing from balmy Runcorn. Then, in the matter of gates, Everton stands at the top of the list, there being very few clubs in the British Isles showing a weekly average equal to the register of their takings. Yet it is only nine years since the club was formed, their first ground being a public one, in Stanley Park, where of course, the great desideration of every Association club –“gates” to wit –could not be obtained. For several years the club's existence was not conspicuous for any remarkable feats, all the players being local and purely amateur ones, both of which qualifications have now been done away with. Of which more anon. After four years' play, the public interested in such matters aroused to the fact that Everton might be made famous for other things than toffee, and the supremacy of that toothsome dainty as the particular and peculiar characteristic of the place was at the last threatened, The “King of Everton” –who as all the world knows, is Mr. John Houlding –consulted with his liege subjects, and the result was the acquisition of a piece of land near Stanley Park, Mr. Houlding generously financing the transaction. With the modesty of greatness, the committee at first erected a couple of small stands for the accommodation of spectators, and until the end of 1887 these sufficed. At the beginning of last season, however, it was found absolutely necessary to increase the accommodation, which was done, at the an expenditure of £1,500 with the result that Everton ground is now as comfortable and as well fitted as any in the kingdom. At each side are large covered stands, behind each goal are other stands, holding nearly 4,000 each, and taking all the stands together, about 12,000 people have a good view of the game from them; while another 6,000 have the same from standing room on the ground. Notwithstanding this, the spectators at times are almost inconveniently crowded, and gates of nearly 20,000 are not altogether unknown. The total receipts last year were £4,500; but of the sum at least £45 was expended every week for paying the professional players. There were, however, circumstances, which will hardly occur again, necessitating this large outlay. Several professionals who were engaged at the beginning of the season did not realise the expectations formed of them, and others had to be looked for, so that the committee were compelled to pay for men whom they did not require. Owing to their lengthily goldbags, the Everton Club can offer to good professionals exceptionally favourable terms, and of course the Land of cakes, being the home of the Association game, has had to part with several fine players, who show an inclination of going “back again.” Among them are a couple of Scottish Internationals –Hannah, the captain, and Alexander Latta. Although Liverpoolians and especially Evertonian folk, are proud of their club, it is to be regretted that there is not a single homegrown player in the team, as this is surely a sad indication that the district cannot raise a man of really first-class form. It will doubtless be of interest to-day if we give a brief sketch of the football career run by the Everton team. Individually as it was constituted a few weeks ago; but doubtless one or two alterations have been made, Weir for instance, not turning out of late, owing to injuries received. Beginning at the goal we take RE Smalley who frequently known as Bob Smalley. Bob is a professional of the game, who's place on the field is under the cross-bar, where he has achieved no little fame. He is 5ft 8in, in height, and his kicking weight is 10st 10lbs. Robert is a Lancashire lad, and first saw the light in 1866 in the town of Darwen, after which the family removed to Preston. There Bob joined the North End, and for the reserve team he made his appearance as left wing forward. During a match he was roughly handled and subsequently to this he was allocated the post of goalkeeper, and in that defensive position, he has remained, repelling hot shots, fisting out shots. He has played for the Everton now for two years. Then come the two full backs, of whom A. Hannah (Captain). Andrew is his front name, and Scotland is his nation, for he was born in Renton, Dumbartonshire on September 17, 1864. He stands 5fy 7ins, with his coat off, and kicks the beam –not to mention the ball –at 11 and half stone. When sixteen years of age, Andy betook himself to jumping, an exercise in which he speedily attained and rivalling of springheel Jack. He attended all the games, as athletic sports are termed across the border and won many prizes, both in running and jumping contests, and truly he made a good thing out of his speed and spring. The Renton wanderers soon enrolled him in their ranks, and as full back he played with both sill and in judgement. Soon after the Renton club took him, and Hannah becoming a member rapidly worked himself into the front rank of footballists. He was chosen to represent his county against Glasgow, and later on he played full back against Lancashire, and he afterwards represented his country against Wales in 1887, and last season his services were wanted by the Everton Club, with the result that at the beginning of the present season he was installed as captain. Hannah is not only a fine player, but he makes a good captain. The other back is, D. Doyle , the biggest man in the team, standing an inch and a half under six feet, and weighting 13 and half stone. Danny is not such a broth of a boy as his name might imply, for it was in Paisley he was born, over twenty-three years ago. Doyle's weights has served him in good stead during the eight years he has figured on the fields of various clubs, his first love being the Airdie Club, which he added for four years than playing a season with Brosburn, and afterwards with the Edinburgh Hibernians. In 1888, at the beginning of the season he went to Grimsby, leaving that club for the Bolton Wanderers before the season closed. With the Wanderers he did great things being on the ball when they beat the proud Preston by 5 goals to one. In may of this year Doyle broke the proverb by going back to Scotland, but he once more said farewell to Auld Reakie and the Gralasmarket, and joined himself unto the Everton club. Both as a defensive and an aggressive player Doyle is a valuable man, and plays with equal football on either side. The right half-back at present, is Charles Parry , who has seen but nineteen summers, or perhaps in the case of a football player we should say winters. At any rate, he is nineteen years of age, 5ft 8 in, in height, and weights 12st, 2lb when in good conditions. He is a robustly built young fellow, and has been extremely useful to the team, first as a forward, and more recently –since Weir was hurt at Wolverhampton –at half-back. Parry's first exploits in the football field were on behalf of a small football club in Oswestry, subsequently casting in his lot with the Chester St. Oswald's with whom he played as centre forward till last season was well on the wane, when he joined Everton. The left back is G. Farmer , who was born in Oswestry twenty-six years ago, weights 11 st , and stands barely 5ft 6in. Geordie is a great favourite with the Everton people, before whom he has been for a long time, being almost a Liverpoolian by right of his seven years' residence here. Taking into account the tender age of the game he may be fairly called a genuine Liverpool player. The gentleman who does the sketches for the Football Echo has rather failed to catch Geordie's charming smile, but for this he has nobly attempted to compensate by giving a fine moustache. Farmer and his smile appeared first to support the fortunes of the Oswestry eleven, and by his qualification there be thrice donned jersey for Wales, look you, as left wing forward. He has played several times for Lancashire, and no district team of Liverpool is complete without him. As a forward he played a dashing game, being as full of tricks as a Waterbury watch, but he has now settled down at half back, where his defensive tackling finds full scope. J. Holt , the centre half back, who is twenty-one, weights 10st, prompt, and is 5ft 4 and half inches, high so that he is not a large man. John Holt began his football career at the age of fifteen, with the Kings' Own F.C., but he ultimately joined the Church Club, and there were soon marked as a fine player. Four years since he came to Liverpool, playing with the Bootle Club for two years, but last season he came to Everton, being a very great acquisition to the club. Holt is without doubt one of the best half-backs in England, his tackling capabilities being what the old Dominie, termed “Prodesgious!” Last Year he played for Lancashire against East of Scotland, the country winning by seven goals to one. Last year he narrowly escaped becoming an international, being chosen as a reserve against Scotland. Probably one of the greatest favourities with the Everton crowds is F. Geary who is but a slender youth, weighting 9 stone, and being 5ft 7ins, above the level of the sea, so to speak, as it were, or words to that effect. Geary is a Nottinghamtonian –that's a good word –and first saw the light in the Lace City on January 23, 1867. A few years after this auspicious date he joined the Bothwell Rangers, playing both well and hard. He continued but one season with the Rangers, and then got on the books of the Basford Rovers, whom, however, he did not serve long, going to the Notts Rangers, with which club he played for three years. Inducements of a pleasant character were instrumental in securing his presence in the ranks of Everton. He was in Liverpool soon after the close of last season, and during the Athletic term he went in for amateur sprinting, in which field he carried off three firsts, two seconds, and ditto of thirds –not at all a bad record for toeing the mark nine times only. He subsequently ran as a professional, and in August last he won a £20 handicap in a most easy fashion, although he was a rank outsider in the opinion of the knowing “bookies.” Geary's great speed, his lightness of foot, and his agility are eminently useful qualities, and it is a sight to him scouring down the field with the ball at his toe, puraned by hopeful but leaden-footed opponents. The estimation in which the speedy forward is held may be gauged to some extent by the result of a competition recently organised by an athletic paper, Geary being voted the best forward in England. Although that is a matter for discussion, there can be no doubt he is one of the best centre forwards in the country. Alexander Latta , outside wing forward, is twenty-two years of age, he weights 12 stone, and stands 5ft 8in, in his socks. Since 1884 he played for Dumbarton Athletic, of which club he was as original member. He was chosen in his county team eight times, and he further represented Scotland against England in the matches last season, and against Wales the previous season. Latta is a new acquisition so Everton this year, his play being of that well judged nature which so strengthen any team. He is a really fine all-round player, and his large experience against first-class clubs is of much use to him. He has won about a dozen medals in football contests, the majority being gold trophies. Alexander Brady . Is another son of Caledonia. He is nineteen years of age, 5ft 5 and half in, high, and weighs 10 stone. He is fairly fast, very tricky, and has a wonderful control over the ball, which he can twist. Curl, and break in a manner the most surprising. His forward play is very good, his training being the Renton star and Renton Thistle Clubs. Last year he went to Sunderland in which club he played as an amateur, and subsequently he figured with the Burnley team. Later he returned to Glasgow, but was given a call by the Everton Club, with whom he hopes to remain. Edgar Chadwick is a Blackburn lad of twenty years, weights 10st, sharp and his front elevation is 5 and half feet. His first experience of the game with a club called the “ Little Dots,” which qualified him for a place in the Blackburn Olympic Reserves. His play in the team was so good that room in the first eleven was made, and Chadwick soon justified the action of the committee so that the Blackburn Rovers annexed him for a season, and last year he joined Everton. Edgar is a fine all round footballists, being a good shot, an excellent kick in any position, leaving one foot free, and his capabilities are available as half-back, or forward-a most useful man for the best team. J. Weir was a fine half-back for the club, but he got hurt some weeks ago. Although he is not yet playing again. Cain , who played with the Airdie Club till lately, has now joined the Everton, and plays at half, vice Farmer, who has not altogether please the committee of late. Milward, who plays for the first team this season, is a capital forward, although one of the youngest members of the team. He formerly played in the London district, where he earned for himself a reputation, which his play here has already enhanced.

EVERTON v. PRESTON NORTH END.
Athletic News - Monday 18 November 1889
EVERTON FAILED TO STAY THE COURSE
By “The Wee Critic”
Evertonians have been so well satisfied with the team that has donned their colours this season that even the match with the powerful North End was viewed with equanimity by the average supporter. The match had been the subject of conversation all over the city during the week, and all sorb of wild rumours respecting the composition of the home team had been circulated. A large crowd was expected, and it was generally thought that the Anfield enclosure would be thoroughly packed; and so it proved, but the arrangements were splendid, and, except on one occasion. when the swaying of the crowd behind the Oakfield-road goal broke down the barriers, they proved satisfactory. About 18,000 were present, and after a preliminary canter the players sorted themselves out as follows;-
Everton; Smalley, goal; Hannah, and Doyle, backs; Parry, Holt and Farmer, half-backs; Latta, Brady, Geary, Chadwick, and Milward, forwards.  Preston North End; Trainer, goal; Howarth and N.J. Ross, backs; Kelso, Russell, and Graham, half-backs; Gordon, Ross, jun, Thomson, Dewhurst, and Drummond, forwards. 
The onlooks were terribly excited and directly the game started the noise commenced.  From the kick-off play was fast and in favour of the vistors, their forwards and half-backs by their splendid play, causing the home supporters a lot of anxiety, as the ball for a little while was unpleasantly near the Everton goal.  First Doyle and then Holt was successful in dealing with Gordon and Ross jun., but North End forced two corners, which were cleared.  The home team now had an innings and from a free kick they experienced "hard lines, - as Trainer fell in saving, but all Geary could do was to hit the bar. It was now that the boarding gave way behind the goal and play was suspended for a few minutes. On resuming the home team took a barren corner and again matters were serious from an Everton point of view, as a foul close in was given against Doyle. Dewhurst, however, spoiled Drummond's a shot at goal. North End, as far as play went, were streets in front of the home team, their passing being grand, but slightly overdone; still they had the best of the exchanges, but Hannah was very safe, and covered Smalley well. The home right now put in some effective passing, and as a result. Trainer saved a difficult shot. Having got in their stride, the Everton forwards gave several brilliant touches, and continuing to improve, Trainer was eventually beaten by Geary amidst the wildest demonstrations of delight. The kick-off brought the North End no relief, and the home lot were most persistent in their attack and, being well backed up, play for a time was of a scrambling order in front of Trainer's charge. At length the ball was worked out, and the visitors enjoyed a brief attack. Play was now fairly even, but there was a wide difference in the mode of attack in the two teams the home players infused a lot of vigour into their work, and let fly whenever an opportunity presented itself.  On the other hand, the visitors seemed to be in an exhibition mood, for frequently the Whole of the forwards would join in perfect combination straight up to the goal, and that was all. The home backs did the rest. Towards the close of the first half they gave us a taste of what was to follow, and Smalley saved well on three occasions.
On commencing operations in the second half, It was plain that the visitors meant " biz,” Their first run was blank, bet not so the second, as Thompson did the trick. Geary and Latta next had shies, but in each case they were wide, and from now to nearly the close there was only one team in it. There was no mistake about it, the North End were terribly in earnest. and from a –“foul " Graham headed through. Next Gordon sent in one of his expresses, and Smalley, by a splendid exhibition of goalkeeping, kept them at bay for a little while, but Russell came dribbling all over the shop, and finished up with a fourth, and Ross. jun., followed with a fifth goal. There's a transformation for you. Most of the home lot were flying signals of distress and Ross and Gordon seemed to do what they like with Farmer and Doyle. A spurt by the home team relieved the monotony, but Trainer kicked clear, and Doyle came out of his shell and stopped a combined run by Dewhurst, Thomson, and Ross, but danger was not cleared for some time.  Play eased up a lot, and the home team made desperate efforts to add to the score, and had the best of matters in the last ten minutes, but the North End at the close had the substantial majority of five goals to one. The result was very disappointing to the Liverpudlians especially the great difference in the scores. I don't want to detract in any shape from the splendid performance of North End, for I am of opinion they could hate rubbed it in thicker than they did: but few will deny that the heavy ground was in their favour. All through the game was fast, but at the start it was a caution, and on crossing over it was plain the Prestonians had something up their sleeve. In the first place their forwards did not exert themselves to the same extent as the Everton front rank; in fact, their style in the first half was decidedly of the exhibition stamp. I cannot expect everyone to swallow this, and a lot of people will put it down to the superiority of the home defence; but look at the change in the second half, when they put on five goals in twenty-one minutes, and it was nothing, but clever combination and accurate shooting which did the trick. There was only one weak man in the whole team, and that was Dewhurst. The forwards all through showed rare passing, and the shots that took effect would have beaten any goalkeeper. A lot of the success of the team was due to the splendid play of the halves, and whether in attack or defence, all through the game they were a long way in front of the home lot, and in the second half especially they seemed to have no difficulty in securing the hall from their opponents. Howarth and Ross, at back, were safe, and as cool as possible, whilst. Trainer, in goal, could not be blamed for the shot that took effect.  Notwithstanding the heavy score against hint, Smalley kept goal in his best style. Lots of shots he stopped, but he had no chance with any of the five which passed him. Hannah played a good game, but Doyle was not fast enough for the men against him. He was, moreover, handicapped by Farmer's feebleness, and before he was aware of it Gordon and Ross were at close quarters, and generally they were too nimble for him. Parry and Holt in the first half were good, but, like the rest, they were not in it when the North End forwards took the whip hand. The forwards were good after about ten minutes' play in the first half, and their method of attack more conducive to scoring than their opponents in the same portion of the game. But throughout the match they have not been seen to less advantage this season. Milward and Chadwick could not do any passing, and Geary was scarcely more successful. Latta and Brady were the best couple but the latter got very weak, and was not able to reader much assistance when the home team were making desperate efforts at the finish to lessen the ' difference in points.

EVERTON NOTES
Athletic News - Monday 18 November 1889
 N. J. Ross had a splendid reception at Everton on Saturday, and he played a rattling game in his old position at full-back. He is a wonderful player, and seems able to adapt himself to any position in the field. The victory at Everton on Saturday was one of North End's greatest achievements, and the manner in which they worked the ball about drew forth the admiration of even the most biased of the Everton spectators, who were loud in their praises of the champions. This is the first time Everton have been defeated on their own ground this season, and five goals to one speaks for itself. And yet some people say North End are “worn out?" They don't think so at Everton.
What a crowd they had at Everton on Saturday. It proves pretty conclusively which is the team for drawing purposes. Our congratulations to Mr. Sudell and the North End team on again heading the list.
CHIPS
Everton may have plenty of money, but they don’t throw it away on giving goalkeepers 5 pounds a week, I am informed that they have one secured for next year at a far less price than that, and Jardine is not the man. 
Out Everton way they are of opinion that their present goalkeeper is equal to Jardine. A lot of people think the report was circulated so as to influence Smalley’s play against North end. 
The falling of the barrier at the great match might have been a series matter, but luckily no one was seriously hurt, the lads, I fancy, being more frightened than injured. 
The result of a big match came as a surprise and was really a battle for championship, North End displacing Everton for the top position.

EVERTON 1 PRESTON NORTH END 5 (Game 34)
November 18 1889.
The Liverpool Courier
Fans injured as barrier give's way behind goal
At twenty minutes to three the Everton team arrived on the field, and was greeted with loud cheers. The team was as follows: Everton: - Smalley goal, Hannah (Captain), and Doyle, backs, Parry, Holt, and Farmer, half-backs, Latta, Brady, Geary, Chadwick, Milward, forwards . A few minutes later the visitors came on, and were received with an enthusiastic outburst of cheering. The team was composed as follows: - Preston North End: - Trainor goal, Howarth and Ross (NJ) (Captain) backs, Kelso, Russell, and Grahams half-backs, Gordon, Ross (Jun), Thompson, Dewhurst, and Drummond, forwards. Fitzroy Norris referee. Hannah lost the toss, and Everton had to play with the sun in their faces. Geary took the kick off, and attempted to pass to Brady, but Graham interposed and kicked to Doyle, who removed the play further down the field. Latta and Nick Ross were on the ball, and the North End back was only just able to clear. Then a pretty piece of play between Chadwick, Midward and Geary took place Howarth, however beating then. The Visiting left wing carried the ball up. Parry neatly beating them. Another temporary raid by the home left wing was made, Howarth again cheering, and giving Gordon and Young Ross a chance. They went away, and some pretty passing occurred at the top corner of the field, the venue of the combat again being removed. Up and down the field the players went, Chadwick and Milward giving Latta a chance but was robbed by Ross not a second too early. The North End went up the field in gallant array forced a couple of corners, which were well placed and equally well defended. Latta was next prominent but found Graham a stumbling block, and then Kelso was well hooted for fouling Milward. The leather was taken from the kick right in the North End goal mouth, and the crowd, which had become intensely excited, swayed forwards, and the barrier behind the goal posts, broke down before the tremendous pressure of the thousands of people behind. A great mass off people lay on the ground, and some of those under neath were hurt, one boy apparently being severely injured, as he was carried by several of the officials to the centre of the field. Play was stopped for some minutes and conjectures were made as to weather the ball had gone through the posts previously, as it appeared to have done. The barricade having been placed in position again, a corner was given to Everton, the ball, however, being kicked behind the posts. North End took up the play from the kick off, Ross, jun, and Thompson being to the fore and “hands” was given against Everton right in the goal mouth, but the leather sailed high over the bar. Ross spoiled Latta when that player looked like becoming dangerous, North End not being able to remove the danger the home forwards playing together in grand style. Nick Ross kicked high in front of the own goal, but Milward could nothing with the chance, “hands” against the visitors again helped Everton, and Russell meeting their attack, transferred the played into the home quarters, where exciting play took place, Dewhurst eventually ending a fine concerted attack by kicking behind. Thompson, Jimmy Ross, and Gordon showed good combination, but were robbed by Doyle, who kicked to Ross, and the players returned it with interest. Hannah replied to the same effect and Latta rushed away, Chadwick and Milward shooting in beautifully, Trainor having to save. Jimmy Ross dashed away up the right, Holt coming to the rescue and enabling Latta to run down and send in a grand long shot, which did not attain the success, it deserved. Dewhurst Ross, and Thompson ran and passed splendid down the centre, but Dewhurst lost his head, and, shooting wildly, a grand chance was lost. The play up to this point had been of the first water, and Everton took up the play, and a grand attack ended by Geary beating Trainor amid thunderous applause. Again Everton were on the attacking side, and retained the ball well into their opponents' territory a regular bombardment being opened on the North End defence, by which the spectators were kept up to a pitch of wild excitement. All the forwards had their attempts to lower the Preston colours defeated, and a length Geary unwittingly caused the play to be changed to midfield by a kick behind the upright. Brady initiated a pretty movement, frustrated by Russell, and play settled in midfield for a few moments. Geary was cheered for a grand pass but Farmer kicking too hard spoiled a grand sequence of passing. North End had a turn, and gained a corner taken by Drummond but Doyle easily removed the danger not to be denied, North End came again, and Jimmy Ross shot over the bar-a near thing. “Hands” against North End was given in midfield, but the North End forwards sailed down in line Parry grandly spoiled the passing and gave the leather to Milward and Chadwick, who rushed down a grand style, Geary however, rendering the movement useless by kicking right to Thompson's feet. When endeavoring to pass to Latta, each end was visited in turn, the calls, however, being fruitless. When North End were executing some of their beautiful passing in front of goal, Drummond was penalized for offside, and again Everton were assisted by “hands” against Russell. This gave Latta another opportunity his shot just failing its mark. The visting right wing raced up and Young Ross propelled the ball clear over the bar, when a goal appeared imminent. Milward forced a corner from Howarth, but Gordon relieved and Thompson and he took the leather right down the centre. Dallying too long, however, Doyle was enabled to rob them and gave the leather to his forwards, who did not make anything of their chance, North End again were to the fore and Smalley grandly saved two shots from the foot of Jimmy Ross, one bring especially difficult to prevent from going through and further he nullified a grand attempt by Gordon. Half-time- Everton 1 goal; North End nil. Upon recommencing the visitors made tracks for the opposing goal, Smalley distinguishing himself by rescuing the ball from a couple of well meant attempts by Thompson and Ross and Farmer spoiled Gordon and kick out of play. Jimmy Ross received the ball, and when just about to shoot, Holt splendidly took the ball from the feet. The visitors were at this juncture having all the play, and could not be checked, Thompson from a pass by Dewhurst, shooting pass Smalley and making the score equal. Kicking off Everton rushed the leather into the visitors quarters, and an exciting scrimmage took place in front of the uprights. Offside against Everton gave relief and play again settled in midfield, Geary broke away, and after rushing through his opponents had the goal at his mercy, but shot wildly, to the evident disappointment of the admirers. Graham easily beat the home forwards, when they were becoming dangerous, and a foul was given against Everton in a dangerous position. Nothing came of it, Smalley neatly clearing North End swarmed like bees in front of Everton's goal, and at length a foul was given to the visitors' close to the goal line. The kick was well placed in the goalmouth, with the result that Russell headed over all his antagonists and scored a second goal for his side. North End received the leather from the kick off, and again swarmed in front, Thompson sending a hot one to Smalley, who scored grandly when failing. North End had evidently got the foot of their opponents, and were having nearly all the game. Everton amidst the encouragement cheers of their supporters tried hard to breakaway but could make no headway, and Gordon from a pass by Thompson beat Smalley for the third time with a magnificent fast low shot. The Preston boys were playing away with wonderful dash, Smalley being compelled fisting the ball away. The Everton right tried to get away, but Nick Ross was on the ball, and would not be denied, his privilge of checking the advance. He gave the ball to his right wing and Smalley was within an ace of being defeated by a low shot by Dewhurst's. Having tasted blood the visitors were battling with that earnestness which is characteristic of them, and Russell and Jimmy Ross raised the score to fourth goals against Everton's one. North End rushed right away from the kick off, their football showing what scientific football really was, and Jimmy Ross easily beat beat Smalley. Graham was a stumbling block to Latta and Brady effectually spoiling them and giving his forwards splendid chances, of which they were not slow to take advantage, and a perfect fusillade was kept up against the home fortress. Dewhurst raced up the centre and passed finely to Thompson, Holt robbed him a gave the leather to his front ranks. Weak combination again was to the fore, and North End, playing with great dash gave Smalley several hard nuts to crack, one shot by Kelso being very difficult one to negotiation. Smalley just managed to keep it out. Doyle was cautioned for rough play. Latta got away and again found that Nick Ross was too clever for him, and mainly owing to this fine player does Howarth the Evertonians were rarely suffered to make an invasion assist tactics. The play was settled in midfield, all the efforts of the home team to get forward seeming fated to ill-luck. Compared with their opponents they moved with the agility of snails and were repeatedly to bad. Nothing was too difficult for the visitors to attempt and time after time when it seemed impossible for the left-back to get near the players or the ball, by dashing runs or plucky tackling the Evertonians were defeated. Final Result; Everton 1 goal, Preston North End 5 goals.

PRESTON NORTH END RESERVES 0 EVERTON RESERVES 1
November 18 1889,
Liverpool Mercury
No details.

EVERTON REVIEW
November 18 1889.
The Liverpool Mercury Preston North End on Saturday'came saw, conquered “There is nothing novel in this statement-the fact has been repeated oftener by North End than by any other club in a given time-but, whilst none are surprised that Everton were beaten, few were prepared for their utter rout of 5 goals to 1 on their own ground, the greatest disaster Everton have suffered for at least three years. Liverpool like other places, made much of the visit of the English cupholders. No club enjoys such widespread popularity and though their success has not of late been so uniform as previously, they still charm as no other club can. If engaged in an exhibition game merely they are sure of having the honour of performing before a “full house.” But the match on Saturday was not a show; it was a stern bout-of-great moment, the issue of which was of such concern almost as a final cup tie, for whatever emerged in triumph would head the League and Probably remain there for the rest of the season. Everton have made such a great name for themselves this year that the contest was generally considered an open one though Preston North End were the most fancied and with the promise of a splendid exposition of the dribbling game, there was, of course a phenomenally large company present. The capacious ground was packed to overflowing. The total number must have been very near 20,000, whilst a great many more were refused admission. The executive of the club admirably carried out the arrangements for the accommodation for the vast assembly, and only one mishap has been record. In the excitement of a severe assault on goal by Everton, the swaying crowd forced down the barricade behind goal, and about 100 spectators tumbled forward in a heap but happily the only injury reported is a broken arm to a boy. Prompt to time the players appeared on the scene, all were well received, J.N.Ross particularity so. The home team opened badly, by losing the toss, and had to turn their faces to the sun but this was balanced somewhat by having the advantage of the slope. Play started on pretty even lines, Preston showing the better combination. Gradually Everton gathered strength, and the left wing were enabled to get within shooting range when Milward struck the post. Geary sent in a return from Trainor and claimed to have scored. Simultaneously, however the crowd fell in and stopped play, a corner was the ruling of M. F.Norris, and the game was renewed after five minutes delay. Everton returned frequently to goal just now in good formation, and in a while Brady cleverly beat Trainor from a central position the shout of triumph being taken up-gain. Nothing further was scored up to the interval. Though North End were very near equalising just before the whistle blew. The fact that Everton led by a goal at half-time was duly recognized with cheers and all so far, was as merry as the proverbial marriage bell. But a rude awakening was at hand, so soon as the restart had been effected the visitors swooped down on Smalley in irresistible force their firm footing and short passing enabling them to pen Everton up, and with seldom a breakaway to relieve the monotony, the home team for 20 minutes were thrown hard on the defence during which period five times Smalley was defeated. The game afterwards was more even, but Everton could make no good aims, and had to retire badly beaten. The explanation briefly appears to be this. The ground was heavy, Everton held their own when fresh and playing downhill, but were paralyzed when having the hill against them. North End were heavier man, and, being thus able to stay better could maintain, and indeed improve their unsurpassable combination. They individually played a superb game, with the exception perhaps of Dewhurst. All the physically strong men of Everton did well, and Holt never did cleverer work, but Farmer, Geary, and Brady, seemed completely fagged before the finish. Everton's solarium in a record “gate” together with the Reserve's victory of a goal, over Preston North End's Reserves.

EVERTON FOOTBALL CLUB
November 19 1889.
The Liverpool Courier
To the editor of the Liverpool Courier.
As a patron of Everton for the last five years, and a spectator at the Preston North End match against Everton. I fate the liberty of making a few remarks on their play. On Saturday it was plainly seen the Everton lost the match simply because their forwards were unable to combined and they received little or no assistance from the half-backs. To remedy these defects I would suggest that Milward should be placed in the centre and Geary, the present centre, put on the outside left wing the place that would be vacated by Milward. I would also suggest that Parry and Farmer at half-back should be Weir and Cain. The team would be Smalley Hannah, Doyle, Weir, Holt, Cain, Latta, Brady, Milward, Chadwick, Geary, and i am sure the combination of the above would be for in front of that which was shown by the Everton team of last Saturday, yours etc Robert Stavely. Liverpool, Nov 18, 1889

DEATH OF EVERTON FOOTBALL PLAYER.
Liverpool Echo - Wednesday 20 November 1889
We hear that Mr. Mike Higgins, until lately well-known in connection with the Everton Football Club, and late captain of Everton Athletic Football Club, died yesterday from internal inflammation. 

EVERTON FOOTBALL CLUB
November 20 1889.
The Liverpool Courier
Sir- I like to take the liberly of adding a few remarks to your correspondent's (Robert Stavely) letter of yesterday's date, about the North End v Everton match. First, although the North End gained a decisive and well deserved victorty, there can be no doubt that the sodden state of the ground rendered them a great advantage. Secondly the incompetence of one of Everton's halves to deal with the opposing forwards was painfully apparent to Evertonians, and as North End soon detect any weak spot in a team, they directed their attack chiefly through this special point. Lastly, I think that Everton need not despair and with a slight alteration in their team that contains, Hannah will again lead them onto, triumph and victory. This following team I would suggest to tried in one of their matches during this season this team Smalley, Hannah, Doyle Parry, Weir, Holt, Latta, Brady, Milward, Chadwick, Geary.
Yours etc, Never too late to Mend- Liverpool Nov 19 1889.

EVERTON FOOTBALL CLUB
November 21 1889.
The Liverpool Courier
Sir- I read “common sense's” letter in today's Courier with great interest, it is very evident the writer was not at the match between North End against Everton, or he would have had more common sense them to rush into print. Parry the best “Half” in the Everton team, well, it is the first time I have heard about it. My experience of football and football players (and is a longer experience than “common sense's”) leads me to the conclusion that J Weir is the best half-back at Everton in front of Farmer, and Holt but then Cain is better than either Parry, Holt or Farmer. I am sure anybody with common sense would say so if they saw him play. In conclusion I say let Everton play the team I suggested, and they will meet with success-yours etc, Liverpool, Nov 20 1889. Robert Staveley.

“Joesph G Allen” writes: - As a member of the Everton football club I agree with much that is said by “Robert Staveley” that something will have to be done and that speedily to remedy the defeats that were so transparent to the thousands of supporters who witnessed Saturday's memorable match. The question is how? Certainly not in the way suggested by “Robert Staveley” leave the forwards as they are at present. They can and do combine, and few will gamsay, that Geary in good form can keep his wings together equal with any centre in the kingdom. The worst fault forward is undoubtedly Chadwick's wandering instead of keeping on his wing, and the combined with the intense eagerness of all the forwards to score, tends frequently to mar combination of attack. Our forwards would do well to emulate the cool, dashing style of the eminent forward, Latta, and work like him from beginning to the finish of the game, and the result would prove the lesson's worth. Saturday's game conclusively proved that the half-backs, useful trio as they are, when the pinch comes, lack the staying power so requisite in a half-back, upon which both backs and forwards whelly rely. Weak in the halves means broken combination, and that's what it meant on Saturday. Unable to withstand the severe attack of Preston, they soon held aloft the flag of distress, and the backs and forwards receiving practically no assistance, the goalkeeper is beaten by shot's impossible to get away. It is here the committee must reinedy. They of course must make the best of the men they have, but I think they should not forget that such good men as Frank Sugg, Cain and Nidd would, in my opinion have done better services on Saturday's heavy ground than the halves who did duty. I am quite sure the committee are quite alive to the changes that will have to be made, for no committee, in my humble opinion could labour with greater determination, patience and perseverance than the body of gentlemen, who never guide the destines of the club, and great credit is due to them for the present improving position of the club; and had it not been for the defection of Gordon Ross, and Groves they would have made the best of teams strike their flags to the Everton club.

“Twister” says: - as an admirer of the Everton F.C. I could not help but feel indignant at “Roberts Staveley” suggesting to rearrange the team and put two men out. If he is annoyed as them for not winning on Saturday last, he is not the only one by hundreds, but he should not rush into print making such poor suggestions, for I am sure there are able men on the committee to suggest alterations, and as for putting a player out like Parry, you never mean it Robert, I am sure. In my humble opinion I consider him a spendid player, particularly last Saturday for he can stand a charge like a rock.

EVERTON FOOTBALL CLUB
November 22 1889.
The Liverpool Courier
To the Editor of the Liverpool Courier. Sir- Noticing the public opinion on Saturday's match between the above club club and the Preston North End, I take the liberty of asking you the publish these for lines in your valuable paper. I quite agree with one or two gentlemen, and as a member of the Everton club, I think I may say a few words in favour of our lads. I believe Smalley capable of keeping goal with any goalkeeper in the country. The backs division is also very strong but the half-backs were weak on Saturday. Certainly to move Parry, however a man that is coming to the front so fast, would be a great mistake. Holt was certainly somewhat out of form, and G.Farmer with all due respect to him, I think should retire, as I am sure he has fought hard enough for his club. I would have the forwards, as Hannah says it takes time for a team to play a good combination game, and no doubt we shall see in our own team quite as good passing as the displayed by our friends the Preston North End- yours etc, A Member That Never Despair, Liverpool, Nov 21, 1889.

Sir, - “Common sense” was on the Everton ground last Saturday, R.Smalley thinks not. Why ? Because “Common sense” and Parry was the best half-back Everton had. But Robert Stavely was there; he himself say so. and what does he say? Listen; there is no doubt Parry is a long way in front of Farmer and Holt. Then we agree; why quarred? But in his reconstruction he leaves out altogether the man who he himself considers best. He must learn to be consistent in his old age. He forgot to do so when young. Yours etc- Common sense. Nov 21 1889.

Sir, Referring to the letters relating to the above, I would suggest to the committee of the Everton F.C. that they look after a few of our local players to strengthen the half-backs division. There are several good juniors in our local clubs that would put the present three half-backs who play for the “Toffees” entirely in the shade. I would suggest the trial of such men as David Williams, George Wilson, and Todd in the place of the present three half-backs. Yours etc Full back Nov 21 1889.

Sir, Allow me to say a few words on this subject. I would like the committee of the club to take some means to check the abominable language used by the young men, and old ones too, unfortunately who attend the matches. My lady friends and I have been awfully shocked at times, and we have often had to leave the ground. Trusting the committee will alter such a bad state of things, yours etc, A Sister.

LIVERPUDLIANA; BY RICHARD SAMUEL
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 23 November 1889
The Fall
Where are Everton now?  That was the cry of the dejected as they crowd as they slowly left the Anfield-rd. ground on Saturday. And the question was generally answered with a melancholy head shake. It is safe to say that in no previous match between North and Everton did the Liverpool team make such an ignoble display as they did in the second half of last Saturday’s match. A misguided evening print created much exasperation in Everton circles by coming out with a malignantly ugly picture of each of the members of the team, and with a fulsome account of their doings. To describe Hannah as the “champion player of the United Kingdom” —from the simple fact, as the writer puts it, that he is the captain of Everton and that club beat the Celtic, -as about the choicest gem of this absurd adulation of “Everton’s heroes,” But the whole production bristled with such touches, and the statement that North End would only reach Smalley over the prostrate body of Hannah was screamingly farcical, read in the light of what did actually occur. But to return. The splendid victory of North End was a fitting lever to raise them to the first place in the League, and there is very little doubt now of their ultimate triumph in the struggle for first place.
A SOLACE
There was Just a solace for the deep and mortal wound to Everton’s pride. An enormous crowd of spectators who willingly parted with their “tanners,” despite the objectors in the local prints, must have piled an immense heap for the Everton coffers. And when, just before the commencement of the game, the bag bearers—there are two for the capacious Everton bag—when they met just in front of the Press stand they were speechless, but the expressive countenance of the elder slowly relaxed, whilst the comfortable aspect of Mr. Wilson grew a shade more satisfied in its expression. They were too full for words. Almost as over full as those seats reserved for the Press, which increased the receipts by a good round sum, for, tardy scribblers found to their cost, they were utilized by the over-taxed officials for the accommodation of spectators. How many were on the ground?  Some estimates give 20,000; but I unhesitatingly affirm I have done before, that there is no accommodation for this number. Fifteen thousand is a liberal estimate, and the gate receipts, together with the revenue from stands, must have come near to £450, if it did not exceed that amount.
SOME ACCOUNT OF THE MATCH
The weather was magnificent; the turf, sodden. The Everton players got a great reception, but the greatest ovation was reserved for N. J. Ross, who as he came on to the ground, flushed nervously, and stroked his head awkwardly ; whilst, in acknowledgment of the great cheer, the little ‘un bowed ostentatiously for his big brother. A disappointed murmur arose as Dewhurst was observed to choose his goal.  Punctually, almost to a second of the advertised time of starting, Geary toes the ball, and the excitement commences. It simmers a long time, a desperate struggle taking place at the centre for possession, and then it boils to a fierce heat as the North End right work amongst the home backs to the very goal, but Doyle was upon them, and the quagmire round the goal made it at once evident that there was not going to be much scoring at that end. In feverish anxiety the crowd watched three corner kicks to North End, all splendidly directed, but all fruitless. And now, amidst a perfect roar, the home team commenced their headlong rushes, and every man in the team threw himself into the wildest enthusiasm. Down upon Trainer they bore. The huge mass on the high gallery sway forward in eager expectancy. Milward strikes the upright a ,terrific bang, Geary dashes the ball with lightning speed at the crossbar, and it rebounds straight down to the foot of Trainer, whilst at the same instant the barriers give way under the great pressure of the surging crowd behind, and the game is at once stopped.  It was a moving sight, that big wave of human beings breaking past the barrier, whilst the foremost fell under those behind. The ground was soon cleared, and happily no one was seriously hurt.  Before long Everton were again attacking strongly, and rapturous applause greeted the first goal to Everton from the foot of Brady. Everton hopes seemed now realized. Never did they play better. North End were sorely pressed, and for ten minutes Ross, Howarth, and Trainer were continually dealing with shots aimed straight and hard upon their goal. This was the turning point of the game. Had this gallant trio broken down then, a very different result might have been recorded. But beaten off, Everton never again throughout the match made anything like a continuous assault. North End. 'Too, now took up the reins, and in the last five minutes of the first halt Smalley made three grand saves.
THE LAST HALF
And so the interval found Everton ahead by a goal.  To re-commence the visitors gave an earnest of what was in store. Smalley had to fist out three shots in a minute, and then Thomson dribbled passed all opposition; round Hannah, not over him, and just when was about to shoot, the Everton captain clutched him by the body, and the whistle promptly recorded this breach of the rules. A free kick to North End resulted in Russell scoring a goal. And then the North End triumph came. The rest is easily told. The North End right and centre made ghastly exhibition of Doyle and Farmer. Goals came at an alarming pace. The Everton forwards panted and gasped as the burly North End half-backs shattered their combination, thwarted their dribbling and threw them back upon their defenders. These, alas! were in a state of utter collapse. Parry worked helplessly, but not hopelessly; that is the most that can be said for him. Farmer was both helpless and hopeless against Gordon and Ross. Holt did all he could, but there was too little of him. As for Hannah and Doyle, they were not even impediments. Smalley alone kept his head under these overwhelming disasters, and stayed many a grand shot. Five goals were scored in something under twenty- five minutes, and daring that time the vast crowd was lost in astonishment at the brilliance of those splendid Preston forwards. Then there was something like a rally amongst the Everton defenders. Both backs seemed to pull themselves, together, and both did lot of good work towards the finish. But the halves were spent, and were the sport of the opposing forwards, whilst the forwards rarely got away, and both Brady and Geary made a mess of a fine opening which presented itself to each at different periods.
WHY
How came about this tearful rout, no less disastrous than the score represents?  Looking back upon the game, it seems to me that sheer brilliance would not hare availed on Saturday against such a team as Everton in such a mood. It was the great weight, indomitable pluck, wonderful endurance, and marvelous combination of the winners, which overcame the flashy brilliance, the bubbling enthusiasm, and great speed of the younger, lighter, and less experienced Everton team. Teams cannot be depended upon which are ready made, and it will inevitably happen that such teams as Wolverhampton Wanderers and Preston North End must in the end triumph over the collections of heterogeneous brilliance which now doing duty for many of the League clubs.   The most remarkable features of North End play were the grand work of N.J. Ross at full back, and the improvement of Sam Thomson as the game went on.  The centre forward started weakly, but never played better than in the second half-a remark which applies to Ross jun, and Gordon.  The half-backs were a magnificent trio.  The Everton backs broke down.  The half-backs did fairly well for a time, but out-classed in facing such a trio as Graham, Russell, and Kelso.  Holt and Parry were much better than Farmer.  As for the left wing pair did plenty of useful work.  Geary was not himself and Brady made a weak display.  The demeanor of the crowd was most highly commendable. 

WE HEAR AND SEE-
Lancashire Evening Post - Saturday 23 November 1889
That outside Preston football supporters are asking , how the North End reconcile North End 5, Everton 1, Corinthians 5, North End 0; that the explanation is not far to seek, being simple that some of the team relaxed, “not wisely but too well.” after last Saturday's victory; that in addition to this the fact that the Prestonians on Monday were without Dewhurst, Kelso, and Graham, and had. In consequence, turn their team topsy-turvy. That their brilliant play last Saturday the North and took up first position in the Football League table, and will now require some pulling down ; that out of eleven remaining matches they have to play seven at home and four away; that Wolverhampton Wanderers are about the only team the club need have any fears of; that the Wanderers have the same number games to play as the North End, and they are divided similarly to those of the Prestonians; that the next three likely to finish well are Aston Villa with 11 play, five home and six away; Everton 10, four at home and six away; and the Blackburn Rovers with 13, five at homeland eight away.
That it is questionable if ever there was such a brilliant display of scientific football that of the North End last Saturday while they were engaged scoring their five goals; that Sam Thomson was the same of the Christmas Day Bolton Wanderers fame; that many go the length of saying he was the best forward on the field, but what about the North End light wing pair? That the re-arrangement worked admirably; that Jack Ross missed his kick a few times, but was nevertheless grand term; that Bob Howarth is the best full back the world is the opinion of many of the North End’s followers. That it is not often that “the punishment fits the crime” in football, but there was such an instance in the Everton v. North End match. Doyle seized Sam Thomson and held him, utterly regardless of the law; that a free-kick was given to the Preston men, and from it they scored a goal; that from this point the collapse of the Everton team was evident. That the crowd at was extremely fair; that when the North End did anything good they were cheered, but when Everton did ditto what a row there was; that Jack Ross had a grand reception, and actually blushed; that Jack has still number of admirers in Liverpool ; that one of the gentler sex, who evidently has great faith in his powers, was determined he should not miss his bit of lemon half-time, and ceremoniously walked up to him, and bade him help himself.

WITH THE LIVERPOOL JUNIORS
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 23 November 1889
By the Unknown
Everton reserve’s victory at Deepdale over Preston North End Reserve by one goal to nil was very pleasant reading after what took place at home and gave great satisfaction to many who had hoped to bring off the dual event. 

EVERTON’S EVANESCENT EFFORT
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 23 November 1889
PRESTON’S POWER PARAMAMOUNT
By Grummer
Really, I feel a  good deal of diffidence in tackling my theme this week, and I would that that foul fiend, the gout, had released “Mickey Free” from its clutches in order that he might tell you all about the gigantic gathering Anfield Road and the astounding climax which followed. The genial Mickey is such an adept at pouring oil into the wounds of the sore distressed ; he knows so well how to “let down gently" the defeated ; he is so ready with soothing explanations and excuses for past mishaps, and inspiring encouragement for the future. In all this I feel my deficiency at the present juncture. Everton had started so well this season, had attained and maintained such a proud position on the record, that it seemed indeed hard that they should be so overthrown. And yet my personal sympathies were, and always have been, with the Preston team since it has become the fashion to decry them, and to talk of them as effete and worn out. The jackals who prowl around waiting for the scraps left by the superior animals, the vultures who circle over the scene as the conflict ready to pounce the victim—all such carrion have chosen to regard the North End as the dying lion, and gloat over the prospect of dismembering the carcass. That is why I am glad that the Preston men have once more asserted their right to be regarded as the champions, and that is also the reason why I do not care for the task of writing of Everton in their hour of defeat. Thus, Mickey, thine ancient enemy has to thee been cruel only to be kind. It has spared thee the anguish of witnessing the overthrow of thy pets, and it has, at the same time, landed me in a sore strait. There is another element about the case that makes it difficult for me. As Olympian knows, the exigencies of publication and of the train service enforced departure from the ground considerably before the termination of the game. When I left, the score stood equal—Everton 1, Preston 1, and as the hansom rattled me to the station I pondered over the probable result of the encounter, and arrived the conclusion that it deserved to be a draw. 


Honestly, on the first half, and the first quarter of hour the second, I didn’t believe there was a goal between the teams. Whatever consolation Everton can extract from such opinion they are heartily welcome to. Up to the time when the North End began to pile on that sensational run of goals the home team were their equals at every point of the game. When I got into the office shortly after five, and they told me the result I refused to credit it. “Who are you getting at?”  I asked, and only the ocular demonstration of the wire would convince me of the possibility of such a result. Well, having got through these “primlaries,”  as old Bouillabaisse has it in “Paul Jones,” let’s get to what I do knew, and what I did see of that remarkable contest for first position on the League table of results. First of all there is the "gate.” It was stupendous. Its limitations knew no bounds but those of space. Every available inch was appropriated; even the police were nearly crowded out, and I observed one intelligent officer doing his patrol on the roof of the reserved stand. The sitting accommodation at Everton is probably the most extensive to be found on any football ground, and here there was no spreading out in lazy comfort. Everybody had to “hutch up” and sit tight. The huge galleries at the backs of the goals, where the “masses” congregate, partook of the same character, and it was on one of these—that at the Oakfield-rd. end—that the only hitch of the afternoon occurred. When the battle waged close to the posts the occupants of the top rows had difficulty in following the movements of the twenty-two units struggling below, and so they leaned forward on their fellows in front. These in turn threw the burden on the lower rung, until layer on layer was piled on the bottom supports. These being but human gave way, and the whole pile fell forward like house of cards. It is a wonderful fact that with so many hundreds involved in the crash that only one small boy was hurt, and he appears to have been sitting beneath the hoarding when it fell. The Everton executive, can well afford to ,
PAY THAT LAD’S DOCTOR S BILL.
The men came on with commendable punctuality, Everton showing the way. Any doubts as to the manner of Jack Ross’s reception were soon set at rest by the round specially-assorted cheers served out to him. Last of all came the one and only Fitzroy T. Norris, referee -in - extraordinary to all the principal clubs. A new navy-blue cap sat jauntily on his empyrean looks, his moustache had an extra curl, a proud smile illumined his classic features, and his legs, encased in fancy heather mixture, trod lightly o’er the turf as the welcoming salute rang round the ropes. He raised his cap with an air of sang froid—insouciance- or any other appropriate gesture that suggests Itself, strode the centre of the arena, superintended the toss-up, whistled, the game began. Everton had the sun to face, but that was practically the only disadvantage of losing the toss, for the wind was scarcely perceptible. For the next forty-five minutes there raged one of the most fierce and hotly contested struggles I ever remember witnessing in any match. It would be folly to take you again through the movements of the game in detail. How Latta and Brady made bravo incursions on the right, often to the discomfiture of the great N. J. Ross, who was again in his element at full back; how Chadwick, Milward, and Geary tried to force through the line of defence; how on the other hand Gordon screwed time after time into the mouth of the Everton goal; how Sam Thomson dribbled and shot straight; and how Jimmy Ross kicked over the bar time and again, I told you last week. In the first half nothing could have been better than the defence Hannah and Doyle. They tackled promptly and well, and Holt, the half-back, though inclined to be shady, was also effective. Smalley had really very little to do, for what shots were not stopped before were they reached him generally went wide. Dewhurst and Ross, junr. were the failures of the North End attack. The Everton forward, especially the right wing, proved much more troublesome to Trainer, although
GEART WAS A DEAD FAILURE THROUQHOUT.
It may be that he had not renewed from his injury at Stoke, or that his boots did not fit; but people who lost their heads and wasted their money in buying votes to place this man at the top the poll in a recent competition for selecting the “best all-round player” will come to their senses shortly. There was half-an-hour’s play before any soars was effected, though before that I thought Kelso joy a very bad trip had brought disaster on his side. The free kick was landed very close in, and it was now that the accident happened at the back of the goal.  When things calmed down again it was seen that the referee had awarded a corner, so that the North End goalkeeper probably saved by putting the ball behind. There was no mistake about the goal that was scored by Brady, though had Ross allowed the ball to roll out instead of keeping it in play and letting up the right-winger the disaster would have been avoided. The remainder of the half was of the “give-and-take" order, though Jimmy Ross threw away one very simple opportunity. Reckoning up matters to the interval I thought it would be a toss-up as to who should win. I fully expected North End to score but did not think that either would get many through. The Preston men restarted in earnest, but did not appear any fresher than their opponents. Both showed traces of the hot going in the first half -going all the more hard because of the cut up condition of the turf, which wore all to pieces as the game progressed. That North End must have had good a deal more left in them than the Everton men after results showed. I saw them score their equalizing goal and then had to cut could the curtain have been rung down then a good deal of heartburning would have been spared the Everton enthusiasts. The humiliating collapse of the last twenty minutes I did not witness, and therefore won’t attempt to describe it. Four goals speak for themselves; and there I leave them. There is one little matter I just want to mention, and that is the impudent appropriation of the seats reserved for the Press by a number of people who had not the slightest business there. Mr. Molyneux, the secretary, very kindly forwarded me a pass, but when I arrived more than half an hour before the start I found the Preston and some Liverpool scribes crushed up on one short bench, whilst on the next there lulled in luxurious ease some half-dozen insolent intruders who refused to move when requested, and who never put pencil to paper during the whole of the game. As showing their intimate relationship with the football Press I may mention that one of these gentry actually asked which was North End and which Everton. Another—a chip from some public school—loudly proclaimed: “You can’t come here; this fellah’s got to write.” All this time legitimate Pressmen were struggling for few inches’ space up and down the stand whereon to get a view of the game and write their notes. As a rule the committee deserves the thanks the Press for their excellent arrangements; on this occasion the arrangements were there, but they failed to see them carried out. Whilst l am on the growl, I should like to call attention to the following brilliant refusing in a local print: The home end was literally bombarded, the short passing of the Prestonians accomplished unerringly at flying speed before the marvel of the beholders, and demanding even reluctant cheers from the entire mass of spectators.” We want the writer of this on our staff right away. It is rather funny, too, to read in the same journal in an article on.   “The Everton Herocs,” that the gentleman who does the sketches for the Football Echo has rather failed to catch Geordie's charming smile." Seeing that this sketch of Farmer, together with those of all the other “heroes,” appeared in the Sunday edition of the New York Herald a fortnight previously, I can well understand the Echo man s failure. If had waited a little longer before appropriating the Herald’s picture the smile might have developed. Still it cannot denied that this sort of cheek is calculated to cause the “marvel of the beholders,’ and even to demand” reluctant cheers from the entire mass." Farewell, Everton, for the present. May your faithful “Mickey “be on hand when next you attempt to pulverize the champions, and may he have a different tale to tell.  This alliterative heading was written before about North End ' went to bring about the fall of Corinth, and got smashed up instead.  However, the three P’s look well in a line, so let them stand. 

EVERTON v. ASTON VILLA-
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 23 November 1889
At Perry Barr, before a good attendance. The Villa winning the toss Geary kicked off uphill, and after a short visit downhill Everton got up, Geary sending in a terrific shot which Warner negotiated. Everton, playing with splendid dribbling, again got up, Parry essayed a long shot that proved abortive. Villa retaliated, getting well down, Dickson and Hodgetts working well together. Hunter finally shot, shaving the post. Again Villa attacked, but Cain relieved the pressure. Everton in turn pressed, the ball travelling rapidly up and down, and after fifteen minutes Chadwick scored. From a pretty centre to Milward Everton returned to the attack, and Warner and company had a busy ten minutes, repelling shot after shot.  A grand corner by Brown and a hot shot all but scored—hard lines for the Villa. Once more Everton assumed the master hand, Chadwick, Millward and Geary working like clockwork, besieging the opponents’ citadel, Brown at length equalizing. At the interval the game stood—Aston Villa, one; Everton, one. Changing ends, the play grew fierce, and Latta raced down on the right. A miss-kick by Cox gave an opportunity, Geary banging through with lightning speed, and registering point two for Everton. Latta again raced down, centring splendidly, Milward just missing with his head as the ball crossed the goalmouth. Still the visitors had much the best of the play. Brady had a good run, Cox dispossessing Geary, who got winded and stopped playing. Resuming, the visitors kept up the pressure, relieved by occasional Villa runs.  Final Result; Aston Villa 1, Everton 2. 

NUGGETS
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 23 November 1889

  • How Bob Smalley smiled at half-time.
  • Jack Ross positively blushed at Everton.
  • “They are showing Everton how to play football.”
  • Gordon could fix his own price of he would join Everton.
  • Who was that Everton forward who was tempting Gordon?
  • Why the Everton executive did not play Cain.  Because he was not “Able”(?) ask Mr. Wilson.
  • Everton’s song, “ Tis gone, ‘twas but a dream”
  • Everton have plastered up their wounds with a comforting 450 pounds.
  • Everton’s defeat by North End to the extent of 5 goals to 1 was not expected.
  • Cox, the Burnley custodian, has signed for Everton next season.
  • Everton are to appear in London on Monday for the first time.
  • The Rovers or the Wanderers, or Everton for the Lancashire Cup-which?
  • Another “meddle” competition-see Letters of advice to Everton F.C in a Liverpool evening paper.
  • The way of Gordon waltzed round the Everton boys led some of the spectators to think he was teaching deportment.
  • At Everton the North End scored five times in twenty-one minutes.  At Richmond they could not do the trick once. 

NORTH END VICTORY AT EVERTON
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 23 November 1889
Mr. Olympian, I know you will have a full reference to the great match at Anfield-rd. last Saturday for I know both your friends "The Grumbler and “Richard Samuel were present. There were a great many Pressmen there, but the Everton Committee ought to know that some of the men in the box were mere lookers-on, who caused the utmost crowding and inconvenience to those parties who had a lot of work on hand. The Preston people were immensely pleased with the result, I can assure you. It had been anticipated that North End would win by two or three goals. You can, therefore, imagine the serious look which came over many countenances in Fishergate when the half-time result' became known, but when the finish came there was a revulsion of feeling, and the crowds vented their enthusiasm in cheers. As to the match there is no doubt that North End had to put in all they knew in the fast half. I know some Evertonians who think that the state of the ground was against their team, but the Prestonians who were present have a well-founded opinion that if it had not been for the soft ground in front of the Everton goal that citadel would have been invaded more than once before the interval It must have been noticeable that several times the passing by the North End forwards was spoiled through the ball sticking in the mud. Through this Doyle was more than able to rob both Ross and Gordon. In the second half the North End forwards found the Everton half of the field more to their liking: it was net too heavy, but just heavy enough, and hi, presto! The ball was seen flying under the Everton crossbar five times in twenty minutes. I ascribe the North End victory to the splendid combination they exhibited—the backs and half-backs knew where to place the ball when they had got it, and the forwards passed it from one to the other with the utmost precisian. This was done often enough in the first half, with the result that, though the home team successfully prevented their opponents from scoring, they did it the cost of a tremendous amount of exertion. The North End backs had also to work hard, but they had not the same amount of exertion, and were consequently better prepared for the second half, when they somewhat astonished the Liverpool people. Prestonians seem to favour the Everton right wing, as showing the most combined play, but they were much surprised at the poor display of Geary.  . I can tell you one thing that Geary would not do for the North End team —he is too much of individual player. Even Gordon—whom the Evertonians so greatly admire that they have been again sounding him—would not be seen to the same advantage if he were not well supported by Jimmy Ross and the half-backs. Then there is only one really strong half-back among the Evertonians, and that is Holt; but the backs and goalkeeper would be a credit to any team. The crowd as a whole were extremely fair. They are naturally very enthusiastic about their own splendid team, but they are fair enough to recognise good points in visiting teams, and in this respect are far more civilized than are some football crowds out East Lancashire way. The great match has done one good thing. It has given us full assurance that we may anticipate a stiff encounter when Everton visit Deepdale next month. I hope the Evertonians will then play as good a match as they did on Saturday. 

ASTON VILLA 1 EVERTON 2 (Game 35)
November 25 1889.
The Liverpool Courier
These teams played their first match in the League contest on Saturday at Perry Barr in fine but dull weather. It will be remembered that last year the Aston Villa defeated the Evertonians at Birmingham in a decisive manner, the game beening very tough. The home team was forced as follows: Aston Villa:- Warrer, goal, Aldridge, and Cox, backs, Devey, Cowan, and Burton half-backs, Brown, Allen, Hunter, Dickson, and Hodgetts, forwards. The Liverpool team only underwent one alteration, Cain taking Farmer's place Everton: - Smalley goal, Hannah (Captain), and Doyle, backs, Parry, Holt Cain half-backs, Latta, Brady Geary Chadwick, and Milward, forwards, Referee Mr Duxbury, and Messrs Frank Sugg and Albut as umpires . Just before three o'clock Aston Villa in the presence of 5,000 spectators took the kick off. The opening play was somewhat desultory until Everton worked down, and Latta evoked applause for some a clever shot. The home men then placed themselves in more favorable position. Hannah and Doyle however, not being found wanting, Dickson and Hodgetts carried the leather beautifully down, and when a goal seemed certain to result, Hannah came finally to the rescue. Allen immediately afterwards shot in the ball going rather wide, the home right wing then rushed down the force, and Hannah was only able to again interpose with his head and save the goal. Everton canted along, and Warmer grandly prevented a beautiful attempt by Chadwick from taking effect. The Villains now labored with a will, without result, although some of the opportunities were very simple. It fell to the luck of the Everton to break the ice, Chadwick sending in the ball, which glanced off Geary's head and passed the goalkeeper. Aston Villa strove to equalise, but their shooting being wretchedly weak, notwithstanding the easy chance offered, even their own supporters indulged in derisive remarks as to their play. The Villans obtained two fruitless corners, and then Everton rushed away Geary merely failing to score with a terrific shot. Then the visitors pressed their opponents, Warner fisting a shot from Chadwick over the bar, and giving a corner. This not being avail, the Villans by nice combined work gradually gained the opposite and forced Parry to grant a corner, from which the ball was neatly headed through, Smalley neatly fisting it from beneath the bar several times. The home men had excellent openings but there was not the slightest improvement in their shooting, the kicks being miserable failures. At length the home team, having possessed by far the greatest advantage in point of position, scored a goal Brown performing the trick with nobody but the goalkeeper opposing him. Latta and Geary bounded along and the former propelled a splendid shot, which was well fisted out, and Geary kicked over the bar. A corner ensused, but Everton did not improve upon it. Half-time, Everton 1 goal, Aston Villa 1 goal. On the resumption of play the visiting team exerted some pressure, no available opportunity of scoring, however, presented. A little time having lapsed, Chadwick made a gallant attempt, the ball just striking the bar. The ill-luck was at once atoned for by Geary sending one pass Warner a couple of minutes later. After the kick-off the Aston Villa boys made a transitory excursion on their opponents' territory and then Latta sprinting along, reached the goal line, from the entrance of which he cleverly shot across the goal mouth, Milward being a second too late in this attempt to crown the grand effort. Parry checked a threatening advance by his energy's with the result that the leather was rushed down, and some exciting play followed on front of Warner, the Evertonians opportunity having the goal, at their mercy. Cox came grandly to the relief, and the Villans assumed a very threatening aspect, two clever shots being satisfactorily negotiated by Smalley. The visitors went at it with determination and rushed their opportunities of a goal to a considerable extent. A couple of corners were given without practical result, but still the ball could not be removed. Warmer experienced several near shaves, eventually all danger being averted by a kick over the line. The home team moved along to the opposite end, though they did not effect anything, and then Everton worked back. Warner had to run out to meet a shot when the game was stopped owing to Geary being winded, but he quickly recovered. Encouraged by the spectators the home boys, put forth their best endeavours to bring the game on level terms, their well means attacks being foiled on every occasion. The visiting right moved very finely along, and Latta terminated the run with a grand centre, which was all but properly settled by Geary. The game continued somewhat in favour of the visitors, the pace at this period being faster than at any other portion of the game. Final Result Everton 2 goals, Aston Villa 1 goal.

EVERTON RESERVES 0 STOKE SWIFTS 3
November 25 1889,
The Liverpool Courier
This match was played at Anfield before a capital attendance. Both sides were strong Kirkwood playing half-back for the home team. It will be remembered that when Everton met the Swifts at Stoke the visitors had to put up with a several defeat- 5 to 1. Everton kick off, and for some time play was even, Edge and W. Tunncliffe broke away, and beating the home defence the latter player easily beat Joliffe, to the evident surprise of the home supporters. Everton had a turn, and Deane disappointed his admirers by shooting wide of the posts. The visitors' right wing put in a grand dribble, and Martin sent in a grand shot, which was within an ace of taking effect. The homesters fully alive to their position, began to press Eccles however, neatly removed the venue to midfield, were a foul was given against the Swifts, no advantage accured to the home team, and the visiting front rank led by Owen, were again in the home territory, Nidd being able to neat the attack at the expense of an abortive corners. Everton broke away R.Jones being the shinning light, but found the defence all there. Martin next tried a long shot, which Merritt saved admirably. The homesters were now having nearly all the game. Deane from a pass by Kirkwood was putting in some good work, which was spoiled by Jones shooting wildly to the chagrin of the crowd. Tannicliffe was cheered for two pretty runs up the left, Nidd met him each time but could not stop him, Joliffe having to negotiate his shots which were first-class, Abbott ran splendidly down the right, amidst the encouraging cheers of the spectators, and tried a long shot, which seemed to go through and upon Mr Lythgoe giving the homesters a goal the visitors left the field. Not for long, however, the Evertonians gave way and Merritt amidst the groans of the crowd, took a goal kick. The visitors had for some time to put up with a lot of banter from the crowd, which did not seem to have much effect on their play. Hammond, who was in good form, stopped several rushes by the visiting forwards, who showed a good combination, and the game preceeded amidst great excitement, both sides in turn assailing their opponents' fortress, without being able to add anything tangible to the score. A pretty combined attack by the visitors took place in front of the home goal ending in Everton conceding a corner, but half-time arrived before it could be taken. Half-time score-Stoke Swifts 1 goal Everton Reserves nil.

Stoke kicked off, and play became for some time remarkably slow. The swifts were the first to throw off their lethargy and Nidd had to concede a corner, which was well taken, and Joliffe was called upon to defend, which he did in first rate style, Everton next gained a corner, a grand run by the Swifts right was rewarded after an exciting scrimmage by a goal. The home team tried hard to put a different complextion on the game, runs by R Jones and Abbott, and Orr and Walton were deservedly applauded, but the visitors' defence was very strong, Merritt putting in some grand kicks, which time after time cleared the danger. The excited spectators cheered Joliffe for throwing two grand shots out, and the cheers were well deserved, for they were remarkably fine saves. The Swifts were pressed severely, and Everton had to put all in to prevent them from adding to their score, Hammond doing good work. Even play followed, neither side being able to claim material advantage. Kirkwood went forward without making very great differences. Smith and Farmer the right and Centre half of the Swifts being quite able to deal with the attacks. Final score- Stoke Swifts, 3 goals Everton Reserves nil.

EVERTON REVIEW
November 25 1889.
The Liverpool Mercury
Everton on Saturday met the Aston Villa for the first time this season at Perry Barr. Compared with the form displayed by the Anfielders against the North End the previous week, it must be gratying to their supporters to see that they were able to hold more than their own against such a formidable team as the men of Perry Barr a performance which the North End failed to accomplish a few weeks ago. It was evident from a spectator's point of view that Aston Villa were determined to advance further up the League ladder, as they had undergone careful preparation during the week, and had even gone to Droitwich to have salt water “dips” Everton again requisitioned Cain at half-back, he taking Parry' s place on the right, and the latter that of Farmer's on the left, an alteration which tended to help the overthrow of the Villans. The game was a very fast one, all through, the ground seemingly suiting both sides. From the kick off Everton soon took up the play, and Warner's charge was early swarmed by the visitors, but a quarter of an hour had gone before Geary, from a clever pass by Chadwick, headed the first goal of the match. Aston Villa at various times severely tested the defence of Everton, but it was close to half time before Brown could equalise. The second portion went principally in favour of the visitors, and but for the grand goalkeeping of Warner, Everton victory would have been greatly increased. However a win of 2 goals to 1 was gladly welcomed by committee and players alike, and it still keeps them second on the League list. For Aston Villa, Warner was a great barrier to goal getting and it was surprising to see his finished style between the posts. Cox, who had more to do than Aldridge, did it well, whilst Cowan was far away the best of the halves; forward, Hunter and Dickson were slow, but the same does not apply to Hodgetts Brown, and Devy, who at times showed good form. Smalley, for Everton, was never severely pressed as the defence of Hannah and Doyle was perfect. The half-backs had always plenty to do, and it was a treat to see Parry disposing of the right wing of the homesters in the cooless possible manner. There was nothing to chose between the forwards as all played an unselfish, persevering and winning game. The Everton team after tea resumed their journey by the seven o'clock train from Birmingham to London and will meet the London Caledonians this afternoon at the oval, and the Casuals on Tuesday at Leyton.

LIVERPOOL DISTRICT NOTES
Athletic News - Monday 25 November 1889
THE CROACKERS HAVE A FIELD DAY
By the Loiterer
The local press has been flooded with correspondence this week re last Saturday's catastrophe, the merits and demerits (very much demerits) of the Everton team have been put up for discussion. Some of the writers propose to put Tom here, Harry there, and throw Dick out altogether. A. lot of them don't know what football is, and thought what they call their team could lick all before them, never dreaming that unity is strength and individualism an imposture. On the day's play they met a better team, and they should take the licking like men (for I consider they got off cheaply), and encourage the team to put forth special of on December 21, and then there will not be four goals difference.
I suppose Everton will now be “the best team in the world” again.  They beat Aston Villa on their own ground, and the grumblers cannot now have much to grumble at.  It was a capital victory.
Stoke Swifts tackled the Everton reserves at Anfield, and a lot of interest was centred in the game.  The first meeting of the teams at Stoke resulted in the defeat of Everton by five goals to one, and on this occasion the home lot fully intend wiping this out; but they could not manage it, Stoke winning by two goals to none. 
More than one League club is complaining about Everton securing their best men for next season.  It is a foolish and suicidal policy, and if it is carried on much further, it will not be to the benefit of Everton.  The League clubs are supposed to assist each other in every possible way, and Everton are running a great risk if half the tales I have heard are true.  Amongst the players “sounded” are Gordon (North End), Bury and Cox (Burnley), and Perry (West Bromwich Albion).  Cox has, I believe, agreed to play for Everton. 

MIDLAND NOTES
Athletic News - Monday 25 November 1889
THE FIRST DEFEAT AT PERRY PARK
Sir, Everton have been (we saw them) and they have conquered, and while I am in the humour to grumble—for it was a magnificent game—l am bound to say that the Liverpudlians ought to think themselves somewhat lucky parties. Let me put myself right about that. On the whole, and taking the game right through, they were the superior team, for their passing was better, they were quicker and smarter on the ball, and the two goals they scored may be put down as fortunate for the visitors, as the first was obtained while Warner was violently appealing for off-side for a shot which he had knocked away, while Aldridges cranium diverted a shot of Chadwick's through his own goal. The Villa keeper had knocked away all the good ones—and there were some stingers—in the most brilliant style, and it seemed almost a pity that a soft thing like this should be registered against him. To a real lover of the game the play must have been very enjoyable, for a lot of it was confined to midfield, and could be watched with the greatest ease: and only here and there could be detected those specimens of wretched roughness and unfairness which are apt to spoil the good name of a team. As I have said. Everton scored the first goal, and this had a very good effect on the Villa, as they made things extremely lively for the visiting defenders, and about half-a dozen chances were badly missed—chances which a first-class team ought to score from nine times out of ten. By dint of hard, untiring, and not unskillful play, with
A RATHER REFRESHING RAID
occasionally by Everton, just  to keep matters lively the Villa bore down time after time on their opponents’ goal, and just before half-time a good hard shot by Allen wail knocked away, the ball came to Albert Brown's foot, and that young man spun It through. The "whisper" that startled the muggy air was a caution, for the Villa had been trying long and desperately for this, and it was a sort of relief. Later Everton seemed to be tiring somewhat, and when half-time arrived there were high hopes that the home team would win, as they are celebrated for going hard at the finish, and always play a better game uphill than down. Well, these prognostications seemed likely to be realized, for the Perry boys came sweeping up time after time, only to be repulsed by the very fine defence of Everton, whose backs would not allow the Villa forwards to get within striking distance, but who on three occasions were very fortunate indeed after fouling the ball in not being penalized. This was through no fault of the referee, who could not possibly see; but the incidents occurred all the same, Allen once appearing certain to score when Parry fouled the ball. Some delightfully smart passing by the Everton forwards was warmly cheered, and they romped away for the Villa goal in fine style. Their system of attack was carried on mainly from the wing, and was very effective, with the swift little man in the centre to take up the running when required. Warner had stopped two or three shots pretty comfortably, when a long pass from Milward was clean missed by Cox, and Geary, whipping round him smartly, banged in a shot which the Villa goalkeeper had no chance at all with. Another smart attack or two by Everton were warded off all right by the home to team, but time was drawing on a pace, and if they were to prevent their stalwart foes front winning it behoved the Villa to go forward in a more persistent manner than they had been doing. So they girded up their loins, so to speak, and they went for the Everton goal in the last quarter of an hour in a style that ought to have brought them success but, didn't, for though they tried hard and well, and had many narrow shaves, through the goal the ball would not go, and a splendid game ended in favour of the visitors by two goal to one. There is no need for Villa supporters to pull long faces over the matter, for though they were beaten, it was by a thoroughly good combination, and the home team and their friends have the satisfaction of knowing that they played a hard and plucky game, and there can be no disgrace about that.

LONDON CALEDONIANS V. EVERTON
Morning Post - Tuesday 26 November 1889
 Spectators mustered in strong force at the Oval yesterday to see the Everton team play the Caledonians. During the first half the Caledonians seemed unable to make any headway against their rivals, and altogether the game on both sides possessed many elements of a scratch match. With the wind behind them, the Caledonians started well enough, and a couple of corners fell to them, but from this point the play became very one-sided. Chadwick obtained the first goal, and Geary, by a fine shot, added a second. Everton next claimed a third, but Milward, who headed it through, was ruled off side. Geary now made a fine run, and obtained a third goal by a good shot. The same player added a four, while Milward scored a fifth. At half time the figures were — Everton, five goals; Caledonians, none. The best point of the second period of the game was the goal-keeping of Stirling for the Scotchmen. Each side scored twice (M'Aulay for the home team and Milward for Everton), and finally Everton won by six goals to one. Sides: Caledonians— Stirling (goal), Stewart and Moody (backs), Casselon, Barbour, and M'Aulay (halt backs). Fry, Burns, Prior, Hogarth, and Sergeant (forwards). Everton — Smalley (goal), Doyle and Hannah (backs). Parry, Frank Sugg, and Cain (half backs), Milward, Chadwick, Geary, Brady, and Latta (forwards). To-day, at Leyton, Everton will meet a strong team of Casuals.


LONDON CALEDONIANS 1 EVERTON 6
November 26 1889.
The Liverpool Courier
The Everton team arrived in London on Saturday night, and put up at the Covert-garden Hotel. The Weather was miserable on Sunday, but the members, accompanied by Mr. J.Houlding, Jun, Mr. Molyneux, and Mr. Ramsey, went down the river to Greenwich in beautiful weather. At Kennington Oval, yesterday and in the presence of 1,000 spectators Everton kicked off and immediately made tracks for the Caledonians goal, when play remained for a few minutes. Chiefly the end of Hogarth transferred the leather to the opposite end, where a futile corner was given. Here a brief stay was made, but Everton broke away, and mainly with the assistance of Frank Sugg, who was playing in Holt's place, the ball was taken well down, and Latta shot well down, and Latta shot well but somewhat slow. The play continued rather uninteresting, though fairly good runs were effected by the wingmen on both sides. Clever work by Latta, Brady, and Geary took place in the Caledonian quarters, and Latta put in a neat screw shot, which missed the mark, but enabled Chadwick to shoot through. Midfield play ensued until Latta and Brady raced down by really grand passing which delighted the spectators, and Latta then attempted to lower the caledonians colours, but shot wide though Milward should have settled the matter. The home team made a temporary incursion and then the Everton forwards rushed away, Geary concluding by sending in a low shot, which had the desired effort. With two goals to the good the visitors worked energetically, and after some pretty passing in the goalmouth, Cain kicked high to the goalkeeper, and Milward running up, headed the ball through. He was, however, ruled offside, and apparently somewhat unfairly. The Caledonians played up with greater spirit, and pressed for a few minutes but they found Hannah and Doyle were impregnable. A relieving kick placed the ball to Latta, who passed to Geary, Freedy sprinted away at a great pace, and outstripping the opponents until only the goalkeeper was in front of him, he shot the third goal. Following this, shortly Geary scored another. The Evertonians maintained their attacking methods, and Brady was very unfortunate in a shot, which hit the upright. This however, did not matter, as the ball rebound into play, and Milward getting hold of it passed to Chadwick who scored the fifth goal with a simple shot. Stirling, the home goalkeeper prevented the ball from beating him a few seconds after, and he was derisively applauded and chaffed by the spectators. Half-time result: - Everton 5 goals Caledonians nil. After the restart the homesters displayed a little more agility and quickly forced a corner. Cassleton took the kick and McAulay headed the ball past Smalley, the Evertonians now took the lead, and racing down the field some very exciting esisories occurred within a few feet of the home goal. All the forwards endeavored to get the sphere through without any luck, and Sugg at last spoiled the movement by kicking over the bar. However, the Metropolitans were not much better attended by luck, and the visitors moving along and going in grand style should have scored again, though Brady help, and a capital shot by Parry was well fisted away by the goalkeeper and a corner to the Evertonians followed. This was not improved upon, but still the Caledonians did not improve their position. The visiting right wing travelled nicely down, and Chadwick kicked fast, Monday interposing and saving the goalkeepers defeat. A corner fell to the left of Everton , and Milward should have put through the ball being placed well in the centre. There was a certain amount of carelessness and want of dashes in the form of the visitors in this half, or they would have scored several times. During the last ten minutes of play, the Liverpoolians beat their opponents at all points of the game, and it was only be mere chance that the score was not taken to double figures. After this heavy bombardment, Milward scored the sixth goal, and the game ended a few seconds later. Final Result: - Everton 6 goals, Caledonians 1. Teams London Caledonians: - Sterling, goal, Hadene, and Stewart, backs, Casulton, Janson, Barbour, Mcaulay, Howarth, Prior, Sergeant, Fry, Burns, Everton: - Smalley goal, Hannah (Captain), and Doyle, backs, Cain Sugg, and Parry, half-backs, Latta, Brady, Geary, Chadwick, and Milward forwards.

LONDON CASUALS 2 EVERTON 7
November 27 1889.
The Liverpool Courier
The second and most important of the two London matches was played yesterday at Leyton, on the Essex County Club Ground in the presence of over 1,000 people. During the morning the weather had been fine and frosty, but shortly before the match rain fell and rendered the ground heavy. Holt resumed his usual place, vice Sugg, who umpired. The Casual team was not very strong, only one of the brothers Walters playing at full-back. From the kick-off the Evertonians took the ball down to the opposing defence, Moon having to fist one from Brady, Glossop cantered away on the left, and several excellent shots were sent in by the Casuals, but Smalley, Hannah and Doyle were fully equal to the task imposed upon them. The visiting left wing worked back again, when Milward, whilst close into goal, shot over the bar. They retained their position, however, and forced a corner from which Geary headed through and thus notched the first goal. The home backs found it an extremely difficult matter to keep their antagonists at bay, and Latta, Geary and Chadwick each had unsuccessful shies at goal. Glossop again rushed away at a spanking pace but the run was rendered unless by a kick over the goal line. Then the Evertonians attacked with a vengeance, Holt nearly scoring with a long shot, and Moon fisting out a beautiful low shot. Milward raced away and finish up, an attempt, Moon easily executing the shot. Hannah easily checked a couple of advances by the Casuals, and gave the sphere to Brady and Latta; the last mentioned player-defeating Moon with a clinking shot. The outside right followed this up with an equally good endeavor a couple of minutes later, but on this occasion the goalkeeper was too sharp for his opponents. The visiting fairly held the advantage over the Casuals and would not be removed from the goalmouth until Brady claimed the credit of the third goal with a neat effort. Cox was applauded for a tricky dash down on the right, and he cleared Doyle, but Hannah came to the rescue. Nothing further was scored up till half-time. Thought the Casuals made temporary raids. Half-time Everton 3 goals, Casuals nil. It should have previously been mentioned that the composition of the Casuals team was almost the same as that of the Corinthians, who defeated the North End last Monday week. On recommencing play the Evertonians went right away down and Milward added the fourth goal. The visitors banged away at the goalkeeper time after time, and remained on their opponents' territory for some length of time by aid of the backs. Holt being particularly prominent. Geary with one of his pretty, low, fast shots, brought the score to five points in favour of Everton. The combination and tackling of the Liverpool men was really brilliant and the play was an improvement on that of the previous day. After the Casuals had paid a few compliments at the Everton end, the visiting right wing carried the ball down and a long oblique pass was made to Milward, who rushed in and with a lighting shot caused Moon's sixth defeat. The homeboys now went more to the front, but the opposing backs would not allow any liberties, and their labour was consequently in vain. Cox and Clarke rushed gallantly up the field, and passed all before them, but when a few feet in front of goal Clarke overran the leather, and Smalley successfully interposed. This was atoned for a few moments afterwards by Foux getting to the fore and beating Smalley. From the kick off the visitors raced away, and Brady shot though, but for some reason the point was not permitted. Again the home men went up to Smalley, and Foux rush the sphere between the sticks. The visitors had all the play to the finish and Milward scored the last goal, and the game ended Everton 7 goals Casual 2. Everton team: - Smalley goal, Hannah (Captain), and Doyle backs, Cain, Holt, and Parry half-backs, Latta, Brady, Geary, Chadwick, and Milward forwards.

EVERTON v. CASUALS.
Sporting Life - Wednesday 27 November 1889
Following their victory up their victory over the London Caldonians at the Oval on Monday, the “Toffeeties” yesterday (Tuesday) metaphorically pulverized a fairly strong team of the Casuals at the County Cricket Ground, Leyton.  About half hour before the advertised time pf starting a very heavy shower descended. Probably tis had a lot to do with the attendance, for though despite the attraction of seeing the second and, according to some authorities the first professional team in the United Kingdom perform, only some 1,500 spectators lined the ropes.  The Casuals at the last moment had to make several alterations in their team, with the result that the visitors held them safe from start to finish, and had it not been for good back play P. M. would have put in considerably more goals than the seven registered against F. Bickey’s eleven. In the second half of the game the home contingent were remarkably Iucky in notching a couple of points,, and Fox to a certain extent redeemed his character his form in the initial forty-five being about of the worst, but, as intimated, during the concluding portion of the game the Westminster midget warmed to his work and was actually the best of the Casuals forward division.  Throughout the play was of the fastest, despite the heaviness of the turf and the consequent greasiness of the ball. The Evertonians won the toss, and elected to play with the wind for the first half, defending the Pavilion goal.  Fox starting the ball for the Casuals at 2.30 p.m. a smart run by Furber was promptly checked by Holt, who placed on to Chadwick, who, in conjunction with Milward, dribbled the ball down on the left, the latter crossed to Brady but Morley, tackling in fine style, the ball went wide of the uprights. From the goal-kick the Casuals attacked in force Glossop and Clarke especially being noticeable, and kept Doyle and Hannah busily engaged. The ex-Volunteer at length relieved the pressure with a long kick, and Cain placing to Chadwick, the latter compelled Daniel to save at the expense of a corner. The ball was placed into the mouth of goal, and Geary, heading it through, registered the first point for the visitors after some five minutes’ play. Restarting, Cox put in a grand dribble, but being badly supported, was deprived by Hannah, who returned the ball to mid-field, and the visitors’ forwards swarming round the Casuals’ citadel. Moon thrice was called on to save his charge in quick succession. P. M. Walters at length cleared the lines, and led on by Glossop, the Casuals in turn attacked, and Fox had a grand opening, but slipping, Doyle cleared, and the visitors at once going away Latta sent a very swift low screw that Moon failed to reach, and placed them two goals ahead.  Within a couple of minutes the visitors again broke the Casuals’ defence, and Brady sliding in a rather soft shot Moon allowed the ball to slip through his hands. Just prior to half time, the Casuals pressed, but were unable to score, and when crossing over Everton was leading three goals to love.  Immediately on restarting Latta, Brady, and Milward kicked the leather into their opponents’ quarters, and after some good passing Brady, with a long shot, put in the fourth point for the visitors. Geary added a fifth, and shortly afterwards, Cox being repulsed by Doyle. Milward got the ball, and terminated a grand single-handed run by sending in a hot-side shot that Moon failed to cope with. Again attacking, Walters headed away, and following the leather up with a long kick, placed on to Fox, who, amidst loud applause, scored for the Casuals. Immediately on restarting from the centre line Brady scored an offside goal for Everton. From the free kick the Casuals went straight away, and Fox was enabled to secure their second and last goal. Although at times the Casuals played well, the visitors always had the upper hand, and Milward registering a further goal, the match ended in a win for Everton by seven goals to two. Throughout the professionals played a sound passing game, whilst on the other hand the Casuals’ forwards were very scratchy. In the first line of defence the visitors were far and away better than  their opponents. Referee, Mr. F. Barnett (Woodville), umpires, Messrs, F. Sugg Everton, and R.E Hetherington (Casuals).  Sides;- Everton; Smalley (goal), Doyle and Hannah (backs), Cain, Holt and Parry (half-backs); Brady, Latta (right-wing), Geary, (centre), Milward, and Chadwick (left).  Casuals;- W.R Moon (goal), P.M. Walters and H.A Morley, (backs); F.J.K. Cross, A.M. Daniel, and W.H. half-backs; S. Furber and L.L Cox (right), C.J.M. Fox (Centre), A.G. Glossop, and T.B Clarke (Left). 

FOOTBALL NOTES.
Sporting Life - Wednesday 27 November 1889
The first appearance of the Everton Club in London was event of some importance to the lovers of the Association game. The enterprise of those who have had the management of this organisation has done a good deal to popularize football, at least of the Association code in Liverpool, and, in fact, given a great impetus to the development of an interest in the winter sport in the district. Those who follow Association football at all closely have noticed the steady advance of Everton to the front of clubs dependent on professional assistance. Only a season or two ago there was little enthusiasm in football the neighborhood of Liverpool, and it has been in a great measure due to the activity of Everton and, in lesser degree, to other kindred clubs that the sporting public of Liverpool has been educated to a general interest in the Association game and Association players.
The Everton team has this winter added considerably to its reputation by the consistently good form they have shown, particularly in the matches they have fulfilled under the auspices of the League. As footballers are well aware, for several weeks they occupied a position at the head of the League clubs, and, indeed, it was only after a desperate struggle on November 16 with Preston North End, who after having the worst of the first half of the game, fairly ran round them, getting many as five goals in twenty minutes, that they had to cede the pride of place. On Saturday last they did another good performance in defeating Aston Villa, and the present time Present North End alone can show a better record in the League matches of this season.
Considering the high reputation they have deservedly gained as a football combination, it is much to be regretted that their capacity was not subjected to a more satisfactory test on the occasion of their first appearance on London ground. On the form of their last match with Everton, the London Caledonians, who won at Lancashire by one goal to none, ought to have made good fight of it Monday at Kennington Oval. That they were decisively beaten, and no less than five goals, was almost as much due to their own mistakes as to the superiority of their opponents, though as the game went there was really no comparison between the play of the two teams. The Caledonian team altogether were very much below their usual standard, although in justice to them it must be added that they were very much weakened by the loss of J. A. Lambie, who would have given a great stimulus to the forwards. All round the play of the losers was below the mark, and had the defence been to the average the Everton score ought to have been materially reduced. It was mainly through the superiority of Everton forward that enabled the team to show to greater advantage, and in this respect the Northerners satisfied the critics, being generally fast, passing with judgment, and on the whole accurate in shooting. The backs, however, did not create quite as favourable impression, and there was not the combination or accuracy which one might reasonably expect to find in team which has been so conspicuously successful.

EVERTON PROFESSIONALS
Pall Mall Gazette - Friday 29 November 1889
In Association circles the chief topic of conversation has been the visit of the Everton Club to the metropolis, which was made at the instigation of that enterprising club the London Caledonians. Everton has attained a very high position this year, having been at the head of the League clubs until dis- possessed of their position on the 16th inst. by Preston North End. They made their first appearance in London on Monday last at Kennington Oval. Although the match had been well advertised and the fact that the Caledonians had beaten Everton last year had been frequently proclaimed, the attendance was small. The London spectators, who are evidently good judges of football, did well to stay away, for the match was uninteresting and the play mediocre in the extreme. The Everton team played with the Caledonians as a cat would with a mouse, and ultimately won easily by six goals to one.
The professionals-for the Everton men are, I am informed, all paid players-had as easy a victory as on the previous day. They were immeasurably the superior team. Notwithstanding the appearance of the International goalkeeper, W. R. Moon, as custodian of the Casuals' fortress, it was seven times reduced, while on only two occasions did the ball pass through the Everton goal. The Old Westminster, C.J . M. Fox, scored both the goals for the losers. To compare the play of the two teams would be absurd. * During the second period of Monday's match the Everton forwards slackened their efforts greatly, doubtless in view of their match against the Casuals on the following day. Mr. Betts, the secretary of the Essex County Cricket Club, never loses a chance to cater for the football enthusiasts at the East-end of London. Last year he induced the Preston North End to play there, and this week he tempted Everton to try the county ground. A very strong team of Casuals was announced to oppose the visitors, but the few hundreds of spectators who attended were doomed to disappointment, for only four or five of the advertised eleven played. Much grumbling was heard in consequence of these alterations.

LIVERPUDLIANA; BY RICHARD SAMUEL
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 30 November 1889
THWE NEW CRITIC
The Everton supporters are given to agitation. Last season a local paper was flooded with suggestions, criticisms, advice, when the team got into low water. The lugubrious wail from the same crowd arose last week in the same fashion. The defeat by Preston North End quite overcame the doddering weak knees, and the team was reorganized and rearranged by these self-constituted authorities in the most unheard of fashion. What is to e said, what is to be done to-day t to defeat Aston Villa at home is a performance of as great merit as to overcome the Celtic at Glasgow. And when the tale of the adventures of Everton in London is told, the vindication of the discredited team is completed.   The southern tour has been brilliant as the defeat by North End was disastrous. Time is all that is needed. Time is all that has been denied to Everton teams in the past. What do Everton want with Cox? This is the burden of a hundred questions in Everton. Energy such as that displayed by the Everton executive cannot but be commended from one point of view. But its expediency is open to question, and certainly it is utterly wanton to extent, indefinitely, the period of anxiety for managers of the clubs, and the unsettling of players at the height of the campaign. No good can come of it, neither to the particular interests of the Everton club, nor to Association football in general.  Today, Everton take a rest, a sort of breather, in the hot work of the season.  Witton are to visit Anfield Road, and though no interest attaches to the game through the recent appearance of Witton at Everton in the Cup tie, there is sure to be a large crowd to welcome the team, fresh from their triumphs. 

WITH THE LIVERPOOL  JUNIORS
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 30 November 1889
By The “Unknown”
Everton Reserve should have opposed Aigburth Vale on Saturday, but owing to that team having to play at Liverpool cup tie, Stoke Swifts filled the gap.  The visitors came with a great reputation, and as they had a month back beaten the Reserve by four goals to nothing at Stoke, a good game was looked forward to.  There was were a large number of the home supporters who thought the time had come when their “pets” would have revenge, but, alas and alack! Such hopes were destined to be rudely shattered, for the Swifts returned home with another feather in their cap, or, in other words, won by three goals to nil.  Both teams were well represented, the Swifts including Montford by the introduction of “Danny” Kirkwood, who played half-back and considering that his position is inside right he made a very creditable display.  One would think by the score that the Swifts had an easy thing on, but such was not the case.  The Reserve had as many chances as their opponents, but failed to take advantage of them, whereas the visitors threw very little away.  The best on the Stoke side were Merritt, Montford, and Tunnicliff.  I cannot but sympathize with the home team, for luck was against them.  The only man who calls for special notice was Abbott, who played a first-class game, and give promise of developing into a fine forward. 

THE EVERTON TEAM IN LONDON
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 30 November 1889
A TRIMPHANT TOUR
The meeting gratifying success attended the first appearance of the Everton team in the Metropoll.  They made a big show in the first of their matches versus the Caledonians on Monday.  As pastime says for the first ten minutes play was fairly level, but afterwards there was only one team in it, and that one was not the Caledonians.  True they were without their best forward J.A. Lambs, who is still too unwell to play.  Although reinforced by three of the Clapton team, Clark, Casselton and Prior, they were quite unable to make any show against the Liverpool men, who appeared to be able to win at they pleased.  As it was, the score was six goals to one at the finish, the losers point being obtained by Clark after a good run by Burns.  There was a lament able absence of combination on the part of the Caledonians, for when only Stirling, Clark, and Casselton did well.  The Everton forwards are a very tricky lot, their combination being excellent.  The backs did not appear to be nearly so good as the forwards.
The Casuals had a poor team at Leyton on Tuesday to oppose the strong Everton eleven, and suffered a defeat almost as ignominious as was inflicted on the Caledonians.  The professionals, however, played a much harder game than at the Oval and at no period of the match did they stroll about as they did during the second half on Monday.  The Everton forwards again showed that clever passing which appears to please the gallery, but Geary brought off none of his runs, F.J.K Cross being much too fast for him.  The half-backs were decidedly smart, Holt in the centre being very clever, but their ability was at no time fairly tested.  The backs had little to do.  For the Casuals Glossop alone of the forwards played good form.  Cross worked hard at half, and was very useful in stopping rushes.  Both the backs played well.  Moon saved two or three very hot shots but missed one or two that might have been saved.  The game lasted for only one hour and a quarter, in consequents of the late start. 

EVERTON v. WITTON
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 30 November 1889
 Not much interest was shown in this match at Everton today, which was probably owing to the fact of Witton’s heavy defeat so recently in the Lancashire Cup ties.  Weir took Holt’s place as centre half.  He met with a warm reception on putting in an appearance.  Everton kicked off, and were soon at the Witton end, where Latta and Brady by good passing came very near to scoring.  A few minutes later their goal was the scene of a short fierce struggle, but the ball was at last cleared by Frankland, only to be put through a second later by Chadwick.  A corner to Everton was not improved on, Smith dribbling through.  Shots were now rained on the Witton goal, and Chadwick added a second point, and Geary a third and fourth.  Half-time; Everton 4, Witton 0.
On resuming play Everton at once began to press, Chadwick adding a fifth goal from a pass by Milward, followed almost immediately by a sixth.  A seventh was scored by Cain from a long shot.  Continuing to press severely another goal was added by Geary with a lightning shot.  Dickinson and Woodacre now had a chance, but they were easily managed by Doyle, who passed to Parry, the latter sending over to the right, but the ball was allowed to pass outside.  A ninth goal was secured Latta. Good passing between the Witton forwards gave only a temporary relief to the back division, for Doyle soon cheeked this movement, giving the ball to Milward, who raised the score to 10. Geary improved on this with two more goals. Brady completed the number with another. Final Result; Everton 13, Witton 0

NUGGET
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 30 November 1889

  • The brothers Sugg were on tour with Everton.
  • A decided success-Everton’s tour down South.
  • Brady’s Nap; Ace, King, Queen, Jack and nine.
  • The long and the short of it- Frank Sugg and Holt
  • Everton’s made it lively in London, particularly at Barnum’s.
  • “Pa” Jackson thinks the “Toffess” are “par” Excellence. 
  • Waugh had the pinch of the meeting.  Latta a good second.
  • Everton evidently meant business when they went on “tower.”
  • Everton are in form.
  • S.B. says Everton toffee is better than London mixtures.
  • London critics are very loath to admit the merits of the Everton team.
  • Is “Pa” nasty because he did not introduce Everton to the London public?
  • Everton scored seven times against Moon, the international goalkeeper, and the North End could not manage it once.